I loved the puppetry and the sets and the acting, but the story didn't quite click with me. I went in knowing it wouldn't be the same as the book, and being OK with that, and ready to like it. But somehow it didn't grab me. A little too chick-flick-y for a movie about a boy, maybe. All that analyzing feelings. I wanted the monsters to just be monstrous, to be a manifestation of the id, as my son would say, and for the boy to get control of them. But not for them to sit around and talk about their feelings. Too much analysis for my taste, I guess. I wanted it to be more metaphorical, maybe. It started out promising, but got awfully introspective before it was over.
Still well worth seeing. We drove 75 miles to see it with our kids in a classic old theater out in the middle of the prairie, which was fun.