No need to say anymore, other than than the fact that Gandalf is perhaps the most recognizable Tolkien character, or at least one of the most recognized (and almost anything in Tolkien beats PJ of course).
As much as I respect PJ, he can't hold a candle to Gandalf.
Well, since Gandalf The Grey is a fictive character of an imaginary world and Peter Jackson is a person that does exist in our world, it's hard to actually compare them... And it doesn't make lots of sense to me to do so lol.
Anyway, I'll play the game and so I voted Gandalf The Grey simply because he's my favourite character of The Hobbit and LOTR and well having a Gandalf here on Earth should be awesome though I've difficulties to see him fit in our reality of 2012. Peter Jackson cannot match The Grey Pilgrim and I think not a lot of people can!
(This post was edited by sam90 on Aug 13 2012, 11:22pm)