Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics: Movie Discussion: The Hobbit:
I have a problem with the whole blasted thing, but I agree with you whole heartedly at the last point.

AinurOlorin
Half-elven

Jan 21 2011, 6:33am


Views: 184
Shortcut
I have a problem with the whole blasted thing, but I agree with you whole heartedly at the last point. [In reply to] Can't Post

A Balrog is innately worse than a Nazgul within Tolkien's cosmology, especially the more fleshed out and settled it became. Gandalf's staff (in the book) breaks due to overexpenditure (as he had already expended a great deal of magic in a dreadful contest of wizardry with The Balrog over control of the door to The Chamber of Marzabul, a contest which he described as the greatest challange he could recall encoutnering, and this even in light of his battle with all nine Nazgul Lords earlier in the same book) after he destroys the bridge, yet he fights for Ten days with the demonic lieutenant of Melkor The Morgoth, and still employs magic, even without the staff, in both the books account and in the film ( I deem it at least reasonably supernatural to summon lightning to one's sword). So, yes, even with a broken staff, which it seems unlikely that any servant of Sauron or once human wraith, however sorcerous, would have the power to do, it doesn't stand to reason that Gandalf would just lay there waiting for the end, especially with a great Elf blade still in his keeping.

In Reply To
in the next scene after the Witch-King breaks it.


Quote
What makes matters worse is that Gandalf has his staff again when he is next seen – did he mend it?


He rides in empty-handed and grabs a spear from a soldier as he enters to confront Denethor on the pyre. (I recall that people had already commented on the boards about that missing staff long before the EE was released.)

Gandalf has several staffs over the course of the movies. They seem to act to channel his innate power, rather than being powerful in themselves. So breaking Saruman's staff would prevent him from "casting" magical spells, even if the staff itself has no innate magic. (And it's symbolic too, of course - as is the Witch-King's breaking of Gandalf's staff.)

I don't like the WiKi/Gandalf confrontation in the film, and I can see why it got cut. But I think the point they were going for is that WiKi actually was capable of beating Gandalf - it's implied in the book that the showdown between the two of them could go either way, but the showdown never happens because the horns of Rohan sound at the crucial moment. As also happens in the film, except that in the film they decided to show a bit of action first, presumably intended to give a sense of the Rohirrim arriving "in the nick of time", and perhaps also to give WiKi the prestige that would make Eowyn's victory all the more miraculous.

But I still don't like that EE scene - Gandalf looks like he's already given up by the time the horns sound. I don't have a particular problem with the staff breaking, if it's replaceable and not magical in itself, but I do have a problem with Gandalf looking as if he has no idea what to do next...

And anyway, for me at least, that moment when the horns sound is too hair-raisingly perfect to be overlaid on this messy little scene.


"Hear me, hounds of Sauron, Gandalf is here! Fly if you value your foul skins, I will shrivel you from tail to snout if you step within this circle!"

"Do not be to eager to deal out death in judgement. Even the very wise cannot see all ends."

Subject User Time
LOTR Failures and problem choices which Peter should not repeat in The Hobbit AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 17 2011, 7:11am
    Here we go again... sador Send a private message to sador Jan 17 2011, 7:54am
        Long time lurker responds Vellamo Send a private message to Vellamo Jan 17 2011, 4:02pm
        Why only Jackson shadowdog Send a private message to shadowdog Jan 18 2011, 1:18am
            I want you to feel free to elaborate. Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 18 2011, 1:31am
                Just a couple off the top of my head shadowdog Send a private message to shadowdog Jan 18 2011, 3:45pm
                    In the book "Lord of the Rings" Tolkien meticulously plotted out the time-lines. Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 18 2011, 4:07pm
                        OT: you had a hilarious typo in your subject line entmaiden Send a private message to entmaiden Jan 18 2011, 4:24pm
    What's this anger about a maia and a human king? lurtz2010 Send a private message to lurtz2010 Jan 17 2011, 8:04am
        no... nobofthepony Send a private message to nobofthepony Jan 17 2011, 12:15pm
            Dawn take you all, and be stone to you! Pipe Dream Send a private message to Pipe Dream Jan 17 2011, 1:08pm
                Remember Helm's Deep Altaira Send a private message to Altaira Jan 17 2011, 1:55pm
                    Well... Pipe Dream Send a private message to Pipe Dream Jan 17 2011, 2:28pm
        Forgive me for not replying to everyone by name or post AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 17 2011, 10:54pm
            My biggest fear for the Hobbit Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 18 2011, 12:00am
                Agreed LordMaximus Send a private message to LordMaximus Jan 18 2011, 12:17am
                    There are a host of cameos of minor significance. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 1:38am
    I think you are going to be disappointed in the Hobbit movies Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 17 2011, 8:11am
        Touche Milknut Send a private message to Milknut Jan 17 2011, 8:24am
        QFT!! Darkstone Send a private message to Darkstone Jan 17 2011, 5:02pm
    I think you are missing something about the Hobbit. Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 17 2011, 9:43am
    The problem with Glorfindel macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 17 2011, 11:54am
    It is just a movie makonix Send a private message to makonix Jan 17 2011, 2:11pm
        LIKE LIKE LIKE !!!!!!! Lindele Send a private message to Lindele Jan 18 2011, 12:41am
        Book vs movie and interpretations of them renzn Send a private message to renzn Jan 18 2011, 8:54pm
    Are you fixing The Hobbit, or LotR? squire Send a private message to squire Jan 17 2011, 2:24pm
        It needn't be that way Flagg Send a private message to Flagg Jan 17 2011, 6:22pm
    It is interesting that you mention the point about Gandalf's magic... sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 17 2011, 5:14pm
        Well macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 17 2011, 6:22pm
            I didn't forget the forcefield bubble, etc. sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 17 2011, 7:49pm
        Gandalf has his abilities very much restricted. Elladan Send a private message to Elladan Jan 17 2011, 7:18pm
            Gandalf was referred to as Bran Send a private message to Bran Jan 17 2011, 7:37pm
        Why does a wizard's strength Ataahua Send a private message to Ataahua Jan 17 2011, 7:44pm
            Part of a great wizard to me is having the ability to show their power sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 17 2011, 8:03pm
            Agreed DiveTwin Send a private message to DiveTwin Jan 17 2011, 10:29pm
        Wow. Lindele Send a private message to Lindele Jan 18 2011, 12:45am
            Nothing worse than a Cheese Wizard!// Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 18 2011, 12:54am
            Having read the books allows one to note the instances of Gandalf's magic and it's implementation AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 1:46am
                lol...reducing Gandalf to a wise old man beating people with a stick is quite cheesy sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 18 2011, 1:01pm
                    sphdle1 macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 18 2011, 1:13pm
                        I know we can't completely compare sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 18 2011, 2:31pm
                            Dumbledore was not based on Gandalf entmaiden Send a private message to entmaiden Jan 18 2011, 2:41pm
                                Rowling macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 18 2011, 2:44pm
                                that was what I had heard, but none the less sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 18 2011, 2:52pm
                                    Maybe Lindele Send a private message to Lindele Jan 18 2011, 3:23pm
                                        No I'll watch both sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 1:44pm
                                    I love hearing your pespective, sphdle Altaira Send a private message to Altaira Jan 18 2011, 6:46pm
                                        thx ... sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 18 2011, 8:15pm
                                            sphdle1 macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 18 2011, 8:27pm
                                                I was just about to suggest the audio tapes entmaiden Send a private message to entmaiden Jan 18 2011, 9:12pm
                                                Yeah I've heard about those... sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 1:47pm
                                I kinda doubt J.Ks word on this. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 11:23pm
                                    I tend to agree sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 1:51pm
                                        I don't know if you got a look at the list I made a few posts back AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 19 2011, 2:05pm
                                            thx ... I saw that.// sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 2:15pm
                                        Not Merlin, but Väinämöinen and Odin Finrod Send a private message to Finrod Jan 19 2011, 2:44pm
                                            Midgård macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 19 2011, 2:49pm
                                    I think she was telling the truth Flagg Send a private message to Flagg Jan 19 2011, 3:39pm
                            hedge wizards vs divine messengers Finrod Send a private message to Finrod Jan 18 2011, 6:59pm
                                Yeah Bran Send a private message to Bran Jan 18 2011, 7:10pm
                                I think, only now, Ataahua Send a private message to Ataahua Jan 18 2011, 7:59pm
                                Very well said, and all true to boot. Thanks. Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 18 2011, 11:08pm
                                Finrod, I won't repost all that you said. . . But Amen, brother. Amen. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 19 2011, 4:40am
                                So it sounds like in the books he did great things... sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 2:08pm
                                    Yup. He was robbed. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 19 2011, 2:16pm
                        As has been said, there is a broad expanse of middle ground AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 9:22pm
                            I liked the films' treatment of the Balrog Flagg Send a private message to Flagg Jan 19 2011, 3:49pm
            What some people find cheesy, others find spectacular sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 18 2011, 12:49pm
                I can see where you're coming from Lindele Send a private message to Lindele Jan 18 2011, 1:33pm
                    He doesn't have to be about magic, he nevertheless has great powers of magic AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 9:53pm
                        Disagree Lindele Send a private message to Lindele Jan 18 2011, 10:20pm
    Book to film adaptations Allanon Jan 17 2011, 5:31pm
        Exactly! Darkstone Send a private message to Darkstone Jan 17 2011, 5:40pm
    OMG! Glorfindel IS in The Hobbit! Darkstone Send a private message to Darkstone Jan 17 2011, 5:36pm
    I happen to think... Pipe Dream Send a private message to Pipe Dream Jan 17 2011, 9:18pm
        How about Bran Send a private message to Bran Jan 17 2011, 9:31pm
        I really can not think of any good reason for creating such a seen in the Hobbit. Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 17 2011, 10:03pm
            Lead Pipe? Pipe Dream Send a private message to Pipe Dream Jan 17 2011, 10:14pm
                Well, there is a fat stay-at-home hobbit... sador Send a private message to sador Jan 17 2011, 10:22pm
                    It's fine. / Ataahua Send a private message to Ataahua Jan 17 2011, 11:31pm
        And according to The Hobbit, he does have that moment... Earl Send a private message to Earl Jan 18 2011, 2:24pm
    Regarding things they shouldn't repeat... FrodoEyes Send a private message to FrodoEyes Jan 17 2011, 9:19pm
    yes CuChulainn Send a private message to CuChulainn Jan 17 2011, 11:02pm
        I'm with you. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 12:02am
    the ring nenyacaster Send a private message to nenyacaster Jan 18 2011, 1:33am
        No, his ring wouldn't have effected that. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 1:49am
            Gandalf's fire and his ring Bran Send a private message to Bran Jan 18 2011, 9:28am
    Well these things seem to represent a magical wizard to me. Owain Send a private message to Owain Jan 18 2011, 5:31am
        Well, now. . . AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 7:14am
            Yeah... I'm not giving anyone carte blanche... Owain Send a private message to Owain Jan 18 2011, 7:31am
                To clarify... Owain Send a private message to Owain Jan 18 2011, 12:20pm
                    interesting Bombadil21 Send a private message to Bombadil21 Jan 18 2011, 12:49pm
                        Right... exactly. Owain Send a private message to Owain Jan 18 2011, 12:54pm
                        It could be argued that what Jackson chose to emphasize... Owain Send a private message to Owain Jan 18 2011, 1:03pm
                I am uptight about it. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 9:15pm
                    Hey AinurOlarin... Owain Send a private message to Owain Jan 18 2011, 9:30pm
                    With due respect to everyone, Bran Send a private message to Bran Jan 18 2011, 9:34pm
            You keep mentioning Arwen Elladan Send a private message to Elladan Jan 18 2011, 1:47pm
                I like to think of the Arwen moment that way as well, however no neophyte will. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 10:10pm
                    As a movie firster Arwen Skywalker Send a private message to Arwen Skywalker Jan 19 2011, 4:16am
                        I agree about the staff Flagg Send a private message to Flagg Jan 19 2011, 3:57pm
                            Gandalf has no staff FarFromHome Send a private message to FarFromHome Jan 20 2011, 8:57pm
                                My mistake Flagg Send a private message to Flagg Jan 20 2011, 9:37pm
                                I have a problem with the whole blasted thing, but I agree with you whole heartedly at the last point. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 21 2011, 6:33am
                        I am a movie-onlyer and sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 5:36pm
                            It's in the RotK extended edition Flagg Send a private message to Flagg Jan 19 2011, 5:40pm
                                The point, as misguided as it was... Captain Salt Send a private message to Captain Salt Jan 19 2011, 7:20pm
                                    The answer may be in the Bran Send a private message to Bran Jan 19 2011, 7:50pm
                                        Actually, mortal weapons could no longer harm Gandalf after his reincarnation. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 20 2011, 2:33am
                                No it didn't! It NEVER happened. It is a lie! An illusion. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 19 2011, 10:29pm
                                    BUT I saw it and it happened! Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 19 2011, 10:42pm
                                        Nope, you didn't AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 20 2011, 2:37am
                                    SuperGandalf macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 19 2011, 10:48pm
                                        Well, it was an exaggerated version.... dormouse Send a private message to dormouse Jan 19 2011, 11:11pm
                                            One of my most favorite scenes in the Book and Peter should have done just as Tolkien did. Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 19 2011, 11:37pm
                                            The problem is they upped the tension excessively AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 20 2011, 2:43am
                                        No, just a superArwen who can drown Nazgul with a chant. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 20 2011, 2:30am
        They did show some display in FOTR, but it was just a teaser sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 18 2011, 2:07pm
            Ginny Weasley! macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 18 2011, 2:14pm
                Hey I have a crush on Ginny Weasely... Earl Send a private message to Earl Jan 18 2011, 2:27pm
                but that is the level of magic Gandalf showed throughout the 3 movies sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 18 2011, 2:36pm
                    Maybe so macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 18 2011, 2:48pm
            I suspect you will be disappointed entmaiden Send a private message to entmaiden Jan 18 2011, 2:17pm
                That puts in it better perspective sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 18 2011, 2:46pm
                    I will give you some examples from the books. . . things the revisionists would keep from you (da dan daaaaant!) lol AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 19 2011, 2:25am
                        Sounds like that is a somewhat pivotal moment in TH... sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 2:14pm
                I agree that Bran Send a private message to Bran Jan 18 2011, 3:27pm
                    Which is a clear and lucid exposition sador Send a private message to sador Jan 18 2011, 3:33pm
                        I disagree Flagg Send a private message to Flagg Jan 18 2011, 4:37pm
                        Yes I agree Bran Send a private message to Bran Jan 18 2011, 5:41pm
                    Perfectly said. As Elrond and Aragorn make plain. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 19 2011, 2:35am
                Gandalf is essential. AinurOlorin Send a private message to AinurOlorin Jan 18 2011, 11:37pm
    By the way... failure is pretty harsh word... for some of the most... Owain Send a private message to Owain Jan 18 2011, 5:39am
    Please no Captain Salt Send a private message to Captain Salt Jan 19 2011, 12:16am
        Those wern't horse droppings. Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 19 2011, 12:21am
            All right, Triceratops droppings, then! Captain Salt Send a private message to Captain Salt Jan 19 2011, 12:24am
                Did you see Jurasic Park? Talk about deroppings!// Kangi Ska Send a private message to Kangi Ska Jan 19 2011, 12:26am
                    Yep... Captain Salt Send a private message to Captain Salt Jan 19 2011, 12:34am
        I actually liked all the scenes you mentioned and the way the humor was done... sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 2:33pm
            sphdle1 macfalk Send a private message to macfalk Jan 19 2011, 2:37pm
                I'll have to some day, but first I'd like to see the extended versions of LOTR.// sphdle1 Send a private message to sphdle1 Jan 19 2011, 5:20pm

 
 
 

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.