3 Rings for the Elves
1 Ring to Rule Them All
4 Hobbits of the Fellowship
1 Tom Bombadil
5 Istari or Wizards
9 Nazgul
2 Trees of Valinor
6 High Kings of the Noldor
5 Feet high secret door to Erebor
3 Trolls of the The Hobbit
5 Hobbits at Crickhollow
8 Surviving members of the Fellowship
9 Original members of the Fellowship
7 Dwarf-lords in their halls of stone
9 Original Aratar
3 Farthing-Stone in the Shire
2 Kingdoms of Gondor and Arnor
3 Daughters of the Old Took
8 Surviving Nazgul at the Final Battle
4 Farthings of the Shire
6 Of October on Weathertop
2 Lamps of the Valar
6 Members of the Fellowship at the Pelennor battle
4 Ages of the World
3 Houses of the Edain
3 Winds that bore news of Boromir
8 Kings of the second Line of Rohan
3 Kindred who pursued Merry and Pippin in Rohan
2 Royal statues of the Argonath
7 Dwarf Rings
9 Years since Gandalf had visited Frodo
5 Armies in the famous Battle at Erebor
0 Wings on a balrog
2 Colors of Gandalf
8 Of March when Aragorn took the Paths of the Dead
8 Volume of HoME is The War of the Ring
4 Fingers on the black hand of Sauron
1 Sting that Shelob gave to Frodo
9 Fingered Frodo and the Ring of Doom 
7 Palantiri of Middle-earth 
1 Chief at this time of day: the right Thain of the Shire and no upstart.
6 Books that make up The Lord of the Rings.
9 Members of The Fellowship of the Ring  (Duplicate #1)
3 Dwarves from Thorin's company killed in the Battle of Five Armies
9 Ships of the Faithful that escaped the Downfall of Numenor.
9 The sum of the family of Feanor and Nerdanel. (They need a large table at restaurants.)
3 Silmarilli
7 Stars on the flag of the King of Gondor
5 Toes on a hobbit's foot; OR, "Fir trees holding Fifteen birds"
1 Tower of Barad Dur; OR, Hands of Beren
0 Have caught Tom Bombadil, for his feet are faster; OR, Number of times Aragorn returned to Cerin Amroth after the War of the Ring.
5 Rivers of Lebennin.
8 Palantiri (incl. the "Master-stone kept at Eressea)
2 Kindreds, the Children of Iluvatar.
0 Times Forlong the Fat missed a meal...
9 Barrows of the First Line of the Kings of the Mark
7 Names of Turin
4 Men who could walk abreast along the top of the Deeping Wall
9 Rings for Mortal Men doomed to die....
4 Children of Finarfin: Finrod, Angrod, Aegnor and Galadriel
4 Years separating two Overlithes
5 Leagues from Helm's Deep to the Fords of Isen
9 'Proper' riddles asked in Riddles in the Dark
2 Watchers at Cirith Ungol
3 Dwarves at the Unexpected Party with rhyming names.
0 Children that Bilbo had
7 Rivers of Ossiriand
8 Called a dozen! as Beorn said to Gandalf indignantly
1 Grandson of Feanor
6 Ponies eaten by Smaug his first night out
4 Roads meet in Ithilien