|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ataahua
Forum Admin
/ Moderator
Dec 18 2014, 8:12am
Post #1 of 36
(4624 views)
Shortcut
|
Which Middle-earth death affected you the most? /
|
Can't Post
|
|
(This post was edited by Ataahua on Dec 18 2014, 8:16am)
|
|
|
Silverlode
Forum Admin
/ Moderator
Dec 18 2014, 10:08am
Post #2 of 36
(4369 views)
Shortcut
|
I never liked him when I read the book, but the movie fleshed him out in such a way that I really understood him as I think Tolkien intended for the first time. That made it hit hard to see him die. All of the others were expected so I was more on guard.
|
|
|
Alcarcalime
Tol Eressea
Dec 18 2014, 10:21am
Post #3 of 36
(4364 views)
Shortcut
|
because even though I knew it would happen, it seemed to be done to evoke maximum emotion and certainly did in my case. I think as a woman, I was seeing it through Tauriel's eyes.
|
|
|
macfalk
Valinor
Dec 18 2014, 11:30am
Post #4 of 36
(4355 views)
Shortcut
|
But Thorin has the best death speech. It's heart breakening.
|
|
|
Gianna
Rohan
Dec 18 2014, 1:58pm
Post #5 of 36
(4347 views)
Shortcut
|
Since I haven't seen BOFA yet (probably will this Saturday) I don't know how I'll feel about the three Dwarves.
|
|
|
Bracegirdle
Valinor
Dec 18 2014, 2:49pm
Post #6 of 36
(4351 views)
Shortcut
|
I couldn’t vote for two; as Boromir’s death affected me about the same. Strange that Gandalf’s ‘death’ didn’t affect people more. Did we all know he wasn’t really dead? Personal note: Should we all become more conscious to differentiate between the books and the movies. I for one become somewhat confused on occasion as to who’s talking about what. It seems most people (so far) on this poll are considering the movies and not the books. Fili and Kili in ‘The Hobbit’ are just two brothers that we know little about beyond being Thorin’s nephews and sons of Dis, and their book deaths are given little note, whereas apparently Kili (and Fili?) is fleshed out much more in the movie (I haven’t seen parts two or three yet). I reckon my point being should we not when posting a question (whether it be Pollantir or whatever) differentiate amongst ‘movie’, ‘books’, or ‘both’? Yet I do recognize that to have Fili and Kili as choices on this particular question invites movie answers. Were it a ‘book only’ question Fili and Kili would most likely not be a part of the poll.
|
|
|
Annael
Immortal
Dec 18 2014, 3:34pm
Post #7 of 36
(4334 views)
Shortcut
|
if it were "book-only" Denethor might even get a couple of votes.
|
|
|
Bracegirdle
Valinor
Dec 18 2014, 4:19pm
Post #8 of 36
(4327 views)
Shortcut
|
should not Balin be one of the choices as he befriended Bilbo more than the other ‘complaining’ Dwarves and seemed to be a singular friend to Bilbo considering him to be more than simply a ‘hired burglar’; and ‘book only’ would not Oin deserve a place in the poll, although he was not ‘fleshed out’ as much as Fili or Kili even in the book. And why would Elessar be left from the poll? Or Arwen? (Book or movie.) Yet we have the choices given to us by Ataahua and that’s fair enough!
|
|
|
Ataahua
Forum Admin
/ Moderator
Dec 18 2014, 5:20pm
Post #9 of 36
(4319 views)
Shortcut
|
That's where 'other' comes in. :)
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
I was thinking of the films but people can feel free to vote for their book responses or a melding of both media, if they wish.
|
|
|
malickfan
Gondor
Dec 18 2014, 6:24pm
Post #10 of 36
(4304 views)
Shortcut
|
In the books Thorin/Gandalf (and possibly Turin) in the films Boromir
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
In addition I was always fond of Balin in The Hobbit book, Ken Stott plays the role perfectly (and looks more or less as I'd pictured him in the books) and when I finally get around to watching FOTR again I'm sure it will hit home...
|
|
|
Bracegirdle
Valinor
Dec 18 2014, 8:03pm
Post #11 of 36
(4297 views)
Shortcut
|
Thank you Ataahua. (Other = peoples). (Maybe strange in this day but I still always think of book first.) And on second thought I would change my vote to 'other' - Aragorn - if I had the option. The "Tale of Aragorn and Arwen" in the appendix is pure gold!
|
|
|
BlackFox
Half-elven
Dec 18 2014, 9:45pm
Post #12 of 36
(4305 views)
Shortcut
|
Both in the book and in the films.
|
|
|
imin
Valinor
Dec 18 2014, 10:33pm
Post #13 of 36
(4312 views)
Shortcut
|
Book - Gandalf Film - Boromir (think it helps Sean Bean was the best actor in the films).
|
|
|
dubulous
Rohan
Dec 18 2014, 11:25pm
Post #14 of 36
(4278 views)
Shortcut
|
Definitely Boromir's. It still gets me every time.
|
|
|
macfalk
Valinor
Dec 18 2014, 11:50pm
Post #15 of 36
(4293 views)
Shortcut
|
A fake-death affected you more than Thorin's?
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
Just curious, because for me Thorin's book death was a gut punch, and Gandalf's death is cheapened IMO because he comes back. To each his own, I guess!
(This post was edited by macfalk on Dec 18 2014, 11:51pm)
|
|
|
Bracegirdle
Valinor
Dec 19 2014, 1:57am
Post #16 of 36
(4285 views)
Shortcut
|
A fake-death affected you more than Thorin's? It was not a 'fake death' to many (most? all?) of the characters, nor was it a 'fake death' to a first time reader; nor was it a 'fake death' to Tolkien (apparently) as "The Tale of Years" (for a single quick reference) states that:
Feb 14 - Gandalf returns to life , and lies in a trance. Returning to life can only be interpreted as once being dead....
|
|
|
Meneldor
Valinor
Dec 19 2014, 2:06am
Post #17 of 36
(4271 views)
Shortcut
|
I voted Theoden, cuz he's Theoden!
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
He had the most moving death in the books, IMO. Gandalf vs the Balrog was a shocker, but Théoden's passing was more profound for me, maybe because he got some decent last words in, as opposed to "Fly, you fools!" Movieverse, I agree with Silverlode. Book Boromir was a bully and big dumb jock, so I was totally unprepared to like him on film, and it was a real surprise that I'd be so moved by his self-sacrifice.
|
|
|
Starling
Half-elven
Dec 19 2014, 3:46am
Post #18 of 36
(4266 views)
Shortcut
|
Agreed: That was no fake death
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
I was so upset after watching FOTR, my friend put me out of my misery and told me Gandalf would be back. She couldn't bear the idea of me having to suffer for a whole year. All these years later, it still upsets me greatly to see him fall. It is the end of Gandalf the Grey, after all.
(This post was edited by Starling on Dec 19 2014, 3:47am)
|
|
|
Bracegirdle
Valinor
Dec 19 2014, 4:48am
Post #19 of 36
(4251 views)
Shortcut
|
Hmm! ‘A bully and a big dumb jock’?
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
Book Boromir was a bully and big dumb jock, so I was totally unprepared to like him on film, and it was a real surprise that I'd be so moved by his self-sacrifice. (book) He was accounted the best man in Gondor. He spent his life on the front lines defending the West. Naturally he was a great warrior and efficient in arms and conflict against evil. He had the same dream his brother had but chose to take the journey to find the elusive Imladris himself. He could have sent Faramir on this journey and remained to accumulate further glory. (Not the actions of a dumb bully.) After learning of the Ring he found himself with eight strangers and yes, he deemed the Ring should be taken to Gondor and used against the Enemy he had fought against all his life instead of what seemed to him a frivolous attempt at its destruction. He more than pulled his weight before the breaking of the Fellowship. Who went to the aid of Gandalf on the Bridge of Khazad-dum – Boromir with Aragorn. He said and did things on Amon Hen, during a moment of anguish and despair, of which he immediately repented (no hesitation as shown in the movie). I don’t believe for a second he had any intent to harm Frodo. Although a great warrior I see Boromir also as a caring sensitive person who wanted justice and fought for the Free Peoples of Middle-earth. A single momentary of loss of control doesn’t turn a lifetime of integrity into a ‘bully’ or a ‘big dumb jock’. IMHO
|
|
|
Meneldor
Valinor
Dec 19 2014, 6:08am
Post #20 of 36
(4248 views)
Shortcut
|
I see where you're coming from, BG.
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
All that you say is true, but I still got a bad first impression of his personality when I first read FotR. Just a matter of different perspectives. IMO, Sean Bean's Boromir totally lives up to your description, but I just didn't get that feeling from the book.
|
|
|
Annael
Immortal
Dec 19 2014, 4:23pm
Post #21 of 36
(4239 views)
Shortcut
|
there's a bit in FOTR where he remembers Boromir as always being kind to him, and Boromir did always look out for him and Merry especially. When I first read LOTR Boromir came across to me as single-minded more than anything. It was all about Gondor for him - which made sense for the oldest and beloved son of Denethor. I had more trouble with Aragorn, who came across as stiff and overly prone to correcting others for saying or doing the "wrong" thing.
|
|
|
joec_34
Rivendell
Dec 19 2014, 8:53pm
Post #22 of 36
(4234 views)
Shortcut
|
Boromir, although I thought about saying the cave troll in Balin's tomb chamber. :p //
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
|
|
|
Eruvandi
Tol Eressea
Dec 20 2014, 12:36am
Post #23 of 36
(4226 views)
Shortcut
|
Kili (also Thorin and Fili but Kili a little bit more because shock-value)
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
Not that the LOTR deaths didn't affect me, but I only discovered LOTR last year and learned about the story by playing the LOTR Lego video game before I saw the movies or read the books, so I knew about those deaths beforehand and of course the way Lego does things softened the initial blow quite a bit. I just got back home from my first BOTFA viewing and Kili's death...I knew it was coming but I didn't know where or how. I went into BOFA knowing minimum spoilers and well...although I was SO glad I hadn't gotten spoiled on the rest of the movie, both Kili and Fili's deaths made me wish I had been spoiled on those scenes so I could have been a little more emotionally prepared. They, especially Kili's death, were actually pretty intense, IMO. 1. I wasn't expecting Fili to get captured by Azog and then run through, so that made me really sad and made me hate Azog with even more abandon then I had previously. 2. I suspected Bolg might kill Kili, but I didn't know for sure. I also wasn't sure if he'd kill Tauriel or not and I was already upset over Fili, so I actually didn't look right at the screen when Kili died. Even just seeing it out of the corner of my eye it was still really intense and sad. Kinda wish it hadn't been slow motion with him and Tauriel looking at each other and...and...*sniff*...I may need to cry a little more before I can get over it. Then, when it got to where Tauriel was crying over Kili at the end, I was already in tears from Bilbo crying over Thorin, but when Tauriel was crying over Kili and started asking why, if this was love, it had to hurt so much that really hit me hard and I had to fight to keep from sobbing. I'm just glad there were some lighter moments throughout the battle scenes and the movie ended on a lighter note to help cheer me up. Really did love the movie though. Very satisfying.
|
|
|
Cirashala
Valinor
Dec 20 2014, 7:47am
Post #24 of 36
(4213 views)
Shortcut
|
wish you'd allowed multiple answers
[In reply to]
|
Can't Post
|
|
Because I was in shock with Fili and Kili's deaths (despite being as spoiled as possible with it), but adrenaline was kicking in high gear from the battle, so it wasn't til all was quiet, and Bilbo tried to show the just died Thorin the eagles that I finally lost it... It was so much like battle in real life- the adrenaline, the feeling and need for survival shoves grief behind temporarily, but when all is finally quiet, then the time to mourn has come. And these depictions of their deaths, and the emotions and reactions afterward are very faithful to that same reality. However, my tears were definitely for all three
|
|
|
imin
Valinor
Dec 20 2014, 12:05pm
Post #25 of 36
(4217 views)
Shortcut
|
If you read the books for the first time, how are you to know that Gandalf didn't die? You prefer the hobbit, of course you won't agree.
|
|
|
|
|