Since he is my favorite character in both books and movies I decided to open a new thread, where we will analyze and compare his outfit and his personality or behaviour between AUJ and the Lord of the Rings trilogy two things;
Once we first see him in "Old friends" chapter he looks very similar then he looked in the Fellowship of the Ring and I liked that very much because Ngila Dickson create a perfect outfit for Gandalf in my opinion and changing that would be a bad idea. His robes may look a little bit dirtier and more scruffy in LOTR but that may be because of different camera and also because in those 60 years he may experienced hard times in Dol Guldur and other places. Interesting things on those two pictures are that I don't see him wearing a scarf in neither of them and his coat seems a little more dense in AUJ.
Gandalf the Gray in the Felowship of the Ring
Gandalf the Gray in The Hobbit
The next thing I noticed about his wardrobe is that he is not wearing the same thing during the movie. We see him in this gray coat only in this first scene while later he doesn't have a coat at all or he is wearing a different coat which is not of the same material. Two examples:
Gandalf without his coat
Gandalf wearing a different coat
In latter two pictures his scarf suddenly becomes very important, so my question is why did they changed his appearance? He is not wearing a coat at all while they are leaving the Shire but when they are chased by wargs he is wearing a completely different piece of robes that we haven't seen it before. Which one do you prefer?
Do you find his outfit better in the LOTR or in AUJ?
Personality and behaviour
There is not much to tell here as Ian Mckellen was always a perfect actor for Gandalf but still I noticed some changes between his role in the Hobbit and the LOTR. He looks more serious and determined in the LOTR while in AUJ he is more peaceful, absend minded and humble like an old grandfather. His speech sound sometimes a little odd like when he is talking about five wizards or when he is talking with Elrond about their journey on the Great East Road. I also don't know why did he hit the nose of one troll with his staff or why he is choking when he is asked how many dragons did he killed. There are maybe some more odd scenes with him but in common I like his portrayal in AUJ very much and I am happy that Ian Mckellen portrayed Gandalf once more.I am also looking forward for the other two movies to see him again.
What are the reasons for changing his behaviour?
Where do you prefer him more?