Sep 26 2013, 8:06pm
Post #26 of 26
I said: 'Voronwe, you implied I had left out important context with respect to letter 131'
'No, I didn't. I said that you were taking the statement out of context, and then I explained what the context was.
Ah I see. My apologies but 'out of context' to me suggests the immediate context of a given text, considering that one can alter the meaning by quoting selectively from something. Plus you noted that I had forgotten to number the letter, which is true, but I wasn't trying to hinder folks from checking a fuller context in the letter.
Not that you said I was. I take your meaning.
By the way, when I wrote 'it's rather easy' above I meant the idea, not that I expressed things easily, necessarily. I just mean: people sometimes make sweeping remarks if what they are saying is generally true [many of the Great Rings do confer invisibility]... and an exception is neither here nor there to the hearer [thus why bring it up when Gandalf is talking about invisibility and fading, as Frodo's Ring does confer invisibility in any case].
Or maybe it's not easy. I don't know anymore
(This post was edited by Elthir on Sep 26 2013, 8:12pm)