Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
 Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien

Forum Nav

TORn Nav

Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
 Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 633 (250655 posts in 9484 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 633 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 127824 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 99989 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Collapse Sticky: The courtesy of our hall is somewhat lessened of late. (Admin Announcement, ALL PLEASE READ) Silverlode 18432 88 Aug 28 2012, 7:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by Lissuin)

  Collapse Sticky: TORn Line Parties now open and in need of Leaders News from Bree 276 2 Nov 21, 3:31am Jump to last post in thread (by Garfeimao)

Collapse Sticky: Recommendation: avoid the Hobbit forum if you don't want spoilers! Altaira 1103 22 Dec 2, 5:19am Jump to last post in thread (by hutch)

  Do we see Smaug talking... xxxyyy 7 0 2 mins ago Jump to last post in thread (by xxxyyy)

  Collapse Can someone who has seen the film answer this question (spoiler request) Voronwë_the_Faithful 126 2 41 mins ago Jump to last post in thread (by Voronwë_the_Faithful)
       Collapse I believe so Name 56 1 33 mins ago
           Just because it is in the trailer doesn't mean it is in the film Voronwë_the_Faithful 41 0 27 mins ago

  Collapse The Thrush Nagini6 261 1 11:22am Jump to last post in thread (by demnation)
       Spoiler demnation 162 0 11:33am

  Collapse A great interview with Richard Armitage and Lee Pace Ataahua 338 2 8:37am Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Really nice interviews NecromancerRising 139 0 8:48am
       Both great interviews! Glorfindela 13 0 24 mins ago

  Collapse Quickbeam's DOS Film Review: Splendid Smaug Splits Fandom? News from Bree 899 22 5:14am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Very well written. Arannir 454 1 10:24am
           A really really great review NecromancerRising 416 0 10:36am
       Collapse Fantastic review. Joe20 398 5 10:51am
         Collapse SPOILERS......Then why did they call the movie ... poochies 402 3 11:02am
               Collapse Because it refers to the wasteland around Erebor Smaug has caused. Nagini6 360 2 11:05am
                   oh I see ... the desolation could be looked at in two differnet ways :-) poochies 341 0 11:13am
                   yeah...right... lidlessEye 156 0 1:20pm
           Me too... Arannir 325 0 11:19am
       Great, insightful thoughts, BornOutOfTheWest 369 0 11:03am
       Really great review. Nagini6 357 0 11:06am
       Collapse Jolly good - sounds like some clearer choices have been made here than in AUJ. DavidDevant 341 4 11:37am
           Great post! BartTheBowman 275 0 12:00pm
           Very good post. Arannir 263 0 12:10pm
           Agreed Orc Berserker 254 0 12:12pm
           Fantastic Post David drewster81 140 0 1:26pm
       So not only do we get a Tauriel/Legolas romance, sauget.diblosio 286 0 12:02pm
       Collapse Great review, Quickbeam. TheFlayedMan 255 1 12:15pm
         Agreed You Rock Always, QB...Now Bombadil 138 0 1:31pm
       Collapse Thank you for this balanced review Eadignes 191 1 12:59pm
           Good balanced review. The Red Avenger 156 0 1:22pm
       Collapse No lines for Bombur AGAIN?? BalrogTrainer 43 1 26 mins ago
         Bombur will get his Moments... Bombadil 2 0 1 min ago

  Collapse Praise for The Hobbit's CGI Sebastian the Hedgehog 627 6 4:39am Jump to last post in thread (by Cetautomatix)
       Collapse Hard to Differentiate Fili 240 4 5:23am
           I know what you mean Sebastian the Hedgehog 215 0 5:26am
           Collapse i must say boldog 204 2 6:09am
               Collapse :) mikeybobaggins 60 1 1:04pm
                   I'm absolutely fine with the CGI in AUJ Glorfindela 19 0 32 mins ago
       Love it, hate it but talk about it. Cetautomatix 10 0 24 mins ago

  Collapse Question about DoS Soundtrack? droidsocket 416 8 3:46am Jump to last post in thread (by Glóin the Dark)
       Collapse Just speculation on my part... Aragorn the Elfstone 235 1 3:49am
           "Or maybe because the company has passed the Misty Mountains" Glóin the Dark 208 0 3:55am
       No sign of it... Glóin the Dark 202 0 3:52am
       Collapse I haven't heard it tarasaurus 202 2 3:53am
           Collapse That seems quite plausible. Glóin the Dark 193 1 3:59am
               I sure hope so.. droidsocket 179 0 4:07am
       Collapse It's in part of "The Forest River" ThorinIIIStonehelm 128 1 7:19am
           I think you might mean... Glóin the Dark 40 0 12:01pm

  Collapse Admit it; Peter Jackson's version of The Hobbit Kangi Ska 1529 56 3:13am Jump to last post in thread (by Cetautomatix)
       Collapse I disagree wholeheartedly, tarasaurus 737 9 3:16am
           Collapse This can be settled on a strictly analytical basis. Kangi Ska 705 8 3:25am
               Collapse Well haldad 674 7 3:42am
                   Fantastic post, Haldad! Joe20 567 0 3:45am
                   Collapse Well-written argument. Fili 530 1 3:56am
                       Not Bitter Kangi Ska 476 0 4:35am
                   Collapse if you are referring to AUJ not DOS I disagree with this, it is considerably not page by page like the book. ElendilTheShort 301 3 6:37am
                       Collapse I just don't see it. haldad 238 2 8:18am
                           I may have been a bit harsh on the stone giants ElendilTheShort 161 0 9:30am
                           Did we see the same scene? sauget.diblosio 150 0 9:59am
       Looking forward to thoughtful, constructive discussion. Username4242 642 0 3:18am
       It's a little rude to ask people to "admit it", as though only your opinion is correct MatthewJer18 641 0 3:19am
       Collapse Not a huge fan of the novel anymore but Annatar598 663 5 3:22am
         Collapse There is not enough frowning on earth, nor any curse in Elvish, Entish or the tongues of Men AinurOlorin 407 3 5:14am
               Collapse It was late and I was cranky... Annatar598 388 2 5:17am
                   Collapse lol. All right. I could have done without the mucus jokes, for certain. AinurOlorin 370 1 5:25am
                       It was enjoyable but a detour Annatar598 362 0 5:29am
           Agreed emre43 199 0 8:31am
       Collapse blah book Gandalf 638 7 3:27am
           Collapse I would not contend with the fact Kangi Ska 622 4 3:36am
               3/10 // Fili 590 0 3:38am
               Collapse double blah book Gandalf 526 1 3:54am
                   I am certain Kangi Ska 452 0 4:40am
               with that outlook, all I can say is...that sucks for you bro, I really wish you liked them.... Snowghost77 288 0 6:34am
           Collapse Bob Bagels tarasaurus 558 1 3:41am
               Bob Bagels LOL isaac 65 0 12:31pm
       Collapse Well StoneHex104 614 3 3:30am
           Collapse These additions were not needed. Kangi Ska 584 2 3:43am
               The additions are the reason the book has a storyline StoneHex104 540 0 3:48am
               Completely disagree. Arannir 219 0 8:28am
       It would be impossible for me to fully answer having not seen DOS yet, Escapist 551 0 3:44am
       Collapse Hooom. Or Whoooom. It is long since we have met.... where have you been Half-ELF? AinurOlorin 396 8 5:10am
           Collapse I have always been here Kangi Ska 344 7 5:34am
               Collapse My problem is some of the "creative" choices being made. I wish they had looked more to the cannon AinurOlorin 329 2 6:03am
                   Collapse my friend AO, I do agree with you on that.... Snowghost77 249 1 7:36am
                       Agreed and indeed, good sir. AinurOlorin 186 0 8:53am
               Collapse Re: Runk Snusgrop 297 2 6:25am
                   Collapse Tolkien's Vision is enough. Kangi Ska 140 1 10:24am
                       Thumbs up! Smeagol Bagginsess 40 0 52 mins ago
               So much more is good as far as i'm concerned Estel78 117 0 10:47am
       I admit nothing Elessar 343 0 5:31am
       Collapse how the hell does it have a vague relation to the novel!! boldog 327 1 6:14am
           No, no. There are many places where WONDERFUL justice is done, HOWEVER, there are also glaring AinurOlorin 203 0 8:49am
       Re: Runk Snusgrop 302 0 6:20am
       Collapse Something that I think needs to be repeated. MatthewJer18 300 1 6:53am
           Yup Fili 252 0 7:32am
       I wouldn't use the word "vague" Tim 243 0 7:59am
       Collapse Based solely on AUJ ... DanielLB 205 1 8:58am
           I agree, there are more parts straightly from the book than in LOTR isaac 75 0 12:35pm
       It certainly has more than a *vague* resemblance dave_lf 90 0 11:50am
       I'll get back to you once I've seen all three movies... LadyEmmaE 83 0 12:02pm
       the hobbit in the bin Eadignes 65 0 1:08pm
       Hmm jf300 50 0 1:33pm
       It's an adaptation Glorfindela 32 0 45 mins ago
       I’m not going to admit anything of the sort but it’s good to see you back, Kangi. Noria 27 0 40 mins ago
       And even if this was the case... Cetautomatix 14 0 22 mins ago

  New DoS clip tonight during Grimm tarasaurus 637 0 2:23am Jump to last post in thread (by tarasaurus)

Collapse About Critics... Bombadil 574 9 2:01am Jump to last post in thread (by Bernhardina)
       Very true Elessar 225 0 2:02am
       Collapse I love Oscar Wilde! Ziggy Stardust 207 1 2:10am
           Exactly! Fili 193 0 2:15am
       Collapse Well... Salmacis81 203 2 2:20am
           Bravo! bungobaggins 154 0 2:58am
           Difference between critic and critic. Fili 123 0 3:52am
       Collapse Not really, no HiddenSpring 109 1 4:32am
           Most critics are movie fans first Grant 91 0 5:26am
       Great post // Bernhardina 57 0 7:55am

  Collapse Is Bolg of any resemblence to Azog? boldog 827 9 12:05am Jump to last post in thread (by Eadignes)
       Collapse .... and is there jumpin4smoke 427 7 12:41am
           Collapse There is a huge difference. Dcole4 481 6 12:50am
               Collapse Is this Bolg...? Captain Salt 440 1 12:57am
                   That Orc... Salmacis81 350 0 1:29am
               Collapse Thanks jumpin4smoke 362 2 12:57am
                   Collapse He talks Dcole4 306 1 1:53am
                       how does azog summon him to continue his persuit? boldog 252 0 2:24am
               So I guess... Salmacis81 284 0 1:59am
       Re Azog and Bolg Eadignes 51 0 1:02pm

  Collapse Reviews, Reactions Part 7 Nagini6 5958 188 Fri, 7:23pm Jump to last post in thread (by Glóin the Dark)
       Yeah, we should probably get a sticky going already. Imladris18 2048 0 Fri, 7:34pm
       Collapse 5 stars out of 5 from Empire! Sweet! NT pandoraziki 2007 1 Fri, 7:46pm
           Hmm Kendalf 567 0 12:41am
       Collapse In regards to the embargo Thorin's Oakenshield 2056 1 Fri, 7:51pm
           Are you sure? daemoon 1932 0 Fri, 8:01pm
       EMPIRE's rating is now on Metacritic tsmith675 2023 0 Fri, 7:54pm
       A few tweets from Collider's Steven Weintraub... Joe20 2094 0 Fri, 8:03pm
       Three positive for the most part reviews that make fair and valid Eruonen 1947 0 Fri, 8:11pm
       Collapse Comingsoon.net Joe20 2057 1 Fri, 8:13pm
           I cant help but feeling that Wordofmask 1945 0 Fri, 8:21pm
       IW Arannir 1761 0 Fri, 8:52pm
       Collapse Tweet Collider Arannir 1630 1 Fri, 9:23pm
           Hope a new wave of reviews Wordofmask 1561 0 Fri, 9:27pm
       Collapse Terrible review by Screencrush tsmith675 1786 24 Fri, 9:27pm
           Ugh Thorin's Oakenshield 1554 0 Fri, 9:32pm
           Collapse Expected daemoon 1582 7 Fri, 9:32pm
               Collapse But give it 4/10? lol Wordofmask 1545 4 Fri, 9:32pm
                   Collapse Jesus Jax_Teller 1502 3 Fri, 9:38pm
                       Collapse This is hilarious daemoon 1117 2 Fri, 9:41pm
                           Hysterical Jax_Teller 1082 0 Fri, 9:42pm
                           I think he makes some very valid points demnation 1061 0 Fri, 9:48pm
               Thor 2 daemoon 1051 0 Fri, 9:48pm
               lol Elskidor 909 0 Fri, 9:58pm
           OMG Nagini6 1543 0 Fri, 9:32pm
           Collapse I've been reading both positve and negative reviews so far LoremIpsum 1541 1 Fri, 9:36pm
               I know, but... tsmith675 1081 0 Fri, 9:40pm
           Lol Macsen 1453 0 Fri, 9:36pm
           Collapse I discard his opinion hobbitrunner 1432 3 Fri, 9:39pm
               Collapse Ignore the Screen Crush review. The Red Avenger 737 2 12:08am
                   Collapse I don't mind this review because it shows mefansmum 53 1 31 mins ago
                       I think that the critics should evaluate DoS as a movie, not as an adaptation, nor as Tolkien fans Noria 42 0 24 mins ago
           Collapse Normally I would welcome contrary opinions demnation 1125 3 Fri, 9:39pm
               Wow Jax_Teller 1065 0 Fri, 9:42pm
               Collapse The Tagline of His Review Fili 1066 1 Fri, 9:47pm
                   "Everyone else is lying!" demnation 971 0 Fri, 9:52pm
           that Screencrush review is just... unexpectedvisitor 871 0 Fri, 10:06pm
           Sounds like he hates everything Tolkien to begin with // Carne 762 0 Fri, 10:16pm
           It's a little hard to judge Escapist 744 0 Fri, 10:36pm
       Hmmm.. None of the links are working. An error? // RaoulJ 1515 0 Fri, 9:28pm
       Collapse Reviews Ar-Pharazôn 1648 8 Fri, 9:36pm
           Collapse My god... Nagini6 1551 2 Fri, 9:38pm
               Collapse Oh my godness Ar-Pharazôn 1129 1 Fri, 9:42pm
                   Well Jax_Teller 1076 0 Fri, 9:44pm
           Collapse Meh Jax_Teller 1135 2 Fri, 9:39pm
               Collapse Reviews Ar-Pharazôn 1077 1 Fri, 9:45pm
                   If you have 70+ score at metacritic Wordofmask 1066 0 Fri, 9:48pm
           that 2 critics gave AUJ only 5 Wordofmask 1104 0 Fri, 9:44pm
           read the reviews unexpectedvisitor 935 0 Fri, 9:59pm
       Collapse Indiewire review - quite negative Thorin's Oakenshield 1058 31 Fri, 10:04pm
           No indiewire Wordofmask 816 0 Fri, 10:18pm
           Collapse now that is a much better written negative review unexpectedvisitor 784 5 Fri, 10:19pm
               Collapse This quote: happydood 946 4 Fri, 10:23pm
                   i do think that some of his points are contradictory... unexpectedvisitor 800 0 Fri, 10:32pm
                   Collapse I'm not so sure demnation 724 2 Fri, 10:37pm
                       Collapse Some of these negative reviews, oh boy... Jax_Teller 717 1 Fri, 10:40pm
                           He also used words like NecromancerRising 665 0 Fri, 10:42pm
           Collapse This is what I was afraid of demnation 781 5 Fri, 10:23pm
               I dont think so Wordofmask 897 0 Fri, 10:25pm
               Collapse well, we'll see unexpectedvisitor 833 1 Fri, 10:29pm
                   You're right demnation 756 0 Fri, 10:34pm
               subject marillaraina 631 0 Fri, 10:44pm
               This is why Ham_Sammy 760 0 Fri, 11:59pm
           Collapse Another one of those that just want to somehow hate it. Nagini6 928 11 Fri, 10:24pm
               Yeah Elskidor 812 0 Fri, 10:29pm
               Collapse Why do people think critics have something against these movies? jtarkey 621 9 Fri, 10:47pm
                   Collapse That's not it. Nagini6 577 1 Fri, 10:51pm
                       Agreed MTRougeau 797 0 Fri, 10:55pm
                   Exactly! MTRougeau 530 0 Fri, 10:53pm
                   I know there'll be some who don't like it and I'm not gonna fall apart... happydood 816 0 Fri, 10:54pm
                   Collapse Well, it's possible Jax_Teller 790 3 Fri, 10:56pm
                       Collapse There aren't that many reviews yet. Nagini6 777 1 Fri, 10:59pm
                           Yeah Jax_Teller 723 0 Fri, 11:04pm
                       Agreed Fili 722 0 Fri, 11:04pm
                   a few reasons Escapist 719 0 Fri, 11:07pm
           Collapse "The one character of any substance in the picture is Tauriel." Nightwing 949 1 Fri, 10:54pm
               well, i know that's not gonna be true for me unexpectedvisitor 626 0 Fri, 11:28pm
           He tries to make the negative review... Arannir 665 0 Fri, 11:20pm
           Collapse While I disagree with many of the scathing details, I DEFINITELY understand what he is saying about AinurOlorin 883 2 3:07am
               I see what you're saying. Fili 747 0 4:05am
               For myself Ham_Sammy 729 0 4:11am
       Collapse The Guardian review Hsvfan 993 33 Fri, 10:18pm
           Collapse Is that he has give DoS 4 / 5 stars? Wordofmask 775 3 Fri, 10:22pm
               Collapse Yep Hsvfan 911 2 Fri, 10:25pm
                   Collapse I think that Wordofmask 806 1 Fri, 10:33pm
                       Afraid that Indiewire will give it negative too Wordofmask 649 0 Fri, 10:45pm
           Collapse I remember... Macsen 946 3 Fri, 10:23pm
               Collapse Ummm ... they actually praised ROTK ... DanielLB 877 2 Fri, 10:26pm
                   Collapse No... Macsen 809 1 Fri, 10:31pm
                       Are you sure it was The Guardian? DanielLB 727 0 Fri, 10:38pm
           great review unexpectedvisitor 931 0 Fri, 10:26pm
           ? Dipling 871 0 Fri, 10:27pm
           Collapse That is a fantastic review from The Guardian! ShireHorse 591 10 Fri, 10:53pm
               7 haarp 664 0 12:20am
               Collapse Erm... Kendalf 621 8 12:29am
                   Collapse Well... Calmandcloudless 569 3 12:38am
                       Collapse Ha! Kendalf 547 2 12:43am
                           Collapse Average Rating RT paleiko 542 1 12:45am
                               no, it should be 7.5 Arannir 535 0 12:46am
                   Collapse An idea of what to expect from UK newspaper reviews. The Red Avenger 490 3 1:01am
                       And what do you expect from Kermode in The Observer? Glóin the Dark 442 0 1:09am
                       Spot on, mostly Kendalf 371 0 10:46am
                       It will be interesting to compare them all with how they reviewed ROTK DanielLB 352 0 10:48am
           Collapse At last! A well-written review. Osskil 764 2 Fri, 11:07pm
               i think both it and Variety are the best reviews so far unexpectedvisitor 573 0 Fri, 11:32pm
               Indeed Kendalf 574 0 12:35am
         Collapse That's a brilliant, well-written review Glorfindela 705 6 Fri, 11:16pm
               Collapse I agree and I said so on page 3. ShireHorse 633 5 Fri, 11:22pm
                   Collapse yeah, pay most attention to the critics you respect unexpectedvisitor 551 4 Fri, 11:37pm
                       I don't find it strange. Fili 499 0 Fri, 11:43pm
                       Collapse 80% on Rotten Tomatoes hobbitrunner 526 2 Fri, 11:44pm
                           Collapse with 5 in... Arannir 793 1 Fri, 11:57pm
                               Hmm If my memory is not that bad Wordofmask 759 0 12:01am
           Collapse Most well written review thus far, however... Aragorn the Elfstone 778 1 12:01am
               Agreed! Osskil 593 0 5:53am
       Collapse Glowing tweet from David Ehrlich Thorin's Oakenshield 829 1 Fri, 11:12pm
           Rottentomato just start up DoS's score Wordofmask 676 0 Fri, 11:21pm
       Collapse 80% on RT atm daemoon 724 5 Fri, 11:20pm
           Or increase tsmith675 681 0 Fri, 11:22pm
           From my memory Wordofmask 698 0 Fri, 11:22pm
           Increase.. Nagini6 620 0 Fri, 11:32pm
           Collapse 70 at Metacritic atm daemoon 743 1 12:09am
               yeah vader815 677 0 12:17am
       Collapse Time Out London's Keith Uhlich likes it! BartTheBowman 657 1 Fri, 11:41pm
           Thx and great! Wordofmask 508 0 Fri, 11:51pm
       Empire 4/5??? Arannir 806 0 12:05am
       Collapse IGN gves 8.5 BartTheBowman 658 1 12:37am
           Full article by Jim Vejvoda BartTheBowman 593 0 12:49am
       Collapse RT 83%, Average Ratin 7.5 Arannir 641 1 12:37am
           **** them Wordofmask 753 0 4:18am
       Great... Arannir 582 0 12:44am
       Collapse Better reviews, more sell-outs, more screenings... Arannir 562 3 12:52am
           Collapse AUJ didn't take a hit at the BO or with general audiences. Escapist 462 2 1:08am
               Collapse The competition... Arannir 446 1 1:10am
                   Frozen Escapist 682 0 1:16am
       Collapse The Wrap... Joe20 825 7 1:11am
           Yes!!! Arannir 719 0 1:14am
           Collapse Skipped over the more spoiler-ish parts... Salmacis81 453 5 2:31am
               Collapse I know acigos00 420 4 2:42am
                   Collapse IGN review AncalagontheBlack 439 2 2:46am
                       IGN video review AncalagontheBlack 396 0 2:57am
                       NOW THAT'S MORE LIKE IT!!!! acigos00 397 0 2:59am
                   Not sure... Elutherian 388 0 2:51am
       Collapse Very positive from HitFix: 'The Hobbit' improves in every way with the thrilling 'Desolation Of Smaug' MatthewJer18 787 5 1:18am
           I was just about to post this... tsmith675 676 0 1:21am
           ... Arannir 668 0 1:23am
           Collapse It's great to hear the (mostly) positive reaction to Tauriel. Joe20 654 1 1:26am
               Yes Adanel 550 0 2:01am
           Why AUJ was not the movie we thought it would be.... The Red Avenger 639 0 1:45am
       Collapse guardian uk book Gandalf 689 2 1:28am
           Collapse Me too Kendalf 347 1 10:49am
               Looking forward to TABA Danielos 337 0 10:56am
       Collapse Total Film 4/5 Arannir 717 7 1:44am
           4/5 (or 8/10) tsmith675 627 0 1:51am
           Collapse I'm getting mixed messages now demnation 631 5 2:04am
               Collapse Contradictions The Red Avenger 571 2 2:09am
                   Annoyed The Red Avenger 538 0 2:13am
                   The only reason I bring it up demnation 515 0 2:18am
               emotion Escapist 514 0 2:21am
               As Gandalf said to Frodo in FOTR EE: hamlet 506 0 2:29am
       Looks promising... Salmacis81 642 0 1:57am
       Collapse another very positive one from screendaily! BartTheBowman 714 5 5:42am
           Collapse Things are looking up. happydood 638 4 5:56am
               untill this time Wordofmask 605 0 6:06am
               I wouldn't take much notice of Rotten Tomatoes just yet. Joe20 605 0 6:06am
               Collapse Why is it depressing? jmeyer2039 575 1 6:19am
                   Don't misunderstand me, happydood 532 0 6:31am
       Collapse So according to this forum - pulpfiction16 579 3 6:32am
           Collapse That's taking it to an extreme Annatar598 545 2 6:50am
               Collapse Don't overdo it with the critic bashing Arannir 382 1 8:39am
                   silveramigos video review AncalagontheBlack 332 0 9:20am
       Two reviews from Middle-earth News Joe20 466 0 8:26am
       Collapse Apparantly RT moderators decided Empire should be counted as 4/5... Arannir 330 2 9:30am
           Collapse Save review AncalagontheBlack 316 1 9:34am
               I think on both sites the moderators decide in the end... Arannir 284 0 9:41am
       Summary Arannir 297 0 9:43am
       Collapse Negative from the Telegraph. MatthewJer18 295 5 10:03am
           Collapse I thought... Arannir 256 2 10:10am
               Collapse Very curious that RT obviously adds negatives first. Nagini6 205 1 10:24am
                   Yes and that melted 78 to 70 immedietly Wordofmask 196 0 10:27am
           Ouch, BornOutOfTheWest 208 0 10:24am
           This was inevitable Shagrat 308 0 11:30am
       Collapse TORN Danielos 424 1 10:30am
           Quickbeam just posted his review :) Arannir 426 0 10:32am
       Very positive from Time Out London BartTheBowman 431 0 10:43am
       Collapse Anothr positive one BartTheBowman 293 2 12:07pm
           Collapse This would change the positive-negative ratio... Arannir 261 1 12:15pm
               Telegragh: Quelle Surprise - Robbie Collins The Red Avenger 162 0 1:27pm
       Twenty bonus points for the first person who can... Glóin the Dark 1 0 3 secs ago

  Collapse Concerning reactions to the CGI... ecthelionsbeard 1075 17 Fri, 6:27pm Jump to last post in thread (by BalrogTrainer)
       Collapse I shouldn't think so Glorfindela 472 1 Fri, 6:57pm
           And, sauget.diblosio 389 0 Fri, 7:16pm
       I'm taking a "wait and see" attitude. sauget.diblosio 400 0 Fri, 7:10pm
       There will always be those tarasaurus 393 0 Fri, 7:13pm
       I greatly prefer HFR as well. Imladris18 390 0 Fri, 7:14pm
       Collapse My only conclusion: Erally 422 1 Fri, 7:14pm
           Yeah, the whole CGI thing seems odd to me. sauget.diblosio 379 0 Fri, 7:35pm
       Collapse Hmmm... Macsen 334 2 Fri, 7:50pm
           I completely agree with this statement... Dcole4 102 0 12:55am
           Eh BalrogTrainer 7 0 20 mins ago
       While I can't comment on the likelihood of your explanation... Macfeast 316 0 Fri, 8:07pm
       Collapse CGI can be awesome or it can cheapen a project. Escapist 313 4 Fri, 8:11pm
           Collapse Well Jax_Teller 252 3 Fri, 8:55pm
               Collapse I agree with your sentiments. Fili 224 1 Fri, 9:13pm
                   He he Jax_Teller 191 0 Fri, 9:35pm
               Gollum was absolutely incredible in HFR unexpectedvisitor 183 0 Fri, 9:44pm
       bear in mind the reaction to AUJ was similar unexpectedvisitor 193 0 Fri, 9:42pm

  Collapse Thread Locked Hey my fellow middle Earthlings... Justin Chang ( Variety)has his fresh review up over on Rottentomatoes! poochies 706 1 Fri, 6:12pm Jump to last post in thread (by Arannir)
       Thread Locked See the review thread below.... ;) Arannir 392 0 Fri, 6:26pm

  Collapse EMPIRE gives DoS 5 Stars! tsmith675 1932 22 Fri, 6:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Smaug Report)
       Collapse Variety Holly report Wordofmask 1029 1 Fri, 6:09pm
           I don't think they are breaking it LoremIpsum 926 0 Fri, 6:16pm
       Collapse NICE! unexpectedvisitor 971 1 Fri, 6:10pm
           You're correct... tsmith675 918 0 Fri, 6:11pm
       great review! unexpectedvisitor 900 0 Fri, 6:21pm
       in metacritic Wordofmask 866 0 Fri, 6:35pm
       Yesssss! Ataahua 791 0 Fri, 6:40pm
       Nice one! Glorfindela 732 0 Fri, 6:47pm
       Wohooo! GREAT news! Danielos 681 0 Fri, 7:04pm
       Collapse 8 haarp 699 2 Fri, 7:07pm
         Can Bomby quote this? Bombadil 615 0 Fri, 7:22pm
           lol unexpectedvisitor 302 0 Fri, 9:29pm
       Collapse I hate to bring a downer on the festivities...but EMPIRE has a tendency to get a little...over enthusiastic about Big Films malickfan 534 7 Fri, 8:04pm
           I see what you're saying... tsmith675 493 0 Fri, 8:09pm
           Collapse Empire Macsen 496 4 Fri, 8:10pm
               Collapse comingsoon review!!!` acigos00 465 2 Fri, 8:48pm
                   Collapse thanks! unexpectedvisitor 300 1 Fri, 9:32pm
                       About Dol Guldur Jax_Teller 205 0 Fri, 10:59pm
               As they should Ziggy Stardust 94 0 2:07am
           I was thinking the same thing Ziggy Stardust 99 0 2:06am
       Some bad, some good Mithfânion 408 0 Fri, 9:12pm
       Thanks for posting Smaug Report 102 0 2:08am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 633 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3
home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.