Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 987 (353710 posts in 14803 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 987 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 167313 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 119782 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 21727 0 Oct 12 2014, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

Collapse Sticky: Folks from the Uni of Waikato want to know YOUR opinion on BotFA! greendragon 5738 25 Jan 21, 4:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by elf-lady)

  Collapse Radagast and Beorn plot DainPig 263 11 Mon, 6:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
       Many of us know you Live in Brazil.. Bombadil 194 0 Mon, 8:13pm
       Collapse Hopefully Mooseboy018 189 5 Mon, 8:18pm
           Collapse Personally don't want to see that Kilidoescartwheels 153 4 Mon, 9:05pm
               Collapse What? DainPig 105 3 Mon, 10:14pm
                   He is in the book - but actually (and unfortunately)not in the Movie-Hobbit NoelGallagher 72 0 Mon, 11:14pm
                   More Beorn is fine, Kilidoescartwheels 57 0 Mon, 11:44pm
                   Not according to PJ. Mooseboy018 37 0 12:36am
       Collapse The TE explained rather poorly Milieuterrien 152 3 Mon, 9:07pm
           Collapse Was Beorn caught? Otaku-sempai 134 1 Mon, 9:21pm
               That would make interesting scenes Milieuterrien 127 0 Mon, 9:32pm
           Where did this come from? Kilidoescartwheels 61 0 Mon, 11:41pm

  Moved: If Dwarves are Norse, then are Elves Celtic? Kilidoescartwheels - - Mon, 4:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)

  Collapse Would you agree that the First 10 Minutes of BOT5A Bombadil 442 23 Mon, 3:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       No Shagrat 386 0 Mon, 4:17pm
       Yes Smaug the iron 373 0 Mon, 4:26pm
       I do not agree. // priell3 367 0 Mon, 4:27pm
       Collapse Yes! One of my favorite sections Avandel 357 7 Mon, 4:42pm
           Collapse This calls for MythBusters! Otaku-sempai 286 6 Mon, 6:00pm
               Collapse Yeah, it's a feather... Bofur01 272 3 Mon, 6:15pm
                   Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 271 2 Mon, 6:18pm
                       Collapse They are supposed to be feathers, but none big enough could be found Bofur01 264 1 Mon, 6:27pm
                           Thanks. Otaku-sempai 258 0 Mon, 6:30pm
               Collapse Multiplication of force? Avandel 14 1 2:34am
                   Sure. Otaku-sempai 2 0 4 mins ago
       Yes to Smaug Kilidoescartwheels 315 0 Mon, 5:26pm
       Collapse A trial of a recreated windlance Eruonen 252 9 Mon, 6:37pm
         GREAT FIND...HE's WayCOOL Bombadil 198 0 Mon, 7:49pm
           Collapse Proof-of-concept. Otaku-sempai 172 7 Mon, 8:25pm
               I agree, the jury rigged-bow just does not look possible as the windlance Eruonen 166 0 Mon, 8:30pm
               Collapse Not the jury-rigged number Kilidoescartwheels 133 5 Mon, 9:01pm
                   Collapse I wouldn't want to have to build one Spriggan 106 4 Mon, 10:13pm
                       Collapse Didn't Bard use the Structural Strenght Bombadil 73 2 Mon, 11:18pm
                           No, the arrow was on Bain's shoulder Kilidoescartwheels 59 0 Mon, 11:50pm
                           Actually... Otaku-sempai 2 0 2 mins ago
                       pre-existing holes Kilidoescartwheels 59 0 Mon, 11:48pm
       Sure CathrineB 56 0 Mon, 11:59pm

Collapse "The White Gems of Lasgalen"... Bombadil 481 20 Mon, 2:42am Jump to last post in thread (by Pandallo)
       Collapse Another mistake by Jackson.... Morthoron 436 10 Mon, 3:47am
           Collapse Legolas Greenleaf Arthael 415 8 Mon, 4:43am
               Collapse Greenleaf is not his surame... Eleniel 374 7 Mon, 6:24am
                   Collapse Legolas of Gondolin Otaku-sempai 341 5 Mon, 8:12am
                       Collapse another Legolas in what sense Elthir 232 2 Mon, 1:04pm
                           Collapse The other Legolas Otaku-sempai 169 1 Mon, 3:05pm
                               Silvan dialectal form Elthir 146 0 Mon, 3:45pm
                       Collapse family names Elthir 205 1 Mon, 1:51pm
                           No, I did not mean that Greenleaf was a surname. Otaku-sempai 166 0 Mon, 3:13pm
                   about the Quenya Elthir 239 0 Mon, 12:45pm
           Well CathrineB 278 0 Mon, 11:18am
       Lasgalen Otaku-sempai 431 0 Mon, 4:05am
       Collapse How did the Dwarves obtain the white gems? Nuradar 180 5 Mon, 2:43pm
           The Elves needed the Dwarves to Fashion it Bombadil 171 0 Mon, 3:02pm
           Collapse We don't know the origin of the White Gems of Lasgalen Otaku-sempai 158 3 Mon, 3:27pm
               Collapse But didn't they belong to his wife? Nuradar 138 2 Mon, 3:56pm
                   Collapse Did they? Otaku-sempai 116 1 Mon, 4:34pm
                       Ahhh... Nuradar 94 0 Mon, 6:02pm
       Collapse Thranduil gave the gems to have a necklace made Milieuterrien 58 1 Mon, 8:39pm
           It's my understanding... Pandallo 22 0 12:28am

  Collapse I lost it Hamfast Gamgee 731 17 Sat, 10:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by glor)
       I think the film makes clear that Gandalf doesn't buy it. Spriggan 701 0 Sat, 11:01pm
       Collapse Gandalf never bought it MyWeeLadGimli 368 6 Sun, 7:31pm
           Collapse Blame Saruman Otaku-sempai 365 5 Sun, 7:35pm
               Collapse Blame Tolkien on this one, I think. Spriggan 334 4 Sun, 8:28pm
                   Collapse I think... Guert 161 1 Mon, 12:40pm
                       Exactly. glor 9 0 58 mins ago
                   Collapse Other rings of power tgshaw 158 1 Mon, 12:49pm
                       Unfortunately, and oddly, Tolkien specifies that he did know Spriggan 153 0 Mon, 1:11pm
       Collapse Gandalf only knew that Bilbo had found Milieuterrien 66 8 Mon, 8:58pm
           I don't think that's right. Spriggan 62 0 Mon, 9:09pm
           Collapse No, Gandalf knew (or guessed) about a ring. Otaku-sempai 61 6 Mon, 9:10pm
               Collapse Gandalf guessed, but he didn't know Milieuterrien 54 5 Mon, 9:20pm
                   Collapse Okay Otaku-sempai 48 2 Mon, 9:25pm
                       Collapse Gandalf knew that Bilbo had had a ring Milieuterrien 42 1 Mon, 9:35pm
                           Maybe. Otaku-sempai 39 0 Mon, 9:37pm
                   Collapse He says that he knew. Spriggan 41 1 Mon, 9:39pm
                       I can concede Milieuterrien 31 0 Mon, 10:14pm

  Collapse Amazon Uk has extended edition up for Nov. 16 Mithfânion 479 1 Sat, 6:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       SPOILERY SPECULATION VID links #2 and #3 from Pryftan Avandel 441 0 Sat, 7:42pm

  Collapse Why does Thranduil turn the Dwarves away? lionoferebor 516 6 Fri, 8:34pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       grudges Mooseboy018 445 0 Fri, 9:38pm
       Collapse They didn't give a lot of detail in the films, but.... Silverlode 413 2 Fri, 11:00pm
           Collapse But Avandel 383 1 Sat, 12:29am
               Maybe an early decision to head for Moria? moreorless 64 0 Mon, 12:07pm
       Were the Elves even there because of the Dragon? Otaku-sempai 180 0 Sat, 10:15pm
       "Starving, homeless, asking for help." Otaku-sempai 39 0 Mon, 3:46pm

  Collapse BOTFA is Nominated for 8 Online Whale Awards Smaug the iron 563 5 Jul 1, 11:22pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruvandi)
       Whale awards? Really? CathrineB 515 0 Jul 1, 11:27pm
       Martin Freeman nominated? DainPig 504 0 Jul 2, 12:03am
       For aspects of the film I thought were outstanding Glorfindela 374 0 Thu, 9:27am
       You can vote by commenting. Peterthorn of Rohan 372 0 Thu, 9:30am
       Whale Awards? Eruvandi 250 0 Thu, 7:58pm

  Collapse Why do the people hate Azog? DainPig 1260 65 Jun 30, 6:38pm Jump to last post in thread (by Milieuterrien)
       I agree... Ereinion Nénharma 1131 0 Jun 30, 6:45pm
       Collapse A lot of the complaints I've heard... Eruvandi 1127 1 Jun 30, 6:55pm
           Actually Adrianna 841 0 Jul 1, 5:24am
       Because he's not very nice.... dormouse 1083 0 Jun 30, 7:43pm
       Because of the Durins Avandel 1068 0 Jun 30, 8:02pm
       Collapse not Azog necessarily Mooseboy018 1045 18 Jun 30, 8:36pm
           Collapse Yup, his story makes zero sense... AshNazg 1003 17 Jun 30, 9:27pm
               Collapse I would recast that somewhat - and don't think the conclusion is the same. Spriggan 953 16 Jun 30, 11:12pm
                   Collapse Azog brotherbeck 911 2 Jul 1, 1:00am
                       Collapse What I find interesting in that... Pandallo 901 1 Jul 1, 1:16am
                           The Beginning of DoS brotherbeck 885 0 Jul 1, 1:37am
                   Collapse Things that don't make sense... AshNazg 759 12 Jul 1, 10:03am
                       That's quite long so I'll split up replies: Intro, 1. and 2. Spriggan 730 0 Jul 1, 11:17am
                       3. Why did he wait. Spriggan 719 0 Jul 1, 11:35am
                       Collapse 4. and conclusion. Spriggan 713 9 Jul 1, 11:44am
                           Respect, DainPig. NoelGallagher 702 0 Jul 1, 12:07pm
                           Collapse We clearly view films very differently AshNazg 501 7 Thu, 12:05pm
                               Collapse I don't think I follow all of that. Spriggan 483 6 Thu, 1:23pm
                                   Collapse I see your viewpoint, but I disagree with it... AshNazg 475 5 Thu, 2:28pm
                                       Collapse Something just occurred to me on your bomb point.... dormouse 467 1 Thu, 3:24pm
                                           Like any theory there are exceptions... AshNazg 296 0 Fri, 7:51am
                                       Azog brotherbeck 458 0 Thu, 3:25pm
                                       This then seems like a third category of objection. Spriggan 463 0 Thu, 3:32pm
                                       Oh and just on DG in the text as an example Spriggan 423 0 Thu, 6:17pm
       I find the character to be unimaginative. Meneldor 1042 0 Jun 30, 8:36pm
       I actually... CathrineB 1023 0 Jun 30, 9:01pm
       I think he makes a good villain Glorfindela 951 0 Jun 30, 11:10pm
       He killed Fili Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 893 0 Jul 1, 1:27am
       Collapse He was superfluous. DanielLB 813 22 Jul 1, 6:44am
           I'm not sure about this... dormouse 527 0 Thu, 9:19am
           Collapse I agree with this 100% Fredeghar Wayfarer 279 20 Fri, 9:10am
               Totally agree... Salmacis81 194 0 Sat, 6:10pm
               Collapse Given the fact that Azog and Bolg had been named by Tolkien Milieuterrien 175 18 Sat, 7:28pm
                   Collapse But why couldn't they stay within canon? That's what I don't get... Salmacis81 139 17 Sun, 4:38pm
                       Collapse They could have, easily. Otaku-sempai 116 16 Sun, 7:45pm
                           Oh yeah, I KNOW they could've stayed within the canon... Salmacis81 106 0 Sun, 8:06pm
                           Collapse Anything could be done Spriggan 94 4 Sun, 8:37pm
                               Collapse Um...huh? Otaku-sempai 87 3 Sun, 9:04pm
                                   Collapse I think that probably illustrates the point. Spriggan 82 2 Sun, 9:26pm
                                       Collapse I see. Otaku-sempai 173 1 Sun, 10:41pm
                                           Changes brotherbeck 155 0 Sun, 11:23pm
                           Collapse What 'Jackson fell in love with' is speculation, I feel Glorfindela 141 9 Mon, 12:44am
                               Collapse Perhaps; perhaps not. Otaku-sempai 133 8 Mon, 12:57am
                                   Collapse It was actually Philippa Boyens who made the statement about Azog the Defiler... Eleniel 117 7 Mon, 6:32am
                                       Thanks Otaku-sempai 104 0 Mon, 7:58am
                                       Collapse I remember that, too Glorfindela 91 5 Mon, 10:41am
                                           Collapse How would that work? Otaku-sempai 72 4 Mon, 3:50pm
                                               Collapse How would what work? Glorfindela 70 3 Mon, 4:09pm
                                                   Collapse Crushing on the actor is all well and good. Otaku-sempai 60 2 Mon, 4:41pm
                                                       Collapse Argh! Glorfindela 56 1 Mon, 5:19pm
                                                           Look. I understood what you posted. Otaku-sempai 53 0 Mon, 5:54pm
       Collapse It started badly Michelle Johnston 630 9 Jul 1, 5:25pm
           They had no other choice than explaining their own plot Milieuterrien 519 0 Jul 1, 11:08pm
           Collapse Well, if Azog did 'just pop up'....... dormouse 522 4 Thu, 9:36am
               Collapse DM I think you have misunderstood me. Michelle Johnston 375 3 Thu, 8:54pm
                   Collapse Not really, I simply answered what you said.... dormouse 351 1 Thu, 10:16pm
                       DM correction again Michelle Johnston 307 0 Fri, 6:20am
                   Excellent analysis Michelle... Salmacis81 184 0 Sat, 6:33pm
           Collapse It's not about the story Milieuterrien 35 2 Mon, 8:20pm
               Collapse Killing Azog Otaku-sempai 32 1 Mon, 8:34pm
                   Don't forget we have three meetings between Azog and Bolg Milieuterrien 22 0 Mon, 9:30pm
       because he is bad :) Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 555 0 Jul 1, 9:02pm
       I think one of the reasons people dislked Azog - Hanzkaz 529 0 Thu, 8:56am
       Collapse He's a one-dimensional bad guy Kilidoescartwheels 371 1 Thu, 9:09pm
           I can't really agree there... moreorless 87 0 Mon, 11:50am

  Collapse ''Bilbo is right...'' Matthijs 589 5 Jun 30, 5:20pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bofur01)
       Welcome to the forum Matthijs Smaug the iron 551 0 Jun 30, 5:26pm
       trailer line Mooseboy018 532 0 Jun 30, 5:37pm
       That could be interesting. Eruvandi 484 0 Jun 30, 6:40pm
       Collapse I think this could be part of the extended Arkenstone debate... AshNazg 385 1 Jun 30, 9:51pm
           Well yes, and Gandalf will have to say... Bofur01 381 0 Jun 30, 10:01pm

  Collapse Little scenes that would have been nice.... Eruonen 997 12 Jun 28, 5:14am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Legolas' arrows AshNazg 859 1 Jun 28, 11:42am
         Legolas' hanging upside down Bracegirdle 818 0 Jun 28, 1:20pm
       Smaug smashing the Mountainside Otaku-sempai 818 0 Jun 28, 1:22pm
       This would only work Bishop 781 0 Jun 28, 3:18pm
       DOS: The giant golden Dwarf statue Legolas_Shoehorn 745 0 Jun 28, 4:31pm
       Thranduil's halls... yes xxxyyy 721 0 Jun 28, 5:10pm
       Scenes in BOT5A? Kilidoescartwheels 654 0 Jun 28, 8:03pm
       Collapse i don't recall that Barrow-Wight 647 1 Jun 28, 8:21pm
           AUJ Appendices MyWeeLadGimli 624 0 Jun 28, 9:05pm
       Collapse Details Avandel 280 2 Jun 30, 7:59pm
           Collapse Especially your 2nd point as that scene in DOS was a little unreal Eruonen 267 1 Jun 30, 8:32pm
             Don't we NEED Raddy giving Gandalf HIS STAFF? Bombadil 117 0 Fri, 6:00pm

  Collapse Fili, Kili and Tauriel - Extended Edition scene DainPig 1460 21 Jun 27, 6:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Gandalf the Green)
       Collapse More Kili - Fili Interactions would be most welcome but... Dcole4 1370 4 Jun 27, 6:54pm
           missing Thranduil scene. Mooseboy018 1285 0 Jun 27, 8:24pm
           Collapse *sigh* Avandel 1260 2 Jun 27, 8:39pm
               Collapse This. Eruvandi 321 1 Jun 30, 6:22pm
                   Extension? Gandalf the Green 150 0 Fri, 1:21pm
       Collapse yes Mooseboy018 1274 1 Jun 27, 8:29pm
         I agree with ya DainPig 1245 0 Jun 27, 8:46pm
       Not for me Avandel 1261 0 Jun 27, 8:33pm
       But why would Fili ask who Tauriel is.... dormouse 1169 0 Jun 27, 10:32pm
       We need more Fili, but Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1114 0 Jun 28, 12:20am
       No Glorfindela 1088 0 Jun 28, 1:45am
       Collapse Ah no way CathrineB 934 6 Jun 28, 10:40am
           Collapse Kili's anger Kilidoescartwheels 788 5 Jun 28, 7:57pm
               Collapse Yeah CathrineB 726 4 Jun 28, 10:25pm
                   Collapse Dwalin and Fili Mooseboy018 693 3 Jun 29, 12:54am
                       Collapse Faramir an Eowyn too Elanor of Rohan 569 2 Jun 29, 2:00pm
                           Don´t forget Smaug the iron 565 0 Jun 29, 2:04pm
                           Yes.... dormouse 417 0 Jun 30, 6:42am
       Collapse OK, I'll play along Kilidoescartwheels 793 2 Jun 28, 7:54pm
           Collapse Doesn't sound like something PJ would approve... AshNazg 789 1 Jun 28, 8:12pm
               You mean another "subtle" reference to LoTR? Kilidoescartwheels 658 0 Jun 29, 4:52am

  Collapse The Curse of the Orcs on the Hill Arandir 561 3 Jun 27, 9:59am Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)
       Collapse Some of the concepts are the same exact shots in FoTR... Hobbity Hobbit 520 2 Jun 27, 11:08am
           Collapse Or maybe... Fredeghar Wayfarer 96 1 Fri, 9:34am
               Shirkers. Silverlode 67 0 Fri, 11:02pm

  Collapse Dwarves by age of actor DainPig 681 12 Jun 27, 12:00am Jump to last post in thread (by MyWeeLadGimli)
       Collapse Wow MyWeeLadGimli 584 3 Jun 27, 3:11am
           Collapse It worked... lionoferebor 473 2 Jun 27, 5:19pm
               Collapse But an uncle can be younger than his nephew.... dormouse 417 1 Jun 27, 10:34pm
                   Most definitely... lionoferebor 384 0 Jun 28, 12:44am
       ^_^ CathrineB 573 0 Jun 27, 5:52am
       Collapse You can't go by the actor's ages! Kilidoescartwheels 411 6 Jun 27, 11:18pm
           Collapse It always... CathrineB 397 4 Jun 27, 11:57pm
               Collapse Let's talk about Ori's slingshot for a moment lionoferebor 356 2 Jun 28, 5:26am
                   Oddly enough... Pandallo 346 0 Jun 28, 7:09am
                   Another "oddly" dernwyn 322 0 Jun 28, 12:38pm
               Ori Otaku-sempai 312 0 Jun 28, 1:30pm
           Book ages MyWeeLadGimli 266 0 Jun 28, 9:01pm

  Collapse We actually got most of what we asked for... Hobbity Hobbit 1231 27 Jun 26, 10:26pm Jump to last post in thread (by Michelle Johnston)
       Collapse Well... CathrineB 1139 7 Jun 26, 10:42pm
         Exactly my sentiments Glorfindela 1121 0 Jun 26, 11:00pm
           Collapse Ditto to this post! Thrain II 1108 5 Jun 26, 11:11pm
               Collapse Same Here brotherbeck 1038 4 Jun 27, 2:09am
                   Collapse PJ explained that Kilidoescartwheels 694 3 Jun 27, 11:27pm
                       Collapse Well, I do wish the battle was more similar to the book. Eruonen 686 2 Jun 27, 11:54pm
                           Collapse Actual Physical Locations vs Green Screen & CGI Landscapes brotherbeck 653 1 Jun 28, 1:59am
                               Most of Pellenor Fields was green screen..... dormouse 602 0 Jun 28, 9:22am
       Collapse I echo your feelings rather than the four expressed above... dormouse 936 1 Jun 27, 9:39am
           Mostly agree with Dormouse Avandel 761 0 Jun 27, 7:39pm
       Collapse Well, yes and no. Spriggan 902 5 Jun 27, 11:56am
           Collapse Yes, a single tone might have been better.... dormouse 891 4 Jun 27, 12:41pm
               Oh sorry .... Spriggan 881 0 Jun 27, 12:52pm
               Collapse Do not agree Begather 131 2 Jun 30, 9:13am
                   Don't you? I think it might, purely in terms of producing.... dormouse 103 0 Jun 30, 2:56pm
                   Courage he needed courage Michelle Johnston 87 0 Jun 30, 6:09pm
       Collapse I am reserving final judgement for the EE. Eruonen 816 2 Jun 27, 4:53pm
         Collapse In Some Ways PJ needed to be a MIND-READER? Bombadil 766 1 Jun 27, 7:31pm
               Well, no, I will disagree with that.... Avandel 747 0 Jun 27, 8:16pm
       Collapse I didn't ask for an Elf/Dwarf romance, or Azog to be brought back from the dead... Salmacis81 527 6 Jun 28, 6:54pm
           Collapse Green screen brotherbeck 481 5 Jun 28, 10:30pm
               Dale Smaug the iron 481 0 Jun 28, 10:42pm
               I know the feeling CathrineB 472 0 Jun 28, 10:47pm
               Indeed, and add the Ride of the Rohirrim and the trip to the Black Gate... Eleniel 437 0 Jun 29, 6:18am
               Collapse But what is 'real'.... dormouse 425 1 Jun 29, 8:03am
                   Not only Dale, Milieuterrien 350 0 Jun 29, 12:21pm
       The Original Intensions Michelle Johnston 393 0 Jun 29, 11:30am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 987 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.