Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 930 (332751 posts in 13942 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 930 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 143872 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 109854 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 3101 0 Oct 12, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

Collapse Sticky: ---> OFFICIAL USER REVIEW THREAD Olorin2607 8959 265 Dec 9, 7:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by pettytyrant101)

  Collapse Sticky: Help us Thank the entire cast & crew of 'All Six Middle-earth Films' News from Bree 249 3 Dec 23, 4:27am Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Instances of Foreshadowing patrickk 200 5 3:35am Jump to last post in thread (by patrickk)
       Collapse There are a lot pettytyrant101 115 4 3:44am
           Collapse Which LOTR scenes did you have in mind patrickk 88 2 3:58am
               Collapse off the top of my head pettytyrant101 78 1 4:27am
                   I think this comes down to sensibilties... patrickk 30 0 6:38am
           Regardless, Lindele 83 0 4:19am

  Moved: What exactly is the power of the dwarven Rings? xxxyyy - - 1:45am Jump to last post in thread (by xxxyyy)

  Collapse So which way did Azogs army march to Erebor? boldog 183 6 1:12am Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       Collapse Doesn't Bolg meet some Gundabad scouts? Spriggan 102 1 1:20am
           Yes I believe so Ham_Sammy 77 0 1:38am
       Collapse 6 haarp 100 3 1:21am
           Collapse Those giant worms... DigificWriter 97 2 1:42am
               Collapse Sort of similar Ham_Sammy 86 1 1:45am
                   A more accurate comparison... DigificWriter 83 0 1:49am

  Collapse Ny two film edit Elutherian 714 42 Sat, 11:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Why... DigificWriter 453 0 Sat, 11:13pm
       I was just giving it a go... Bofur01 436 0 Sat, 11:14pm
       Project Danielos 414 0 Sat, 11:17pm
       Collapse I'm making a two film edit at the moment Beorn's Bees 415 31 Sat, 11:23pm
           Collapse Still baffled... DigificWriter 408 21 Sat, 11:28pm
               Collapse In my opinion Ham_Sammy 371 2 Sat, 11:38pm
                   Collapse Actually... DigificWriter 364 1 Sat, 11:40pm
                       That's what I meant Ham_Sammy 324 0 12:00am
               Collapse because Me85 334 17 Sat, 11:55pm
                   Collapse Like it or not... DigificWriter 327 16 12:00am
                       Collapse Has it ever occurred to you... Bofur01 323 15 12:02am
                           Collapse Making changes... DigificWriter 309 11 12:06am
                               I love the Hobbit films... Bofur01 296 0 12:11am
                               Collapse Hmmm.... Morthoron 113 9 3:58am
                                   Collapse People need to knock it off... DigificWriter 103 8 4:16am
                                       Collapse I find it disrespectul to Tolkien, so I guess we're even... Morthoron 74 6 5:41am
                                           Collapse Tauriel... DigificWriter 64 5 6:09am
                                               Collapse I am uninterested in what you take seriously... Morthoron 57 3 6:32am
                                                   Collapse Aragorn frenching his horse? Starling 41 2 6:50am
                                                       Collapse It's after the Aragorn falling off a cliff and being lost for dead scene... Bladerunner 24 1 7:23am
                                                           I was being completely sarcastic Starling 22 0 7:29am
                                               Itaril/Tauriel... Bladerunner 24 0 7:16am
                                     Agree – it is annoying and disrespectful, to put it mildly Glorfindela 12 0 30 mins ago
                           Collapse trilogy Danielos 297 2 12:11am
                               Me either Ham_Sammy 275 0 12:24am
                             can I put, like swordwhale 84 0 5:18am
           Collapse Short version: Elutherian 393 8 Sat, 11:31pm
               If it ain't broke, why fix it? DigificWriter 357 0 Sat, 11:35pm
               Collapse The thing is, the more you cut, the more difficult it gets. Bofur01 367 6 Sat, 11:35pm
                   Collapse Give me a while...... Elutherian 360 5 Sat, 11:37pm
                       Collapse Ok here it is... Elutherian 292 4 12:28am
                           Could you still include Legolas... Bladerunner 229 0 1:15am
                           I can dig that Ham_Sammy 207 0 1:33am
                           I really want to see this when you're finished Gianna 150 0 2:23am
                           I haven't cut Tauriel like you have! sycorax82 135 0 3:03am
       Collapse I feel sorry for you guys... xxxyyy 336 2 12:08am
           Collapse Just so you understand me... Bofur01 303 1 12:14am
               Ah! Good good // xxxyyy 162 0 1:48am
       It would be interesting... DigificWriter 179 0 1:40am
       Me too! KateTheHobbit 148 0 2:36am
       I've done a bit of this sort of thing myself pettytyrant101 143 0 3:01am
       2 Films how to arrive there Michelle Johnston 34 0 7:02am

  Collapse The 2-film script Bofur01 768 8 Sat, 8:35pm Jump to last post in thread (by There&ThereAgain)
       Collapse Riverbank Lost Hobbit 426 1 Sat, 9:07pm
           PJ said SafeUnderHill 332 0 Sat, 10:13pm
       Collapse The 'original cut' of An Unexpected Journey... DigificWriter 347 3 Sat, 10:17pm
           Collapse Also, BornOutOfTheWest 244 2 Sat, 10:50pm
               I was counting that under the heading of "the Carrock sequence" DigificWriter 216 0 Sat, 11:06pm
               They only showed... Bofur01 204 0 Sat, 11:18pm
       Both films would have been brilliant, is what I believe sycorax82 99 0 2:33am
       the Balin/Bard scene There&ThereAgain 17 0 7:32am

  Collapse Balin and Dwalin Appreciation Thread DisDwarfWoman 373 13 Sat, 7:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by Old Toby)
       8 haarp 221 0 Sat, 8:06pm
       Absolutely love those! Ham_Sammy 178 0 Sat, 8:55pm
       Collapse Don't forget Dwalin and Thorin Riven Delve 173 9 Sat, 9:34pm
           Love that one too! Ham_Sammy 142 0 Sat, 9:53pm
           Collapse haha, yes! DisDwarfWoman 125 6 Sat, 10:25pm
               Collapse Hee hee Riven Delve 113 1 Sat, 10:32pm
                   yep! DisDwarfWoman 106 0 Sat, 10:38pm
               Collapse It was Ham_Sammy 119 3 Sat, 10:33pm
                   Collapse That's cool! DisDwarfWoman 107 2 Sat, 10:39pm
                       Collapse Loebelia no doubt Ham_Sammy 98 1 Sat, 10:49pm
                           right... DisDwarfWoman 90 0 Sat, 10:55pm
           loved that line! Old Toby 13 0 6:42am
       yep........ swordwhale 27 0 5:22am

  Collapse Rankings Elutherian 381 8 Sat, 5:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Nira)
       Some interesting questions... moreorless 155 0 Sat, 8:30pm
       mine Mooseboy018 131 0 Sat, 8:42pm
       Entertaining good thread Ham_Sammy 124 0 Sat, 8:48pm
       Rankings KingTurgon 102 0 Sat, 9:15pm
       lots to think about Escapist 99 0 Sat, 9:17pm
       This is fun boldog 63 0 12:14am
       My rankings Gianna 34 0 2:26am
       Rankings (as of today) Nira 16 0 5:47am

  Collapse "The reasons why Peter Jackson’s Hobbit movies failed" Elfhelm 1406 32 Sat, 5:15pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       What an odd series of thoughts. Spriggan 670 0 Sat, 5:29pm
       Collapse Nothing we havenmt heard many times before... moreorless 626 2 Sat, 5:40pm
           Exactly NecromancerRising 555 0 Sat, 5:46pm
         Including that "these films have failed"... which is hilarious, mae govannen 32 0 5:57am
       Well, that was confusing. Riven Delve 576 0 Sat, 5:47pm
       Collapse Once, just once Old Toby 584 5 Sat, 5:56pm
           Collapse And just for once pettytyrant101 487 4 Sat, 6:37pm
               Collapse I think you misunderstood my comment Old Toby 355 1 Sat, 8:28pm
                   I find your comment quite correct and justified.// mae govannen 33 0 5:41am
               Collapse Well to be fair Ham_Sammy 340 1 Sat, 8:32pm
                   Not by way of comparison, though, mae govannen 34 0 5:46am
       I think he was spot on with most of his points. Azaghâl 532 0 Sat, 6:15pm
       Collapse One thing that espeically seems overplayed to me... moreorless 517 2 Sat, 6:35pm
           Collapse Jackson added lots of references to the Lord of the Rings films... Bladerunner 123 1 2:06am
               I don't see what's wrong in all the examples mae govannen 23 0 6:21am
       Collapse The review fails to fairly support its hypothesis IMO Avandel 445 1 Sat, 7:16pm
           Agree with you on all your points. // mae govannen 23 0 6:02am
       Collapse Failed? A matter of opinion. Hanzkaz 432 1 Sat, 7:22pm
           Agree fully with you; and mae govannen 40 0 5:18am
       That was just weird Elarie 414 0 Sat, 7:40pm
       Hmmmmm Ham_Sammy 375 0 Sat, 8:08pm
       Collapse This journalist... patrickk 378 4 Sat, 8:36pm
           Good post Ham_Sammy 323 0 Sat, 8:53pm
           Collapse well peterLF 101 1 2:44am
               Tolkein did in fact foreshadow... patrickk 93 0 3:14am
           You're quite right in your critic of this critic!...// mae govannen 34 0 5:39am
       Collapse Superb Silranhir 300 1 Sat, 9:31pm
           Yep... Avnar 256 0 Sat, 10:21pm
       Hmmm... Dipling 251 0 Sat, 10:39pm
       Collapse Huh? glor 154 1 1:12am
           Numerous examples Ham_Sammy 119 0 2:09am
       What "failure" is he talking about, to start with??? mae govannen 45 0 5:37am

  Collapse Hobbit Questionnaire wesray 235 1 Sat, 4:35pm Jump to last post in thread (by swordwhale)
       well that was fun swordwhale 10 0 5:13am

  Collapse Does anyone know if EomundDaughter 365 4 Sat, 4:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by KateTheHobbit)
       Some say the middle of next year.. patrickk 121 0 Sat, 8:55pm
       November at the earliest // AshNazg 70 0 Sat, 11:04pm
       The last I saw Ham_Sammy 68 0 Sat, 11:22pm
       November? KateTheHobbit 33 0 2:42am

  Collapse BOTFA - as bad as the Phantom Menace? (Not my opinion) Beorn's Bees 901 20 Sat, 3:14pm Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       It's way over the top in my view Glorfindela 468 0 Sat, 3:19pm
       Somewhat Ham_Sammy 414 0 Sat, 3:25pm
       Everyone is entitled to their opinion... MorgolKing 384 0 Sat, 3:27pm
       People have all kinds of varying opinions about BOFA. Escapist 388 0 Sat, 3:31pm
       "almost no character moments"? Loresilme 405 0 Sat, 3:57pm
       No, I think BOTFA is in a different class completely Elarie 337 0 Sat, 4:50pm
       I think the desire for "another prequals" actually explains quite a bit of the reaction... moreorless 318 0 Sat, 5:08pm
       Collapse If your friend thinks BOTFA is one of the worst films he's ever seen, Starling 296 1 Sat, 6:07pm
         ........ swordwhale 26 0 5:20am
       There was more genuine character interaction Annatar598 277 0 Sat, 6:09pm
       As someone who'd been looking forward to the Star Wars prequels - Hanzkaz 233 0 Sat, 7:49pm
       Maybe more like Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones the_scribe 190 0 Sat, 8:56pm
       In my opinion, The Phantom Menace was one of the worst movies ever made, VeArkenstone 194 0 Sat, 8:57pm
       Apart from the point of ... patrickk 180 0 Sat, 9:01pm
       Collapse Am I the only one around here KingTurgon 206 3 Sat, 9:03pm
           You're not alone MechaGodzilla 157 0 Sat, 9:37pm
           No, I still like it! (mostly) sycorax82 49 0 2:19am
           It's OK. arithmancer 14 0 7:01am
       He is correct HeadingSouth 170 0 Sat, 9:26pm
       LOL Aragorn the Elfstone 125 0 Sat, 10:46pm

Moved: COULD WE MAKE A SINGLE FORUM FOR THE SIXOLOGY? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) - - Sat, 1:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mr. Arkenstone (isaac))

  Collapse PJ's Cameo... patrickk 1256 9 Fri, 11:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by grammaboodawg)
       Collapse so not khamul then? erdildeniz 629 3 Fri, 11:51pm
           Collapse Definitely not khamul Aranarth 189 2 Sat, 2:44pm
               I suspect... DigificWriter 168 0 Sat, 3:13pm
               Not sure... patrickk 78 0 Sat, 8:54pm
       Collapse I still haven't caught it! tarasaurus 458 2 Sat, 3:07am
           Collapse Isn't Katie one of the first Laketowners you see on screen? Earl 387 1 Sat, 5:30am
               Yup. Roheryn 369 0 Sat, 5:50am
       Lake town man Arthael 355 0 Sat, 10:30am
       Yes. That's Peter. grammaboodawg 52 0 1:30am

  Collapse At last BOFA has reached us here in Australia.. patrickk 795 13 Fri, 11:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kerewyn)
       Collapse Glad it finally arrived for you. Eruonen 383 1 Fri, 11:08pm
           Personally Glorfindela 366 0 Fri, 11:28pm
       Collapse Pity that Glorfindel's place was taken by Arwen Elanor of Rohan 359 4 Fri, 11:51pm
           Collapse It just for me... patrickk 323 3 Sat, 12:32am
               Collapse No no no no no no no *terrified face* Mooseboy018 268 2 Sat, 4:34am
                   replacing arwen? Me85 226 0 Sat, 5:49am
                   Well this has certainly stirred up a hornet's nest... patrickk 184 0 Sat, 9:35am
       Glad you got to see it Ham_Sammy 313 0 Sat, 12:16am
       Collapse Here's a nice article from The Australian Kim 368 3 Sat, 12:22am
           Ditto!! Old Toby 231 0 Sat, 6:48am
           This review was also mefansmum 152 0 Sat, 1:37pm
         LOL Kim I second your agreement Avandel 114 0 Sat, 5:49pm
       Yeah, at last! Kerewyn 59 0 Sat, 11:27pm

  Collapse Rating the LotR and Hobbit films out of 10. Bofur01 1049 51 Fri, 9:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Lindele)
       Here are my ratings... ecthelionsbeard 594 0 Fri, 9:54pm
       My rankings DigificWriter 564 0 Fri, 9:57pm
       my rankings FrogmortonJustice65 530 0 Fri, 10:03pm
       6 haarp 490 0 Fri, 10:24pm
       Collapse mine Crunchable Birdses 491 10 Fri, 10:33pm
           Collapse There was no "studio-demanded 3-film split" DigificWriter 415 9 Fri, 11:29pm
               Collapse It was a bad idea regardless of who thought of it... Elizabeth 285 2 Sat, 3:09am
                   Collapse ....especially given the timing of the decision. Eurolock 274 1 Sat, 4:30am
                       That doesnt seem to mesh with what we've heard moreorless 243 0 Sat, 8:43am
               Collapse I think the reality is... Osskil 254 4 Sat, 6:59am
                   Collapse Watch the Appendices for the Extended Editions DigificWriter 238 3 Sat, 7:10am
                       Collapse My guess is that it wasnt just the amount of material moreorless 207 2 Sat, 11:01am
                           Collapse Bard Glorfindela 181 1 Sat, 12:04pm
                               Theres room enough for both but.. moreorless 170 0 Sat, 12:44pm
               right sure Crunchable Birdses 32 0 Sat, 11:57pm
       I have have given them in order... patrickk 433 0 Fri, 11:06pm
       Rankings Ham_Sammy 414 0 Fri, 11:11pm
       Mine... Joe20 387 0 Fri, 11:15pm
       Here goes BlackFox 393 0 Fri, 11:17pm
       mine MedwedtoBeorn 359 0 Fri, 11:34pm
       Mine: Glorfindela 367 0 Fri, 11:35pm
       Rating, perhaps a little arbitrary, but fun! Foromir 342 0 Sat, 12:23am
       DoS rating low CuriousG 356 0 Sat, 12:24am
       Hmmm, in the category of fantasy films Spriggan 340 0 Sat, 12:29am
       Mine m.summers343 316 0 Sat, 1:00am
       Collapse all EE of course (except BOTFA I'm predicting) Nira 316 1 Sat, 2:11am
           On that basis: Elizabeth 267 0 Sat, 3:07am
       Ok I'll bite demnation 283 0 Sat, 2:11am
       Mah ratings MechaGodzilla 275 0 Sat, 2:29am
     MINE!!! MJM 263 0 Sat, 2:50am
       My ranking... Eurolock 262 0 Sat, 2:57am
       Collapse All Extended Editions Istaris'staffs 268 1 Sat, 3:33am
           my fav and my worst mo0on-light 261 0 Sat, 6:06am
       Ratings Osskil 246 0 Sat, 6:51am
       Mine: NecromancerRising 245 0 Sat, 6:57am
       Ratings imin 226 0 Sat, 8:55am
       Collapse Everyone holds the Hobbit in much higher regard than me! Arthael 236 1 Sat, 10:52am
           Well, you liked The Hobbit films more than me! malickfan 167 0 Sat, 12:50pm
       Mine Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 197 0 Sat, 11:30am
       My Ranking malickfan 173 0 Sat, 12:48pm
       My ratings! Peterthorn of Rohan 153 0 Sat, 1:21pm
       My ratings, with explanations Scorchster 157 0 Sat, 2:00pm
       Here... Elutherian 115 0 Sat, 4:23pm
       my ratings painjoiker 100 0 Sat, 4:44pm
       My rank Miceluz 92 0 Sat, 5:02pm
       My own... SamtheMan 84 0 Sat, 6:05pm
       Collapse Fun, but useless... xxxyyy 92 2 Sat, 6:29pm
           Hobbit is a mess JayFank 49 0 Sat, 10:41pm
           Ok, I f... up the rating for TTT (there is no edit button...) xxxyyy 34 0 12:00am
       Favorites grimbeorn15 22 0 1:15am
       Ratings Lindele 10 0 4:11am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 930 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.