Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 931 (333062 posts in 13953 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 931 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 144017 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 109919 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 3206 0 Oct 12, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Sticky: Help us Thank the entire cast & crew of 'All Six Middle-earth Films' News from Bree 283 3 Dec 23, 4:27am Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Sticky: NEW! Official Hobbit movie reviews - post them here! entmaiden 75 1 1:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Faramir5)

  Moved: Dave Comer in PJ's Hobbit Production Diary Faramir5 - - 1:44am Jump to last post in thread (by Faramir5)

  Collapse 3rd Hobbit Movie Gollum1 271 2 1:34am Jump to last post in thread (by Kim)
       the appearance of HFR can be off-putting Avandel 123 0 1:44am
       Depends on who you ask - I personally love HFR Kim 65 0 3:05am

  Collapse What would have made Fili's death better Kilidoescartwheels 435 24 12:50am Jump to last post in thread (by patrickk)
       Collapse Do you mean better for the audience Spriggan 210 6 12:57am
           Collapse Well both, really Kilidoescartwheels 180 5 1:12am
               Collapse I think it might be worth separating them. Spriggan 181 4 1:21am
                   Collapse *waves hand* Riven Delve 171 2 1:35am
                       Collapse Ha ha. Spriggan 156 1 1:42am
                           How appropriate for the film version... Morthoron 132 0 2:21am
                   yes, there have been comments around the net Avandel 161 0 1:37am
       Collapse Some blood on Azog's hand-sword thing for a start Joe20 212 4 12:58am
           Collapse Oh, no, not decapitation! Kilidoescartwheels 191 3 1:10am
               Collapse Blood and Battle equals an R or 15 rating glor 140 1 2:05am
                   yep Ham_Sammy 99 0 2:46am
               Actually... lionoferebor 9 0 43 mins ago
       Collapse I think CathrineB 216 3 12:58am
           Yes it was shocking Kilidoescartwheels 181 0 1:18am
           Collapse Interesting Avandel 167 1 1:30am
               To me GhostofMacbeth 149 0 1:41am
       Collapse Fili's death has a main outcome Milieuterrien 150 1 1:59am
           The book had.. patrickk 6 0 24 mins ago
       Collapse A purpose in Fili's death Elarie 137 2 2:25am
           Collapse This JayFank 114 1 2:46am
               You've come to the wrong place if you're looking for people who don't care about the characters Riven Delve 103 0 2:51am
       I thought it was very effective Kim 77 0 3:28am
       he did fight though- we just don't see it Cirashala 47 0 5:03am
       One word - CLOSURE lionoferebor 15 0 48 mins ago

  Collapse Big Movie Productions Not to be OTT to be Commercially Successful... Girdle of Melian 250 5 12:03am Jump to last post in thread (by Girdle of Melian)
       Collapse Elves leaping over dwarves Kilidoescartwheels 114 1 1:03am
           Agree about the CGI Rams Avandel 94 0 1:13am
       Collapse Azog doesn't bother me, some lack of logic IMO does Avandel 100 2 1:08am
           Collapse A couple of thoughts Spriggan 83 1 1:31am
               Foot Soldiers.. Girdle of Melian 37 0 3:34am

  Collapse Food lionoferebor 510 11 Sun, 5:03pm Jump to last post in thread (by Starling)
       Collapse I imagine... BlackFox 323 3 Sun, 5:06pm
           Collapse Ahh... lionoferebor 287 2 Sun, 5:10pm
               Collapse In fact... BlackFox 290 1 Sun, 5:12pm
                   no he doesn't MouthofSauron 22 0 3:20am
       Collapse Good point! Danielos 271 1 Sun, 5:27pm
         See above response to the specific question! Glorfindela 207 0 Sun, 6:27pm
       Collapse On a slightly different food subject Elarie 163 4 Sun, 8:12pm
           Collapse Nothing is said about lettuce Milieuterrien 77 3 Sun, 11:31pm
               Collapse I was actually referring to the supplies the elves brought to the Laketowners in BOTFA Elarie 54 2 12:41am
                   For that kind of answer I somewhat miss invisible Bilbo living among the Elves Milieuterrien 47 0 1:01am
                   I made a point of looking at the veges today Starling 7 0 5:10am

  Moved: Top 20 scenes from LOTR and TH hms_ocean - - Sun, 4:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by hms_ocean)

  Collapse Box Office MedwedtoBeorn 1054 19 Sun, 3:30pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Deadline Ham_Sammy 548 0 Sun, 4:09pm
       Collapse Now in a dead heat with AUJ DwellerInDale 539 8 Sun, 4:39pm
           Collapse Which puts the worldwide total at... BlackFox 507 3 Sun, 5:01pm
               Collapse World wide total shadowdog 158 2 Sun, 10:52pm
                   BOFA wins 2nd week in a row beating Unbroken and Into the Woods Eruonen 33 0 4:37am
                   Hooray! Hooray! Hooray! *jumps up and down with joy* mae govannen 15 0 30 mins ago
           Collapse Apples and oranges Estel78 427 3 Sun, 5:54pm
               Good result Estel78 394 0 Sun, 6:14pm
               Collapse In this day and age Ham_Sammy 389 1 Sun, 6:20pm
                   DOS suffered because of the freezing weather glor 203 0 Sun, 9:21pm
       From Forbes Avandel 490 0 Sun, 5:16pm
       Collapse I guess having just good news would be too much to ask... Estel78 362 6 Sun, 7:12pm
           Collapse If i am not mistaken though, NecromancerRising 345 5 Sun, 7:15pm
               Collapse In about 3 or 4 important markets Estel78 314 4 Sun, 7:28pm
                   Collapse Japan is one market NecromancerRising 291 3 Sun, 7:37pm
                       Collapse No, not exactly apples and apples Estel78 275 1 Sun, 7:44pm
                           The only true indications so far NecromancerRising 293 0 Sun, 7:47pm
                       The appreciation of the US$... patrickk 288 0 Sun, 7:56pm
       I lost interest in tracking the box office Escapist 320 0 Sun, 7:49pm

  Collapse Your favorite moment from the score of BOTFA? erdildeniz 534 16 Sun, 2:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Saneliur)
       Dain Cari 297 0 Sun, 2:56pm
       I'm still making my way through the first CD :) Earl 262 0 Sun, 3:23pm
       I'm listening to it now! elentari3018 260 0 Sun, 3:26pm
       Collapse So many moments for me. Scorchster 276 1 Sun, 3:47pm
           That theme SafeUnderHill 106 0 Sun, 9:50pm
       Collapse I haven't bought the cd yet Elanor of Rohan 229 1 Sun, 4:19pm
           The horns SafeUnderHill 101 0 Sun, 9:51pm
       I think mine must be... Bofur01 238 0 Sun, 4:29pm
       Two Shirriff Anthony 141 0 Sun, 8:46pm
       Collapse My favourite moment SafeUnderHill 109 1 Sun, 9:53pm
           That is one of mine, as well. cats16 97 0 Sun, 9:58pm
       Collapse The choral piece during fire and water There&ThereAgain 72 1 Sun, 11:28pm
           Yay! SafeUnderHill 59 0 Sun, 11:49pm
       Collapse I agree! KingTurgon 39 1 1:26am
           Sons of Durin and Mithril Jay2001 22 0 2:54am
       Mithril scene Saneliur 1 0 2 mins ago

  Collapse Can someone please explain why Galadriel looked like she did in FOTR during her encounter with Sauron? BornOutOfTheWest 1059 34 Sun, 11:17am Jump to last post in thread (by GhostofMacbeth)
       It's up to each of of us to interpret but it struck me Spriggan 627 0 Sun, 11:27am
       hmmm hms_ocean 548 0 Sun, 11:31am
       To quote Gandalf BlackFox 523 0 Sun, 1:01pm
       Collapse It's a forced reference to LotR Merovech 492 3 Sun, 1:08pm
           Collapse it depends really what you think were seeing in FOTR moreorless 451 2 Sun, 1:33pm
               Collapse I disagree Merovech 418 1 Sun, 1:42pm
                   The rings temptation yes I agree BUT.. moreorless 406 0 Sun, 1:54pm
       Collapse Good question Riven Delve 450 14 Sun, 1:09pm
           Collapse The Ring is evil, but that is not, I don't think the key issue. Spriggan 386 10 Sun, 2:12pm
               Collapse A bit of both, perhaps? Riven Delve 218 9 Sun, 7:09pm
                   Collapse I was with you most of the way down. Spriggan 193 5 Sun, 7:49pm
                       Collapse I think perhaps it is the "excess" Riven Delve 176 4 Sun, 8:11pm
                           Collapse Well, yes and no. Spriggan 164 3 Sun, 8:25pm
                               Collapse Well, no and yes. Riven Delve 103 2 Sun, 8:51pm
                                   Collapse That's a yes and a yes, I think! Spriggan 99 1 Sun, 8:54pm
                                       *fist bump* // Riven Delve 98 0 Sun, 8:56pm
                   Collapse Wait, what? ecthelionsbeard 172 2 Sun, 8:27pm
                       Collapse The Elven rings are bound to the One Ring, yes Riven Delve 165 1 Sun, 8:44pm
                           I thought the Noldor line.. ecthelionsbeard 102 0 Sun, 9:10pm
           Collapse Agree! And it's not working for me Avandel 276 2 Sun, 5:31pm
               Collapse My take on it, Power is Scary MEIGWIT 69 1 Sun, 10:24pm
                   I do not know... ecthelionsbeard 54 0 Sun, 10:46pm
       Collapse A valid question indeed, at least in my eyes... mae govannen 447 1 Sun, 1:12pm
           Completely agree, BornOutOfTheWest 399 0 Sun, 1:42pm
       . Nerven 319 0 Sun, 4:01pm
       Collapse not very well executed Mooseboy018 267 1 Sun, 6:13pm
           It is frustrating that we can only know this from a Chronicles book Riven Delve 225 0 Sun, 7:19pm
       Collapse To determine myself I'll wait for the EE Milieuterrien 210 3 Sun, 7:54pm
           And Well Done Milieuterrien... patrickk 181 0 Sun, 8:10pm
           Collapse I'm still baffled by the idea that Galadriel loses some of her power Riven Delve 191 1 Sun, 8:14pm
               Well, not that that comes across in the film. Spriggan 115 0 Sun, 8:58pm
       Collapse None Shirriff Anthony 112 2 Sun, 8:48pm
           Collapse I just really think it is a bad interpretation and insult to Cate's acting ability... Girdle of Melian 53 1 Sun, 11:40pm
               My view GhostofMacbeth 43 0 12:32am

  Collapse Thread Locked Oh dear what a waste Axeman21 811 3 Sun, 10:47am Jump to last post in thread (by Eledhwen)
       Thread Locked what? hms_ocean 382 0 Sun, 11:44am
       Thread Locked Oh, dear I'm so sorry you didn't like it Glorfindela 325 0 Sun, 12:12pm
       Thread Locked Please repost in the user review thread above! Eledhwen 265 0 Sun, 12:26pm

  Collapse Instances of Foreshadowing patrickk 793 19 Sun, 3:35am Jump to last post in thread (by peterLF)
       Collapse There are a lot pettytyrant101 450 16 Sun, 3:44am
           Collapse Which LOTR scenes did you have in mind patrickk 388 11 Sun, 3:58am
               Collapse off the top of my head pettytyrant101 390 1 Sun, 4:27am
                   I think this comes down to sensibilties... patrickk 323 0 Sun, 6:38am
               Collapse I don't think Balin's tomb has been much affected... Salmacis81 170 8 Sun, 4:34pm
                   Collapse Absolutely... Eleniel 153 7 Sun, 5:01pm
                       Collapse Does a foreshadow... patrickk 78 6 Sun, 10:39pm
                           Collapse well... Magpie 62 4 Sun, 11:42pm
                               Collapse But patrickk 55 3 Sun, 11:50pm
                                   Collapse I never said foreshadowing isn't important Magpie 34 2 1:37am
                                       An example Ham_Sammy 27 0 2:30am
                                       I think we have to agree to disagree... patrickk 12 0 5:10am
                           Why does the use shadowdog 46 0 12:48am
           Regardless, Lindele 376 0 Sun, 4:19am
           Collapse Don't forget the worst offender of all... Eleniel 295 2 Sun, 10:17am
               There was also... Salmacis81 174 0 Sun, 4:29pm
               Elenial remind me of the forshadow... patrickk 123 0 Sun, 7:35pm
       Oddly, it's a criticism I haven't heard levelled at Tolkien Spriggan 278 0 Sun, 10:30am
       maybe just a nod? peterLF 0 0 2 mins ago

  Moved: What exactly is the power of the dwarven Rings? xxxyyy - - Sun, 1:45am Jump to last post in thread (by xxxyyy)

  Collapse So which way did Azogs army march to Erebor? boldog 505 11 Sun, 1:12am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Doesn't Bolg meet some Gundabad scouts? Spriggan 250 1 Sun, 1:20am
           Yes I believe so Ham_Sammy 219 0 Sun, 1:38am
       Collapse 6 haarp 254 3 Sun, 1:21am
           Collapse Those giant worms... DigificWriter 264 2 Sun, 1:42am
               Collapse Sort of similar Ham_Sammy 242 1 Sun, 1:45am
                   A more accurate comparison... DigificWriter 242 0 Sun, 1:49am
       Collapse steady on......................... hms_ocean 121 3 Sun, 12:00pm
           Collapse Ravenhill is to the west of the battle, not the south. Spriggan 122 2 Sun, 12:10pm
               Collapse hmmm hms_ocean 97 1 Sun, 1:00pm
                   Well, yes I think so. Spriggan 81 0 Sun, 2:05pm
       From the East. Otaku-sempai 75 0 Sun, 2:49pm

  Collapse Ny two film edit Elutherian 1410 64 Sat, 11:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by redgiraffe)
       Why... DigificWriter 811 0 Sat, 11:13pm
       I was just giving it a go... Bofur01 773 0 Sat, 11:14pm
       Project Danielos 733 0 Sat, 11:17pm
       Collapse I'm making a two film edit at the moment Beorn's Bees 770 47 Sat, 11:23pm
           Collapse Still baffled... DigificWriter 758 35 Sat, 11:28pm
               Collapse In my opinion Ham_Sammy 701 2 Sat, 11:38pm
                   Collapse Actually... DigificWriter 680 1 Sat, 11:40pm
                       That's what I meant Ham_Sammy 622 0 Sun, 12:00am
               Collapse because Me85 650 26 Sat, 11:55pm
                   Collapse Like it or not... DigificWriter 640 24 Sun, 12:00am
                       Collapse Has it ever occurred to you... Bofur01 635 22 Sun, 12:02am
                           Collapse Making changes... DigificWriter 615 18 Sun, 12:06am
                               I love the Hobbit films... Bofur01 603 0 Sun, 12:11am
                               Collapse Hmmm.... Morthoron 348 16 Sun, 3:58am
                                   Collapse People need to knock it off... DigificWriter 348 15 Sun, 4:16am
                                       Collapse I find it disrespectul to Tolkien, so I guess we're even... Morthoron 322 12 Sun, 5:41am
                                           Collapse Tauriel... DigificWriter 304 11 Sun, 6:09am
                                               Collapse I am uninterested in what you take seriously... Morthoron 295 3 Sun, 6:32am
                                                   Collapse Aragorn frenching his horse? Starling 266 2 Sun, 6:50am
                                                       Collapse It's after the Aragorn falling off a cliff and being lost for dead scene... Bladerunner 243 1 Sun, 7:23am
                                                           I was being completely sarcastic Starling 240 0 Sun, 7:29am
                                               Collapse Itaril/Tauriel... Bladerunner 252 6 Sun, 7:16am
                                                   Collapse A quick Google arithmancer 221 5 Sun, 2:52pm
                                                       The script rewrites... DigificWriter 213 0 Sun, 3:05pm
                                                       Collapse Thanks for the clarification... Bladerunner 165 3 Sun, 4:54pm
                                                           Collapse (Very Long) Thoughts On a Fan Edit brotherbeck 154 2 Sun, 6:11pm
                                                               I don't know.. glor 105 0 Sun, 9:53pm
                                                               It's not naive at all DigificWriter 98 0 Sun, 10:07pm
                                     Collapse Agree it is annoying and disrespectful, to put it mildly Glorfindela 247 1 Sun, 8:08am
                                           Perspective Michelle Johnston 187 0 Sun, 10:43am
                           Collapse trilogy Danielos 590 2 Sun, 12:11am
                               Me either Ham_Sammy 559 0 Sun, 12:24am
                             can I put, like swordwhale 298 0 Sun, 5:18am
                       well redgiraffe 37 0 3:20am
                   If it's a hobby folks enjoy then go for it. Spriggan 168 0 Sun, 10:48am
               Collapse Much more was added than the Carrock, Bree and forges AshNazg 28 4 5:12am
                   Collapse The EE Appendices... DigificWriter 22 3 5:22am
                       Collapse hmmmm redgiraffe 17 2 49 mins ago
                           Collapse Pick-up shoots... DigificWriter 12 1 36 mins ago
                               Yes redgiraffe 2 0 1 min ago
           Collapse Short version: Elutherian 706 10 Sat, 11:31pm
               Collapse If it ain't broke, why fix it? DigificWriter 649 1 Sat, 11:35pm
                   They are broke though imin 217 0 Sun, 9:00am
               Collapse The thing is, the more you cut, the more difficult it gets. Bofur01 659 6 Sat, 11:35pm
                   Collapse Give me a while...... Elutherian 652 5 Sat, 11:37pm
                       Collapse Ok here it is... Elutherian 599 4 Sun, 12:28am
                           Could you still include Legolas... Bladerunner 525 0 Sun, 1:15am
                           I can dig that Ham_Sammy 497 0 Sun, 1:33am
                           I really want to see this when you're finished Gianna 359 0 Sun, 2:23am
                           I haven't cut Tauriel like you have! sycorax82 354 0 Sun, 3:03am
               I agree with you! elentari3018 193 0 Sun, 3:29pm
       Collapse I feel sorry for you guys... xxxyyy 649 2 Sun, 12:08am
           Collapse Just so you understand me... Bofur01 600 1 Sun, 12:14am
               Ah! Good good // xxxyyy 365 0 Sun, 1:48am
       It would be interesting... DigificWriter 389 0 Sun, 1:40am
       Me too! KateTheHobbit 356 0 Sun, 2:36am
       I've done a bit of this sort of thing myself pettytyrant101 358 0 Sun, 3:01am
       Collapse 2 Films how to arrive there Michelle Johnston 290 4 Sun, 7:02am
           Collapse I'm sorry but all of that sounds awful lurtz2010 184 3 Sun, 11:21am
               Collapse Thanks Michelle Johnston 170 2 Sun, 12:00pm
                   Collapse I think a bagend start is needed for Bilbo though.. moreorless 236 1 Sun, 1:16pm
                       Bag End for us but not so much for the wider audience Michelle Johnston 169 0 Sun, 4:54pm
       I wouldnt say its totally impossible.. moreorless 185 0 Sun, 10:51am
     I bet you Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 152 0 Sun, 1:00pm

  Collapse The 2-film script Bofur01 1206 9 Sat, 8:35pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eleniel)
       Collapse Riverbank Lost Hobbit 639 1 Sat, 9:07pm
           PJ said SafeUnderHill 556 0 Sat, 10:13pm
       Collapse The 'original cut' of An Unexpected Journey... DigificWriter 603 3 Sat, 10:17pm
           Collapse Also, BornOutOfTheWest 455 2 Sat, 10:50pm
               I was counting that under the heading of "the Carrock sequence" DigificWriter 424 0 Sat, 11:06pm
               They only showed... Bofur01 405 0 Sat, 11:18pm
       Collapse Both films would have been brilliant, is what I believe sycorax82 326 1 Sun, 2:33am
           Totally! // Eleniel 184 0 Sun, 9:44am
       the Balin/Bard scene There&ThereAgain 241 0 Sun, 7:32am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 931 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.