merklynn
Lorien
May 21 2008, 6:44pm
Views: 440
|
I'd rather an experienced hand wrote the script than an inexperienced one
|
|
|
By the same token, the experience that Fran, Phillipa and Peter had in making the LOTR, working on the scripts and subsequently revising, and cutting out scenes that they later found would be inappropriate make them for me better choices than anyone else. They had the first hand experience with the fan reactions to scenes like Arwen at Helm's Deep etc, and they made the adjustments. This time around, they go into scripting the Hobbit knowing what fans are demanding of them and knowing to treat the subject with great care. Trusting some new team that GDT might assemble might be a little harder, given that we at least know that this is the Walsh/Boyens second shot at this and they are vets in the LOTR universe now. Also, as a fan of both the books and the films, I actually enjoyed the characterizations of Merry, Pippin, and Gimli in the films, and I think it was funny and enjoyable because of the quality and charms of the actors. Often I hear it stated here as if it is fact that these characters were a let down to all, but all I heard in the audience when watching these films at the theatre was laughter and applause in all the right places. I think they worked, even if they were portrayed a little dfifferently, they were still (for me) great characters.
|