The One Ring Forums: Off Topic: The Pollantir:
Is it time for a graphic novel adaptation of 'The Lord of the Rings'?

Poll: Is it time for a graphic novel adaptation of 'The Lord of the Rings'?
Yes. 11 / 58%
No. 5 / 26%
Maybe. 2 / 11%
What's a graphic novel, precious? 1 / 5%
19 total votes


Feb 19, 3:13pm

Views: 4093
Is it time for a graphic novel adaptation of 'The Lord of the Rings'?

It hit me recently that it has been over thirty years now since the now defunct Eclipse Comics released their 3-part comic-book adaptation of The Hobbit, adapted by Charles ('Chuck') Dixon with Sean Deming, and lavishly illustrated by David Wenzel. The comic book was subsequently collected into a graphic novel which was published by Ballantine and has been kept in-print ever since.

Back in the 1980s, a graphic novel adaptation of The Lord of the Rings seemed too ambitious; the book was too long, the story too complex to be easily serialized, the audience for such a project might be too small. However, there have been a few changes over the years. Eclipse is no more. The make up of the Tolkien Estate has shifted. And it can be argued that the graphic novel format has come into its own, with both original books and adaptations of major literary works having become commonplace. Should the idea of a comics adaptation of LoR be revisited?

I could certainly see it happen. Each of the six books that comprise LotR could be adapted as separate miniseries and collected into book form, probably in multiple volumes and without the appendices, though perhaps even they could be included in an abridged form. Personally, I think Dark Horse Comics (publishers of Mike Mignola's Hellboy) would be the ideal place for such a project. But what do you think?


Forum Admin / Moderator

Feb 19, 5:46pm

Views: 4046
I like the idea of a six-book graphic novel.

The graphic novel section of my little library has been growing by leaps and bounds, both fiction and non-fiction! Some of the fiction books are receiving awards (Jerry Craft's "New Kid" just won the Newbery). And they're wonderful for the kid who is turned off by "too many words".

I grew up on Classics Illustrateds, you might call them the "original graphic novels"!

A properly adapted and illustrated LotR would be great. I'd love to see a set done by, say, Ted Nasmith or Alan Lee or John Howe, or a similar artist. Or maybe have a separate artist for each book.

I wonder if the Hildebrandts are still around?



"I desired dragons with a profound desire"


Feb 19, 6:24pm

Views: 4041
Hildebrandts and Collected Volumes

Sadly, Tim Hildebrandt passed away in 2006. Greg is still around at age 81.

I imagine each 'Book' of The Lord of the Rings being adapted as separate arcs; however, the six arcs could be doubled up into just three volumes under the familiar titles: The Fellowship of the Ring; The Two Towers; and The Return of the King. Not that six volumes couldn't be done.


(This post was edited by Otaku-sempai on Feb 19, 6:25pm)


Feb 19, 6:34pm

Views: 4037
I read "Moby Dick" one afternoon as "Classics Illustrated"

and it was more satisfying than reading the Cliff's Notes. I also wasn't going to read the actual book with its many chapters devoted solely to whaling, which would bore me.

I can see that, just as the Peter Jackson movies induced some people to read Tolkien's books, so too would graphic novels be a gateway to the trilogy and the movies for some readers. Depending on the adaptation and illustrations, I might even read them myself, and I'm very much a book-first fanboy.

Grey Havens

Feb 22, 8:47am

Views: 3874
As a former reading specialist and Classics Illustrated fan

I think graphic novels, depending on vocabulary level, would be a great gateway drug for people new to the story or needing HIER (high interest, easy reading) materials. Also useful for ESL learners.

"I shall not wholly fail if anything can still grow fair in days to come."


Feb 22, 11:30am

Views: 3865
My dad, not a fan of fantasy,

was never going to read "The Hobbit" or watch three whole fantasy films, but he enjoyed the David Wenzel version I gave him so he could understand what I kept going on about. It was a nice bonding thing for us when the films came out.

Maybe, just maybe, he would have liked a LOTR graphic novel as well.Evil I would.

Grey Havens

Feb 23, 12:09am

Views: 3817
A quality version would be great.//


Fourth Age Adventures at the Inn of the Burping Troll
Home of Best FanFic stories of 2005 and 2006 "The Last Grey Ship" and "Ashes, East Wind, Hope That Rises" by Erin Rua

(Found in Mathoms, LOTR Tales Untold)


Feb 23, 2:15am

Views: 3812
Only the best!

If I have any complaint about the Hobbit graphic novel, it's that it is so text-heavy that the text crowds the art. It could have used a bit more room to allow it to breathe.



Feb 27, 4:21pm

Views: 3479
I'd love it

I have a small but select collection of graphic novels, including one of "Pride & Prejudice" and one of "Jane Eyre." All the Firefly ones. Alan Moore's stuff. Some Desden Files. I'd definitely buy a LOTR graphic novel.

I am a dreamer of words, of written words. I think I am reading; a word stops me. I leave the page. The syllables of the words begin to move around The words take on other meanings as if they had the right to be young.

-- Gaston Bachelard

* * * * * * * * * *

NARF and member of Deplorable Cultus since 1967
my blog:


Apr 2, 5:25pm

Views: 2888
i'm with you that the idea of a six-book format would be nice

it would keep the volumes from getting overwhelmingly long and separate out the various story-threads a bit