DwellerInDale
Rohan
Oct 11 2012, 12:52pm
Views: 1076
|
Here is another, very simple way to resolve many of these seeming contradictions: AUJ ends just after the spider battle in Mirkwood. In a previous thread I also mentioned the trailer scene where Radagast, clearly inside Rhosgobel, warns of a "dark power". The question was and is, who is he speaking to? Gandalf? But Gandalf doesn't come near Mirkwood/Rhosgobel until after the break that everyone is assuming (just after the eagle rescue). In that thread I theorized that he might even be speaking to Legolas and Tauriel, as messengers from Thranduil-- that would give them a reason to go patrolling Mirkwood in the first place. I wrote that those two could then go "kick some serious spider butt"; now that the Lego set ads are out, that prediction seems to be accurate. Thus emboldened, here is an updated theory: - If the first movie ends after the spider battle, wherein it is actually Legolas and Tauriel who kill most of the spiders, then we have a nice triple cliffhanger: Tauriel, Legolas, and the rest of the Elves capture the Dwarves and lead them away; Bilbo, using the ring, is left behind in agony of what to do; and Gandalf and Radagast, over at Rhosgobel, are attacked by the spider(s). - Bilbo has his climactic moment, as he kills his spider and names his sword Sting. -This assumption of AUJ ending at the Carrock has always seemed rather weak, dramatically. Plus there is now all this merchandise, from both Bridge Direct and Lego, featuring Legolas and Tauriel, and the spider battle. Are people really going to spend $30-$60 for Christmas gifts based on characters that aren't in the movie? The kids will be so confused that the parents will have to go spend another $20 on GI Joe with Kung-Fu Grip or something to make up for it. The lame explanation for all the toys has been that they were made, and marketing plans set in place, long before the decision to expand to 3 movies. But how difficult would it really have been to delay the release of those products? -This theory doesn't contradict the new official poster: Barrels Out of Bond is still cut from AUJ and will now be seen in DOS. Mirkwood never appeared in either poster. -The only thing contradicting this theory is that the names Orlando Bloom and Evangeline Lilly no longer appear on the "official" website. But that could easily be explained: the website is after all run by the financing company (Warner Bros.) overseeing the production company (New Line) supervising the film company (Wingnut) that is making the movies. When Peter Jackson pitched the 3 film idea to Warner Bros. in July, they no doubt wanted to know immediately how he would now break up the films. At that point in time he could have indicated "after the eagles' rescue", and WB's advertising department ran with it. But Jackson should have the freedom to break the films where he wishes, so the web site information should not be taken as the last word. -Thoughts?
(This post was edited by Ataahua on Oct 11 2012, 6:18pm)
|