Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 961 (345661 posts in 14405 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 961 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (activity)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 149072 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 111839 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 9445 0 Oct 12 2014, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Sticky: NEW! Official Hobbit movie reviews - post them here! entmaiden 3289 61 Dec 29 2014, 1:40am Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)

Collapse Sticky: Folks from the Uni of Waikato want to know YOUR opinion on BotFA! greendragon 1121 23 Jan 21, 4:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mr. Arkenstone (isaac))

  Collapse Sticky: DOS Chapter of the Week (CHOW) Sign-up for February 2015! DanielLB 739 15 Jan 23, 8:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by DanielLB)

Collapse Sticky: Admin announcement: a clean-up of The Hobbit discussion board Ataahua 2795 5 Jan 24, 10:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)

  Collapse I predict the future! painjoiker 743 19 Sat, 3:03am Jump to last post in thread (by Hanzkaz)
       Collapse It does seem that way... AshNazg 644 4 Sat, 3:14am
           Collapse Not much happens... Jeffrodo 625 3 Sat, 3:36am
               There could be, but would it be interesting? QuackingTroll 614 0 Sat, 3:51am
               Collapse I meant not much happens in the book... AshNazg 609 1 Sat, 3:56am
                   You could I spose argue Aragorn's character might be the main basis for the film.. moreorless 297 0 Sat, 4:15pm
       Yep!! My thoughts exactly! ecthelionsbeard 604 0 Sat, 4:04am
       What about Tauriel? Moahunter 583 0 Sat, 5:22am
       Collapse I hope not. Mooseboy018 487 1 Sat, 9:55am
           8 haarp 460 0 Sat, 11:08am
       Collapse I don't think I could stomach any more of Orlando Bloom Glorfindela 449 2 Sat, 11:42am
           Collapse They could do an animated TV show... AshNazg 419 1 Sat, 12:40pm
               Yes, that could be an idea Glorfindela 386 0 Sat, 1:51pm
       Collapse As much as I would love that... frodolives 302 3 Sat, 4:22pm
           Collapse Not by crtiics... Pandallo 265 2 Sat, 5:17pm
               Collapse My perception only frodolives 249 1 Sat, 5:39pm
                   Sounds a bit odd... Spriggan 248 0 Sat, 5:43pm
       Collapse It's possible, but... burrahobbit 187 1 Sat, 8:51pm
           I can see a few personally... moreorless 77 0 5:58am
       One of the benefits of the relative lack of source material - Hanzkaz 8 0 27 mins ago

  Collapse Fascinating quotes by Guillermo del Toro frodolives 725 21 Sat, 4:12pm Jump to last post in thread (by squiggle)
       Collapse yep balbo biggins 628 7 Sat, 4:38pm
           Collapse Or, y'know... Pandallo 568 3 Sat, 5:14pm
               Ugh! frodolives 543 0 Sat, 5:32pm
               Collapse He left because of legal issues... QuackingTroll 491 1 Sat, 6:05pm
                   GDT's enthusiasm seemed less than genuine to me glor 32 0 11:31am
           Collapse It's important to remember SafeUnderHill 418 2 Sat, 7:20pm
               Collapse yes balbo biggins 411 1 Sat, 7:27pm
                   8 haarp 382 0 Sat, 8:11pm
       Collapse Yes, they are interesting...... dormouse 618 8 Sat, 4:53pm
           Collapse Stop confusing the issue with facts Voronwë_the_Faithful 602 3 Sat, 4:57pm
               Collapse Oops, sorry! dormouse 598 2 Sat, 4:59pm
                   Collapse Seems pretty cozy in there Voronwë_the_Faithful 574 1 Sat, 5:10pm
                       Welcoming things, teapots! // dormouse 504 0 Sat, 5:51pm
           Excellent find! Kirly 591 0 Sat, 5:01pm
           Collapse Great stuff frodolives 566 2 Sat, 5:12pm
             Collapse Perhaps he should be asked to do a fan edit? Glorfindela 351 1 Sat, 8:52pm
                   LOL /// Kirly 143 0 5:20am
       For myself Glorfindela 528 0 Sat, 5:45pm
       Collapse I, too, like a certain lead singer and rhythm guitarist, believe virtually everything I read... xxxyyy 500 1 Sat, 6:01pm
           Huh? frodolives 485 0 Sat, 6:10pm
       PJ film making team of Hobbitt ees thus far couldn't be better to me squiggle 12 0 32 mins ago

  Collapse Does anyone else wish the battle looked more like this Thorins_apprentice 562 8 Sat, 2:59am Jump to last post in thread (by Eleniel)
       Collapse But it did look exactly like that! AshNazg 512 1 Sat, 3:20am
           I thought so too! CathrineB 492 0 Sat, 3:42am
       I simply would have enjoyed more dwarves! banaili 248 0 Sat, 3:49pm
       yes balbo biggins 234 0 Sat, 4:34pm
       Collapse imagine that ElendilTheShort 159 1 Sat, 8:15pm
           Yeah CathrineB 92 0 1:08am
       Collapse Who's Alan Howe? QuackingTroll 20 1 11:08am
           I really like Matt Stewart's work.. Eleniel 10 0 46 mins ago

  Collapse Will we ever see any of GDT's designs? frodolives 348 13 Sat, 3:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by glor)
       Collapse well deskp 322 1 Sat, 3:43pm
           Cool! frodolives 315 0 Sat, 3:46pm
       Collapse Yes MedwedtoBeorn 316 2 Sat, 3:51pm
           Collapse After? frodolives 299 1 Sat, 4:08pm
               well deskp 284 0 Sat, 4:38pm
       Collapse Regarding ST Kirly 281 5 Sat, 4:47pm
           Collapse Yes, they thought he was too young frodolives 273 3 Sat, 4:50pm
               Collapse That's right, I remember that detail now Kirly 267 1 Sat, 4:54pm
                   Townsend as Aragorn. Otaku-sempai 167 0 Sat, 8:38pm
               Townsend glor 13 0 52 mins ago
           Reading between the lines at the time, c. when FotR was being made Glorfindela 29 0 11:13am
       Collapse We apparently have... Pandallo 259 1 Sat, 5:12pm
           And the stone giants scene... frodolives 251 0 Sat, 5:15pm

  Collapse Use of Dwarvish/Khuzdul in the Hobbit movies Kim 118 4 7:01am Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       Dwarvish was a secret language. Elizabeth 105 0 7:42am
       More Dwarvish! Ilmatar 45 0 10:20am
       From memory Glorfindela 30 0 11:06am
       Also, the elves speak in common tongue in The Hobbit... QuackingTroll 19 0 11:32am

  Collapse JRR Tolkien's The Hobbit: On the Doorstep Goldeneye 405 13 Sat, 6:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by TheHutt)
       Collapse In the book... arithmancer 347 1 Sat, 6:21pm
           re: Goldeneye 343 0 Sat, 6:25pm
       Collapse Another poster gave you one helpful suggestion... dormouse 343 8 Sat, 6:39pm
           Collapse dormouse Goldeneye 340 7 Sat, 6:45pm
               How about "My edit of Peter Jackson's Hobbit" Voronwë_the_Faithful 286 0 Sat, 7:54pm
               It's a confusing thread name burrahobbit 271 0 Sat, 8:22pm
               Not sure why you need a title for something that's meant..... dormouse 195 0 Sat, 11:04pm
               Collapse Here's a few titles... AshNazg 187 3 Sat, 11:20pm
                   Collapse There and Back Again Goldeneye 177 2 Sat, 11:42pm
                       Just cut out the filler: 'Th Hbbt' // QuackingTroll 167 0 Sat, 11:52pm
                       Or 'The Hobbit: Legoless Edition' QuackingTroll 158 0 12:19am
       Why not just call it Bishop 153 0 12:30am
       Do consider changing the title TheHutt 57 0 8:11am

  Collapse CGI Dain: any reason why they did this? Goldeneye 721 20 Fri, 6:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse Earlier discussion Ilmatar 664 14 Fri, 6:22pm
           Collapse ah... Goldeneye 646 13 Fri, 6:39pm
               Collapse One certainly can't disagree that it was Connolly's performance... Spriggan 638 1 Fri, 6:45pm
                   I agree with this! banaili 204 0 Sat, 3:44pm
               Collapse I enjoyed Billy Connolly's performance, same as Spriggan.... dormouse 609 10 Fri, 7:16pm
                   Collapse meh Goldeneye 473 9 Fri, 10:36pm
                       Collapse Eh? CathrineB 410 1 Sat, 12:24am
                         Well, shucks, I didn't even know Dain had been CGI'd except for the obvious Avandel 103 0 Sat, 9:26pm
                       Collapse Or maybe they were just under a lot of pressure? dormouse 327 6 Sat, 8:19am
                           Collapse dormouse Goldeneye 224 5 Sat, 3:03pm
                               Collapse I'm not one for CGI interest but Spriggan 174 4 Sat, 5:38pm
                                   Collapse spriggan Goldeneye 159 3 Sat, 6:04pm
                                       I'm pretty sure it's the colour grading... Bofur01 156 0 Sat, 6:09pm
                                       Then again..... dormouse 145 0 Sat, 6:33pm
                                       I wonder if memorialise "realism" in a way. Spriggan 122 0 Sat, 7:34pm
       Reason? Avnar 552 0 Fri, 8:32pm
       I wish ... DanielLB 480 0 Fri, 10:31pm
       Collapse I think Dain looked fine Glorfindela 282 1 Sat, 11:44am
           Quite impressive, in fact /// Kirly 181 0 Sat, 5:04pm
       Sums up what is wrong with this trilogy frodolives 211 0 Sat, 3:35pm

  Collapse Glowing Tauriel Milieuterrien 910 40 Wed, 7:42pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elthir)
       Collapse She's still a Silvan elf, though. Bofur01 594 23 Wed, 7:54pm
           Collapse All elves glow around Bilbo when he wears the Ring Milieuterrien 589 21 Wed, 7:57pm
               Collapse Yeah... Bofur01 571 20 Wed, 8:01pm
                   Collapse So you are affirmative when you believe Milieuterrien 564 18 Wed, 8:04pm
                       Collapse Well, I can't remember for certain... Bofur01 552 17 Wed, 8:06pm
                           Collapse So let's call for the scholars Milieuterrien 549 16 Wed, 8:09pm
                               Collapse Or cast off the shackles Spriggan 487 1 Wed, 10:27pm
                                   I would say output AND input Milieuterrien 461 0 Wed, 10:52pm
                               Collapse One does not have to dig too deep... The Grey Wanderer 424 13 Thu, 12:23am
                                   Collapse No, not quite right.... Morthoron 383 12 Thu, 4:42am
                                       Thanks for explaining this.. Eleniel 315 0 Thu, 1:58pm
                                       Collapse Respectfully disagree in part - and admit error in others... The Grey Wanderer 188 4 Fri, 1:16am
                                           Collapse Eldar revisited Elthir 75 2 Sat, 2:44pm
                                               Collapse Interesting. I hadn't realized he had been so inconsistent on this issue. The Grey Wanderer 40 1 Sat, 4:49pm
                                                   the citations Elthir 27 0 Sat, 6:28pm
                                           a flood of words Elthir 57 0 Sat, 3:08pm
                                       Collapse I always read "on the other side" swordwhale 173 5 Fri, 6:48am
                                           Collapse Nope.... Morthoron 169 4 Fri, 7:16am
                                               Collapse Circumstances may play a role Milieuterrien 148 2 Fri, 12:42pm
                                                   Personally... arithmancer 130 0 Fri, 2:29pm
                                                   this sounds reasonable... swordwhale 101 0 Fri, 6:01pm
                                               ah, I see the light swordwhale 102 0 Fri, 6:00pm
                   Silvan but still Teleri. Otaku-sempai 510 0 Wed, 9:45pm
           And yet... BlackFox 493 0 Wed, 10:13pm
       Well Thrain II 590 0 Wed, 7:57pm
       Collapse Here's the thing.... dormouse 462 1 Wed, 11:22pm
           Enthousiasticly yours. Milieuterrien 443 0 Wed, 11:28pm
       Collapse Non-Glowing Galadriel Girdle of Melian 351 2 Thu, 9:20am
           Glowing Tinne 339 0 Thu, 10:28am
           Gandalf has a presence on the unseen plane, too. Bofur01 312 0 Thu, 1:45pm
       Collapse Ha! find any reason that pleases you to justify a terribly executed scene jtarkey 333 2 Thu, 12:43pm
           Or maybe they just don't agree with you BlackFox 326 0 Thu, 1:02pm
           "Terribly executed" ? Come on.... Milieuterrien 307 0 Thu, 2:50pm
       Collapse my headcanon explanation marary 295 5 Thu, 4:20pm
           Collapse Rather romantic, but no less cheesy Milieuterrien 281 4 Thu, 4:34pm
               Collapse It definitely did look awkward marary 254 3 Thu, 4:49pm
                   Collapse Tauriel glows gritty, that's indeed the point Milieuterrien 243 2 Thu, 5:09pm
                       Collapse *standing ovation* marary 228 1 Thu, 6:29pm
                           They did also very well with Eowyn Milieuterrien 207 0 Thu, 7:22pm
       I don't know about the literary legitimacy sauget.diblosio 116 0 Fri, 4:29pm

  DOS Chapter of the Week: Under Arrest Starglass 101 0 Sat, 4:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by Starglass)

  Collapse Survey: A study of the Hobbit Trilogy grimbeorn15 715 23 Thu, 2:35am Jump to last post in thread (by grimbeorn15)
       2 pages grimbeorn15 499 0 Thu, 2:54am
       Collapse Made it clickable for you... Queen of Erebor 521 1 Thu, 3:15am
           Awesome. Thanks so much! grimbeorn15 397 0 Thu, 1:14pm
       Collapse Done! MyWeeLadGimli 484 1 Thu, 3:30am
           I couldn't find one for DoS... Queen of Erebor 473 0 Thu, 3:50am
       Collapse Would like to explain my answers Kilidoescartwheels 482 3 Thu, 4:55am
           Collapse I agree with almost everything marary 444 2 Thu, 7:43am
               I have to go with ... swordwhale 211 0 Fri, 6:43am
               I don't think it was an either/or situation... moreorless 207 0 Fri, 7:22am
       Collapse Done - almost dormouse 442 2 Thu, 9:09am
           Collapse Good point. grimbeorn15 401 1 Thu, 1:15pm
               Fair enough... dormouse 391 0 Thu, 2:01pm
       Done! BlackFox 421 0 Thu, 10:19am
       Collapse Done... Gianna 348 5 Thu, 6:27pm
           Done, but bom objects to the Question? Bombadil 298 0 Thu, 10:09pm
           Collapse Hoping for better character resolution in the EE grimbeorn15 109 3 Fri, 10:01pm
               Collapse Me too, especially for Tauriel // Gianna 107 2 Fri, 10:06pm
                   Collapse They'll probably not have saved any Tauriel scenes... Bofur01 100 1 Fri, 10:27pm
                       You're probably right... Gianna 99 0 Fri, 10:30pm
       Done// Bladerunner 255 0 Fri, 12:00am
       Collapse Nice survey! Brethil 257 1 Fri, 12:12am
           Thank you! grimbeorn15 53 0 Sat, 1:43pm
       Thanks to all of you have responded so far! grimbeorn15 111 0 Fri, 9:59pm

  Collapse The King Under the Mountain and The Seven Houses of the Dwarves chauvelin2000 1205 42 Feb 16, 10:29am Jump to last post in thread (by chauvelin2000)
       Collapse Firstly - and someone should say it.... dormouse 642 17 Feb 16, 1:52pm
           Collapse I'm curious also BlackFox 359 16 Feb 16, 9:02pm
               Collapse That passage... Pandallo 350 11 Feb 16, 9:24pm
                   Collapse That is from Tolkien Otaku-sempai 340 2 Feb 16, 9:42pm
                       Collapse Clarification Pandallo 321 1 Feb 16, 10:06pm
                           Your welcome. Otaku-sempai 304 0 Feb 16, 10:19pm
                   Collapse The Woodland queen would yet have been alive at the time of commission ... chauvelin2000 319 7 Feb 16, 11:46pm
                       Collapse A wonderful and gracious reply. Michelle Johnston 301 3 Feb 17, 12:14am
                           Collapse Great thoughts ... and an excellent idea for the Celebrían story! chauvelin2000 287 1 Feb 17, 12:33am
                               Thank you for your endorsement Michelle Johnston 264 0 Feb 17, 3:55am
                           Agreed. Arannir 233 0 Feb 17, 9:38am
                       Collapse Thank you for this and well said... dormouse 235 1 Feb 17, 9:23am
                           Thanks for your comments and insights! chauvelin2000 177 0 Feb 18, 1:24am
                       Thank you for these wonderful ideas to think about and discuss Riven Delve 203 0 Feb 17, 4:36pm
               It may have occurred in just that way ... chauvelin2000 327 0 Feb 16, 9:32pm
               Collapse I'll hazard a guess Otaku-sempai 322 2 Feb 16, 9:34pm
                   Collapse Thranduil's wife more questions than answers Michelle Johnston 311 1 Feb 16, 10:18pm
                       And what are we to make of Legolas? Otaku-sempai 299 0 Feb 16, 10:30pm
       Grrrr 8 Konrad S 524 0 Feb 16, 2:12pm
       Collapse Bifur, Bofur, Bombur Otaku-sempai 523 3 Feb 16, 2:30pm
           Collapse I think this is the best spot entmaiden 489 2 Feb 16, 2:57pm
               Collapse Could be. Otaku-sempai 480 1 Feb 16, 3:00pm
                   Eastern cousins, ancient Gems, 'fire-drake' exceptions to solidarity . . . chauvelin2000 406 0 Feb 16, 6:21pm
       Well done! Pandallo 442 0 Feb 16, 4:31pm
       Thank you very much for your thoughtful post Glorfindela 436 0 Feb 16, 5:01pm
       Fascinating - thank you! Avandel 416 0 Feb 16, 5:40pm
       Collapse The Longbeards and Belegost Otaku-sempai 397 2 Feb 16, 6:37pm
           Collapse Tolkien and the ability of individuals — and races — to change . . . chauvelin2000 351 1 Feb 16, 8:59pm
               The Belegost Connection Otaku-sempai 326 0 Feb 16, 9:30pm
       Collapse Just posting to say that I am reading Voronwë_the_Faithful 391 11 Feb 16, 7:40pm
           Nothing about History but Bombadil 355 0 Feb 16, 8:36pm
           Collapse You are not alone! Kirly 148 9 Feb 19, 2:39am
               Collapse Ancient wanderings of Durin 'the Deathless' and his 'Longbeard' folk from Gundabad . . . chauvelin2000 106 8 Feb 22, 7:31pm
                   Collapse Disposition of the Dwarven Houses Otaku-sempai 90 4 Feb 22, 9:25pm
                       Collapse The Dwarves' western and eastern Houses . . . chauvelin2000 80 3 Feb 22, 11:30pm
                           Collapse Bifur, Bofur and Bombur Otaku-sempai 68 2 Feb 23, 12:28am
                               Collapse Momentary (off-topic) digression . . . chauvelin2000 62 1 Feb 23, 1:03am
                                   Thanks. Otaku-sempai 58 0 Feb 23, 1:28am
                   Collapse Gunderbad maybe the oldest Dwarven City of ME Michelle Johnston 53 2 Feb 23, 6:54am
                       Collapse Natal-shrines, Wraithworlds, Palantírs ... Oh, my!! chauvelin2000 52 1 Feb 23, 9:35am
                           Gundabad and the Rings of Power . . . chauvelin2000 21 0 Sat, 1:23pm
       What a wonderful scholastic achievement Michelle Johnston 318 0 Feb 16, 10:12pm

  Collapse Galadriel's Orc Blasting.... Girdle of Melian 845 13 Thu, 9:25am Jump to last post in thread (by elvish.mafia)
       Collapse the more Dol Guldur in the EE NoelGallagher 668 2 Thu, 11:55am
         Collapse Bom viewed THAT?..this way... Bombadil 653 1 Thu, 12:16pm
               Bolg's blog DeadRabbits 613 0 Thu, 1:39pm
       Collapse Orc blasting Kilidoescartwheels 609 3 Thu, 2:32pm
         Collapse KDCW..WoW sounds like a T-Shirt IDEA? // Bombadil 587 2 Thu, 2:51pm
               Collapse Glorious G-Girl CAME prepared... Bombadil 511 1 Thu, 6:02pm
                   Or more simply "G-Girl has Game"// The Grey Wanderer 304 0 Fri, 1:23am
       Collapse The blast was very cool... Nolane 504 2 Thu, 6:21pm
           Collapse Minimal involvement, maximal impact Milieuterrien 453 1 Thu, 7:33pm
               Waste of Energy... Girdle of Melian 375 0 Thu, 10:41pm
       she is fantastic mirkwoodwanderer 459 0 Thu, 7:27pm
       Galadriel is demonstrating to the nine & Necromancer her power squiggle 346 0 Thu, 11:44pm
       Should've given Frodo a lesson in phialling... elvish.mafia 93 0 Sat, 8:47am

Collapse The USE of Orcrist, Glamdring & Sting? Bombadil 788 30 Feb 24, 12:22pm Jump to last post in thread (by tunagirll)
       Collapse Am I the only fan of Rankin/Bass' Sting? QuackingTroll 484 2 Feb 24, 12:28pm
           actually not radically different... swordwhale 382 0 Tue, 4:33pm
           I like it too. Mooseboy018 347 0 Tue, 6:23pm
       Collapse I'll add my voice to yours BlackFox 457 12 Tue, 1:16pm
           Collapse Why would only STING Glow Blue..? Bombadil 410 11 Tue, 3:39pm
               Collapse All should have glowed Otaku-sempai 401 9 Tue, 4:06pm
                   Collapse Well? PJ did give a good Answer Bombadil 412 1 Tue, 4:16pm
                     heee heeee heeeeeeeeee swordwhale 388 0 Tue, 4:37pm
                   Collapse No mystery over Glamdring... Eleniel 303 6 Tue, 8:58pm
                       Collapse Indeed. Otaku-sempai 288 2 Tue, 9:09pm
                           What for? Bracegirdle 257 0 Tue, 11:23pm
                           Bom does remember Elrond's Spech in TH, but Bombadil 256 0 Tue, 11:34pm
                       Collapse a well done article... in a sense... Elthir 191 2 Wed, 1:42pm
                           Collapse Yes. DanielLB 179 1 Wed, 1:56pm
                               No problem... Elthir 159 0 Wed, 2:40pm
             A little bit of fun BlackFox 331 0 Tue, 7:13pm
       Collapse Beautiful swords! Starglass 416 3 Tue, 3:57pm
           Collapse There is a particular moment in Bombadil 413 2 Tue, 4:07pm
               Collapse Yes! Starglass 251 1 Tue, 11:49pm
                 SPARKS Flew ONCE fighting AZOG..TOO!../// Bombadil 244 0 Wed, 1:44am
       Collapse Orchrist!!! Kilidoescartwheels 367 9 Tue, 6:43pm
           Collapse What a great screencap of Fili there. Brethil 326 8 Tue, 7:56pm
               Bom thinks John Howe was the Sneeky littl' Guy Bombadil 320 0 Tue, 8:02pm
               Collapse It's extremely heavy tunagirll 233 6 Wed, 7:46am
                 Collapse Welcome to TORn , Tunagirll! Brethil 127 4 Wed, 8:09pm
                       Collapse In the Book & the Movie Bombadil 94 2 Thu, 2:48pm
                           Anor is the Sindarin name for the Sun BlackFox 91 0 Thu, 3:15pm
                           Yes, I agree with our BF about the Flame. Brethil 85 0 Thu, 4:17pm
                       Thank you! tunagirll 28 0 Sat, 12:23am
                   even less than that ElendilTheShort 42 0 Fri, 6:44pm

  Collapse Creative work and editing/adaptations GoBlue 1075 85 Thu, 4:13am Jump to last post in thread (by Bladerunner)
       Collapse PJ has not cut pages out of Tolkien's actual book and paraded it around as a better version of the novel. Aragorn the Elfstone 722 42 Thu, 4:36am
           Collapse Not following your logic GoBlue 715 41 Thu, 4:51am
               Collapse That would be fine. Aragorn the Elfstone 719 15 Thu, 4:54am
                   Collapse But why is it WRONG? AshNazg 681 14 Thu, 5:50am
                       It's not wrong Bishop 677 0 Thu, 5:57am
                       Collapse I don't care what anybody does in their own privacy... Aragorn the Elfstone 677 1 Thu, 5:58am
                           I agree with this a bit! banaili 206 0 Thu, 3:43pm
                       Like I said in the other thread... BlackFox 602 0 Thu, 10:25am
                       Collapse Simple. Darkstone 323 9 Thu, 5:29pm
                           Collapse But that doesn't make the fanedit itself wrong. Gianna 298 7 Thu, 6:09pm
                               Collapse Well Darkstone 291 6 Thu, 7:02pm
                                   Collapse ... Gianna 180 4 Thu, 11:00pm
                                       Collapse So it's wrong... Darkstone 136 3 Fri, 2:23pm
                                           Fan edits may be sauget.diblosio 111 0 Fri, 4:23pm
                                           No, that's not what I was saying at all. Gianna 91 0 Fri, 5:53pm
                                           Would you consider it not OK to.... Bladerunner 58 0 Fri, 11:21pm
                                   It is not wrong as you've described. Otaku-sempai 116 0 Fri, 4:01pm
                           Be careful waving that common sense around. It might go off by accident. // Brethil 207 0 Thu, 9:35pm
               Collapse Spot on - that is the difference. Spriggan 582 21 Thu, 1:24pm
                   Collapse Editing is one step in a process Bishop 528 20 Thu, 2:55pm
                       Collapse But surely the editor who works on the film itself ..... dormouse 535 19 Thu, 3:03pm
                           Collapse I was just making a point Bishop 521 18 Thu, 3:16pm
                               Collapse I'm not denying the skill involved.... dormouse 509 14 Thu, 3:26pm
                                   Collapse We're not really disagreeing here Bishop 213 13 Thu, 3:37pm
                                       Collapse The view is that the director is the only "artrist" involved AshNazg 200 12 Thu, 4:02pm
                                           Collapse I beg to differ Bishop 192 8 Thu, 4:08pm
                                               Collapse Agreed, but editors are artists too! :) banaili 175 4 Thu, 4:34pm
                                                   Collapse i think it is absurd Lindele 156 3 Thu, 4:58pm
                                                       Collapse Sorry... >_< banaili 131 2 Thu, 5:13pm
                                                           Collapse I know Lindele 126 1 Thu, 5:17pm
                                                               Gotcha! banaili 122 0 Thu, 5:19pm
                                               Collapse hahaha Lindele 160 2 Thu, 4:53pm
                                                   Collapse I was kidding Bishop 146 1 Thu, 5:00pm
                                                       good Lindele 135 0 Thu, 5:01pm
                                           Collapse Ah, but.... dormouse 169 1 Thu, 4:49pm
                                               But the editor also creatively constructs the final product... AshNazg 123 0 Thu, 5:22pm
                                           this is highly incorrect Lindele 155 0 Thu, 4:56pm
                               Cuts and editing burrahobbit 512 0 Thu, 3:30pm
                               Collapse I agree with all that! Spriggan 307 1 Thu, 5:29pm
                                   It can be an annual event Bishop 295 0 Thu, 5:43pm
               Collapse you can do adaptations swordwhale 188 2 Fri, 5:53am
                   Collapse You can do those activities entmaiden 93 1 Fri, 6:11pm
                       indeed, with permission of course swordwhale 87 0 Fri, 6:16pm
       Collapse I've got no interest in fan edits Kilidoescartwheels 696 1 Thu, 5:08am
           They're anti-fan hack attacks. /// Kirly 194 0 Fri, 3:07am
       Some thoughts Bishop 682 0 Thu, 5:24am
       I don't see the big deal seelbach 637 0 Thu, 7:53am
       Easy.... dormouse 618 0 Thu, 8:50am
       Quoting from my posts on the subject from the other thread Glorfindela 578 0 Thu, 11:34am
       i think the debate here is of the notion of a fan edit, it is clear its no legal without his permission Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 564 0 Thu, 1:22pm
       Collapse OK - here's another question - for you, for anyone here.... dormouse 558 7 Thu, 2:21pm
           Collapse Hmmm - is personal censorship what we mean by censorship, though? Spriggan 541 5 Thu, 2:33pm
               Collapse OK, I take your point.... dormouse 532 4 Thu, 2:40pm
                   Collapse They might come from the same place, but... I'm not sure that that actually means anything. Macfeast 499 3 Thu, 3:29pm
                       Collapse Fair enough.... dormouse 215 2 Thu, 3:31pm
                           Collapse I like bouncing, bouncing is fun. // Macfeast 198 1 Thu, 3:39pm
                               Me too :-) // dormouse 156 0 Thu, 4:50pm
           Abridgement Darkstone 235 0 Thu, 9:09pm
       In terms of artistic expression there are precedents Elarie 527 0 Thu, 3:05pm
       Collapse IMO, fan edits are created by a destructive process rather than a creative one. Noria 230 8 Thu, 3:37pm
           How would you feel Bishop 208 0 Thu, 3:47pm
           George Lucas case is a bit unusual burrahobbit 215 0 Thu, 3:52pm
           Yes to this dormouse 178 0 Thu, 4:35pm
           Collapse Peter Jackson didn't edit the films! AshNazg 138 1 Thu, 5:10pm
               well Lindele 123 0 Thu, 5:22pm
           2200 hours versus 9 hours Darkstone 297 0 Thu, 6:15pm
           noria: Goldeneye 254 0 Thu, 7:50pm
           What is your opinion on fan edits of movie trailers?// Bladerunner 118 0 Fri, 1:59am
       There is a major difference Lindele 179 0 Thu, 4:52pm
       Collapse Fan edits are waste of time... Nolane 300 2 Thu, 6:37pm
           Collapse Well said Glorfindela 278 1 Thu, 6:48pm
               the word you may be looking for is... swordwhale 183 0 Fri, 6:07am
       goblue: Goldeneye 264 0 Thu, 7:22pm
       Creative alterations Elarie 258 0 Thu, 7:56pm
       Collapse In my opinion, there is no difference. RosieLass 233 9 Thu, 9:33pm
           Collapse The FILMS are Peter Jackson's. Aragorn the Elfstone 214 8 Thu, 9:47pm
               Collapse To be clear Goldeneye 204 7 Thu, 10:09pm
                   I'm not speaking of legality... Aragorn the Elfstone 200 0 Thu, 10:19pm
                   Collapse To be clear (again) Voronwë_the_Faithful 198 4 Thu, 10:24pm
                       Collapse I think what fanedit.org was trying to get across... Bofur01 193 3 Thu, 10:29pm
                           Collapse I edited my post at the same time that you were replying to it Voronwë_the_Faithful 193 2 Thu, 10:31pm
                               Obviously you are more expert than I... Spriggan 186 0 Thu, 10:53pm
                               re voronwe: Goldeneye 151 0 Fri, 12:57am
                   Dunno Darkstone 192 0 Thu, 10:46pm
       D.I.Y. aftermarket customization... Bladerunner 218 0 Fri, 2:24am

  Collapse Thread Locked Did anyone else get the feeling in PJ's video message that maybe...just maybe...more movies?? Jeffrodo 583 12 Fri, 8:22pm Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)
       Collapse Thread Locked Hope not... Avnar 521 7 Fri, 8:35pm
           Collapse Thread Locked So true! BlackFox 506 4 Fri, 8:44pm
               Thread Locked Oh! Lindele 483 0 Fri, 8:55pm
               Thread Locked Gonna be tough days ahead in the Reading Room. // Brethil 473 0 Fri, 8:57pm
               Collapse Thread Locked A Morgul-book! How scary! // cats16 466 1 Fri, 9:00pm
                 Thread Locked *mods up* // BlackFox 459 0 Fri, 9:02pm
           Thread Locked DESTROYED?!??! Mooseboy018 503 0 Fri, 8:50pm
           Thread Locked well, you have to admit Magpie 496 0 Fri, 8:54pm
       Collapse Thread Locked I absolutely think that Magpie 500 1 Fri, 8:51pm
           Thread Locked I think there's probably studio interest... AshNazg 464 0 Fri, 9:07pm
       Thread Locked I just said something similar on Main, but... cats16 466 0 Fri, 9:02pm
     Thread Locked ---> Please post in the existing thread on Main. Thanks! // Altaira 442 0 Fri, 9:12pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 961 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.