Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 952 (342411 posts in 14266 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 952 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (activity)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 147952 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 110874 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 6024 0 Oct 12 2014, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Sticky: Help us Thank the entire cast & crew of 'All Six Middle-earth Films' News from Bree 811 6 Dec 23 2014, 4:27am Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)

  Collapse Sticky: NEW! Official Hobbit movie reviews - post them here! entmaiden 2587 49 Dec 29 2014, 1:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Spriggan)

Collapse Sticky: Folks from the Uni of Waikato want to know YOUR opinion on BotFA! greendragon 544 21 Jan 21, 4:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by CaroMichelle)

  Collapse Sticky: DOS Chapter of the Week (CHOW) Sign-up for February 2015! DanielLB 295 7 Jan 23, 8:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)

Collapse Sticky: Admin announcement: a clean-up of The Hobbit discussion board Ataahua 765 5 Jan 24, 10:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)

  Collapse Do you think The Hobbit will gain more recognization as it grows older? Hobbity Hobbit 1321 61 Wed, 12:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by redgiraffe)
       Collapse No. NottaSackville 706 1 Wed, 1:15pm
           Hmm. arithmancer 644 0 Wed, 1:45pm
       Collapse Yes, I do dormouse 632 31 Wed, 1:57pm
           Collapse I doubt it, unfortunately Voronwë_the_Faithful 613 29 Wed, 2:18pm
               Collapse Ah, Voronwe..... dormouse 523 20 Wed, 4:22pm
                   ah, dormouse Voronwë_the_Faithful 444 0 Wed, 5:24pm
                   Collapse I agree with your thoughts, Dormouse Brethil 426 17 Wed, 6:06pm
                       Collapse So right, Brethil Glorfindela 375 3 Wed, 6:37pm
                           Collapse Yes, the defending gets exhausting! Brethil 326 1 Wed, 7:43pm
                               That Oscar night was really something, wasn't it..... dormouse 249 0 Thu, 12:05am
                           So do I shadowdog 222 0 Thu, 1:01am
                       Collapse Spot on Elessar 324 4 Wed, 7:30pm
                         Collapse *Hullo, Elessar!* // Brethil 299 3 Wed, 7:41pm
                               Collapse Hey!! :-D Elessar 290 2 Wed, 8:10pm
                                 Collapse Good! Just COLD right now! Brrrrr! Brethil 244 1 Wed, 11:08pm
                                       That's great! Elessar 202 0 Thu, 1:56am
                       Collapse I was around, too Estel78 335 6 Wed, 7:32pm
                           Collapse Well then maybe our memories are different Brethil 315 4 Wed, 7:40pm
                               Collapse Maybe in book enthusiasts forums... Estel78 312 1 Wed, 8:00pm
                                   At least on this forum... RosieLass 259 0 Thu, 12:00am
                               Absolutely – that's how I remember it, too, Brethil Glorfindela 234 0 Thu, 12:37am
                               you are not mistaken shadowdog 226 0 Thu, 1:10am
                           You are speaking of the critics and their reviews, mae govannen 163 0 Thu, 7:45am
                       Analysis of the LOTR past that is quite true, mae govannen 166 0 Thu, 7:36am
                   LOL.. I absolutely share your optimism, dormouse! // mae govannen 160 0 Thu, 7:27am
               Collapse Perhaps but to some degree there was a need for a "new prequals"... moreorless 138 7 Thu, 11:32am
                   Collapse But that culture is based on a falsehood glor 95 5 Thu, 8:47pm
                       Collapse The funny thing is..... dormouse 59 3 Thu, 11:31pm
                           Agreed, Dormouse Glorfindela 41 0 12:14am
                           Collapse It is why they work for me too glor 47 1 12:15am
                               subject redgiraffe 10 0 35 mins ago
                       SW prequels redgiraffe 4 0 16 mins ago
                   Hmm redgiraffe 1 0 7 mins ago
           Agree totally with you on this. // mae govannen 169 0 Thu, 6:47am
       Yes, I think it's a set of films that certainly will Glorfindela 567 0 Wed, 2:11pm
       Not sure. Arannir 515 0 Wed, 3:11pm
       Gain popularity? Lindele 526 0 Wed, 3:22pm
       I do. Elessar 497 0 Wed, 3:28pm
       maybe not balbo biggins 452 0 Wed, 4:34pm
       I think they'll still be appreciated iduna 439 0 Wed, 4:53pm
       ... nymmerod 420 0 Wed, 5:15pm
       of course not stoutfiles 434 0 Wed, 5:30pm
       Collapse Hard to say JTurner82 388 3 Wed, 6:29pm
           Collapse That is also true Glorfindela 367 2 Wed, 6:37pm
               Collapse Thanks. JTurner82 341 1 Wed, 6:56pm
                 Welcome, JTurner! // Brethil 288 0 Wed, 7:36pm
       Hmm - what kind of recognition are you referring to? elostirion74 319 0 Wed, 7:28pm
       Collapse No they don't have the quality of timeless movies burrahobbit 277 3 Wed, 11:06pm
           Collapse same here redgiraffe 209 2 Thu, 4:27am
               Signed Arannir 151 0 Thu, 3:01pm
               Nice post! // burrahobbit 75 0 Thu, 9:32pm
       It's hard for any of us to say *now*, but it's not impossible MechaGodzilla 206 0 Thu, 2:12am
       Collapse No. jtarkey 178 7 Thu, 9:31am
           Collapse This statement (quoted below) actually boggles MY mind Glorfindela 172 4 Thu, 11:48am
               Collapse yep jtarkey 154 3 Thu, 1:21pm
                   I think it should've been pretty obvious Skaan 131 0 Thu, 1:28pm
                   As you well know Glorfindela 120 0 Thu, 2:04pm
                   And yet "Dawn" almost put me to sleep with boredom Elarie 153 0 Thu, 2:49pm
           Collapse Really? Ilmatar 138 1 Thu, 1:55pm
             Thank you, Ilmatar Glorfindela 164 0 Thu, 2:11pm
       No. sauget.diblosio 110 0 Thu, 8:09pm

  Collapse Alternative Structure / Scenes / Events for TH movies (Long Post) Arannir 576 12 Thu, 9:41am Jump to last post in thread (by Michelle Johnston)
       An interesting read. Macfeast 282 0 Thu, 10:39am
       Very interesting read... Eleniel 268 0 Thu, 10:48am
       "There and Back Again" Arannir 245 0 Thu, 2:26pm
       A good idea! KingTurgon 198 0 Thu, 2:59pm
       Collapse It's a very interesting read.... dormouse 177 1 Thu, 4:23pm
           Thanks to all tjlhe feedback by several people. Arannir 96 0 Thu, 8:19pm
       Collapse Thanks for a very interesting read Bishop 139 1 Thu, 6:17pm
           Absolutely. Arannir 91 0 Thu, 8:27pm
       Collapse Thanks for all your hard work. Michelle Johnston 138 2 Thu, 6:27pm
           Collapse Thanks and agreed on your general points. Arannir 96 1 Thu, 8:22pm
               It has to pass the test of a one stop experience Michelle Johnston 7 0 56 mins ago
       It was well done... MyWeeLadGimli 26 0 5:46am

  Collapse Would have repented Thorin liked to be buried with the arkenstone? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 247 2 Thu, 9:11am Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       It was the highest honor that any King Under the Mountain could have Elarie 122 0 Thu, 1:47pm
       If we see it I wouldnt be supprized if thats part of the reason why... moreorless 6 0 56 mins ago

  Collapse Here's an excellent video essay sauget.diblosio 389 5 Thu, 8:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Legolas_Shoehorn)
       Collapse Yet this video Lindele 242 3 Thu, 8:22pm
           Collapse I'd say that LotR had it's fair share of expectations going in, sauget.diblosio 209 1 Thu, 8:29pm
               Whether or not Lindele 182 0 Thu, 9:02pm
         Expectations is the wrong word ... Legolas_Shoehorn 25 0 6:54am
       Interesting polemic burrahobbit 169 0 Thu, 9:30pm

  Collapse What happens to the Goblins anyways? Bishop 518 18 Thu, 3:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bishop)
       Collapse Sunlight Merovech 301 11 Thu, 4:04pm
           Collapse I guess that's why I asked Bishop 260 10 Thu, 4:47pm
               Collapse I believe Elessar 251 4 Thu, 4:50pm
                   Collapse Yes, that could be the intention Bishop 234 3 Thu, 4:53pm
                       Collapse I guess Elessar 222 2 Thu, 4:55pm
                           Collapse I think if Jackson had gone for a more stormy look Bishop 226 1 Thu, 5:05pm
                               Of course Elessar 189 0 Thu, 5:30pm
               Collapse Perhaps... BlackFox 227 4 Thu, 5:04pm
                   Collapse I don't think that's as plausible.. Bishop 212 3 Thu, 5:08pm
                       Collapse Sure, but... BlackFox 197 2 Thu, 5:16pm
                           Collapse "I know your king was just killed and all, but I got this" Bishop 196 1 Thu, 5:30pm
                             Exactly! BlackFox 145 0 Thu, 6:37pm
       Collapse Coffee Break. n/m Brandybuckled 220 1 Thu, 5:03pm
           heh! Bishop 199 0 Thu, 5:06pm
       Collapse Problems organizing. Darkstone 92 3 Thu, 10:17pm
         Collapse When the Goblin-King Crashed Bombadil 51 2 2:30am
               Collapse People just have different tastes. / Darkstone 33 1 4:17am
                   To each their own... Bishop 27 0 5:03am

  Collapse the two Fili! Andreorn89 450 4 Thu, 9:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by lionoferebor)
       Collapse Looks a little too old, I think. Pandallo 230 1 Thu, 10:26pm
           O'Gorman's Fili lionoferebor 103 0 3:07am
       Collapse Cosplay CathrineB 195 1 Thu, 11:15pm
           I think... ecthelionsbeard 126 0 1:26am

Collapse The River of Denial discussions part deux - UUTs, alternative endings, and speculating on those LOGIC GAPS Avandel 1340 47 Mon, 11:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by Riven Delve)
       Collapse *Breaking news* Kim 601 4 Mon, 11:44pm
           Collapse Can we get some barrels? Avandel 458 3 Tue, 2:08am
               Collapse Well, would you look at that?! Kim 443 1 Tue, 2:19am
                   Laketown being the multi-cultural center that it was, Lissuin 431 0 Tue, 3:22am
               Barrels come with their own sushi Dame Ioreth 307 0 Tue, 2:10pm
       Collapse Can you hear the sniggering from inside the teapot? dormouse 545 4 Mon, 11:49pm
           Collapse Some can wear a SKIRT Avandel 451 3 Tue, 2:15am
               Collapse ah yaaaaaaasssssssss swordwhale 389 2 Tue, 6:37am
                   Collapse Bomby is Freezing in this Frozen River of Denial Bombadil 392 1 Tue, 7:06am
                       Let it gooooooooooooooooooooooooooo swordwhale 250 0 Tue, 7:15pm
       Collapse But wait, there's more! Riven Delve 521 1 Tue, 12:39am
           Are his uncle and brother and Mr. Dwalin coming? Avandel 459 0 Tue, 2:12am
       I always tell people there's no denying that Lissuin 482 0 Tue, 1:40am
     Now THIS was well worth driving home for! Brethil 426 0 Tue, 4:20am
       Collapse The truth is out there ... somewhere Kilidoescartwheels 445 3 Tue, 5:28am
           priceless.... swordwhale 400 0 Tue, 6:33am
           Laughing so hard now the teapot's rolling over.... dormouse 377 0 Tue, 8:24am
         And if you can't get enough - epilogue Avandel 210 0 Wed, 5:42am
       ahhhhhhhhhh............ swordwhale 412 0 Tue, 5:38am
       It all makes sense.... Miss-Merriweather 346 0 Tue, 12:55pm
       Collapse This is a wonderful thread! Starglass 319 7 Tue, 3:28pm
           Collapse found him... swordwhale 261 3 Tue, 7:38pm
             Oh, this is so cool SW! // Brethil 211 0 Wed, 3:36am
               ROFLOL Avandel 208 0 Wed, 5:43am
               Yes! I knew he would be there! Starglass 77 0 Thu, 3:11pm
           Collapse Floating on the tender tides Ilmatar 215 2 Tue, 11:52pm
               niiiiiiiiiiice swordwhale 207 0 Wed, 5:13am
               Perfect! Starglass 78 0 Thu, 3:12pm
       must once more swordwhale 263 0 Tue, 7:41pm
       Bwahaha! Roheryn 195 0 Wed, 1:36am
       Collapse but wait, there's more swordwhale 226 11 Wed, 5:11am
         Collapse *yowza* ROFLOL Avandel 158 1 Wed, 8:31pm
               I'll take two........... swordwhale 56 0 Thu, 6:15pm
           Collapse Er, I do believe Glorfindela 127 8 Thu, 12:50am
             Collapse Not sure these days.... Avandel 118 4 Thu, 1:28am
                   Collapse oh, dratties swordwhale 59 3 Thu, 6:17pm
                       Collapse BOMBy is Leaving..No ROOM for a MAN..HERE? // Bombadil 44 2 Thu, 7:11pm
                           Well, not too many Men Riven Delve 43 0 Thu, 7:42pm
                         What? Avandel 23 0 12:46am
             Collapse aaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh swordwhale 61 2 Thu, 6:13pm
                 Collapse it's ALWAYS the elves Avandel 28 1 12:39am
                       Elves nothing! Riven Delve 17 0 2:05am
       Collapse With too many threads focussing on the deaths... Queen of Erebor 122 3 Thu, 2:33am
         all are welcome in the River - grab a floaty chair! Avandel 101 0 Thu, 5:42am
           pull up a boat.... swordwhale 46 0 Thu, 7:10pm
           PS, deviantart swordwhale 44 0 Thu, 7:14pm
       Yet more proof they survived! Kilidoescartwheels 70 0 Thu, 5:17pm

  Collapse My Love Letter to The Hobbit (long) SheHathaldir 936 25 Tue, 10:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by SheHathaldir)
       Thank you! iduna 373 0 Tue, 11:07pm
       Wonderful post Kim 370 0 Tue, 11:07pm
       Collapse Thank you so much for this.... dormouse 390 1 Tue, 11:27pm
           I echo dormouse's post The Grey Wanderer 308 0 Wed, 1:05am
       This is a gift Voronwë_the_Faithful 351 0 Tue, 11:39pm
       Collapse Thank you for sharing your thoughts Glorfindela 342 1 Tue, 11:46pm
           Beautiful Jeffrodo 318 0 Wed, 12:20am
       Thank you! Riven Delve 310 0 Wed, 1:07am
       Thank you for sharing, I hope PJ and crew read this. Eruonen 302 0 Wed, 3:20am
       Bravo! Pandallo 282 0 Wed, 4:15am
       I urge anyone Starling 279 0 Wed, 6:22am
       Collapse Thank you. I really enjoyed this Brethil 257 1 Wed, 6:36am
           Very nice comment too here...// mae govannen 179 0 Wed, 2:24pm
       Beautiful! Especially your extended version. GloryBox 255 0 Wed, 6:52am
       Collapse Thank you for this – your eloquence is lovely, Noria 206 1 Wed, 1:26pm
           Ditto... Thank you Noria! // mae govannen 177 0 Wed, 2:27pm
       That's fantastic! Elessar 170 0 Wed, 3:31pm
       I wish Christopher Tolkien would read this love-letter mae govannen 186 0 Wed, 3:47pm
       What a beautiful letter Theodora 133 0 Wed, 7:53pm
       Wonderful! Domien 114 0 Wed, 10:01pm
       I could have Lindele 114 0 Wed, 10:56pm
       Beautifully Said ! spurg63 82 0 Thu, 5:58am
       Lovely! elf-lady 45 0 Thu, 5:18pm
       This is absolutely beautiful and I wish it could remain on this front page forever Loresilme 45 0 Thu, 5:49pm
     To all who have responded, thank you! SheHathaldir 29 0 1:05am

  Collapse When will someone put an honest version of "The Hobbit" on film? Kangi Ska 760 15 Thu, 1:26am Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Collapse I predict the next major attempt at Hobbit/LotR adaptations... MechaGodzilla 470 1 Thu, 2:28am
           I wouldnt underestimate hollywoods desperation... moreorless 332 0 Thu, 6:56am
       Well Bishop 363 0 Thu, 4:25am
       Collapse An honest version of "The Hobbit" exists already, Kangi - two versions.... dormouse 317 9 Thu, 9:03am
           Collapse I would not question Peter Jackson's sincerity (honesty) Kangi Ska 224 7 Thu, 3:07pm
               Collapse I would say Glorfindela 192 5 Thu, 3:28pm
                   Collapse Technically/literally speaking... Brandybuckled 157 1 Thu, 5:12pm
                     One Orc is the same as any other to me Glorfindela 130 0 Thu, 6:14pm
                   Collapse But Azog was only important to Pete's version of the Hobbit. Kangi Ska 130 2 Thu, 6:15pm
                       Well yes and no. Spriggan 82 0 Thu, 9:35pm
                       Not in PJ's adaptation Glorfindela 58 0 12:05am
               Well, taking your second point first... dormouse 194 0 Thu, 3:31pm
           Indeed Elessar 187 0 Thu, 3:29pm
       We already have an 'honest' adaptation Glorfindela 272 0 Thu, 11:54am
       Those interested in a different take... BlackFox 201 0 Thu, 3:40pm

  Collapse Durin's Day - An Astronomical Error? Otaku-sempai 767 54 Jan 18, 2:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Where does it say in that quote SafeUnderHill 419 39 Jan 18, 2:54pm
           Collapse That is why the question requires some expertise. Otaku-sempai 395 38 Jan 18, 2:56pm
               Collapse I know little about Tolkien's mythology SafeUnderHill 385 37 Jan 18, 3:09pm
                   Collapse It might have been a new moon (according to Tolkien) Otaku-sempai 382 35 Jan 18, 3:22pm
                       Collapse Where it says thin new moon SafeUnderHill 358 4 Jan 18, 3:42pm
                           Collapse Or... Otaku-sempai 349 3 Jan 18, 3:48pm
                               Collapse Yes SafeUnderHill 333 1 Jan 18, 4:04pm
                                   For it to be A, A a, FULL Moon...? Bombadil 296 0 Jan 18, 6:42pm
                               Not that far off? DanielLB 253 0 Jan 18, 7:54pm
                       Collapse Yes, I think a new moon is implied. Silverlode 198 29 Jan 18, 11:28pm
                           Collapse "the first day of the last moon of Autumn" Otaku-sempai 190 28 Jan 18, 11:58pm
                               Collapse What's your definition of Autumn? Elizabeth 169 3 Jan 19, 1:04am
                                   Collapse Autumn as per Shire Reckoning Otaku-sempai 159 2 Jan 19, 2:43am
                                       Collapse Funny, I just noticed this for the first time Gwytha 220 1 Jan 19, 3:09am
                                           Great observation! Otaku-sempai 213 0 Jan 19, 3:20am
                               Collapse In my opinion*, DanielLB 202 23 Jan 19, 7:04am
                                   Collapse If my understanding is now correct... Otaku-sempai 183 12 Jan 19, 1:46pm
                                       Collapse I am now very confused. Bumblingidiot 162 11 Jan 20, 2:00am
                                           Collapse The two events are not mutually exclusive. DanielLB 153 2 Jan 20, 7:35am
                                               Collapse What I meant was Bumblingidiot 122 1 Jan 20, 3:35pm
                                                   It's a question of alignment. Elizabeth 72 0 Jan 21, 7:53am
                                           Fulll Moons Otaku-sempai 127 0 Jan 20, 2:28pm
                                           Collapse Our calendar is different from Middle-earth iduna 42 6 Jan 21, 7:34pm
                                               Collapse I read that. Otaku-sempai 38 5 Jan 21, 8:06pm
                                                   Collapse Ack! Otaku-sempai 14 4 Jan 23, 12:02am
                                                       Collapse Second (Third?) Thoughts Otaku-sempai 18 3 Tue, 6:03pm
                                                           Collapse Duin's Day in TH:DoS Otaku-sempai 12 2 Tue, 10:04pm
                                                               Collapse It's always something! Otaku-sempai 8 1 Wed, 3:09pm
                                                                   Tolkien's Descrepency Otaku-sempai 2 0 Thu, 10:24pm
                                   Collapse And...what was considered to be the start of Winter? Otaku-sempai 113 9 Jan 20, 4:36pm
                                       Collapse October 23 to November 20? Otaku-sempai 109 8 Jan 20, 5:07pm
                                           Collapse Semantics ... Bracegirdle 93 7 Jan 20, 11:11pm
                                               Collapse Okay... Otaku-sempai 86 6 Jan 21, 1:04am
                                                   Collapse Durin's Day in 'TH:BotFA' Otaku-sempai 84 5 Jan 21, 1:24am
                                                       Collapse I can’t refute Bracegirdle 76 4 Jan 21, 4:02am
                                                           Collapse Yes. realistically it would make a difference Otaku-sempai 69 3 Jan 21, 11:01am
                                                               Collapse Is 6000 years enough time? . . . Bracegirdle 57 2 Jan 21, 3:08pm
                                                                   Collapse Best guess Otaku-sempai 60 1 Jan 21, 3:20pm
                                                                       One final (I hope!) correction: Otaku-sempai 53 0 Jan 21, 4:26pm
                   I think it means the last lunar cycle. Elizabeth 163 0 Jan 19, 1:30am
       Collapse I don't know whether it's an error or not... But... leonmuse 308 4 Jan 18, 6:56pm
           Collapse Aaargh! Otaku-sempai 287 2 Jan 18, 7:00pm
               Collapse Don't worry about it! leonmuse 275 1 Jan 18, 7:03pm
                   As an Aquarius, Double Gemini W/ a Full Moon Bombadil 267 0 Jan 18, 7:11pm
           It's been corrected. dernwyn 252 0 Jan 18, 7:48pm
       Collapse I think Tolkien would have known enough astronomy to realise ... DanielLB 270 4 Jan 18, 7:45pm
           Collapse Are you sure that's right? AshNazg 244 3 Jan 18, 8:25pm
               The full moon is opposite the sun. Elizabeth 180 0 Jan 19, 12:56am
               Collapse Earth casting shadow swordwhale 205 1 Jan 19, 4:11am
                   As the moon passes quarter moon and heads shadowdog 203 0 Jan 19, 4:22am
       Collapse Maybe things work differently in Middle Earth... HeWhoArisesinMight 167 2 Jan 19, 1:31am
           What is Myth? Otaku-sempai 154 0 Jan 19, 2:53am
           As the moon wanes and approaches the new moon shadowdog 223 0 Jan 19, 3:20am
       Dwarven New Year and Durin's Day (final thoughts) Otaku-sempai 31 0 Jan 23, 2:35pm

  Collapse The 'Arkenstone' Silmaril . . . chauvelin2000 435 10 Thu, 7:28am Jump to last post in thread (by ElendilTheShort)
       For me IT IS Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 220 0 Thu, 9:09am
       Collapse JDR and the Arkenstone Elthir 173 6 Thu, 1:47pm
           Collapse Can somebody explain, as I'm not a geologist... Eleniel 136 5 Thu, 3:07pm
               Collapse A lot of volcanos shadowdog 98 4 Thu, 6:25pm
                   Collapse Yes I know land masses shift and move... Eleniel 68 3 Thu, 8:38pm
                       Collapse No more a stretch as ... DanielLB 60 1 Thu, 9:04pm
                           Ah, but Beater and Biter could easily have been carried away by the enemy... Eleniel 53 0 Thu, 9:38pm
                       Not really shadowdog 56 0 Thu, 9:21pm
       That's interesting! Lindarielwen 150 0 Thu, 1:56pm
       the descriptions of the two gems are entirely different ElendilTheShort 53 0 Thu, 9:55pm

  Collapse Multicultural Laketown Drakblod 888 57 Jan 23, 6:37am Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       I thought it was a good move... moreorless 507 0 Jan 23, 6:48am
       Collapse Liked it. Arannir 434 1 Jan 23, 9:05am
           Pretty Much smtfhw 392 0 Jan 23, 9:20am
       I noticed it, of course. RosieLass 419 0 Jan 23, 9:11am
       Didn't bother me. bungobaggins 362 0 Jan 23, 12:16pm
       Collapse Middle Earth stories are supposed to be myths. Bumblingidiot 398 9 Jan 23, 12:55pm
           Yes, I agree with this Glorfindela 353 0 Jan 23, 1:08pm
           Collapse Middle-earth DjU 326 7 Jan 23, 2:44pm
               also ignoring... Brandybuckled 294 0 Jan 23, 3:35pm
               Collapse If you're commenting on something I wrote, please Bumblingidiot 220 5 Jan 24, 2:47am
                   Collapse Plus... Ereinion Nénharma 196 4 Jan 24, 7:26am
                       Collapse Not knowing about means not knowing about. Bumblingidiot 54 3 Sun, 5:03pm
                           Collapse Err... Ereinion Nénharma 43 1 Sun, 6:00pm
                               Er, no. Bumblingidiot 5 0 Thu, 9:16pm
                           You do make some interesting points. Otaku-sempai 59 0 Sun, 10:15pm
       Collapse As a trading post Ham_Sammy 321 19 Jan 23, 2:35pm
           Collapse I agree! Mcoull 302 18 Jan 23, 2:50pm
               Collapse Alatar and Pallando... Bladerunner 176 17 Jan 23, 10:34pm
                   Collapse I would not have liked that Glorfindela 254 7 Jan 23, 11:27pm
                       Collapse And what about Magneto????.... Bladerunner 243 4 Jan 24, 12:08am
                           Collapse That's my point of view. Glorfindela 234 3 Jan 24, 12:31am
                               Collapse X-Men came out a year before Lord of the Rings.... Bladerunner 232 2 Jan 24, 1:02am
                                 Collapse Good – problem solved, then. Glorfindela 224 1 Jan 24, 1:19am
                                       I didn't have a problem that needed solving to begin with...// Bladerunner 215 0 Jan 24, 1:25am
                       Collapse What DjU 220 1 Jan 24, 1:41am
                           OK, then Glorfindela 162 0 Jan 24, 1:19pm
                   Collapse I agree... Ereinion Nénharma 190 8 Jan 24, 7:20am
                       Collapse Taken "out" of Middle Earth Mcoull 165 7 Jan 24, 1:32pm
                           Collapse Maoris in Lake-town would be an anachronism. Moahunter 135 6 Jan 24, 7:24pm
                               Ah, but the world was shaped differently then.....mythically. Eruonen 106 0 Jan 24, 10:07pm
                               Collapse Yes, but Maori-like people may have been in ME all the time Glorfindela 93 1 Jan 24, 11:45pm
                                   Obviously Middle-earth is complete fiction... Salmacis81 80 0 Jan 25, 3:03am
                               Collapse There are Maoris in Lake Town Mcoull 74 2 Sun, 6:15pm
                                   Collapse There are no Maoris in Lake-town. Otaku-sempai 60 1 Sun, 10:06pm
                                       Yes you're right Mcoull 41 0 Mon, 1:07am
       Collapse There is a certain logic. Otaku-sempai 287 1 Jan 23, 3:54pm
           Easterlings... Salmacis81 79 0 Jan 25, 1:59am
       Collapse I didn't hardly think about it Bishop 258 10 Jan 23, 6:15pm
           Collapse Not quite the first- Mcoull 236 1 Jan 23, 7:13pm
               Right Bishop 224 0 Jan 23, 7:20pm
           Collapse Including LotR? Otaku-sempai 231 7 Jan 23, 7:24pm
               Collapse What's the deal with the "in reply to" on this forum? Bishop 233 6 Jan 23, 7:29pm
                   Not a problem. Otaku-sempai 213 0 Jan 23, 7:31pm
                   Collapse Hi! arithmancer 218 4 Jan 23, 7:34pm
                       Collapse He did it right. Otaku-sempai 209 2 Jan 23, 7:37pm
                           Collapse Need more coffee...I was looking at his last post, which WAS to you.!// arithmancer 199 1 Jan 23, 7:39pm
                               Yes. Otaku-sempai 192 0 Jan 23, 7:43pm
                       Cool, thanks Bishop 206 0 Jan 23, 7:37pm
       Collapse Can't say that I noticed Spriggan 223 7 Jan 24, 1:22am
           Collapse (Bit of an essay here) The reason we have different ethnicities in the first place is because people were geographically isolated Bumblingidiot 207 6 Jan 24, 3:51am
               Collapse I don't think they are the two options are they? Spriggan 180 5 Jan 24, 11:51am
                   Collapse The different ethnicities are represented in the books. Bumblingidiot 55 4 Sun, 2:47pm
                       Collapse What probability level are you looking for? Spriggan 42 3 Sun, 5:45pm
                           Collapse In areas of population shift, occupation or free trade, Bumblingidiot 50 2 Mon, 12:42am
                               Collapse We are talking about Laketown! Spriggan 46 1 Mon, 12:57am
                                   Nobody was disagreeing on that Bumblingidiot 31 0 Mon, 1:28pm
       As stated in The Hobbit...clearly, Laketown was a center for trade coming from Eruonen 145 0 Jan 24, 6:42pm

  Collapse The most....... dormouse 1385 48 Jan 23, 2:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Collapse What a great idea! BlackFox 638 2 Jan 23, 2:22pm
           Collapse Filling in the blanks BlackFox 576 1 Jan 23, 3:00pm
               Bomby's List Bombadil 454 0 Jan 23, 5:34pm
       Great thread! Starglass 598 0 Jan 23, 2:33pm
       Thanks dormouse, this is fun. :-) DanielLB 604 0 Jan 23, 2:39pm
       Good one! Bishop 515 0 Jan 23, 4:05pm
       Awards KingTurgon 497 0 Jan 23, 4:14pm
     I'll go for things off the top of my head Glorfindela 503 0 Jan 23, 4:24pm
       Collapse Ooh ooh! Elvanui 491 1 Jan 23, 4:31pm
           must agree with swordwhale 92 0 Mon, 5:08am
       Here's mine... Elutherian 472 0 Jan 23, 4:41pm
       My thoughts Elessar 457 0 Jan 23, 4:58pm
       Excellent idea Michelle Johnston 458 0 Jan 23, 5:10pm
       Mine... arithmancer 430 0 Jan 23, 5:27pm
       mine Jeffrodo 417 0 Jan 23, 5:44pm
       Really great idea! tsmith675 396 0 Jan 23, 6:09pm
       The TORnies! (or would that be the Kimmies?) Kim 400 0 Jan 23, 6:37pm
       Collapse Where are yours? Voronwë_the_Faithful 402 3 Jan 23, 6:39pm
           Collapse Who Sir? Me Sir? *Looks innocent* dormouse 374 2 Jan 23, 7:52pm
               Very nice :) Elessar 333 0 Jan 23, 8:08pm
               Too hard! But just for you I will try. Voronwë_the_Faithful 354 0 Jan 23, 8:17pm
       Ooh, good idea! Gianna 395 0 Jan 23, 6:43pm
       My response Nolane 371 0 Jan 23, 7:14pm
       O.K. : VeArkenstone 351 0 Jan 23, 7:44pm
       My list & nomination for "dumbest scene" Kilidoescartwheels 353 0 Jan 23, 8:16pm
       mine Mooseboy018 325 0 Jan 23, 8:16pm
       Most... Riven Delve 338 0 Jan 23, 9:53pm
       This is too hard... Noria 333 0 Jan 23, 10:05pm
       Just off the top of my head Old Toby 330 0 Jan 23, 10:09pm
       Sadly I can't do 'Reply All'...... dormouse 307 0 Jan 23, 11:27pm
       Okay, I'll play! Roheryn 314 0 Jan 23, 11:27pm
     Excellent notion, Dormouse! Brethil 306 0 Jan 23, 11:39pm
       this is too hard for me, but Avandel 300 0 Jan 24, 12:07am
       A little bit of everything. Farficom 284 0 Jan 24, 1:36am
       Mr. A´s list Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 282 0 Jan 24, 2:31am
       Collapse Here goes. Macfeast 251 1 Jan 24, 11:44am
           Just have to say that I completely agree with this sentiment... Salmacis81 160 0 Jan 25, 2:45am
       Oh wow Elarie 226 0 Jan 24, 2:56pm
       Here are mine Elanor of Rohan 215 0 Jan 24, 4:13pm
       Finally put my mind to it... Eleniel 206 0 Jan 24, 8:18pm
       Collapse Brilliant post! MirielCelebel 182 1 Jan 24, 11:02pm
           Mine Pandallo 92 0 Mon, 5:00am
       Adding two more "Cheer" moments: Brethil 178 0 Jan 24, 11:13pm
       Mine Salmacis81 163 0 Jan 25, 2:13am
       Great idea! elostirion74 54 0 Mon, 9:45pm
       Here are mine :D grammaboodawg 49 0 Tue, 2:03am
       Collapse So this is my first post on these boards... laurethiel1138 19 1 Thu, 7:17pm
           Hello, welcome... dormouse 12 0 Thu, 8:05pm

HAS the "EMBARGO" been Lifted YET? Bombadil 357 0 Thu, 7:24pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)

  Collapse Would PJ ever release a shorter, book-accurate Hobbit? stoutfiles 1238 69 Tue, 6:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by Darkstone)
       Collapse So much effort... Aragorn the Elfstone 661 7 Tue, 6:52pm
           Collapse I was under the impression... stoutfiles 648 6 Tue, 6:58pm
               Yeah... no. Pandallo 595 0 Tue, 7:01pm
               No, that is not what happened. Aragorn the Elfstone 590 0 Tue, 7:01pm
               I don't get this Bishop 546 0 Tue, 7:19pm
               Doesn't sound like Lindele 430 0 Tue, 7:50pm
               PJ... arithmancer 373 0 Tue, 8:29pm
               No, they were creative decisions Annatar598 311 0 Wed, 5:53am
       Collapse No. Pandallo 581 12 Tue, 6:57pm
           Collapse What I view? stoutfiles 578 11 Tue, 7:01pm
               Collapse None of those people matter. Aragorn the Elfstone 556 7 Tue, 7:04pm
                   Collapse Okay, then cut PJ out of the loop stoutfiles 544 6 Tue, 7:08pm
                       Collapse Read the book. Aragorn the Elfstone 541 5 Tue, 7:10pm
                           Collapse You forget who's stories these really are stoutfiles 520 3 Tue, 7:17pm
                               Collapse No. Tolkien is the author of the source material. PJ is the director of HIS films. Aragorn the Elfstone 511 2 Tue, 7:28pm
                                   Collapse You are the exception stoutfiles 422 1 Tue, 7:57pm
                                       That's irrelevant. Aragorn the Elfstone 359 0 Tue, 8:33pm
                           Like community theater perhaps? Bishop 496 0 Tue, 7:20pm
               Collapse Please don't Ataahua 527 2 Tue, 7:23pm
                   Collapse Just showing that people care stoutfiles 493 1 Tue, 7:25pm
                       And it's great to discuss them. Ataahua 469 0 Tue, 7:36pm
       Collapse No, of course he won't dormouse 548 12 Tue, 7:15pm
           Collapse Huh? stoutfiles 523 10 Tue, 7:23pm
               Collapse probably all of them. DjU 481 5 Tue, 7:29pm
                   Collapse The point was the director is not crucial when adapting a story stoutfiles 465 4 Tue, 7:36pm
                       Collapse A massive assumption DjU 449 2 Tue, 7:42pm
                           Collapse Common sense? stoutfiles 426 1 Tue, 7:49pm
                               I tend to see the Middle-Earth films - Hanzkaz 389 0 Tue, 8:00pm
                       Nope. arithmancer 329 0 Tue, 8:37pm
               Chris Columbus. Alfonso Cuaron. Mike Newell. David Yates. Aragorn the Elfstone 465 0 Tue, 7:33pm
               Collapse People who love the stories may have given the first film..... dormouse 194 2 Tue, 11:59pm
                   Perhaps it is a weakness... Aragorn the Elfstone 181 0 Wed, 12:08am
                   Me Too smtfhw 265 0 Wed, 8:23am
           Someone else, maybe, not PJ. Elizabeth 294 0 Wed, 6:36am
       Collapse It's weird - Hanzkaz 463 2 Tue, 7:39pm
           Collapse What time and expense? stoutfiles 380 1 Tue, 7:54pm
               I'm not an expert on film-making, Hanzkaz 360 0 Tue, 8:09pm
       Collapse i would love it. balbo biggins 400 10 Tue, 7:59pm
           Collapse I don't get any anger Spriggan 269 9 Tue, 9:59pm
               Collapse its about experimenting playing a challenge balbo biggins 237 1 Tue, 10:27pm
                   I don't think I recall someone ever asking that! Spriggan 177 0 Tue, 11:51pm
               Collapse Don't worry, this is not an invitation to a thread closing debate Bishop 214 6 Tue, 11:18pm
                   Collapse Ha - that's good to know. Spriggan 176 5 Tue, 11:54pm
                       Collapse Gotcha Bishop 172 4 Tue, 11:59pm
                           Collapse Well, there are lots of things. Spriggan 331 3 Wed, 12:08am
                               Collapse Yes that makes sense Bishop 320 1 Wed, 12:17am
                                   No worries. Spriggan 317 0 Wed, 12:23am
                               If someone goes this route I think it would be better for it to be a stand alone film moreorless 261 0 Wed, 8:23am
       Zero chance of that happening, I'd say... Salmacis81 345 0 Tue, 8:22pm
       Collapse No. arithmancer 345 2 Tue, 8:25pm
           Collapse Compared to the book stoutfiles 316 1 Tue, 8:49pm
               yes balbo biggins 300 0 Tue, 8:53pm
       It was an average adaptation, but no he won't and he shouldn't burrahobbit 317 0 Tue, 9:05pm
       I don't believe that PJ would ever reedit his films, Noria 280 0 Tue, 9:36pm
       No, thank goodness Glorfindela 220 0 Tue, 11:28pm
       No, but... Otaku-sempai 189 0 Tue, 11:55pm
       Collapse Of course that will never happen R11 347 3 Wed, 2:38am
           Collapse Posts like this... Pandallo 349 2 Wed, 3:54am
               And This I Think is the Crux of the Matter smtfhw 283 0 Wed, 8:30am
               Just wanted to thank you for the link to Oakentoon 56.... dormouse 257 0 Wed, 9:21am
       Collapse An old argument Michelle Johnston 283 4 Wed, 9:06am
           Collapse Agreed. Arannir 253 3 Wed, 9:43am
               Collapse PJ wouldn't have cut that for sure stoutfiles 182 1 Wed, 5:33pm
                   Doesn't this tell you something? dormouse 112 0 Wed, 11:54pm
               Trolls scene Michelle Johnston 148 0 Wed, 8:06pm
       This is a pointless question... Saneliur 243 0 Wed, 10:29am
       No Nolane 164 0 Wed, 6:28pm
       Nope Lindarielwen 62 0 Thu, 2:18pm
       Probably just the opposite. Darkstone 53 0 Thu, 6:58pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 952 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.