Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 950 (341949 posts in 14250 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 950 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (activity)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 147638 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 110598 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 5555 0 Oct 12 2014, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Sticky: Help us Thank the entire cast & crew of 'All Six Middle-earth Films' News from Bree 767 6 Dec 23 2014, 4:27am Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)

  Collapse Sticky: NEW! Official Hobbit movie reviews - post them here! entmaiden 2506 49 Dec 29 2014, 1:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Spriggan)

Collapse Sticky: Folks from the Uni of Waikato want to know YOUR opinion on BotFA! greendragon 395 9 Jan 21, 4:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elizabeth)

Collapse Sticky: Admin announcement: a clean-up of The Hobbit discussion board Ataahua 429 5 Sat, 10:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)

The River of Denial discussions part deux - UUTs, alternative endings, and speculating on those LOGIC GAPS Avandel 8 0 7 mins ago Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)

  Collapse Hobbit China Box Office. $14.9m Opening day. anthonyroy 1596 53 Sat, 10:35am Jump to last post in thread (by shadowdog)
       Collapse BotFA Heading to $950-$960m worldwide anthonyroy 731 7 Sat, 10:57am
           Collapse That sounds really good to me! Glorfindela 615 6 Sat, 1:29pm
               Collapse Same here! dormouse 589 4 Sat, 1:40pm
                   Yes shadowdog 512 0 Sat, 3:40pm
                   Collapse Looking good Elessar 118 2 2:08pm
                       Collapse Good number Estel78 52 1 7:23pm
                           Nice and let's hope :) Elessar 15 0 48 mins ago
               Hear, hear! Avandel 481 0 Sat, 4:31pm
       Collapse Very good (yet not enough) Estel78 695 2 Sat, 11:01am
           Yes think $1billion is very much dead now anthonyroy 645 0 Sat, 12:45pm
           Pretty much right in line with what I predicted Voronwë_the_Faithful 591 0 Sat, 2:02pm
       Collapse Well that should teach the studios... Earl 681 35 Sat, 1:00pm
           Collapse I agree, ends too quickly, not enough resolve, who disagrees and why? greenbalrog 585 1 Sat, 2:09pm
               There are many... arithmancer 546 0 Sat, 3:01pm
           Collapse Bit of an odd statement... DjU 576 32 Sat, 3:07pm
               It would have beaten AUJ Estel78 555 0 Sat, 3:37pm
               Collapse Peace! Earl 516 30 Sat, 4:08pm
                   If more people have chosen to see the final film Spriggan 513 0 Sat, 4:24pm
                 Also Avandel 481 0 Sat, 4:44pm
                   Collapse I Got You First Time. Michelle Johnston 472 27 Sat, 5:46pm
                       Collapse Took Estimated 117m yuan ($18.77m) on Saturday in China anthonyroy 471 24 Sat, 6:18pm
                           Looks like Saturday estimates were right on the money Voronwë_the_Faithful 420 0 Sun, 5:34am
                           Collapse $50 million weekend Voronwë_the_Faithful 392 22 Sun, 2:44pm
                               Collapse Not bad Estel78 359 4 Sun, 3:40pm
                                   Collapse Tickets sold Voronwë_the_Faithful 359 3 Sun, 4:05pm
                                       Collapse In 20 years... Estel78 367 2 Sun, 4:21pm
                                           Collapse I'm sure WB is crying all the way to the bank! Voronwë_the_Faithful 358 1 Sun, 4:33pm
                                             Indeed – epic fail, what? Glorfindela 348 0 Sun, 5:13pm
                               Collapse $49.5m China debut Estel78 324 16 Sun, 7:37pm
                                   Collapse Which currently puts it at... BlackFox 314 14 Sun, 8:36pm
                                     Yes – saw that Glorfindela 285 0 Sun, 9:37pm
                                       Collapse Actually Kristin Thompson 254 12 Sun, 11:50pm
                                           Collapse I'm not sure about this Glorfindela 258 10 12:18am
                                               Collapse BOFA "Stuns" with Box Office Record. ShireHorse 172 5 12:11pm
                                                   Collapse Entirely agree with your sentiments, Shire Horse Glorfindela 146 3 1:15pm
                                                       Collapse Rooting it to fail Elessar 126 2 2:09pm
                                                           Collapse Yes, that's true Glorfindela 107 1 3:10pm
                                                               Agreed Elessar 81 0 3:55pm
                                                   Interesting articles..... dormouse 121 0 2:15pm
                                               Collapse The total at the top is not up to date to January 25 for all countries Kristin Thompson 85 2 3:37pm
                                                   It is up to date Estel78 43 0 7:12pm
                                                   That number is the correct up to date number shadowdog 3 0 12 mins ago
                                               You are correct shadowdog 5 0 19 mins ago
                                           Glorfindela is right BlackFox 185 0 9:46am
                                   Looking good Voronwë_the_Faithful 94 0 3:17pm
                       Collapse I'll admit there was a lot of beheading in this film... Bofur01 459 1 Sat, 6:25pm
                           Nice One Michelle Johnston 476 0 Sat, 10:02pm
       Collapse I've been reading everywhere ShireHorse 603 4 Sat, 4:23pm
           Collapse Unfortunately Richard retweeted false information Voronwë_the_Faithful 501 3 Sat, 6:36pm
               Collapse I'm one of those people in that thread :D. anthonyroy 452 2 Sat, 6:46pm
                   I had a feeling you were Voronwë_the_Faithful 450 0 Sat, 7:03pm
                   Well, my mistake. ShireHorse 393 0 Sat, 8:32pm
       The Real Story is Gold Michelle Johnston 222 0 5:04am

  Collapse Who else liked how the deaths played out? Hobbity Hobbit 224 9 8:15pm Jump to last post in thread (by burrahobbit)
       Hated it Shirriff Anthony 116 0 9:12pm
       Thorin's was a real high point. Spriggan 99 0 9:28pm
       I liked it. Noria 74 0 9:46pm
       I do think... arithmancer 74 0 9:48pm
       good overall Mooseboy018 66 0 9:54pm
       bit meh balbo biggins 54 0 10:05pm
       I think they were very well done Glorfindela 47 0 55 mins ago
       I don't have a problem with how they were changed from the book Bishop 23 0 19 mins ago
       I think PJ overcomplicated things burrahobbit 16 0 13 mins ago

  Collapse The Mysterious Case of the Disappearing Dwarf Roheryn 1415 67 Sun, 12:51am Jump to last post in thread (by Elarie)
       Collapse Good question! Brethil 701 2 Sun, 12:57am
           Collapse It appears that Roheryn 677 1 Sun, 2:12am
               Potty vs non-potty rationales Brethil 589 0 Sun, 2:27am
       It's a bit of a plothole. Merovech 600 0 Sun, 2:27am
       Collapse Only the EE knows..... Bishop 614 1 Sun, 2:31am
           True....we now all await the EE to make EVERTHING better that has caused some Eruonen 23 0 9:34pm
       Bad reputation.... Miss-Merriweather 598 0 Sun, 2:47am
       Collapse Very good point Avandel 588 46 Sun, 3:05am
         Collapse Its a nice river. A quiet river. Brethil 537 36 Sun, 3:32am
               Collapse Floaty chairs for all Kim 448 9 Sun, 6:42am
                   Collapse one daiquiri, please Ilmatar 343 8 Sun, 11:47am
                       Collapse *hands over frosty beverage* Kim 223 7 Sun, 8:02pm
                           Collapse what happens at THE RIVER Avandel 239 5 Sun, 8:59pm
                             Collapse This...this...! Brethil 198 1 Sun, 10:01pm
                                   *bows* thank you! - and now I have to Avandel 165 0 Sun, 11:00pm
                               Collapse Priceless! dormouse 162 1 Sun, 11:02pm
                                 *waves at Dormouse* Avandel 144 0 Sun, 11:37pm
                               Sweet! Kim 117 0 1:17am
                           thank you Kim :) Ilmatar 198 0 Sun, 9:29pm
               Collapse Maybe we should start a "river of denial" thread Kilidoescartwheels 160 15 Sun, 11:25pm
                 Collapse *Excellent idea KDC! I second Avandel as Thread-starter!* Brethil 146 12 Sun, 11:38pm
                       Collapse bows humbly Avandel 125 10 12:47am
                           Collapse fear not the enchanted waters of the River of Denial swordwhale 84 9 5:35am
                               Collapse I want to learn how to kayak. Dame Ioreth 78 2 6:11am
                                   Collapse oooh - me too re kayaking! Avandel 82 1 3:59pm
                                       Know what the lobster boats in Bar Harbor (Maine) call sea kayaks? dernwyn 79 0 4:15pm
                             Collapse great images Avandel 55 5 6:39pm
                                   Collapse But.... but...... dormouse 49 4 7:05pm
                                       Collapse Mmmm, wings... Otaku-sempai 44 3 7:17pm
                                           Collapse OK, wings are ready! Kim 34 2 8:05pm
                                               Collapse Great! Otaku-sempai 33 1 8:08pm
                                                   All are invited! Kim 30 0 8:16pm
                       Thirded! Kim 120 0 1:20am
                   Collapse LOL Avandel 150 1 Sun, 11:38pm
                       Wait, Did I hear something about a River thread? Dame Ioreth 133 0 12:39am
               Collapse I have a kayak swordwhale 88 9 5:15am
                   Collapse I brought you all some boats.... swordwhale 88 8 5:21am
                       Collapse and there's tai chi to help everyone relax.......... swordwhale 84 7 5:25am
                           Collapse and don't believe a word these guys say.... swordwhale 85 6 5:26am
                               just relax and smell the lotus........ swordwhale 81 0 5:32am
                               Collapse Oh, I know what *they're* saying: Roheryn 120 2 10:44am
                                 Collapse on sharing Avandel 76 1 5:25pm
                                       That is too great! Elarie 12 0 9:55pm
                               Collapse At our local seaside town the other day.... Na Vedui 87 1 3:52pm
                                   Friend of Mine recently reported back smtfhw 80 0 4:05pm
           Collapse Right. Roheryn 528 5 Sun, 3:47am
             Collapse ROFLMAO! Avandel 461 4 Sun, 6:19am
                   Collapse Ooooh, do share. Roheryn 397 3 Sun, 9:35am
                       Slavish breeze Brethil 328 0 Sun, 12:52pm
                       Collapse The proper way to share the pool boy Elarie 110 1 2:04pm
                           LOL - is it Valentine's already? Avandel 58 0 6:31pm
           Collapse Cannonball! Dame Ioreth 219 2 Sun, 8:48pm
             Of course water therapy is good for all of us! Avandel 212 0 Sun, 9:01pm
               Water therapy is very beneficial Kim 194 0 Sun, 9:36pm
       Collapse not sure Ham_Sammy 501 1 Sun, 4:23am
           I'd have to Roheryn 470 0 Sun, 5:23am
       Collapse Dwalin saw Alfrid sneaking away in the dress... Brandybuckled 460 1 Sun, 7:53am
         Hehehe! // BlackFox 378 0 Sun, 9:44am
       Collapse I know... right? But my UUT is... grammaboodawg 358 4 Sun, 1:49pm
         By Jove Gramma, I think you've got it Brethil 310 0 Sun, 2:13pm
           Ooh - I like your UUT dormouse 300 0 Sun, 2:19pm
           Perfect, gramma! Roheryn 232 0 Sun, 7:49pm
           *mods way up!*// Arandiel 68 0 5:10pm
       One of my... CathrineB 290 0 Sun, 3:27pm
       Dwalin AWOL Axeman21 280 0 Sun, 4:01pm
       Tons of orcs TheSexyBeard 279 0 Sun, 4:03pm
       My UUT NottaSackville 83 0 4:30pm

  Collapse Martin Freeman not so secret extra role in The Hobbit Oleander Took 860 9 4:09pm Jump to last post in thread (by gliido)
       WOW Name 423 0 4:39pm
       Great reference! Pandallo 382 0 4:56pm
       Collapse Not again! Shirriff Anthony 421 1 5:01pm
           Not again!! SafeUnderHill 259 0 6:31pm
       Collapse Absolutely NUTS Dcole4 333 2 5:58pm
           Connolly's illness Pandallo 293 0 6:24pm
           I wouldn't condemn the filmmakers Annatar598 161 0 7:52pm
       I didn't pick that! Ataahua 278 0 6:22pm
       Now that I've seen the prosthetic version... gliido 56 0 9:49pm

  Collapse In that last shot of the Dwarves when they are saying goodbye to Bilbo, does anyone else... Lio 1172 24 Sun, 12:29am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       yes Ilmatar 530 0 Sun, 12:31am
       What a shot that it is. Brethil 536 0 Sun, 12:38am
       Yeah... Riven Delve 494 0 Sun, 12:47am
       sad marillaraina 486 0 Sun, 12:50am
       Collapse Definitely Starglass 451 1 Sun, 2:06am
           there's something swordwhale 100 0 5:00am
       Oh, yes. Arveldis 435 0 Sun, 2:23am
     Yes Avandel 425 0 Sun, 3:07am
       Collapse It's such a classically Disney moment full of Annatar598 469 1 Sun, 3:26am
           Bilbo hates saying good-bye. Gwytha 111 0 3:58am
       Collapse For me the moment that really hit.... dormouse 370 1 Sun, 10:22am
           Yes it was :( // Ilmatar 298 0 Sun, 11:59am
       Collapse Very poignant moment Kelly of Water's Edge 316 8 Sun, 12:53pm
           Collapse Oin, not Gloin MyWeeLadGimli 179 1 Sun, 9:58pm
               Yes. Kelly of Water's Edge 169 0 Sun, 10:12pm
           subject marillaraina 134 0 1:41am
           Collapse Gloin? Gloin isn't killed in Moria. Otaku-sempai 73 4 3:28pm
               Collapse No, it should be Oin... Eleniel 32 3 7:59pm
                   Collapse Been there, done that. Otaku-sempai 30 2 8:06pm
                       Collapse I was replying to your post... Eleniel 28 1 8:09pm
                           Oops! Otaku-sempai 14 0 9:46pm
       Collapse Oh god yes CathrineB 292 1 Sun, 2:27pm
           One of many times for this movie DisDwarfWoman 221 0 Sun, 7:02pm
       Yes lionoferebor 253 0 Sun, 4:45pm

  Collapse The most....... dormouse 1321 45 Fri, 2:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by elostirion74)
       Collapse What a great idea! BlackFox 625 2 Fri, 2:22pm
           Collapse Filling in the blanks BlackFox 561 1 Fri, 3:00pm
               Bomby's List Bombadil 439 0 Fri, 5:34pm
       Great thread! Starglass 583 0 Fri, 2:33pm
       Thanks dormouse, this is fun. :-) DanielLB 590 0 Fri, 2:39pm
       Good one! Bishop 501 0 Fri, 4:05pm
       Awards KingTurgon 483 0 Fri, 4:14pm
     I'll go for things off the top of my head Glorfindela 490 0 Fri, 4:24pm
       Collapse Ooh ooh! Elvanui 478 1 Fri, 4:31pm
           must agree with swordwhale 54 0 5:08am
       Here's mine... Elutherian 459 0 Fri, 4:41pm
       My thoughts Elessar 444 0 Fri, 4:58pm
       Excellent idea Michelle Johnston 444 0 Fri, 5:10pm
       Mine... arithmancer 417 0 Fri, 5:27pm
       mine Jeffrodo 403 0 Fri, 5:44pm
       Really great idea! tsmith675 383 0 Fri, 6:09pm
       The TORnies! (or would that be the Kimmies?) Kim 387 0 Fri, 6:37pm
       Collapse Where are yours? Voronwë_the_Faithful 389 3 Fri, 6:39pm
           Collapse Who Sir? Me Sir? *Looks innocent* dormouse 361 2 Fri, 7:52pm
               Very nice :) Elessar 319 0 Fri, 8:08pm
               Too hard! But just for you I will try. Voronwë_the_Faithful 316 0 Fri, 8:17pm
       Ooh, good idea! Gianna 382 0 Fri, 6:43pm
       My response Nolane 359 0 Fri, 7:14pm
       O.K. : VeArkenstone 339 0 Fri, 7:44pm
       My list & nomination for "dumbest scene" Kilidoescartwheels 341 0 Fri, 8:16pm
       mine Mooseboy018 313 0 Fri, 8:16pm
       Most... Riven Delve 301 0 Fri, 9:53pm
       This is too hard... Noria 297 0 Fri, 10:05pm
       Just off the top of my head Old Toby 294 0 Fri, 10:09pm
       Sadly I can't do 'Reply All'...... dormouse 271 0 Fri, 11:27pm
       Okay, I'll play! Roheryn 276 0 Fri, 11:27pm
     Excellent notion, Dormouse! Brethil 270 0 Fri, 11:39pm
       this is too hard for me, but Avandel 262 0 Sat, 12:07am
       A little bit of everything. Farficom 248 0 Sat, 1:36am
       Mr. A´s list Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 246 0 Sat, 2:31am
       Collapse Here goes. Macfeast 214 1 Sat, 11:44am
           Just have to say that I completely agree with this sentiment... Salmacis81 121 0 Sun, 2:45am
       Oh wow Elarie 190 0 Sat, 2:56pm
       Here are mine Elanor of Rohan 179 0 Sat, 4:13pm
       Finally put my mind to it... Eleniel 170 0 Sat, 8:18pm
       Collapse Brilliant post! MirielCelebel 143 1 Sat, 11:02pm
           Mine Pandallo 55 0 5:00am
       Adding two more "Cheer" moments: Brethil 142 0 Sat, 11:13pm
       Mine Salmacis81 125 0 Sun, 2:13am
       Great idea! elostirion74 10 0 9:45pm

  Collapse A thread to appreciate the Thorin/Bilbo confrontation scene Radagast-Aiwendil 458 11 10:48am Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
     By that point in the Movie? Bombadil 257 0 11:38am
       The scene is beyond words good Glorfindela 245 0 11:53am
       Collapse Excellent post... dormouse 237 1 12:01pm
           ...With all this TALK about "Action Jackson" Bombadil 219 0 12:20pm
       Collapse Agreeing, all the way Ilmatar 210 1 1:27pm
           This is so true Glorfindela 159 0 3:22pm
       Yes a terrific scene to be sure Old Toby 111 0 6:28pm
       Agreed. Fantastic scene, brilliantly acted... Nolane 79 0 7:47pm
       Echoing what others have said Kim 56 0 8:47pm
       ^^^^ What everyone has said PrincessBlade 37 0 9:24pm
       perfect Mooseboy018 30 0 9:33pm

  Collapse What are 5 things from the trilogy that was jarring for you. Thorins_apprentice 1295 41 Sun, 2:30am Jump to last post in thread (by Me85)
       Mostly additions of PJ... Salmacis81 786 0 Sun, 2:41am
       Collapse Hmmm Beorn's Bees 699 1 Sun, 3:17am
           close to my list Annael 327 0 Sun, 4:44pm
       Not in order... grammaboodawg 695 0 Sun, 3:39am
       Collapse In no order Shirriff Anthony 625 2 Sun, 6:35am
           Collapse What about Galadriel? Otaku-sempai 434 1 Sun, 2:13pm
               Certainly not Shirriff Anthony 349 0 Sun, 4:12pm
       Collapse Here are mine DanielLB 567 2 Sun, 9:57am
           Collapse For actual 'jarring' versus other niggles, I agree with 2 points on your list Brethil 444 1 Sun, 1:58pm
               well said swordwhale 154 0 5:12am
       Let's do this ... Legolas_Shoehorn 511 0 Sun, 11:06am
       Collapse Taking 'jarring' to mean something that takes me out of the film.... dormouse 524 1 Sun, 11:35am
           That would be it for me Elessar 104 0 2:13pm
       Collapse Really only Glorfindela 493 1 Sun, 12:08pm
           Totally agree!!! mangotree 105 0 1:54pm
       Collapse so many to narrow down! Eleniel 483 1 Sun, 12:20pm
           I really agree with everyone's list Bishop 339 0 Sun, 4:16pm
       Here's mine Name 390 0 Sun, 3:10pm
       1 = most jarring, 5 = least jarring Gianna 415 0 Sun, 3:17pm
       reply carson_le_great 359 0 Sun, 3:37pm
       Mine Ham_Sammy 339 0 Sun, 4:14pm
       Off the top of my head... Bladerunner 330 0 Sun, 4:44pm
       I don't think I was "jarred" by anything. Spriggan 304 0 Sun, 5:24pm
       Fingernails scraping the blackboard jarring Gwytha 298 0 Sun, 6:35pm
       Collapse Mine annthanatos 278 3 Sun, 7:23pm
           the big and inacceptable lack of... NoelGallagher 269 0 Sun, 7:40pm
           Collapse An interesting thought in passing. Spriggan 232 1 Sun, 10:23pm
               They do indeed // dormouse 202 0 Sun, 11:03pm
       only 5? FernysApple 259 0 Sun, 8:15pm
       Collapse good lists; some further thoughts Felagund 284 3 Sun, 9:03pm
           lol greenbalrog 249 0 Sun, 9:52pm
           "Tauri Loves Kili" Bladerunner 205 0 12:37am
           "Jarring" - well... Kilidoescartwheels 184 0 3:05am
       Collapse Good question CathrineB 250 1 Sun, 10:14pm
           Well said! mangotree 110 0 2:00pm
       Tricky question. Bumblingidiot 128 0 12:25pm
       Collapse my 5 Jeffrodo 101 1 2:31pm
           agree about older actors! mangotree 50 0 6:57pm
       Collapse Easy... Tauriel xxxyyy 98 2 2:54pm
           Agree! Tauriel! mangotree 55 0 6:45pm
         pretty much... Me85 22 0 9:21pm

  Collapse I have seen mirkwoodwanderer 428 5 6:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by PrincessBlade)
     Collapse Damn, YOU have SET a RECORD...Unless gramma Beats you? // Bombadil 183 1 6:38pm
           so, you're obviously the owner of a cinema?! NoelGallagher 144 0 7:36pm
       By 2016...I might pass that EomundDaughter 127 0 7:43pm
       No one will every doubt your fan loyalty Nolane 135 0 7:44pm
       Wow! PrincessBlade 47 0 9:08pm

  Collapse Can we agree that everyone trusting Alfrid was silly? (BOTFA SPOILERS) CaptainObvious 1110 74 Sun, 2:32am Jump to last post in thread (by Ilmatar)
       Collapse I liked him Thorins_apprentice 594 2 Sun, 2:36am
           I certainly didnt find it not in keeping with the tone of the series... moreorless 545 0 Sun, 3:18am
           Monty Python characters Gwytha 236 0 Sun, 4:44pm
       Collapse No, I like Alfrid Avandel 543 1 Sun, 2:48am
           Though I think Bard's character probably had too much faith in Alfrid considering their history, Eruonen 482 0 Sun, 5:09am
       Collapse It's better to not think about such things Bishop 487 12 Sun, 5:32am
           Collapse Is Alfrid even shown as being given that much power? moreorless 453 9 Sun, 6:51am
               Collapse Alfrid The Grate Michelle Johnston 416 8 Sun, 9:12am
                   Collapse I think it makes sense with a shift to three films.. moreorless 382 7 Sun, 11:10am
                       Collapse Aragorn Do Not See It Michelle Johnston 206 6 Sun, 6:27pm
                           Collapse Which is mostly limited to DOS.. moreorless 188 5 4:43am
                               Collapse Bard V Thorin Michelle Johnston 184 4 5:22am
                                   Collapse Great scene I would agree and key to the story but... moreorless 166 3 8:45am
                                       I think you're right - that's exactly the role Alfrid is playing.... dormouse 155 0 9:33am
                                       Collapse See my post above Michelle Johnston 142 1 10:16am
                                           Again though the issue is your dealing with two films... moreorless 93 0 4:13pm
           Collapse Thinking about such things leads to better films Gwytha 225 1 Sun, 5:23pm
               Nice People Good Thoughts Michelle Johnston 180 0 Sun, 7:50pm
       No... dormouse 380 0 Sun, 11:25am
       Collapse My view Glorfindela 378 16 Sun, 12:13pm
           Collapse I agree - Eleniel 354 11 Sun, 12:28pm
               Or if PJ is desperate to include it Glorfindela 325 0 Sun, 1:55pm
               Collapse Personally I liked what we got... moreorless 309 4 Sun, 2:06pm
                   Collapse I disagree Bishop 131 3 Sun, 11:33pm
                       Collapse Alfrid 2 Movie 3 Movie differences Michelle Johnston 117 2 12:19am
                           Collapse That's very interesting Bishop 107 1 12:30am
                               Three Film Additions Michelle Johnston 100 0 1:34am
               Collapse What I don't get KingTurgon 239 4 Sun, 3:51pm
                   Collapse I think they chose to keep Alfred alive as a foil for Bard.... dormouse 238 3 Sun, 4:06pm
                       Collapse But Alfrid tries to say he's in charge KingTurgon 158 2 Sun, 9:09pm
                           Collapse So far as I remember.... dormouse 135 1 Sun, 10:52pm
                               Master Arc Perfect for EE Michelle Johnston 113 0 12:12am
           Collapse As a a parent Yes Michelle Johnston 217 3 Sun, 6:06pm
               Collapse But in the scene as written... arithmancer 180 2 Sun, 7:41pm
                   The Unwanted Help Michelle Johnston 169 0 Sun, 8:04pm
                   Why wouldn't he kill them? Mcoull 91 0 1:20am
       Collapse 7 haarp 358 1 Sun, 1:29pm
         Terrific, inspirational insight Glorfindela 331 0 Sun, 1:53pm
       Collapse Actually, it made sense to me Elarie 319 2 Sun, 2:13pm
           Alfrid is violent though Mcoull 300 0 Sun, 2:31pm
           Bard knowing Thranduil arithmancer 276 0 Sun, 3:12pm
       Eh CathrineB 279 0 Sun, 2:58pm
       Perhaps Bard was testing Alfrid. Otaku-sempai 276 0 Sun, 3:03pm
       As my old music teacher would have said Name 281 0 Sun, 3:15pm
       I agree it didn't make sense to me Gwytha 214 0 Sun, 4:39pm
       Collapse I thought the orders were more minor punishments Spriggan 240 16 Sun, 5:19pm
           Collapse Good point Gwytha 226 2 Sun, 5:29pm
               Collapse Really? Spriggan 222 1 Sun, 5:47pm
                   And Alfrid's reaction... arithmancer 211 0 Sun, 6:14pm
           Collapse I got that impression too Bishop 75 12 2:27am
               Collapse As I recall.. Pandallo 65 3 3:05am
                   Collapse It's still clear that Alfred is looking after the children Bishop 214 2 3:17am
                       Collapse Indeed. Pandallo 203 1 3:45am
                           I guess what I mean is this Bishop 197 0 4:14am
               Collapse Well, it's the middle of a battle, as you say. Spriggan 157 7 8:45am
                   Collapse It's not so much that he was supposed to do anything useful Bishop 57 6 7:27pm
                       Collapse I don't think we are supposed to think of Alfrid as dangerous Spriggan 39 5 8:04pm
                           Collapse You don't see kicking a drowning person in the face Bishop 36 4 8:10pm
                               Well - two points. Spriggan 28 0 8:19pm
                               Collapse thing about Alfrid Ilmatar 28 2 8:32pm
                                   I totally agree Bishop 22 0 8:44pm
                                   clarification Ilmatar 13 0 9:02pm
       Men are weak. annthanatos 193 0 Sun, 7:16pm
       Collapse Alfrid and Lobelia - Greenwood Hobbit 152 1 Sun, 10:29pm
         Bwa..HA, HA, Ha, ha..haaaa..?/// Bombadil 83 0 1:48am
       Collapse Bard displays the mercy all of Tolkien's heroes possess. Silverlode 96 3 2:03am
           Collapse Frodo/Gollum Bard/Alfrid Michelle Johnston 149 2 10:06am
               Elevation is probably a bit much I agree Spriggan 128 0 10:45am
               Um... Silverlode 130 0 11:00am
       Collapse Trusting the greediest, least principled person with something very valuable... Bumblingidiot 126 2 12:01pm
           Collapse *passes Bumblingidiot a cough drop...* // dormouse 113 1 12:04pm
               Cheers! Bumblingidiot 109 0 1:11pm
       no he was not mirkwoodwanderer 76 0 6:32pm
       Alfrid was terrible in BOTFA Nolane 45 0 7:54pm

Collapse BOFA DVD/BluRay: first bonus features! TheHutt 897 5 Fri, 2:03pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Thank you for posting this Glorfindela 281 0 Fri, 4:14pm
       Oh good - that's a hopeful sign! thanks for posting // dormouse 250 0 Fri, 4:51pm
       I just can't wait for this to come out on Bluray tsmith675 238 0 Fri, 6:10pm
       Collapse Another rated feature: TheHutt 25 1 6:24pm
           Sounds promising - thanks! dormouse 18 0 7:02pm

  Collapse Smaug - did he live up to your expectations? Skaan 887 24 Sun, 5:12pm Jump to last post in thread (by mirkwoodwanderer)
       A wondrous creation, is Smaug Glorfindela 479 0 Sun, 5:20pm
       Exceeded them, vastly....... dormouse 461 0 Sun, 5:21pm
       Loved Smaug! Old Toby 429 0 Sun, 5:42pm
       What I liked most was that he didnt become another "action monster" moreorless 458 0 Sun, 5:47pm
       He is the Remus 400 0 Sun, 6:38pm
       Oh yes very much so CathrineB 371 0 Sun, 6:53pm
       Yes Bishop 358 0 Sun, 7:09pm
       Smaug was superbly designed and voiced; the only flaws were in the writing burrahobbit 372 0 Sun, 7:21pm
       Smaug... Ereinion Nénharma 327 0 Sun, 8:09pm
       I don't think it's hyperbolic to say he's one of the trilogy's greatest accomplishments MechaGodzilla 311 0 Sun, 8:35pm
       Collapse Exceeded Them Michelle Johnston 297 1 Sun, 8:55pm
           Most Definitely brotherbeck 277 0 Sun, 9:10pm
       More than lived up to Ham_Sammy 277 0 Sun, 9:07pm
       Any expectations I had were wildly exceeded and obliterated Noria 260 0 Sun, 10:04pm
       Defnitely! Greenwood Hobbit 240 0 Sun, 10:22pm
       Collapse perfect but not perfect balbo biggins 252 3 12:00am
         Collapse WE got a TOUR of ALL Angles of him... Bombadil 217 2 1:45am
               Collapse Plus Yngwulff 196 1 3:17am
                 *snicker*...*snicker* GotThatRight...// Bombadil 137 0 5:41am
       I suppose technically he lived down to them Bumblingidiot 104 0 12:35pm
       He was impressive and enjoyable enough Nightwing 86 0 2:14pm
       My only quibble, noted during DOS discussions, was that his color Eruonen 79 0 2:49pm
       Smaug was Magnificent! (guess the tune) Ruxendil_Thoorg 63 0 4:04pm
       yes. mirkwoodwanderer 34 0 6:32pm

  Collapse Multicultural Laketown Drakblod 855 56 Fri, 6:37am Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       I thought it was a good move... moreorless 496 0 Fri, 6:48am
       Collapse Liked it. Arannir 423 1 Fri, 9:05am
           Pretty Much smtfhw 382 0 Fri, 9:20am
       I noticed it, of course. RosieLass 408 0 Fri, 9:11am
       Didn't bother me. bungobaggins 352 0 Fri, 12:16pm
       Collapse Middle Earth stories are supposed to be myths. Bumblingidiot 388 8 Fri, 12:55pm
           Yes, I agree with this Glorfindela 344 0 Fri, 1:08pm
           Collapse Middle-earth DjU 317 6 Fri, 2:44pm
               also ignoring... Brandybuckled 285 0 Fri, 3:35pm
               Collapse If you're commenting on something I wrote, please Bumblingidiot 213 4 Sat, 2:47am
                   Collapse Plus... Ereinion Nénharma 188 3 Sat, 7:26am
                       Collapse Not knowing about means not knowing about. Bumblingidiot 46 2 Sun, 5:03pm
                           Err... Ereinion Nénharma 34 0 Sun, 6:00pm
                           You do make some interesting points. Otaku-sempai 50 0 Sun, 10:15pm
       Collapse As a trading post Ham_Sammy 310 19 Fri, 2:35pm
           Collapse I agree! Mcoull 293 18 Fri, 2:50pm
               Collapse Alatar and Pallando... Bladerunner 167 17 Fri, 10:34pm
                   Collapse I would not have liked that Glorfindela 247 7 Fri, 11:27pm
                       Collapse And what about Magneto????.... Bladerunner 235 4 Sat, 12:08am
                           Collapse That's my point of view. Glorfindela 227 3 Sat, 12:31am
                               Collapse X-Men came out a year before Lord of the Rings.... Bladerunner 225 2 Sat, 1:02am
                                 Collapse Good – problem solved, then. Glorfindela 217 1 Sat, 1:19am
                                       I didn't have a problem that needed solving to begin with...// Bladerunner 208 0 Sat, 1:25am
                       Collapse What DjU 213 1 Sat, 1:41am
                           OK, then Glorfindela 155 0 Sat, 1:19pm
                   Collapse I agree... Ereinion Nénharma 183 8 Sat, 7:20am
                       Collapse Taken "out" of Middle Earth Mcoull 156 7 Sat, 1:32pm
                           Collapse Maoris in Lake-town would be an anachronism. Moahunter 128 6 Sat, 7:24pm
                               Ah, but the world was shaped differently then.....mythically. Eruonen 98 0 Sat, 10:07pm
                               Collapse Yes, but Maori-like people may have been in ME all the time Glorfindela 86 1 Sat, 11:45pm
                                   Obviously Middle-earth is complete fiction... Salmacis81 73 0 Sun, 3:03am
                               Collapse There are Maoris in Lake Town Mcoull 65 2 Sun, 6:15pm
                                   Collapse There are no Maoris in Lake-town. Otaku-sempai 51 1 Sun, 10:06pm
                                       Yes you're right Mcoull 32 0 1:07am
       Collapse There is a certain logic. Otaku-sempai 278 1 Fri, 3:54pm
           Easterlings... Salmacis81 72 0 Sun, 1:59am
       Collapse I didn't hardly think about it Bishop 249 10 Fri, 6:15pm
           Collapse Not quite the first- Mcoull 227 1 Fri, 7:13pm
               Right Bishop 215 0 Fri, 7:20pm
           Collapse Including LotR? Otaku-sempai 222 7 Fri, 7:24pm
               Collapse What's the deal with the "in reply to" on this forum? Bishop 224 6 Fri, 7:29pm
                   Not a problem. Otaku-sempai 204 0 Fri, 7:31pm
                   Collapse Hi! arithmancer 209 4 Fri, 7:34pm
                       Collapse He did it right. Otaku-sempai 200 2 Fri, 7:37pm
                           Collapse Need more coffee...I was looking at his last post, which WAS to you.!// arithmancer 190 1 Fri, 7:39pm
                               Yes. Otaku-sempai 183 0 Fri, 7:43pm
                       Cool, thanks Bishop 197 0 Fri, 7:37pm
       Collapse Can't say that I noticed Spriggan 216 7 Sat, 1:22am
           Collapse (Bit of an essay here) The reason we have different ethnicities in the first place is because people were geographically isolated Bumblingidiot 200 6 Sat, 3:51am
               Collapse I don't think they are the two options are they? Spriggan 171 5 Sat, 11:51am
                   Collapse The different ethnicities are represented in the books. Bumblingidiot 48 4 Sun, 2:47pm
                       Collapse What probability level are you looking for? Spriggan 35 3 Sun, 5:45pm
                           Collapse In areas of population shift, occupation or free trade, Bumblingidiot 39 2 12:42am
                               Collapse We are talking about Laketown! Spriggan 37 1 12:57am
                                   Nobody was disagreeing on that Bumblingidiot 18 0 1:28pm
       As stated in The Hobbit...clearly, Laketown was a center for trade coming from Eruonen 138 0 Sat, 6:42pm

  Collapse DOS Chapter of the Week (CHOW) Sign-up for February 2015! DanielLB 193 5 Fri, 8:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       Collapse Ooh Hobbity Hobbit 77 1 Fri, 8:45pm
           Inside Information is all yours, Hobbity Hobbit! / DanielLB 54 0 Fri, 9:58pm
       Collapse Yay! Starglass 74 1 Fri, 9:42pm
           It's good to see you again, Starglass. DanielLB 71 0 Fri, 10:00pm
       May I have The Enemy Revealed? BlackFox 24 0 10:32am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 950 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.