Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 931 (333112 posts in 13956 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 931 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (activity)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 144112 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 109930 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 3253 0 Oct 12, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Sticky: Help us Thank the entire cast & crew of 'All Six Middle-earth Films' News from Bree 290 3 Dec 23, 4:27am Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Sticky: NEW! Official Hobbit movie reviews - post them here! entmaiden 124 3 1:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Kerewyn)

  Collapse Big Movie Productions Not to be OTT to be Commercially Successful... Girdle of Melian 364 11 12:03am Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Collapse Elves leaping over dwarves Kilidoescartwheels 177 1 1:03am
           Agree about the CGI Rams Avandel 153 0 1:13am
       Collapse Azog doesn't bother me, some lack of logic IMO does Avandel 160 3 1:08am
           Collapse A couple of thoughts Spriggan 142 1 1:31am
               Foot Soldiers.. Girdle of Melian 89 0 3:34am
           "How come so much focus is on Bard's kids in Dale"... patrickk 33 0 8:39am
       Collapse For me the action problems in the Hobbit werent "unrealistic" so much as dramatic moreorless 41 1 8:31am
           yup I tend to agree... patrickk 33 0 8:35am
       Collapse As soon as you have Elves, or Wizards, you're bound mae govannen 36 2 8:37am
           Collapse I will expect to see OTT moments Girdle of Melian 15 1 44 mins ago
               Luckily for me I don't know about 'super mario routine' mae govannen 6 0 8 mins ago

  How did Elrond, Saruman and Saruman sneak in Dol Guldur without Sauron Noticing? Girdle of Melian 10 0 13 mins ago Jump to last post in thread (by Girdle of Melian)

  Collapse "The reasons why Peter Jackson’s Hobbit movies failed" Elfhelm 2194 85 Sat, 5:15pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       What an odd series of thoughts. Spriggan 1002 0 Sat, 5:29pm
       Collapse Nothing we havenmt heard many times before... moreorless 941 2 Sat, 5:40pm
           Exactly NecromancerRising 843 0 Sat, 5:46pm
         Including that "these films have failed"... which is hilarious, mae govannen 300 0 Sun, 5:57am
       Well, that was confusing. Riven Delve 871 0 Sat, 5:47pm
       Collapse Once, just once Old Toby 898 6 Sat, 5:56pm
           Collapse And just for once pettytyrant101 791 5 Sat, 6:37pm
               Collapse I think you misunderstood my comment Old Toby 649 1 Sat, 8:28pm
                   I find your comment quite correct and justified.// mae govannen 273 0 Sun, 5:41am
               Collapse Well to be fair Ham_Sammy 632 2 Sat, 8:32pm
                   Collapse Not by way of comparison, though, mae govannen 271 1 Sun, 5:46am
                       I agree shadowdog 145 0 Sun, 7:40pm
       I think he was spot on with most of his points. Azaghâl 832 0 Sat, 6:15pm
       Collapse One thing that espeically seems overplayed to me... moreorless 822 5 Sat, 6:35pm
           Collapse Jackson added lots of references to the Lord of the Rings films... Bladerunner 426 4 Sun, 2:06am
               Collapse I don't see what's wrong in all the examples mae govannen 275 3 Sun, 6:21am
                   Pretty much.. moreorless 214 0 Sun, 10:27am
                   Collapse I guess we just totally disagree.... Bladerunner 117 1 Sun, 4:50pm
                       Well, we agree at least on those three then! mae govannen 32 0 3:58am
       Collapse The review fails to fairly support its hypothesis IMO Avandel 746 3 Sat, 7:16pm
           Collapse Agree with you on all your points. // mae govannen 257 2 Sun, 6:02am
               Collapse Thank you Avandel 175 1 Sun, 6:26pm
                 I luv your 'translation' of that Review!!! mae govannen 33 0 4:26am
       Collapse Failed? A matter of opinion. Hanzkaz 727 1 Sat, 7:22pm
           Agree fully with you; and mae govannen 274 0 Sun, 5:18am
       That was just weird Elarie 698 0 Sat, 7:40pm
       Hmmmmm Ham_Sammy 657 0 Sat, 8:08pm
       Collapse This journalist... patrickk 681 28 Sat, 8:36pm
           Good post Ham_Sammy 606 0 Sat, 8:53pm
           Collapse well peterLF 383 23 Sun, 2:44am
               Collapse Tolkein did in fact foreshadow... patrickk 387 21 Sun, 3:14am
                   foreshadowing elostirion74 188 0 Sun, 11:37am
                   Collapse no peterLF 181 19 Sun, 6:28pm
                       Collapse Whilst I don't particularly disagree Spriggan 162 18 Sun, 7:10pm
                           Collapse Only little resemblance indeed...: peterLF 60 17 Sun, 11:44pm
                               Collapse ..as I recall patrickk 51 4 12:11am
                                   Collapse . peterLF 19 3 6:23am
                                       Collapse If you have a six movie set which we will in a few years.. patrickk 15 2 6:34am
                                           Collapse to each his own peterLF 12 1 6:48am
                                               But why not watch films in... patrickk 3 0 9:09am
                               Collapse It's described as a "morgul shaft" Spriggan 48 11 12:38am
                                   Collapse Even the reason for the name 'kingsfoil' mae govannen 33 8 5:00am
                                       Collapse Like I said... peterLF 26 7 6:08am
                                           Collapse Aragorn... patrickk 25 5 6:17am
                                               Collapse sooo.... peterLF 19 3 6:24am
                                                   Collapse Not sure... patrickk 18 2 6:35am
                                                       Collapse watch the film peterLF 15 1 6:51am
                                                           But Oin... patrickk 6 0 8:56am
                                               Thank you for replying mae govannen 2 0 34 mins ago
                                           No sarcasm, please; what I say about Aragorn mae govannen 2 0 40 mins ago
                                   Collapse two elves, out of how many? peterLF 14 1 6:44am
                                       Eh? There are several other healing scenes Spriggan 4 0 41 mins ago
               I prefer to see the movies - Hanzkaz 240 0 Sun, 9:05am
           You're quite right in your critic of this critic!...// mae govannen 271 0 Sun, 5:39am
           Collapse Foreshadowing is subject to the same restrictions as any other technique elostirion74 216 1 Sun, 10:21am
               The proof of the pudding... patrickk 152 0 Sun, 7:27pm
       Collapse Superb Silranhir 599 1 Sat, 9:31pm
           Yep... Avnar 541 0 Sat, 10:21pm
       Hmmm... Dipling 533 0 Sat, 10:39pm
       Collapse Huh? glor 441 1 Sun, 1:12am
           Numerous examples Ham_Sammy 409 0 Sun, 2:09am
       What "failure" is he talking about, to start with??? mae govannen 303 0 Sun, 5:37am
       Collapse Totally agree And back again 258 10 Sun, 9:48am
           Sorry I'm lost on the troll point. Spriggan 247 0 Sun, 10:21am
           Collapse Proof they have failed And back again 228 6 Sun, 11:38am
               Collapse That's to do with promotion and Warner not wanting to spend money! Glorfindela 192 3 Sun, 12:21pm
                   Collapse Oh, they would show the films And back again 188 2 Sun, 12:46pm
                       I don't know what film you are talking about here Glorfindela 174 0 Sun, 1:27pm
                       Chocolate company Ham_Sammy 115 0 Sun, 4:23pm
               Hobbit movies in Germany kiwifan 92 0 Sun, 5:34pm
               Proof they have failed... patrickk 148 0 Sun, 7:32pm
           Collapse Huh? arithmancer 148 1 Sun, 2:59pm
               Yes, it read like that to me. Spriggan 196 0 Sun, 5:39pm
       Only thing I'm hoping... BlackCountry 181 0 Sun, 1:20pm
       Collapse Thanks for this article elentari3018 144 1 Sun, 3:54pm
           It's in the first post, near the top. n/t Elfhelm 105 0 Sun, 4:58pm
       Collapse Wouldn't exactly call them "failures"... Salmacis81 129 8 Sun, 9:02pm
           Collapse I could accept "disappointment" and agree that "failure" just doesn't fit. Escapist 117 6 Sun, 9:07pm
               Collapse The only things... ecthelionsbeard 104 3 Sun, 9:24pm
                   Collapse From what I can recall... Salmacis81 107 2 Sun, 9:40pm
                       Collapse But.. ecthelionsbeard 98 1 Sun, 9:48pm
                           Most of the poor reviews I remember reading... Salmacis81 84 0 Sun, 10:35pm
               Collapse I was 100% speaking from my own personal POV... Salmacis81 118 1 Sun, 9:29pm
                   '...and I guess some of us actually did' patrickk 56 0 Sun, 11:59pm
           Hmm KW 72 0 Sun, 11:35pm

  Collapse Can someone please explain why Galadriel looked like she did in FOTR during her encounter with Sauron? BornOutOfTheWest 1127 37 Sun, 11:17am Jump to last post in thread (by Girdle of Melian)
       It's up to each of of us to interpret but it struck me Spriggan 665 0 Sun, 11:27am
       hmmm hms_ocean 581 0 Sun, 11:31am
       To quote Gandalf BlackFox 558 0 Sun, 1:01pm
       Collapse It's a forced reference to LotR Merovech 526 3 Sun, 1:08pm
           Collapse it depends really what you think were seeing in FOTR moreorless 485 2 Sun, 1:33pm
               Collapse I disagree Merovech 447 1 Sun, 1:42pm
                   The rings temptation yes I agree BUT.. moreorless 436 0 Sun, 1:54pm
       Collapse Good question Riven Delve 481 17 Sun, 1:09pm
           Collapse The Ring is evil, but that is not, I don't think the key issue. Spriggan 417 10 Sun, 2:12pm
               Collapse A bit of both, perhaps? Riven Delve 247 9 Sun, 7:09pm
                   Collapse I was with you most of the way down. Spriggan 222 5 Sun, 7:49pm
                       Collapse I think perhaps it is the "excess" Riven Delve 203 4 Sun, 8:11pm
                           Collapse Well, yes and no. Spriggan 191 3 Sun, 8:25pm
                               Collapse Well, no and yes. Riven Delve 131 2 Sun, 8:51pm
                                   Collapse That's a yes and a yes, I think! Spriggan 126 1 Sun, 8:54pm
                                       *fist bump* // Riven Delve 126 0 Sun, 8:56pm
                   Collapse Wait, what? ecthelionsbeard 200 2 Sun, 8:27pm
                       Collapse The Elven rings are bound to the One Ring, yes Riven Delve 195 1 Sun, 8:44pm
                           I thought the Noldor line.. ecthelionsbeard 131 0 Sun, 9:10pm
           Collapse Agree! And it's not working for me Avandel 302 4 Sun, 5:31pm
               Collapse My take on it, Power is Scary MEIGWIT 101 3 Sun, 10:24pm
                   I do not know... ecthelionsbeard 82 0 Sun, 10:46pm
                   Collapse Dark vs Dark? moreorless 13 1 55 mins ago
                       Gandalf Doing the Black Speech of Mordor Girdle of Melian 6 0 36 mins ago
           Yes. Completely agree. Elizabeth 29 0 6:49am
       Collapse A valid question indeed, at least in my eyes... mae govannen 474 1 Sun, 1:12pm
           Completely agree, BornOutOfTheWest 425 0 Sun, 1:42pm
       . Nerven 344 0 Sun, 4:01pm
       Collapse not very well executed Mooseboy018 296 1 Sun, 6:13pm
           It is frustrating that we can only know this from a Chronicles book Riven Delve 255 0 Sun, 7:19pm
       Collapse To determine myself I'll wait for the EE Milieuterrien 239 3 Sun, 7:54pm
           And Well Done Milieuterrien... patrickk 208 0 Sun, 8:10pm
           Collapse I'm still baffled by the idea that Galadriel loses some of her power Riven Delve 220 1 Sun, 8:14pm
               Well, not that that comes across in the film. Spriggan 144 0 Sun, 8:58pm
       Collapse None Shirriff Anthony 140 2 Sun, 8:48pm
           Collapse I just really think it is a bad interpretation and insult to Cate's acting ability... Girdle of Melian 83 1 Sun, 11:40pm
               My view GhostofMacbeth 74 0 12:32am

  Collapse Your favorite moment from the score of BOTFA? erdildeniz 592 17 Sun, 2:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by SafeUnderHill)
       Dain Cari 329 0 Sun, 2:56pm
       I'm still making my way through the first CD :) Earl 291 0 Sun, 3:23pm
       I'm listening to it now! elentari3018 288 0 Sun, 3:26pm
       Collapse So many moments for me. Scorchster 308 1 Sun, 3:47pm
           That theme SafeUnderHill 138 0 Sun, 9:50pm
       Collapse I haven't bought the cd yet Elanor of Rohan 258 1 Sun, 4:19pm
           The horns SafeUnderHill 130 0 Sun, 9:51pm
       I think mine must be... Bofur01 269 0 Sun, 4:29pm
       Two Shirriff Anthony 173 0 Sun, 8:46pm
       Collapse My favourite moment SafeUnderHill 143 1 Sun, 9:53pm
           That is one of mine, as well. cats16 127 0 Sun, 9:58pm
       Collapse The choral piece during fire and water There&ThereAgain 104 1 Sun, 11:28pm
           Yay! SafeUnderHill 89 0 Sun, 11:49pm
       Collapse I agree! KingTurgon 73 1 1:26am
           Sons of Durin and Mithril Jay2001 56 0 2:54am
       Collapse Mithril scene Saneliur 39 1 6:33am
           I believe SafeUnderHill 21 0 9:04am

Collapse Thranduil Appreciation Thread Part XXX VValar 856 57 Fri, 9:47am Jump to last post in thread (by Lurker in the Mirk)
     Collapse *peeks from behind laptop screen* *checks left* *checks right* VValar 437 4 Fri, 9:56am
         Yay, number THIRTY! On_the_partyelk 375 0 Fri, 12:49pm
         Collapse *LoL* TAXXX! Definitely worth breaking out the party hats Lurker in the Mirk 368 2 Fri, 1:12pm
               Collapse Have you seen BoFA again? Just curious. I do not think I will be able to VeArkenstone 203 1 Sat, 9:23pm
                   Yes I have. Twice now Lurker in the Mirk 137 0 Sun, 6:01am
     Collapse The gorgeous latest official Thranduil pic VValar 461 1 Fri, 10:02am
           the source of the new pictures stn5 414 0 Fri, 10:32am
     Collapse If you want a bit of Christmas Carols fun VValar 420 2 Fri, 10:10am
           Thanks for the signal boost, VValar. And thralls... Lurker in the Mirk 363 0 Fri, 1:15pm
         How about a Christmas Song just for us? My Thrall take on Eartha Kitt's Santa Baby Lurker in the Mirk 12 0 9:02am
     Collapse Reply to Lurker's last batch of season's Pretty from last thread VValar 410 1 Fri, 10:17am
         Been a while since we got some FLAST eh? Lurker in the Mirk 365 0 Fri, 1:14pm
     Collapse Thranduil doesn't want to listen to his son -gif. It's Xmas! VValar 440 1 Fri, 10:27am
           Just SNERT! Lurker in the Mirk 366 0 Fri, 1:16pm
     Collapse The BIG Three O! Lurker in the Mirk 376 11 Fri, 1:07pm
           Collapse Another Pretty - armour!fan art Lurker in the Mirk 377 4 Fri, 1:19pm
               Collapse Very nice mariel 308 3 Fri, 5:14pm
                   Collapse *LoL* About hands Lurker in the Mirk 141 2 Sun, 6:04am
                       Collapse Quite right mariel 78 1 Sun, 8:59pm
                           And there was a tumblr post dedicated Lurker in the Mirk 11 0 8:55am
           Where did 29 go? mariel 310 0 Fri, 5:11pm
           Collapse :) Ilmatar 283 1 Fri, 7:49pm
             Hi Ilmatar Lurker in the Mirk 134 0 Sun, 6:10am
         Collapse Vendelina's edits bonanza - including a Xmas Thranduil greeting Lurker in the Mirk 134 2 Sun, 7:00am
               Collapse And more mariel 81 1 Sun, 8:55pm
                   Fresh off the press again, eh? Lurker in the Mirk 11 0 8:57am
       Wow! Adrianna 360 0 Fri, 2:32pm
     Way to go VValar! Eruvandi 349 0 Fri, 3:00pm
       Collapse Hobbit Talk: Is Thranduil a good father? stn5 368 11 Fri, 4:22pm
           Collapse I vote "good father" in that he's a work in progress Ruxendil_Thoorg 330 2 Fri, 5:30pm
               Exactly! Adrianna 312 0 Fri, 5:57pm
               Hi R_T! Thanks for stopping by Lurker in the Mirk 137 0 Sun, 6:17am
           Collapse interesting topic for sure On_the_partyelk 310 1 Fri, 7:05pm
             Definitely "Thranduil Defense Squad" Lurker in the Mirk 139 0 Sun, 6:18am
           Collapse I don't think Thranduil was a bad father either! And I think he is a good king. VeArkenstone 206 5 Sat, 9:31pm
               Collapse Welcome Ve! Adrianna 181 1 Sat, 11:11pm
                   Thranduil's age Lurker in the Mirk 145 0 Sun, 6:24am
             Collapse Re Immortality Paranoia Lurker in the Mirk 142 2 Sun, 6:22am
                   Collapse Immortality Paranoia - DOS EE - VeArkenstone 80 1 Sun, 9:00pm
                       Definitely something to ponder Lurker in the Mirk 10 0 8:54am
       Collapse *brings red velvet cake to Mirkwood court, curtsies before Thranduil, serves cake to Elvenking and his followers* Holly Hobbit 356 4 Fri, 4:26pm
           Collapse *appreciative excellent cake munching* Lurker in the Mirk 142 3 Sun, 6:15am
               Collapse I would love any movie that included Oropher, Thranduil and Legolas. VeArkenstone 69 2 Sun, 9:24pm
                   yes please Me85 55 0 Sun, 9:59pm
                 As long as Lee Pace reprises his role Lurker in the Mirk 10 0 8:52am
     Picking myself off the floor! Nice side by side pic! Adrianna 327 0 Fri, 5:45pm
       Collapse Thanks for the Welcome Vvalar. No. 30, and showing no signs of slowing down! Good! VeArkenstone 202 1 Sat, 9:19pm
           *LoL* Thanks for the compliments on the lexicon Lurker in the Mirk 136 0 Sun, 6:27am
       Collapse Hello TA! XXX eh? lots of love (or... an X rating, so much pretty?) Kerewyn 163 2 Sun, 3:14am
           Welcome back, Kerewyn! Heheh ... that rating... if only eh? Lurker in the Mirk 135 0 Sun, 6:35am
           I was very emotional at the end of BOFA. .... VeArkenstone 75 0 Sun, 9:21pm
       Welcome back Ke! Adrianna 157 0 Sun, 3:34am
     Cast Interview:funny Q & A Lurker in the Mirk 138 0 Sun, 8:27am
       eTalk (Canada) programme: Interview Vid with LP, PJ and PB Lurker in the Mirk 121 0 Sun, 12:47pm
     Read: Confessions of a Thranduil Fan Lurker in the Mirk 50 0 3:25am
       psst, VValar and Eruvandi. Leggy fan art Lurker in the Mirk 14 0 8:23am
     There's a new thread on Thranduil's eyelashes Lurker in the Mirk 14 0 8:32am

  Collapse What would have made Fili's death better Kilidoescartwheels 634 26 12:50am Jump to last post in thread (by Angharad73)
       Collapse Do you mean better for the audience Spriggan 294 6 12:57am
           Collapse Well both, really Kilidoescartwheels 261 5 1:12am
               Collapse I think it might be worth separating them. Spriggan 261 4 1:21am
                   Collapse *waves hand* Riven Delve 251 2 1:35am
                       Collapse Ha ha. Spriggan 235 1 1:42am
                           How appropriate for the film version... Morthoron 214 0 2:21am
                   yes, there have been comments around the net Avandel 239 0 1:37am
       Collapse Some blood on Azog's hand-sword thing for a start Joe20 294 4 12:58am
           Collapse Oh, no, not decapitation! Kilidoescartwheels 271 3 1:10am
               Collapse Blood and Battle equals an R or 15 rating glor 222 1 2:05am
                   yep Ham_Sammy 179 0 2:46am
               Actually... lionoferebor 92 0 5:52am
       Collapse I think CathrineB 301 3 12:58am
           Yes it was shocking Kilidoescartwheels 263 0 1:18am
           Collapse Interesting Avandel 248 1 1:30am
               To me GhostofMacbeth 227 0 1:41am
       Collapse Fili's death has a main outcome Milieuterrien 236 1 1:59am
           The book had.. patrickk 93 0 6:11am
       Collapse A purpose in Fili's death Elarie 224 2 2:25am
           Collapse This JayFank 199 1 2:46am
               You've come to the wrong place if you're looking for people who don't care about the characters Riven Delve 186 0 2:51am
       I thought it was very effective Kim 156 0 3:28am
       Collapse he did fight though- we just don't see it Cirashala 130 1 5:03am
           That's what I thought, too Angharad73 26 0 8:52am
       One word - CLOSURE lionoferebor 99 0 5:47am
       Other than it not happening? Roheryn 33 0 8:30am

  Collapse Gothmog (the Orc) cameo in BOFA? above 236 2 6:38am Jump to last post in thread (by patrickk)
       Collapse To go a little OT am I the only one who would like to see him "CGIed" in an "ultimate" ROTK moreorless 102 1 8:38am
           Gothmog... patrickk 98 0 8:44am

  Collapse Eyelashes; aka, Ro's Been Thinking Again Roheryn 127 6 7:57am Jump to last post in thread (by Roheryn)
       Yes it is his eyelashes... patrickk 58 0 8:11am
     Collapse I KNEW it was Thranduil you were thinking of right away Lurker in the Mirk 53 2 8:21am
           Collapse Who else? Roheryn 44 1 8:36am
               *GASP* Lurker in the Mirk 42 0 8:40am
       Collapse Maybe he's born with it... Starling 49 1 8:24am
           A good Elf Roheryn 43 0 8:40am

  Collapse Symbolism in BOFA and the Hobbit trilogy Saneliur 607 8 Fri, 6:46am Jump to last post in thread (by Lurker in the Mirk)
       Metaphorical Symbols DwellerInDale 341 0 Fri, 7:33am
       Arrgh! I would like to have words with PJ Earl 343 0 Fri, 7:50am
       Collapse Here's another! Scorchster 201 4 Fri, 4:46pm
           That's a nice way to look at it! DisDwarfWoman 54 0 Sat, 7:05pm
           Collapse Nice! That's what I got too Lurker in the Mirk 43 2 Sun, 7:04am
               Collapse Yes! Although I was quite exhausted by the end! Scorchster 29 1 Sun, 3:55pm
                   I did! Lurker in the Mirk 3 0 8:26am
       This is only one particular moment Riven Delve 40 0 Sun, 1:27pm

  Collapse Instances of Foreshadowing patrickk 837 20 Sun, 3:35am Jump to last post in thread (by patrickk)
       Collapse There are a lot pettytyrant101 474 16 Sun, 3:44am
           Collapse Which LOTR scenes did you have in mind patrickk 412 11 Sun, 3:58am
               Collapse off the top of my head pettytyrant101 413 1 Sun, 4:27am
                   I think this comes down to sensibilties... patrickk 346 0 Sun, 6:38am
               Collapse I don't think Balin's tomb has been much affected... Salmacis81 196 8 Sun, 4:34pm
                   Collapse Absolutely... Eleniel 178 7 Sun, 5:01pm
                       Collapse Does a foreshadow... patrickk 101 6 Sun, 10:39pm
                           Collapse well... Magpie 85 4 Sun, 11:42pm
                               Collapse But patrickk 79 3 Sun, 11:50pm
                                   Collapse I never said foreshadowing isn't important Magpie 57 2 1:37am
                                       An example Ham_Sammy 51 0 2:30am
                                       I think we have to agree to disagree... patrickk 35 0 5:10am
                           Why does the use shadowdog 70 0 12:48am
           Regardless, Lindele 400 0 Sun, 4:19am
           Collapse Don't forget the worst offender of all... Eleniel 320 2 Sun, 10:17am
               There was also... Salmacis81 198 0 Sun, 4:29pm
               Elenial remind me of the forshadow... patrickk 148 0 Sun, 7:35pm
       Oddly, it's a criticism I haven't heard levelled at Tolkien Spriggan 304 0 Sun, 10:30am
       Collapse maybe just a nod? peterLF 25 1 6:33am
           Yes there ... patrickk 14 0 8:08am

  Collapse Box Office MedwedtoBeorn 1175 21 Sun, 3:30pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Deadline Ham_Sammy 599 0 Sun, 4:09pm
       Collapse Now in a dead heat with AUJ DwellerInDale 596 8 Sun, 4:39pm
           Collapse Which puts the worldwide total at... BlackFox 565 3 Sun, 5:01pm
               Collapse World wide total shadowdog 217 2 Sun, 10:52pm
                   BOFA wins 2nd week in a row beating Unbroken and Into the Woods Eruonen 93 0 4:37am
                   Hooray! Hooray! Hooray! *jumps up and down with joy* mae govannen 79 0 6:05am
           Collapse Apples and oranges Estel78 480 3 Sun, 5:54pm
               Good result Estel78 446 0 Sun, 6:14pm
               Collapse In this day and age Ham_Sammy 444 1 Sun, 6:20pm
                   DOS suffered because of the freezing weather glor 256 0 Sun, 9:21pm
       From Forbes Avandel 549 0 Sun, 5:16pm
       Collapse I guess having just good news would be too much to ask... Estel78 419 7 Sun, 7:12pm
           Collapse If i am not mistaken though, NecromancerRising 400 6 Sun, 7:15pm
               Collapse In about 3 or 4 important markets Estel78 368 5 Sun, 7:28pm
                   Collapse Japan is one market NecromancerRising 347 4 Sun, 7:37pm
                       Collapse No, not exactly apples and apples Estel78 327 1 Sun, 7:44pm
                           The only true indications so far NecromancerRising 352 0 Sun, 7:47pm
                       Collapse The appreciation of the US$... patrickk 349 1 Sun, 7:56pm
                           Important difference to remember indeed... Thank you! // mae govannen 56 0 7:01am
       Collapse I lost interest in tracking the box office Escapist 390 1 Sun, 7:49pm
           Nice to see it all happening, though... mae govannen 72 0 7:25am

  Collapse **Geeky Observation List for BofFA - Give me your Observations! :) grammaboodawg 1646 92 Dec 18, 4:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by grammaboodawg)
       Collapse :D Elvanui 648 1 Dec 18, 5:06pm
           I love that part! grammaboodawg 597 0 Dec 18, 5:42pm
       Collapse Legolas lost BOTH his white knives stn5 650 3 Dec 18, 5:17pm
           True! grammaboodawg 588 0 Dec 18, 5:44pm
           the Borg... swordwhale 244 0 Dec 19, 12:08am
           I watched for it... grammaboodawg 233 0 Dec 19, 5:33pm
       also: Elarie 585 0 Dec 18, 5:45pm
       Collapse Jimmy Nesbitt's kids Ham_Sammy 600 7 Dec 18, 5:48pm
           Collapse Tilda and Sigrid are a little bit more than cameos Crunchable Birdses 496 2 Dec 18, 7:26pm
               Collapse Just because... DigificWriter 483 1 Dec 18, 7:30pm
                   that's what i said - read the post that i was replying to :) Crunchable Birdses 459 0 Dec 18, 7:34pm
           Collapse Jimmy Nesbitt's kids MomoftheShire 190 3 Dec 20, 3:43am
               Collapse Awesome! Can you tell me where they show up, please? :) // grammaboodawg 137 2 Dec 21, 4:16am
                   Collapse They play Bard's two daughters. Silverlode 137 1 Dec 21, 4:52am
                       Seriously!? :D grammaboodawg 107 0 Dec 22, 1:25am
       Collapse Re #48 DisDwarfWoman 619 9 Dec 18, 5:50pm
           I also remember it as Bombur Elarie 553 0 Dec 18, 5:55pm
           Collapse Bombur // BlackFox 535 3 Dec 18, 5:55pm
               Collapse And IIRC... BlackFox 551 2 Dec 18, 5:57pm
                   Not sure... DisDwarfWoman 531 0 Dec 18, 6:05pm
                 Bomby theory..Bombur is their "Last line of Defense" of Erebor.. Bombadil 538 0 Dec 18, 6:10pm
           Collapse D'OH! You're Right! grammaboodawg 528 1 Dec 18, 6:32pm
               Smaug and the Master of Lake-town DigificWriter 535 0 Dec 18, 6:40pm
           Collapse Bombur swordwhale 218 1 Dec 19, 12:09am
               yep :) grammaboodawg 210 0 Dec 19, 5:34pm
       Bells Ham_Sammy 554 0 Dec 18, 6:04pm
       The return journey syameese 530 0 Dec 18, 6:51pm
       One very morbid observation BlackFox 597 0 Dec 18, 6:58pm
     Collapse I LOVE YOU Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 538 1 Dec 18, 7:03pm
           *blushes* Isn't this fun!? :D grammaboodawg 102 0 Dec 22, 4:10am
       Collapse Another BlackFox 517 1 Dec 18, 7:07pm
           Despite saying porr bilbo Im glad some give a real punch to some one during the battle Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 491 0 Dec 18, 7:16pm
       Collapse The Arkenstone appears to be one large radiant beautiful fire opal. elf_wannabee 463 3 Dec 18, 7:48pm
           Collapse Not based on the book DisDwarfWoman 320 1 Dec 18, 8:34pm
               Bain's sword DigificWriter 318 0 Dec 18, 8:47pm
           Without directing stating it…. ecthelionsbeard 205 0 Dec 19, 1:37am
       Collapse Through all three movies Oleander Took 384 7 Dec 18, 7:59pm
           Collapse He was eating a banana in AUJ Crunchable Birdses 348 4 Dec 18, 8:19pm
               Collapse Behind the scenes? Oleander Took 313 2 Dec 18, 8:33pm
                   Collapse Hmmmm...i honestly don't know now, maybe it was in an extra Crunchable Birdses 290 1 Dec 18, 8:45pm
                       I remember seeing Oleander Took 273 0 Dec 18, 9:39pm
               I dont remember this? When? macfalk 216 0 Dec 18, 11:41pm
           Collapse can't remember if he takes a bite FrogmortonJustice65 254 1 Dec 18, 10:02pm
               No BlackFox 251 0 Dec 18, 10:04pm
       The bunny on his back caught my eye as well! joec_34 354 0 Dec 18, 8:13pm
       Collapse some I remember Cirashala 308 15 Dec 18, 10:46pm
           Collapse My goodness, Cirashala! MatthewJer18 255 1 Dec 18, 10:47pm
               funnily enough Cirashala 238 0 Dec 18, 11:39pm
           Collapse awesome.... swordwhale 225 11 Dec 19, 12:32am
               Collapse WOW Cirashala 209 1 Dec 19, 12:37am
                   hee hee heee swordwhale 230 0 Dec 19, 1:55pm
               Collapse aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand.... swordwhale 210 1 Dec 19, 12:43am
                   cool, that didn't work (type pic of curb bit).... swordwhale 190 0 Dec 19, 12:44am
               Collapse Gandalf's horse is unlikely to be a Shire Starling 172 6 Dec 19, 4:13am
                   Collapse ah yes swordwhale 220 5 Dec 19, 1:33pm
                       Collapse The Stationbred Starling 173 4 Dec 20, 4:22am
                           Collapse wow swordwhale 145 3 Dec 20, 10:30pm
                               Collapse Not sure if anyone has noticed the wet, husky-mix-looking dog Brethil 117 2 Dec 21, 10:15pm
                                   Collapse need to go back and see it again... swordwhale 50 1 Dec 23, 6:17pm
                                       When the Master is leaving grammaboodawg 36 0 Wed, 1:35pm
           *massive high five* Fabulous! THANKS! :D // grammaboodawg 85 0 Dec 22, 4:43pm
       Collapse I just posted a bunch of mine yesterday. Silverlode 260 1 Dec 18, 11:39pm
           *staggers, swoons* So Cool! THANKS! // grammaboodawg 86 0 Dec 22, 4:42pm
       After 3rd viewing Ham_Sammy 205 0 Dec 19, 2:48am
       A few I haven't seen in this thread: SirDennisC 206 0 Dec 19, 4:02am
       Fili's final words... GloryBox 298 0 Dec 19, 5:07am
       The jar Ham_Sammy 255 0 Dec 19, 5:59am
       Ah, Gramma, I have been looking forward to this list! Riven Delve 247 0 Dec 19, 1:27pm
       It says June 22? Lily Fairbairn 224 0 Dec 19, 4:14pm
       *** This is GREAT! Keep 'em coming! grammaboodawg 221 0 Dec 19, 5:37pm
     Collapse **More of my Geeky Observations grammaboodawg 152 11 Dec 22, 4:46am
           Collapse Wonderful list! GloryBox 100 1 Dec 22, 6:40am
               YEP! You're right! grammaboodawg 72 0 Dec 22, 4:37pm
           Collapse A couple of comments BlackFox 107 2 Dec 22, 11:14am
               Collapse Excellent :) grammaboodawg 69 1 Dec 22, 4:38pm
                   My pleasure! BlackFox 85 0 Dec 22, 4:44pm
           Collapse And I'll add one BlackFox 95 1 Dec 22, 11:20am
               He's so hurt grammaboodawg 74 0 Dec 22, 4:40pm
           Collapse erm, gramma Cirashala 93 2 Dec 22, 8:05pm
               Collapse *squints at list* grammaboodawg 54 1 Dec 23, 2:34pm
                   you are very welcome! Cirashala 43 0 Dec 23, 6:56pm
           Another note Cirashala 80 0 Dec 22, 8:17pm
       Collapse Gloin Regal Armor gliido 85 1 Dec 22, 3:59pm
           That's so cool! grammaboodawg 93 0 Dec 22, 4:41pm
       Collapse Something random lionoferebor 77 1 Dec 23, 4:20am
           Thanks for pointing this out. GloryBox 67 0 Dec 23, 4:33am
     ***This is so Great!! :D*** grammaboodawg 42 0 Wed, 1:44pm
       Collapse A personal favorite Elarie 45 1 Wed, 5:09pm
           Good ones!!! :D THANKS! // grammaboodawg 16 0 Sun, 1:39am
       Collapse In Laketown Riven Delve 21 1 Sat, 5:05pm
           Yes! grammaboodawg 17 0 Sun, 1:41am
       My last bit of stuff to add grammaboodawg 10 0 7:16am

  Collapse Ny two film edit Elutherian 1438 69 Sat, 11:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by brotherbeck)
       Why... DigificWriter 828 0 Sat, 11:13pm
       I was just giving it a go... Bofur01 789 0 Sat, 11:14pm
       Project Danielos 748 0 Sat, 11:17pm
       Collapse I'm making a two film edit at the moment Beorn's Bees 786 52 Sat, 11:23pm
           Collapse Still baffled... DigificWriter 775 40 Sat, 11:28pm
               Collapse In my opinion Ham_Sammy 717 2 Sat, 11:38pm
                   Collapse Actually... DigificWriter 695 1 Sat, 11:40pm
                       That's what I meant Ham_Sammy 636 0 Sun, 12:00am
               Collapse because Me85 666 27 Sat, 11:55pm
                   Collapse Like it or not... DigificWriter 655 25 Sun, 12:00am
                       Collapse Has it ever occurred to you... Bofur01 650 23 Sun, 12:02am
                           Collapse Making changes... DigificWriter 630 19 Sun, 12:06am
                               I love the Hobbit films... Bofur01 617 0 Sun, 12:11am
                               Collapse Hmmm.... Morthoron 357 17 Sun, 3:58am
                                   Collapse People need to knock it off... DigificWriter 357 16 Sun, 4:16am
                                       Collapse I find it disrespectul to Tolkien, so I guess we're even... Morthoron 331 13 Sun, 5:41am
                                           Collapse Tauriel... DigificWriter 314 12 Sun, 6:09am
                                               Collapse I am uninterested in what you take seriously... Morthoron 305 3 Sun, 6:32am
                                                   Collapse Aragorn frenching his horse? Starling 276 2 Sun, 6:50am
                                                       Collapse It's after the Aragorn falling off a cliff and being lost for dead scene... Bladerunner 253 1 Sun, 7:23am
                                                           I was being completely sarcastic Starling 249 0 Sun, 7:29am
                                               Collapse Itaril/Tauriel... Bladerunner 262 7 Sun, 7:16am
                                                   Collapse A quick Google arithmancer 241 6 Sun, 2:52pm
                                                       The script rewrites... DigificWriter 233 0 Sun, 3:05pm
                                                       Collapse Thanks for the clarification... Bladerunner 184 4 Sun, 4:54pm
                                                           Collapse (Very Long) Thoughts On a Fan Edit brotherbeck 174 3 Sun, 6:11pm
                                                               I don't know.. glor 124 0 Sun, 9:53pm
                                                               It's not naive at all DigificWriter 117 0 Sun, 10:07pm
                                                               This redgiraffe 17 0 6:44am
                                     Collapse Agree – it is annoying and disrespectful, to put it mildly Glorfindela 256 1 Sun, 8:08am
                                           Perspective Michelle Johnston 196 0 Sun, 10:43am
                           Collapse trilogy Danielos 603 2 Sun, 12:11am
                               Me either Ham_Sammy 572 0 Sun, 12:24am
                             can I put, like swordwhale 306 0 Sun, 5:18am
                       well redgiraffe 55 0 3:20am
                   If it's a hobby folks enjoy then go for it. Spriggan 176 0 Sun, 10:48am
               Collapse Much more was added than the Carrock, Bree and forges AshNazg 48 8 5:12am
                   Collapse The EE Appendices... DigificWriter 41 7 5:22am
                       Collapse hmmmm redgiraffe 36 6 5:46am
                           Collapse Pick-up shoots... DigificWriter 31 5 5:59am
                               Collapse Yes redgiraffe 20 3 6:35am
                                   Collapse What do you mean by "the battle at the end"? DigificWriter 20 2 6:38am
                                       Collapse subject redgiraffe 17 1 6:45am
                                           Hmm... DigificWriter 14 0 6:47am
                               Dissenting Opinions brotherbeck 15 0 6:48am
           Collapse Short version: Elutherian 719 10 Sat, 11:31pm
               Collapse If it ain't broke, why fix it? DigificWriter 662 1 Sat, 11:35pm
                   They are broke though imin 225 0 Sun, 9:00am
               Collapse The thing is, the more you cut, the more difficult it gets. Bofur01 672 6 Sat, 11:35pm
                   Collapse Give me a while...... Elutherian 665 5 Sat, 11:37pm
                       Collapse Ok here it is... Elutherian 612 4 Sun, 12:28am
                           Could you still include Legolas... Bladerunner 538 0 Sun, 1:15am
                           I can dig that Ham_Sammy 510 0 Sun, 1:33am
                           I really want to see this when you're finished Gianna 367 0 Sun, 2:23am
                           I haven't cut Tauriel like you have! sycorax82 362 0 Sun, 3:03am
               I agree with you! elentari3018 211 0 Sun, 3:29pm
       Collapse I feel sorry for you guys... xxxyyy 662 2 Sun, 12:08am
           Collapse Just so you understand me... Bofur01 613 1 Sun, 12:14am
               Ah! Good good // xxxyyy 373 0 Sun, 1:48am
       It would be interesting... DigificWriter 397 0 Sun, 1:40am
       Me too! KateTheHobbit 364 0 Sun, 2:36am
       I've done a bit of this sort of thing myself pettytyrant101 366 0 Sun, 3:01am
       Collapse 2 Films how to arrive there Michelle Johnston 299 4 Sun, 7:02am
           Collapse I'm sorry but all of that sounds awful lurtz2010 192 3 Sun, 11:21am
               Collapse Thanks Michelle Johnston 178 2 Sun, 12:00pm
                   Collapse I think a bagend start is needed for Bilbo though.. moreorless 255 1 Sun, 1:16pm
                       Bag End for us but not so much for the wider audience Michelle Johnston 187 0 Sun, 4:54pm
       I wouldnt say its totally impossible.. moreorless 194 0 Sun, 10:51am
     I bet you Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 160 0 Sun, 1:00pm

  Collapse Balin and Dwalin Appreciation Thread DisDwarfWoman 629 24 Sat, 7:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by ecthelionsbeard)
       Collapse 8 haarp 373 1 Sat, 8:06pm
         now I wonder (or it haunts me) was the dwarflessness just for the kids? Avandel 46 0 12:38am
       Absolutely love those! Ham_Sammy 330 0 Sat, 8:55pm
       Collapse Don't forget Dwalin and Thorin Riven Delve 339 12 Sat, 9:34pm
           Love that one too! Ham_Sammy 293 0 Sat, 9:53pm
           Collapse haha, yes! DisDwarfWoman 272 9 Sat, 10:25pm
               Collapse Hee hee Riven Delve 254 1 Sat, 10:32pm
                   yep! DisDwarfWoman 245 0 Sat, 10:38pm
               Collapse It was Ham_Sammy 265 6 Sat, 10:33pm
                   Collapse That's cool! DisDwarfWoman 249 2 Sat, 10:39pm
                       Collapse Loebelia no doubt Ham_Sammy 241 1 Sat, 10:49pm
                           right... DisDwarfWoman 230 0 Sat, 10:55pm
                   Collapse Also acknowledging Dwalin's reaction... BlackCountry 153 2 Sun, 1:23pm
                       Such a terrible moment indeed... *sigh* mae govannen 138 0 Sun, 1:51pm
                       yes, can't forget about that DisDwarfWoman 113 0 Sun, 5:33pm
           loved that line! Old Toby 172 0 Sun, 6:42am
       yep........ swordwhale 183 0 Sun, 5:22am
       Collapse I agree! elentari3018 81 3 Sun, 9:21pm
           Collapse True! DisDwarfWoman 79 2 Sun, 9:46pm
               Collapse Funny thing... ecthelionsbeard 76 1 Sun, 9:50pm
                   That whole part for me, yeah. DisDwarfWoman 68 0 Sun, 10:41pm
       Collapse Enjoyed both of these guys throughout the trilogy... Salmacis81 61 2 Sun, 10:56pm
           Collapse Agree on the looks Ham_Sammy 29 1 2:38am
               The only ones who didn't look like dwarves to me... ecthelionsbeard 10 0 6:06am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 931 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.