Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 1048 (370647 posts in 15719 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1048 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (activity)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 197490 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 129565 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 41501 0 Oct 12 2014, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse Dwarves that don't look like dwarves... Gandalf the Green 819 131 Mon, 3:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by Gandalf the Green)
       Collapse 9 of 13? Otaku-sempai 683 17 Mon, 4:04pm
           Collapse Yes, what O-S said. Riven Delve 561 16 Mon, 6:00pm
               Collapse Fair enough... I know about the body movement thing. Gandalf the Green 552 15 Mon, 6:09pm
                   Collapse Prince Thorin Otaku-sempai 539 14 Mon, 6:30pm
                       Collapse A problem I have with that is... Gandalf the Green 534 13 Mon, 6:32pm
                           Collapse Looks like another instance of Peter Jackson messing up the timeline. ange1e4e5 532 11 Mon, 6:34pm
                               Yeah, heh.. Gandalf the Green 334 0 Mon, 6:36pm
                               Collapse He did, but... Otaku-sempai 323 9 Mon, 6:53pm
                                   Collapse Hmm... Gandalf the Green 311 8 Mon, 7:08pm
                                       Collapse Wow...no kidding? Otaku-sempai 300 7 Mon, 7:34pm
                                           Collapse At least, Gandalf the Green 279 6 Mon, 8:09pm
                                               Collapse Gray/white Smaug the iron 266 1 Mon, 8:32pm
                                                   - Gandalf the Green 260 0 Mon, 8:50pm
                                               Collapse Assumptions Otaku-sempai 261 3 Mon, 8:51pm
                                                   Collapse Would it apply to the movies? Gandalf the Green 252 2 Mon, 9:20pm
                                                       Collapse Longbeards = Durin's Folk Otaku-sempai 243 1 Mon, 9:32pm
                                                           Corrections Otaku-sempai 228 0 Mon, 9:54pm
                           Yeah... Otaku-sempai 329 0 Mon, 6:48pm
       Collapse They look like dwarves Lindele 678 18 Mon, 4:04pm
           Collapse Well, let's just say Gandalf the Green 656 1 Mon, 4:26pm
               They all look like dwarves to me... dormouse 642 0 Mon, 4:37pm
           Collapse I would think Tolkien has the final say MyWeeLadGimli 138 15 Tue, 5:21am
               Collapse In the books... ange1e4e5 271 2 Tue, 5:27am
                   Also! Nieriel 264 0 Tue, 5:33am
                   Merry and Pippin weren't naturally tall MyWeeLadGimli 254 0 Tue, 5:59am
               Collapse Um, no? TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 244 9 Tue, 6:48am
                   Collapse Reminds me LSF 236 8 Tue, 7:16am
                       Collapse Incomparable Gandalf the Green 218 7 Tue, 11:29am
                           Collapse I'd say it is... LSF 158 6 Tue, 4:19pm
                               Collapse Penguin suits Darkstone 140 4 Tue, 5:08pm
                                   Collapse instruments LSF 211 3 Tue, 7:00pm
                                       Collapse They wouldn't be able to traverse mountains with a wagon though. ange1e4e5 203 1 Tue, 7:01pm
                                           wagon LSF 194 0 Tue, 7:06pm
                                       Well Darkstone 171 0 Tue, 7:36pm
                               Characters don't need to look like "humans" to relate to them or to feel sad for them. Otherwise, explain why animal deaths are so saddening. Gandalf the Green 244 0 Tue, 6:05pm
               Collapse Agreed. Gandalf the Green 217 1 Tue, 11:34am
                   Cultural Assimilation? Otaku-sempai 179 0 Tue, 3:09pm
       Collapse What does a dwarf look like? dormouse 672 17 Mon, 4:18pm
           Collapse Beard shortening for pragmatic reasons ange1e4e5 666 2 Mon, 4:22pm
               Collapse - Gandalf the Green 635 1 Mon, 4:42pm
                   I will agree with you in part Kilidoescartwheels 209 0 Mon, 10:58pm
           Collapse A dwarf is hairy, wide, by no means skinny, and short, and far more than just a downsized human... Gandalf the Green 653 13 Mon, 4:31pm
               Collapse You're putting words into my mouth and theirs now.... dormouse 630 12 Mon, 4:54pm
                   Collapse Now you're just twisting things... Gandalf the Green 606 9 Mon, 5:14pm
                       Collapse I'll try just once more, very slowly.... dormouse 590 8 Mon, 5:27pm
                           - Gandalf the Green 572 0 Mon, 5:52pm
                           Collapse Well, dormouse... Otaku-sempai 337 6 Mon, 6:42pm
                               Collapse Sigh.... dormouse 309 1 Mon, 7:21pm
                                   I did read the previous posts Otaku-sempai 300 0 Mon, 7:38pm
                               Collapse But they WERE stockier Kilidoescartwheels 208 3 Mon, 11:13pm
                                   Collapse Hey! I'm on your side! Otaku-sempai 202 2 Mon, 11:24pm
                                       Collapse Sorry, must have linked to the wrong post Kilidoescartwheels 161 1 Tue, 2:41am
                                           S'all right. // Otaku-sempai 149 0 Tue, 3:22am
                   Collapse On beards Darkstone 602 1 Mon, 5:17pm
                       Well Smaug the iron 580 0 Mon, 5:42pm
       Collapse I can't see the image but I disagree Noria 657 6 Mon, 4:27pm
           Collapse "real population" LSF 644 5 Mon, 4:37pm
               Collapse Yes you can. Gandalf the Green 630 4 Mon, 4:51pm
                   Collapse Yes, they didn't have to LSF 612 3 Mon, 5:05pm
                       Collapse But in the process, they did sacrifice time, as well as believability for many that these were actually.. y'know, dwarves like Gimli... Gandalf the Green 597 2 Mon, 5:23pm
                           Collapse On beard length and dwarf diversity Ilmatar 142 1 Wed, 9:56pm
                               Fair enough Gandalf the Green 15 0 9:02pm
       Collapse ... StingingFly 187 1 Tue, 12:14am
           Yeah... Otaku-sempai 154 0 Tue, 3:21am
       Collapse The discussion that never dies... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 188 34 Tue, 12:37am
           People can relate to Balin MyWeeLadGimli 141 0 Tue, 5:11am
           Collapse But dwarves ARE hairy little men with huge noses... Gandalf the Green 223 32 Tue, 11:26am
               Collapse Gimli Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 212 28 Tue, 12:05pm
                   Collapse Aesthetically Gandalf the Green 208 27 Tue, 12:34pm
                       Collapse Yes but Gandalf and Gimli are two people Smaug the iron 207 1 Tue, 12:50pm
                           Thirteen or eight or five Gimlis would have been boring IMO. Noria 194 0 Tue, 1:31pm
                       Collapse Well, Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 181 24 Tue, 3:13pm
                           Collapse Consistency Gandalf the Green 170 23 Tue, 4:01pm
                               It IS still about the story Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 150 0 Tue, 4:35pm
                               Collapse Where? Smaug the iron 141 10 Tue, 5:08pm
                                   Collapse Not Thorin, and not typical Dwarves either Darkstone 130 9 Tue, 5:22pm
                                       Collapse Thought that Dain's people were also Thorin's people, or Dain was very close ange1e4e5 131 3 Tue, 5:24pm
                                           Collapse Ask Tolkien Darkstone 251 2 Tue, 6:03pm
                                               Collapse Thorin had closer relations than Dain, there was Balin, Dwalin, Oin and Gloin. ange1e4e5 106 1 Wed, 2:02am
                                                   Just the opposite Darkstone 90 0 Wed, 4:46am
                                       Collapse Dwarves of the Iron Hills Otaku-sempai 122 4 Tue, 5:40pm
                                           Collapse But... Darkstone 111 3 Tue, 5:49pm
                                               Collapse Yes Otaku-sempai 107 2 Tue, 5:56pm
                                                   Collapse But... Darkstone 241 1 Tue, 6:11pm
                                                       True... Otaku-sempai 213 0 Tue, 6:49pm
                               Collapse If someone were to take a picture of you standing with your father.... dormouse 139 10 Tue, 5:12pm
                                   Collapse Interpretations Gandalf the Green 232 9 Tue, 6:19pm
                                       Collapse No Smaug the iron 222 5 Tue, 6:41pm
                                           Collapse Yes Gandalf the Green 200 4 Tue, 7:02pm
                                               Bombur apparently relies on a large ladle as a weapon and at one point bumps a goblin to his death with his girth. ange1e4e5 194 0 Tue, 7:06pm
                                               Collapse weapons LSF 190 1 Tue, 7:11pm
                                                   Yeah, pretty much. Otaku-sempai 184 0 Tue, 7:19pm
                                               Alright Smaug the iron 168 0 Tue, 7:56pm
                                       Collapse So.... dormouse 172 1 Tue, 7:59pm
                                           At the very least TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 150 0 Tue, 10:24pm
                                       Tolkien's eyebrow revision Elthir 215 0 Wed, 4:23pm
               Collapse And THAT might be the problem Kilidoescartwheels 238 2 Tue, 6:18pm
                   Collapse Well Gandalf the Green 232 1 Tue, 6:26pm
                       What Balin said Kilidoescartwheels 135 0 Tue, 11:04pm
       Collapse This quote sums up why some of us care about the beard lack MyWeeLadGimli 113 28 Wed, 1:51am
           Collapse This is never stated in the films TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 106 27 Wed, 2:14am
               Collapse It kind of is in the movies MyWeeLadGimli 93 26 Wed, 4:39am
                   Collapse No, that is not true TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 288 25 Wed, 5:32am
                       Collapse I guess we have different views of adaptation MyWeeLadGimli 287 22 Wed, 5:43am
                           That would be well within your rights to do so TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 275 0 Wed, 6:11am
                           Collapse Well, it's an interesting thought... dormouse 264 19 Wed, 9:37am
                               Collapse Tolkien and adaptations Otaku-sempai 218 16 Wed, 4:32pm
                                   Yes.... dormouse 199 0 Wed, 5:05pm
                                   Collapse "Art or Cash" Darkstone 189 14 Wed, 5:35pm
                                       Collapse The Hobbit? Otaku-sempai 184 13 Wed, 5:58pm
                                           Collapse LOTR Darkstone 174 12 Wed, 6:36pm
                                               Collapse I still don't see a problem. Otaku-sempai 171 11 Wed, 7:01pm
                                                   Collapse Caveat venditor Darkstone 147 10 Wed, 9:55pm
                                                       Collapse Okay... Otaku-sempai 137 4 Wed, 10:32pm
                                                           Collapse Well, yeah Darkstone 128 3 Wed, 10:51pm
                                                               Collapse Let's just...let it go-ooo... Otaku-sempai 122 2 Wed, 11:01pm
                                                                   Collapse You misunderstand. Darkstone 120 1 Wed, 11:25pm
                                                                       No, no! Otaku-sempai 150 0 Thu, 12:32am
                                                       Collapse IMO it doesn’t matter if Tolkien thought that his books could not be turned into films. Noria 103 4 Thu, 4:13pm
                                                           Collapse Exactly! Otaku-sempai 94 3 Thu, 4:49pm
                                                               Collapse minor aside on concept art Elthir 60 2 1:45pm
                                                                   Yes Voronwë_the_Faithful 53 0 2:01pm
                                                                   Rackham or not Rackham - LotR Adaptation Otaku-sempai 33 0 5:51pm
                               Collapse a couple others... LSF 195 1 Wed, 5:18pm
                                   Planet of the Apes (1968) Darkstone 181 0 Wed, 5:45pm
                           I recommend John Irving's "My Movie Business: A Memoir" Darkstone 242 0 Wed, 2:22pm
                       Collapse Well... Gandalf the Green 254 1 Wed, 12:55pm
                           It’s really too bad that the visuals of these movies are not to your liking, but that all that means is that you personally don’t like them. Noria 230 0 Wed, 3:33pm
       Collapse Shoulda Deep Royed it! Darkstone 143 2 Wed, 10:15pm
           Collapse orcs LSF 136 1 Wed, 10:28pm
               Good choice. Darkstone 129 0 Wed, 10:38pm

  Collapse BOFA Denial Association? HOBBITFAN13 439 11 Thu, 4:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       There are two divisions. Darkstone 419 0 Thu, 4:18pm
     Collapse And the River folks LOL Avandel 387 9 Thu, 5:20pm
           Collapse We're all in Egypt Kilidoescartwheels 364 8 Thu, 5:37pm
             Collapse What? Avandel 282 7 Thu, 10:14pm
                   Collapse Sorry to disappoint you... Queen of Erebor 259 1 Thu, 10:55pm
                       Questionable fanfics Kilidoescartwheels 206 0 1:24am
                   Collapse Well, let's get this party (barge) started! Kilidoescartwheels 211 4 1:15am
                       Collapse Well, for now.... Avandel 186 3 2:46am
                           Collapse Valentine's link Ilmatar 106 1 12:52pm
                             Thank you!!! (: re the link repost! - whoops.... Avandel 50 0 5:47pm
                           Was it mentioned Bracegirdle 102 0 1:05pm

  Collapse How old is Beorn? DainPig 163 4 Thu, 8:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Beorn Otaku-sempai 155 0 Thu, 9:08pm
       Collapse Well... ThorinsNemesis 143 2 Thu, 9:34pm
           several hundred years LSF 131 0 Thu, 10:06pm
           Beorn's Enchantment Otaku-sempai 95 0 3:00am

  Collapse Dwarves that don't ACT like dwarves? Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 535 32 Tue, 7:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Gloin probably exemplified dwarves the best ange1e4e5 484 0 Tue, 7:20pm
       Collapse Mostly okay... Otaku-sempai 471 2 Tue, 7:34pm
           Collapse Best & worst "Dwarvish" qualities Kilidoescartwheels 442 1 Tue, 8:20pm
               Comic Effect Otaku-sempai 434 0 Tue, 8:31pm
       Gloin Gandalf the Green 447 0 Tue, 8:09pm
       Collapse What do Dwarves act like? Kilidoescartwheels 449 5 Tue, 8:12pm
           Collapse Well... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 428 1 Tue, 8:42pm
               But they are FIGHTERS! Kilidoescartwheels 97 0 Thu, 5:46pm
           Collapse Bit harsh. Bumblingidiot 381 2 Tue, 11:34pm
               Collapse Er, um, sure! Kilidoescartwheels 348 1 Wed, 12:57am
                   But how good are they? ange1e4e5 341 0 Wed, 1:05am
       Collapse The only issues I have.... dormouse 447 2 Tue, 8:18pm
           And then there's Dain! Kilidoescartwheels 430 0 Tue, 8:36pm
           Aww, I don't want to knock them and be harsh and negative... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 426 0 Tue, 8:49pm
       They all act like dwarves LSF 440 0 Tue, 8:30pm
       For me Glorfindela 364 0 Wed, 12:34am
       According to Tolkien... MyWeeLadGimli 335 0 Wed, 1:41am
       Collapse I think the movies did a good job Elarie 331 3 Wed, 1:53am
         Collapse Nicely said IMO and will add Avandel 204 2 Wed, 11:07pm
               Collapse Ooooh, I'd LUV to see that bust! Kilidoescartwheels 97 1 Thu, 5:43pm
                   You've probably seen it.... Avandel 46 0 Thu, 10:33pm
       Collapse Compared to the Rankin-Bass film Kilidoescartwheels 94 10 Thu, 5:53pm
           Collapse Reader's Digest version Otaku-sempai 95 9 Thu, 6:01pm
               Collapse Yep! DainPig 69 8 Thu, 8:32pm
                   Collapse Yes. Otaku-sempai 67 7 Thu, 8:38pm
                       Collapse What about the lakemen? DainPig 81 3 Thu, 8:44pm
                           Collapse Lake-men and Wizards Otaku-sempai 76 2 Thu, 8:56pm
                               Collapse No, I mean DainPig 72 1 Thu, 9:08pm
                                   Missing the brim of Gandalf's hat. Otaku-sempai 68 0 Thu, 9:13pm
                       Collapse Perhaps Rankin/Bass wanted to differentiate the Wood-elves from the High Elves like Elrond. ange1e4e5 66 2 Thu, 9:20pm
                           Makes sense DainPig 61 0 Thu, 9:29pm
                           Elrond Halfelven, half something else No One in Particular 53 0 Thu, 10:03pm

  Collapse Rotten Tomatoes for The Hobbit? HOBBITFAN13 710 38 Feb 7, 7:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse I think they all should be higher TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 655 6 Feb 7, 7:17pm
           Collapse EE of DOS is a masterpiece Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 402 5 Mon, 3:09pm
               Collapse Could have done without the Wilhelm Scream from Thrain when Sauron kills him. ange1e4e5 394 1 Mon, 3:35pm
                   Not all the drama for me Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 390 0 Mon, 3:37pm
               Collapse Hmm. Speaking of Thrain... Gandalf the Green 382 2 Mon, 3:49pm
                   Collapse wouldn't say unresolved LSF 369 1 Mon, 4:07pm
                       - Gandalf the Green 245 0 Mon, 5:45pm
       Collapse To be fair... Gandalf the Green 620 2 Feb 7, 9:29pm
           Collapse That would mean they're worse than most films MyWeeLadGimli 606 1 Feb 7, 10:00pm
               Well... Gandalf the Green 471 0 Mon, 10:40am
       I think HeadingSouth 586 0 Sun, 10:36pm
       Collapse If I was being really mean with the marks.... dormouse 571 5 Sun, 11:53pm
           Collapse So, HeadingSouth 546 3 Mon, 2:00am
               Collapse Yes dormouse 482 2 Mon, 9:26am
                   Collapse No problem, HeadingSouth 174 1 Mon, 10:35pm
                       Yes... dormouse 164 0 Mon, 11:06pm
           If I was overlord of all critic's reviews (lol) TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 531 0 Mon, 3:05am
       Collapse What's inerseting... Darkstone 432 18 Mon, 2:02pm
           Collapse And what, would you say... Gandalf the Green 428 15 Mon, 2:39pm
               Collapse Easy... dormouse 377 13 Mon, 4:02pm
                   Collapse You mean... LSF 368 4 Mon, 4:14pm
                       You'd be surprized... Darkstone 362 0 Mon, 4:20pm
                       Collapse What is the world coming to...... dormouse 356 1 Mon, 4:24pm
                           Yeah, Tolkien is srs bsns!! Darkstone 320 0 Mon, 5:07pm
                       Easily Otaku-sempai 220 0 Mon, 6:44pm
                   Collapse Obviously... Darkstone 337 7 Mon, 4:54pm
                       Collapse - Gandalf the Green 251 6 Mon, 5:43pm
                           Collapse Add-on Gandalf the Green 237 5 Mon, 6:21pm
                               Collapse Enjoyable but bad movies. ange1e4e5 235 3 Mon, 6:24pm
                                   Yeah, Gandalf the Green 230 0 Mon, 6:26pm
                                   Collapse Xanadu (1980) Darkstone 227 1 Mon, 6:38pm
                                       Yes, Gandalf the Green 214 0 Mon, 7:07pm
                               Well, everyone's response is different...... Avandel 32 0 Thu, 4:45pm
               Simple Darkstone 366 0 Mon, 4:17pm
           Collapse I think its down to the shift to net based criticism personally moreorless 129 1 Tue, 11:36am
               IMO nicely said - agree Avandel 37 0 Thu, 4:18pm
       Artificially Lower Score jlj93byu 336 0 Mon, 4:50pm
       My rating HOBBITFAN13 191 0 Mon, 8:34pm

Collapse The Hobbit films at theaters bumbaroo_1 326 6 Tue, 6:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elessar)
       Collapse Well, they do occasionally re-show the LoTR movies Kilidoescartwheels 292 2 Tue, 6:23pm
           Collapse Thing is, Gandalf the Green 287 1 Tue, 6:31pm
               I believe they stand a great chance of being considered classics in time TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 253 0 Tue, 10:07pm
       Collapse I do think they will be Elessar 169 2 Wed, 2:35pm
           Collapse Agree tho I think they need to do better PR Avandel 112 1 Wed, 10:29pm
               Agreed Elessar 64 0 Thu, 3:07pm

  Collapse BOFA EE better or worse? HOBBITFAN13 672 16 Feb 6, 5:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       Better Smaug the iron 628 0 Feb 6, 6:21pm
       Collapse Emphatically better in all respects.... dormouse 615 4 Feb 6, 6:53pm
           Collapse I'm wondering... LSF 606 1 Feb 6, 6:59pm
               Michael Bay? ange1e4e5 605 0 Feb 6, 7:00pm
           Collapse Spot-on as usual Dormouse KingTurgon 447 1 Feb 7, 3:43am
               Thanks! dormouse 412 0 Feb 7, 8:56am
       Everything better LSF 608 0 Feb 6, 6:57pm
       Several shades better TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 607 0 Feb 6, 7:02pm
       Better. OldestDaughter 598 0 Feb 6, 7:09pm
       Don't you count Legolas suspended at a bat and killing eighty orcs Milieuterrien 579 0 Feb 6, 7:41pm
       Overall Better MyWeeLadGimli 520 0 Feb 6, 11:03pm
       Immeasurably better// Nieriel 502 0 Feb 6, 11:22pm
       Collapse Much better Noria 378 1 Feb 7, 2:15pm
           available on DVD bumbaroo_1 206 0 Tue, 6:16pm
       Better Elessar 152 0 Wed, 2:36pm
       For me, I think it helped even out the film and improved the viewing experience. Eruonen 103 0 Thu, 4:33am

  Collapse What would Tolkien think of the Hobbit films? HOBBITFAN13 786 66 Feb 5, 1:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by Hamfast Gamgee)
       Hm. Fereth 704 0 Feb 5, 2:03pm
       That no one knows, that no one knows, and no one ever will.... dormouse 700 0 Feb 5, 2:12pm
       Well Darkstone 698 0 Feb 5, 2:26pm
       It doesn't really matter; I'll bite anyhow TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 697 0 Feb 5, 2:27pm
       Collapse My Guess? Otaku-sempai 677 1 Feb 5, 3:35pm
           My opinion ange1e4e5 667 0 Feb 5, 3:52pm
       Well Smaug the iron 655 0 Feb 5, 4:52pm
       Reply: HeadingSouth 572 0 Feb 5, 10:01pm
       Collapse Let's not mince words... Morthoron 542 48 Feb 6, 1:29am
           I have to say, HeadingSouth 534 0 Feb 6, 1:44am
           Collapse Eviscerated ? Milieuterrien 478 45 Feb 6, 9:39am
               Collapse Eviscerated. Gandalf the Green 470 37 Feb 6, 10:51am
                   Collapse Receipes Milieuterrien 463 36 Feb 6, 11:34am
                       Collapse It appears you are unwaware... Morthoron 416 35 Feb 6, 2:42pm
                           Collapse it appears that I'm aware Milieuterrien 408 34 Feb 6, 2:50pm
                               Collapse Publishers, not editors... Morthoron 397 33 Feb 6, 3:11pm
                                   Sorry but, Milieuterrien 389 0 Feb 6, 3:35pm
                                   Collapse In fact, LotR consists of six books. Otaku-sempai 333 31 Feb 6, 8:44pm
                                       Collapse Those were apparently suggestions sent to the publisher Milieuterrien 315 30 Feb 6, 9:03pm
                                           Collapse Um...no. Otaku-sempai 304 29 Feb 6, 9:13pm
                                               Collapse My sources Milieuterrien 298 28 Feb 6, 9:23pm
                                                   Collapse Stuff your sources. Otaku-sempai 295 27 Feb 6, 9:43pm
                                                       Collapse If there are no individual book titles Milieuterrien 286 24 Feb 6, 10:03pm
                                                           Collapse Wha??? Otaku-sempai 277 23 Feb 6, 10:10pm
                                                               Collapse You introduce 'books', I jump on the 'Book' wagon Milieuterrien 261 19 Feb 6, 10:34pm
                                                                   Collapse Back to the Films Otaku-sempai 254 18 Feb 6, 10:49pm
                                                                       Collapse Exactly, HeadingSouth 244 4 Feb 6, 11:02pm
                                                                           Collapse But they are Smaug the iron 236 3 Feb 6, 11:42pm
                                                                               Collapse It really isn't, HeadingSouth 213 2 Feb 7, 12:17am
  Collapse I think The Children of Hurin expanded on the battles part, particularly with the Nirnaeth Arnoediad. ange1e4e5 210 1 Feb 7, 12:18am
       Yes, HeadingSouth 199 0 Feb 7, 12:31am
                                                                       Collapse That's where we differ Milieuterrien 238 12 Feb 6, 11:43pm
                                                                           Collapse You are mistaken... Otaku-sempai 225 11 Feb 7, 12:00am
                                                                               Collapse What you call 'additions' are interpretations Milieuterrien 194 10 Feb 7, 12:53am
  Collapse Pretty much, HeadingSouth 186 6 Feb 7, 1:19am
       Collapse Facing negative generalities as usual Milieuterrien 176 5 Feb 7, 1:35am
           Collapse Why do you find it so hard to accept HeadingSouth 168 2 Feb 7, 1:36am
               Collapse Well, the fact that someone managed to get such an ambitious project off the ground (The Lord of the Rings) and have the critics and public like it. ange1e4e5 162 1 Feb 7, 1:44am
                   So because some critics and the general audience like it, HeadingSouth 159 0 Feb 7, 1:47am
           Collapse Wait...what? Morthoron 145 1 Feb 7, 2:28am
               I'm leaving this board Milieuterrien 276 0 Feb 7, 2:46am
  Collapse Ch-ch-ch-changes Otaku-sempai 177 2 Feb 7, 1:31am
       Collapse Well Smaug the iron 240 1 Feb 7, 8:06am
           The Stone-giants. Otaku-sempai 233 0 Feb 7, 8:19am
                                                               Collapse As a matter of interest - geordie 188 2 Feb 7, 6:58pm
                                                                   As a further matter of interest - geordie 179 0 Feb 7, 7:10pm
                                                                   Thanks. Otaku-sempai 171 0 Feb 7, 7:20pm
                                                       Collapse just a quick note - geordie 191 1 Feb 7, 6:50pm
                                                           Thanks for the correction. Otaku-sempai 174 0 Feb 7, 7:14pm
               Collapse Credit where credit is due. Otaku-sempai 433 6 Feb 6, 1:30pm
                   Collapse If credit is to put where credit is due Milieuterrien 414 3 Feb 6, 2:43pm
                       Collapse Nonetheless... Otaku-sempai 325 1 Feb 6, 8:50pm
                           Christopher has HeadingSouth 275 0 Feb 6, 10:09pm
                       Christopher's sons are called Simon and Adam geordie 195 0 Feb 7, 6:47pm
                   Collapse Yes, I think he would like them TaliaEmerald 85 1 Wed, 1:30am
                       Well... Otaku-sempai 80 0 Wed, 3:33am
           You nailed it! hamlet 327 0 Feb 6, 8:48pm
       Collapse I think Silverlode 533 1 Feb 6, 2:01am
           I think you're right... dormouse 217 0 Feb 7, 2:45pm
       Collapse To answer the question Milieuterrien 457 1 Feb 6, 11:50am
           And sensitive treat Milieuterrien 428 0 Feb 6, 1:42pm
       Collapse Well, to answer Hamfast Gamgee 152 3 Mon, 12:05am
           Collapse Funny, that.... dormouse 146 2 Mon, 9:53am
               According to Appendix A, ange1e4e5 127 0 Mon, 3:14pm
               Yes, I guess you are right Hamfast Gamgee 41 0 Thu, 12:43am
       I think he'd like some and not like some Elessar 57 0 Wed, 2:49pm

  Collapse Why not a boar? DainPig 364 14 Tue, 3:21am Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse Yeah... Otaku-sempai 337 2 Tue, 3:23am
           Collapse Same here ange1e4e5 335 1 Tue, 3:23am
               You mean, his mustache? DainPig 331 0 Tue, 3:31am
       PJ Mooseboy018 311 0 Tue, 4:51am
       Collapse Completely agree Earl 297 1 Tue, 5:33am
           I think that would be PJ Avandel 266 0 Tue, 8:12am
       PJ fel in love with a pig. Smaug the iron 279 0 Tue, 7:35am
       Collapse I like it LSF 273 2 Tue, 7:42am
           Collapse Exactly. Fereth 200 1 Tue, 2:01pm
             LOL, that's the fun of it - agree! Avandel 63 0 Wed, 10:22pm
       Why not a pig? dormouse 252 0 Tue, 9:43am
       Boar versus pig Noria 214 0 Tue, 1:08pm
       I think a pig worked better against the wood elves... moreorless 180 0 Tue, 4:28pm
       Hey Dain, been awhile! Kilidoescartwheels 131 0 Tue, 8:39pm

  Collapse Unpopular Hobbit trilogy opinions? jackster 780 33 Feb 6, 8:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       Opinion HOBBITFAN13 699 0 Feb 6, 8:37pm
       I think the poo is a nice touch to Radagast's bird nest hairdo BlackFox 679 0 Feb 6, 9:27pm
       Collapse I think there should have been more singing MyWeeLadGimli 631 4 Feb 6, 11:11pm
           Collapse Imagine if animals talked when Bilbo put on the Ring... AshNazg 610 3 Feb 6, 11:47pm
               Collapse That Wouldn't work for Roac MyWeeLadGimli 534 2 Feb 7, 6:44am
                   Collapse Ravens do speak in real life... AshNazg 444 1 Feb 7, 4:06pm
                       The Ravens of Erebor Otaku-sempai 438 0 Feb 7, 4:21pm
       Collapse Mine: TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 549 2 Feb 7, 6:38am
           I agree Noria 475 0 Feb 7, 2:16pm
           Hear, hear! dormouse 469 0 Feb 7, 2:20pm
       Collapse Mine LSF 540 2 Feb 7, 6:46am
           Collapse Ooo! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 531 1 Feb 7, 6:59am
               Alfrid's death LSF 530 0 Feb 7, 7:03am
       Nice job- I like this posts grimbeorn15 456 0 Feb 7, 3:08pm
       Mine: malickfan 425 0 Feb 7, 5:53pm
       My opinions ThorinsNemesis 409 0 Feb 7, 6:27pm
       Collapse For what it's worth Nieriel 355 4 Feb 7, 9:59pm
           Collapse LOL Avandel 333 3 Mon, 12:17am
               Moose Nieriel 310 0 Mon, 1:35am
               Collapse My unpopular opinion (maybe) Fereth 310 1 Mon, 2:08am
                   Amen to that! Kilidoescartwheels 215 0 Mon, 10:32pm
       Collapse My unpopular opinions Kilidoescartwheels 219 2 Mon, 10:38pm
           ^You're not the only one... ThorinsNemesis 208 0 Mon, 10:53pm
           I like the stone giants scene too Avandel 134 0 Tue, 7:29am
       Collapse I wish they had included some "O! tra-la-la-lally" RosieLass 197 2 Tue, 12:39am
           Collapse And Beorn's serving animals? // Voronwë_the_Faithful 155 1 Tue, 12:58am
               Sure, why not? // RosieLass 105 0 Wed, 6:08am
       Collapse Just liking the films Elessar 103 4 Wed, 2:30pm
           Collapse How right you are! :-) // dormouse 86 2 Wed, 3:28pm
               On liking The Hobbit films ange1e4e5 90 0 Wed, 3:35pm
               Thought you might like that one. lol Elessar 72 0 Wed, 4:31pm
           Too true, too true. // BlackFox 43 0 Wed, 10:07pm
       Yes liking the movies sometimes seems like an unpopular opinion here. Noria 82 0 Wed, 3:59pm

  Collapse Dori's Role MyWeeLadGimli 385 11 Feb 6, 11:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ilmatar)
       Collapse On Dori ange1e4e5 351 4 Feb 6, 11:16pm
           Yes, there wasn't much room for a chaperon to Bilbo Milieuterrien 323 0 Feb 7, 12:16am
           Collapse On Dori being fussy... Ilmatar 166 2 Mon, 5:51pm
               Collapse Well Smaug the iron 161 1 Mon, 6:08pm
                   Thank you Ilmatar 41 0 Wed, 10:04pm
       Dori Smaug the iron 329 0 Feb 7, 12:12am
       Collapse Yeah... Otaku-sempai 302 1 Feb 7, 1:39am
           Lots of people loved Bofur Milieuterrien 290 0 Feb 7, 2:09am
       Collapse Just the way it worked out, I think.... dormouse 107 1 Tue, 10:04am
           Bofur Thorinshield 84 0 Tue, 5:27pm
       mostly casting, I think LSF 79 0 Tue, 5:38pm

  Collapse can't wait for the generation that watches all 6 in chronological order makingstarwars 1806 67 Jan 15, 12:45pm Jump to last post in thread (by verdealex79)
       and of course (my edit button disappeared sorry) makingstarwars 1631 0 Jan 15, 1:32pm
       I am very much Lindele 1606 0 Jan 15, 2:35pm
       Made me smile :) Gianna 1605 0 Jan 15, 2:38pm
       Collapse ... StingingFly 1313 2 Jan 17, 6:11pm
           Don't think so. Smaug the iron 1300 0 Jan 17, 6:31pm
           Well, I wouldn't feel too sad.... dormouse 1277 0 Jan 17, 7:03pm
       Collapse I will go to my grave pushing for publication/release order in ALL things... Aragorn the Elfstone 1297 5 Jan 17, 6:51pm
           Collapse It's a fair point... dormouse 1268 3 Jan 17, 7:12pm
               Collapse Well, the books are the books and the films are the films... Aragorn the Elfstone 1265 2 Jan 17, 7:38pm
                   Collapse The films do work as a whole for me, but..... dormouse 1258 1 Jan 17, 7:43pm
                       Yes to appendices in this order TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1212 0 Jan 17, 10:43pm
           Disagree KingTurgon 238 0 Jan 30, 7:27am
     That'll be me over the next evening or two squiggle 1197 0 Jan 17, 11:36pm
       Collapse I'll be warning the next generation... Avnar 1072 43 Jan 19, 1:53am
           Or you might just trust them to make their own judgement... // dormouse 1019 0 Jan 19, 11:37am
           Collapse At least for the next generation in my family Goldeneye 1005 40 Jan 19, 3:41pm
               Collapse And people wonder why I don't condone these practices... TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 911 5 Jan 19, 9:49pm
                   Collapse I put Elessar 515 4 Jan 20, 6:18pm
                       Collapse I'm going to pretend I didn't hear that. Aragorn the Elfstone 507 3 Jan 20, 6:24pm
                           Collapse Sorry man Elessar 395 2 Jan 20, 11:34pm
                               Collapse I'm glad the Oscar voters didn't agree with you... Aragorn the Elfstone 395 1 Jan 20, 11:39pm
                                   I wish they had. Elessar 363 0 Jan 21, 4:18am
               Collapse ... Anubis 522 27 Jan 20, 6:07pm
                   Collapse Fair enough Goldeneye 496 26 Jan 20, 6:44pm
                       Collapse Except your spliced up "edit"... Aragorn the Elfstone 495 25 Jan 20, 6:57pm
                           Collapse Yes Goldeneye 486 24 Jan 20, 7:05pm
                               Collapse You are taking credit for Peter Jackson and co.'s work TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 469 23 Jan 20, 8:27pm
                                   Collapse Ha Goldeneye 454 22 Jan 20, 8:57pm
                                       Collapse That's not what I said TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 446 20 Jan 20, 9:13pm
                                           Collapse Yes Goldeneye 445 19 Jan 20, 9:20pm
                                               You know... ThorinsNemesis 434 0 Jan 20, 9:32pm
                                               Collapse If Lindele 430 16 Jan 20, 9:38pm
                                                   Collapse ... Goldeneye 420 15 Jan 20, 10:02pm
                                                       Collapse I read and loved the Hobbit book way before the movies came out.. ThorinsNemesis 416 14 Jan 20, 10:16pm
                                                           Sure he is Milieuterrien 602 0 Jan 21, 3:19pm
                                                           Collapse This! Jeffrodo 434 12 Jan 25, 4:17pm
                                                               Collapse Bloat Otaku-sempai 417 2 Jan 25, 8:23pm
                                                                   Collapse My kids will be raised with LotR, sauget.diblosio 389 1 Jan 26, 9:40am
                                                                       Don't get me wrong... Otaku-sempai 377 0 Jan 26, 3:04pm
                                                               Collapse Less is more. Gandalf the Green 229 8 Jan 30, 9:49am
                                                                   Wait, or - OR! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 188 0 Jan 31, 10:18pm
                                                                   Collapse Or maybe they just enjoyed the films.... dormouse 167 1 Feb 1, 8:49am
                                                                       What dormouse and TheOnlyOne said Noria 152 0 Feb 1, 1:45pm
                                                                   Collapse Not necessarily Omnigeek 145 4 Feb 1, 2:43pm
                                                                       Collapse Do you always object to things you don't understand? dormouse 136 3 Feb 1, 3:45pm
                                                                           Collapse Nope Omnigeek 132 2 Feb 1, 4:00pm
                                                                               Collapse Returning to the screening order, Milieuterrien 126 1 Feb 1, 4:24pm
  These are wonderful films. verdealex79 29 0 Wed, 10:05am
                                               So you will keep in the torturing of the orc by Beorn in the book Milieuterrien 317 0 Jan 21, 2:59pm
                                       Just a question Smaug the iron 430 0 Jan 20, 9:40pm
               ............ ThorinsNemesis 501 0 Jan 20, 6:28pm
               Collapse Yeah... no... LSF 460 4 Jan 20, 8:42pm
                   Collapse Sorry Goldeneye 447 3 Jan 20, 9:09pm
                       That's where we defintely differ LSF 434 0 Jan 20, 9:29pm
                       Collapse Again, you're under the mistaken belief... Aragorn the Elfstone 415 1 Jan 20, 10:15pm
                           The key right here! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 355 0 Jan 21, 6:10am
           Really? KingTurgon 239 0 Jan 30, 7:22am
       Collapse Watch LOTR first Jeffrodo 989 3 Jan 19, 4:05pm
           Collapse I think we've been given a rare opportunity Lindele 982 2 Jan 19, 4:29pm
               Collapse I see Jeffrodo 975 1 Jan 19, 4:33pm
                   I see that Lindele 968 0 Jan 19, 4:39pm
       Chronological order LSF 961 0 Jan 19, 4:43pm
       I will be curious to see Elessar 947 0 Jan 19, 5:31pm
       Or else... Darkstone 944 0 Jan 19, 6:02pm
       The Order of Films QuiteALittleFellow 895 0 Jan 19, 10:05pm
       Collapse Publication/release order for me Omnigeek 313 1 Jan 28, 3:43am
           *Shriek!!!* Aragorn the Elfstone 287 0 Jan 28, 9:38pm

  Collapse Scooby Do Smaug Chase StingingFly 318 6 Feb 7, 6:45pm Jump to last post in thread (by TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense)
       Dr. Strange? Kilidoescartwheels 181 0 Mon, 10:43pm
       Collapse Barliman Butterbur Darkstone 179 1 Mon, 11:02pm
           Excellent! StingingFly 152 0 Tue, 12:19am
       Gandalf... AshNazg 97 0 Tue, 6:32pm
       Collapse ... StingingFly 70 1 Wed, 2:13am
           Balin: Is that... a mask? TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 66 0 Wed, 2:45am

  Collapse Trivia: Durin's Day according to Bard's Calendar Otaku-sempai 131 2 Tue, 5:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Discrepencies Otaku-sempai 104 0 Tue, 7:03pm
       Nice Wall Art Otaku-sempai 84 0 Tue, 11:06pm

  Collapse The ONE thing BOT5A did better than the other two movies Kilidoescartwheels 384 2 Tue, 6:35pm Jump to last post in thread (by Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf)
       eh... LSF 348 0 Tue, 7:29pm
       Agreed, they did a good job Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 320 0 Tue, 8:51pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1048 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.