Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 929 (332456 posts in 13930 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 929 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (activity)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 143702 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 109767 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 2995 0 Oct 12, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

Collapse Sticky: ---> OFFICIAL USER REVIEW THREAD Olorin2607 8761 247 Dec 9, 7:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Dipling)

  Collapse Sticky: Help us Thank the entire cast & crew of 'All Six Middle-earth Films' News from Bree 228 3 Tue, 4:27am Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

  Collapse True heroes Elanor of Rohan 944 60 Dec 20, 2:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ilmatar)
       Thoughts mirkwoodwanderer 500 0 Dec 20, 3:11pm
       Collapse Fili's death MedwedtoBeorn 509 1 Dec 20, 3:26pm
           I think that is true mirkwoodwanderer 476 0 Dec 20, 3:27pm
       Collapse Fili's death Elarie 502 1 Dec 20, 3:30pm
           So PJ made a good point mirkwoodwanderer 486 0 Dec 20, 3:34pm
       Collapse The thematic heroism of TBotFA's climax DigificWriter 461 2 Dec 20, 4:03pm
           Collapse In a way, they both.. MasterOrc 424 1 Dec 20, 4:52pm
               Well, quite Spriggan 347 0 Dec 20, 7:14pm
       Apparently none of the big bad orcs... Miss-Merriweather 394 0 Dec 20, 5:49pm
       Collapse I think Elentari03 386 46 Dec 20, 7:09pm
           Collapse Missed that version of the film marillaraina 342 43 Dec 20, 8:58pm
               Collapse That would be the one where... Eleniel 324 2 Dec 20, 9:17pm
                   Collapse Not really supporting her case. LOL marillaraina 316 1 Dec 20, 9:51pm
                       Agree with you on all these.points... // mae govannen 194 0 Dec 21, 6:43am
               Collapse That would also be the scene.... lionoferebor 297 39 Dec 20, 10:50pm
                   No concept Miss-Merriweather 165 0 Dec 21, 5:16pm
                   Collapse Agree with this. Arveldis 115 37 Dec 22, 2:55am
                       Collapse maybe a bit, but DisDwarfWoman 108 1 Dec 22, 3:22am
                           True... lionoferebor 104 0 Dec 22, 3:36am
                       Collapse Exactly lionoferebor 166 4 Dec 22, 3:56am
                           Collapse good point DisDwarfWoman 162 3 Dec 22, 4:02am
                               Collapse Agreed lionoferebor 163 2 Dec 22, 4:09am
                                   Collapse thanks! DisDwarfWoman 160 1 Dec 22, 4:15am
                                       Yes... lionoferebor 158 0 Dec 22, 4:20am
                       Collapse subject marillaraina 162 29 Dec 22, 5:13am
                           Okay... lionoferebor 154 0 Mon, 8:16am
                           Collapse A brief rebuttal Arveldis 141 27 Mon, 10:12pm
                               Collapse actually, I can think of an instance Cirashala 128 23 Tue, 2:19am
                                   Collapse I knew I could count on you Arveldis 88 22 Tue, 9:57pm
                                       Thank you lionoferebor 76 0 Tue, 10:32pm
                                       Collapse lol Cirashala 75 19 Tue, 10:39pm
                                           Collapse Regarding Kili Arveldis 78 10 Tue, 11:27pm
                                               Collapse fair enough Cirashala 74 9 Tue, 11:40pm
                                                   Collapse Oh, definitely. Arveldis 56 1 Wed, 2:24am
                                                       I get you Cirashala 54 0 Wed, 2:37am
                                                   Collapse a side note Ilmatar 87 6 Wed, 8:48am
                                                       Collapse fair enough Cirashala 66 5 Wed, 9:59pm
                                                           Collapse partly agree, but then again... Ilmatar 42 1 Fri, 9:51am
                                                               . Ilmatar 39 0 Fri, 10:31am
                                                           Collapse . Ilmatar 18 2 Fri, 8:12pm
                                                               Collapse No offense taken Cirashala 15 1 Fri, 8:23pm
                                                                   yes Ilmatar 4 0 13 mins ago
                                           Collapse A Good Time lionoferebor 66 7 Wed, 1:57am
                                               Collapse thanks for the insight into waking from a medical procedure Cirashala 63 6 Wed, 2:11am
                                                   Collapse I would call it proactive... lionoferebor 56 5 Wed, 2:41am
                                                       Collapse so if any of the others Cirashala 50 4 Wed, 2:43am
                                                           Collapse Okay, you got me lionoferebor 75 3 Wed, 5:14pm
                                                               Collapse I think it shows that he does think Cirashala 75 2 Wed, 9:43pm
                                                                   Collapse Yes, it is true lionoferebor 61 1 Wed, 11:18pm
                                                                       and those are all very fair :) Cirashala 62 0 Wed, 11:25pm
                                       Your conversation with Cirashala Elentari03 47 0 Wed, 8:42am
                               Collapse Exaggeration IMO marillaraina 116 2 Tue, 7:20am
                                   Collapse Actually it's Nori lionoferebor 106 1 Tue, 10:33am
                                       Thank you both Arveldis 76 0 Tue, 10:10pm
           Thank you... lionoferebor 286 0 Dec 20, 10:51pm
           Yes... but that was part of Kili's charm to be the way he was... mae govannen 215 0 Dec 21, 6:38am
       You captured my feelings perfectly. Arveldis 343 0 Dec 20, 9:20pm
       Collapse Agreed CathrineB 157 2 Dec 21, 8:27pm
           Collapse subject marillaraina 124 1 Dec 22, 1:59am
               Ohh I think you're right! Cirashala 154 0 Mon, 9:10am

  Collapse Post your EE wishlist here! KingTurgon 1196 45 Wed, 8:13pm Jump to last post in thread (by There&ThereAgain)
       Collapse What I really-really want... BlackFox 688 3 Wed, 8:31pm
           Collapse Wow Thrain II 603 2 Wed, 8:35pm
             Collapse Well... BlackFox 558 1 Wed, 8:38pm
                 Indeed! Thrain II 519 0 Wed, 8:50pm
       For me Thrain II 591 0 Wed, 8:34pm
       Mine: NecromancerRising 554 0 Wed, 8:49pm
       I'll give it a try, borrowing some of yours MechaGodzilla 547 0 Wed, 8:49pm
       Collapse Above all, the funeral scene Elarie 519 1 Wed, 9:03pm
           The general audience wouldn't care about the funeral, mae govannen 261 0 Thu, 7:32am
       Collapse Similar to others.... Avandel 541 14 Wed, 9:08pm
           Collapse Noooo. NecromancerRising 511 1 Wed, 9:10pm
               LOL yessss *grins*...my Alfrid! Avandel 499 0 Wed, 9:19pm
           Collapse This is pretty much my list as well... Queen of Erebor 476 1 Wed, 9:34pm
             I'm not big on the funeral scene either Avandel 393 0 Wed, 10:58pm
           Collapse But confused about the rallying. Isn't that already in? Spriggan 456 9 Wed, 9:47pm
               And let's not forget... BlackFox 443 0 Wed, 9:55pm
               Collapse No, but gaawwgh, I can't find this image... Avandel 438 7 Wed, 10:29pm
                   Collapse this image? Kim 363 1 Thu, 12:56am
                     That's the one! Many thanks Kim! Avandel 163 0 Thu, 3:22pm
                 Collapse LOL, you managed to make me laugh about Thorin!!! mae govannen 247 2 Thu, 7:48am
                     Collapse Well, after watching the Mountain King walk through a dooway in AUJ Avandel 167 1 Thu, 3:48pm
                           Having been properly chastized, never, I say never mae govannen 61 0 Fri, 6:21am
                   Collapse That line is in the movie, though. Silverlode 225 1 Thu, 9:59am
                     LOL - that's what I get for ASSUMING based on one picture Avandel 155 0 Thu, 3:51pm
       More CathrineB 486 0 Wed, 9:33pm
       Collapse one thing nymmerod 446 1 Wed, 9:57pm
           Exactly! Also, more about the Three, please! xxxyyy 157 0 Thu, 3:39pm
       Collapse Let's see... Sharkey 427 1 Wed, 10:26pm
           party tree Mooseboy018 266 0 Thu, 3:37am
       more mirkwoodwanderer 382 0 Wed, 11:16pm
       Collapse More... Riven Delve 377 1 Thu, 12:08am
           I'm with you on that list of yours... mae govannen 232 0 Thu, 8:53am
       My list BalrogTrainer 316 0 Thu, 2:34am
       Collapse Mine: Glorfindela 331 4 Thu, 2:48am
           Collapse Why are so many... BalrogTrainer 306 3 Thu, 3:14am
               Collapse Because Glorfindela 283 1 Thu, 3:22am
                 "Youzz GroovyGuys&Gals" R..Jus'.. Great! Bombadil 262 0 Thu, 5:43am
               Alright, here it goes: DeadRabbits 95 0 Thu, 10:08pm
       ... Salmacis81 202 0 Thu, 12:54pm
       Collapse Okay... Otaku-sempai 176 1 Thu, 3:36pm
           Balin should say something (just a line would suffice) about retaking Moria (now that Azog is dead) at Thorin's funeral or Dain's coronation // xxxyyy 148 0 Thu, 4:27pm
       My take on why the funeral scene was cut sycorax82 154 0 Thu, 6:30pm
       One scene I wouldn't mind seeing... BlackCountry 51 0 Fri, 10:28am
       Collapse Might seem redundant now but.... BlackCountry 32 1 Fri, 4:16pm
           In the DOS EE commentary There&ThereAgain 5 0 37 mins ago

  Collapse I am still not sure exactly how Bard cobbled together a bow strong enough Eruonen 745 48 Fri, 5:46am Jump to last post in thread (by ElendilTheShort)
       Collapse Unfortunately it was an utter nonsense moment ElendilTheShort 402 4 Fri, 8:18am
           Collapse It is a children's book... nicely made into a movie. mirkwoodwanderer 328 1 Fri, 10:23am
               i wouldnt want my children seeing this movie due to the level of violence ElendilTheShort 312 0 Fri, 10:50am
           Collapse Smaug's pride joec_34 46 1 1:09am
               Agree, he had no fear of Bard, a puny man with an ineffective weapon. Eruonen 40 0 1:49am
       Collapse I am certain this was a problematic non credible action sequence the 13th warrior 354 1 Fri, 8:49am
           maybe not indy jones ridiculous ElendilTheShort 315 0 Fri, 9:33am
       Collapse you have to stop watching the movie as an adult mirkwoodwanderer 311 1 Fri, 10:24am
           The book was just fine..adults and children....black arrow into his heart. Eruonen 135 0 Fri, 6:41pm
       Collapse Here is a picture of a man using a makeshift bow to shoot a talking dragon Spriggan 344 27 Fri, 11:00am
           Collapse did you not realise ElendilTheShort 321 26 Fri, 11:42am
               Collapse Tolkien also worked hard Roheryn 297 1 Fri, 12:04pm
                   thankS ElendilTheShort 179 0 Fri, 5:56pm
               Only probability rather than reality Spriggan 273 0 Fri, 12:19pm
               Collapse Sure but... Arvida 247 22 Fri, 12:54pm
                   Collapse Or, without leaving the scene in question, genetic language learning. Spriggan 245 21 Fri, 1:11pm
                       Collapse that is a good example of a fantastical element ElendilTheShort 154 20 Fri, 6:11pm
                           Collapse How is it fantastical? Spriggan 145 19 Fri, 6:29pm
                               Collapse men understanding the language of birds is fantastical, i don't now how else to put it. ElendilTheShort 135 18 Fri, 6:42pm
                                   Collapse Ha - so it is a free probability pass. Spriggan 193 2 Fri, 7:00pm
                                       Collapse not at all ElendilTheShort 178 1 Fri, 7:14pm
                                           So which is it for Bard then? Spriggan 174 0 Fri, 7:19pm
                                   Collapse It showcases his narcissism and invincibility Cirashala 168 14 Fri, 7:38pm
                                       Collapse yet he would have known the threat was possible ElendilTheShort 157 13 Fri, 7:56pm
                                           But Girion's black arrows only knocked one scale off him Cirashala 141 0 Fri, 8:14pm
                                           Collapse LOTR has the same problem. Darkstone 143 1 Fri, 8:32pm
                                               that is a rather large hole in the story ElendilTheShort 110 0 Fri, 9:39pm
                                           Collapse There is a difference Eruonen 140 9 Fri, 8:56pm
                                               Collapse swords are ElendilTheShort 108 6 Fri, 9:42pm
                                                   Collapse Orcrist however is designed with more meat at the end. Eruonen 94 5 Fri, 9:54pm
                                                       Collapse the closest actual example to Orcrist would be a falchion ElendilTheShort 86 4 Fri, 10:00pm
                                                           Collapse Evidently you can throw a sword Eruonen 80 3 Fri, 10:03pm
                                                               Collapse take his summary with a big bag of salt ElendilTheShort 69 1 Fri, 10:23pm
                                                                   Some video attempts... Eruonen 59 0 Fri, 11:01pm
                                                               Yep!! My thoughts exactly! ecthelionsbeard 68 0 Fri, 10:24pm
                                               Collapse Of course Legolas can throw a sword Elarie 24 1 4:11am
                                                   nicely done ElendilTheShort 6 0 49 mins ago
       Well, as PJ said in one of the DOS appendices... Elarie 271 0 Fri, 1:37pm
       Collapse Suspension of disbelief. tsmith675 224 9 Fri, 2:57pm
           Collapse If you can't suspend disbelief who is at fault? Moahunter 164 7 Fri, 6:13pm
               Collapse if you are forced to suspend belief ElendilTheShort 153 3 Fri, 6:29pm
                   Collapse Bard's improvised bow... DigificWriter 136 2 Fri, 6:41pm
                       Collapse The question concerns how he made it, it is hard to tell from the film Eruonen 131 1 Fri, 6:46pm
                           Overconfidence.... DigificWriter 192 0 Fri, 6:50pm
               Collapse Of course there is a limit... tsmith675 185 2 Fri, 7:07pm
                   This is the point of the thread - "He made the bow and it worked. " Eruonen 177 0 Fri, 7:18pm
                   one way or another that bow is as unlikely as ElendilTheShort 169 0 Fri, 7:42pm
           Suspension of belief does not apply here...this is simply a Eruonen 148 0 Fri, 6:45pm

  Collapse Rating the LotR and Hobbit films out of 10. Bofur01 571 30 Fri, 9:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       Here are my ratings... ecthelionsbeard 358 0 Fri, 9:54pm
       My rankings DigificWriter 337 0 Fri, 9:57pm
       my rankings FrogmortonJustice65 317 0 Fri, 10:03pm
       6 haarp 282 0 Fri, 10:24pm
       Collapse mine Crunchable Birdses 273 5 Fri, 10:33pm
           Collapse There was no "studio-demanded 3-film split" DigificWriter 209 4 Fri, 11:29pm
               Collapse It was a bad idea regardless of who thought of it... Elizabeth 84 1 3:09am
                   ....especially given the timing of the decision. Eurolock 33 0 4:30am
               Collapse I think the reality is... Osskil 15 1 6:59am
                   Watch the Appendices for the Extended Editions DigificWriter 5 0 59 mins ago
       I have have given them in order... patrickk 232 0 Fri, 11:06pm
       Rankings Ham_Sammy 221 0 Fri, 11:11pm
       Mine... Joe20 202 0 Fri, 11:15pm
       Here goes BlackFox 204 0 Fri, 11:17pm
       mine MedwedtoBeorn 176 0 Fri, 11:34pm
       Mine: Glorfindela 182 0 Fri, 11:35pm
       Rating, perhaps a little arbitrary, but fun! Foromir 157 0 12:23am
       DoS rating low CuriousG 170 0 12:24am
       Hmmm, in the category of fantasy films Spriggan 146 0 12:29am
       Mine m.summers343 137 0 1:00am
       Collapse all EE of course (except BOTFA I'm predicting) Nira 118 1 2:11am
           On that basis: Elizabeth 78 0 3:07am
       Ok I'll bite demnation 102 0 2:11am
       Mah ratings MechaGodzilla 92 0 2:29am
     MINE!!! MJM 81 0 2:50am
       My ranking... Eurolock 77 0 2:57am
       Collapse All Extended Editions Istaris'staffs 68 1 3:33am
           my fav and my worst mo0on-light 23 0 6:06am
       Ratings Osskil 20 0 6:51am
       Mine: NecromancerRising 15 0 6:57am

  Collapse The 171-year gap between Smaug's attack and events of The Hobbit tiamy 755 31 Fri, 2:36am Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       Yeah, it's kinda screwed up Name 428 0 Fri, 2:48am
       Collapse Dwarven arhtritis dwarvenboot 372 12 Fri, 4:25am
           Collapse But nowhere in the films... tiamy 357 8 Fri, 4:33am
               Collapse aragorn lived to be around 200 years old ElendilTheShort 284 7 Fri, 6:54am
                   Collapse The Quest for Erebor actually occurred in T.A. 2940... DigificWriter 273 6 Fri, 7:30am
                       Collapse Actually... lionoferebor 17 5 4:45am
                           Collapse Bilbo's 111th birthday party... DigificWriter 11 4 6:34am
                               Collapse So... lionoferebor 6 3 6:50am
                                   Collapse The Quest begins in 2940... DigificWriter 6 2 6:53am
                                       Collapse A few questions - all movie verse lionoferebor 3 1 7:02am
                                           Your queries DigificWriter 3 0 7:07am
           Collapse Even so Name 329 2 Fri, 4:48am
             "By SHIRE reckoning.?..Brandybuck or TOOK TIME...xoxoBomby//. Bombadil 298 0 Fri, 5:20am
               The movie vs the book Ham_Sammy 147 0 Fri, 4:05pm
       Collapse In the movieverse, isn't 60 years supposed to have passed between Smaug's attack and the Quest for Erebor? DeadRabbits 253 9 Fri, 9:12am
           Collapse 2811 (TA) - Smaug conquers Eerebor? Otaku-sempai 197 8 Fri, 1:31pm
               Collapse I just said this elsewhere... DigificWriter 175 7 Fri, 3:03pm
                   Yes. Otaku-sempai 169 0 Fri, 3:08pm
                   Collapse That still makes Thorin fairly old. Otaku-sempai 150 5 Fri, 4:06pm
                       Collapse Based on what we see... DigificWriter 147 4 Fri, 4:10pm
                           Collapse Rough estimates Otaku-sempai 141 3 Fri, 4:16pm
                               Collapse Defining the term "young" would probably be helpful DigificWriter 139 2 Fri, 4:21pm
                                   Collapse Thorin at the Sack of Erebor Otaku-sempai 137 1 Fri, 4:32pm
                                       Three assumptions and a timeline guesstimate DigificWriter 118 0 Fri, 6:06pm
       Collapse ages, aging, timelines Cirashala 99 6 Fri, 8:01pm
           Collapse Dwalin doesn't necessarily have to be older than Thorin... DigificWriter 86 4 Fri, 8:16pm
               Collapse that's fair Cirashala 77 3 Fri, 8:29pm
                   Collapse If you leave Thorin's age at 195... DigificWriter 69 2 Fri, 8:55pm
                       Collapse maybe Cirashala 64 1 Fri, 9:07pm
                           Dwalin's age isn't that superfluous, actually... DigificWriter 53 0 Fri, 9:48pm
           Great post.... lionoferebor 15 0 5:41am

  Collapse At last BOFA has reached us here in Australia.. patrickk 395 9 Fri, 11:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by Old Toby)
       Collapse Glad it finally arrived for you. Eruonen 193 1 Fri, 11:08pm
           Personally Glorfindela 177 0 Fri, 11:28pm
       Collapse Pity that Glorfindel's place was taken by Arwen Elanor of Rohan 158 3 Fri, 11:51pm
           Collapse It just for me... patrickk 121 2 12:32am
               Collapse No no no no no no no *terrified face* Mooseboy018 66 1 4:34am
                   replacing arwen? Me85 32 0 5:49am
       Glad you got to see it Ham_Sammy 123 0 12:16am
       Collapse Here's a nice article from The Australian Kim 138 1 12:22am
           Ditto!! Old Toby 27 0 6:48am

  Collapse Is BOTFA and the Hobbit trilogy really as good as we want it to be? Hobbithole 897 26 Fri, 9:08am Jump to last post in thread (by Aragorn the Elfstone)
       Collapse Well, there's a faithful adaptation and then there's an entertaining film... Aragorn the Elfstone 516 2 Fri, 9:20am
           Collapse Totally agree! Hobbithole 413 1 Fri, 9:30am
               In general... Aragorn the Elfstone 25 0 6:23am
       A 'faithful' adaptation would've been boring... elvish.mafia 446 0 Fri, 9:36am
       yes. it is mirkwoodwanderer 384 0 Fri, 10:20am
       Collapse They nailed the arkestone plot and Thorin and Bilbo's relationship LoremIpsum 426 5 Fri, 10:28am
           Collapse For me Glorfindela 371 1 Fri, 11:40am
               Totally this! Lurker in the Mirk 276 0 Fri, 1:25pm
           Collapse Agree with Lorem Ipsum and Hammy Sammy, among others Avandel 213 2 Fri, 4:08pm
               Collapse Missing characters Ham_Sammy 205 1 Fri, 4:15pm
                 Thank you for your reply Avandel 162 0 Fri, 5:15pm
       Hm.. Anubis 362 0 Fri, 10:37am
       They are, of course, not quite as good as if I had made them myself..... Miss-Merriweather 370 0 Fri, 10:53am
       I would say it was a tendency to polarisation, in both directions. Spriggan 362 0 Fri, 11:11am
       "As good as"? Roheryn 284 0 Fri, 1:46pm
       Not as much as there is a Lindele 265 0 Fri, 2:03pm
       Of course not. tsmith675 248 0 Fri, 3:00pm
       I can only say for myself Ham_Sammy 241 0 Fri, 3:29pm
       Of course not! Darkstone 236 0 Fri, 3:37pm
       Collapse My personal opinion and experience. NecromancerRising 227 2 Fri, 4:46pm
           Collapse Beautifully said! Avandel 168 1 Fri, 5:26pm
               This! Exactly. NecromancerRising 151 0 Fri, 5:43pm
       Collapse Is BOTFA and the Hobbit trilogy really as good as we want it to be? Old Toby 146 2 Fri, 6:43pm
           Loved it! Ann Kalagon 61 0 12:07am
           In my opinion Ham_Sammy 61 0 12:19am
       I believe Peter Jackson took greater care fmaximus 40 0 1:34am

  Collapse PJ's Cameo... patrickk 557 4 Fri, 11:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Roheryn)
       so not khamul then? erdildeniz 288 0 Fri, 11:51pm
       Collapse I still haven't caught it! tarasaurus 127 2 3:07am
           Collapse Isn't Katie one of the first Laketowners you see on screen? Earl 55 1 5:30am
               Yup. Roheryn 48 0 5:50am

  Collapse Galadriel's Power Drain? Girdle of Melian 699 31 Fri, 8:16am Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       by fan boys do you mean those that wanted these characters to be more rather than less based on Tolkien ElendilTheShort 381 0 Fri, 8:27am
       Collapse Pretty much bad writing based on a misinterpreted quote... Eleniel 407 19 Fri, 8:28am
           Collapse first time ive heard of this quote ElendilTheShort 350 18 Fri, 9:28am
               Collapse Galadriel spoke that line in the FOTR movie Tintallė 208 12 Fri, 4:55pm
                   Collapse A couple of points Spriggan 193 11 Fri, 5:26pm
                       Collapse ??? Tintallė 177 10 Fri, 6:05pm
                           Collapse Nenya doesn't obviously have power as a direct offensive weapon. Spriggan 166 9 Fri, 6:40pm
                               Collapse the elven rings were not weapons at all ElendilTheShort 160 6 Fri, 6:47pm
                                   Preservation, healing, building, inspiration and defense Spriggan 141 0 Fri, 7:05pm
                                   Collapse We don't know specifically the powers of Nenya, but Galadriel did Eruonen 103 4 Fri, 10:27pm
                                       Collapse That's an interesting one... Eleniel 86 2 Fri, 10:56pm
                                           Collapse I don't think Galadriel needed to Nenya to destroy Dol Guldur Girdle of Melian 58 1 Fri, 11:37pm
                                               They fade, not wink out in a snap. Eruonen 32 0 2:47am
                                       She threw down the walls of Dol Guldur... Elizabeth 43 0 1:54am
                               Collapse She says it after Frodo has looked in Galadriel's mirror Tintallė 43 1 1:14am
                                   Sorry I thought you were talking about Spriggan 40 0 1:18am
               Collapse It's around the 9 minute mark if you want to check it out... Eleniel 127 4 Fri, 9:33pm
                   Collapse terrible ElendilTheShort 122 3 Fri, 9:56pm
                       Collapse Well that's not clear at all. Spriggan 110 2 Fri, 10:14pm
                           Collapse fair call by you in that respect ElendilTheShort 94 1 Fri, 10:30pm
                               Absolutely. Spriggan 87 0 Fri, 10:42pm
       I don't think it was bad writing at all... ecthelionsbeard 337 0 Fri, 9:15am
       I think Sauron started consuming her since she entered Dol Guldur. irasel 331 0 Fri, 9:51am
       Collapse I think this sort if engineer's mindset is unlikely to be any sort of clue. Spriggan 302 4 Fri, 10:53am
           Collapse i think only those whose primary interest or backround is gaming would look for absolutes in any type of heirachy ElendilTheShort 282 3 Fri, 11:28am
               Collapse Interpretation is just that. Spriggan 273 2 Fri, 11:39am
                   Collapse using aragorns example ElendilTheShort 274 1 Fri, 11:51am
                       Absolutely. Spriggan 261 0 Fri, 12:05pm
       . Nerven 229 0 Fri, 1:52pm
       Collapse I resented it. Elizabeth 33 1 3:00am
           Remember, Gandalf also was a poor weak form after his encounter so that is not totally Eruonen 19 0 5:21am

  Collapse The theatrical version is not clear on how the masses of orcs Eruonen 618 11 Fri, 9:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eurolock)
       I am assuming the loss of their leadership signaling station Eruonen 303 0 Fri, 9:28pm
       Collapse The way the battle was portrayed is one of the problems I have with the end of BOTFA. Holly Hobbit 320 1 Fri, 9:43pm
           "Ravenhill had been inspired by Frozen." Funny! Eruonen 258 0 Fri, 9:46pm
       I agree Ham_Sammy 223 0 Fri, 10:05pm
       I actually thought the ambiguity worked out very well. Spriggan 230 0 Fri, 10:10pm
       Collapse And the Fellowship was vastly outnumbered... Darkstone 229 5 Fri, 10:22pm
           Collapse amon Hen Ham_Sammy 199 2 Fri, 10:36pm
               Collapse Yep Darkstone 169 1 Fri, 10:52pm
                   Not really a fair comparison... Eurolock 46 0 4:43am
           Collapse Aragorn arrived with more than that... Eruonen 179 1 Fri, 10:52pm
               Maybe there will be a... MasterOrc 83 0 2:30am

  Collapse Another versus thread maybe? Boromir2k 276 6 Fri, 7:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by Darkstone)
       Collapse Working as intended. Darkstone 168 3 Fri, 7:57pm
           Collapse I find the different aesthetics to be at conflict Bishop 118 1 Fri, 9:36pm
               For example.... Darkstone 81 0 Fri, 10:49pm
           wise words from a wise man. mirkwoodwanderer 51 0 12:01am
       Collapse Battle scenes CuriousG 51 1 12:31am
           LOTR scenes.... Darkstone 22 0 4:19am

  Collapse Fire and Water, or 'Twas a night of deep rumbling Ruxendil_Thoorg 236 9 Fri, 5:22am Jump to last post in thread (by Rembrethil)
       Collapse *raving applause* BlackFox 69 1 Fri, 10:50am
           *bow* Thanks so much BlackFox! Ruxendil_Thoorg 43 0 Fri, 2:57pm
       Collapse *mods up* Roheryn 66 1 Fri, 11:59am
           Thank you Ro! Ruxendil_Thoorg 43 0 Fri, 2:56pm
       Collapse This is superb! dernwyn 44 1 Fri, 3:02pm
           glad you thought so dernwyn! :) Ruxendil_Thoorg 37 0 Fri, 4:26pm
       Collapse Bravo! Kim 31 1 Fri, 6:15pm
           Thank you very much Kim! :) // Ruxendil_Thoorg 26 0 Fri, 6:29pm
       Awesome!! Rembrethil 10 0 3:45am

  Collapse Thorin and Azogs final effort boldog 670 13 Fri, 7:57am Jump to last post in thread (by Ham_Sammy)
       Collapse I definitely agree Angharad73 328 1 Fri, 9:18am
           Denial ain't just a river in egypt LoremIpsum 277 0 Fri, 11:59am
       Best and most intense duel in the cinematic NecromancerRising 333 0 Fri, 9:28am
       I didn't like it Glorfindela 291 0 Fri, 11:42am
       Thorin is just fantastic mirkwoodwanderer 198 0 Fri, 4:17pm
       Collapse I enjoyed the sequence Ham_Sammy 185 2 Fri, 4:50pm
           Collapse Competely agree with your post Avandel 62 1 12:00am
               Fate Ham_Sammy 24 0 3:44am
       I thought it was splendid. Tintallė 174 0 Fri, 5:05pm
       Gripping Ruxendil_Thoorg 160 0 Fri, 5:45pm
       Collapse Stupid Danielos 129 1 Fri, 9:12pm
           Brutally intense... ecthelionsbeard 106 0 Fri, 9:40pm
       Agreed! tarasaurus 34 0 3:05am

  Collapse Musings on The Hobbit vs. LOTR Roheryn 699 16 Fri, 1:23pm Jump to last post in thread (by demnation)
       Possibly… Glorfindela 350 0 Fri, 1:55pm
     Collapse Thanks for this, Roheryn Lurker in the Mirk 328 1 Fri, 2:05pm
           Nice thoughts too, Lurker. Roheryn 71 0 12:22am
       I do have quite a bit of gripes with these movies LoremIpsum 307 0 Fri, 2:52pm
       For me, it's all about the characters Elarie 285 0 Fri, 2:59pm
       Collapse I had the opposite reaction Eledhwen 286 1 Fri, 3:35pm
           And therein Roheryn 73 0 12:31am
       Collapse Saw it 10 times mirkwoodwanderer 272 1 Fri, 4:16pm
           The actors in the Hobbit trilogy are better caliber than in LOTR ltnjmy 211 0 Fri, 6:26pm
       Collapse You have captured EXACTLY the sentiments Tintallė 254 2 Fri, 4:31pm
           that makes me cry too. Thank you mirkwoodwanderer 191 0 Fri, 5:59pm
           I've been channeling you! Roheryn 66 0 12:43am
       Same here ghost_matt 222 0 Fri, 4:32pm
       Great post Ro Ruxendil_Thoorg 210 0 Fri, 5:07pm
       My love for Dwarves grew slowly Elanor of Rohan 121 0 Fri, 9:42pm
       I feel the opposite, but it's cool that you feel like you do! demnation 50 0 2:39am

  Collapse Beorn deleted Aranarth 1426 29 Wed, 3:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bladerunner)
       Collapse I just hope Glorfindela 734 1 Wed, 3:49pm
           He will be .. don't worry.. mirkwoodwanderer 678 0 Wed, 4:04pm
       Collapse IMO much could have been different Avandel 609 1 Wed, 4:27pm
           What amazes me Glorfindela 564 0 Wed, 4:45pm
       Collapse Beorn v. Trolls MorgolKing 606 1 Wed, 4:35pm
           This is one of the things I was hoping for too. Boromir Stark 485 0 Wed, 5:37pm
       Collapse I'd like to hear the reasoning behind this KingTurgon 577 17 Wed, 4:49pm
           Collapse Putting aside the odd Boyens bit, why not flip the question? Spriggan 531 16 Wed, 5:41pm
               Good way to look at it MedwedtoBeorn 460 0 Wed, 5:54pm
               Collapse Would have justified his introduction in DOS... Eurolock 343 2 Wed, 10:03pm
                   Collapse That's a bit circular. Spriggan 300 1 Wed, 11:44pm
                       Agree....but... Eurolock 251 0 Thu, 2:04am
               Collapse Well, those are three really good reasons. Elizabeth 321 2 Wed, 11:09pm
                   Why would it offer a broader range of allies? Spriggan 292 0 Wed, 11:48pm
                   but for those who didn't see the EE Cirashala 290 0 Thu, 12:28am
               Collapse Beorn's function... Bladerunner 211 6 Thu, 8:11am
                   Collapse Great to hear about your reading of him. Spriggan 156 3 Thu, 10:47am
                       Collapse Beorn's Function (Continued)... Bladerunner 98 2 Thu, 3:46pm
                           Collapse Would you say that Bilbo showed a similar affinity Spriggan 64 1 Thu, 9:37pm
                               I agree it wouldn't work in the movie as directed by Sir Jackson.... Bladerunner 12 0 1:41am
                   Collapse Beautifully put re. Beorn, Bladerunner Glorfindela 139 1 Thu, 1:28pm
                       Thanks Glorfindela! Bladerunner 86 0 Thu, 3:57pm
               Collapse Beorn's function (continued)... Bladerunner 185 1 Thu, 8:48am
                   Too much Legolas /too little Beorn Hobbithole 172 0 Thu, 9:24am
       Collapse I agree about Beorn. Greenwood Hobbit 560 2 Wed, 4:56pm
           The TE arithmancer 545 0 Wed, 5:05pm
           The conspiracy revealed! Brandybuckled 554 0 Wed, 5:20pm
       That's my biggest issue Thrain II 376 0 Wed, 8:54pm
       it's rubbish that he was all but completely excluded ElendilTheShort 47 0 Fri, 7:09am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 929 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.