Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 1 of 915 (328763 posts in 13711 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 915 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (activity)
  Sticky: Thread Locked Welcome to the Hobbit Movie board! Altaira 141360 0 May 24 2008, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)

  Sticky: How Best to Contact an Admin for Help Kyriel 109193 0 Mar 31 2009, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kyriel)

  Sticky: The Courtesy of our Halls (Discussion Guidelines) Silverlode 1934 0 Oct 12, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

Collapse Sticky: DOS Chapter of the Week (CHOW) Sign-up for November 2014! cats16 519 20 Nov 13, 10:18am Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)

  Sticky: 'Tis the Season of Spoilers! (Spoiler Policy) Silverlode 1351 0 Nov 20, 3:23am Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)

Collapse Sticky: ---> OFFICIAL USER REVIEW THREAD Olorin2607 6668 180 Dec 9, 7:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)

  Collapse **Geeky Observation List for BofFA - Give me your Observations! :) grammaboodawg 490 29 4:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by DisDwarfWoman)
       Collapse :D Elvanui 218 1 5:06pm
           I love that part! grammaboodawg 176 0 5:42pm
       Collapse Legolas lost BOTH his white knives stn5 208 1 5:17pm
           True! grammaboodawg 174 0 5:44pm
       also: Elarie 179 0 5:45pm
       Collapse Jimmy Nesbitt's kids Ham_Sammy 178 3 5:48pm
           Collapse Tilda and Sigrid are a little bit more than cameos Crunchable Birdses 73 2 7:26pm
               Collapse Just because... DigificWriter 70 1 7:30pm
                   that's what i said - read the post that i was replying to :) Crunchable Birdses 58 0 7:34pm
       Collapse Re #48 DisDwarfWoman 176 7 5:50pm
           I also remember it as Bombur Elarie 158 0 5:55pm
           Collapse Bombur // BlackFox 155 3 5:55pm
               Collapse And IIRC... BlackFox 156 2 5:57pm
                   Not sure... DisDwarfWoman 142 0 6:05pm
                 Bomby theory..Bombur is their "Last line of Defense" of Erebor.. Bombadil 137 0 6:10pm
           Collapse D'OH! You're Right! grammaboodawg 131 1 6:32pm
               Smaug and the Master of Lake-town DigificWriter 125 0 6:40pm
       Bells Ham_Sammy 147 0 6:04pm
       The return journey syameese 119 0 6:51pm
       One very morbid observation BlackFox 121 0 6:58pm
     I LOVE YOU Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 111 0 7:03pm
       Collapse Another BlackFox 102 1 7:07pm
           Despite saying porr bilbo Im glad some give a real punch to some one during the battle Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 86 0 7:16pm
       Collapse The Arkenstone appears to be one large radiant beautiful fire opal. elf_wannabee 48 1 47 mins ago
           Not based on the book DisDwarfWoman 0 0 1 min ago
       Collapse Through all three movies Oleander Took 38 2 36 mins ago
           Collapse He was eating a banana in AUJ Crunchable Birdses 19 1 16 mins ago
               Behind the scenes? Oleander Took 2 0 2 mins ago
       The bunny on his back caught my eye as well! joec_34 27 0 22 mins ago

  Collapse Reviews #20 thomasofrohan 44 2 14 mins ago Jump to last post in thread (by macfalk)
       Certified fresh Estel78 15 0 5 mins ago
       It needs 75% to get certified fresh, right? macfalk 14 0 4 mins ago

  Collapse Galadriel goes ghost dwarvenboot 712 14 Wed, 11:21pm Jump to last post in thread (by Girdle of Melian)
       Collapse same here erdildeniz 391 1 Wed, 11:40pm
           that's what happens in the appendices though MouthofSauron 197 0 4:16am
       Collapse I didn't like it Fichtenbrenner 400 3 Wed, 11:40pm
           Collapse Question HiddenSpring 319 2 12:37am
               fI'll on nuclear Ham_Sammy 298 0 12:47am
               Not really dubulous 87 0 8:47am
       As with most magic in the books and films Spriggan 403 0 Wed, 11:46pm
       Collapse ... swordwhale 187 3 3:52am
           Collapse Older then the Sun, Younger the Trees Finrod 58 2 2:26pm
               that..... was.... swordwhale 48 0 3:06pm
             That was... Iarhen 4 0 40 mins ago
       Collapse Poor effects dubulous 97 1 8:43am
           I Agree.... Girdle of Melian 1 0 7 mins ago
       . Nerven 92 0 8:48am

  Collapse Rank The Hobbit movies BlackFox 435 19 4:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ham_Sammy)
       After just one viewing of BOTFA Elessar 289 0 4:33pm
       My rankings DigificWriter 261 0 4:35pm
       For me: tsmith675 245 0 4:38pm
       Collapse Based on initial viewing Ardamírë 242 1 4:38pm
           Adding in the LotR movies DigificWriter 219 0 4:42pm
       I can't make up my mind between nos 1 and 3 Glorfindela 218 0 4:41pm
       I've grown fonder of BOFA with every subsequent viewing BlackFox 205 0 4:51pm
       1. BOFA 2. AUJ 3. DOS // macfalk 181 0 4:53pm
       Collapse mine so far Scourge of the Stoors 177 1 5:04pm
           In the prologue? BlackFox 119 0 5:58pm
       I rank them like this.... dormouse 175 0 5:14pm
       Mine Ham_Sammy 121 0 5:52pm
       Collapse My ranking of TH/LOTR malickfan 131 1 5:57pm
           Definitely check out DoS EE when you can... QuackingTroll 88 0 6:29pm
       1. BOFA ghost_matt 100 0 6:22pm
       All 6... SamtheMan 80 0 6:44pm
       mine Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 53 0 7:04pm
       Collapse There's no final list until the EE of BOFA... Elutherian 40 1 7:29pm
           If I did all six Ham_Sammy 12 0 19 mins ago

  Laketowner with Rosary? XD NateGate 39 0 24 mins ago Jump to last post in thread (by NateGate)

  Collapse Are we to assume that in SPJ's cinematic treatment of the Hobbit that Tauriel will die of a broken heart? elf_wannabee 96 2 40 mins ago Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       really good observation! Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 44 0 31 mins ago
       I hadnt thought about this, but.... DigificWriter 37 0 26 mins ago

  Collapse Re Thranduil (*SPOILER*) The Grey Elf 491 8 3:04pm Jump to last post in thread (by shadowdog)
       Collapse He says something along the lines of... BlackFox 285 3 3:16pm
           Collapse thranduil legolas Me85 116 2 5:45pm
               Collapse Crazy stupid love BlackFox 103 1 6:02pm
                   yes could be Me85 84 0 6:18pm
       I was going to start a new topic misspoptart 239 0 3:23pm
       I have to go back and watch it again... swordwhale 229 0 3:27pm
       Collapse I don't know. Cillendor 39 1 7:13pm
           Why is it confusing shadowdog 17 0 27 mins ago

Collapse Biggest Theater Crackup Scenes... NateGate 482 13 6:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by tarasaurus)
       My theater got a kick out of... DigificWriter 254 0 6:19pm
       "Not every man is brave enough to wear a corset." BlackFox 233 0 6:20pm
       Collapse Several Ham_Sammy 235 1 6:21pm
         The Master's Death..By Hanging? Bombadil 202 0 6:30pm
       The headbutting troll and... QuackingTroll 205 0 6:33pm
       Collapse My theater also laughed when... DigificWriter 200 1 6:36pm
         HE GOT Squashed into JELLY?....WayCOOOL// Bombadil 166 0 6:38pm
       Collapse BEORN FALLING INTO THE BATTLE FIELD Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 148 1 7:02pm
           i mean this was epic no laughable, sorry I let myself go Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 56 0 45 mins ago
       The biggest laughter in mine was rather political utku 156 0 7:02pm
       A few dubulous 129 0 7:08pm
       Not much laughter but... dungolfin 93 0 7:30pm
       same with my theater! tarasaurus 34 0 29 mins ago

  Collapse Observations from a second viewing (all spoilery) Silverlode 1094 25 3:56am Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse Another interesting thought.. ecthelionsbeard 536 1 4:02am
           Bilbo and Balin syameese 429 0 4:49am
       I've only seen it once so far... swordwhale 470 0 4:09am
       Collapse another observation about Fili (thanks for compiling this for us!) Cirashala 484 7 4:29am
           Thorin Ham_Sammy 454 0 4:33am
           Collapse I absolutely agree lionoferebor 186 5 12:17pm
             Collapse A whole different perspective indeed... mae govannen 139 1 2:00pm
                   Yes, Fili is very courageous lionoferebor 102 0 2:57pm
               Collapse Ah, you thought that as well?... Na Vedui 24 1 6:37pm
                   *nods* BlackFox 22 0 6:50pm
               Did he? Cirashala 7 0 31 mins ago
       Azog's blood tarasaurus 393 0 5:25am
     Wow, thanks for posting these observations! Avandel 352 0 5:40am
       Collapse A followup thought... Silverlode 383 7 6:01am
           GREAT theory Cirashala 334 0 6:05am
           Collapse Given their importance, it struck me as odd that... thomasofrohan 345 5 6:08am
               Collapse Like the Laketown restitution... Silverlode 326 4 6:17am
                   Collapse Given how Dain treats Thranduil during their confrontation... thomasofrohan 336 3 6:24am
                       Collapse But it's a matter of honor Silverlode 321 2 6:46am
                           But Avandel 285 0 7:40am
                         "Choice comments"... LOL! mae govannen 120 0 2:12pm
       Collapse Great observations, Silverlode. Roheryn 231 1 10:33am
           YOU BOW to No ONE...SILVERGIRL..Sail on &ON! Bombadil 179 0 11:46am
       Collapse How many significant details one can find mae govannen 129 1 2:23pm
           Details are why I wish I had the DVD already! Avandel 63 0 4:54pm

  Collapse For Pete(r)' Sake - This is how I would have handled Galadriel ... Girdle of Melian 342 8 5:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mr. Arkenstone (isaac))
       I highly approve this post Spalko 118 0 6:15pm
       Collapse Everyone does realize.... DigificWriter 150 6 6:27pm
           I know. Cillendor 84 0 7:04pm
           Collapse Well technically... dubulous 71 3 7:16pm
               Collapse I think the Dol Guldur demonic energy affetts her in the way she looks in nuclear form Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 29 2 43 mins ago
                   Collapse Her Elven Ring DigificWriter 26 1 40 mins ago
                       apparently in movieverse she is affected by the energy that is in Dol Guldur, so I think the ring Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 20 0 32 mins ago
           . Nerven 29 0 46 mins ago

  Collapse Peter Jackson frees ourselves out of Tolkien's obsession with battles Milieuterrien 773 37 Mon, 11:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by Milieuterrien)
       Collapse Not sure I followed all of your points. Spriggan 341 8 Mon, 11:53pm
           Collapse I maintain battles in fiction aren't necessary Milieuterrien 311 7 Tue, 12:19am
               Collapse Yes - I'm agreeing with that. Spriggan 273 6 Tue, 12:51am
                   Collapse Banning wars out of fiction would be... Milieuterrien 259 5 Tue, 1:05am
                       Collapse I understand what you mean - I just don't agree. Spriggan 251 4 Tue, 1:16am
                           Collapse Expressing himself about real wars surroundig you is often dangerous Milieuterrien 236 2 Tue, 1:39am
                               Haha, well, imo FotR is vastly superior to any and all movies! Name 205 0 Tue, 3:13am
                               Now, we move from one point to another Spriggan 122 0 Tue, 8:04am
                           On the other hand, Milieuterrien 217 0 Tue, 1:59am
       Collapse To an extent shadowdog 306 1 Tue, 12:16am
           Tolkien surely was, Milieuterrien 289 0 Tue, 12:31am
       Collapse I agree with most of what you said TnuaccayM 305 1 Tue, 12:20am
           Thank you for this support ; this somehow has to be talked about, Milieuterrien 261 0 Tue, 12:55am
       You are aware... Morthoron 193 0 Tue, 3:43am
       Collapse Scratching my head here HiddenSpring 191 21 Tue, 3:51am
           Collapse Bloodless gets you a PG-13 rating glor 172 1 Tue, 4:01am
               My point stands HiddenSpring 162 0 Tue, 4:13am
           Collapse We must concede Milieuterrien 128 18 Tue, 9:23am
               Collapse Why stop at war? Bumblingidiot 88 17 Tue, 3:21pm
                   Excellent post! Morthoron 83 0 Tue, 3:37pm
                   Collapse Because war hurts much more what you should propose to stop at Milieuterrien 79 15 Tue, 3:54pm
                       Collapse What? Morthoron 85 14 Tue, 4:28pm
                           Collapse The fact is war lies all over Tolkien's books Milieuterrien 67 3 Tue, 5:22pm
                               Clearly, you are very passionate about this Spriggan 62 0 Tue, 5:37pm
                               Collapse Your feelings are misplaced.... Morthoron 90 1 Tue, 5:45pm
                                   When I make researches, i always prefer looking into the real history Milieuterrien 71 0 Tue, 7:34pm
                           Collapse Writing this, I realize Milieuterrien 83 9 Tue, 7:11pm
                               Collapse Please provide a shred of evidence.... Morthoron 73 4 Tue, 7:40pm
                                   Collapse And you, try to show me evidence Milieuterrien 65 3 Tue, 8:05pm
                                       Collapse Okay... Morthoron 65 2 Tue, 8:10pm
                                           Collapse Thank you for the advice Milieuterrien 59 1 Tue, 8:38pm
                                               I have a Degree in English lit.... Morthoron 51 0 Wed, 12:32am
                               Collapse Your history is rather selective. Bumblingidiot 27 3 Wed, 2:55pm
                                   Collapse The facts are : Milieuterrien 21 2 Wed, 4:48pm
                                       Collapse She and King's Solomon's Mines and Beowulf. Bumblingidiot 9 1 5:42pm
                                           The question is not to wonder if Tolkien had read legends Milieuterrien 1 0 35 mins ago
       I've returned from my months long sabbatical demnation 40 0 Wed, 1:59am

Collapse Spoiler warning - Galadriel/Dol Guldur possible EE scenes... Iarhen 167 3 51 mins ago Jump to last post in thread (by Mr. Arkenstone (isaac))
       Collapse yeah it was some weird things in this scene Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 87 2 47 mins ago
           Collapse Yeah... Iarhen 69 1 44 mins ago
               It looks weird when she appears beside Elrond. She looks out of place Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 69 0 42 mins ago

  Collapse Chronicles: Art and Design: Battle of the Five Armies Orc Berserker 846 40 Wed, 8:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by ghost_matt)
       Collapse Start with Dol Guldur! :o) TiberiusOgden 483 3 Wed, 9:02pm
           Collapse Gandalfs' vision! Orc Berserker 448 1 Wed, 9:19pm
               The Palantir Scene Shagrat 350 0 Wed, 9:43pm
           Palantir - vision! Orc Berserker 424 0 Wed, 9:23pm
       Collapse Sounds interesting MechaGodzilla 439 28 Wed, 9:09pm
           Collapse Bolg Orc Berserker 388 7 Wed, 9:31pm
               Collapse could you make a resume of what could be a pottential material for the EE? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 378 2 Wed, 9:32pm
                   Collapse Blimey... Orc Berserker 291 1 Wed, 10:11pm
                       Extended Edition grimbeorn15 99 0 3:51am
               Collapse Nice, thanks a lot for the info MechaGodzilla 345 1 Wed, 9:34pm
                   I hope so! Orc Berserker 247 0 Wed, 10:14pm
               Collapse Why does Bolg Remus 340 1 Wed, 9:40pm
                   Spot on Orc Berserker 243 0 Wed, 10:18pm
           Collapse Dain Orc Berserker 394 19 Wed, 9:39pm
               Collapse Boy oh boy PJ and his CGI Azaghâl 354 18 Wed, 9:44pm
                   Collapse Doesn't sound like the full story Carne 332 17 Wed, 9:48pm
                       Collapse dain Me85 304 15 Wed, 9:54pm
                           Collapse Wouldn't have been fair to Connolly I guess Carne 296 1 Wed, 9:55pm
                               i get it Me85 259 0 Wed, 10:08pm
                           Collapse Why? Spriggan 252 9 Wed, 10:13pm
                               Collapse because gci people look very fake. Me85 238 8 Wed, 10:20pm
                                 Collapse @Orc Berserker NoelGallagher 237 4 Wed, 10:34pm
                                       Collapse Hard to tell Orc Berserker 219 3 Wed, 10:53pm
                                           Persbrandt's first day of filming was a torture scene Carne 207 0 Wed, 11:01pm
                                           Collapse Yes! Dcole4 158 1 Wed, 11:57pm
                                               Hmm... Orc Berserker 64 0 8:05am
                                   Collapse Well in this case Spriggan 179 2 Wed, 11:22pm
                                       Collapse Exactly! Glorfindela 160 1 Wed, 11:48pm
                                           me too MedwedtoBeorn 137 0 12:21am
                           Collapse Well, for me Silverlode 106 2 2:37am
                               Collapse The only shot of Dain that looked cgi to me... ecthelionsbeard 91 1 3:31am
                                   I still think it's a combination. Silverlode 87 0 3:53am
                       This sounds more plausible! adt100 182 0 Wed, 11:07pm
       Collapse Ugh, taking me so long to get this book Carne 409 1 Wed, 9:13pm
           LOADS OF BEASTS!!! Orc Berserker 320 0 Wed, 9:49pm
       Collapse Sauron O_O Remus 416 1 Wed, 9:18pm
           Sauron Orc Berserker 304 0 Wed, 9:55pm
       Collapse Saruman Curun!r 225 1 Wed, 10:43pm
           Not much Orc Berserker 207 0 Wed, 10:59pm
       more EE ghost_matt 5 0 44 mins ago

  Collapse PJ Leaves Room for more MIddle Earth Movies MorgolKing 881 15 1:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mr. Arkenstone (isaac))
       Uh-oh.... Hear, hear, all folks!!! mae govannen 441 0 1:45pm
       Collapse I think it's time for someone else. Azaghâl 427 11 1:46pm
           Collapse The way I see it, The Hobbit is primarily a kids movie AshNazg 366 10 2:20pm
               That could be quite interesting indeed...// mae govannen 312 0 2:27pm
               Collapse You sound like Christopher Tolkien.... macfalk 340 8 2:29pm
                   Collapse Did he say THAT?!... LOL!!! mae govannen 309 3 2:34pm
                       Collapse Unpopular opinion here, but macfalk 318 2 2:36pm
                           Collapse I think that may be... swordwhale 186 1 3:47pm
                               Im not up for any toy Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 37 0 57 mins ago
                   Collapse Unlike CT, I'm not implying that it can't be enjoyed by anyone else AshNazg 281 1 2:38pm
                       PLEASE include the 'Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth' mae govannen 236 0 3:06pm
                   Collapse Action-adventure films for youths of 15–25 years Finrod 241 1 3:09pm
                       I know his exact quote from Le Monde macfalk 218 0 3:24pm
       More Middlle-Earth movies? Hanzkaz 280 0 3:06pm
       Let it go, Peter HiddenSpring 203 0 3:48pm

  Collapse Can anyone explain? (Spoilers) MJM 647 21 2:42pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       A were-worm pushed him out // AshNazg 285 0 2:45pm
       I just presumed it was just for cinematic purposes There&ThereAgain 254 0 3:02pm
       Collapse Legolas anti-gravity boots make no sense MorgolKing 255 4 3:02pm
           Well... MJM 200 0 3:33pm
           Collapse I have two insights.... swordwhale 196 2 3:41pm
               Interesting comments there! adt100 123 0 5:02pm
               Hero Ham_Sammy 88 0 5:50pm
       Collapse It's because PJ is really bad at physics... dungolfin 240 3 3:14pm
           Collapse True this. I mean a dragon being able to fly with those small wings too! adt100 211 2 3:23pm
               Collapse Yep, the film is a failure as a physics course supplement. Darkstone 188 1 3:41pm
                 Wow, that was completely uncalled for. Cillendor 45 0 7:19pm
       Collapse Perhaps he floated over a rock. Spriggan 229 3 3:18pm
           Collapse Yes... MJM 190 2 3:36pm
               Collapse Well it must be very shallow indeed anyway utku 57 1 6:52pm
                 HAVE Any of you been to Niagara Falls? Bombadil 36 0 7:24pm
       That scene bugged me tbh! adt100 217 0 3:22pm
       Collapse I don't even care. tsmith675 230 2 3:25pm
           That's my feeling too Ham_Sammy 199 0 3:35pm
           It was... MJM 190 0 3:42pm
       First Remus 188 0 3:43pm
       Cuz it's awesome! grammaboodawg 98 0 5:48pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 915 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.