Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 9 of 879 (320639 posts in 13177 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 879 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse The Hobbit: An Unexpected Booklet 2! TheHutt 806 25 Nov 18, 10:13am Jump to last post in thread (by MechaGodzilla)
     AMAZING!!!! NoelGallagher 338 0 Nov 18, 10:30am
       Wow! Just totally awesome... Eleniel 315 0 Nov 18, 10:41am
       Fabulous! Glorfindela 293 0 Nov 18, 11:09am
       Beautiful work... dormouse 277 0 Nov 18, 11:41am
     HUTT! you ARE...a REAL STAR! Bombadil 280 0 Nov 18, 11:48am
       The... Systemisation of Smaug QuackingTroll 286 0 Nov 18, 11:58am
       Collapse Fantastic. Thank you for these! AshNazg 259 11 Nov 18, 1:19pm
           Collapse The Problem is Fleuz 272 10 Nov 18, 1:40pm
               I suppose one has to wait and see BOFA... TheHutt 248 0 Nov 18, 2:12pm
               Collapse That's a good point, however... AshNazg 245 8 Nov 18, 2:19pm
                   Collapse Well, I don't really see the point... TheHutt 231 7 Nov 18, 2:33pm
                       Collapse color Fleuz 218 6 Nov 18, 2:47pm
                           Collapse Sure it is... TheHutt 213 1 Nov 18, 2:54pm
                               Touché Fleuz 201 0 Nov 18, 2:58pm
                           Collapse Might it be a raven? Eleniel 184 1 Nov 18, 3:58pm
                               That's what I said in my post... AshNazg 139 0 Nov 18, 6:02pm
                           Collapse IMO KingTurgon 28 1 Nov 20, 10:03pm
                               I understand where you're coming from MechaGodzilla 16 0 Nov 21, 4:01am
       Fantastic Hutt! NecromancerRising 157 0 Nov 18, 4:42pm
       Top notch, Hutt Kendalf 141 0 Nov 18, 5:34pm
       Fantastic job! Voronwë_the_Faithful 140 0 Nov 18, 5:40pm
       Fantastic! BlackFox 117 0 Nov 18, 6:58pm
       Collapse Meh... CerseiBlanchett 125 1 Nov 18, 7:57pm
           People come here to share their passion, it's not a pragmatical thing. Fàfnir 110 0 Nov 18, 8:08pm
       Thanks so much! Riven Delve 90 0 Nov 18, 8:59pm

  Collapse The Hobbit: There and Back Again by Bilbo Baggins Númenórean 671 2 Nov 18, 4:42am Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
       Editing is way too fast QuackingTroll 224 0 Nov 18, 5:01am
       good overall Mooseboy018 198 0 Nov 18, 5:46am

  Collapse How will you feel about the trilogy if the following happens Bishop 1257 18 Nov 18, 4:34am Jump to last post in thread (by TricksyHobbitses)
       Collapse We'll find out in a month. tsmith675 516 2 Nov 18, 4:56am
           Collapse Well yes, we'll find out. It's a ton of speculation. Bishop 504 1 Nov 18, 4:57am
               Yeah I'm saying... tsmith675 481 0 Nov 18, 5:22am
       Collapse It depends how it's handled... QuackingTroll 520 1 Nov 18, 5:07am
         "They could have Radagast's bunnies kill Azog if they want. " Rembrethil 15 0 Sun, 3:25am
       disappointed Mooseboy018 492 0 Nov 18, 5:37am
       We'll see There&ThereAgain 412 0 Nov 18, 6:42am
       The conclusion Axeman21 372 0 Nov 18, 8:06am
       everything else kinda works tattooed_dwarf 365 0 Nov 18, 8:15am
       Collapse I have no idea.... dormouse 362 3 Nov 18, 8:38am
           Collapse As dormouse said, context is all. Noria 245 2 Nov 18, 1:37pm
               Collapse This. // Eruvandi 151 1 Nov 18, 5:34pm
                   Hard to decide who to reply to... TricksyHobbitses 17 0 Sun, 5:41am
       I hope this does not happen Glorfindela 306 0 Nov 18, 11:12am
       Depends Aitieuriskon 225 0 Nov 18, 2:10pm
       Pre FOTR - How would we have felt about Boromir's death being changed? Spriggan 252 0 Nov 18, 2:28pm
       I don't really like the idea of Thorin killing Azog - Hanzkaz 226 0 Nov 18, 2:44pm
       My reactions, (in red): joec_34 191 0 Nov 18, 5:00pm

  Collapse The Hobbit: the Battle of the Five Armies spoiler rumours are false News from Bree 1622 21 Nov 18, 1:49am Jump to last post in thread (by Queen of Erebor)
       Collapse would they tell us if they were true?! NoelGallagher 754 5 Nov 18, 7:27am
           Collapse haha. indeed! Demosthenes 721 1 Nov 18, 7:33am
             THANK you Demos...bom avoided READING any of that Bombadil 535 0 Nov 18, 11:44am
           Collapse Basically this nhui06 428 1 Nov 18, 2:15pm
               Independently... Demosthenes 392 0 Nov 18, 2:36pm
           I think Skaan 261 0 Nov 18, 6:48pm
       Collapse Not gonna lie.... Joe20 782 1 Nov 18, 7:30am
           The only disapointment for me Guert 507 0 Nov 18, 1:17pm
       I hope Hobbit 3 is really, really good - Hanzkaz 710 0 Nov 18, 7:41am
       Collapse Well they can't 'all' be false Shagrat 670 3 Nov 18, 9:31am
           Collapse "all false" arithmancer 491 2 Nov 18, 1:18pm
               Collapse Contract-breach? Danielos 445 1 Nov 18, 1:55pm
                   It's all about getting caught Guert 431 0 Nov 18, 2:05pm
       Collapse Oh that's great Hobbity Hobbit 533 3 Nov 18, 12:47pm
           Collapse Before invalidation KeenObserver 231 2 Nov 18, 8:22pm
               Collapse Yeah Hobbity Hobbit 185 1 Nov 18, 9:32pm
                   That would be Richard Armitage... Queen of Erebor 131 0 Nov 19, 1:42am
       Collapse Thanks for digging deeper into this Skaan 462 1 Nov 18, 1:47pm
           Nah, no worries Demosthenes 397 0 Nov 18, 2:38pm
       His description of the epilogue was a dead giveaway! sycorax82 309 0 Nov 18, 7:03pm
       Well, this is 4chan we're talking about... StarGodziller 219 0 Nov 18, 8:38pm

  Collapse Some possible leaks (not confirmed) Skaan 2960 36 Nov 17, 9:30pm Jump to last post in thread (by frodo284)
       I doesn't make sense *so called spoilers* Fàfnir 1219 0 Nov 17, 9:43pm
       hmm.. (spoilers) shaundobson 1151 0 Nov 17, 9:44pm
       Another so called "Spoiler" that doesn't make sense JamesPaganini 1170 0 Nov 17, 9:46pm
       Why I doubt this Shagrat 1092 0 Nov 17, 9:47pm
       Sounds like someone... dubulous 1081 0 Nov 17, 9:48pm
       Collapse Some things which make me doubt the credibility of this guy: Skaan 1142 3 Nov 17, 9:50pm
           yeah your right shaundobson 1003 0 Nov 17, 9:53pm
           10 minute prologue about anything sounds ludicrous. They're never that long. // dubulous 1019 0 Nov 17, 9:54pm
           Nope Guert 965 0 Nov 17, 10:03pm
       Bogus gliido 988 0 Nov 17, 9:56pm
       Collapse 99% sure this is all BS. tsmith675 1048 2 Nov 17, 9:57pm
           Collapse I think this is the worst thing about all of this Skaan 1029 1 Nov 17, 10:03pm
               I know, right? KeenObserver 794 0 Nov 17, 11:15pm
       9/10 Darkstone 1008 0 Nov 17, 10:05pm
       Collapse Walk away people.. Drakblod 980 8 Nov 17, 10:24pm
           He can use any material present in the Appendicies sycorax82 871 0 Nov 17, 10:47pm
         It makes for a good laugh, doesn't it? KeenObserver 842 0 Nov 17, 10:52pm
           Collapse This isn't the first or second source to say that Sauron is the prologue... AshNazg 369 5 Nov 18, 5:30am
               Collapse It's been thought of several times. Mooseboy018 325 2 Nov 18, 6:02am
                   Collapse Really? AshNazg 312 1 Nov 18, 6:07am
                       I speculated in a Sauron centered prologue as early as a year ago... DeadRabbits 235 0 Nov 18, 8:44am
               i will say FiliSonOfDis 286 0 Nov 18, 6:57am
               I remember that a Sauron-prologue was suggested, painjoiker 168 0 Nov 18, 1:07pm
       Most of this is very believable. However...*no spoilers* sycorax82 734 0 Nov 18, 12:36am
       Collapse As soon as I got to the Thorin suicide part I literally laughed out loud. Name 669 2 Nov 18, 1:15am
           I didn't read it Ham_Sammy 617 0 Nov 18, 1:27am
           If this guy is legit then I'm Peter Jackson... Tardisious 619 0 Nov 18, 1:40am
       haha there's some acutally half decent stuff in there Joe20 587 0 Nov 18, 2:14am
       Collapse Imagine if last year someone told us about the golden statue... nobofthepony 550 2 Nov 18, 3:37am
           Collapse Improbable Mooseboy018 365 1 Nov 18, 5:30am
               my response Mooseboy018 334 0 Nov 18, 6:07am
       funniest thing Barrow-Wight 502 0 Nov 18, 4:03am
       So I went back and read the whole thing through Joe20 397 0 Nov 18, 6:07am
       Collapse Some of the things mentioned I want to see, - Hanzkaz 343 1 Nov 18, 6:54am
           Old Bilbo Mooseboy018 316 0 Nov 18, 7:06am
       BS frodo284 138 0 Nov 19, 1:43am

  Collapse Could Bolg being fought by Tauriel and Legolas be earlier on? Hobbity Hobbit 668 5 Nov 17, 8:23pm Jump to last post in thread (by Fàfnir)
       He's not here during Hobbity Hobbit 325 0 Nov 17, 8:57pm
       Not possible, because he gets additional pieces of armor Fàfnir 297 0 Nov 17, 9:46pm
       No King_horse 248 0 Nov 17, 10:24pm
       i hope Bolg kills Tauriel MouthofSauron 156 0 Nov 18, 4:02am
       Plus, Tauriel's theme can be heard in the sample from the "Ravenhill" track // Fàfnir 63 0 Nov 18, 8:01pm

Collapse Observation and question about HOBBIT Extended Editions. Simon L. de Paiva 887 11 Nov 17, 7:58pm Jump to last post in thread (by Simon L. de Paiva)
       Collapse credits Mooseboy018 392 1 Nov 17, 8:20pm
           Observation and question about HOBBIT Extended Editions. Simon L. de Paiva 356 0 Nov 17, 8:30pm
       Collapse PJ can't Lindele 418 1 Nov 17, 8:27pm
           I completely agree... Simon L. de Paiva 336 0 Nov 17, 8:37pm
       Collapse Sorry but no There&ThereAgain 324 1 Nov 17, 8:51pm
           Although I see your point... Simon L. de Paiva 287 0 Nov 17, 9:01pm
       Collapse For only 100 bucks! Darkstone 322 2 Nov 17, 8:58pm
           Collapse Thanks for the link Simon L. de Paiva 285 1 Nov 17, 9:08pm
               There was a discussion of this topic last month. Moahunter 201 0 Nov 17, 11:51pm
       Collapse Welcome to TORn, Simon :) grammaboodawg 31 1 Sun, 5:55pm
           Thanks for welcoming me, grammaboodawg. Simon L. de Paiva 27 0 Sun, 7:02pm

Collapse Ian Brodie's "The Hobbit Location Guide Book".. YIPPIE! Bombadil 472 5 Nov 17, 7:38pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mithfânion)
       JUST Ordered IT...In Time for ThankZgiving.. Bombadil 163 0 Nov 17, 8:14pm
       Hoping to get it for Christmas Kilidoescartwheels 88 0 Nov 18, 3:32am
       Got it Mithfânion 49 0 Nov 18, 8:44pm
       Collapse Oh that's cool Hobbity Hobbit 38 1 Nov 18, 9:50pm
           So much Mithfânion 16 0 Nov 19, 10:55am

  Collapse How many Hobbit movies would you have prefered? Danielos 1144 37 Nov 17, 4:15pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cillendor)
       Collapse Two, the way it was originally going to be tsmith675 621 2 Nov 17, 4:22pm
           Collapse That would have been my preference, too. Eleniel 574 1 Nov 17, 4:26pm
               I agree.. Drakblod 464 0 Nov 17, 5:19pm
       Collapse 3 3-hour movies, with plot and character development instead of long action sequences Crunchable Birdses 545 5 Nov 17, 4:59pm
           I was going to say something similar... QuackingTroll 427 0 Nov 17, 5:54pm
           Collapse Nailed it. Arthael 209 3 Nov 17, 10:49pm
               Collapse DoS Crunchable Birdses 128 1 Nov 18, 1:17pm
                   Thrain scenes were great! Arthael 62 0 Nov 18, 10:40pm
               I couldn't agree more! // Bernhardina 64 0 Nov 18, 10:10pm
       I'm happy with three movies but dubulous 525 0 Nov 17, 5:04pm
       Collapse Nineteen Darkstone 524 2 Nov 17, 5:11pm
         Exactly! // BlackFox 283 0 Nov 17, 7:48pm
           LOL... Ditto! (If you're NOT joking...) // mae govannen 135 0 Nov 18, 12:17pm
       Nine MouthofSauron 456 0 Nov 17, 5:35pm
     Collapse Get ready for it… Glorfindela 494 5 Nov 17, 5:35pm
           Collapse There was more than enough for 3 films. Ham_Sammy 448 4 Nov 17, 5:59pm
               Collapse Yes, I agree with this Glorfindela 385 3 Nov 17, 6:32pm
                   Collapse yes I agree also Ham_Sammy 363 2 Nov 17, 6:37pm
                       Collapse To be honest Glorfindela 340 1 Nov 17, 7:00pm
                           The Stone Giants Ham_Sammy 345 0 Nov 17, 7:06pm
       I have to agree with others here... priell3 410 0 Nov 17, 6:15pm
       Two movies but longer EEs Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 385 0 Nov 17, 6:33pm
       Two might have been best, but nothing wrong with three Bishop 332 0 Nov 17, 7:06pm
       Collapse 2 would have been perfect jtarkey 322 1 Nov 17, 7:20pm
           I understand your point... adu 69 0 Nov 18, 9:45pm
       I'm happy we got three Hobbit films - Hanzkaz 284 0 Nov 17, 8:06pm
       Collapse I'm fine with three.... (providing they're EEs) dormouse 291 3 Nov 17, 8:15pm
           Collapse Agreed - Hanzkaz 261 2 Nov 17, 8:45pm
               Collapse Agreed too Noria 110 1 Nov 18, 1:46pm
                   Now that we have three Mithfânion 81 0 Nov 18, 8:47pm
       One Gianna 274 0 Nov 17, 8:28pm
       Nice post - and six for me Avandel 266 0 Nov 17, 9:17pm
       No idea. Spriggan 217 0 Nov 17, 10:16pm
       3 films were OK, but... Grand Bob 219 0 Nov 17, 11:01pm
       Initially 2... adu 73 0 Nov 18, 9:37pm
       My first post here, lurker since 2012. Thrain II 55 0 Nov 19, 12:50am
       I think three is best. Cillendor 18 0 Nov 20, 11:07pm

  Collapse Important question about Gandalf and Galadriel? erdildeniz 692 3 Nov 17, 9:48am Jump to last post in thread (by Darkstone)
       Collapse I think it's just a matter of angle and timing // dubulous 288 2 Nov 17, 9:50am
           Collapse or a matter of late changes NoelGallagher 301 1 Nov 17, 11:02am
               Yes. Darkstone 216 0 Nov 17, 3:13pm

Collapse Finally it's out. The Kili-Tauriel situation according to the creators [spoilers] Lurker in the Mirk 2850 155 Nov 17, 6:43am Jump to last post in thread (by namarie)
       Collapse Philippa has referenced it as a romance all along in interviews.... Eleniel 1149 34 Nov 17, 7:36am
           Collapse It's been pretty obvious on the screen too dubulous 1083 1 Nov 17, 8:03am
               Oh it's truly cringe-worthily obvious in caps all right. Lurker in the Mirk 1070 0 Nov 17, 8:19am
           Collapse Really? Impression I got Lurker in the Mirk 1083 1 Nov 17, 8:17am
             "The Gimli/Galadriel LOVE STORY...*CLICK* Bombadil 1062 0 Nov 17, 8:38am
           Collapse Denial? Or just a different way of looking at things.... dormouse 1031 4 Nov 17, 9:02am
               Collapse Same here Elessar 458 2 Nov 17, 2:09pm
                   Collapse Right... mae govannen 280 1 Nov 18, 12:37pm
                       That too lol Elessar 263 0 Nov 18, 1:42pm
             I'll remember the Egg Sandwich Metaphor... Per-fect!!! mae govannen 278 0 Nov 18, 12:45pm
           Collapse I still fail to see this relationship as a romance NecromancerRising 1015 24 Nov 17, 9:20am
               Collapse HAHAHAHA, is that a joke? QuackingTroll 901 18 Nov 17, 11:27am
                   Collapse He says that while in pain and drugged Annatar598 880 1 Nov 17, 11:37am
                       You're right, it is overblown Lurker in the Mirk 551 0 Nov 17, 12:46pm
                   Collapse My thoughts exactly dubulous 853 1 Nov 17, 11:45am
                       For those with issues Shagrat 840 0 Nov 17, 11:59am
                   Collapse ... Anubis 835 5 Nov 17, 12:00pm
                       Collapse Really? Shagrat 818 3 Nov 17, 12:03pm
                           Collapse ... Anubis 800 2 Nov 17, 12:09pm
                               Collapse But dubulous 797 1 Nov 17, 12:18pm
                                   Well... Anubis 753 0 Nov 17, 12:40pm
                       That was my first thought shadowdog 268 0 Nov 17, 7:26pm
                   Collapse Kili was in an utterly NecromancerRising 841 2 Nov 17, 12:17pm
                       Collapse I don't think they wrote the dialogue for people to pass it off as delirious nonsense... QuackingTroll 323 1 Nov 17, 6:23pm
                           Let's agree to disagree NecromancerRising 309 0 Nov 17, 6:27pm
                   Collapse Why all the HATE??? Kilidoescartwheels 299 4 Nov 18, 2:07am
                       I haven't seen any hate at all! Bishop 282 0 Nov 18, 2:39am
                       Collapse Why I don't like the romance sarahb1863 283 1 Nov 18, 2:59am
                           I think you are mistaken marillaraina 277 0 Nov 18, 3:05am
                       Only for myself Avandel 235 0 Nov 18, 3:09pm
               Collapse More sex, please! Danielos 817 4 Nov 17, 12:23pm
                   That would be inspired. But methinks the true inspiration would be Lurker in the Mirk 537 0 Nov 17, 12:50pm
                   Well, if we're going to trash it up... Eowyn of Penns Woods 357 0 Nov 17, 9:09pm
                   People would deny the romance even then... QuackingTroll 246 0 Nov 17, 11:49pm
                   "No Sex Please,..." Darkstone 243 0 Nov 18, 12:10am
       Collapse My daughter has remained adamant ever since we watched DoS last December. Moahunter 1130 6 Nov 17, 8:51am
           Collapse Your daughter's smart Lurker in the Mirk 538 5 Nov 17, 12:40pm
               Collapse It's funny.. Drakblod 424 4 Nov 17, 2:24pm
                   Kinda same boat here. Imladris18 400 0 Nov 17, 2:36pm
                   Collapse That's the thing Lurker in the Mirk 206 2 Nov 18, 6:41am
                       Collapse subject marillaraina 211 1 Nov 18, 3:35pm
                           Who dragged what into it Lurker in the Mirk 81 0 Nov 19, 3:49am
       Collapse It can be a love story Starling 987 2 Nov 17, 9:10am
         "The Young & Reckless".. Bombadil 944 0 Nov 17, 9:31am
           subject marillaraina 297 0 Nov 18, 12:48am
       Collapse They've completely misinterpreted the Gimli/Galadriel thread QuackingTroll 934 11 Nov 17, 11:12am
           Collapse Yes, they've misinterpreted it lol leonmuse 873 1 Nov 17, 11:35am
               This Lurker in the Mirk 533 0 Nov 17, 12:43pm
           Collapse Yay, someone who saw the truth Lurker in the Mirk 546 2 Nov 17, 12:42pm
               Collapse Don't think it is about "getting it" arithmancer 513 1 Nov 17, 1:09pm
                   Sure, and that's the creepier prospect, to me Lurker in the Mirk 217 0 Nov 18, 6:27am
           Collapse Exactly... Eleniel 471 5 Nov 17, 1:55pm
               Collapse One problem I have... QuackingTroll 256 3 Nov 18, 12:00am
                   Collapse You mean like Thranduil and Thorin??? Kilidoescartwheels 266 2 Nov 18, 3:29am
                       Collapse Well, with Thranduil and Thorin it's more personal... QuackingTroll 235 1 Nov 18, 6:04am
                           Agreed Lurker in the Mirk 208 0 Nov 18, 6:59am
               This! Lurker in the Mirk 201 0 Nov 18, 6:56am
       Collapse This just tells me (spoilers) sueb1863 935 2 Nov 17, 11:17am
           Well, apparently the book doesn't matter anyway Lurker in the Mirk 532 0 Nov 17, 12:52pm
           hope that doesn't happen ): Avandel 435 0 Nov 17, 2:16pm
       Collapse I don't mind calling it a love story BlackFox 544 32 Nov 17, 12:58pm
           Collapse Agreed, it doesn't, but platonic (in the dictionary sense) doesn't seem to be the way Lurker in the Mirk 505 3 Nov 17, 1:13pm
               Collapse I used that particular word in relation to Gimli BlackFox 476 1 Nov 17, 1:50pm
                   As it applies to Gimli, I can agree with Lurker in the Mirk 210 0 Nov 18, 6:16am
               Just as they are fixating shadowdog 234 0 Nov 17, 7:49pm
           Collapse However, Glorfindela 442 21 Nov 17, 2:30pm
               Me neither, actually BlackFox 390 0 Nov 17, 2:48pm
               Collapse That was my feeling as well Ham_Sammy 427 19 Nov 17, 3:59pm
                   Collapse The suspicion still nags me Shagrat 375 18 Nov 17, 5:50pm
                       Collapse WB all the way Ham_Sammy 355 16 Nov 17, 5:55pm
                           Collapse Well there is that interview with Evangeline Ardamírë 354 1 Nov 17, 6:06pm
                               yeah Ham_Sammy 328 0 Nov 17, 6:09pm
                           Collapse Studio Interference nhui06 338 4 Nov 17, 6:14pm
                               Collapse He was referring to the Smaug chase. Imladris18 332 3 Nov 17, 6:19pm
                                   Collapse Another example Ham_Sammy 315 1 Nov 17, 6:27pm
                                       Blame Syd Field. Darkstone 252 0 Nov 17, 7:43pm
                                   Commentary Michelle Johnston 266 0 Nov 17, 11:27pm
                           Collapse I would agree to studio interference... Darkstone 289 7 Nov 17, 7:11pm
                               Collapse Depends on the studio surely? Shagrat 280 1 Nov 17, 7:16pm
                                   Apparently not. Darkstone 272 0 Nov 17, 7:26pm
                               Collapse Yeah... Imladris18 271 4 Nov 17, 7:26pm
                                   Collapse Yeah Name 246 3 Nov 17, 7:44pm
                                       Collapse I like the addition of Tauriel - Hanzkaz 383 2 Nov 17, 8:35pm
                                           Simple. Darkstone 368 0 Nov 17, 8:49pm
                                           Yeah, Boyens makes some interesting decisions Name 328 0 Nov 17, 9:39pm
                           However you choose to look at it Elessar 276 0 Nov 17, 7:23pm
                       Probably dubulous 289 0 Nov 17, 6:53pm
           Collapse Neither Do I Michelle Johnston 214 5 Nov 18, 8:03am
               Collapse Great insights Michelle Noria 250 2 Nov 18, 2:28pm
                   Personally, I don't think about it as the addition of a female character Spriggan 231 0 Nov 18, 3:14pm
                   How Triangulated are T/K/L Michelle Johnston 138 0 Nov 18, 7:43pm
               Beautifully put Elessar 180 0 Nov 18, 4:50pm
               Excellent post... dormouse 148 0 Nov 18, 6:22pm
       Collapse She also said in the EE (paraphrasing): Imladris18 540 12 Nov 17, 2:02pm
           Collapse Which girls? Avandel 472 11 Nov 17, 2:18pm
               My first thought was the reaction of some folks on here. Imladris18 457 0 Nov 17, 2:21pm
               Collapse I know. Adanel 410 1 Nov 17, 4:52pm
                   Ditto Lurker in the Mirk 207 0 Nov 18, 6:36am
               Collapse The girls who were dragged to the cinemas by their boyfriends. bungobaggins 423 6 Nov 17, 7:54pm
                   Collapse But did ticking the demographics boxes WORK? Avandel 237 5 Nov 18, 12:20am
                       Collapse Re: "So where's all the YA Kili/Tauriel angst?" Lurker in the Mirk 229 4 Nov 18, 6:38am
                           Collapse Thank you - fairness is good - 'coz I thought if this had WORKED Avandel 255 3 Nov 18, 2:34pm
                               Collapse Honestly, this isn't something that interests me Lurker in the Mirk 108 2 Nov 19, 4:01am
                                   and fades like a shadow of a shadow Avandel 86 0 Nov 19, 3:56pm
                                   I don't see what you see in this "relationship" Cirashala 52 0 Nov 20, 7:19am
               exactly :) // namarie 47 0 Nov 20, 9:37am
       Oh man. Scorchster 444 0 Nov 17, 2:25pm
       Collapse Their relationship is as much a love story as Lindele 433 23 Nov 17, 2:43pm
           Collapse It's really not, though dubulous 402 1 Nov 17, 4:58pm
               Well said, dubulous! And c'mon, Lindele: really? Lurker in the Mirk 203 0 Nov 18, 6:47am
           Collapse Would you still feel that way Bishop 324 20 Nov 17, 6:34pm
               Collapse But they didn't BlackFox 260 19 Nov 17, 7:42pm
                   Collapse What? Bishop 348 18 Nov 17, 9:09pm
                       Collapse We can come back to this in a month BlackFox 329 17 Nov 17, 9:27pm
                           Collapse You agree though... Bishop 309 15 Nov 17, 10:10pm
                               Collapse I have never claimed that it is merely a friendship BlackFox 304 9 Nov 17, 10:23pm
                                   Collapse Not purely physical, sure Bishop 289 8 Nov 17, 10:37pm
                                       Collapse Hmm... BlackFox 279 7 Nov 17, 10:49pm
                                           Collapse Do you agree Bishop 250 4 Nov 17, 11:33pm
                                               I doubt the confines of the story strand Spriggan 241 0 Nov 17, 11:47pm
                                               Collapse Well, if it's the AUJ extended you're talking about.... dormouse 314 2 Nov 18, 8:30am
                                                   Collapse subject marillaraina 191 1 Nov 18, 4:25pm
                                                       Yes, I agree // dormouse 181 0 Nov 18, 4:29pm
                                           Collapse And yes, Bishop 247 1 Nov 17, 11:37pm
                                               Alright then BlackFox 303 0 Nov 18, 9:55am
                               Collapse If "he's rather tall for a dwarf" was flirting.... dormouse 275 4 Nov 17, 11:18pm
                                   I always thought... Darkstone 267 0 Nov 17, 11:28pm
                                   Collapse OK, perhaps you're right Bishop 251 2 Nov 17, 11:46pm
                                       Collapse Well yes, if you will.... dormouse 326 1 Nov 18, 8:22am
                                           I do the same. Elessar 261 0 Nov 18, 1:48pm
                           Also Bishop 301 0 Nov 17, 10:17pm
       Collapse I'm scratching my head slightly Spriggan 415 1 Nov 17, 2:56pm
           Well, it's that darned "R" word Lurker in the Mirk 204 0 Nov 18, 6:54am
       Collapse So "love" equals "sex"? Darkstone 424 4 Nov 17, 3:09pm
         LOL! *mods up* Silverlode 239 0 Nov 18, 5:48am
           *LoL* Shocking! Lurker in the Mirk 213 0 Nov 18, 6:49am
           Darkstone, you're priceless - thanks for the laugh! // dormouse 311 0 Nov 18, 8:28am
           What a wonderful collection of beautiful quotes. I'll keep it mae govannen 279 0 Nov 18, 12:59pm
       Collapse DOS EE nhui06 376 1 Nov 17, 3:39pm
           Not just Philippa? Avandel 318 0 Nov 18, 12:33am
       I think they misunderstood... Merovech 455 0 Nov 17, 4:36pm
       Collapse Don't care for the label... Arannir 420 4 Nov 17, 8:54pm
           Collapse Well said, Arannir! BlackFox 343 1 Nov 17, 9:29pm
               subject marillaraina 306 0 Nov 18, 1:03am
           Yes, the message is a good one Lurker in the Mirk 206 0 Nov 18, 7:01am
           *Vigorous Hand Clapping* mae govannen 276 0 Nov 18, 1:03pm
       Collapse I read this in the Movie Guide too MirielCelebel 316 4 Nov 18, 3:25am
           Wonderful post, and couldn't agree more Bishop 271 0 Nov 18, 3:27am
           Thank you, MirielCelebel Lurker in the Mirk 214 0 Nov 18, 7:03am
           Collapse More than just "romantic" love Tardisious 152 1 Nov 18, 8:32pm
               Well-said! Lurker in the Mirk 101 0 Nov 19, 4:10am
       Collapse It's Deja Vu All Over Again DwellerInDale 328 1 Nov 18, 11:39am
         Well, you'll forgive me if it's only a whisper in the dark for me Lurker in the Mirk 92 0 Nov 19, 3:45am
       Collapse Why all the surprise? SirDennisC 101 1 Nov 19, 3:30am
           It's about as subtle as a murmukil traipsing towards the Pelennors, isn't it? Lurker in the Mirk 103 0 Nov 19, 4:12am

  Collapse That's what I need- a map! Cirashala 642 3 Nov 17, 5:19am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
     Cira, Darlin' SSOoo..Correct! Bombadil 235 0 Nov 17, 9:13am
       Collapse I would love to see more of Erebor Elarie 154 1 Nov 17, 1:31pm
         "... The Lord of SILVER Fountains..." : BARD Bombadil 139 0 Nov 17, 3:00pm

  Collapse Extended edition spoilers: That last scene with Thrain REALLY upsets me ~Medieval Soul 1457 15 Nov 17, 5:13am Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       Collapse Please just search for Wilhelm scream next time... nusilver 762 3 Nov 17, 6:46am
           Collapse Agreed nhui06 313 2 Nov 17, 6:16pm
               Absolutely! // dormouse 223 0 Nov 17, 8:20pm
               agreed Avandel 166 0 Nov 18, 12:04am
       No Glorfindela 631 0 Nov 17, 9:12am
       The thing is.. Drakblod 458 0 Nov 17, 2:25pm
       Collapse We really don't know what happens to him either. Eruonen 454 3 Nov 17, 2:39pm
           it has been said NoelGallagher 434 0 Nov 17, 2:51pm
           death is confirmed in commentary. nusilver 318 0 Nov 17, 6:18pm
           true MouthofSauron 123 0 Nov 18, 4:05am
       Collapse Yup I agree Barrel_Rider 191 3 Nov 17, 10:46pm
           Collapse There was a weird emotional response when it happened... QuackingTroll 126 2 Nov 18, 5:17am
               Collapse i really don't know what all the fuss is about MouthofSauron 110 1 Nov 18, 8:03am
                   It is partially the fault of the viewer... QuackingTroll 99 0 Nov 18, 12:06pm
       Doesn't annoy me. Crunchable Birdses 181 0 Nov 17, 11:32pm

  Moved: Music Video ideas Barrow-Wight - - Nov 17, 2:02am Jump to last post in thread (by Barrow-Wight)

  Collapse "Sounds like quite the party you're having up there..." delius82 923 7 Nov 17, 1:39am Jump to last post in thread (by Kerewyn)
       Collapse Or am I just missing out.. delius82 433 2 Nov 17, 2:06am
           Collapse One can indeed hear sounds of revelry in the distance :) // Earl 370 1 Nov 17, 2:21am
               hah delius82 330 0 Nov 17, 3:24am
       Collapse In the appendices Barrow-Wight 436 3 Nov 17, 2:37am
           Collapse Was it this one? TricksyHobbitses 389 2 Nov 17, 4:03am
             I loved that! LOL // Eruvandi 263 0 Nov 17, 4:50am
               That is SO funny! Kerewyn 173 0 Nov 17, 11:14am
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 879 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.