Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 9 of 873 (319035 posts in 13086 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 873 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Where is Radagast?? :( QueenCirce 861 9 Nov 12, 5:19am Jump to last post in thread (by Mad Hatter of Middle-Earth)
       Collapse here Númenórean 562 3 Nov 12, 5:34am
           Collapse Oooo MouthofSauron 414 2 Nov 12, 7:40am
               Collapse Radi Fleuz 400 1 Nov 12, 7:53am
                   Ahh! MouthofSauron 370 0 Nov 12, 7:59am
     I hope you have recovered by now, poor Queen Circe!... mae govannen 310 0 Nov 12, 10:23am
       Collapse Radagast probably enters Dol Guldur with Galadriel. As for his fate..... sycorax82 217 1 Nov 12, 3:33pm
           .. deskp 152 0 Nov 12, 4:34pm
       The eagles are my hunch. Imladris18 160 0 Nov 12, 4:37pm
       Well let's not forget Sylvestor McCoy's comments Mad Hatter of Middle-Earth 118 0 Nov 12, 8:31pm

  Collapse Galadriel at Dol Guldur Speculation (SPOILERS) Mooseboy018 1063 30 Nov 12, 2:26am Jump to last post in thread (by Girdle of Melian)
       Collapse My take HiddenSpring 592 11 Nov 12, 2:57am
           Collapse Regarding point #1 Ardamírë 546 3 Nov 12, 3:08am
             Collapse "Nuclear" Galadriel @ her Mirror, in FOTR may be our BEST HINT! Bombadil 517 2 Nov 12, 4:38am
                   Collapse Nuclear Galadriel Kilidoescartwheels 220 1 Nov 12, 2:42pm
                       I think maybe... Girdle of Melian 49 0 Nov 13, 1:19pm
           Collapse AGREE with Hidden QueenCirce 489 5 Nov 12, 5:11am
               Collapse +1 Spalko 447 4 Nov 12, 5:27am
                   Collapse visualizing the battle Mooseboy018 446 3 Nov 12, 5:56am
                       Collapse Very true dubulous 329 1 Nov 12, 9:11am
                           I think they will both drive him out... Girdle of Melian 230 0 Nov 12, 1:33pm
                       But was he, in the book? Eleniel 276 0 Nov 12, 10:36am
           Actually, this can't be right! Cillendor 71 0 Nov 13, 2:51am
       Can't wait to see how this will come about... Tinuviel-Luthien 462 0 Nov 12, 5:04am
       Collapse . Nerven 411 8 Nov 12, 6:27am
           Collapse Spoiler Spalko 447 7 Nov 12, 6:47am
               Collapse That is a beautiful photo! Arannir 332 1 Nov 12, 9:15am
                   It is! Spalko 260 0 Nov 12, 10:36am
             Collapse Lovely shot, LOL... mae govannen 312 4 Nov 12, 9:31am
                   Collapse Thang You...bomby's Next DeskTOP Image! Bombadil 298 3 Nov 12, 9:42am
                       Collapse Gandalf Mithfânion 279 2 Nov 12, 10:22am
                           I could see Sauron interrogating him... Arannir 280 0 Nov 12, 10:24am
                           . Nerven 264 0 Nov 12, 10:29am
       I think this is more likely to happen... Girdle of Melian 401 0 Nov 12, 7:14am
       Collapse Galadriel goes "nuclear" and dol-guldur is reduced to ruble MouthofSauron 385 1 Nov 12, 8:03am
           IT mightbe WAyCOOL to See Saruman go "NUCLEAR"... Bombadil 327 0 Nov 12, 9:37am
       Anything, but NOT Galadriel against Gandalf, that's impossible!!! mae govannen 302 0 Nov 12, 10:07am
       Collapse maybe like this? Jettorex 205 3 Nov 12, 3:42pm
         Collapse GREAT Plot..Thinkin' There!...JET..// Bombadil 161 2 Nov 12, 4:39pm
               Collapse Galadriel will whip out her secret weapon.... priell3 135 1 Nov 12, 7:18pm
                   . Nerven 62 0 Nov 13, 6:08am

  Collapse Peter v Tolkien- The Ultimate debate hms_ocean 987 31 Nov 12, 1:43am Jump to last post in thread (by Elessar)
       Great analysis Beorn's Bees 487 0 Nov 12, 3:16am
       Hmm Drakblod 440 0 Nov 12, 6:42am
       Collapse It's a very well-thought out, interesting analysis.... dormouse 428 17 Nov 12, 8:36am
           Collapse I agree hms_ocean 371 3 Nov 12, 11:02am
               Collapse I think Glorfindela 338 1 Nov 12, 12:31pm
                   Just read this... Grand Bob 261 0 Nov 12, 3:35pm
               Possible *spoilers* arithmancer 334 0 Nov 12, 12:36pm
           I have rarely agreed more with you than now. Arannir 376 0 Nov 12, 11:05am
           Collapse I'm with you 100% Elessar 306 11 Nov 12, 2:40pm
               Collapse Why? Glorfindela 298 6 Nov 12, 2:52pm
                   Collapse Pitting the two Elessar 262 4 Nov 12, 3:36pm
                       Collapse Fine Glorfindela 219 3 Nov 12, 4:57pm
                           Collapse I'm not Elessar 193 2 Nov 12, 5:31pm
                               Collapse One may as well pit the farmer who grows the tomato Spriggan 150 1 Nov 12, 7:10pm
                                   agreed :-) Elessar 141 0 Nov 12, 7:19pm
                   Timing Grand Bob 238 0 Nov 12, 4:08pm
               Collapse Maybe the OP could have chosen a different title for the thread... Salmacis81 156 3 Nov 12, 7:11pm
                   Collapse That it does lol Elessar 144 2 Nov 12, 7:20pm
                       Collapse Thanks hms_ocean 68 1 Nov 13, 11:03am
                           Time Out Elessar 38 0 Nov 13, 4:43pm
       Collapse Nice summary Grand Bob 317 9 Nov 12, 2:40pm
         Collapse Recommendations KeenObserver 278 3 Nov 12, 3:59pm
               Collapse Bravo Grand Bob 246 2 Nov 12, 4:13pm
                   Collapse I will, Grand Bob KeenObserver 242 1 Nov 12, 4:32pm
                       Well... Grand Bob 226 0 Nov 12, 4:53pm
           Yep- they are remotely similar. Spriggan 169 0 Nov 12, 7:06pm
           Yes - me dormouse 120 0 Nov 12, 8:35pm
           Collapse Yes. Arannir 66 2 Nov 13, 11:06am
               Collapse Well... Grand Bob 58 1 Nov 13, 1:58pm
                   And I have my books too. Spriggan 40 0 Nov 13, 4:35pm
       I've just watched the Extended Edition of DOS - Hanzkaz 120 0 Nov 12, 9:39pm

  Collapse How much more of Smaug will we get? NateGate 838 17 Nov 12, 12:44am Jump to last post in thread (by TheSexyBeard)
       Collapse I am very curious There&ThereAgain 494 6 Nov 12, 12:46am
           Collapse I really hope he speaks. Mooseboy018 402 5 Nov 12, 2:05am
               same There&ThereAgain 355 0 Nov 12, 2:20am
               Collapse Well he had to be silent for the forges chase, they had no more lines to use! sycorax82 376 1 Nov 12, 2:22am
                   Smaug talking to Thorin Mooseboy018 360 0 Nov 12, 4:06am
               Collapse Well, you can't mae govannen 243 1 Nov 12, 7:39am
                   he will speak Mithfânion 207 0 Nov 12, 10:18am
       Collapse EXPECTATIONS Denneker 332 4 Nov 12, 5:35am
           Collapse Ponies would be good... Joe20 306 3 Nov 12, 5:49am
             Collapse Bomby iz Convinced he will either Gobble down the Master... Bombadil 273 1 Nov 12, 7:15am
                   Will the master...? Denneker 69 0 Nov 12, 9:05pm
               Agreed...! Denneker 70 0 Nov 12, 9:01pm
       Collapse Quite a bit. Arannir 223 3 Nov 12, 10:21am
         Collapse The Black Arrow NEEDz a "Follow Shot" Bombadil 174 2 Nov 12, 2:24pm
               I think you're right Bomby! There&ThereAgain 129 0 Nov 12, 4:51pm
               Present HIS Maginficence...? Denneker 56 0 Nov 12, 9:29pm
       Dwarves TheSexyBeard 45 0 Nov 12, 10:44pm

  Collapse Possible changes you'll mind and changes you won't (spoilers ofc) macfalk 716 11 Nov 12, 12:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Eye's on Guard)
       Good news! Name 435 0 Nov 12, 1:21am
       Collapse Changes Eye's on Guard 403 2 Nov 12, 1:25am
           Collapse Connoly confirmed in an interview he would be king at the end of the movie / Fàfnir 75 1 Nov 12, 8:59pm
               Great news! Eye's on Guard 49 0 Nov 12, 10:53pm
       A couple wills and wonts dubulous 224 0 Nov 12, 10:02am
       Hm Arannir 209 0 Nov 12, 10:08am
       Mind Mithfânion 205 0 Nov 12, 10:26am
       Fili and Kili is an odd one Spriggan 119 0 Nov 12, 7:19pm
       Collapse Mine... Salmacis81 114 2 Nov 12, 7:21pm
           Collapse Why does Dain need to kill Azog? macfalk 95 1 Nov 12, 8:06pm
               Because Dain killing Azog... Salmacis81 96 0 Nov 12, 8:18pm

  Collapse Thorin's fate, spoilers. Hamfast Gamgee 746 5 Nov 11, 11:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by Hamfast Gamgee)
       Collapse Probably not surprised when Thorin carks it Crunchable Birdses 389 1 Nov 11, 11:37pm
           Fili and Kili Hamfast Gamgee 24 0 Nov 14, 1:05am
       Collapse Critics love major character deaths. Name 308 2 Nov 12, 1:17am
           Collapse This reminds me of one of the most classic post titles ever: Loresilme 292 1 Nov 12, 3:12am
               Ha! That is pretty great! Name 151 0 Nov 12, 11:11am

  Moved: Hobbit Trilogy marathon in U.S. cinemas Monday 12/15 News from Bree - - Nov 11, 10:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by News from Bree)

  Collapse What essential,wonderful and massively illuminating scenes will be cut from BOTFA TE, only to be in the EE months later? TheImaginator 771 6 Nov 11, 10:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       I don't think I was expecting 2 or 3 Spriggan 398 0 Nov 11, 10:10pm
       Collapse Considering we don't even know what scenes are IN the film... dormouse 331 3 Nov 11, 11:00pm
         Agree w/Darling dormouse once again... Bombadil 268 0 Nov 11, 11:17pm
           Collapse You mean... macfalk 211 1 Nov 12, 12:45am
               Now you mention it.... dormouse 127 0 Nov 12, 7:48am
       An extended 'Back Again" portion There&ThereAgain 301 0 Nov 11, 11:14pm

  Collapse Thorin vs Azog to take place away from the battle...? NateGate 547 2 Nov 11, 9:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Name)
       As I understand it, in the films Spriggan 310 0 Nov 11, 10:15pm
       You pose some good questions Name 186 0 Nov 12, 1:10am

  Collapse BOTFA TV SPOT erdildeniz 1686 41 Nov 11, 8:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Starling)
       click dave_lf 904 0 Nov 11, 9:00pm
       Collapse Great one! Arannir 806 1 Nov 11, 9:04pm
           What he said BlackFox 607 0 Nov 11, 9:40pm
       Collapse "They...are my friends" Loresilme 848 28 Nov 11, 9:08pm
           Collapse Well Faleel 755 24 Nov 11, 9:10pm
               Collapse They're all his friends Loresilme 736 23 Nov 11, 9:14pm
                   Collapse Doesn't make sense dubulous 695 22 Nov 11, 9:18pm
                       Collapse I don't think I'm reading too much into it Loresilme 671 21 Nov 11, 9:22pm
                           Collapse That's two completely unrelated things dubulous 594 5 Nov 11, 9:38pm
                               Collapse Creativity often involves connecting seemingly unrelated things Loresilme 486 4 Nov 11, 10:11pm
                                   Collapse marketing Mooseboy018 424 2 Nov 11, 10:48pm
                                       Collapse I'm not sure what is meant by "marketing"? Loresilme 358 1 Nov 11, 11:21pm
                                           Yes. Darkstone 73 0 Nov 12, 5:29pm
                                 That is the Definition of "Innovation" Bombadil 396 0 Nov 11, 11:06pm
                           Collapse Well I don't think Gandalf & Galadriel Kilidoescartwheels 432 8 Nov 11, 10:53pm
                               Collapse Friends kiss - it's not a proposal of marriage! // dormouse 407 5 Nov 11, 10:59pm
                                   Collapse Ha! Faleel 409 1 Nov 11, 11:02pm
                                       LOL! Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 399 0 Nov 11, 11:04pm
                                   Collapse Yeah, but... Darkstone 54 2 Nov 12, 7:24pm
                                       Collapse *Cough*... dormouse 42 1 Nov 12, 7:55pm
                                           Darkstone and Dormouse Starling 14 0 Nov 13, 5:20am
                               Collapse it's the same sort of kiss that Aragorn gave Boromir when he was dying Cirashala 279 1 Nov 12, 1:45am
                                   Good comparisons here, mae govannen 163 0 Nov 12, 8:40am
                           Collapse PJ doesn't really have anything to do with the trailers. There&ThereAgain 385 5 Nov 11, 11:09pm
                               Collapse How does this figure into Loresilme 359 4 Nov 11, 11:26pm
                                   Collapse Standard procedure There&ThereAgain 347 3 Nov 11, 11:46pm
                                     T&TA!.. Thang you berry Buch... Bombadil 320 0 Nov 12, 12:08am
                                       Collapse Thank you! Loresilme 244 1 Nov 12, 3:06am
                                           I hope it was clear! There&ThereAgain 226 0 Nov 12, 3:50am
           Collapse Huh? No, I doubt that. Arannir 721 1 Nov 11, 9:13pm
               I'm sorry could you be more specific? Doubt what? Loresilme 678 0 Nov 11, 9:15pm
         CAN't Wait! ..Saw many commercials during the Most Bombadil 715 0 Nov 11, 9:17pm
       Okay now I'm really feeling it... tsmith675 711 0 Nov 11, 9:29pm
       That was great! Ardamírë 621 0 Nov 11, 9:39pm
       YouTube link: Carne 636 0 Nov 11, 9:42pm
       Collapse Balin TheSexyBeard 576 1 Nov 11, 10:02pm
         Was happy to see Balin too! Avandel 118 0 Nov 12, 1:50pm
       Collapse Yeah I'm missing my fair Elven King in this one VValar 478 2 Nov 11, 10:42pm
           Well, there IS one shot of him there... mae govannen 186 0 Nov 12, 8:49am
           I am still hoping that NOT seeing things re trailers is a good sign Avandel 126 0 Nov 12, 2:05pm
       Is it just me Name 351 0 Nov 12, 1:03am

  Trailer up on Apple Quicktime's Trailer Page Aragorn the Elfstone 272 0 Nov 11, 8:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by Aragorn the Elfstone)

  Collapse Estel Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 778 23 Nov 11, 7:55pm Jump to last post in thread (by macfalk)
       No.. Drakblod 384 0 Nov 11, 8:00pm
       Collapse I want to see an Aragorn cameo. Hanzkaz 333 9 Nov 11, 8:34pm
           Collapse Gimli Faleel 295 8 Nov 11, 8:57pm
               Collapse no he's not (book spoilers) Cirashala 184 7 Nov 12, 2:32am
                   Collapse the linked article Elthir 108 6 Nov 12, 12:30pm
                       Collapse Similarity is Not Identity Ostadan 67 5 Nov 12, 7:08pm
                           Collapse not necessarily Cirashala 62 4 Nov 12, 8:44pm
                               Collapse Remember, everyone can have their own opinion, entmaiden 53 3 Nov 12, 9:14pm
                                   Collapse Sorry Entmaiden Cirashala 54 2 Nov 12, 9:18pm
                                       Collapse There are many people entmaiden 51 1 Nov 12, 10:14pm
                                           fair enough Cirashala 40 0 Nov 12, 11:26pm
       If it happened to be in, and you enjoy it Spriggan 299 0 Nov 11, 8:44pm
       Collapse Estel Loresilme 295 1 Nov 11, 8:54pm
           Exactly the way I feel too about this possibility. // mae govannen 139 0 Nov 12, 6:04am
       Imho unnecessary. Arannir 275 0 Nov 11, 9:01pm
       Ugh, no thank you! Glorfindela 209 0 Nov 11, 11:19pm
       Collapse Didn't Viggo rip into the new trilogy? sycorax82 184 1 Nov 12, 2:06am
           They had a talk together later on mae govannen 151 0 Nov 12, 6:15am
       At about what age was Aragorn/Strider mae govannen 142 0 Nov 12, 6:48am
       Collapse If there is one I hope it's brief, painjoiker 110 1 Nov 12, 11:48am
           Yes, even just that much mae govannen 104 0 Nov 12, 12:05pm
       I'm on the fense. Cillendor 55 0 Nov 12, 9:10pm
       If the cameo is subtle, then maybe yes... macfalk 17 0 Nov 13, 4:30pm

  Collapse Who is Bilbo speaking to? Iris70 567 15 Nov 11, 7:03pm Jump to last post in thread (by Iris70)
       Collapse My guess is either Thorin, or maybe Bofur? Eruvandi 183 7 Nov 12, 12:42am
           Thank you, that already helps!... // mae govannen 107 0 Nov 12, 7:28am
           Collapse Yes, James Nesbit already confirmed in an interview this is so... Eleniel 130 5 Nov 12, 7:44am
               Is it so?! How interesting! mae govannen 103 0 Nov 12, 8:55am
             Collapse Oh, really? Nice! Eruvandi 58 3 Nov 12, 4:27pm
                   Collapse Actually, it was MF not Nesbitt! Eleniel 58 2 Nov 12, 5:08pm
                       Great article, thanks for the link!..// mae govannen 32 0 Nov 13, 3:44am
                     thx Iris70 20 0 Nov 13, 4:48pm
       Collapse Same question as you, can't help!... mae govannen 117 6 Nov 12, 7:26am
           Collapse Great! First answer above confirmed as correct !!! // mae govannen 93 5 Nov 12, 9:02am
             Collapse Thanks Iris70 89 4 Nov 12, 12:26pm
                 Collapse LOL... Even Thorin himself laughs about such an idea mae govannen 90 3 Nov 12, 12:51pm
                     Collapse U R right Iris70 70 2 Nov 12, 2:59pm
                           Collapse Yes... Usually he is too serious!... mae govannen 39 1 Nov 13, 4:37am
                             Thorin Iris70 25 0 Nov 13, 4:50pm

  Collapse Exactly how short could this film be? Shagrat 853 15 Nov 11, 5:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by Misty Mountain Hop)
       Collapse Confirmed runtime Danielos 531 9 Nov 11, 6:00pm
           Collapse Nothing is confirmed at this point. Arannir 449 8 Nov 11, 6:16pm
               Collapse Disappointment Dcole4 375 4 Nov 11, 6:41pm
                   Collapse Not majorly concerned if... DjU 315 3 Nov 11, 7:17pm
                       Collapse Agree with a lot of this. Arannir 277 2 Nov 11, 7:27pm
                           Collapse Also remember: Arannir 248 1 Nov 11, 7:44pm
                               Not worried Mithfânion 153 0 Nov 11, 9:48pm
               Collapse SF is a reliable source. // macfalk 156 2 Nov 11, 9:54pm
                   Collapse I did not deny that. Arannir 141 1 Nov 11, 10:00pm
                       Just saying! // macfalk 123 0 Nov 11, 10:08pm
       Collapse Logistics and turn around time? DjU 343 1 Nov 11, 6:52pm
           Well Shagrat 300 0 Nov 11, 7:01pm
       Collapse 2:34 Misty Mountain Hop 194 2 Nov 11, 9:54pm
           Collapse Not funny... wmsd 147 1 Nov 11, 10:24pm
               Understood... Misty Mountain Hop 26 0 Nov 12, 9:40pm

  Collapse Ranking the EE's so far, TheImaginator 832 17 Nov 11, 4:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by BalrogTrainer)
       Ranking Dcole4 466 0 Nov 11, 4:52pm
       Collapse How are you ranking them?? QuackingTroll 448 4 Nov 11, 4:54pm
           Collapse As films themselves... Dcole4 321 1 Nov 11, 6:04pm
               re: DOS and the forges scene There&ThereAgain 109 0 Nov 12, 12:43am
           Collapse I often wonder if I am the only one here who prefers the TEs Spriggan 192 1 Nov 11, 8:46pm
               My List hms_ocean 122 0 Nov 12, 12:15am
       Collapse Not sure how to rank them... Arannir 378 1 Nov 11, 5:14pm
           I would've much... BalrogTrainer 23 0 Nov 13, 2:01am
       In order of preference Glorfindela 383 0 Nov 11, 5:24pm
       Here goes! BlackFox 364 0 Nov 11, 5:28pm
       Collapse In terms of the added scenes... Elutherian 358 1 Nov 11, 5:41pm
           In terms of how I rank the films in general... Elutherian 328 0 Nov 11, 5:46pm
       In thinking of improving on the original film There&ThereAgain 330 0 Nov 11, 5:51pm
       Collapse Difficult Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 280 1 Nov 11, 6:38pm
           Movieverse Aragorn is an adult during Bilbo's adventure - Hanzkaz 225 0 Nov 11, 7:51pm
       My list Elessar 271 0 Nov 11, 6:41pm
       My ranking of the Extended Editions NecromancerRising 295 0 Nov 11, 6:42pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 873 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.