Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 9 of 987 (353583 posts in 14797 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 987 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Location Smaug the iron 512 9 May 24, 4:14pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Erebor CathrineB 476 4 May 24, 4:56pm
           Collapse Well Smaug the iron 469 3 May 24, 5:01pm
               Collapse Ah CathrineB 433 2 May 24, 6:16pm
                 The SHIRE since IT was "ADAPTED" from a Sheep Farm. Bombadil 429 0 May 24, 7:03pm
                   That's Earnslaw Burn Kilidoescartwheels 401 0 May 24, 7:30pm
       Collapse Earnslaw Burn Kilidoescartwheels 406 3 May 24, 7:27pm
           Ajsdsh CathrineB 398 0 May 24, 7:39pm
         Collapse Ian Brodie's Books are GREAT Bombadil 395 1 May 24, 7:58pm
               Also, his LOTR Location Books are in 2 Parts, Bombadil 361 0 May 24, 10:22pm

  Collapse What did we all expect from The Hobbit movies given the realities of movie making and PJ's history? Noria 1235 36 May 24, 1:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by Laineth)
       For myself Glorfindela 1057 0 May 24, 1:54pm
       Collapse To sum up Otaku-sempai 1032 1 May 24, 2:23pm
           OL' Bom will just wait to see the EE because.. Bombadil 1021 0 May 24, 2:43pm
       I for one... CathrineB 1014 0 May 24, 2:49pm
     Collapse Didn't consciously think about it re AUJ Avandel 1008 1 May 24, 2:55pm
           Argh - gotta PS my own post.... Avandel 990 0 May 24, 3:19pm
       Collapse What did I expect after three cinematic masterpieces? Aragorn the Elfstone 989 7 May 24, 3:41pm
           Collapse The second I saw the first designs for the dwarves I had doubts... AshNazg 969 5 May 24, 4:09pm
               Collapse Yes, that certainly instilled some doubt... Aragorn the Elfstone 962 2 May 24, 4:15pm
                   Collapse agreed lonelymountainhermit 912 1 May 24, 5:20pm
                     Bomby has learned to "Expect the Unexpected" from PJ&Co./// Bombadil 901 0 May 24, 5:25pm
               Collapse This! Avnar 625 1 May 25, 10:27am
                   yup lonelymountainhermit 585 0 May 25, 1:31pm
           Great post Bishop 903 0 May 24, 5:29pm
       Collapse This topic has been discussed many times under similar headings, however, it is Eruonen 856 1 May 24, 6:46pm
           Here is Something to think about...? Bombadil 771 0 May 24, 10:40pm
       Collapse Noria I have a lot of respect for you so I will jump in here Michelle Johnston 792 3 May 24, 10:30pm
           About the Dwarves Kilidoescartwheels 679 0 May 25, 4:44am
           Collapse Michelle, Noria 429 1 May 25, 9:06pm
               Lovely Reply Michelle Johnston 139 0 May 29, 6:23pm
       Collapse Siimple, really, and not unlike your own reaction.... dormouse 765 1 May 24, 10:48pm
           Yes. All of this. Laineth 59 0 Jun 5, 7:25am
       I was totally open minded with a tad of trepidation squiggle 762 0 May 24, 10:54pm
       Collapse the expectations CathrineB 751 1 May 24, 11:43pm
           Your last sentence is particularly interesting... AshNazg 741 0 May 25, 12:09am
       I just got back from The Avengers - Age of Ultron and was impressed with the character Eruonen 738 0 May 25, 12:14am
       Another magical trip to Middle Earth Elarie 581 0 May 25, 1:38pm
       Speaking as someone who was deeply disappointed in LOTR... RosieLass 490 0 May 25, 2:42pm
       Some at odds quotes about discontent - to remind me of perspective Eruonen 466 0 May 25, 4:20pm
       Collapse Met expectations Milieuterrien 440 2 May 25, 8:19pm
         GREAT Summary,,"Thang you Berry Buch".../// Bombadil 391 0 May 25, 10:01pm
           A few comments... Avandel 395 0 May 25, 10:20pm
       Well, Istaris'staffs 352 0 May 26, 5:49am
       interesting question - perhaps less indulgence and more consistency elostirion74 285 0 May 26, 5:48pm
       Collapse Simply put, these were not the movies I was hoping for NOR what I feel I was lead to believe we'd receive The Grey Elf 240 1 May 27, 2:01pm
           yes lonelymountainhermit 165 0 May 29, 3:32pm

  Collapse BotFA Extended Edition Clips MedwedtoBeorn 1529 8 May 23, 9:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Adrianna)
       Collapse Why would you do that? Mooseboy018 1404 1 May 23, 11:16pm
           No, clips! Adrianna 646 0 May 26, 12:33am
       Collapse Your title made my heart skip! AshNazg 1369 4 May 24, 12:15am
           Collapse I think Smaug the iron 1362 3 May 24, 12:23am
               Collapse I hope so. Mooseboy018 1332 2 May 24, 1:24am
                   Collapse My thought was the chariot scene... AshNazg 1328 1 May 24, 1:36am
                     Just what is PJ & Jabezz doing? Bombadil 1123 0 May 24, 11:53am
       Well... lionoferebor 954 0 May 24, 5:52pm

  Collapse How do you view the Hobbit trilogy next to the LOTR trilogy? Gandalf the Green 1732 131 May 23, 8:25am Jump to last post in thread (by Gandalf the Green)
       Sure CathrineB 1438 0 May 23, 8:40am
       Collapse Unfitting exposition of the movie Milieuterrien 1447 54 May 23, 8:49am
           Collapse ...yes, they do AshNazg 1417 53 May 23, 10:50am
               Collapse Well said AshNazg! I applaud you. lionoferebor 1380 2 May 23, 12:37pm
                   Collapse Indeed Gandalf the Green 1363 1 May 23, 1:25pm
                     Nah! It is Told with OLD Bilbo's Fuzzy memory.... Bombadil 1349 0 May 23, 1:53pm
               Collapse The absurdity of your statements shows Milieuterrien 1336 49 May 23, 2:19pm
                   Collapse What on Earth are you talking about? AshNazg 1321 48 May 23, 2:39pm
                       Collapse Do you belong to audiences Milieuterrien 1312 47 May 23, 2:49pm
                           Collapse I didn't say that it was a box office failure... AshNazg 1240 46 May 23, 4:54pm
                               exactamundo lonelymountainhermit 1223 0 May 23, 5:52pm
                               Collapse It's no useful talking about generalities that could be true about any movies Milieuterrien 1214 40 May 23, 6:12pm
                                   Collapse What? Mooseboy018 621 35 May 23, 9:35pm
                                       Collapse It would not be only a flash-beheading, like the ones in the movie Milieuterrien 595 34 May 23, 10:22pm
                                           Collapse Sorry but that's silly. Mooseboy018 579 22 May 23, 11:12pm
                                               Bolg Smaug the iron 570 0 May 23, 11:26pm
                                               Collapse You may criticize Milieuterrien 577 20 May 23, 11:28pm
                                                   Collapse It was testicles Glorfindela 358 1 May 24, 12:06am
                                                       It was not real testicles Smaug the iron 356 0 May 24, 12:12am
                                                   Collapse Funny thing about camera angles... Morthoron 356 16 May 24, 12:14am
                                                       Collapse Beorn Smaug the iron 351 15 May 24, 12:19am
                                                           Collapse What exactly has that to do with anything? Morthoron 351 4 May 24, 12:24am
                                                               Collapse You are hating PJ Smaug the iron 349 3 May 24, 12:34am
                                                                   Collapse Sorry, that is not the correct answer... Morthoron 341 1 May 24, 12:47am
                                                                       I understand and respekt your opinion. Smaug the iron 334 0 May 24, 12:57am
                                                                   Yeah, Morthoron! AshNazg 341 0 May 24, 1:01am
                                                           Collapse People were annoyed about Tom Bombadil's exclusion too... AshNazg 344 1 May 24, 12:39am
                                                               Are you kidding? Noria 525 0 May 24, 12:26pm
                                                           Collapse Bombadil in FotR Otaku-sempai 485 7 May 24, 2:31pm
                                                               Collapse Maybe they could have had Legolas rescue them // AshNazg 474 4 May 24, 2:46pm
                                                                   Collapse I do hope that you're joking! Otaku-sempai 473 3 May 24, 2:51pm
                                                                       Collapse Of course I was joking... AshNazg 464 2 May 24, 2:59pm
                                                                           Okay Otaku-sempai 457 0 May 24, 3:05pm
                                                                           When I think about it Smaug the iron 450 0 May 24, 3:05pm
                                                               Collapse Bombadil was Not effected by the ONE Ring.. Bombadil 467 1 May 24, 2:54pm
                                                                   I'm not sure what your point is, Bomby. Otaku-sempai 465 0 May 24, 2:59pm
                                                   People can have differing opinions Mooseboy018 318 0 May 24, 1:30am
                                           Collapse Have you seen Disney/Pixar's Brave? AshNazg 283 10 May 27, 8:15pm
                                               Collapse The difference, AshNazg, stays in the 3D/hdr stuff Milieuterrien 278 9 May 27, 8:28pm
                                                   Collapse Okay, so what's the difference between... AshNazg 251 8 May 27, 9:47pm
                                                       Collapse Legolas has elegance Milieuterrien 244 7 May 27, 10:28pm
                                                           Collapse Nothing to do with mocap... Bofur01 211 6 May 28, 8:05am
                                                               Collapse If mocap isn't needed to shape realism in facial movements, Milieuterrien 399 5 May 28, 8:20am
                                                                   Collapse They're not supposed to be furious dogs, nor wolves, but wargs. Bofur01 396 4 May 28, 8:33am
                                                                       Collapse I think they did their best with Wargs, but... Milieuterrien 387 3 May 28, 9:00am
                                                                           Wargs and Wolves arithmancer 367 0 May 28, 12:27pm
                                                                           Collapse FYI they did do some mocap for Wargs, apparently Lio 265 1 May 29, 1:41am
                                                                               Fine ! That image seems to be rare and I didn't hear about it Milieuterrien 232 0 May 29, 9:15am
                                   Collapse But redgiraffe 375 3 May 27, 4:41am
                                       Collapse Or course Thror's beheading is shocking, but much less than it could have been Milieuterrien 365 1 May 27, 7:00am
                                           Subthread removed. dernwyn 260 0 May 27, 9:17pm
                                       And? Otaku-sempai 317 0 May 27, 3:32pm
                               Collapse Well said Grand Bob 307 3 May 27, 1:50pm
                                   Collapse The feeling of the film may differ from the feeling of the book Milieuterrien 328 1 May 27, 2:54pm
                                       Yes, but... Grand Bob 315 0 May 27, 3:31pm
                                   agreed lonelymountainhermit 233 0 May 29, 4:00pm
       hmm lonelymountainhermit 1279 0 May 23, 3:58pm
       Collapse I view them as a continuous sequence of films.... dormouse 1178 4 May 23, 7:14pm
         Bomby will Go with our Lovely "Half-Elven" dormouse..anytime.. Bombadil 1157 0 May 23, 7:39pm
           Collapse What dormouse said, every word. Noria 639 2 May 23, 9:15pm
               Collapse That's my second most disliked scene, and for the same reason.... dormouse 597 1 May 23, 10:38pm
                   I agree completely about the Faramir scene. Noria 521 0 May 24, 12:33pm
       Just as the books really. Spriggan 664 0 May 23, 8:35pm
       This!! Avnar 650 0 May 23, 8:45pm
       Collapse I Get the 'slapstick' in the Hobbit movies & now can take the slapstick in LoTRs in a new fashion squiggle 331 7 May 24, 1:06am
           Collapse This THREAD is Like an OUT-OF-CONTROL Oldsmobile..? Bombadil 317 6 May 24, 2:44am
               Collapse Ad nauseam, Bombadil Milieuterrien 592 5 May 24, 3:32am
                   Collapse Bashing vs Criticism Mooseboy018 588 1 May 24, 4:08am
                       "Wordsmithing" is just like Any ARTFORM? Bombadil 571 0 May 24, 4:45am
                   Collapse A true fan speaks out lonelymountainhermit 446 2 May 24, 3:24pm
                       Collapse I have a feeling Christopher Tolkien.... dormouse 418 1 May 24, 4:14pm
                           perhaps lonelymountainhermit 408 0 May 24, 4:26pm
       Collapse I've made it into this thread too later, perhaps... DanielLB 353 17 May 24, 6:02pm
           This - in shedloads.... dormouse 300 0 May 24, 11:00pm
           Collapse I just want to bring up a point to see if people agree... AshNazg 302 14 May 24, 11:17pm
               Collapse Completely agreed lonelymountainhermit 293 11 May 25, 12:29am
                   Collapse What is more baffling to me Bishop 289 1 May 25, 12:36am
                       indeed lonelymountainhermit 281 0 May 25, 12:50am
                   Collapse Bomby will agree w/ ASHNAG but not with "HERMIT" Bombadil 655 5 May 25, 8:06am
                       Collapse but lonelymountainhermit 613 4 May 25, 1:34pm
                           Collapse And how is that relevant... dormouse 594 3 May 25, 2:36pm
                               Collapse maybe lonelymountainhermit 587 2 May 25, 2:49pm
                                   You know what they say about sarcasm...... // dormouse 549 0 May 25, 5:03pm
                                   money Mooseboy018 466 0 May 25, 9:55pm
                   Collapse "Solely for the purpose of greed"???????? dormouse 648 2 May 25, 8:47am
                     Collapse ABSOLUTELY Right, dmouse... Bombadil 640 1 May 25, 12:00pm
                         Bomby would like to tell a Short Story? Bombadil 632 0 May 25, 12:22pm
               Collapse Well, yes to the first..... dormouse 661 1 May 25, 7:56am
                   Great post dormouse.// Noria 472 0 May 25, 9:07pm
           Beautiful post tho Avandel 524 0 May 25, 6:48pm
       Collapse A little late, but chiming in Loresilme 399 38 May 27, 4:13pm
           Collapse The Lack of Consistency is Real Gandalf the Green 333 37 May 28, 8:24pm
               Collapse It's consistent to me Loresilme 311 36 May 28, 9:30pm
                   Collapse Does me good to read a post like this.... dormouse 310 2 May 28, 9:54pm
                       Collapse You are not alone Voronwë_the_Faithful 176 1 May 29, 1:27pm
                           :-) // dormouse 163 0 May 29, 2:02pm
                   Collapse How? I can't manage to view it that way... Gandalf the Green 306 31 May 28, 9:54pm
                       Collapse We seem to have posted at the same time... dormouse 298 30 May 28, 10:22pm
                           Collapse Designs aren't the only things about the visuals Gandalf the Green 291 19 May 28, 11:00pm
                               Collapse I suggest Milieuterrien 238 3 May 29, 9:06am
                                   Collapse You seem to misunderstand Gandalf the Green 164 2 May 29, 2:05pm
                                       Collapse I don't feel the need to understand your will to show up 'awfulness' Milieuterrien 242 1 May 29, 2:26pm
                                           Ironic Gandalf the Green 238 0 May 29, 2:31pm
                               Collapse Just once more.... dormouse 191 11 May 29, 12:37pm
                                   Collapse Many Examples of Ridiculousness in The Hobbit Gandalf the Green 171 10 May 29, 1:35pm
                                       Collapse One last time..... dormouse 165 6 May 29, 2:03pm
                                           Collapse Yes Gandalf the Green 162 5 May 29, 2:09pm
                                               Collapse But this isn't a discussion, it's a monologue.... dormouse 197 4 May 29, 3:19pm
                                                   Collapse Subjective VS Objective Gandalf the Green 194 3 May 29, 3:31pm
                                                       Collapse Well.... dormouse 310 2 May 29, 4:20pm
                                                           Legolas antics are a matter of equations Milieuterrien 290 0 May 29, 4:41pm
                                                           But Gandalf the Green 262 0 May 29, 5:09pm
                                       Collapse Someone help me out here... Bofur01 237 2 May 29, 2:26pm
                                           Collapse Isn't it obvious? Gandalf the Green 234 1 May 29, 2:41pm
                                               So it means it looks ridiculous. Bofur01 192 0 May 29, 3:28pm
                               Barrel scene / Amon Hen scene Loresilme 180 0 May 29, 1:27pm
                               Collapse Digital vs. film arithmancer 140 1 May 29, 10:07pm
                                   This is about a movie saga, not videos of Paris Gandalf the Green 85 0 Jun 1, 5:36pm
                           Collapse This, exactly. Loresilme 188 9 May 29, 12:32pm
                               Collapse Mmmm, thanks! I like ice cream :-) // dormouse 187 8 May 29, 12:40pm
                                   Collapse Lorsilme and dormouse, I agree. Noria 250 7 May 29, 2:14pm
                                       Collapse Moderation Gandalf the Green 247 6 May 29, 2:20pm
                                           Collapse Just off the top of the head Voronwë_the_Faithful 216 5 May 29, 2:54pm
                                               Collapse What? Gandalf the Green 224 4 May 29, 3:01pm
                                                   Collapse None ? Really ? Milieuterrien 205 3 May 29, 3:09pm
                                                       Collapse True Gandalf the Green 195 2 May 29, 3:18pm
                                                           Collapse If you're talking about wounds Milieuterrien 168 1 May 29, 3:43pm
                                                               No need to blame Tolkien Gandalf the Green 160 0 May 29, 3:57pm
                   Agree, I had no issue with the world presented. Eruonen 261 0 May 29, 3:44am
       LOTR inspires me to save up for a better TV, The Hobbit makes me want to buy editing software Bumblingidiot 220 0 May 29, 10:52am
     A reminder to stick to the topic and not post for the sake of criticising other board members. Ataahua 179 0 May 29, 7:46pm

Collapse Favorite Deaths? Bombadil 732 13 May 22, 9:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by beorn58)
       Collapse Smaug. Meneldor 610 6 May 22, 11:16pm
           Collapse Would you say DWALIN did the Most? Bombadil 565 5 May 23, 3:24am
               Collapse Of the Dwarves... AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 475 4 May 23, 1:55pm
                   Collapse How do they split up teamwork kills? Bofur01 473 3 May 23, 2:04pm
                       Collapse I'm Not 100% Sure AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 464 2 May 23, 2:21pm
                           Bilbo's Death TOTAL? Bombadil 450 0 May 23, 3:04pm
                         Your Total comes to 383 for the Dwarves? Bombadil 449 0 May 23, 3:15pm
     Collapse LOL Bomby Avandel 388 3 May 24, 1:25am
           Collapse You KNOW..if you are CAST as an ORC..? Bombadil 373 2 May 24, 3:23am
               Collapse HERE is one Random Incident, that has kinda got Skipped over? Bombadil 343 1 May 24, 11:31am
                   Troll-slaves Otaku-sempai 318 0 May 24, 2:37pm
       You mean "favorite death scene?" Kilidoescartwheels 296 0 May 24, 7:07pm
       I'm sure it would have been Bolg's death beorn58 98 0 May 30, 10:48pm

  Collapse My theory on the Watchful Peace and Angmar in the Hobbit movies ThorinsNemesis 800 18 May 22, 4:36am Jump to last post in thread (by ThorinsNemesis)
       Collapse The Watchful Peace on Film Otaku-sempai 672 17 May 22, 3:16pm
           Collapse Minas Ithil Otaku-sempai 639 16 May 22, 4:54pm
               Collapse Earnur, Minas Ithil and Angmar ThorinsNemesis 629 15 May 22, 5:35pm
                   Collapse Earnur and Fornost ThorinsNemesis 621 1 May 22, 5:53pm
                       Earnur as a Wraith Otaku-sempai 608 0 May 22, 6:11pm
                   Collapse Shadow of Mordor Otaku-sempai 617 12 May 22, 6:01pm
                     Collapse Aragorn and Earnur ThorinsNemesis 607 11 May 22, 6:13pm
                           Collapse Aragorn in the Films Otaku-sempai 598 10 May 22, 6:27pm
                               Collapse Years in the LOTR movies ThorinsNemesis 586 9 May 22, 6:40pm
                                   Collapse That is true. Otaku-sempai 583 8 May 22, 6:47pm
                                       Collapse Aragorn, Thranduil and Gandalf ThorinsNemesis 579 7 May 22, 7:00pm
                                           Collapse Aragandalf Otaku-sempai 575 6 May 22, 7:06pm
                                               Collapse Yes ThorinsNemesis 572 5 May 22, 7:18pm
                                                   Collapse No Viggo Otaku-sempai 568 4 May 22, 7:21pm
                                                       Collapse Why? ThorinsNemesis 562 3 May 22, 7:24pm
                                                           Bilbo was not de-aged with computers in FotR Otaku-sempai 556 0 May 22, 7:31pm
                                                           Collapse Some news articles say Hobbity Hobbit 550 1 May 22, 7:34pm
                                                               Yeah, probably ThorinsNemesis 542 0 May 22, 7:40pm

  Collapse Is it okay to like the movies? Kilidoescartwheels 1413 36 May 22, 1:45am Jump to last post in thread (by joec_34)
       Collapse Misinformed here, or not up to date… for when you get off your treadmill. . . Bracegirdle 1218 3 May 22, 2:18am
           Read the book three times, once when young, when I was older, and before the movies came out... Pandallo 1209 0 May 22, 2:35am
           Collapse Well that wasn't my point Kilidoescartwheels 1197 1 May 22, 3:13am
               In short ,my question was simply curiosity not judgmental or meant as criticism. Bracegirdle 1179 0 May 22, 4:01am
       Collapse But but but ... DanielLB 1153 11 May 22, 6:28am
           Wait a minute..... you LIKED that star wars prequels!?!?! adt100 1051 0 May 22, 11:04am
           Collapse Minor point of correction, Daniel Otaku-sempai 901 5 May 22, 3:32pm
               Collapse From what I remember shadowdog 825 2 May 22, 5:32pm
                   Collapse 2001 Otaku-sempai 809 1 May 22, 5:53pm
                       this is correct Bishop 798 0 May 22, 6:25pm
               Collapse Bad example. DanielLB 775 1 May 22, 7:15pm
                   Gah! // Aragorn the Elfstone 725 0 May 22, 8:50pm
           Collapse Well it was mostly a rant Kilidoescartwheels 705 1 May 22, 9:39pm
               No. DanielLB 516 0 May 22, 10:02pm
           Collapse Yay Episodes I, II and III! SirDennisC 296 1 May 24, 3:44am
               I like them too... joec_34 158 0 May 26, 4:18pm
       Collapse Of course CathrineB 1100 1 May 22, 8:44am
         OKAY? Bomby's Turn.. Bombadil 1064 0 May 22, 10:57am
       Collapse 'Course it is! :-) dormouse 984 3 May 22, 1:19pm
           Ooo, Ooo! Never knew the dormouse to block her spout Bracegirdle 956 0 May 22, 1:53pm
           Collapse That's one more, or one less, than me. sador 261 1 May 24, 7:31pm
               A preference. Adrianna 197 0 May 26, 1:47am
       Definitely OK Elarie 974 0 May 22, 1:22pm
       Well... Thrain II 938 0 May 22, 2:22pm
       It's OK to like (or dislike) both or either Glorfindela 936 0 May 22, 2:29pm
       Collapse I like them, too. RosieLass 909 6 May 22, 3:35pm
         Collapse Doesn't the word "Adaptation" mean Different..? Bombadil 849 5 May 22, 5:04pm
               Not "unrecognizably different." // RosieLass 764 0 May 22, 7:16pm
               Collapse Actually... lionoferebor 486 3 May 23, 1:02am
                   Collapse Wrong comparison. Otaku-sempai 399 1 May 23, 12:57pm
                       If you must know... lionoferebor 366 0 May 23, 3:58pm
                   The hobbit movies are not an adaptation on the book? Spriggan 337 0 May 23, 8:18pm
       sure lonelymountainhermit 728 0 May 22, 8:57pm
       Yes. Absolutely. Positively. Aragorn the Elfstone 531 0 May 22, 9:43pm
       Of course it is... Queen of Erebor 506 0 May 22, 10:18pm
       We might never know. Gandalf the Green 430 0 May 23, 8:29am

  Collapse Hobbit Accuracy to Books vs LOTR Accuracy to Books Hobbity Hobbit 1087 36 May 21, 10:20pm Jump to last post in thread (by elostirion74)
       Collapse Well, I can't agree, but... Otaku-sempai 966 1 May 21, 11:27pm
         JRRT wrote it, Sir PJ Adapted it, 80 years Later?// Bombadil 908 0 May 22, 3:37am
       Collapse Whaaaat?! AshNazg 853 18 May 22, 11:28am
           Collapse Do you honestly believe everything you just wrote? Skaan 848 16 May 22, 11:31am
               Collapse Yeah, Hobbity Hobbit 835 15 May 22, 11:58am
                   Collapse Hmmm, off the top of my head.... Morthoron 810 12 May 22, 1:07pm
                       Collapse It depends on how you measure "faithfulness" Voronwë_the_Faithful 794 9 May 22, 1:41pm
                           Collapse I understand what you're saying, V... Morthoron 784 8 May 22, 2:02pm
                               Collapse That's only one opinion Voronwë_the_Faithful 763 6 May 22, 2:55pm
                                   And Smaug the iron 756 0 May 22, 3:05pm
                                   Collapse Well, I won't defend Peter Jackson, in any case... Morthoron 687 4 May 22, 6:16pm
                                       Collapse So Smaug the iron 629 3 May 22, 7:38pm
                                           Collapse Certainly in the case of Bilbo rescuing the Dwarves from the spiders... Eleniel 618 2 May 22, 7:45pm
                                               Well Smaug the iron 609 0 May 22, 7:57pm
                                               Yes you're right Bishop 368 0 May 22, 7:59pm
                               Plus Voronwë_the_Faithful 734 0 May 22, 4:00pm
                       Characters Smaug the iron 785 0 May 22, 1:56pm
                       Radagast TheHutt 769 0 May 22, 2:45pm
                   Thranduil and Bard Otaku-sempai 748 0 May 22, 3:38pm
                   I don´t agree with your assessment of Bard & Thranduil elostirion74 145 0 May 26, 6:19pm
           Exactly lonelymountainhermit 675 0 May 22, 6:31pm
       I get what you're saying and agree about the Hobbit Elarie 789 0 May 22, 1:54pm
       Collapse Jackson took liberties with both trilogies Bishop 667 5 May 22, 7:03pm
           Collapse Bilbo Smaug the iron 642 4 May 22, 7:29pm
               Collapse I think Frodo Bishop 630 2 May 22, 7:40pm
                   Collapse Well Smaug the iron 363 1 May 22, 8:16pm
                       On comparisons Bishop 356 0 May 22, 8:27pm
               Bilbo, Frodo and "God" AshNazg 292 0 May 23, 11:43am
       Thanks Elarie! Hobbity Hobbit 638 0 May 22, 7:30pm
       For me, the Hobbit Trilogy would be more accurate to ME squiggle 338 0 May 22, 11:29pm
       Collapse I very much disagree, the LOTR films are MUCH more Tolkien-like, because Gandalf the Green 310 5 May 23, 8:08am
           Collapse Exactly this... Eleniel 261 4 May 23, 8:17pm
               Collapse I would have preferred the Dol Guldur plot... AshNazg 235 3 May 24, 12:23am
                   Collapse Movies should show, not tell Otaku-sempai 210 2 May 24, 2:42pm
                       Collapse But my proposition does show... AshNazg 207 1 May 24, 2:51pm
                           I don't entirely disagree with you. Otaku-sempai 203 0 May 24, 2:55pm

  Collapse The Carving above the Secret Door. Otaku-sempai 561 6 May 21, 5:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ilmatar)
       Collapse The carving Ilmatar 488 5 May 21, 7:26pm
           Collapse Thanks for this! Otaku-sempai 479 4 May 21, 7:32pm
               Collapse No problem :) Ilmatar 470 3 May 21, 7:45pm
                   Well... Otaku-sempai 467 0 May 21, 7:53pm
                   Collapse If the idea was that the King who held the Arkenstone.... dormouse 405 1 May 21, 10:40pm
                       :) Thank you, that sounds like a logical explanation! // Ilmatar 253 0 May 22, 10:34pm

  Collapse An honest discussion about Alfrid Bishop 1015 84 May 21, 3:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       Collapse Well Smaug the iron 885 4 May 21, 3:15pm
           Collapse A lot of people wanted the gold / gems Bishop 874 3 May 21, 3:25pm
               Collapse Alfrid reasons Smaug the iron 821 2 May 21, 4:19pm
                   Collapse I didn't really get that at all Bishop 809 1 May 21, 4:23pm
                       I diden't mean Smaug the iron 747 0 May 21, 5:18pm
       Collapse Someone for characters to talk to... AshNazg 885 30 May 21, 3:23pm
           Collapse I agree that he is a useful tool for narrative Bishop 862 29 May 21, 3:37pm
               Collapse As I said, Alfrid's continued inclusion is to create a mirror... AshNazg 751 28 May 21, 5:24pm
                   Collapse Humor Smaug the iron 430 22 May 21, 5:41pm
                       Collapse mixed bag Mooseboy018 366 5 May 21, 7:31pm
                           Collapse I think Smaug the iron 363 4 May 21, 7:40pm
                               Collapse We can only hope! // Otaku-sempai 353 2 May 21, 7:55pm
                                   Collapse depends on which one Mooseboy018 347 1 May 21, 7:59pm
                                     Just Checked IMDB, Ryan is in a new TV Series Bombadil 333 0 May 21, 8:24pm
                               Has there been anything official on this? Bishop 352 0 May 21, 7:58pm
                       Collapse There's no justification for such an abomination, IMHO Glorfindela 289 14 May 21, 10:20pm
                           Collapse Different cinemas, perhaps? Spriggan 260 13 May 21, 11:42pm
                               Collapse In reply Glorfindela 416 12 May 22, 7:15am
                                   Collapse Also recall... Goldeneye 359 6 May 22, 1:16pm
                                       Collapse That's as may be Glorfindela 351 4 May 22, 2:19pm
                                           Collapse Nauseam is just a matter of preference. Milieuterrien 347 3 May 22, 2:33pm
                                               Collapse I don't need your (or anyone else's) 'forgiveness' Glorfindela 342 2 May 22, 3:04pm
                                                   Collapse Apology Milieuterrien 321 1 May 22, 4:15pm
                                                       No problem Glorfindela 309 0 May 22, 4:42pm
                                       mixed feelings Mooseboy018 252 0 May 24, 5:37am
                                   Collapse Really? How odd! Spriggan 169 4 May 23, 8:10pm
                                       Collapse If you want to get personal… Glorfindela 296 3 May 23, 10:53pm
                                           Oh dear. My humour has been lost there. Spriggan 269 0 May 24, 1:30am
                                           Collapse Something that worries me... AshNazg 272 1 May 24, 1:31am
                                               PJ and comedy Glorfindela 229 0 May 24, 8:47am
                       I'm a Brit and I thought most of the humour was spot on :) adt100 382 0 May 22, 10:55am
                   Collapse Not that I'm aware of Kilidoescartwheels 324 4 May 21, 8:41pm
                       Collapse The New Esgaroth Otaku-sempai 315 1 May 21, 8:53pm
                           Bilbo told Smaug the iron 309 0 May 21, 9:09pm
                       Collapse Read it again... Eleniel 305 1 May 21, 9:32pm
                           Okay, people Kilidoescartwheels 247 0 May 22, 12:49am
       Collapse Alfrid and the Master of Lake-town Otaku-sempai 872 3 May 21, 3:26pm
           Collapse I agree Kilidoescartwheels 743 1 May 21, 5:21pm
               Not just any Hobbit ... DanielLB 420 0 May 22, 6:34am
           Yes, it appears PJ was trying to add the lessons of greed and redemption Eruonen 119 0 May 26, 5:18pm
       Collapse Alfrid is his Foil...even when Bard First gets to Laketown... Bombadil 849 9 May 21, 3:51pm
           Collapse Jackson did it... Otaku-sempai 801 8 May 21, 4:31pm
               Collapse I agree Bishop 783 7 May 21, 4:41pm
                   Collapse Alfrid in Dale? Bombadil 777 2 May 21, 4:47pm
                       Collapse None of those things are logical or necessary to me Bishop 768 1 May 21, 4:58pm
                           Well, there is ONE more thing to consider? Bombadil 749 0 May 21, 5:16pm
                   Collapse Not this. Otaku-sempai 778 1 May 21, 4:47pm
                       Except Bishop 774 0 May 21, 4:51pm
                   Collapse His presence... arithmancer 290 1 May 21, 10:02pm
                       Foil and contrast glor 267 0 May 21, 11:10pm
       Collapse Master´s book is a perfect coda for the theme of greed Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 818 3 May 21, 4:13pm
           Collapse Well yes, some ending for the character would have been better Bishop 811 2 May 21, 4:21pm
               The ONLY reason I can think of Kilidoescartwheels 732 0 May 21, 5:33pm
               Jackson could have got rid of Alfrid, and orc chase at Laketown and still had elves in the town being canon to the book Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 387 0 May 21, 6:47pm
       Jackson usually accesses populations through two or three "avatars" Spriggan 758 0 May 21, 5:07pm
       Collapse Alfrid Goldeneye 738 4 May 21, 5:26pm
           Collapse Yeah, Stephen Fry is good at comedy! Kilidoescartwheels 729 1 May 21, 5:34pm
               Time on Screen & Logistics Bombadil 412 0 May 21, 5:57pm
           Collapse Agree with everything you said... Salmacis81 386 1 May 21, 6:50pm
               Another thought... Morthoron 368 0 May 21, 7:27pm
       Didn't mind him in DoS too much... Salmacis81 391 0 May 21, 6:45pm
       Yiesh CathrineB 332 0 May 21, 8:29pm
       Collapse I'm curious about your use of 'honest'.... dormouse 273 4 May 21, 11:12pm
           I'm one of those. Milieuterrien 253 0 May 22, 12:25am
           Collapse I don't know. Honest as in fair? Bishop 223 2 May 22, 1:45am
               Well, I'll add a comment Avandel 439 0 May 22, 2:00am
               There are historical references as well. Bombadil 443 0 May 22, 2:22am
       Collapse I have to add my opinion ... DanielLB 424 1 May 22, 6:31am
         The World of Men in the 3RD Age...? Bombadil 392 0 May 22, 10:33am
       I honestly liked him! adt100 382 0 May 22, 10:53am
       Collapse I am floored by the rationale some people are making to excuse such a horribly written character. jtarkey 253 2 May 23, 11:50am
           I don't agree that he adds nothing... AshNazg 244 0 May 23, 12:15pm
           I can understand people not liking him, but... adt100 147 0 May 26, 4:20pm
       Collapse Alfrid is one of BOTFA’s weak aspects IMO Noria 237 10 May 23, 1:07pm
           Collapse Why do Bard 'use' Alfrid ? Let's have a look. Milieuterrien 226 9 May 23, 2:43pm
               Collapse On the contrary, it is deplorable storytelling.... Morthoron 210 8 May 23, 4:51pm
                   Collapse Bard said : Milieuterrien 200 7 May 23, 5:52pm
                       Collapse You need to read the book again. Perhaps more than once... Morthoron 191 6 May 23, 6:59pm
                           Collapse Do you have any problem with Sweden Smaug the iron 182 2 May 23, 7:30pm
                               Collapse And Starling 323 1 May 23, 8:28pm
                                   Yep, proper humour is private property. Milieuterrien 295 0 May 23, 10:33pm
                           Collapse Compared to Jackson's, Tolkien's Laketown (pic) is tinier Milieuterrien 182 2 May 23, 7:34pm
                               Collapse Another example... Morthoron 168 1 May 23, 8:13pm
                                   But the orcs in Sauron's army in BotFA Bofur01 324 0 May 23, 8:27pm

  Collapse Thorin's and Bilbo's Relationship Bishop 1027 27 May 20, 7:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
       Collapse The main problem with DOS Dcole4 793 3 May 20, 8:17pm
           Collapse Re: MEM 595 2 May 21, 3:25am
               Collapse original ending Mooseboy018 584 1 May 21, 4:11am
                   Thorin and Bilbo in the original script.... Pandallo 385 0 May 21, 5:09pm
       I interpreted the relationship shadowdog 791 0 May 20, 8:20pm
       Collapse The hug-fest at the end of AUJ was misplaced. RosieLass 764 6 May 20, 8:47pm
           Collapse Slightly different take Ilmatar 721 5 May 20, 9:54pm
               Collapse And another version Avandel 431 1 May 21, 2:57pm
                   I do agree... Ilmatar 410 0 May 21, 3:44pm
               Collapse I guess what I mean is... RosieLass 163 2 May 22, 3:45pm
                   Collapse Where Smaug the iron 154 1 May 22, 4:03pm
                       He never is. Mooseboy018 105 0 May 24, 5:30am
       Collapse Well CathrineB 765 4 May 20, 8:52pm
           Collapse Shipping arithmancer 727 1 May 20, 9:32pm
               Agreed re pretty graphics from shippers Avandel 551 0 May 21, 6:29am
           I might Laineth 688 0 May 20, 10:40pm
           You're not the only one... Queen of Erebor 684 0 May 20, 11:10pm
       In defense of Thorin Kilidoescartwheels 755 0 May 20, 8:58pm
       Collapse Thorin and Bilbo in AUJ arithmancer 753 1 May 20, 9:00pm
           Bilbo and Thorin's arc Mooseboy018 600 0 May 21, 2:39am
       Collapse Bilbo and Thorin´s relationship was one of the things I was completely satisfied with all the way elostirion74 718 3 May 20, 9:56pm
           Collapse Thorin's death arithmancer 656 2 May 21, 12:12am
             Collapse Bomby would hug someone who just saved my Life? Bombadil 637 1 May 21, 12:54am
                   But... arithmancer 623 0 May 21, 1:58am
       Collapse DOS EE Bilbo answers for Thorin infront the master of laketown Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 551 1 May 21, 6:28am
           That was a Key Turning Point well played... Bombadil 547 0 May 21, 6:46am
       I love it. Smaug the iron 446 0 May 21, 2:15pm

  Collapse Funeral and Chariot Scenes Laineth 770 1 May 20, 3:23pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Did read this, but THANKS for Bringing it Again!// Bombadil 521 0 May 21, 1:03am

  Collapse River of Denial part 3 - more Thorin pics!!! Kilidoescartwheels 759 11 May 20, 1:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by entmaiden)
       Collapse You had me worried for a moment there... dormouse 716 2 May 20, 1:58pm
         Collapse There is No Denying, your DENIAL..? // Bombadil 670 1 May 20, 2:49pm
               NOPE! Kilidoescartwheels 642 0 May 20, 3:45pm
       Collapse Aww CathrineB 635 4 May 20, 4:05pm
         Collapse Badassery for sure Avandel 592 1 May 20, 5:06pm
               Badassery for sure! Kilidoescartwheels 582 0 May 20, 5:25pm
           Well, can't forget Fili! Kilidoescartwheels 587 0 May 20, 5:13pm
           I removed your picture entmaiden 482 0 May 20, 10:24pm
     Collapse Of course Avandel 619 2 May 20, 4:38pm
           "THORINISTA", "FILIISTA", "KILIISTA" Bombadil 567 0 May 20, 5:54pm
           Here's a sneak peek of that happy moment Loresilme 568 0 May 20, 5:55pm

Collapse A Few Reasons these 2 Trilogies are SSOo..Different? Bombadil 1447 25 May 19, 9:16am Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       You're certainly right about The Hobbit films being a tragedy... jtarkey 1299 0 May 19, 10:59am
       3 Weddings and a Funeral Kilidoescartwheels 1211 0 May 19, 2:20pm
       Collapse Here's a nice comparison of the two trilogies "Style vs Function" AshNazg 1117 5 May 19, 6:49pm
         Collapse AN.. your Video does bring up some Interesting points Bombadil 1070 4 May 19, 8:07pm
               Collapse We have seen the movie he was destined to make... Morthoron 1023 3 May 19, 9:30pm
                   Collapse Nice Opinion? Have anything more to ADD?// Bombadil 992 2 May 19, 10:05pm
                       Collapse No, nothing further presently, however... Morthoron 992 1 May 19, 10:13pm
                         Well, "Thang YOU Berry BUCH..?"// Bombadil 928 0 May 20, 12:30am
       Collapse One Trilogy was more epochal for it's time, the other is more for it's Genre squiggle 959 1 May 19, 11:43pm
         In a way? PJ invented? the GENRE... Bombadil 893 0 May 20, 3:05am
       Collapse I refuse to admit Istaris'staffs 889 13 May 20, 5:49am
           Along that that lline, The Hobbit is a single book and not a trilogy Eruonen 775 0 May 20, 4:54pm
           Collapse I can't agree Kilidoescartwheels 723 11 May 20, 9:26pm
               Collapse I guess you are completely unaware... Morthoron 697 10 May 21, 12:19am
                   Collapse MOST Excellent post! Bombadil 676 1 May 21, 1:00am
                       You think it's great that he ran me down so badly? Kilidoescartwheels 515 0 May 22, 12:31am
                   Collapse I would imagine complaints about "development" arithmancer 663 1 May 21, 1:55am
                       Thank you for that Kilidoescartwheels 520 0 May 21, 11:54pm
                   Collapse Don't be so condescending Kilidoescartwheels 533 3 May 21, 11:52pm
                       Collapse I sort of get it. Otaku-sempai 496 2 May 22, 4:25am
                           Hm, not sure what to think of that Kilidoescartwheels 384 0 May 22, 9:49pm
                           This past April...double nickle. Eruonen 108 0 May 23, 12:46am
                   Collapse A reminder... Silverlode 488 1 May 22, 8:10am
                       Silverlode says it for me Noria 405 0 May 22, 6:42pm
       Looking at an object purely via the lens of another, is it more useful 'what is' rather than 'what is not'? squiggle 669 0 May 21, 1:40am

  Collapse DOS: Smaugs 'cool down sound' Legolas_Shoehorn 759 18 May 19, 5:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Bishop)
       Collapse proper sound effects Mooseboy018 702 1 May 19, 6:13am
           haha! Bishop 559 0 May 19, 2:42pm
       Theres also a few times where Smaug's wing hits the floor without making a sound AshNazg 663 0 May 19, 8:11am
       Collapse Hmm. arithmancer 586 1 May 19, 1:47pm
           Same here.... dormouse 578 0 May 19, 1:57pm
       Collapse My feeling on the wilhelm withstanding...... Bishop 535 12 May 19, 3:42pm
           We must remember these are PROFESSIONALS Bombadil 522 0 May 19, 3:53pm
           Collapse Actually ... Legolas_Shoehorn 521 10 May 19, 3:59pm
               Water stored underground for a few hundred years is probably pretty cool... Bofur01 510 0 May 19, 4:03pm
               Collapse I guess that's what you'd call the biology of fantasy Bishop 502 7 May 19, 4:12pm
                   ..."they took away his front legs"...MAYBE we should ASK Bombadil 337 0 May 20, 3:28pm
                   Collapse They didn't remove Smaug's forelegs. Otaku-sempai 326 5 May 20, 4:20pm
                       Collapse This is actually not true Bishop 317 4 May 20, 4:54pm
                           Collapse It is a matter of interpretation. Otaku-sempai 314 3 May 20, 5:00pm
                               Collapse I'm just making a distinction between forearms and wings Bishop 303 2 May 20, 5:09pm
                                   Collapse Indeed. Otaku-sempai 297 1 May 20, 5:26pm
                                       I think the problem Bishop 286 0 May 20, 5:52pm
               Balrogs Mooseboy018 480 0 May 19, 5:45pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 987 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.