Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 9 of 960 (345513 posts in 14395 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 960 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
Collapse "Thorin fights for his soul" scene - kudos to the unsung hero sound/light/color WETA folks Avandel 637 10 Jan 31, 2:19am Jump to last post in thread (by Elarie)
       Collapse I especially loved the dragon in the gold floor Elarie 246 2 Jan 31, 3:52am
           Collapse Not only the dragon in the gold Dame Ioreth 30 1 Feb 6, 1:50pm
               Thank you for pointing that out Elarie 31 0 Feb 6, 5:34pm
       Collapse I liked the scene up until Thorin starts drowning Earl 248 3 Jan 31, 6:04am
           Collapse Again I felt that avoided whats normally a clinche moreorless 239 2 Jan 31, 6:37am
               I really loved Thorin's internal battle... ecthelionsbeard 221 0 Jan 31, 6:43am
               Thank you! For me, THIS Avandel 128 0 Jan 31, 8:39pm
       An area I felt the Hobbit actually outdid LOTR... moreorless 242 0 Jan 31, 6:33am
       Collapse Agree with everything you say about the Thorin scenes, Avandel Glorfindela 182 1 Jan 31, 12:31pm
         RA is IMO spectacular Avandel 175 0 Jan 31, 8:41pm

  Collapse Anyone else feel the Misty mountains song didnt go with the tone of the movie? Thorins_apprentice 993 19 Jan 31, 1:19am Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       Collapse No. Fast forward to Thorin's death scene, Lissuin 486 1 Jan 31, 5:39am
           PS Pan's Labyrinth swordwhale 285 0 Jan 31, 4:55pm
       Collapse I felt like the rest of the movie didn't go with the tone of Misty Mountains :) Earl 475 4 Jan 31, 6:11am
           Collapse I agree. Elizabeth 430 2 Jan 31, 6:19am
               This! Arannir 347 0 Jan 31, 11:21am
               Yeah... Rembrethil 193 0 Jan 31, 11:41pm
           yaaaaaaaaaaaaaassssss swordwhale 282 0 Jan 31, 3:50pm
       Yes it was a magical start burrahobbit 357 0 Jan 31, 11:54am
       Collapse No - it's a spine-tingling moment that says so much.... dormouse 347 1 Jan 31, 12:06pm
           When the hidden door is opened... Riven Delve 329 0 Jan 31, 12:25pm
       No, not at all Glorfindela 321 0 Jan 31, 12:28pm
       What is the tone of the 480 minutes Michelle Johnston 259 0 Jan 31, 7:03pm
       Collapse Are you kidding??? Kilidoescartwheels 253 1 Jan 31, 9:23pm
           I don't think you are in a minority at all Glorfindela 193 0 Feb 1, 12:39am
       Collapse Not at all Kim 200 2 Feb 1, 1:50am
           Collapse Still dreaming... Pandallo 206 1 Feb 1, 3:27am
               Yes... Ereinion Nénharma 142 0 Feb 1, 9:21pm
       Do not agree with you at all mirkwoodwanderer 88 0 Feb 2, 5:44pm
       To some extent. Bumblingidiot 67 0 Feb 3, 1:05am

  Collapse Any "homages" to Rankin/Bass? stoutfiles 601 5 Jan 30, 10:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by ElendilTheShort)
       No Mooseboy018 308 0 Jan 30, 11:08pm
       Collapse Not that I recall. RosieLass 326 3 Jan 30, 11:21pm
           Collapse what Bakshi moments were there ElendilTheShort 80 2 Feb 4, 7:06am
               Collapse Apparently you've never seen the Bakshi film BalrogTrainer 55 1 Feb 5, 11:41am
                   seen it but its been a while ElendilTheShort 48 0 Feb 6, 5:43am

  Collapse That moment when Gandalf tries to clean his pipe... Radagast-Aiwendil 1763 41 Jan 30, 6:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Rythia)
       Collapse There is a thread... Ilmatar 764 1 Jan 30, 7:00pm
           Yes, once a thread has moved off the front page, entmaiden 457 0 Jan 31, 12:32am
       Your considered reaction... arithmancer 691 0 Jan 30, 7:50pm
       Collapse I already stated... Thrain II 678 15 Jan 30, 8:09pm
           Actually Starling 635 0 Jan 30, 8:18pm
           Different people react differently but that doesn't mean it's wrong... elf-lady 616 0 Jan 30, 8:36pm
           joke? Mooseboy018 478 0 Jan 30, 11:21pm
           Collapse This was one of my favorite scenes and I felt Gandalf's quiet presence Gwytha 435 11 Jan 31, 4:37am
               Agreed! cats16 376 0 Jan 31, 4:55am
               Collapse Without the Thrain II 344 9 Jan 31, 12:05pm
                   Collapse I don't know if you have been close to death Spriggan 361 1 Jan 31, 1:59pm
                       Well expressed, Spriggan. // Riven Delve 282 0 Jan 31, 4:58pm
                   Collapse No, it isn't inappropriate.... dormouse 337 1 Jan 31, 3:18pm
                       Yes, it is. Thrain II 301 0 Jan 31, 4:07pm
                   Collapse I would point out Starling 289 3 Jan 31, 6:43pm
                       Collapse also, in terms of appropriateness... Magpie 289 1 Jan 31, 7:11pm
                           Absolutely, Magpie – and Spriggan and Dormouse Glorfindela 257 0 Jan 31, 8:04pm
                       agree re: different kinds of laughter Ilmatar 175 0 Feb 1, 9:53pm
                   "This happened every time I watched it (5 times)" Farficom 254 0 Jan 31, 11:26pm
       Collapse Shows no emotion stoutfiles 664 3 Jan 30, 8:40pm
           Exactly this! Thrain II 588 0 Jan 30, 8:44pm
           no emotion? uncaring? Mooseboy018 485 0 Jan 30, 11:19pm
           Disagree Glorfindela 470 0 Jan 30, 11:32pm
       Collapse Occasionally, I feel a pang of sympathy for Jackson. Spriggan 657 3 Jan 30, 9:12pm
           Indeed Starling 550 0 Jan 30, 9:39pm
           Collapse PJ's net worth stoutfiles 525 1 Jan 30, 10:41pm
               I'm sure he will. Spriggan 486 0 Jan 30, 10:54pm
       It was a perfect scene and totally in character. Eruonen 512 0 Jan 30, 10:25pm
       I don't think Gandalf "decided" to have a smoke. Meneldor 534 0 Jan 30, 10:30pm
       I have mixed feelings about this scene. RosieLass 481 0 Jan 30, 11:32pm
       Collapse This is one of my favourite scenes of all grammaboodawg 416 3 Jan 31, 4:12am
           Collapse I agree with you. It ranks up there as one of my favorite moments too. Farficom 383 2 Jan 31, 6:53am
               Collapse oh my grammaboodawg 310 1 Jan 31, 12:25pm
                   Thag you. Farficom 223 0 Jan 31, 11:33pm
       Collapse For me this is one of the loveliest moments in all six movies. Noria 342 1 Jan 31, 1:28pm
           at first swordwhale 160 0 Feb 2, 3:43am
       One of my favourite scenes of the movie dubulous 247 0 Jan 31, 9:51pm
       Collapse An embrace without the embrace. Michelle Johnston 178 1 Feb 2, 6:45am
           Responsibility Miss-Merriweather 133 0 Feb 2, 11:56am
       It is fantastic mirkwoodwanderer 101 0 Feb 2, 5:46pm
       Great scene Rythia 53 0 Feb 5, 9:06pm

  Collapse DOS: Was Thranduil Referencing Morgoth? KingTurgon 793 4 Jan 30, 6:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by chauvelin2000)
       I think... Ereinion Nénharma 331 0 Jan 30, 10:08pm
       Collapse i think he was referencing sauron as this was the link the film makers were making, but......... ElendilTheShort 232 2 Jan 31, 9:12am
           Collapse well said swordwhale 168 1 Jan 31, 3:51pm
               Very cool insights and thoughtful use of Tolkien's 'applicability' ... chauvelin2000 84 0 Feb 2, 9:03am

  Collapse Too close to the book(s)? Brandybuckled 875 13 Jan 30, 3:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by Pandallo)
       Collapse There is one instance I can think of off the top of my head Glorfindela 522 5 Jan 30, 4:05pm
           Oooh, good one. Brandybuckled 357 0 Jan 30, 5:38pm
           But most of the "good bye's" weren' very close to the book. Elizabeth 337 0 Jan 30, 6:20pm
           Collapse IMO, the people who complained about the long goodbye weren't adequately invested in the films. Imladris18 276 2 Jan 30, 8:14pm
               Collapse Well, I was very invested in the films Glorfindela 214 1 Jan 30, 11:25pm
                   I was referring more specifically to the actual endings, not RotK as a whole. Imladris18 51 0 Feb 3, 12:39am
       The critics hated the first part of AUJ for this reason Elizabeth 383 0 Jan 30, 6:22pm
       Collapse I have a feeling Thrain II 319 2 Jan 30, 8:11pm
           Collapse I didn't like it... Salmacis81 230 1 Jan 30, 11:29pm
               I liked Thrain II 236 0 Jan 30, 11:41pm
       Collapse I could have done without Starling 318 1 Jan 30, 8:25pm
           I could have done without the burping Glorfindela 232 0 Jan 30, 11:28pm
       The Trolls Pandallo 63 0 Feb 3, 4:11am

Collapse WARNING..This is JUST for FUN? Bombadil 614 6 Jan 30, 2:24pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse I m glad to find movie dwarves supersticious too Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 236 2 Jan 30, 2:29pm
           Collapse POOR Fran..? Bombadil 187 1 Jan 30, 4:22pm
               I just to date a girl that looked like Fran Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 152 0 Jan 30, 5:59pm
       bear feets swordwhale 163 0 Jan 30, 5:32pm
       Collapse The shirt... arithmancer 132 1 Jan 30, 7:55pm
           IT was SSOoo..Nice to SEE Bombadil 117 0 Jan 31, 2:20am

  Collapse The Hobbit: One Film (what would make for a "definitive" cut) Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 674 13 Jan 30, 1:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by shadowmikeuk)
       Collapse I'm sorry you are unwell Glorfindela 321 3 Jan 30, 2:10pm
           Collapse I dont want to lead people to confusion, I love having 3 films Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 294 2 Jan 30, 2:15pm
               Collapse That sounds like shadowdog 262 1 Jan 30, 2:57pm
                   mm I think it does Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 248 0 Jan 30, 3:02pm
       Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 260 1 Jan 30, 3:00pm
           Yeah I like that Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 243 0 Jan 30, 3:04pm
       Collapse This is intended as description of a fan edit, right? arithmancer 237 3 Jan 30, 4:50pm
           Collapse it wouldnt be unpleasant IMO Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 217 2 Jan 30, 5:58pm
               Collapse Unpleasant... arithmancer 174 1 Jan 30, 7:59pm
                   Yeah Ii meant the second case of viewers Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 163 0 Jan 30, 8:22pm
       I don't think there is such a thing as a 'definitive' cut... dormouse 217 0 Jan 30, 5:29pm
       Not in the style Jackson directed the films... moreorless 151 0 Jan 31, 5:41am
       The Hobbit - The Tolkien Edit shadowmikeuk 52 0 Feb 5, 8:55pm

  Collapse Chapter of the Week: The Enemy Revealed BlackFox 360 8 Jan 30, 10:34am Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       Collapse "Our Enemy has returned" Riven Delve 124 1 Jan 31, 1:40am
           Thank you for replying, Riven Delve! BlackFox 90 0 Jan 31, 10:29am
       Collapse My answers arithmancer 87 1 Jan 31, 3:45pm
           Thank you for your input, arithmancer! BlackFox 76 0 Jan 31, 4:09pm
       Collapse We're back! Kim 71 1 Jan 31, 8:31pm
           Thank you, Kim! BlackFox 65 0 Jan 31, 9:01pm
       Collapse My thoughts Noria 46 1 Feb 1, 2:17pm
           Thank you for sharing your thoughts, Noria! // BlackFox 42 0 Feb 1, 3:03pm

  Collapse the two Fili! Andreorn89 1076 11 Jan 29, 9:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by Arveldis)
       Collapse Looks a little too old, I think. Pandallo 523 1 Jan 29, 10:26pm
           O'Gorman's Fili lionoferebor 407 0 Jan 30, 3:07am
       Collapse Cosplay CathrineB 483 1 Jan 29, 11:15pm
           I think... ecthelionsbeard 413 0 Jan 30, 1:26am
       Collapse Well, to be fair Riven Delve 282 2 Jan 30, 1:38pm
           well said swordwhale 217 0 Jan 30, 5:35pm
           Agreed...even Kili's look changed during filming... elvish.mafia 155 0 Jan 31, 6:17am
       Collapse We'll never know how it would have turned out, but... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 113 3 Jan 31, 4:51pm
           Collapse Welcome! Riven Delve 103 2 Jan 31, 5:06pm
               Collapse Agree, but... CathrineB 97 1 Jan 31, 6:57pm
                   I agree with this. Arveldis 82 0 Feb 1, 7:36pm

  Collapse Here's an excellent video essay sauget.diblosio 911 17 Jan 29, 8:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Michelle Johnston)
       Collapse Yet this video Lindele 501 12 Jan 29, 8:22pm
           Collapse I'd say that LotR had it's fair share of expectations going in, sauget.diblosio 451 10 Jan 29, 8:29pm
               Collapse Whether or not Lindele 431 2 Jan 29, 9:02pm
                   well said swordwhale 181 0 Jan 30, 5:42pm
                   A movie doesn't have to redefine cinema to get recognition... AshNazg 66 0 Feb 1, 12:35pm
               Collapse The expectations were as different as night and day. entmaiden 200 6 Jan 30, 4:48pm
                   Collapse To me... Salmacis81 138 5 Jan 31, 12:28am
                       Collapse My Expectations Were Driven By What The Film Makers Said Michelle Johnston 143 4 Jan 31, 2:41am
                           Collapse Can you imagine a single Hobbit film? AshNazg 78 3 Feb 1, 1:18pm
                               Collapse I can't speak for anyone else Spriggan 77 1 Feb 1, 1:33pm
                                   You do speak for me also BlackFox 63 0 Feb 1, 3:20pm
                               A Single Film Michelle Johnston 54 0 Feb 1, 9:29pm
         Expectations is the wrong word ... Legolas_Shoehorn 269 0 Jan 30, 6:54am
       Collapse Interesting polemic burrahobbit 427 1 Jan 29, 9:30pm
           Distance Travelled Michelle Johnston 134 0 Jan 31, 3:40am
       i love hobbit films anyway Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 234 0 Jan 30, 1:10pm
       Biggest difference and the one that IMHO really hurt the Hoibbit movies: Arannir 116 0 Jan 31, 11:27am

Collapse HAS the "EMBARGO" been Lifted YET? Bombadil 668 1 Jan 29, 7:24pm Jump to last post in thread (by swordwhale)
       oooooooooooooooooooo o.O swordwhale 141 0 Jan 30, 5:49pm

  Collapse What happens to the Goblins anyways? Bishop 821 28 Jan 29, 3:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by AshNazg)
       Collapse Sunlight Merovech 451 20 Jan 29, 4:04pm
           Collapse I guess that's why I asked Bishop 407 18 Jan 29, 4:47pm
               Collapse I believe Elessar 397 12 Jan 29, 4:50pm
                   Collapse Yes, that could be the intention Bishop 372 11 Jan 29, 4:53pm
                       Collapse I guess Elessar 362 10 Jan 29, 4:55pm
                           Collapse I think if Jackson had gone for a more stormy look Bishop 369 9 Jan 29, 5:05pm
                               Collapse Of course Elessar 322 8 Jan 29, 5:30pm
                                   Collapse I think thats something that much easier to write than to film moreorless 129 7 Jan 30, 1:10pm
                                       Along with the bats... Otaku-sempai 111 0 Jan 30, 3:04pm
                                       Collapse Good Point Elessar 109 5 Jan 30, 3:16pm
                                           Collapse I certainly would not have picked at that... Salmacis81 69 4 Jan 30, 11:45pm
                                               Agree to disagree I guess Elessar 65 0 Jan 31, 1:13am
                                               Collapse Just because..... dormouse 46 2 Jan 31, 11:54am
                                                   Collapse Done that already... arithmancer 35 1 Jan 31, 3:48pm
                                                       Crumbs, yes, you're right..... dormouse 28 0 Jan 31, 4:09pm
               Collapse Perhaps... BlackFox 359 4 Jan 29, 5:04pm
                   Collapse I don't think that's as plausible.. Bishop 341 3 Jan 29, 5:08pm
                       Collapse Sure, but... BlackFox 326 2 Jan 29, 5:16pm
                           Collapse "I know your king was just killed and all, but I got this" Bishop 323 1 Jan 29, 5:30pm
                             Exactly! BlackFox 271 0 Jan 29, 6:37pm
           Gandalf says "Only one thing can save us now, daylight" AshNazg 33 0 Jan 31, 8:48pm
       Collapse Coffee Break. n/m Brandybuckled 352 1 Jan 29, 5:03pm
           heh! Bishop 328 0 Jan 29, 5:06pm
       Collapse Problems organizing. Darkstone 228 3 Jan 29, 10:17pm
         Collapse When the Goblin-King Crashed Bombadil 194 2 Jan 30, 2:30am
               Collapse People just have different tastes. / Darkstone 162 1 Jan 30, 4:17am
                   To each their own... Bishop 160 0 Jan 30, 5:03am
       I'm with Darkstone and Bomby swordwhale 99 0 Jan 30, 5:58pm

  Collapse Alternative Structure / Scenes / Events for TH movies (Long Post) Arannir 959 24 Jan 29, 9:41am Jump to last post in thread (by Michelle Johnston)
       An interesting read. Macfeast 477 0 Jan 29, 10:39am
       Very interesting read... Eleniel 461 0 Jan 29, 10:48am
       "There and Back Again" Arannir 456 0 Jan 29, 2:26pm
       A good idea! KingTurgon 387 0 Jan 29, 2:59pm
       Collapse It's a very interesting read.... dormouse 372 1 Jan 29, 4:23pm
           Thanks to all tjlhe feedback by several people. Arannir 285 0 Jan 29, 8:19pm
       Collapse Thanks for a very interesting read Bishop 328 1 Jan 29, 6:17pm
           Absolutely. Arannir 277 0 Jan 29, 8:27pm
       Collapse Thanks for all your hard work. Michelle Johnston 331 14 Jan 29, 6:27pm
           Collapse Thanks and agreed on your general points. Arannir 288 13 Jan 29, 8:22pm
               It has to pass the test of a one stop experience Michelle Johnston 206 0 Jan 30, 8:29am
               Collapse Here's mine KingTurgon 187 3 Jan 30, 5:03pm
                   Collapse An Unexpected Mini Series Michelle Johnston 134 2 Feb 1, 9:11am
                       One significant typo I noticed tho lol KingTurgon 121 0 Feb 1, 5:48pm
                       Regarding the mini series KingTurgon 103 0 Feb 5, 5:27am
               Collapse As promised. Michelle Johnston 74 7 Feb 7, 3:18am
                   Thanks so much. Arannir 67 0 Feb 7, 10:10am
                   Collapse This is marvellous. Arannir 43 5 Feb 17, 3:58pm
                       Collapse Thank you for your witness Michelle Johnston 46 4 Feb 18, 11:29am
                           Collapse Thanks. Arannir 35 3 Feb 18, 12:44pm
                               The Commentaries Michelle Johnston 30 0 Feb 18, 9:49pm
                               Your Examples Michelle Johnston 26 0 Feb 19, 2:33am
                               An Update Michelle Johnston 19 0 Feb 22, 2:01am
       It was well done... MyWeeLadGimli 224 0 Jan 30, 5:46am

  Collapse Would have repented Thorin liked to be buried with the arkenstone? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 391 3 Jan 29, 9:11am Jump to last post in thread (by Mr. Arkenstone (isaac))
       It was the highest honor that any King Under the Mountain could have Elarie 194 0 Jan 29, 1:47pm
       Collapse If we see it I wouldnt be supprized if thats part of the reason why... moreorless 91 1 Jan 30, 8:29am
           Dain humbler ruler, I like that Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 83 0 Jan 30, 1:00pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 960 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.