Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 9 of 973 (349272 posts in 14582 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 973 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse TH trilogy BluRay WOODEN BOX! TheHutt 1157 7 Mar 19, 10:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
     Collapse *sighs* Avandel 1050 1 Mar 19, 11:56pm
           Answering my own post re contents Avandel 691 0 Mar 20, 4:35pm
       There is only one question... laurethiel1138 1036 0 Mar 20, 12:15am
       hmmm balbo biggins 988 0 Mar 20, 12:56am
       Whoa, that is seriously cool Kim 903 0 Mar 20, 5:22am
       Collapse Looks too much like a coffin for a rabbit to me :D Arannir 836 1 Mar 20, 9:55am
           Thanks for the chuckle! // VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 759 0 Mar 20, 1:21pm

  Collapse Sauron - How many times ... Legolas_Shoehorn 950 7 Mar 19, 7:55am Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       Collapse I think... Arannir 912 1 Mar 19, 8:24am
           "If our enemy has returned..." BlackFox 879 0 Mar 19, 10:05am
       Collapse Well... BlackFox 880 4 Mar 19, 10:02am
           Collapse Gandalf in the WC meeting also says Sauron leonmuse 839 3 Mar 19, 11:39am
               Collapse I knew I was forgetting something BlackFox 806 2 Mar 19, 12:31pm
                   Collapse you're welcome! leonmuse 763 1 Mar 19, 2:18pm
                       Surprisingly few BlackFox 749 0 Mar 19, 2:24pm

  Collapse Dol Goldur Fan Edit (Gandalf's whole side-quest) leonmuse 1175 12 Mar 19, 3:37am Jump to last post in thread (by guitarzankansasfan)
       Collapse shutdown balbo biggins 959 9 Mar 19, 2:34pm
           Collapse won't happen with time Magpie 954 1 Mar 19, 2:40pm
               i bet balbo biggins 934 0 Mar 19, 3:04pm
           Collapse I was looking at threads from 2004 on these boards AshNazg 950 6 Mar 19, 2:52pm
               I have to agree here Pandallo 938 0 Mar 19, 2:58pm
               Collapse Some of the difference may be due to entmaiden 939 1 Mar 19, 3:03pm
                   Copyright was still an issue... AshNazg 934 0 Mar 19, 3:18pm
               Collapse Out of interest Spriggan 892 2 Mar 19, 4:08pm
                   Collapse Oh, you're right. I was looking at 2007 threads... AshNazg 836 1 Mar 19, 6:09pm
                       No worries - I thought there might be an archive somewhere. Spriggan 626 0 Mar 20, 11:55am
       uh oh Goldeneye 771 0 Mar 19, 9:09pm
       That's almost like creating the "Bridge film" guitarzankansasfan 457 0 Mar 21, 3:51pm

  Collapse Can anyone with skill make a photoshop putting Thror in the place of Thorin, and Thrain instead anyother dwarf except Balin and Dwalin? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1099 11 Mar 18, 4:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Collapse More specific? gliido 1010 4 Mar 18, 4:58pm
           Collapse no specific scene Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1002 3 Mar 18, 5:22pm
               Collapse So..... He is a wizard, you know! 942 1 Mar 18, 6:51pm
                   No, Thorin for Thror Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 926 0 Mar 18, 7:12pm
               WHY??? Kilidoescartwheels 516 0 Mar 19, 8:19pm
       Collapse You might want to see this 'shop job that TORn did... Eleniel 888 3 Mar 18, 8:19pm
           Collapse Yeah something like thatbut with the whole gang Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 872 2 Mar 18, 8:26pm
               Collapse I'm still confused... He is a wizard, you know! 749 1 Mar 19, 1:17am
                   OP wants a screenshot from The Hobbit of Thorin... QuackingTroll 740 0 Mar 19, 1:51am
       Collapse Like this sort of? Bishop 698 1 Mar 19, 5:38am
           Wouldn't it be great to also have Rob Kazinsky AshNazg 586 0 Mar 19, 2:42pm

  Collapse "The Genius of Bofur" KRRouse 1220 15 Mar 17, 10:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by Brethil)
       Collapse dwarves balbo biggins 1119 1 Mar 17, 10:27pm
           No chance! He is a wizard, you know! 1087 0 Mar 17, 11:19pm
     Collapse The writer of this analysis makes Bombadil 740 4 Mar 19, 9:34am
           Collapse Mistake? Oin getting a new Ear Trumpet...// Bombadil 729 1 Mar 19, 9:59am
             Also, Bofur got to Lead the Bombadil 720 0 Mar 19, 11:57am
           Collapse Bom, I'm confused..... He is a wizard, you know! 623 1 Mar 20, 2:53am
               Mostly in Bom's SPECULATIVE post above.. Bombadil 599 0 Mar 20, 10:58am
       Collapse I loved Bofur in the first film... banaili 403 1 Mar 22, 1:57pm
           Oin! marary 378 0 Mar 22, 8:19pm
       Collapse good stuff swordwhale 351 5 Mar 23, 1:11am
         Collapse KICK SUM ORCish Butt!... analysis .. Bombadil 298 4 Mar 23, 10:37pm
               Collapse I think it suffered somehow in translation... swordwhale 244 3 Mar 24, 2:26pm
                   Collapse Don't know if you revised it since the TAS-3 run Brethil 232 2 Mar 24, 5:04pm
                       Collapse hey yeah! swordwhale 212 1 Mar 25, 1:55am
                         Google Docs can be a wrestling match at times! Brethil 179 0 Mar 26, 12:46am

  Collapse I think there's more to the Sauron vs Galadriel "fight" ... Arandir 1626 28 Mar 17, 7:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by ber20)
       Collapse There should be a Saruman vs Sauron scene. erdildeniz 1480 3 Mar 17, 8:28pm
           Collapse That's not really true. Spriggan 873 2 Mar 19, 1:35pm
               Collapse Right. Otaku-sempai 850 1 Mar 19, 2:27pm
                   On the stone Spriggan 824 0 Mar 19, 4:03pm
       Agreed, BornOutOfTheWest 1451 0 Mar 17, 8:44pm
       I agree with your thoughts MechaGodzilla 1425 0 Mar 17, 9:02pm
       Collapse Three Rings Mooseboy018 1419 1 Mar 17, 9:04pm
           Soundtrack TiberiusOgden 1346 0 Mar 17, 10:16pm
       Agreed. Arannir 1386 0 Mar 17, 9:40pm
       Definitely there must be more ... ;o) TiberiusOgden 1362 0 Mar 17, 10:04pm
       Collapse I really hope that the Dol Guldur scene is not just significantly expanded, but also significantly changed VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 1344 16 Mar 17, 10:28pm
           Collapse Radagast Mooseboy018 1264 15 Mar 18, 2:16am
               Collapse It's too late to edit things out now....despite what we like and what we don't like ..so Girdle of Melian 926 14 Mar 19, 4:51am
                   Bomby STILL has Hope Bombadil 895 0 Mar 19, 9:55am
                   Collapse Exactly ;o) TiberiusOgden 842 12 Mar 19, 3:12pm
                       Collapse Radagast and Beorn? Otaku-sempai 825 11 Mar 19, 4:09pm
                           Collapse It is almost without a doubt filmed. Pandallo 820 10 Mar 19, 4:17pm
                               Collapse Well, ASK yourself This..? Bombadil 771 1 Mar 19, 8:03pm
                                   ONE more Reason..for the Statue? Bombadil 689 0 Mar 20, 11:37am
                               Collapse There's also the LEGO set that has Beorn at Dol Guldur. Imladris18 675 1 Mar 20, 1:09pm
                                   Yes. I agree with that. Otaku-sempai 656 0 Mar 20, 2:25pm
                               Collapse Radagast and Beorn was supposed to be a flashback... AshNazg 652 5 Mar 20, 2:59pm
                                   Okay Otaku-sempai 628 0 Mar 20, 4:50pm
                                   Collapse Wow... Arannir 305 1 Mar 23, 8:42am
                                       Or not Elessar 121 0 Mar 23, 1:07pm
                                   That's interesting... dormouse 132 0 Mar 23, 10:54am
                                   I recall something about that Elessar 123 0 Mar 23, 1:06pm
     It isn't really a Fight... ber20 89 0 Mar 24, 2:48am

  Collapse Bifur Smaug the iron 742 5 Mar 17, 6:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Welcome, Smaug the iron! Roheryn 439 4 Mar 19, 9:33am
         Collapse If you would Allow us to know your Native tongue..? Bombadil 438 1 Mar 19, 9:43am
               Sweden Smaug the iron 407 0 Mar 19, 4:20pm
           Collapse Thank you Smaug the iron 413 1 Mar 19, 4:18pm
               There are members from SWEDEN but it's NOT Bombadil 381 0 Mar 19, 6:57pm

  Collapse TBOTFA Pick-Ups Legomir 2283 120 Mar 17, 3:47am Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Collapse A Hunch... Dcole4 2041 1 Mar 17, 4:14am
           Tauriel Kilidoescartwheels 444 0 Mar 19, 8:28pm
       Collapse I think the entire Ravenhill Scene... Legolas_Shoehorn 1984 1 Mar 17, 7:10am
           Correct me if I'm wrong Legomir 1855 0 Mar 17, 11:18am
       Collapse Yeah CathrineB 1959 108 Mar 17, 7:45am
           Collapse I wonder Legomir 1854 107 Mar 17, 11:21am
               Collapse The Ravenhill sequence as a later addition. Otaku-sempai 1721 106 Mar 17, 2:14pm
                   Collapse so sad Goldeneye 1650 105 Mar 17, 3:53pm
                       Collapse I know!! CathrineB 1614 4 Mar 17, 4:25pm
                           Collapse Whoa, there..... dormouse 874 3 Mar 17, 8:41pm
                               I agree Legomir 772 0 Mar 17, 11:19pm
                               Collapse Sorry... Otaku-sempai 737 1 Mar 18, 12:34am
                                   Don't be sorry.... dormouse 626 0 Mar 18, 8:45am
                       The death scenes are pretty good tbh Skaan 1613 0 Mar 17, 4:27pm
                       Collapse Absolutely! VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 1596 25 Mar 17, 4:52pm
                           Collapse whoa Goldeneye 1574 22 Mar 17, 5:03pm
                               Collapse Maybe VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 1567 6 Mar 17, 5:11pm
                                   Collapse Correction Goldeneye 1556 5 Mar 17, 5:24pm
                                       Actually... Darkstone 1522 0 Mar 17, 5:53pm
                                       That surprises me not at all // VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 1486 0 Mar 17, 6:13pm
                                       opinions mate CathrineB 1403 0 Mar 17, 7:37pm
                                       subject marillaraina 685 0 Mar 18, 4:51am
                                       Reactions certainly vary, Roheryn 494 0 Mar 19, 9:45am
                               Collapse But they WEREN'T depicted in the book Kilidoescartwheels 443 14 Mar 19, 8:40pm
                                   Collapse I beg to differ... Eleniel 422 13 Mar 19, 10:44pm
                                       Collapse Or... Otaku-sempai 346 10 Mar 20, 2:33pm
                                           Collapse Bodyguards and heirs Elanor of Rohan 453 9 Mar 21, 10:52am
                                               Collapse Heirs in Battle Otaku-sempai 443 6 Mar 21, 11:54am
                                                   Collapse The Theme of Family. Michelle Johnston 426 5 Mar 21, 1:14pm
                                                       Collapse One heir..... dormouse 396 4 Mar 21, 3:09pm
                                                           I totally agree with what you said Elanor of Rohan 386 0 Mar 21, 3:39pm
                                                           I agree with all of this lionoferebor 364 0 Mar 21, 5:52pm
                                                           Collapse Sorry DM that was loose wording on my part Michelle Johnston 339 1 Mar 21, 8:11pm
                                                               Yes, but film isn't only about conversation.... dormouse 264 0 Mar 22, 10:16am
                                               Collapse Nowadays, no, it is not considered a good idea... Eleniel 409 1 Mar 21, 2:17pm
                                                   probably I was just summarizing my previous threads' pov Elanor of Rohan 388 0 Mar 21, 3:36pm
                                       Perfectly reasonable interpretation, but then Spriggan 334 0 Mar 20, 2:58pm
                                       I certainly never pictured it any differently than this when reading the book VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 404 0 Mar 21, 2:31pm
                           Collapse I think you may be confusing yourself with someone else. N.E. Brigand 842 1 Mar 17, 9:32pm
                               I'm flattered! VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 804 0 Mar 17, 10:21pm
                       Collapse Well, the trouble with 'going out in glory in the thick of the battlefield' dormouse 1394 9 Mar 17, 7:43pm
                           Collapse re: dormouse Goldeneye 1372 8 Mar 17, 7:58pm
                               And if you wanted to do the same thing with the three dwarves. Macfeast 895 0 Mar 17, 8:16pm
                               Collapse wonderfully put marary 890 3 Mar 17, 8:26pm
                                   Collapse All in good fun :) lionoferebor 765 2 Mar 17, 11:32pm
                                       Collapse Thorin's part in it marary 663 1 Mar 18, 5:36am
                                           Halls of Mandos lionoferebor 636 0 Mar 18, 8:19am
                               Actually... Darkstone 882 0 Mar 17, 8:39pm
                               Collapse The same movie? dormouse 854 1 Mar 17, 9:03pm
                                   Sometimes... Darkstone 848 0 Mar 17, 9:14pm
                       Collapse Instagram Arannir 830 62 Mar 17, 9:32pm
                           Collapse Yes that really focus's the individuals within the drama of Ravenhill Michelle Johnston 616 61 Mar 18, 9:07am
                               Collapse Wraith world? dormouse 561 56 Mar 18, 11:32am
                                   Collapse Narzag's Interrogation Michelle Johnston 553 55 Mar 18, 11:52am
                                       Collapse Morgul-arrow Otaku-sempai 512 1 Mar 18, 1:27pm
                                           Thank you again Michelle Johnston 476 0 Mar 18, 2:21pm
                                       Collapse Definitely only poisoned VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 480 2 Mar 18, 2:21pm
                                           Collapse Thank you Michelle Johnston 734 1 Mar 18, 2:23pm
                                               Careless filmmaking VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 732 0 Mar 18, 2:30pm
                                       Collapse Well, I thought he called him the black-haired archer.... dormouse 725 49 Mar 18, 2:56pm
                                           Collapse "Morgul-wound" Darkstone 707 44 Mar 18, 3:21pm
                                               Collapse Yes.... dormouse 701 41 Mar 18, 3:29pm
                                                   Collapse N˙menˇrean blood makes a big difference Darkstone 686 40 Mar 18, 3:50pm
                                                       Fair enough! // dormouse 669 0 Mar 18, 3:58pm
                                                       Collapse Not that much by this time pettytyrant101 677 38 Mar 18, 4:05pm
                                                           Collapse "the blood of Westernesse " Darkstone 657 37 Mar 18, 4:34pm
                                                               Collapse I didnt say it was spent pettytyrant101 656 36 Mar 18, 4:39pm
                                                                   Collapse As with Tolkien's magic in the texts Spriggan 338 35 Mar 20, 2:54pm
                                                                       Collapse My issue pettytyrant101 438 34 Mar 20, 4:11pm
                                                                           Collapse Without picking through all of that. Spriggan 434 33 Mar 20, 4:26pm
                                                                               Collapse Im not sure you did read it pettytyrant101 428 32 Mar 20, 4:35pm
  Collapse Fear not, I did. Spriggan 419 31 Mar 20, 4:50pm
       Collapse I do have to agree with p.t.101 to some extent Otaku-sempai 408 14 Mar 20, 5:12pm
           Collapse You see, to my mind, there aren't any "ramifications" Spriggan 393 13 Mar 20, 5:23pm
               Collapse Historical changes Otaku-sempai 384 12 Mar 20, 5:38pm
                   Collapse All of which is the "slot" Spriggan 378 11 Mar 20, 5:44pm
                       Collapse I dont disagree here pettytyrant101 372 4 Mar 20, 6:07pm
                           Collapse I don't recall any Spriggan 357 3 Mar 20, 6:35pm
                               Collapse Timeline? Otaku-sempai 350 2 Mar 20, 6:45pm
                                   Collapse I'm with the topic Spriggan 343 1 Mar 20, 6:54pm
                                       Yes, I suppose that Orcs could have siezed Minas Ithil Otaku-sempai 337 0 Mar 20, 7:04pm
                       Collapse Internal consistancy Otaku-sempai 354 5 Mar 20, 6:36pm
                           Collapse Looking back to your example, Spriggan 342 4 Mar 20, 6:50pm
                               Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 337 3 Mar 20, 6:59pm
                                   Collapse Ha - you are still slotting! Spriggan 329 2 Mar 20, 7:15pm
                                       Collapse The problem is that I am a book-firster Otaku-sempai 327 1 Mar 20, 7:25pm
                                           Oh me too. Spriggan 323 0 Mar 20, 7:33pm
       Collapse My point is pettytyrant101 407 15 Mar 20, 5:12pm
           Collapse I can't see why those rules wouldn't apply Spriggan 402 14 Mar 20, 5:17pm
               Collapse You are right. Otaku-sempai 397 13 Mar 20, 5:21pm
                   Collapse Chekhov's blade VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 362 12 Mar 20, 6:29pm
                       Collapse For me, I don't think it was suggested to have significance Spriggan 355 6 Mar 20, 6:42pm
                           Collapse The foundations of the story feeling Michelle Johnston 599 5 Mar 20, 7:48pm
                               Collapse I once joked that I was making a list of things in these stories which are not iconic... Spriggan 583 4 Mar 20, 8:14pm
                                   Collapse Thanks Michelle Johnston 497 3 Mar 21, 6:44am
                                       Collapse I feel like I might be misunderstanding something. Spriggan 480 2 Mar 21, 9:40am
                                           Collapse Lets agree to disagree Life Is To Short Michelle Johnston 437 1 Mar 21, 12:21pm
                                               OK? Spriggan 423 0 Mar 21, 1:43pm
                       The Morgul-knife Otaku-sempai 356 0 Mar 20, 6:42pm
                       Collapse Most of whose issues are in my head? pettytyrant101 597 3 Mar 20, 7:58pm
                           Collapse Thank you for proving my point // VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 579 2 Mar 20, 8:19pm
                               Collapse Perhaps, aside from making snide remarks pettytyrant101 575 1 Mar 20, 8:36pm
                                   I have had many wonderful discussions with critics of Jackson's films VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 559 0 Mar 20, 8:53pm
                                               Collapse Not sure about getting it right pettytyrant101 698 1 Mar 18, 3:37pm
                                                   Thank you Michelle Johnston 626 0 Mar 18, 5:50pm
                                           Collapse Thanks D M Michelle Johnston 617 3 Mar 18, 6:09pm
                                               Collapse Don't overthink it VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 598 2 Mar 18, 6:33pm
                                                   Collapse Good Idea Michelle Johnston 589 1 Mar 18, 7:07pm
                                                       Meanwhile, I hope you feel better soon VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 562 0 Mar 18, 9:14pm
                               Collapse Hm. Arannir 520 3 Mar 18, 1:18pm
                                   The Morgul Arrow Michelle Johnston 493 0 Mar 18, 2:07pm
                                   Collapse Thorins arc. Michelle Johnston 728 1 Mar 18, 2:37pm
                                       No need to apologize. Arannir 722 0 Mar 18, 2:39pm
       Collapse There were quite a few pickups, DanielLB 1876 6 Mar 17, 10:56am
           Collapse 2014 Pick-Ups Legomir 1856 5 Mar 17, 11:22am
               Collapse Jimmy Nesbitt Pandallo 1852 4 Mar 17, 11:28am
                   Collapse Yeah. Arannir 1815 2 Mar 17, 12:03pm
                       The beneficiaries VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 1731 0 Mar 17, 2:05pm
                       disappointed Mooseboy018 1468 0 Mar 17, 6:37pm
                   Bofur is one of my favorites also Legomir 774 0 Mar 17, 11:17pm

Collapse Anyone want to Speculate about long Expected Funeral Scene..? Bombadil 1667 24 Mar 16, 12:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by Goldeneye)
       Collapse Excited about the music Shagrat 1540 10 Mar 16, 12:30pm
           Collapse funeral scene Goldeneye 1505 7 Mar 16, 1:17pm
               Collapse Yeah... Arannir 1488 1 Mar 16, 1:46pm
                   Indeed Thrain II 1468 0 Mar 16, 2:17pm
               Collapse Unlikely, but wouldn't it be cool if they sang Misty Mountain reprise?? AshNazg 1393 1 Mar 16, 3:38pm
                   This has been my dream! Pandallo 1356 0 Mar 16, 4:03pm
               Thorin's funeral could be a nice counterpoint to Aragorn's coronation... Bladerunner 1001 0 Mar 17, 2:33am
               Collapse I completely agree... banaili 195 1 Mar 22, 2:02pm
                   yes Goldeneye 178 0 Mar 22, 9:46pm
           Collapse I wonder if the music.... dormouse 1455 1 Mar 16, 2:36pm
               ironfoot's music Goldeneye 1414 0 Mar 16, 3:17pm
       Thorin's funeral and Dain Otaku-sempai 1407 0 Mar 16, 3:31pm
       Collapse My guess Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1403 1 Mar 16, 3:36pm
           I think it'll be short and involve a few silent shots... AshNazg 1389 0 Mar 16, 3:46pm
       Collapse It is important but not toooo long so that the EE cannot fill in the gaps where needed. Eruonen 1235 9 Mar 16, 7:48pm
           other scenes Goldeneye 1169 0 Mar 16, 9:16pm
           Collapse Where else is anything needed? AshNazg 1144 7 Mar 16, 9:47pm
               More time with - Eruonen 1108 0 Mar 16, 10:42pm
               Collapse The Journey Home and The Last Stage Otaku-sempai 1076 5 Mar 16, 11:32pm
                   Collapse hmm Goldeneye 990 4 Mar 17, 3:24am
                       Collapse I don't think that it's all that much. Otaku-sempai 984 3 Mar 17, 3:43am
                         Collapse Trying to PICTURE IT? Bombadil 663 2 Mar 18, 4:39pm
                               Collapse An Image FLASH for the Funeral..? Bombadil 446 1 Mar 20, 11:30pm
                                 JUS' A Postcard .. from Bomby Bombadil 425 0 Mar 21, 1:29am

  Collapse An Unexpected Journey . . . (Part 1) chauvelin2000 1500 21 Mar 16, 2:28am Jump to last post in thread (by chauvelin2000)
       Collapse An Unexpected Journey . . . (Part 1) chauvelin2000 1380 2 Mar 16, 3:21am
           Collapse "All good stories deserve embellishment" Pandallo 1360 1 Mar 16, 3:52am
               Actualizing Tolkien's 'Embellishment' vision . . . chauvelin2000 1124 0 Mar 16, 6:01pm
       Collapse Mount Gram Lio 1048 15 Mar 16, 10:33pm
           Mount Gram Otaku-sempai 1026 0 Mar 16, 11:45pm
           Collapse Gram to Gundabad . . . chauvelin2000 1016 13 Mar 17, 12:39am
               Collapse Gundabad not always 'bad' . . . chauvelin2000 995 1 Mar 17, 2:04am
                   Correction (errata) ... chauvelin2000 954 0 Mar 17, 6:13am
               Collapse Funny... Otaku-sempai 982 10 Mar 17, 4:02am
                   Collapse Guessing Gram . . . chauvelin2000 966 9 Mar 17, 5:27am
                       Collapse Yes, I know (now) that Fonstad's placement was a guess. Otaku-sempai 863 8 Mar 17, 1:12pm
                           Collapse Thanks for the clarifications you two Lio 648 7 Mar 18, 11:07pm
                               Collapse Relishing the 'Mists' . . . chauvelin2000 630 2 Mar 19, 3:41am
                                   Yes to this...., dormouse 611 0 Mar 19, 9:27am
                                   That's a much better way to put it! Lio 536 0 Mar 20, 12:51am
                               Collapse Beautifully Put Michelle Johnston 569 3 Mar 19, 7:02pm
                                   Collapse Tolkien: Immersing Us in Mysteries . . . chauvelin2000 401 2 Mar 21, 11:41am
                                       The Gift of Men Lio 347 0 Mar 22, 12:37am
                                       Creation's Music and the All-father's Gifts to Men . . . chauvelin2000 161 0 Mar 27, 6:13am
       Collapse Thank you again Michelle Johnston 854 1 Mar 17, 1:57pm
           Motivating Uses of Map & Key . . . chauvelin2000 733 0 Mar 18, 4:22am

  Collapse Why the theme while Thorin Oakenshield charges to attack Azog in AUJ makes sense. Hobbity Hobbit 888 8 Mar 15, 11:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by SafeUnderHill)
       Collapse Hm Arannir 705 6 Mar 16, 10:48am
           Collapse It was weirdly used for Sauron in the FotR prologue... // Bofur01 683 5 Mar 16, 12:12pm
               Collapse But imho in a totally different way. Arannir 678 4 Mar 16, 12:24pm
                   Yes, exactly VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 660 0 Mar 16, 1:32pm
                   Collapse The lyrics are in Khuzdul though... Bofur01 642 2 Mar 16, 2:14pm
                       Collapse I know that. Arannir 637 1 Mar 16, 2:30pm
                           Agree with this... AshNazg 545 0 Mar 16, 7:48pm
       Yes. SafeUnderHill 543 0 Mar 16, 7:49pm

  Collapse Kili and Tauriel: An 'almost-love-story' Otaku-sempai 2743 147 Mar 15, 3:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Milieuterrien)
       Collapse Yes.... dormouse 2385 33 Mar 15, 4:34pm
           Collapse In theory, I agree VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 2361 32 Mar 15, 4:57pm
               Collapse But it was real... marary 2356 1 Mar 15, 5:03pm
                   Bom Votes Yes! to Bombadil 2322 0 Mar 15, 5:32pm
               Collapse Well yes..... dormouse 2098 27 Mar 16, 12:02am
                   Collapse I'm not so different VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 2079 26 Mar 16, 12:26am
                       Collapse Yes, and I was thinking last night.... dormouse 804 25 Mar 16, 8:54am
                           Collapse I agree, but there's also more to it for me. Silverlode 770 23 Mar 16, 10:45am
                               Collapse Yes, that's a very good point.... dormouse 736 20 Mar 16, 12:22pm
                                   Collapse ages of ME races marary 727 2 Mar 16, 12:35pm
                                       Very puzzling dormouse 726 0 Mar 16, 12:38pm
                                       Tauriel isn't really all that young. Otaku-sempai 673 0 Mar 16, 3:09pm
                                   Collapse I definitely agree that there is a refection of the Athrabeth VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 705 16 Mar 16, 2:10pm
                                       Collapse Yes, so do I.... dormouse 695 15 Mar 16, 2:29pm
                                           Collapse Indeed! VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 652 14 Mar 16, 3:42pm
                                               Pray Tell Michelle Johnston 634 0 Mar 16, 4:24pm
                                               Collapse Appendix 10 VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 697 12 Mar 16, 4:54pm
                                                   Collapse Many Thanks Michelle Johnston 463 11 Mar 17, 6:16pm
                                                       Collapse My pleasure VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 457 10 Mar 17, 6:33pm
                                                           Collapse I hope you don't mind if I adopt this term for myself as well BlackFox 418 7 Mar 17, 7:25pm
                                                               Collapse Please do! VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 411 1 Mar 17, 7:27pm
                                                                   Like me - I'm one... // dormouse 651 0 Mar 17, 7:43pm
                                                               Collapse It transcends its flaws... Milieuterrien 413 4 Mar 17, 7:28pm
                                                                   Nicely put! // BlackFox 660 0 Mar 17, 7:36pm
                                                                   Nice! // dormouse 647 0 Mar 17, 7:44pm
                                                                   Collapse *slow clap* marary 640 1 Mar 17, 8:07pm
                                                                       Yikes, it's absolutely the good Pace for applause Milieuterrien 618 0 Mar 17, 9:04pm
                                                           Collapse I am a great Shippey fan Michelle Johnston 641 1 Mar 17, 8:20pm
                                                               I figured you were a fan of Shippey's VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 597 0 Mar 17, 10:37pm
                               Well said, indeed VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 704 0 Mar 16, 2:07pm
                               Beautifully Put Michelle Johnston 651 0 Mar 16, 3:39pm
                           Tauriel was a more relatable elf marary 740 0 Mar 16, 12:07pm
               Collapse Agreed. Arannir 757 1 Mar 16, 10:50am
                   Tauriel had to re-connect with Thranduil Milieuterrien 719 0 Mar 16, 12:40pm
       Collapse now that's very interesting! Kili/Tauriel more interesting than love at first sight marary 2358 39 Mar 15, 4:57pm
           Collapse When Tauriel is hurt... Otaku-sempai 2297 38 Mar 15, 6:09pm
               Collapse The effect on Kili Michelle Johnston 816 37 Mar 16, 8:05am
                   Collapse Kili (and Fili) Otaku-sempai 675 36 Mar 16, 3:00pm
                       Collapse One can hope- Durin family moments are the best marary 675 35 Mar 16, 3:08pm
                           Collapse 'Agreed Otaku-sempai 664 1 Mar 16, 3:13pm
                               maybe marary 653 0 Mar 16, 3:28pm
                           Collapse Er - Tauriel characteristics Avandel 706 32 Mar 16, 4:51pm
                               Collapse Eh marary 690 30 Mar 16, 5:12pm
                                   Agree Starling 684 0 Mar 16, 5:17pm
                                   Collapse So fine and specific statement ! Milieuterrien 673 22 Mar 16, 5:32pm
                                       Collapse Everyone has a bit of "Sue" in them marary 657 21 Mar 16, 5:51pm
                                           Be careful Starling 642 0 Mar 16, 6:01pm
                                           Collapse but alas Cirashala 632 19 Mar 16, 6:22pm
                                               Collapse Wow! Impressive analysis marary 584 3 Mar 16, 7:46pm
                                                   Collapse Thorin Cirashala 654 2 Mar 17, 3:36am
                                                       Where was Dwalin? Combing his beard?? marary 619 0 Mar 17, 7:43am
                                                       Agree with your points Avandel 472 0 Mar 17, 5:38pm
                                               Maybe a Mary-Sue but... Milieuterrien 579 0 Mar 16, 8:12pm
                                               Collapse And about Tauriel disturbing the canon plot, Milieuterrien 575 12 Mar 16, 8:38pm
                                                   Collapse Disturb or Distract and Whats Canon Michelle Johnston 525 11 Mar 16, 10:10pm
                                                       Collapse Following the book-canon would have been a mess. Milieuterrien 500 10 Mar 16, 11:26pm
                                                           Collapse The Battle of Five Armies. Otaku-sempai 490 4 Mar 16, 11:59pm
                                                               Collapse More a mess in the book than in the movie Milieuterrien 675 3 Mar 17, 1:01am
                                                                   Collapse It isn't as bad as you think. Otaku-sempai 644 2 Mar 17, 3:39am
                                                                       Collapse Tolkien stated the battle was a mess Milieuterrien 580 1 Mar 17, 10:24am
                                                                           Jackson may have improved on the battle in some ways... Otaku-sempai 535 0 Mar 17, 1:47pm
                                                           Collapse Story Telling Not Battle Strategy Michelle Johnston 614 4 Mar 17, 8:01am
                                                               Collapse One thing which has been satisfactory nailed is the toxicity of greed Milieuterrien 599 3 Mar 17, 9:10am
                                                                   Yes to all of this, Milieuterrien marary 555 0 Mar 17, 12:04pm
                                                                   Collapse Ravenhill Occupants Michelle Johnston 501 1 Mar 17, 4:09pm
                                                                       Ravenhill scene Milieuterrien 478 0 Mar 17, 5:26pm
                                               Beautifully summarized IMO - agree Avandel 690 0 Mar 17, 12:34am
                                   You make an interesting point. Otaku-sempai 628 0 Mar 16, 6:20pm
                                   Well here's a thing..... dormouse 610 0 Mar 16, 6:51pm
                                   Collapse Thank you Avandel 485 3 Mar 17, 12:12am
                                       Collapse I wouldn't underestimate the importance of appealing to 11-year old girls marary 629 2 Mar 17, 7:09am
                                           Collapse *Bows* IMO you make very good points, well-spoken! (: Avandel 490 1 Mar 17, 5:14pm
                                               cheers! marary 466 0 Mar 17, 5:50pm
                               I just took the Mary Sue Litmus Test for Tauriel Cirashala 670 0 Mar 16, 5:42pm
       Collapse dosnt make sense balbo biggins 2334 1 Mar 15, 5:20pm
           He's not in love when they first meet marary 2332 0 Mar 15, 5:24pm
       Collapse Sounds good on paper but... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 2303 1 Mar 15, 6:04pm
           The relationship always felt contrived to me... Otaku-sempai 2281 0 Mar 15, 6:22pm
       Collapse Well CathrineB 2282 6 Mar 15, 6:19pm
           Collapse Agree lionoferebor 569 5 Mar 18, 2:09am
               Collapse subject marillaraina 564 4 Mar 18, 3:42am
                   Collapse POV lionoferebor 546 1 Mar 18, 6:00am
                       PJ's POV on Kili/Tauriel lionoferebor 471 0 Mar 18, 3:43pm
                   Collapse What Kili and Tauriel represented marary 549 1 Mar 18, 6:01am
                       Out-of-love with everything else. Otaku-sempai 483 0 Mar 18, 2:22pm
       Collapse John nails it but ů... Michelle Johnston 2260 8 Mar 15, 7:00pm
           Collapse On this particular point, I largely agree with you VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 2194 2 Mar 15, 8:40pm
               Collapse such a shame marary 2174 1 Mar 15, 8:55pm
                   Marary Nicely Put Michelle Johnston 2155 0 Mar 15, 9:24pm
           Collapse I agree that working the relationship off Legolas is the point Milieuterrien 2160 4 Mar 15, 9:20pm
               Collapse Nice Michelle Johnston 2129 3 Mar 15, 10:28pm
                   Collapse The core of this enigma is 'what was intended to be done with the 'bridge movie'" ? Milieuterrien 2027 1 Mar 16, 2:13am
                       Digression: The 'bridge movie'. Otaku-sempai 1977 0 Mar 16, 4:24am
                   the token female dilemma marary 1909 0 Mar 16, 7:13am
       Collapse I like their scenes in the woodelve Dungeons squiggle 2010 1 Mar 16, 2:36am
           The Mirkwood Dungeon scene had a lot going for it marary 821 0 Mar 16, 7:24am
     Collapse Almost love would have been nice Avandel 1915 15 Mar 16, 7:09am
         Collapse Much of this Dangling, Un-Resolved PlotLine Bombadil 822 12 Mar 16, 8:10am
               I'm getting excited for the EE! marary 800 0 Mar 16, 8:35am
               Collapse I am sorry Bomby but enough, IMO, re Tauriel and EE Avandel 637 10 Mar 16, 4:37pm
                   Collapse You should be careful about telling other people "enough" VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 701 5 Mar 16, 5:08pm
                       Except that the post to which Avandel replied... RosieLass 613 0 Mar 16, 7:10pm
                       Collapse Was meant generically but OK Avandel 508 3 Mar 16, 11:17pm
                           Collapse "all have, by default, a right to their perceptions and opinions" VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 698 2 Mar 17, 12:30am
                               Collapse ??? Avandel 694 1 Mar 17, 12:38am
                                   No VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 680 0 Mar 17, 1:11am
                   Collapse Thank you Cirashala 694 1 Mar 16, 5:10pm
                       You are welcome and re the image Avandel 686 0 Mar 17, 12:46am
                   Collapse Thranduils triangulation & Disappearing Dwarves Michelle Johnston 603 1 Mar 16, 7:10pm
                       The dwarves did not disappear in the movie Milieuterrien 530 0 Mar 16, 10:03pm
           Collapse Tauriel's character-arc. Otaku-sempai 687 1 Mar 16, 2:46pm
               I like that a lot! RosieLass 598 0 Mar 16, 7:16pm
       Collapse That may have been the original plan Kilidoescartwheels 407 33 Mar 19, 9:18pm
           Collapse I think he was partly thinking about Legolas VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 396 32 Mar 19, 9:31pm
               Collapse subject marillaraina 365 31 Mar 19, 11:58pm
                   Collapse I'm glad it works for you! VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 352 30 Mar 20, 3:53am
                       Collapse subject marillaraina 347 29 Mar 20, 4:30am
                           Collapse Evidence based Love v Philosophical View Point Michelle Johnston 336 28 Mar 20, 11:15am
                               Collapse The Wood-elves of Mirkwood were Teleri. Otaku-sempai 304 27 Mar 20, 1:52pm
                                   Collapse Avari or Teleri Michelle Johnston 288 24 Mar 20, 4:29pm
                                       Well... Otaku-sempai 279 0 Mar 20, 4:42pm
                                       Collapse To me the more fundamental point is one that you alluded to earlier VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 243 22 Mar 20, 8:37pm
                                           Collapse subject marillaraina 524 4 Mar 20, 9:08pm
                                               Collapse Personally... Darkstone 524 1 Mar 20, 9:19pm
                                                   Still Children of Eru VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 488 0 Mar 20, 11:09pm
                                               Collapse Accepted, but only so far VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 479 1 Mar 20, 11:21pm
                                                   subject marillaraina 469 0 Mar 20, 11:58pm
                                           Collapse Perfect Michelle Johnston 463 16 Mar 21, 12:20am
                                               Collapse On the other hand VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 456 1 Mar 21, 1:22am
                                                   Indeed :) Michelle Johnston 441 0 Mar 21, 6:55am
                                               Is it not just a one step seperation of Destiny that squiggle 394 0 Mar 21, 2:53pm
                                               Collapse subject marillaraina 375 12 Mar 21, 7:36pm
                                                   Collapse puppies marary 343 11 Mar 22, 2:51am
                                                       Collapse Roaming thoughts Milieuterrien 287 10 Mar 22, 8:52pm
                                                           Collapse Tauriel's fate marary 281 9 Mar 22, 9:08pm
                                                               His mother lionoferebor 269 0 Mar 22, 10:23pm
                                                               Collapse Kili's cheesy stance Milieuterrien 268 6 Mar 22, 10:51pm
                                                                   Collapse Kili isn't cheesy :) marillaraina 260 5 Mar 23, 12:03am
                                                                       Collapse Tauriel really needs a road trip marary 243 4 Mar 23, 5:38am
                                                                           Kili's death scene marary 212 0 Mar 23, 5:29pm
                                                                           Collapse Mirkwood is a very large forest Milieuterrien 183 2 Mar 23, 10:52pm
                                                                               Collapse cool theory! marary 174 1 Mar 24, 4:07am
  Seeing Galadriel and Tauriel interact Milieuterrien 137 0 Mar 24, 11:17pm
                                                               Why Legolas left arithmancer 255 0 Mar 23, 2:08am
                                   Inconceivable lionoferebor 276 0 Mar 20, 5:28pm
                                   subject marillaraina 249 0 Mar 20, 8:25pm
       Excellent responses all 'round! Otaku-sempai 197 0 Mar 23, 7:19pm

Moved: For Those of YOU who Loved Gwahir Bombadil - - Mar 15, 3:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)

  Collapse What if the dwarves and Gandalf had been lying? Cirashala 939 4 Mar 15, 4:25am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       It depends on the lie, it would seem... MyWeeLadGimli 857 0 Mar 15, 5:50am
       Collapse Perhaps if he'd thought one of his animal-friends had been harmed. Otaku-sempai 681 2 Mar 15, 3:10pm
           Collapse That seems fair Cirashala 576 1 Mar 15, 11:17pm
               They hang horse thieves, don't they? Otaku-sempai 531 0 Mar 16, 3:52am

  Collapse When we are presumed to have news of the EE, and, wich parts of the book are yet to be covered? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1431 8 Mar 14, 5:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Collapse Don't know about the 'when' (October or November 2015?) Otaku-sempai 1274 6 Mar 14, 8:31pm
           Collapse ????? He is a wizard, you know! 1191 5 Mar 14, 10:32pm
               Collapse Look at Sting in 'LotR' Otaku-sempai 1149 4 Mar 14, 11:21pm
                   Collapse Bom for one, is REally Glad there was No Funeral Bombadil 884 3 Mar 15, 12:09pm
                       Collapse I think that we really need that closure. Otaku-sempai 818 2 Mar 15, 2:47pm
                           Collapse Dain Mooseboy018 703 1 Mar 15, 9:13pm
                               I don't think so... arithmancer 616 0 Mar 16, 2:32am
       So far.... TheHutt 1152 0 Mar 14, 11:20pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 973 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.