Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 951 (342343 posts in 14263 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 951 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Sir Patrick Stewart as Radagast the Brown Elutherian 875 23 Jan 15, 12:14am Jump to last post in thread (by Celedor)
       Collapse Huh... ecthelionsbeard 487 5 Jan 15, 12:17am
           Collapse I love Patrick Stewart QueenCirce 459 4 Jan 15, 12:29am
               Collapse I would only ad Brandybuckled 176 2 Jan 15, 5:49pm
                   Collapse I agree, reaching for laughs, though understandable in the big scheme of Eruonen 164 1 Jan 15, 6:12pm
                       Is this his Avatar test? ;) Eruonen 158 0 Jan 15, 6:15pm
               Agree with your changes Gwytha 102 0 Jan 15, 11:10pm
       Collapse Actually Yngwulff 361 1 Jan 15, 4:25am
           where to sign?! NoelGallagher 329 0 Jan 15, 6:04am
       No, thank you Glorfindela 305 0 Jan 15, 8:02am
       Collapse Somewhere in the 6 films TheSexyBeard 224 6 Jan 15, 3:29pm
           Collapse I don't see him as a good character for these films. Eruonen 219 3 Jan 15, 3:30pm
               Collapse Stewart as Cirdan... Brethil 193 2 Jan 15, 4:43pm
                   Collapse Yes, I can see him as Cirdan Meneldor 106 1 Jan 15, 11:19pm
                       I do recall - Sir Patrick is a standout in any Medieval setting Brethil 60 0 Jan 16, 9:14pm
           Collapse Denethor... Evernight 44 1 Jan 17, 8:42pm
               mckellen vs stewart news at eleven...... swordwhale 31 0 Jan 19, 4:36am
       Bit late really.... dormouse 204 0 Jan 15, 4:06pm
       Stewart would have been better... Nolane 173 0 Jan 15, 6:02pm
       Where PJ's Radagast came from burrahobbit 150 0 Jan 15, 8:45pm
       Collapse "These are the voyages of the morning star ship Vingilot." / Darkstone 90 1 Jan 16, 3:56am
           make it sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo swordwhale 26 0 Jan 19, 4:34am
       Sir Patrick Stewart is great. Farficom 72 0 Jan 16, 2:51pm
       Make it So Celedor 11 0 Sun, 3:53pm

  Collapse Pre-CGI Dain - Any Info/Pictures? Dcole4 893 8 Jan 14, 11:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elentari03)
       I don't think another actor would have given us as much Spriggan 497 0 Jan 15, 12:12am
       Collapse In earlier interviews with Billy Connolly... Bladerunner 488 3 Jan 15, 3:07am
           Collapse Apparently, the reason for going with CGI for Dain... DeadRabbits 360 1 Jan 15, 10:44am
               The difference between LOTR and Hobbit Dcole4 209 0 Jan 15, 5:38pm
           There is Elentari03 105 0 Jan 16, 4:26am
       I think he looked fine Glorfindela 362 0 Jan 15, 8:00am
       I'm still befuddled as to if he is CGI or not Annatar598 335 0 Jan 15, 10:06am
       There's a shot TnuaccayM 227 0 Jan 15, 5:22pm

  Collapse Legolas During The Climax brotherbeck 1155 26 Jan 14, 5:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by mangotree)
       Collapse Fan-Cut Dcole4 640 5 Jan 14, 5:55pm
           Collapse Great! mangotree 204 4 Jan 15, 4:01pm
               Collapse I happen to really like swordwhale 52 3 Jan 19, 4:43am
                   Collapse I know, mangotree 36 2 Jan 20, 2:15pm
                       Collapse Legolas Harukalioncourt 21 1 Jan 22, 2:03pm
                           Agree! He needed some place in the Hobbit but not too much! mangotree 19 0 Jan 22, 2:46pm
       Collapse Legolas was a fan-girl favorite in the days of LotR. Elizabeth 560 11 Jan 14, 8:18pm
           Collapse Totally agree with this Azaghâl 470 1 Jan 14, 9:27pm
               Cutting Away During The Climactic Fight brotherbeck 429 0 Jan 14, 10:34pm
           Collapse Agreed. Arannir 274 7 Jan 15, 11:05am
               Collapse Suspect Methodology Michelle Johnston 274 6 Jan 15, 12:20pm
                   As a huge Legolas fan... Imladris18 247 0 Jan 15, 2:05pm
                   That sounds like a great scenario. Macfeast 177 0 Jan 15, 5:59pm
                   Collapse Legolas as scout, not commander huzzlewhat 174 1 Jan 15, 6:25pm
                       Multiple Benefits & Opens Up His Character Michelle Johnston 167 0 Jan 15, 7:06pm
                   Collapse indeed swordwhale 49 1 Jan 19, 4:46am
                       Not Scientific but interesting Michelle Johnston 48 0 Jan 19, 5:05am
           Totally agree!!! mangotree 209 0 Jan 15, 3:36pm
       Agree CathrineB 426 0 Jan 14, 10:11pm
       Collapse It may be worth considering it from the perspective of those who don't know the story. Spriggan 436 3 Jan 14, 11:50pm
           Collapse That's an interesting idea // dormouse 374 2 Jan 14, 11:53pm
               Collapse That is a very interesting idea... brotherbeck 374 1 Jan 15, 1:00am
                   Bolg was created for Legolas Michelle Johnston 279 0 Jan 15, 12:23pm
       I couldn't agree more Bernhardina 143 0 Jan 15, 9:44pm
       Collapse Agree! Anorien 102 1 Jan 16, 5:41am
           and my first thought was swordwhale 50 0 Jan 19, 4:47am

  Collapse Doug Adams suggests Alfrid's 'comeuppance' will feature in the EE Shagrat 1480 48 Jan 14, 5:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by DjU)
       Cool Elessar 719 0 Jan 14, 5:23pm
     Collapse Alfrid having a a comeppance won't work for me Avandel 786 16 Jan 14, 5:32pm
           Collapse It won't last more than a few seconds NecromancerRising 695 15 Jan 14, 5:36pm
             Collapse *grins* Avandel 231 14 Jan 15, 5:39am
                   Collapse www.ineedmoredwarves.com Kim 294 13 Jan 15, 6:17am
                       Collapse I wonder... Dcole4 283 9 Jan 15, 7:01am
                           Collapse so disappointing Mooseboy018 269 8 Jan 15, 8:17am
                             Collapse Beautiful post - IMO needs to be on the front page! Avandel 196 5 Jan 15, 4:12pm
                                   Collapse Gandalf was right. Mooseboy018 159 1 Jan 15, 6:22pm
                                     True Avandel 124 0 Jan 15, 8:35pm
                                   Collapse As long as we're talking about the need for more Dwarves... an interesting theme WholeUnderGround 111 2 Jan 15, 9:50pm
                                       Collapse Great thoughts - thank you for posting this Avandel 86 1 Jan 15, 10:50pm
                                           I was waiting for Brandybuckled 72 0 Jan 15, 11:49pm
                               Collapse Agreed. Macfeast 170 1 Jan 15, 4:50pm
                                   Another front page post IMO! Avandel 89 0 Jan 15, 10:05pm
                       Collapse According to dernwyn 212 1 Jan 15, 12:44pm
                           My prediction for the EE Brandybuckled 131 0 Jan 15, 8:27pm
                     I bet if you build it, they will come - I will! Avandel 173 0 Jan 15, 4:24pm
       Collapse I don't like the sound of this BlackFox 674 1 Jan 14, 6:01pm
           One thing that might be considered Glorfindela 209 0 Jan 15, 12:40pm
     Collapse Please, no Glorfindela 631 6 Jan 14, 6:21pm
           Ditto // Kim 519 0 Jan 14, 6:38pm
           Collapse Agreed completely... Eleniel 470 4 Jan 14, 7:42pm
               I really hope so, Eleniel Glorfindela 399 0 Jan 14, 8:53pm
               Collapse I'm all for the thematically and dramatically important.... dormouse 320 2 Jan 14, 11:20pm
                   Collapse I'd really rather they not... Dcole4 310 1 Jan 14, 11:29pm
                       Two words Voronwë_the_Faithful 304 0 Jan 14, 11:39pm
       Collapse I wish... Dcole4 581 9 Jan 14, 6:38pm
           Collapse Prosthetic Bolg would never have been involved in those scenes Shagrat 541 5 Jan 14, 7:09pm
               Collapse I hope he didn't say that KingTurgon 309 1 Jan 14, 11:41pm
                   Interesting thought.... dormouse 292 0 Jan 14, 11:51pm
               Collapse I doubt this. arithmancer 277 2 Jan 15, 12:32am
                   Collapse I suspect Gundabad was also a way to bring in Angmar Spriggan 286 1 Jan 15, 12:37am
                       Yes, definitely. And a way to mae govannen 252 0 Jan 15, 7:55am
           Ultimate PredatoR 492 0 Jan 14, 7:21pm
           Collapse The history of Azog and Bolg - In three Parts of Course Michelle Johnston 60 1 Jan 16, 1:29am
               Based on... DjU 64 0 Jan 16, 3:04am
       Collapse If I ever see Alfrid again Riven Delve 575 1 Jan 14, 7:02pm
           Agreed Gwytha 459 0 Jan 14, 7:41pm
     NO! Thrain II 489 0 Jan 14, 7:40pm
       I also don't really care for this Name 406 0 Jan 14, 9:07pm
       He is a superior comic relief than Gimli in LOTR for sure... but who cares? // xxxyyy 265 0 Jan 15, 12:51am
       Please let him go to whatever end... mae govannen 262 0 Jan 15, 8:12am
       I'm all for it - just bring it on! DeadRabbits 240 0 Jan 15, 10:38am
       Collapse WHY? Arannir 241 3 Jan 15, 11:02am
           Collapse Exactly. Not knowing his end is a fitting conclusion for his character. // xxxyyy 59 1 Jan 16, 12:46am
               It does suggest... QuackingTroll 69 0 Jan 16, 12:50am
           Spot On Michelle Johnston 54 0 Jan 16, 1:34am

  Collapse Peter Jackson: “no regrets” Arannir 1703 57 Jan 14, 1:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by FernysApple)
       Collapse Strange to have this reposted now Voronwë_the_Faithful 823 4 Jan 14, 1:21pm
           Collapse Oh sorry. Arannir 733 2 Jan 14, 1:33pm
               Collapse I didn't meant that it was strange that you posted it Voronwë_the_Faithful 724 1 Jan 14, 1:41pm
                   Actually, I alerted the main page crew about this article about a month ago... DeadRabbits 688 0 Jan 14, 1:51pm
         Linking to the original article crashed my Mac Glorfindela 690 0 Jan 14, 1:58pm
       Collapse Thank you Michelle Johnston 687 2 Jan 14, 2:40pm
           Collapse Without reading the article Glorfindela 614 1 Jan 14, 4:35pm
               Really? Elessar 547 0 Jan 14, 5:21pm
       Collapse Insightful Ham_Sammy 664 1 Jan 14, 3:01pm
           That it is. Elessar 537 0 Jan 14, 5:20pm
       Collapse Where are all the people now who... R11 500 36 Jan 14, 9:11pm
           Hm.. Anubis 431 0 Jan 14, 9:32pm
           Quite. Merovech 398 0 Jan 14, 9:49pm
           Collapse Deary me - you mean he tried to get as many people as possible to like it? Spriggan 414 25 Jan 14, 9:52pm
               Collapse So am I... Merovech 371 24 Jan 14, 10:30pm
                   Collapse How many fewer people liking it would you prefer? Spriggan 359 23 Jan 14, 10:45pm
                       Collapse That's not what I'm saying Merovech 355 22 Jan 14, 10:49pm
                           Collapse How do they increase profit without the films being more popular? Spriggan 348 2 Jan 14, 10:53pm
                               Collapse Sorry Merovech 341 1 Jan 14, 10:55pm
                                   Entirely up to you, of course. Spriggan 319 0 Jan 14, 11:02pm
                           But surely you're not suggesting that... BlackFox 320 0 Jan 14, 11:07pm
                           Collapse What is mind-blowing... Arannir 260 17 Jan 15, 11:09am
                               Collapse What would make us think Jackson didn't seek to please as many people as possible with LOTR, too? Spriggan 232 16 Jan 15, 1:57pm
                                   Collapse I meant... Arannir 221 15 Jan 15, 2:15pm
                                       Collapse Those remarks about 9-year-old girls reminded me.... dormouse 215 1 Jan 15, 2:53pm
                                           Including female characters... Arannir 195 0 Jan 15, 3:39pm
                                       Collapse I'm not sure we can ascribe any real differences - how do we know? Spriggan 183 12 Jan 15, 3:48pm
                                           Collapse The only thing I meant... Arannir 174 11 Jan 15, 3:53pm
                                               Collapse That's not the question though, I don't think Spriggan 152 10 Jan 15, 4:28pm
                                                   Collapse Possible he did try to appeal to them... Arannir 146 9 Jan 15, 4:46pm
                                                       Collapse The achievement Spriggan 112 8 Jan 15, 8:45pm
                                                           Collapse I never said otherwise. Arannir 104 7 Jan 15, 8:46pm
                                                               Collapse You mentioned that Jackson's Spriggan 108 6 Jan 15, 8:49pm
                                                                   Collapse The way he stated it. Arannir 130 5 Jan 15, 9:07pm
                                                                       Of course, Spriggan 124 0 Jan 15, 9:11pm
                                                                       Collapse Perhaps one thing to bear in mind here... dormouse 109 1 Jan 15, 11:15pm
                                                                           He has talked about Tauriel... Arannir 67 0 Jan 16, 8:23am
                                                                       My thoughts Ham_Sammy 95 0 Jan 15, 11:43pm
                                                                       Your final point is well made. Michelle Johnston 70 0 Jan 16, 6:33am
           Collapse i could not disagree more. Ham_Sammy 406 7 Jan 14, 11:08pm
               Collapse If Jackson had FernysApple 375 6 Jan 15, 12:04am
                   Collapse well I don't agree Ham_Sammy 360 3 Jan 15, 12:07am
                       Collapse I quite agree with your disagreement Ham Sammy Old Toby 310 2 Jan 15, 4:42am
                           Yes exactly Ham_Sammy 298 0 Jan 15, 5:03am
                           so if the book is so boring, according to you FernysApple 52 0 Jan 16, 11:14pm
                   Collapse We don't want the masses getting ideas about Tolkien Riven Delve 373 1 Jan 15, 12:17am
                       shudder the thought FernysApple 169 0 Jan 15, 4:02pm
       none at all bungobaggins 400 0 Jan 14, 9:43pm
       Collapse Good on him, I say. DanielLB 402 5 Jan 14, 10:06pm
           Collapse I agree with most of your post... Bladerunner 325 3 Jan 14, 11:04pm
               Collapse I didn't mean to suggest that ... DanielLB 288 2 Jan 15, 7:20am
                   This 2nd formulation I can agree with as well. // mae govannen 217 0 Jan 15, 2:10pm
                   Ok, in that case I can agree.// Bladerunner 80 0 Jan 16, 1:07am
           I agree totally with that. // mae govannen 217 0 Jan 15, 2:08pm
       Collapse What’s the next cool thing that the elf is going to do? Bladerunner 356 2 Jan 15, 2:08am
           Good observation Ham_Sammy 329 0 Jan 15, 3:00am
           Uh oh marillaraina 323 0 Jan 15, 3:58am

  Collapse The pipe scene: Anyone else's favorite? HiddenSpring 1003 44 Jan 14, 10:58am Jump to last post in thread (by HiddenSpring)
       Indeed. Arannir 490 0 Jan 14, 11:05am
       Certainly one of my favourites... dormouse 480 0 Jan 14, 11:17am
       Collapse Different and strange reactions. NecromancerRising 510 1 Jan 14, 11:30am
           Similar to hobbits drinking at end of ROTK Jeffrodo 456 0 Jan 14, 12:03pm
       That is one of the best scenes in any of the six movies IMO. Noria 419 0 Jan 14, 1:11pm
       A really touching and beautiful scene Elarie 407 0 Jan 14, 1:35pm
     Collapse One of the worst scenes Thrain II 461 20 Jan 14, 1:47pm
           Collapse Obviously not working for you... arithmancer 419 2 Jan 14, 1:50pm
               Yeah Thrain II 395 0 Jan 14, 2:02pm
               In Agreement smtfhw 344 0 Jan 14, 2:45pm
           Collapse Crumbs, I'm glad I wasn't in the cinema with you! dormouse 389 4 Jan 14, 2:17pm
               Collapse Anyone who thinks that Peter Jackson can't do subtle should watch that scene Voronwë_the_Faithful 379 2 Jan 14, 2:20pm
                   Absolutely // dormouse 323 0 Jan 14, 2:34pm
                   Totally agree Noria 291 0 Jan 14, 3:52pm
               You've got it Gwytha 232 0 Jan 14, 6:31pm
           Collapse I am pretty much with you on this one Old Toby 347 6 Jan 14, 3:02pm
               Collapse Indeed Thrain II 314 5 Jan 14, 3:33pm
                   Collapse Maybe in the EE..... Miss-Merriweather 253 1 Jan 14, 6:17pm
                       Hmmm, I never thought of that Old Toby 176 0 Jan 14, 9:55pm
                   Collapse That's war, and that's life. Spriggan 242 2 Jan 14, 6:35pm
                       Yes indeed Na Vedui 197 0 Jan 14, 8:46pm
                       Quite true and important remark // mae govannen 82 0 Jan 15, 7:29am
           Collapse I'm with you on this too Kim 246 4 Jan 14, 6:26pm
               I think it was quite clever Glorfindela 189 0 Jan 14, 8:57pm
               Collapse We all do some strange things Riven Delve 188 2 Jan 14, 9:05pm
                   Collapse It reminds me of the scene in TTT EE where Gandalf was trying to comfort Theoden Gwytha 108 1 Jan 15, 4:42am
                       Yes, a turning point Riven Delve 67 0 Jan 15, 12:45pm
       Definitely one of the highlights! // Estel78 348 0 Jan 14, 2:17pm
       *raises hand* BlackFox 347 0 Jan 14, 2:33pm
       Loved it...two heroes EomundDaughter 335 0 Jan 14, 2:45pm
       Agree with everyone else, a beautiful moment. Eruonen 328 0 Jan 14, 2:49pm
       Collapse When Gandalf gives hugs Riven Delve 336 1 Jan 14, 3:15pm
         Exactly. *tears up* mae govannen 86 0 Jan 15, 7:39am
       I like it a lot Glorfindela 275 0 Jan 14, 4:39pm
       Collapse One of my favorites Eruvandi 270 1 Jan 14, 4:56pm
           One of My Favorites from BOTFA brotherbeck 254 0 Jan 14, 6:19pm
       Collapse I laughed. TheSexyBeard 227 1 Jan 14, 7:10pm
           That awkward laughter glor 123 0 Jan 15, 2:13am
       a scene for us The Ranger Anduiel 164 0 Jan 14, 10:25pm
       Collapse Easily one of my fav scenes of the movie. Arthael 118 2 Jan 15, 2:15am
           Yes...// mae govannen 74 0 Jan 15, 7:46am
           That's how I see it too HiddenSpring 41 0 Jan 16, 4:35pm
       It's my absolute favourite of all 3 films. grammaboodawg 115 0 Jan 15, 4:15am
       It's probably my favourite scene of the whole trilogy Mischa07 86 0 Jan 15, 7:45am

  Collapse Thrain encounter in the Desolation of Smaug EE elentari3018 820 15 Jan 14, 5:57am Jump to last post in thread (by elentari3018)
       I prefer what they've done lurtz2010 440 0 Jan 14, 6:10am
       keeping Thrain alive Mooseboy018 417 0 Jan 14, 6:11am
       Collapse I think the "key" difference... Eleniel 363 7 Jan 14, 9:38am
           Collapse Maybe Thrain II 248 4 Jan 14, 1:55pm
               Collapse In the books, yes... Eleniel 240 3 Jan 14, 2:09pm
                   Not well thought out Voronwë_the_Faithful 236 0 Jan 14, 2:14pm
                   Collapse Cause and Effect Michelle Johnston 186 1 Jan 14, 5:34pm
                       I'm not sure I would be very keen on 1. Spriggan 170 0 Jan 14, 5:54pm
           Thrain and Gandalf - filmverse arithmancer 253 0 Jan 14, 2:01pm
           "I was not at the Battle of Moria"... "No. But I was..." Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 123 0 Jan 14, 10:16pm
       Collapse Yeah, the timeline is changed Thrain II 253 4 Jan 14, 1:52pm
           Collapse They apparently shot the key-giving scene Dcole4 185 3 Jan 14, 6:43pm
               Me too Thrain II 149 0 Jan 14, 8:21pm
             I felt the same Michelle Johnston 74 0 Jan 15, 4:15am
               Then i hope more can be clarified in the EE of BotFA! elentari3018 89 0 Jan 15, 4:31am

  Collapse Has The Hobbit been left behind in BotFA? burrahobbit 1217 54 Jan 14, 12:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Bladerunner)
       Collapse Very different experience. Spriggan 544 3 Jan 14, 1:05am
           Collapse Is Thorin's funeral not also from Bilbo's perspective? burrahobbit 495 1 Jan 14, 1:23am
               Not so strongly as the screen version, I would argue. Spriggan 469 0 Jan 14, 1:46am
           Agree so much with you... mae govannen 353 0 Jan 14, 5:41am
       I must say, I completely disagree with you Glorfindela 509 0 Jan 14, 1:09am
       Collapse Perhaps you are reacting to the pace of the film Avandel 488 4 Jan 14, 1:21am
           Collapse Yes it's the pace and lack of contrast burrahobbit 456 3 Jan 14, 1:37am
               Collapse I think the problem is you're too invested in Bilbo... QuackingTroll 458 2 Jan 14, 1:48am
                   Collapse Hmmm burrahobbit 457 1 Jan 14, 2:02am
                       I didn't mean to imply anything negative, sorry... QuackingTroll 430 0 Jan 14, 2:15am
       Collapse Of two minds... Aragorn the Elfstone 480 2 Jan 14, 1:23am
           Collapse The Quest of Erebor... Bladerunner 419 1 Jan 14, 2:50am
               Poor choice of words on my part Aragorn the Elfstone 400 0 Jan 14, 2:54am
       Collapse What Spriggan and Glorfindela said. Noria 466 3 Jan 14, 1:25am
           Collapse Yes he's not active in this part of the story burrahobbit 460 2 Jan 14, 1:30am
               Collapse Well... arithmancer 409 1 Jan 14, 2:41am
                   I second you on all your points. // mae govannen 323 0 Jan 14, 5:49am
       Collapse These movies are meant to be viewed as parts to one story Annatar598 455 1 Jan 14, 2:00am
           Standing applause!!! I agree with your every word.// mae govannen 322 0 Jan 14, 7:40am
       Collapse I agree with you completely Bishop 426 8 Jan 14, 2:38am
           Collapse Hopefully we'll get to see another director's vision of this story in a decade or so... Bladerunner 389 6 Jan 14, 3:36am
               Collapse I don't think we'll see it Bishop 376 5 Jan 14, 3:46am
                   Collapse Maybe a video game... QuackingTroll 351 2 Jan 14, 3:54am
                       Collapse Maybe! Bishop 340 1 Jan 14, 4:12am
                           And maybe mae govannen 318 0 Jan 14, 7:45am
                   Great post. Arannir 310 0 Jan 14, 8:38am
                   I agree... Bladerunner 211 0 Jan 14, 10:49pm
           But still, even in this version, Bilbo remains the central actor mae govannen 336 0 Jan 14, 6:02am
       Collapse Bilbo is somewhat diminished in the film... HeWhoArisesinMight 401 6 Jan 14, 3:29am
           Collapse You seem to have missed other CRUCIAL moments mae govannen 340 4 Jan 14, 7:31am
               Collapse I will have to watch them all again HeWhoArisesinMight 200 3 Jan 15, 12:40am
                   Collapse My best wishes for your next viewing(s) !... mae govannen 165 2 Jan 15, 7:09am
                       Collapse Thanks for the kind words HeWhoArisesinMight 148 1 Jan 15, 2:09pm
                           I so much agree with all you say mae govannen 91 0 Jan 16, 11:46am
           I'm not sure missing Spriggan 308 0 Jan 14, 8:53am
       I enjoyed the film Ham_Sammy 374 0 Jan 14, 3:39am
       Collapse Book verses Movie - impossible on this one Michelle Johnston 387 1 Jan 14, 4:15am
           I agree Ham_Sammy 355 0 Jan 14, 4:40am
       Unsure. Arannir 333 0 Jan 14, 8:32am
       Collapse I couldn't disagree more... dormouse 344 5 Jan 14, 9:27am
           Collapse I think you have good intentions... Bladerunner 204 4 Jan 15, 2:28am
               Agree to some extent. Arannir 160 0 Jan 15, 11:14am
               Collapse I don't see this as a question of fault.... dormouse 151 2 Jan 15, 2:42pm
                   What an excellent post... So true...*Mods up*// mae govannen 99 0 Jan 16, 4:42am
                   Thank you for your response. Bladerunner 32 0 Jan 19, 3:58am
       Collapse yes i agree with you. Bilbo has been sidelined FernysApple 76 7 Jan 16, 11:24pm
           Collapse But I don't think Bilbo is the main character... QuackingTroll 75 6 Jan 16, 11:38pm
               Collapse the movies FernysApple 54 5 Jan 17, 3:26pm
                   Collapse By that logic LotR's main character should be Sauron QuackingTroll 55 4 Jan 17, 4:29pm
                       Collapse if you are bored FernysApple 50 3 Jan 17, 6:39pm
                           Collapse It sounds to me like YOU are the one watching the wrong film... QuackingTroll 60 2 Jan 17, 7:15pm
                               Stop. skyofcoffeebeans 43 0 Jan 17, 8:07pm
                               oh it was absolutely FernysApple 36 0 Jan 17, 10:03pm
       Martin Freeman was a great Bilbo, sauget.diblosio 50 0 Jan 17, 7:39pm

  Collapse What will the last hobbit chronicle book be about ? hood815 670 10 Jan 13, 11:58pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Collapse Battles! Defiant 339 2 Jan 14, 4:08am
           Collapse well deskp 282 1 Jan 14, 5:56am
               Mmmm Defiant 239 0 Jan 14, 8:27am
       Collapse Is there definitely going to be another book? dormouse 246 4 Jan 14, 8:56am
           Collapse Release Date: 23 May 2015 Silmaril 260 3 Jan 14, 9:29am
               Collapse Thanks! dormouse 209 2 Jan 14, 9:42am
                   Collapse Placeholder DjU 99 1 Jan 14, 6:26pm
                       Ah - OK, thanks.... dormouse 107 0 Jan 14, 6:43pm
       Stay tuned... Timdalf 171 0 Jan 14, 1:46pm
       Daniel Falconer Dcole4 138 0 Jan 14, 4:49pm

  Collapse An Unexpected Tear Sharkey 1044 32 Jan 13, 11:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by GrimMorwen)
       Martin Thrain II 468 0 Jan 13, 11:30pm
       Collapse The most unexpectedly emotional moment in my third viewing... QuackingTroll 533 1 Jan 13, 11:32pm
           subject marillaraina 379 0 Jan 14, 12:37am
       All these things Glorfindela 445 0 Jan 13, 11:41pm
       Collapse The acorn scene Avandel 409 14 Jan 14, 12:59am
           Collapse About the acorn scene... AshNazg 402 11 Jan 14, 1:09am
               Collapse I've wondered this question for a long time. Seconds after I post it I thought of an answer AshNazg 372 1 Jan 14, 1:13am
                   I planted an English Oak in my yard Gwytha 278 0 Jan 14, 4:40am
               Collapse I guess you've never taken a pebble from a beach on a far flung holiday Spriggan 342 1 Jan 14, 1:14am
                   That's funny, I was just reading Ataahua's thread in Off topic AshNazg 329 0 Jan 14, 1:30am
               Collapse The Acorn might not have made it to the Shire Otaku-sempai 353 4 Jan 14, 1:21am
                   Collapse *Sob* Avandel 356 2 Jan 14, 1:30am
                       I'd hoped it would turn into the party tree... AshNazg 331 0 Jan 14, 1:34am
                       Love this drawing! elentari3018 259 0 Jan 14, 5:15am
                   *sticks fingers in ears, loud humming ensues* DisDwarfWoman 307 0 Jan 14, 2:33am
               Collapse There are lots of different sorts of oak Na Vedui 304 1 Jan 14, 2:28am
                   I felt stupid for asking after the first explanation... AshNazg 298 0 Jan 14, 2:41am
           YES!!// arithmancer 283 0 Jan 14, 2:49am
           I enjoyed ... CathrineB 113 0 Jan 14, 6:00pm
       Thorin being drawn to Azog Spriggan 378 0 Jan 14, 1:08am
       7 haarp 249 0 Jan 14, 7:55am
       Collapse It was not MY tears that were unexpected... Saneliur 273 1 Jan 14, 8:26am
           The thing that gets me about that Kim 109 0 Jan 14, 6:34pm
       There is a particular musical moment... Arannir 254 0 Jan 14, 8:42am
       I find tears coming at moments I don't expect dormouse 252 0 Jan 14, 9:10am
       Collapse Personally... CathrineB 237 1 Jan 14, 10:15am
           I'm like you, CathrineB Riven Delve 155 0 Jan 14, 3:18pm
       I got tears in my eyes at what is probably an odd time Dame Ioreth 166 0 Jan 14, 3:54pm
       One of the most moving moments for me Old Toby 157 0 Jan 14, 4:48pm
       I cried all through the burning of Laketown Gwytha 108 0 Jan 14, 6:50pm
       I'm really unemotional.... Bofur01 106 0 Jan 14, 7:46pm
       My Unexpected Tear GrimMorwen 64 0 Jan 15, 3:23pm

Collapse Home? what Irony.. Bombadil 554 6 Jan 13, 10:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Not really. Otaku-sempai 195 0 Jan 14, 1:23am
       Collapse I don't know if it's THE lesson Riven Delve 182 4 Jan 14, 2:23am
           Collapse love it! DisDwarfWoman 172 3 Jan 14, 2:37am
               Collapse Yes. It was only a replacement home, while Erebor mae govannen 55 2 Jan 15, 1:49pm
                   Collapse I love that part! DisDwarfWoman 36 1 Jan 15, 11:05pm
                     Exactly. Beautiful, and so moving... mae govannen 44 0 Jan 16, 4:58am

  Collapse I want to confess a sin: I like Legolas Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1073 52 Jan 13, 8:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by fiveforchaos)
       I'll join you on that! // Thranderz 487 0 Jan 13, 8:03pm
       Here,here// Aranaes 470 0 Jan 13, 8:08pm
       Yeah... tsmith675 472 0 Jan 13, 8:18pm
       Collapse I really like Legolas, too. DanielLB 496 11 Jan 13, 8:21pm
           Collapse I can top that... QuackingTroll 461 5 Jan 13, 8:43pm
             Collapse I'll see that and raise you... BlackFox 410 1 Jan 13, 9:12pm
                 Okay, okay you win! I can't take anymore // QuackingTroll 379 0 Jan 13, 9:19pm
               Collapse Everything about him in the EE I love. DanielLB 401 1 Jan 13, 9:17pm
                   Glad I'm not the only who likes the Great Goblin song! KingTurgon 258 0 Jan 14, 2:08am
               I also loved Bombur's barrel gag. fiveforchaos 30 0 Jan 18, 12:45pm
           I agree about Gimli... Bladerunner 258 0 Jan 14, 1:43am
           Collapse You don't like Gimli in the movies? Elessar 109 3 Jan 14, 5:29pm
               Collapse My admiration for Gimli. DanielLB 98 2 Jan 14, 5:50pm
                   Got ya. Elessar 87 0 Jan 14, 6:03pm
                   See, I still see that in the films. Imladris18 78 0 Jan 14, 6:10pm
       Is that a sin? mutelock 451 0 Jan 13, 8:31pm
       Collapse I HATE Legolas and his stupid fight scenes and bad acting... QuackingTroll 502 1 Jan 13, 8:40pm
           Totally agree with you! mangotree 260 0 Jan 14, 2:25am
       I like him very much too. NecromancerRising 434 0 Jan 13, 8:43pm
       Collapse Well that was quite normal Thrain II 445 11 Jan 13, 8:44pm
           Collapse I didn't like him in LotR, but for different reasons... QuackingTroll 447 5 Jan 13, 8:49pm
               Collapse LOL Thrain II 415 4 Jan 13, 8:56pm
                   Collapse I know. But there's a certain majesty to how, say, Haldir speaks... QuackingTroll 424 1 Jan 13, 9:03pm
                       I watched the FOTR commentary recently KingTurgon 273 0 Jan 14, 2:05am
                 Collapse RELAX for any Actor to Play "Leggy" Bombadil 411 1 Jan 13, 9:08pm
                       I don't want to sound like I'm just knocking Bloom... QuackingTroll 395 0 Jan 13, 9:17pm
           Collapse People started to hate him NecromancerRising 448 1 Jan 13, 9:11pm
               EXACTLY once he took on other ROLES Bombadil 383 0 Jan 13, 9:30pm
           Collapse I still love him in LOTR Avandel 310 2 Jan 13, 10:45pm
               Great post! Thrain II 294 0 Jan 13, 11:25pm
               He really doesn't have an abundance of screen time in BotFA though. Imladris18 145 0 Jan 14, 2:16pm
       That's not a sin.// Aragorn the Elfstone 359 0 Jan 13, 9:24pm
       Collapse I think his addition to the films was a good idea. FrogmortonJustice65 342 1 Jan 13, 9:56pm
           I felt that it wasn't worth the trade-off.... Bladerunner 262 0 Jan 14, 1:21am
       I thought Ataahua 340 0 Jan 13, 10:01pm
       Good for you - I like him too dormouse 276 0 Jan 13, 11:22pm
       I've been thinking about this Glorfindela 296 0 Jan 13, 11:58pm
       I like Legolas too. Noria 261 0 Jan 14, 1:20am
     Collapse It's not a sin KingTurgon 255 1 Jan 14, 2:10am
           Of course it's not a sin. There's all kinds of weirdos out there... AshNazg 255 0 Jan 14, 2:31am
       Collapse I like him too. arithmancer 248 1 Jan 14, 3:08am
           Yeah Ii showed real courage there by still suporting Tauriel when he knew that she loved Kili Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 169 0 Jan 14, 11:04am
       I like Legolas best in LOTR films Gwytha 217 0 Jan 14, 5:00am
       LOL! Talk about guilty pleasures! Old Toby 225 0 Jan 14, 5:13am
       why is it a sin??? Snowghost77 210 0 Jan 14, 7:06am
       Collapse Hm... Arannir 201 1 Jan 14, 8:44am
           He was one of my favourite characters in the book.... dormouse 200 0 Jan 14, 9:01am
       Legolas is like Elf mercury, very impulsive and volatile... the 13th warrior 172 0 Jan 14, 11:19am
       LOL!!! Excellent 'sin' in my book!!! mae govannen 135 0 Jan 14, 2:41pm
       Collapse I have a confession too Riven Delve 140 1 Jan 14, 3:02pm
           I think I actually love those stunts even more Gwytha 84 0 Jan 14, 6:43pm
       I quite enjoyed Legolas Elessar 116 0 Jan 14, 5:28pm

  Collapse Did little birdies tell them? Mooseboy018 638 10 Jan 13, 6:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       ravens Ilmatar 332 0 Jan 13, 6:34pm
       I like to think they're both off-screen moments... QuackingTroll 323 0 Jan 13, 6:34pm
       I tried answering the first question... BlackFox 303 0 Jan 13, 6:37pm
       Collapse On the second, the people of Laketown are clearly under new leadership Spriggan 285 1 Jan 13, 6:44pm
           Or his nephews who witnessed the whole thing simply told him on their arrival?// Aranaes 222 0 Jan 13, 7:46pm
       On the first.... dormouse 284 0 Jan 13, 7:04pm
       Collapse On the second one... Aranaes 246 3 Jan 13, 7:49pm
           I thought... DisDwarfWoman 217 0 Jan 13, 8:14pm
           Collapse I didn't even think of that. Mooseboy018 200 1 Jan 13, 8:27pm
               I still like to pretend the raven did it... QuackingTroll 200 0 Jan 13, 8:58pm

Collapse Some DOS questions Legolas_Shoehorn 587 5 Jan 13, 3:26pm Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       "This would look very cool!" Azaghâl 317 0 Jan 13, 3:40pm
       #1 Orcs brought their own barrel fleet but ended up going over the wall; and Brandybuckled 289 0 Jan 13, 3:51pm
       Bard recovered some older barrels? Otaku-sempai 275 0 Jan 13, 4:01pm
       Collapse Bell Tower in the Teaser Trailer Arandir 200 1 Jan 13, 6:24pm
           Here's a comparison QuackingTroll 207 0 Jan 13, 7:12pm

Collapse Silhouettes & Signature Weapons? Bombadil 438 6 Jan 13, 12:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by DisDwarfWoman)
       I do agree Elarie 193 0 Jan 13, 12:57pm
       Collapse Agree kilifili 180 1 Jan 13, 1:02pm
           Me too dormouse 152 0 Jan 13, 1:56pm
       Collapse Definitely! DisDwarfWoman 79 2 Jan 13, 8:23pm
           Collapse The Goblintown Fight & Escape featured Bombadil 72 1 Jan 13, 9:18pm
               Indeed! DisDwarfWoman 85 0 Jan 13, 9:29pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 951 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.