Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 1001 (357799 posts in 15006 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 1001 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Really hope that PJ gives Sir Christopher and Andrew Lesnie a tribute in the EE KingTurgon 396 3 Aug 9, 6:26pm Jump to last post in thread (by shadowdog)
       Collapse Yes definitely Smaug the iron 376 1 Aug 9, 6:31pm
           I agree, do it for both! KingTurgon 367 0 Aug 9, 6:36pm
       I fully expect homages to both shadowdog 317 0 Aug 9, 7:16pm

  Collapse An open mind... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1002 19 Aug 9, 1:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Collapse They are good if you do have the book in mind too, I would say. Spriggan 892 1 Aug 9, 2:30pm
           They are better if you have the book in mind. ;) // Estel78 844 0 Aug 9, 2:51pm
       Thank you for this.... dormouse 862 0 Aug 9, 2:45pm
       Collapse Well... Thrain II 825 12 Aug 9, 3:08pm
           Collapse Dain? Smaug the iron 809 2 Aug 9, 3:14pm
               Collapse He was in 6 scenes? MyWeeLadGimli 792 1 Aug 9, 3:25pm
                   Yes he have 6 scenes Smaug the iron 768 0 Aug 9, 3:38pm
           Collapse I bet Avandel 600 7 Aug 9, 5:56pm
               You're getting things mixed up here. Gandalf the Green 520 0 Aug 9, 7:24pm
               Collapse Thank you for your answer! Thrain II 487 5 Aug 9, 7:56pm
                   Collapse Yes Smaug the iron 476 4 Aug 9, 8:07pm
                       Seconded (or thirded)… Glorfindela 373 0 Aug 9, 11:29pm
                       Collapse Or Jabez Olssen Dipling 312 2 Aug 10, 5:09am
                           three editors Mooseboy018 301 0 Aug 10, 5:39am
                           Smeagol error Mooseboy018 299 0 Aug 10, 5:42am
           Neither this trilogy nor the SW prequels have been labeled as failures KingTurgon 544 0 Aug 9, 6:57pm
       Yesterday OldestDaughter 774 0 Aug 9, 3:34pm
       Not thinking about the books. Arannir 635 0 Aug 9, 5:34pm
       You are right, the movies ARE good! Kilidoescartwheels 193 0 Aug 10, 2:04pm

  Collapse 10 Things You Didn't Know About 'The Desolation Of Smaug' Smaug the iron 538 4 Aug 9, 1:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Thrain II)
       Collapse Didn't know about the Beorn poster. Did you know... QuackingTroll 480 2 Aug 9, 1:46pm
           Collapse I prefer the one on the offiicial website. Smaug the iron 468 1 Aug 9, 1:50pm
               Exactly, but the one on the official website isn't available anywhere else... QuackingTroll 460 0 Aug 9, 1:56pm
       Didn't know about the Beorn poster also Thrain II 415 0 Aug 9, 2:24pm

Collapse Alternate endings/scenes to the trilogy Cirashala 852 14 Aug 8, 11:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Collapse Legolas' death... QuackingTroll 766 3 Aug 8, 11:58pm
           I like it! Cirashala 759 0 Aug 9, 12:01am
           Collapse Wouldnt Faleel 756 1 Aug 9, 12:02am
               I imagined both kinda happening... QuackingTroll 749 0 Aug 9, 12:06am
       The best alternative ending.... Morthoron 714 0 Aug 9, 12:47am
       Well, I actually know how the EE ends already... AshNazg 717 0 Aug 9, 12:55am
       Collapse This is how I'd end it (seriously). Bumblingidiot 658 1 Aug 9, 2:51am
           thanks for that lovely mental image Cirashala 652 0 Aug 9, 2:55am
       No way! It was PERFECT as IS! Bishop 411 0 Aug 9, 1:08pm
       Well Smaug the iron 287 0 Aug 9, 8:40pm
       . MyWeeLadGimli 267 0 Aug 9, 9:10pm
       Collapse Old Bilbo is looking at his ring.... dormouse 235 2 Aug 9, 10:45pm
         Dormouse for the win! Cirashala 226 0 Aug 9, 11:01pm
           Brilliant!! :D // Loresilme 123 0 Aug 10, 3:17pm

  Collapse How much could fit in 20 minutes? lionoferebor 1633 67 Aug 8, 9:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by Spriggan)
       Collapse You forgot one in DOS Smaug the iron 1454 2 Aug 8, 9:47pm
           Collapse You're right... lionoferebor 1427 1 Aug 8, 9:57pm
               You’re welcome Smaug the iron 1424 0 Aug 8, 9:58pm
       Collapse a lot can happen in 20 minutes Cirashala 1346 40 Aug 8, 11:10pm
           Collapse 100% this! droidsocket 1239 39 Aug 9, 2:04am
               Collapse Yes lionoferebor 1224 38 Aug 9, 2:36am
                   Collapse 20 Minutes brotherbeck 1196 1 Aug 9, 3:25am
                       I agree... lionoferebor 1182 0 Aug 9, 3:55am
                   Collapse New scenes aragorn2015 349 35 Aug 10, 6:34am
                       Collapse Falling out of love with Kili lionoferebor 308 34 Aug 10, 12:54pm
                           Collapse True on both parts... Dcole4 293 28 Aug 10, 1:28pm
                               Thank you lionoferebor 262 0 Aug 10, 2:53pm
                               Collapse I don't understand why people STILL insist that the romance was... Aragorn the Elfstone 238 19 Aug 10, 4:10pm
                                   Collapse Partly True... Dcole4 226 18 Aug 10, 4:26pm
                                       Collapse Apparently the healing scene was also added... QuackingTroll 223 3 Aug 10, 4:33pm
                                           Collapse No Smaug the iron 213 2 Aug 10, 4:38pm
                                               Collapse Evidence?// QuackingTroll 205 1 Aug 10, 4:38pm
                                                   The appendices Smaug the iron 208 0 Aug 10, 4:41pm
                                       No Smaug the iron 215 0 Aug 10, 4:35pm
                                       Collapse No Smaug the iron 205 12 Aug 11, 7:30am
                                           Collapse Ravenhill and Dale Otaku-sempai 175 11 Aug 11, 2:16pm
                                               Collapse Only a couple of tweaks but Spriggan 163 10 Aug 11, 7:08pm
                                                   Collapse Actually, it does conflict with Thror's map. Otaku-sempai 149 9 Aug 11, 8:14pm
                                                       Collapse Well the scales are clearly different but I thought Spriggan 139 8 Aug 11, 10:16pm
                                                           Collapse Thror's Map Otaku-sempai 129 7 Aug 12, 12:54am
                                                               Collapse I think we might be at cross purposes Spriggan 112 6 Aug 12, 8:31am
                                                                   Collapse Thror's (movie) map agrees with Tolkien on Ravenhill. Otaku-sempai 98 5 Aug 12, 1:16pm
                                                                       Collapse Only if one chooses to imagine the label refers to that point Spriggan 88 4 Aug 12, 3:45pm
                                                                           Collapse Ravenhill and the ridge Otaku-sempai 69 3 Aug 12, 10:07pm
                                                                               Collapse To agree Spriggan 59 2 Aug 12, 10:25pm
  Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 53 1 Aug 12, 10:33pm
       Fair enough :) Spriggan 50 0 Aug 12, 10:40pm
                               Collapse another great post IMO Avandel 221 6 Aug 10, 4:28pm
                                   Collapse LOL! Well said IMO lionoferebor 192 3 Aug 10, 4:58pm
                                       Collapse my guess bilbo1997 161 2 Aug 10, 6:11pm
                                           Collapse If that's what makes it in... Dcole4 154 1 Aug 10, 6:23pm
                                               - bilbo1997 148 0 Aug 10, 6:29pm
                                   Collapse Daddy to a biological son and a foster daughter? Ilmatar 196 1 Aug 11, 8:32am
                                       Tauriel's age. Otaku-sempai 175 0 Aug 11, 2:18pm
                           Collapse Well said IMO! Avandel 244 3 Aug 10, 4:02pm
                               I think Smaug the iron 227 0 Aug 10, 4:18pm
                               Collapse May I just throw a tiny, weeny, mouse-sized spanner into the idea.... dormouse 277 1 Aug 10, 7:27pm
                                   I think most people are upset for another reason... Dcole4 270 0 Aug 10, 7:42pm
                           Tauriel aragorn2015 224 0 Aug 11, 3:15am
       Collapse I want the Dwarf hero moments! Kilidoescartwheels 1151 4 Aug 9, 4:47am
           Collapse dwarves Mooseboy018 1122 3 Aug 9, 5:23am
               Legolas doing his stunts on the broken stairs Elanor of Rohan 990 0 Aug 9, 9:53am
               Agree with this Glorfindela 973 0 Aug 9, 10:19am
               THIS Avandel 482 0 Aug 9, 5:23pm
       A lot can be done in 20 minutes squiggle 1147 0 Aug 9, 4:50am
       Collapse In my opinion Kelly of Water's Edge 930 1 Aug 9, 11:09am
           Yes, I'd go along with those.... dormouse 909 0 Aug 9, 11:32am
       Collapse Did the announcement of the new 25 minutes of DOS? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 842 14 Aug 9, 12:43pm
           Collapse No, the additional 25 does not include the arranged footage lionoferebor 808 13 Aug 9, 1:26pm
               Collapse So this means that Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 796 12 Aug 9, 1:30pm
                   Collapse Dol Guldur lionoferebor 770 11 Aug 9, 1:58pm
                       Collapse Galadriel and Gandalf moments arithmancer 761 5 Aug 9, 2:03pm
                           Collapse The kiss lionoferebor 716 4 Aug 9, 3:00pm
                               Collapse So far so good... arithmancer 521 3 Aug 9, 3:23pm
                                   Collapse To be honest... lionoferebor 464 2 Aug 9, 5:43pm
                                       Collapse Sorry, mistook your meaning arithmancer 455 1 Aug 9, 5:52pm
                                           No problem... lionoferebor 422 0 Aug 9, 6:34pm
                       Collapse The three elven rings. Smaug the iron 756 3 Aug 9, 2:06pm
                           Collapse The Three Rings lionoferebor 703 2 Aug 9, 3:18pm
                               Collapse Yes Smaug the iron 512 1 Aug 9, 3:33pm
                                   It would seem... lionoferebor 457 0 Aug 9, 5:45pm
                       Weel regarding the rings and Benedict Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 749 0 Aug 9, 2:10pm

  Collapse R rating for sentimental scenes DainPig 1097 27 Aug 8, 3:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bishop)
       Collapse unless there is very revealing intimacy involved Cirashala 1024 9 Aug 8, 4:08pm
           R vs PG-13 arithmancer 786 0 Aug 8, 6:10pm
           Collapse birds and bees Smaug the iron 680 7 Aug 8, 8:05pm
               Collapse they have a freaking dragon attacking town Cirashala 652 6 Aug 8, 8:34pm
                   Collapse Maybe in Dale. Smaug the iron 638 5 Aug 8, 8:46pm
                       Collapse Bain sees Alfrid in a dress // QuackingTroll 616 1 Aug 8, 8:57pm
                           LOL Smaug the iron 606 0 Aug 8, 9:01pm
                       Sigrid is 14 or 15 Cirashala 589 0 Aug 8, 9:10pm
                       Collapse Sigrid DEFINITELY saw some hot dwarves Kilidoescartwheels 416 1 Aug 9, 4:29am
                           True... lionoferebor 366 0 Aug 9, 6:54am
       Collapse No Avandel 1004 2 Aug 8, 4:14pm
           Collapse Perhaps zalmoxis 900 1 Aug 8, 5:06pm
               Freeman now displays his middle finger in every scene // QuackingTroll 824 0 Aug 8, 5:46pm
       Collapse R-rated funeral? Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 994 1 Aug 8, 4:17pm
         I'd pay to see that Avandel 934 0 Aug 8, 4:47pm
       Collapse "Rated R for some violence" Númenórean 955 2 Aug 8, 4:38pm
           Thank you Shagrat 943 0 Aug 8, 4:42pm
           Any Idea what this will be in the UK? QuackingTroll 826 0 Aug 8, 5:47pm
       Definitely Not MyWeeLadGimli 739 0 Aug 8, 6:54pm
       Collapse It is the never-seen and little-known Tauriel shower scene. Otaku-sempai 625 3 Aug 8, 8:53pm
           In 3D? Shut up and take my money! // QuackingTroll 618 0 Aug 8, 8:55pm
           Collapse not too far off Mooseboy018 442 1 Aug 9, 3:45am
               Yup, you're right, according to Paul Lasaine... Eleniel 399 0 Aug 9, 5:23am
       I agree that young people shouldn't be exposed to Tauriel, without an adult to explain that she shouldn't really be there. Bumblingidiot 452 0 Aug 9, 3:07am
       Collapse I think it will be… Glorfindela 126 1 Aug 9, 1:13pm
           And all the ladys who love Olando Bloom Smaug the iron 122 0 Aug 9, 1:19pm
       I really don't get the confusion about this R thing Bishop 107 0 Aug 9, 2:19pm

  Collapse Nervousness Thread - When (do you think) we will see the official announcement/first clip of EE? Númenórean 1042 9 Aug 7, 10:58pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avnar)
       I think... Dcole4 987 0 Aug 7, 11:03pm
       I had hoped it would come out today... Aragorn the Elfstone 957 0 Aug 7, 11:15pm
       Collapse Who cares? This movie is dead. // xxxyyy 859 3 Aug 8, 12:45am
           Collapse True. David44 846 1 Aug 8, 1:03am
               what?! NoelGallagher 702 0 Aug 8, 6:49am
           This... Avnar 147 0 Aug 9, 10:15pm
       According to this... lionoferebor 417 0 Aug 8, 5:54pm
       We need this. Mooseboy018 281 0 Aug 9, 3:49am
       Hopefully tomorrow we 'll get something David44 184 0 Aug 9, 6:45pm

  Collapse Pessimism Thread - What do you think will be left out? Mooseboy018 1579 65 Aug 7, 10:15pm Jump to last post in thread (by Aragorn the Elfstone)
       I think they will miss out the scenes Spriggan 1432 0 Aug 7, 10:22pm
       it's a matter of perspective Elanor of Rohan 1431 0 Aug 7, 10:22pm
       Fili Smaug the iron 1429 0 Aug 7, 10:23pm
       I think the most potential scene to be left ou in your list is... DainPig 1415 0 Aug 7, 10:26pm
       Weeell... dormouse 1406 0 Aug 7, 10:29pm
       Collapse Ugh... Dcole4 1402 4 Aug 7, 10:33pm
           Collapse Dain Mooseboy018 1375 3 Aug 7, 10:44pm
               Collapse She didn't confirmed... Dcole4 1371 2 Aug 7, 10:47pm
                   Collapse True. Mooseboy018 1363 1 Aug 7, 10:50pm
                       Definitely Dcole4 1341 0 Aug 7, 10:59pm
       Collapse D-D-D-Dol Guldur... AshNazg 1397 4 Aug 7, 10:37pm
           Good point... Dcole4 1379 0 Aug 7, 10:41pm
           Collapse I hope you are wrong. Dol Guldur was the worst part of the movie (edititng problems)... when it should have been the best // xxxyyy 1170 2 Aug 8, 12:43am
               Like The Book brotherbeck 1155 0 Aug 8, 1:05am
               More reason to see less of it IMO // AshNazg 346 0 Aug 8, 4:49pm
       Collapse Anything Fili... CathrineB 1381 1 Aug 7, 10:40pm
           What about fans of Gloin? He was my favourite // AshNazg 1320 0 Aug 7, 11:07pm
       Fili Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1316 0 Aug 7, 11:13pm
       Collapse Fili lionoferebor 1295 37 Aug 7, 11:28pm
           Collapse The Quiet Character Scenes brotherbeck 1259 36 Aug 7, 11:56pm
               Collapse Like in the book. Smaug the iron 1242 35 Aug 8, 12:04am
                   Collapse the dwarves Mooseboy018 1209 34 Aug 8, 12:26am
                       Collapse Fili was used... QuackingTroll 1187 8 Aug 8, 12:37am
                           Collapse Unfortunately, this is true Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 731 7 Aug 8, 1:57am
                               Collapse the surprises Elanor of Rohan 644 6 Aug 8, 9:50am
                                   Collapse Oh go ahead re Alrid Avandel 456 1 Aug 8, 2:22pm
                                       Hope is fading lionoferebor 324 0 Aug 8, 5:15pm
                                   Collapse But Alfrid IS the Jar Jark Binks of this trilogy Kilidoescartwheels 379 3 Aug 9, 3:42am
                                       Collapse IMO very good points! Avandel 250 2 Aug 9, 6:36pm
                                           Collapse I think the question about the Master's role is easily resolved.... dormouse 228 1 Aug 9, 7:52pm
                                               Thank you Dormouse (: Avandel 164 0 Aug 10, 1:42am
                       Collapse Indeed so. Macfeast 1145 22 Aug 8, 1:19am
                           Collapse Thorin is supposed to be inconsistent Goblin Mutant 592 8 Aug 8, 11:06am
                               Collapse He had just overcome his dragon sickness at that point. Macfeast 578 7 Aug 8, 11:20am
                                   Collapse Cheers for clarifying Goblin Mutant 566 1 Aug 8, 11:33am
                                       I think that... Macfeast 544 0 Aug 8, 11:47am
                                   Collapse So Smaug the iron 540 4 Aug 8, 11:49am
                                       Collapse The opposite. // Macfeast 534 2 Aug 8, 11:52am
                                           Collapse Sorry Smaug the iron 526 1 Aug 8, 11:56am
                                               No need to apologize, happens to everyone :) // Macfeast 522 0 Aug 8, 11:57am
                                       Maybe Goblin Mutant 512 0 Aug 8, 12:13pm
                           Collapse But did he, though? dormouse 469 12 Aug 8, 2:01pm
                               And I would add Avandel 420 0 Aug 8, 2:59pm
                               Collapse I think my problem lies very much in what we do not see. Macfeast 414 10 Aug 8, 3:05pm
                                   Collapse 164 Minutes brotherbeck 369 4 Aug 8, 4:23pm
                                       You're not the only one... lionoferebor 283 0 Aug 8, 5:47pm
                                       Collapse *Sigh* - completely agree with this Avandel 275 2 Aug 8, 5:52pm
                                           Collapse Editing brotherbeck 493 1 Aug 8, 6:11pm
                                               Yes - frustrating! Avandel 454 0 Aug 8, 7:00pm
                                   Collapse Nice - a thought Avandel 354 1 Aug 8, 4:42pm
                                       The poignancy of Thorin's words grew something immensely in retrospect. Macfeast 264 0 Aug 8, 6:07pm
                                   Collapse Thorin does explain it Cirashala 323 2 Aug 8, 5:14pm
                                       Oh, for what might have been... Avandel 479 0 Aug 8, 6:27pm
                                       Realistic and logical... Macfeast 476 0 Aug 8, 6:29pm
                       Collapse Hear, hear!!!!! Avandel 730 1 Aug 8, 2:00am
                           I think Smaug the iron 629 0 Aug 8, 10:18am
       Fimi QuackingTroll 1248 0 Aug 7, 11:58pm
       Collapse Don't forget, the revised timing statement from Bill Hunt still quotes most of the additional material Eleniel 368 6 Aug 9, 5:48am
           The final 3rd needs the most focus! adt100 317 0 Aug 9, 8:57am
           that amuses me Cirashala 200 0 Aug 9, 11:12pm
           Collapse Well Smaug the iron 192 3 Aug 9, 11:23pm
               Collapse As sad as I am about this Cirashala 184 2 Aug 9, 11:41pm
                   Oh yes... Eleniel 139 0 Aug 10, 6:26am
                   On the contrary, I'll be really surprised if we don't get that scene. Aragorn the Elfstone 136 0 Aug 10, 6:33am
       You guys are too pessimistic imo. Aragorn the Elfstone 358 0 Aug 9, 6:00am

  Collapse Spoiler - Durin Deaths BOTFA EE lionoferebor 1601 40 Aug 7, 9:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse maybe it is Fili Smaug the iron 1481 1 Aug 7, 9:58pm
           Maybe they did mix it up Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1318 0 Aug 7, 11:16pm
       Collapse Azog's death was toned down a little too... QuackingTroll 1481 37 Aug 7, 10:01pm
           Collapse Baffled Glorfindela 1398 36 Aug 7, 10:40pm
               Collapse Since you mention it a couple of times Spriggan 1361 13 Aug 7, 10:54pm
                   Collapse Plot holes Glorfindela 1008 12 Aug 8, 10:25am
                       Collapse No rush. Spriggan 992 11 Aug 8, 10:40am
                           Collapse There are six huge plot-holes AshNazg 835 10 Aug 8, 1:19pm
                               No - those are pot-holes... ;-) // dormouse 792 0 Aug 8, 2:02pm
                               Collapse Well Shagrat 779 8 Aug 8, 2:20pm
                                   Collapse Not really.... dormouse 755 6 Aug 8, 2:43pm
                                       Collapse That's not correct Shagrat 736 3 Aug 8, 2:52pm
                                           Collapse I think that's assuming an instant reaction. Spriggan 709 2 Aug 8, 3:09pm
                                               Collapse That's really stretching Shagrat 697 1 Aug 8, 3:18pm
                                                   I don't think there is any stretch - it hadn't occurred to me until you mentioned it Spriggan 688 0 Aug 8, 3:28pm
                                       Collapse Also Shagrat 713 1 Aug 8, 3:05pm
                                           Jibe? No, I don't do jibes.... dormouse 358 0 Aug 8, 6:13pm
                                   Why not? Spriggan 741 0 Aug 8, 2:48pm
               Collapse They are certainly necessary Arandir 1082 21 Aug 8, 8:09am
                   Collapse No blood Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 959 19 Aug 8, 11:13am
                       Collapse LOTR did a great job Arandir 942 2 Aug 8, 11:23am
                           Collapse Believable violence Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 927 1 Aug 8, 11:48am
                               This... lionoferebor 860 0 Aug 8, 12:48pm
                       Collapse Maybe the R rating... CathrineB 946 15 Aug 8, 11:24am
                           PG-13 lionoferebor 893 0 Aug 8, 12:19pm
                           Collapse No need to apologize for that Gandalf the Green 439 1 Aug 8, 4:45pm
                               Thank you lionoferebor 409 0 Aug 8, 5:25pm
                           Collapse I've always felt that Fili's death was edited short... QuackingTroll 384 1 Aug 8, 5:53pm
                               Something was edited Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 362 0 Aug 8, 6:12pm
                           Lack of blood Ilmatar 323 0 Aug 8, 8:32pm
                           Collapse The blood on Fili's face Kilidoescartwheels 248 8 Aug 9, 3:28am
                               Collapse Wouldn't it be...uh nice...to see this lionoferebor 239 7 Aug 9, 4:04am
                                   Collapse I can't see that happening Cirashala 236 6 Aug 9, 4:14am
                                       Collapse First off... lionoferebor 234 5 Aug 9, 4:42am
                                           Collapse Thank you :) Cirashala 148 4 Aug 9, 11:07pm
                                               Collapse I hope you continue to feel better quickly! // Voronwë_the_Faithful 139 1 Aug 9, 11:12pm
                                                   thank you :) Cirashala 136 0 Aug 9, 11:13pm
                                               Collapse Oh my... lionoferebor 118 1 Aug 10, 12:01am
                                                   thanks Cirashala 114 0 Aug 10, 12:07am
                   Well that doesn't explain his reaction Kilidoescartwheels 255 0 Aug 9, 3:22am

  Collapse Running time: still 164 minutes! TheHutt 1715 22 Aug 7, 8:20pm Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       Double confirmation... Dcole4 1617 0 Aug 7, 8:27pm
       This was mentioned in a previous thread... QuackingTroll 1596 0 Aug 7, 8:30pm
       Collapse I guess 20 minutes it is. OldestDaughter 1533 10 Aug 7, 8:50pm
           Collapse what is confusing and disappointing... Dcole4 1512 9 Aug 7, 8:57pm
               Collapse The question is Smaug the iron 1486 3 Aug 7, 9:02pm
                   I don't think it's fair if WB got involved... QuackingTroll 998 0 Aug 8, 2:08am
                   Collapse IF material has been deliberately omitted from the EEs - Hanzkaz 709 1 Aug 8, 11:30am
                       Of course material has been deliberately omitted! Spriggan 672 0 Aug 8, 11:56am
             Yeah but... Avandel 1018 0 Aug 8, 1:52am
               Collapse I wonder about the wording of this quote... QuackingTroll 1011 3 Aug 8, 2:03am
                   Thats it Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 804 0 Aug 8, 9:14am
                   Collapse Here Smaug the iron 781 1 Aug 8, 9:38am
                       Well, he said it would be 30mins long... QuackingTroll 602 0 Aug 8, 1:33pm
       Collapse Big disappointment... Thrain II 1488 1 Aug 7, 9:01pm
           Agree with this Glorfindela 1207 0 Aug 7, 10:35pm
       future box set theory coming strong Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1469 0 Aug 7, 9:04pm
       Collapse My deepest apologies, guys. Aragorn the Elfstone 1388 3 Aug 7, 9:27pm
           It is okey Aragorn Smaug the iron 1345 0 Aug 7, 9:38pm
           Time for you to go into hiding... QuackingTroll 1308 0 Aug 7, 9:50pm
           It's okay MechaGodzilla 1250 0 Aug 7, 10:17pm
       Why does it hurt so much? Mooseboy018 1327 0 Aug 7, 9:45pm
       But that´s still with a 10 minutes of re-arranged TE footage, could be? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 808 0 Aug 8, 9:13am

  Collapse what about the super extended editions to come Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1039 15 Aug 7, 7:22pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       You mean... DainPig 952 0 Aug 7, 7:32pm
       Collapse I am starting to wonder at this point Shagrat 949 1 Aug 7, 7:36pm
           A couple things... Dcole4 911 0 Aug 7, 7:50pm
       I'll be very annoyed if it turns out they deliberately reduced the extra material - Hanzkaz 910 0 Aug 7, 7:50pm
       Collapse About the "Never Venture East" scene OldestDaughter 882 1 Aug 7, 8:01pm
           RE: Never Venture East Dcole4 830 0 Aug 7, 8:26pm
       I find all this very unlikely. Spriggan 877 0 Aug 7, 8:02pm
       Collapse A "super extended edition" of any of the films is something I find about as likely as... Aragorn the Elfstone 719 2 Aug 7, 10:21pm
           Yeah Mooseboy018 686 0 Aug 7, 10:48pm
           I wouldn't say that... Dcole4 679 0 Aug 7, 10:50pm
       Collapse At this point we're really just grasping at the last straw :-) Earl 579 4 Aug 8, 2:33am
           Collapse He did.... dormouse 475 3 Aug 8, 9:26am
               Collapse I don't think most people are being negative just for the sake of being negative Earl 403 2 Aug 8, 12:37pm
                   Collapse Hard to feel cheerful in here right now, Earl... dormouse 359 1 Aug 8, 2:37pm
                       Great post but timing tho Avandel 318 0 Aug 8, 3:48pm

  Collapse The chariot scene at the end of Sons of Durin track DainPig 469 6 Aug 7, 5:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by werewormses)
       Collapse . SafeUnderHill 446 4 Aug 7, 6:00pm
           Collapse This means... DainPig 425 3 Aug 7, 6:07pm
               I think Smaug the iron 404 0 Aug 7, 6:16pm
               Collapse Not necessarily Shagrat 402 1 Aug 7, 6:16pm
                   Not to mention Faleel 394 0 Aug 7, 6:20pm
     I've always believed that music to belong to... werewormses 212 0 Aug 8, 1:18am

  Collapse Thread Locked BOTFA Extended Edition cover? I found it in Amazon.... DainPig 771 3 Aug 7, 12:17am Jump to last post in thread (by dernwyn)
       Thread Locked Already discussing it here: QuackingTroll 725 0 Aug 7, 12:26am
       Thread Locked I'd come closer to believing THIS one Kilidoescartwheels 716 0 Aug 7, 12:30am
       Thread Locked Please discuss this in the existing thread below. Thanks!// dernwyn 667 0 Aug 7, 12:59am

  Collapse BotFA EE: 20 Minutes NEW Footage, 10 Minutes EXCHANGED Footage Legolas_Shoehorn 2916 50 Aug 6, 10:20pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse That's speculation only.// Aragorn the Elfstone 2740 3 Aug 6, 10:23pm
           Collapse Yep Faleel 2728 2 Aug 6, 10:25pm
               one thing is readjusting scenes Elanor of Rohan 2701 0 Aug 6, 10:32pm
               . SafeUnderHill 903 0 Aug 7, 5:54pm
       a new film? balbo biggins 2521 0 Aug 7, 12:24am
       Collapse One of a kind cinematic Fantasy Adventure Trilogy completion squiggle 2444 1 Aug 7, 1:26am
           Too Good To Be True brotherbeck 2369 0 Aug 7, 2:46am
       Collapse this would be awesome and tends to confirm.... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 2142 1 Aug 7, 7:50am
           Agreed! This is actually very promising in a way.... adt100 2054 0 Aug 7, 9:19am
       Collapse Well Gandalf the Green 1981 37 Aug 7, 10:13am
           Collapse One can only hope not Spriggan 1909 34 Aug 7, 11:10am
             Collapse No. Gandalf the Green 1817 33 Aug 7, 11:53am
                   Collapse I would think that there is something wrong with that. Spriggan 1717 19 Aug 7, 1:00pm
                       Collapse Seems to work out well for Marvel... AshNazg 1694 18 Aug 7, 1:11pm
                           Collapse I think the Marvel and DC models are quite the reverse. Spriggan 1577 16 Aug 7, 2:29pm
                               Collapse I have at agree.. droidsocket 1511 1 Aug 7, 3:05pm
                                   I very much agree with your points. Spriggan 1344 0 Aug 7, 4:16pm
                             Collapse Bomby is not sure where he read it..BUT? Bombadil 1499 13 Aug 7, 3:10pm
                                   Collapse That may be true... droidsocket 1472 2 Aug 7, 3:23pm
                                       Collapse . SafeUnderHill 895 1 Aug 7, 5:56pm
                                           also droidsocket 775 0 Aug 7, 7:14pm
                                   Collapse no balbo biggins 853 9 Aug 7, 6:30pm
                                       Collapse Which of Da Vinci's writings Spriggan 847 8 Aug 7, 6:36pm
                                           Collapse hmm balbo biggins 676 7 Aug 7, 9:15pm
                                               Collapse More than a bit "debatable" I think Spriggan 656 6 Aug 7, 9:24pm
                                                   Collapse I'm reminded of Yogi Berra... Darkstone 644 1 Aug 7, 9:29pm
                                                       Appropriated quotes Spriggan 621 0 Aug 7, 9:54pm
                                                   Collapse huh? balbo biggins 542 3 Aug 8, 12:54am
                                                       Collapse Oh was it from a book? Spriggan 396 2 Aug 8, 5:21pm
                                                           Collapse double huh? balbo biggins 369 1 Aug 8, 6:05pm
                                                               I meant your source... Spriggan 191 0 Aug 9, 2:11pm
                           Let's not make this a Marvel vs DC debate. tsmith675 1384 0 Aug 7, 4:00pm
                   Collapse But I thought you wanted him to listen to fans.... dormouse 1455 12 Aug 7, 3:30pm
                       Collapse Me? droidsocket 1390 1 Aug 7, 3:57pm
                           No - sorry..... dormouse 1294 0 Aug 7, 4:36pm
                       Collapse Fans Mooseboy018 1315 3 Aug 7, 4:32pm
                           Collapse Oh, here we go..... dormouse 972 2 Aug 7, 4:57pm
                               Collapse Dormouse? Otaku-sempai 874 1 Aug 7, 6:12pm
                                   Words, Otaku, words and their meanings..... dormouse 815 0 Aug 7, 7:00pm
                       Collapse Full Acceptance? Gandalf the Green 313 5 Aug 9, 12:15am
                           Collapse Well, OK dormouse 262 4 Aug 9, 8:02am
                               Collapse Not like that Gandalf the Green 204 3 Aug 9, 1:19pm
                                   Collapse Hmmm, well.... dormouse 178 2 Aug 9, 2:42pm
                                       Collapse ... Gandalf the Green 136 1 Aug 9, 7:43pm
                                           ya know Cirashala 69 0 Aug 9, 11:09pm
           Collapse That's ridiculous SafeUnderHill 888 1 Aug 7, 6:01pm
               It already is removed though :p KingTurgon 516 0 Aug 8, 3:46am
       Collapse I really want to believe it. Arannir 1893 1 Aug 7, 11:18am
           I don't think he wanted to make a conclusion... QuackingTroll 602 0 Aug 7, 10:18pm
       Just remove Legolas? FrodoEyes 708 0 Aug 7, 8:24pm

  Collapse The plot thickens. TheDigitalBits confirms that the Extended Cut is... Aragorn the Elfstone 2811 87 Aug 6, 9:23pm Jump to last post in thread (by droidsocket)
       Well that is.... interesting.... adt100 2536 0 Aug 6, 9:27pm
       Collapse And now we all owe kilidoescartwheels an apology // QuackingTroll 2531 3 Aug 6, 9:27pm
           I don't think any of us will mind that. ;) // Aragorn the Elfstone 2515 0 Aug 6, 9:29pm
           Collapse apology accepted Kilidoescartwheels 2399 1 Aug 6, 9:53pm
               Lol KingTurgon 891 0 Aug 7, 12:09am
       Collapse this length is more in line Elanor of Rohan 2524 9 Aug 6, 9:29pm
           Collapse Weird speculation, but Alfrid's death... QuackingTroll 2510 8 Aug 6, 9:31pm
               Collapse Pray for the best but prepare for the worst bilbo1997 2486 7 Aug 6, 9:36pm
                   Collapse Still assuming 20 for now. Mooseboy018 2323 6 Aug 6, 10:04pm
                       Collapse Entirely reliable. Aragorn the Elfstone 2307 4 Aug 6, 10:07pm
                           Collapse bookmarked Mooseboy018 2279 3 Aug 6, 10:11pm
                               Collapse If the info is wrong, I'll likely have to go into hiding for a while... Aragorn the Elfstone 1167 1 Aug 6, 10:19pm
                                   Thank you bilbo1997 1139 0 Aug 6, 10:26pm
                               There are some words you just cannot say angrily... QuackingTroll 869 0 Aug 7, 12:23am
                       Agreed! Thrain II 1011 0 Aug 6, 11:10pm
       Collapse I'm believing this for now. tsmith675 2519 2 Aug 6, 9:30pm
           Collapse So what the previous link a fake? adt100 2481 1 Aug 6, 9:40pm
               FSK TheHutt 2464 0 Aug 6, 9:41pm
       That is good, Smaug the iron 2509 0 Aug 6, 9:31pm
       19 mins could still be ok... adt100 2437 0 Aug 6, 9:45pm
       Collapse Noooooooooo Mooseboy018 2414 1 Aug 6, 9:48pm
           I feel the same, we don't know how reliable this is... QuackingTroll 2385 0 Aug 6, 9:54pm
       Possible 3-hour cut Otaku-sempai 2367 0 Aug 6, 9:56pm
     Collapse It means nothing... Númenórean 2354 8 Aug 6, 9:59pm
           It says they have new info Elanor of Rohan 2339 0 Aug 6, 10:02pm
           Collapse Not the same thing. Aragorn the Elfstone 2339 2 Aug 6, 10:03pm
               Collapse I REALLY hope you are right Númenórean 2266 1 Aug 6, 10:13pm
                   At topic starter bilbo1997 1173 0 Aug 6, 10:17pm
           Time will tell... Otaku-sempai 2326 0 Aug 6, 10:03pm
           Collapse Exactly Shagrat 479 2 Aug 7, 8:15am
               Collapse PJ-Speech? zalmoxis 950 1 Aug 7, 8:41am
                   Doubt it Shagrat 942 0 Aug 7, 8:47am
       Skeptical... Dcole4 2298 0 Aug 6, 10:08pm
       TheDigitalBits Lindele 1149 0 Aug 6, 10:25pm
       But the FSK... Olorin2607 1123 0 Aug 6, 10:32pm
       Collapse German FSK is law Estel78 1104 19 Aug 6, 10:41pm
           Collapse As said elsewhere, the German version may be different... QuackingTroll 870 4 Aug 7, 12:20am
               What is the FSK rating? lionoferebor 769 0 Aug 7, 2:00am
               Collapse This very possible... lionoferebor 697 2 Aug 7, 3:25am
                   Collapse R rating is equivalent to the German 16 rating Estel78 582 1 Aug 7, 6:33am
                       Still... lionoferebor 866 0 Aug 7, 10:53am
           Collapse German extended edition Otaku-sempai 661 11 Aug 7, 4:24am
               Collapse There's no way the German version is 15 minutes shorter Estel78 590 10 Aug 7, 6:26am
                   There's a first time for everything lionoferebor 850 0 Aug 7, 11:10am
                   Collapse Alternatives Otaku-sempai 657 8 Aug 7, 3:01pm
                       Collapse contact bilbo1997 624 7 Aug 7, 3:16pm
                           Collapse Actually, we should know for sure soon enough. Aragorn the Elfstone 595 2 Aug 7, 3:31pm
                               Collapse . Vashetti 524 1 Aug 7, 4:03pm
                                   Maybe today. Otaku-sempai 432 0 Aug 7, 4:49pm
                           Collapse Aragorn? Otaku-sempai 594 2 Aug 7, 3:32pm
                             Collapse That may be overstating my position a bit. Aragorn the Elfstone 465 1 Aug 7, 4:39pm
                                   You are only the messenger. Otaku-sempai 437 0 Aug 7, 4:46pm
                           I asked him about the German Classification Board listing on his Facebook page Voronwë_the_Faithful 582 0 Aug 7, 3:36pm
           Collapse The FSK and the MPAA are both law lionoferebor 849 1 Aug 7, 11:09am
               No one is saying any ratings board is wrong Estel78 728 0 Aug 7, 2:07pm
       Collapse Well, it seems the movie could be smoother with the additional scenes at the end Eruonen 1066 11 Aug 6, 10:51pm
           Collapse Don't we already know about Legloas? Spriggan 1017 10 Aug 6, 11:09pm
               Collapse Never heard of the scene resoluion and of course we have not seen it. Eruonen 950 9 Aug 6, 11:29pm
                   Collapse I'm not sure what that means, sorry. Spriggan 496 8 Aug 7, 8:04am
                       Collapse ? Eruonen 343 7 Aug 7, 6:15pm
                           Collapse Well, it's in the TE... Spriggan 321 6 Aug 7, 6:25pm
                               Collapse How does Legolas know who Bolg and Azog are? AshNazg 299 3 Aug 7, 6:35pm
                                   Collapse I'm not sure what you mean. Spriggan 282 2 Aug 7, 6:39pm
                                       Collapse Balin says: "Azog, the giant Gundabad orc..." in AUJ AshNazg 277 1 Aug 7, 6:42pm
                                           I'm not sure that follows. Spriggan 528 0 Aug 7, 6:47pm
                               Collapse We need to see it or else it is a very choppy ending with him Eruonen 280 1 Aug 7, 6:39pm
                                   What are the unanswered questions? Spriggan 261 0 Aug 7, 6:44pm
       Collapse Too early to celebrate? Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 987 1 Aug 6, 11:18pm
           Just keep the cork in the bottle until there's an official statement // QuackingTroll 858 0 Aug 7, 12:24am
       Anyone Númenórean 981 0 Aug 6, 11:20pm
       Now I don't know what to believe... MechaGodzilla 810 0 Aug 7, 1:10am
       Well, let's hope this is right, because I'm just depressed // xxxyyy 725 0 Aug 7, 2:51am
       Collapse Bill Hunt confirms the 164 minute as running time of the EE Vila 313 14 Aug 7, 6:35pm
           Collapse Mmm Shagrat 295 2 Aug 7, 6:37pm
               Collapse . SafeUnderHill 276 1 Aug 7, 6:41pm
                   He didn't suggest it was speculation Shagrat 545 0 Aug 7, 6:45pm
           Collapse 164 minutes Otaku-sempai 524 6 Aug 7, 6:50pm
               Collapse Well.. bilbo1997 485 5 Aug 7, 7:00pm
                   . SafeUnderHill 463 0 Aug 7, 7:06pm
                   Collapse Don't forget! Otaku-sempai 453 2 Aug 7, 7:07pm
                       Collapse Will there be? Mooseboy018 447 1 Aug 7, 7:08pm
                           That's what is being reported. Otaku-sempai 436 0 Aug 7, 7:09pm
                   Honestly.... dormouse 399 0 Aug 7, 7:25pm
           So, 20 minutes it is, and that ain't all that bad MechaGodzilla 491 0 Aug 7, 6:59pm
           Collapse So... what did I say? Olorin2607 374 2 Aug 7, 7:38pm
               Collapse So many conspiracy theories... QuackingTroll 343 1 Aug 7, 7:57pm
                   well.. droidsocket 276 0 Aug 7, 8:36pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 1001 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.