Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 1056 (374102 posts in 15840 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 1056 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Thorin's map ghost_matt 595 3 Feb 22, 9:51pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Yes Otaku-sempai 561 2 Feb 22, 11:38pm
           Collapse That explains a lot Smaug the iron 450 1 Feb 23, 5:53pm
               Thrain I Otaku-sempai 445 0 Feb 23, 6:16pm

  Collapse On the topic of suspense, throughout the entire trilogy... Gandalf the Green 910 11 Feb 22, 6:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by squiggle)
       good and bad balbo biggins 847 0 Feb 22, 7:40pm
       Suspense No One in Particular 844 0 Feb 22, 7:49pm
       Collapse Full of suspense! Darkstone 825 1 Feb 22, 8:24pm
           Good one! // dormouse 679 0 Feb 23, 8:44am
       Collapse I enjoyed the movies a great deal, but Kilidoescartwheels 824 2 Feb 22, 8:30pm
           Collapse I agree... Bladerunner 766 1 Feb 22, 11:59pm
               "Children of Men" has its - small - flaws TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 758 0 Feb 23, 12:36am
       Collapse It's a hard one to answer.... dormouse 689 1 Feb 23, 8:54am
           I agree Noria 656 0 Feb 23, 12:59pm
       Bilbo searching for the Arkenstone ProudFeet 524 0 Feb 24, 12:38pm
       It's more an immersive dramatic experience for me squiggle 449 0 Feb 25, 11:08am

  Collapse No More Tolkien films because of failure of Hobbit? HOBBITFAN13 1571 54 Feb 22, 1:23pm Jump to last post in thread (by Dame Ioreth)
       Collapse What? Smaug the iron 1443 8 Feb 22, 1:42pm
           Collapse - Gandalf the Green 1416 1 Feb 22, 2:24pm
               i know seriously wizzardly 1146 0 Feb 23, 12:01am
           Ditto - what????? Avandel 1382 0 Feb 22, 3:03pm
           Collapse Perfectly said Smaug the iron Nieriel 357 4 Feb 25, 2:21am
               ROTFLMAO Noria 323 0 Feb 25, 1:45pm
               Thanks for the laugh, Nieriel! dormouse 326 0 Feb 25, 1:54pm
               YYYY Gandalf the Green 303 0 Feb 25, 6:23pm
               New meme Darkstone 285 0 Feb 25, 7:46pm
       Movie rights Noria 1430 0 Feb 22, 1:53pm
       Purporting failure in opening header TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1414 0 Feb 22, 2:24pm
       Collapse Point one: the Hobbit was not a failure. Now read on... dormouse 1423 12 Feb 22, 2:25pm
           Collapse "You're adding 2 and 2 and making 203 here." TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1412 11 Feb 22, 2:31pm
               Collapse That's definitely not adding 2 and 2. Gandalf the Green 1406 10 Feb 22, 2:38pm
                   Collapse It's a good thing Chris isn't a filmmaker! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1393 1 Feb 22, 2:46pm
                       The two shouldn't be carbon copies... Gandalf the Green 1386 0 Feb 22, 2:52pm
                   Collapse So, are you psychic? dormouse 1359 7 Feb 22, 3:46pm
                       Collapse - Gandalf the Green 1342 6 Feb 22, 3:59pm
                           Collapse Fact versus fiction Noria 1319 5 Feb 22, 4:24pm
                               Collapse I'm not saying he said anything according to fact... Gandalf the Green 1262 4 Feb 22, 5:56pm
                                   Collapse I love watching these discussions... AshNazg 1123 3 Feb 23, 2:21am
                                       :) wizzardly 1106 0 Feb 23, 2:32am
                                       Well, I think TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1097 0 Feb 23, 3:22am
                                       Isn’t that what a true discussion debate/demands? Noria 999 0 Feb 23, 12:51pm
       I think you're forgetting... LSF 1340 0 Feb 22, 3:58pm
       Tolkien Estate Lindele 1299 0 Feb 22, 4:45pm
       Your premise is flawed... Otaku-sempai 1290 0 Feb 22, 4:59pm
       Collapse No more Tolkien films because of the success of The Hobbit? Darkstone 1271 1 Feb 22, 5:48pm
         Tom Bombadil's Holiday Special Dame Ioreth 168 0 Mar 1, 2:37pm
       Collapse No more Tolkien films because no more rights are available. RosieLass 947 4 Feb 23, 6:45pm
           Collapse Not entirely accurate Otaku-sempai 542 3 Feb 23, 6:52pm
               They could always do a television cooking show TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 535 0 Feb 23, 6:55pm
               Collapse I wasn't counting spinoffs. RosieLass 536 1 Feb 23, 6:58pm
                   Okay. Otaku-sempai 476 0 Feb 23, 9:29pm
       Collapse As far as I am aware the Tolkien Estate were againist cinematic adaptations even before the LOTR films were made... malickfan 547 5 Feb 23, 7:19pm
           Collapse Too bad...the screen adaptations never replace the books EomundDaughter 526 1 Feb 23, 7:35pm
               I agree with you...partially. malickfan 503 0 Feb 23, 7:54pm
           Collapse Um, Malickfan? Otaku-sempai 489 1 Feb 23, 9:26pm
               Ah yeah...the quotes thing was unitentional... malickfan 467 0 Feb 23, 10:19pm
           Thanks for that link! N.E. Brigand 463 0 Feb 23, 11:14pm
       Collapse Hmmm... Avnar 438 2 Feb 24, 3:45am
           Collapse Ha, yeah TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 433 1 Feb 24, 4:41am
               As TheOnlyOneAroundHereWithAnySense says, Noria 401 0 Feb 24, 1:58pm
       Collapse Err... Bumpypotato 252 10 Feb 26, 12:51am
           Collapse It's because of the rights over The Silmarillion, unfortunately. ange1e4e5 242 9 Feb 26, 1:43am
               Collapse 'The Silmarillion' isn't needed... Otaku-sempai 238 8 Feb 26, 1:57am
                   Collapse Do we know if any potential spin off films would legally have to have a basis in the books? malickfan 196 7 Feb 26, 9:13pm
                     Collapse Interesting idea EomundDaughter 194 1 Feb 26, 9:22pm
                           Ha...no...I doubt I have a creative bone in my body... malickfan 188 0 Feb 26, 9:34pm
                       Collapse Spinning off from the books (and films)... Otaku-sempai 189 3 Feb 26, 9:39pm
                           Collapse Hmm... malickfan 247 2 Feb 26, 9:46pm
                               Balin's trip to Moria, the War in the North, and, of course... Bofur01 236 0 Feb 26, 10:41pm
                               But, would any studio greenlight those? Otaku-sempai 221 0 Feb 27, 1:42am
                       Well Darkstone 249 0 Feb 26, 9:59pm

  Collapse How long these movies should've been... HOBBITFAN13 1226 87 Feb 19, 9:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Gandalf the Green)
       Collapse eh wizzardly 1131 78 Feb 19, 10:16pm
           Collapse No Smaug the iron 1125 2 Feb 19, 10:23pm
               nah wizzardly 1117 0 Feb 19, 10:34pm
               But it felt rushed & things were cut in the movie we got... AshNazg 331 0 Feb 20, 11:08pm
           Collapse Oh, really? Kilidoescartwheels 1090 74 Feb 20, 1:33am
               Collapse - LSF 1084 1 Feb 20, 1:41am
                   Parody script Kilidoescartwheels 1048 0 Feb 20, 4:13am
               Collapse yes really wizzardly 1080 71 Feb 20, 2:24am
                   Collapse Oh... Lindele 1044 70 Feb 20, 4:59am
                       My thoughts exactly, Lindele TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1035 0 Feb 20, 5:11am
                       Collapse it explains what exactly? wizzardly 948 68 Feb 20, 3:55pm
                           Collapse Yes, but Smaug the iron 940 8 Feb 20, 4:16pm
                               Collapse time wizzardly 927 7 Feb 20, 4:39pm
                                   Collapse Well Smaug the iron 920 6 Feb 20, 4:52pm
                                       Collapse But! Gandalf the Green 919 1 Feb 20, 4:59pm
                                           No Smaug the iron 909 0 Feb 20, 5:16pm
                                       Collapse that's the point wizzardly 913 3 Feb 20, 5:10pm
                                           Collapse Well Smaug the iron 904 2 Feb 20, 5:25pm
                                               similarities to LOTR LSF 901 0 Feb 20, 5:33pm
                                               Well wizzardly 898 0 Feb 20, 5:41pm
                           Collapse Yes, but... Otaku-sempai 374 58 Feb 20, 9:11pm
                               Collapse 2 1/2 hours sounds about right. ange1e4e5 370 57 Feb 20, 9:15pm
                                   In addition... Otaku-sempai 366 0 Feb 20, 9:23pm
                                   Exactly! wizzardly 352 0 Feb 20, 10:44pm
                                   Collapse "The Sorcerer's Stone" is a lifeless, creativity-starved slog TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 350 54 Feb 20, 10:47pm
                                       Collapse still wizzardly 344 47 Feb 20, 10:51pm
                                           Collapse Rotten Tomatoes is a terrible barometer for quality TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 302 46 Feb 21, 12:15am
                                               Collapse so wizzardly 293 45 Feb 21, 12:21am
                                                   Collapse Because... LSF 286 44 Feb 21, 12:34am
                                                       Collapse ok wizzardly 279 42 Feb 21, 12:42am
                                                           Collapse Well Smaug the iron 271 41 Feb 21, 12:54am
                                                               Collapse - wizzardly 266 38 Feb 21, 1:04am
                                                                   Collapse - Gandalf the Green 232 37 Feb 21, 9:59am
                                                                       Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 428 18 Feb 21, 2:40pm
                                                                           Collapse - wizzardly 417 17 Feb 21, 3:10pm
                                                                               Collapse I agree. Otaku-sempai 412 2 Feb 21, 3:20pm
  Collapse I too would have liked to hear the Ravens and Eagles Omnigeek 321 1 Feb 21, 7:19pm
       The Sil... Otaku-sempai 316 0 Feb 21, 7:30pm
                                                                               Collapse Well Smaug the iron 401 13 Feb 21, 3:55pm
  Collapse - wizzardly 389 12 Feb 21, 4:49pm
       Collapse He don't think it looks believable. Smaug the iron 386 11 Feb 21, 4:58pm
           Collapse yeah wizzardly 379 10 Feb 21, 5:10pm
               Collapse Opinions Smaug the iron 365 9 Feb 21, 5:31pm
                   Collapse - wizzardly 361 8 Feb 21, 5:35pm
                       What? Smaug the iron 350 0 Feb 21, 5:48pm
                       Collapse so... LSF 341 6 Feb 21, 6:08pm
                           Collapse - wizzardly 336 5 Feb 21, 6:35pm
                               Collapse So Smaug the iron 314 4 Feb 21, 7:38pm
                                   Collapse No wizzardly 307 3 Feb 21, 7:54pm
                                       Collapse But Smaug the iron 301 1 Feb 21, 8:02pm
                                           it a matter of degree wizzardly 297 0 Feb 21, 8:16pm
                                       A lot of us are lifelong fans Omnigeek 303 0 Feb 21, 8:04pm
                                                                       Collapse or... LSF 406 17 Feb 21, 3:53pm
                                                                           Collapse But it nullifies Bilbo's conversation with Smaug, and involvement in the story... AshNazg 278 16 Feb 21, 11:55pm
                                                                               yes i agree wizzardly 262 0 Feb 22, 1:52am
                                                                               Collapse That was a sly attempt TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 246 14 Feb 22, 4:57am
  Exclusive theonering.net sneak peek of my new CD, "Bilbo Rappins!" TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 233 0 Feb 22, 5:37am
  Collapse Excellent post, TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense Noria 407 5 Feb 22, 1:24pm
       Collapse Thank you, I appreciate it TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 394 4 Feb 22, 2:20pm
           Collapse Believe me, you're not the only one who feels this way! // dormouse 390 1 Feb 22, 2:27pm
               Well, at least I'm not alone lol TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 387 0 Feb 22, 2:35pm
           Collapse Making everyone agree that I'm corrrect... No One in Particular 372 1 Feb 22, 3:39pm
               I understand this TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 363 0 Feb 22, 3:52pm
  Collapse Mmmmm ... no, weak rebuttal Omnigeek 346 6 Feb 22, 5:07pm
       But Bilbo is still a part of Smaug's death Smaug the iron 336 0 Feb 22, 5:24pm
       Bilbo's Contributions Otaku-sempai 333 0 Feb 22, 5:32pm
       Collapse Weak rebuttal, hogwash and B.S. TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 313 3 Feb 22, 6:46pm
           Collapse The bird Gandalf the Green 310 2 Feb 22, 7:06pm
               Collapse That's all my post accomplished, eh? TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 301 1 Feb 22, 7:17pm
                   I'll leave it to the person you were directly replying to to respond to the rest, but Gandalf the Green 293 0 Feb 22, 7:35pm
                                                               Collapse Smaug the iron, I agree. Noria 216 1 Feb 21, 2:15pm
                                                                   Seconded TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 435 0 Feb 21, 2:27pm
                                                       What LSF said TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 278 0 Feb 21, 12:42am
                                       also wizzardly 341 0 Feb 20, 10:55pm
                                       No matter. Gandalf the Green 313 0 Feb 20, 11:48pm
                                       I get where you are coming from... malickfan 306 0 Feb 21, 12:03am
                                       Collapse Harry Potter is far better than The Hobbit... AshNazg 312 1 Feb 21, 12:10am
                                           Sure TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 301 0 Feb 21, 12:17am
                                       Also, what's a creativity-starved slog... Gandalf the Green 305 0 Feb 21, 12:20am
       Longer Smaug the iron 1123 0 Feb 19, 10:25pm
       - LSF 1082 0 Feb 20, 1:48am
     Collapse Hobbit films are never long enough... Avandel 1060 1 Feb 20, 3:06am
           Time length LSF 1027 0 Feb 20, 5:50am
       Collapse More or less Gandalf the Green 941 2 Feb 20, 4:03pm
           Collapse I think three 90min movies... AshNazg 323 1 Feb 20, 11:26pm
               Not a bad idea :) wizzardly 317 0 Feb 20, 11:33pm
       I wouldn't necessarily say the films needed to be any shorter or longer at the time of release... malickfan 318 0 Feb 20, 11:31pm

  Collapse That Smaug shot at the end of DoS that stands out Bofur01 1011 17 Feb 19, 12:07am Jump to last post in thread (by LSF)
       Collapse I guess they missed it when converting from 48fps? // AshNazg 974 7 Feb 19, 12:15am
           Collapse The motion blur recorded in the image should be the same Bofur01 954 6 Feb 19, 2:26am
               Collapse There's less motion blur in 48fps... AshNazg 619 5 Feb 20, 11:39pm
                   Collapse They don't add in motion blur for the 24fps version, adding motion blur is very, very difficult Bofur01 576 4 Feb 21, 10:40am
                       Collapse no balbo biggins 511 3 Feb 22, 1:32am
                           Collapse For CG shots yes, but real shots, no... Bofur01 486 2 Feb 22, 9:06am
                               Collapse yes balbo biggins 476 1 Feb 22, 1:30pm
                                   hm... LSF 456 0 Feb 22, 4:40pm
       The movie... HOBBITFAN13 974 0 Feb 19, 12:20am
       Yes Smaug the iron 907 0 Feb 19, 6:36am
       Collapse *Puzzled* Avandel 820 2 Feb 19, 4:18pm
           Collapse Here Smaug the iron 807 1 Feb 19, 5:02pm
               Hmmm Kilidoescartwheels 783 0 Feb 19, 7:27pm
       Saw DOS in IMAX 3D HOBBITFAN13 740 0 Feb 19, 11:40pm
       Collapse hmmm balbo biggins 733 1 Feb 20, 12:14am
           erm wizzardly 729 0 Feb 20, 12:34am
       Ergh Gandalf the Green 615 0 Feb 20, 11:43pm

  Collapse "What Comes First? The Hobbit or the Rings?" KRRouse 1185 42 Feb 18, 1:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       ... HOBBITFAN13 1091 0 Feb 18, 2:00pm
       Hobbit First!!! Lindele 1081 0 Feb 18, 2:44pm
       Hobbit first LSF 1059 0 Feb 18, 3:36pm
       Hmm... I say... Gandalf the Green 1034 0 Feb 18, 4:41pm
       Collapse FOTR Darkstone 1024 2 Feb 18, 5:44pm
           Collapse As I've said elsewhere TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 971 1 Feb 18, 9:22pm
               Also TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 964 0 Feb 18, 9:31pm
       The Hobbit Nieriel 960 0 Feb 18, 9:35pm
       Collapse I'm having a sense of deja vu... (oh, and the answer is 'Rings', of course) Aragorn the Elfstone 953 4 Feb 18, 10:16pm
           Collapse For me, "Prometheus comes last" in other ways than chronology, too. // N.E. Brigand 934 3 Feb 18, 10:33pm
               This is true TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 925 0 Feb 18, 11:06pm
               Collapse LOL, well... Aragorn the Elfstone 922 1 Feb 18, 11:25pm
                   Actually TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 907 0 Feb 18, 11:42pm
       Haven't aged a day AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 871 0 Feb 19, 3:47am
       Collapse As with the Star Wars Prequels... Legolas_Shoehorn 817 26 Feb 19, 10:00am
           Collapse Time is going to be very kind to these prequels... TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 805 24 Feb 19, 11:34am
               Collapse Nah Gandalf the Green 715 23 Feb 20, 8:35am
                   Collapse We shall see TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 712 22 Feb 20, 8:47am
                       Collapse , Gandalf the Green 702 21 Feb 20, 9:31am
                           Collapse Everyone has a right to their opinion, art is largely subjective and yada yada yada obligatory set-up to reach the point TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 683 20 Feb 20, 11:58am
                               Collapse , Gandalf the Green 662 19 Feb 20, 3:26pm
                                   Collapse No, you were about right Omnigeek 618 3 Feb 20, 11:11pm
                                       Collapse Yes. Gandalf the Green 446 2 Feb 20, 11:41pm
                                           Collapse That's ludicrous TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 432 1 Feb 21, 12:05am
                                               To a lesser extent Gandalf the Green 423 0 Feb 21, 12:15am
                                   Collapse I will definitely agree that "TH" will forever be lesser than "LOTR" TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 435 14 Feb 20, 11:52pm
                                       Collapse The whimsical tone existed in AUJ. But did it after that? Gandalf the Green 424 12 Feb 21, 12:12am
                                           Well Smaug the iron 421 0 Feb 21, 12:23am
                                           Collapse Even the scenes you mentioned fit the bill of whimsical and more child-like TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 415 10 Feb 21, 12:38am
                                               Collapse - Gandalf the Green 397 9 Feb 21, 10:05am
                                                   Collapse Yes, I do TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 391 8 Feb 21, 12:08pm
                                                       Collapse [Wrong, there are plenty of other things] Gandalf the Green 386 7 Feb 21, 12:52pm
                                                           Yes but Smaug the iron 381 0 Feb 21, 1:02pm
                                                           Collapse Screenshots TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 373 5 Feb 21, 2:24pm
                                                               Collapse - Gandalf the Green 358 4 Feb 21, 6:26pm
                                                                   Collapse I can't see it TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 336 1 Feb 21, 11:33pm
                                                                       Yes Gandalf the Green 294 0 Feb 22, 6:14pm
                                                                   BOFA vs BoPF Noria 316 0 Feb 22, 1:36pm
                                                                   They tried to make it different dormouse 269 0 Feb 22, 11:51pm
                                       TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense nails it Noria 377 0 Feb 21, 1:38pm
           Agree completely HOBBITFAN13 749 0 Feb 19, 10:00pm
       I would personally always recommend watching in Release order// malickfan 610 0 Feb 20, 11:38pm

  Collapse The Dol Guldor subplot Hamfast Gamgee 1006 12 Feb 16, 5:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse ... StingingFly 923 10 Feb 16, 8:32pm
           Collapse - LSF 921 8 Feb 16, 8:36pm
               Collapse ... StingingFly 895 7 Feb 16, 9:17pm
                   Collapse Because Saruman was closer? Kilidoescartwheels 889 3 Feb 16, 9:27pm
                       I would have liked to have seen some of those "devices" Eruonen 860 0 Feb 16, 11:05pm
                       Collapse Actually Lorien is closer to the Shire than Isengard is MyWeeLadGimli 660 1 Feb 18, 4:37am
                           Mind-to-mind Otaku-sempai 638 0 Feb 18, 7:28am
                   - LSF 885 0 Feb 16, 9:30pm
                   Collapse Well Smaug the iron 883 1 Feb 16, 9:44pm
                       Nuclear Galadriel Ringtir 859 0 Feb 16, 11:05pm
           After this she is weak. Smaug the iron 908 0 Feb 16, 8:59pm
       Galadriel has an interesting parallel to Gandalf in a way squiggle 681 0 Feb 18, 3:19am

  Collapse Why did the Hobbit HAVE to have a similar tone as LOTR? MyWeeLadGimli 1297 51 Feb 16, 4:15am Jump to last post in thread (by TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense)
       Collapse - LSF 1181 3 Feb 16, 4:22am
           Collapse Audience expectation doesn't mean they won't like it MyWeeLadGimli 1170 2 Feb 16, 4:34am
               not saying LSF 1168 0 Feb 16, 4:35am
               When I read The Hobbit after LotR I was very disappointed. Noria 1081 0 Feb 16, 1:27pm
       a very good question wizzardly 1178 0 Feb 16, 4:23am
       Collapse Audience inerest and expectations... AshNazg 1168 29 Feb 16, 4:52am
           Collapse Also, it seems to be the wrong parts of LotR that crosses over... AshNazg 1161 28 Feb 16, 5:31am
               Yes, indeed Glorfindela 1026 0 Feb 16, 4:56pm
               Collapse How can you say that? Kilidoescartwheels 926 14 Feb 16, 9:24pm
                   Collapse , Gandalf the Green 834 13 Feb 17, 7:21am
                       Collapse Well I don't see that, either Kilidoescartwheels 764 12 Feb 17, 7:56pm
                           Collapse Because... Gandalf the Green 553 11 Feb 17, 10:56pm
                               Collapse Because? Kilidoescartwheels 528 10 Feb 18, 2:12am
                                   Collapse I think "LotR" is a better film than "The Hobbit" TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 519 9 Feb 18, 3:30am
                                       Collapse I agree with TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense and Kilidoescartwheels Noria 484 8 Feb 18, 1:58pm
                                           Collapse And, and maybe that's just me, but... Gandalf the Green 475 7 Feb 18, 4:52pm
                                               Collapse i agree wizzardly 390 6 Feb 19, 7:22pm
                                                   Collapse 'Faithful' is not a prerequisite for 'good' TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 375 2 Feb 19, 9:22pm
                                                       Collapse yes wizzardly 363 1 Feb 19, 10:11pm
                                                           Well, obviously TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 355 0 Feb 19, 10:41pm
                                                   Collapse I think it is. Smaug the iron 347 1 Feb 19, 10:59pm
                                                       yes wizzardly 338 0 Feb 19, 11:41pm
                                                   wizzardly, I first read The Hobbit almost fifty years ago Noria 291 0 Feb 20, 1:56pm
               Collapse ... Anubis 463 11 Feb 18, 6:16pm
                   You can't hear me TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 437 0 Feb 18, 9:18pm
                   Collapse ........ Gandalf the Green 323 9 Feb 20, 8:31am
                       Collapse Location Smaug the iron 319 1 Feb 20, 8:56am
                           obviously... LSF 314 0 Feb 20, 9:12am
                       Collapse ... Anubis 304 2 Feb 20, 11:50am
                           Want to add one more to your #1 TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 300 0 Feb 20, 12:22pm
                           the Hobbit book, which seems like the typical Dungeons & Dragons adventure KW 271 0 Feb 20, 3:46pm
                       Collapse OK Gandalf the Green, now I get you. Noria 288 3 Feb 20, 2:15pm
                           Collapse Well.. Gandalf the Green 283 2 Feb 20, 3:03pm
                               Maybe not so much a matter of "realism" KW 270 0 Feb 20, 4:01pm
                               It’s sad that the balance didn’t satisfy you Noria 224 0 Feb 21, 1:18pm
       Collapse Because it's the way Peter Jackson wanted it to be... dormouse 1125 5 Feb 16, 8:48am
           Collapse If he wants to that's fine MyWeeLadGimli 994 4 Feb 16, 6:06pm
               Because of what people said about AUJ. Smaug the iron 986 0 Feb 16, 6:26pm
               I'd say it depends on the audience.... dormouse 974 0 Feb 16, 6:47pm
               comparisons LSF 968 0 Feb 16, 7:03pm
               Well… Glorfindela 885 0 Feb 17, 12:33am
       I Find each film to have a slightly different tone to one another myself squiggle 1105 0 Feb 16, 11:12am
       Peter Jackson made an artistic choice. Noria 1079 0 Feb 16, 1:31pm
       so-called "audience expectations" Gianna 1073 0 Feb 16, 1:58pm
       Collapse PJ HOBBITFAN13 1016 1 Feb 16, 5:17pm
           I wish they'd done TH first, too, for the same reasons. // Gianna 997 0 Feb 16, 6:00pm
       So it'd get made? Darkstone 938 0 Feb 16, 9:01pm
       Well I don't think it started that way Kilidoescartwheels 928 0 Feb 16, 9:16pm
       As mentioned above, there are many valid and important reasons for Eruonen 260 0 Feb 20, 5:09pm
       Collapse Whimsical it is and whimsical it is not lionoferebor 183 1 Feb 27, 2:28am
           Well said! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 175 0 Feb 27, 3:11am

  Collapse Hobbit's Video Game Effects HOBBITFAN13 1628 117 Feb 16, 2:25am Jump to last post in thread (by KW)
       Collapse Disagree entirely TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1462 5 Feb 16, 2:40am
           Collapse Agree with TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense completely // Nieriel 1438 4 Feb 16, 3:52am
               Thank you TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1412 0 Feb 16, 6:18am
               Collapse I have to disagree with Nieriel in his agree with TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense when he is disagreeding... Ringtir 1386 2 Feb 16, 10:06am
                   Collapse And about DoS and BOFA Ringtir 1378 1 Feb 16, 10:36am
                       The bats Smaug the iron 1371 0 Feb 16, 11:29am
       3D Otaku-sempai 1454 0 Feb 16, 2:47am
       i agree wizzardly 1448 0 Feb 16, 2:58am
       Collapse no for me LSF 1439 6 Feb 16, 4:05am
           Collapse Uncharted 4? AshNazg 1319 5 Feb 16, 4:39pm
               Collapse There was at least one scene where it did seem like a video game ange1e4e5 1317 4 Feb 16, 4:44pm
                   camera balbo biggins 1304 0 Feb 16, 5:00pm
                   Collapse Lego The Hobbit AshNazg 1312 2 Feb 16, 5:02pm
                       ? Smaug the iron 1297 0 Feb 16, 5:19pm
                       yeah wizzardly 1234 0 Feb 17, 1:18am
       The CGI in the hobbit is great. Smaug the iron 1412 0 Feb 16, 6:32am
       yep balbo biggins 1313 0 Feb 16, 4:42pm
       Collapse Funnily enough.... dormouse 1201 8 Feb 17, 9:19am
           Funnily enough ... Voronwë_the_Faithful 1157 0 Feb 17, 3:44pm
           gamer here LSF 1156 0 Feb 17, 3:59pm
           Collapse Well put TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1138 1 Feb 17, 5:28pm
               Ya think? Noria 1101 0 Feb 17, 9:00pm
           Collapse Spoiled redgiraffe 239 3 Feb 24, 3:51am
               Collapse Fair enough.... dormouse 514 2 Feb 24, 8:54am
                   Agree word-for-word TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 508 0 Feb 24, 9:33am
                   For sure redgiraffe 363 0 Feb 25, 7:55am
       Collapse Hmmm... Avnar 1063 83 Feb 18, 2:08am
           That is obviously incorrect TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1055 0 Feb 18, 3:22am
           Sheep? ange1e4e5 541 0 Feb 18, 3:28am
           Collapse Avnar, obviously you have not forgotten these films. And Baaa... Noria 522 75 Feb 18, 2:16pm
               Collapse I'm not sure which statistics are accurate. Gandalf the Green 411 74 Feb 21, 12:01am
                   Collapse Yeah no, that's incorrect TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 414 68 Feb 21, 12:08am
                       Collapse Incorrect? Gandalf the Green 402 67 Feb 21, 12:26am
                           Collapse I'm not sure what that has to do with anything TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 399 66 Feb 21, 12:41am
                               Collapse - Gandalf the Green 313 65 Feb 22, 10:14am
                                   Collapse Correct Avnar 311 64 Feb 22, 11:19am
                                       Collapse - Gandalf the Green 299 5 Feb 22, 12:11pm
                                           Collapse In your opinion. Noria 286 4 Feb 22, 1:54pm
                                               Collapse yadda yadda opinions yadda yadda subjective Gandalf the Green 270 3 Feb 22, 2:24pm
                                                   Collapse Yeah, that's an opinion there, Gandy TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 266 2 Feb 22, 2:25pm
                                                       Collapse - Gandalf the Green 261 1 Feb 22, 2:34pm
                                                           The entire post was an opinion TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 261 0 Feb 22, 2:41pm
                                       Collapse Facts vs opinion Noria 226 2 Feb 22, 4:52pm
                                           Collapse okiflops Gandalf the Green 400 1 Feb 22, 6:10pm
                                               LOL TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 393 0 Feb 22, 6:47pm
                                       Collapse um... LSF 412 53 Feb 22, 5:08pm
                                           Collapse he's right though wizzardly 370 52 Feb 23, 12:13am
                                               Collapse I saw "Goodfellas" in the $7 bin at Walmart about a month ago TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 359 51 Feb 23, 12:33am
                                                   Collapse - wizzardly 355 4 Feb 23, 12:37am
                                                       Collapse Fun TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 349 3 Feb 23, 12:49am
                                                           Collapse yes wizzardly 341 2 Feb 23, 12:54am
                                                               Collapse I know TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 333 1 Feb 23, 1:05am
                                                                   Middle-earth has ice cream, right? TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 342 0 Feb 23, 1:13am
                                                   Collapse The Hobbit dvds... Avnar 320 45 Feb 23, 2:56am
                                                       Um, all three theatrical "LotR"s ARE in the $5 DVD bin at Walmart... TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 310 0 Feb 23, 3:31am
                                                       Collapse -- wizzardly 317 16 Feb 23, 3:32am
                                                           Collapse It's surely because TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 305 2 Feb 23, 3:43am
                                                               Collapse oscars LSF 292 1 Feb 23, 3:52am
                                                                   A TON finds its basis in politics TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 283 0 Feb 23, 4:32am
                                                           Collapse Academy Awards. Noria 351 12 Feb 23, 3:55pm
                                                               Well put, and I mostly agree TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 327 0 Feb 23, 5:45pm
                                                               Collapse I agree with Noria KW 326 10 Feb 23, 7:33pm
                                                                   Collapse However, I agree with Noria Avandel 300 3 Feb 23, 10:15pm
                                                                       Collapse You did not address my objection. KW 467 2 Feb 24, 4:41pm
                                                                           Collapse Of course there was no conspiracy. Noria 332 1 Feb 25, 2:49pm
                                                                               No "of course" about it. KW 292 0 Feb 25, 9:34pm
                                                                   Collapse You are right that I was speaking in generalities Noria 496 5 Feb 24, 2:32pm
                                                                       Collapse Sorry but that is a copout... Avnar 437 4 Feb 24, 9:44pm
                                                                           Collapse yeah wizzardly 422 2 Feb 24, 11:44pm
                                                                               Collapse Don't get me wrong... Avnar 402 1 Feb 25, 12:43am
  yeah wizzardly 391 0 Feb 25, 1:03am
                                                                           There seems to be a local conspiracy, at least TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 407 0 Feb 25, 12:42am
                                                       Collapse I bought 'Gladiator' and 'The Princess Bride' dormouse 260 26 Feb 23, 9:00am
                                                           Collapse No... Avnar 243 25 Feb 23, 11:03am
                                                               Collapse Well Smaug the iron 225 21 Feb 23, 12:42pm
                                                                   Collapse Nudity Otaku-sempai 222 20 Feb 23, 12:52pm
                                                                       Collapse So what? Smaug the iron 371 19 Feb 23, 12:58pm
                                                                           Collapse Cartoonishness Otaku-sempai 368 18 Feb 23, 1:00pm
                                                                               Collapse -- wizzardly 260 17 Feb 24, 3:19am
  Collapse Nudity control? TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 256 14 Feb 24, 3:26am
       Collapse -- wizzardly 253 13 Feb 24, 3:29am
           Collapse Or... Avnar 250 12 Feb 24, 3:32am
               Collapse yeah maybe you're right wizzardly 243 3 Feb 24, 3:35am
                   Collapse Probably because... Avnar 237 2 Feb 24, 3:43am
                       Collapse yeah wizzardly 235 1 Feb 24, 3:51am
                           If you watch the appendices you would know Smaug the iron 511 0 Feb 24, 9:06am
               Collapse Oh, noes! Otaku-sempai 225 7 Feb 24, 4:26am
                   Collapse Nudity in Middle Earth No One in Particular 220 1 Feb 24, 4:36am
                       Indeedy-doo! Otaku-sempai 210 0 Feb 24, 4:47am
                   Collapse But don't you see, Otaku-sempai? TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 216 4 Feb 24, 4:37am
                       Collapse Oh? Otaku-sempai 542 3 Feb 24, 4:49am
                           Collapse I'm not sure how he feels TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 542 2 Feb 24, 4:59am
                               Collapse cgi naked LSF 535 1 Feb 24, 5:20am
                                   re: CGI naked Noria 485 0 Feb 24, 2:48pm
  Collapse Wrong movie Otaku-sempai 227 1 Feb 24, 4:12am
       oh wizzardly 225 0 Feb 24, 4:16am
                                                               This reminds me of 2001 all over again. Noria 368 0 Feb 23, 1:32pm
                                                               Collapse IMO you are forgetting... Avandel 304 1 Feb 23, 9:48pm
                                                                   changing times LSF 286 0 Feb 23, 10:56pm
                                       No, no and thrice no.... dormouse 378 0 Feb 23, 12:01am
                   Collapse anecdotal evidence LSF 406 4 Feb 21, 12:18am
                       Collapse Well, Gandalf the Green 402 3 Feb 21, 12:23am
                           Collapse Anecdotal evidence is worthless, except for getting validation for one’s own opinions. Noria 360 2 Feb 21, 10:13pm
                               Collapse I like to source all my knowledge from Google... AshNazg 350 1 Feb 21, 11:26pm
                                   oh come on wizzardly 339 0 Feb 22, 2:11am
           yup wizzardly 484 0 Feb 18, 11:54pm
           Make that 13 Loresilme 427 0 Feb 20, 7:45pm
           Collapse Sheep? Jeffrodo 271 2 Feb 24, 2:49am
               I still think being a sheep on this issue TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 266 0 Feb 24, 3:04am
               I know you meant those "Baas" to sound like a sheep... AshNazg 387 0 Feb 25, 2:05am
       The "smaller" CGI moments CathrineB 455 0 Feb 19, 10:40am
       Collapse What games are you playing Bumpypotato 305 4 Feb 22, 11:34am
           A bit harsh Gandalf the Green 296 0 Feb 22, 11:58am
           - LSF 280 0 Feb 23, 4:23am
           Collapse Watch this... AshNazg 281 1 Feb 23, 4:33am
               No it is not equally as jarring TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 278 0 Feb 23, 4:38am
       Not that bad QuiteALittleFellow 262 0 Feb 23, 5:54am

Collapse Hobbit ee Trilogy Wrap squiggle 715 3 Feb 15, 2:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by nymmerod)
       Collapse Honest opinion HOBBITFAN13 554 1 Feb 16, 2:23am
           Thanks for taking time to post your take squiggle 531 0 Feb 16, 4:09am
       I think... nymmerod 366 0 Feb 18, 4:52pm

Collapse Valentine's Day AUJ screen cap *image lard* - because it's all about LUV - part 3 Avandel 900 21 Feb 14, 8:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
     Collapse FINALE - OMG the LOVE! Avandel 829 8 Feb 14, 8:29pm
           Collapse Happy Valentine's! Ilmatar 801 7 Feb 14, 11:28pm
             Collapse GORGEOUS POST IMO - thank you! Avandel 778 6 Feb 15, 1:21am
                 Collapse Thank you Ilmatar 708 5 Feb 15, 4:03pm
                     Collapse Day late is OK 'coz U.S. has a HOLIDAY today Avandel 679 4 Feb 15, 6:27pm
                           Collapse Such a HAPPY Day!!! Kilidoescartwheels 590 3 Feb 16, 8:59pm
                             Collapse I'm glad (: and isn't that dwarf bust a great sculpt? *luv* Avandel 564 2 Feb 17, 2:18am
                                   Collapse Bwahaha Riven Delve 511 1 Feb 17, 7:44pm
                                     That poem is a CLASSIC Avandel 489 0 Feb 18, 2:05am
       Collapse Thanks for these, all three posts..... dormouse 794 1 Feb 14, 11:55pm
         *Smiles* I hadn't seen AUJ for a while.... Avandel 780 0 Feb 15, 1:01am
       Collapse Lovely images Elarie 729 1 Feb 15, 11:47am
           You are most welcome! Avandel 690 0 Feb 15, 6:01pm
       Collapse Thanks so much, Avandel! Riven Delve 616 3 Feb 16, 12:08pm
         Collapse *Bows deeply* and Avandel 605 2 Feb 16, 5:10pm
               Collapse I haven't watched the Hobbit movies in months... Queen of Erebor 575 1 Feb 16, 11:47pm
                   Glad you got your CHOCOLATE! (: Avandel 553 0 Feb 17, 2:29am
     Collapse Hello, darling dwarf girls! Nieriel 543 1 Feb 17, 4:01am
           Too true, much can be said about WHITE chocolate Avandel 532 0 Feb 17, 5:02am
       Collapse AWAWEAWE!!!! TaliaEmerald 412 1 Feb 21, 9:52pm
           Happy you liked the threads and Avandel 401 0 Feb 22, 2:42pm

Collapse When Thorin arrived... Gandalf the Green 794 38 Feb 14, 7:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by wizzardly)
       Collapse I love... LSF 748 1 Feb 14, 7:58pm
           Haha! Gandalf the Green 728 0 Feb 14, 8:36pm
       Collapse It was not odd. Smaug the iron 749 19 Feb 14, 7:59pm
           Collapse Oh! Gandalf the Green 732 18 Feb 14, 8:35pm
               Collapse by that point... LSF 725 9 Feb 14, 8:40pm
                   Collapse True enough Avandel 719 1 Feb 14, 8:45pm
                       Well Gandalf the Green 709 0 Feb 14, 9:01pm
                   Collapse No Gandalf the Green 710 6 Feb 14, 8:58pm
                       Collapse THey all might not LSF 707 5 Feb 14, 9:06pm
                           Collapse ! Gandalf the Green 691 4 Feb 14, 9:49pm
                               Collapse What? Smaug the iron 681 3 Feb 14, 10:08pm
                                   Collapse Herring a nook? Otaku-sempai 640 2 Feb 14, 11:50pm
                                       Collapse Obs, sorry. Smaug the iron 430 1 Feb 15, 4:42am
                                           Not a problem... Otaku-sempai 426 0 Feb 15, 4:45am
               Collapse Not the same thing. Smaug the iron 708 7 Feb 14, 9:05pm
                   Collapse The difference Gandalf the Green 689 6 Feb 14, 9:57pm
                       Collapse The point is. Smaug the iron 668 4 Feb 14, 10:22pm
                           Collapse An Gandalf the Green 648 3 Feb 14, 11:18pm
                               Collapse Well, you might recall.... dormouse 637 1 Feb 14, 11:51pm
                                   - LSF 636 0 Feb 14, 11:55pm
                               disagree as Avandel 612 0 Feb 15, 12:49am
                       Not danger, but tension tonyg 633 0 Feb 15, 12:06am
       Because he's a KING, y'all Avandel 729 0 Feb 14, 8:33pm
       Collapse I think it was done with the audience in mind Elarie 676 1 Feb 14, 10:14pm
           Good point LSF 664 0 Feb 14, 10:25pm
       What I see is Nieriel 582 0 Feb 15, 4:32am
       Collapse This is a thing now? Hm. TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 421 1 Feb 15, 5:42am
           Just an observation Gandalf the Green 411 0 Feb 15, 7:59am
       Collapse I think you are overreacting and misinterpreting. Noria 408 8 Feb 15, 12:38pm
           Collapse I'm not overreacting. Gandalf the Green 403 7 Feb 15, 1:17pm
               Collapse Maybe it seems so to you because you don't like the films.... dormouse 405 6 Feb 15, 1:45pm
                 Collapse You know... Avandel 388 2 Feb 15, 6:42pm
                       Collapse Yes.... dormouse 376 1 Feb 15, 7:30pm
                         *grins* Avandel 331 0 Feb 16, 2:06am
                   Collapse No - it seems so to me because I can enjoy a film without automatically finding it good... Gandalf the Green 364 2 Feb 15, 8:19pm
                       Collapse Well, as you seem to place so little value on enjoyment.... dormouse 315 1 Feb 16, 8:42am
                           I’m not sure I think these movies are masterpieces Noria 302 0 Feb 16, 1:12pm
       - wizzardly 224 0 Feb 23, 1:25am

Collapse Valentine's Day AUJ screen cap *image lard* - because it's all about LUV - part 2B Avandel 437 5 Feb 14, 7:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by TaliaEmerald)
       Collapse Part 2B2 Avandel 414 4 Feb 14, 7:36pm
         Collapse Part 2B3 Avandel 406 3 Feb 14, 7:47pm
             Collapse leaving Rivendell.... Avandel 402 1 Feb 14, 7:54pm
                 and GOBLINS and GOLLUM Avandel 396 0 Feb 14, 8:09pm
             LOOOVE!! TaliaEmerald 252 0 Feb 21, 10:01pm

Collapse Valentine's Day AUJ screen cap *image lard* - because it's all about LUV - part 1 Avandel 436 4 Feb 14, 6:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by TaliaEmerald)
     Collapse Bag End part 2 Avandel 410 3 Feb 14, 6:57pm
           Collapse Bag End part 3 Avandel 407 1 Feb 14, 7:12pm
               Love and gold Riven Delve 299 0 Feb 16, 11:57am
           LOVE THIS!! TaliaEmerald 230 0 Feb 21, 9:57pm

Collapse Tolkien Estate's copyright limits GrimMorwen 709 10 Feb 14, 2:27pm Jump to last post in thread (by GrimMorwen)
       Collapse Well, I don't know about an official source for this... dormouse 672 1 Feb 14, 3:47pm
           Rights to Hobbit and more GrimMorwen 666 0 Feb 14, 3:58pm
       Collapse I'm glad you asked this question - geordie 652 1 Feb 14, 4:46pm
           Rights to Hobbit and more GrimMorwen 645 0 Feb 14, 4:52pm
       Collapse As Dormouse said... Silverlode 544 5 Feb 15, 5:03am
           Collapse Tolkien did not seel the movie rights to that man Zaentz - geordie 482 4 Feb 15, 6:55pm
               Collapse 1969 Voronwë_the_Faithful 468 1 Feb 15, 7:22pm
                   Thanks - geordie 457 0 Feb 15, 8:13pm
               Collapse Thanks Silverlode 421 1 Feb 16, 2:45am
                   Thag you very buch everybody GrimMorwen 394 0 Feb 16, 11:49am
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 1056 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.