Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 913 (328392 posts in 13685 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 913 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  "The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies" receives 2 Critics Choice nominations News from Bree 179 0 Mon, 10:18am Jump to last post in thread (by News from Bree)

  Collapse Reviews #15 NecromancerRising 1385 10 Mon, 6:59am Jump to last post in thread (by NecromancerRising)
       Collapse Thank you so much for following up on all this, and sharing it! // mae govannen 452 1 Mon, 7:14am
           My pleasure MG NecromancerRising 411 0 Mon, 8:46am
       Collapse I am puzzled... Bernhardina 446 2 Mon, 11:03am
           Collapse It does not add up after all the reviews I have read. mefansmum 427 1 Mon, 11:23am
               Let me remind all of you that approximately at this stage NecromancerRising 447 0 Mon, 11:54am
       Collapse A very positive review from Jonathan Lack NecromancerRising 296 4 Mon, 4:30pm
           From the "Village Voice"? (NYC's Arts magazine) Bombadil 240 0 Mon, 5:05pm
           Collapse A mixed to positive NecromancerRising 217 2 Mon, 5:55pm
               Collapse Dustin Putman's review was just added as fresh in RT. NecromancerRising 207 1 Mon, 6:13pm
                   Another mostly positive by Top Critic Kerry Lengel NecromancerRising 180 0 Mon, 7:51pm

  Collapse Spoilers Bain 723 4 Mon, 5:35am Jump to last post in thread (by tiamy)
       Haha even my 11 year old brother giggled at the reference... elvish.mafia 258 0 Mon, 7:56am
       Remember hearing that on set. Moahunter 215 0 Mon, 9:08am
     It's sweet and fun that even some Wellington places mae govannen 197 0 Mon, 9:25am
       True! tiamy 68 0 Mon, 3:47pm

  Collapse To those who have also seen the film: any guesses on the context for this deleted scene? thomasofrohan 1110 9 Mon, 5:13am Jump to last post in thread (by Aitieuriskon)
       Collapse Maybe Thorin... elvish.mafia 502 4 Mon, 7:58am
           Collapse I think it's part of the battle Carne 427 1 Mon, 9:41am
               Complicated Aitieuriskon 93 0 Mon, 7:40pm
           Collapse Certainly seems possible. moreorless 327 1 Mon, 11:13am
               Battle? (Spoilers) Mcoull 255 0 Mon, 1:21pm
       Collapse I can't see where it fits Milieuterrien 206 2 Mon, 2:20pm
           Collapse I think that.. Dcole4 97 1 Mon, 6:53pm
               Thorin, Kili, Fili and Dwalin had to go somewhere out of the battle Milieuterrien 104 0 Mon, 7:00pm
       Maybe this is something they tried.... dormouse 164 0 Mon, 4:13pm

  Collapse Thranduil's Strange portrayal in TBotFA Rheged 1538 38 Mon, 3:16am Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Me too lastnickleft 746 0 Mon, 3:26am
       Personally, I liked his characterisation... elvish.mafia 759 0 Mon, 3:51am
       Collapse Not seen the film yet, but from mae govannen 648 2 Mon, 5:55am
           Collapse necklace Me85 148 1 Mon, 8:32pm
               Oh, thank you for this info confirming mae govannen 64 0 Tue, 4:35am
       Collapse yes, character butchering ElendilTheShort 573 6 Mon, 8:06am
           no complaints on this NoelGallagher 549 0 Mon, 8:18am
           Collapse I don't think so: did you read my post above?...// mae govannen 517 4 Mon, 8:25am
               Collapse yes but i was replying to the op ElendilTheShort 502 3 Mon, 8:51am
                   Collapse I haven't seen the film yet, sorry if I am still unaware mae govannen 453 2 Mon, 9:33am
                       Collapse i hope you enjoy it ElendilTheShort 420 1 Mon, 10:41am
                           From what many others are saying, mae govannen 55 0 Tue, 4:46am
       Collapse Hmmm dubulous 527 4 Mon, 8:38am
           Collapse I wonder whether we might see more about the Jewels moreorless 413 3 Mon, 11:22am
               Collapse Grief (spoilers) Mcoull 331 1 Mon, 2:08pm
                   There should have been a scene of Bilbo with Bofur... Eleniel 297 0 Mon, 2:12pm
               I am totally with you on this, mae govannen 56 0 Tue, 5:12am
       Collapse No, I wasn't, though.... dormouse 530 4 Mon, 8:49am
           Collapse Thranduil enigmatic and nuanced Michelle Johnston 405 3 Mon, 12:11pm
               Collapse And i am really looking forward to your review NecromancerRising 350 1 Mon, 12:19pm
                   Review On My Blog Michelle Johnston 281 0 Mon, 2:13pm
               SPOILERS the last hour was hard to see in some respects ElendilTheShort 234 0 Mon, 5:26pm
       3 possible EE scenes which may change impressions of Thranduil Shagrat 488 0 Mon, 11:18am
       Collapse Dwarves are insulting to elves... Milieuterrien 372 7 Mon, 1:07pm
           Collapse i think your post shows how far this is from tolkien if people ElendilTheShort 225 6 Mon, 5:18pm
               Collapse Odd generalization dubulous 185 5 Mon, 6:30pm
                   Collapse it was not an odd conclusion, it was a response to another post ElendilTheShort 127 2 Mon, 8:47pm
                       Collapse Yes, and I was refering to both posts // dubulous 117 1 Mon, 9:06pm
                           superb ElendilTheShort 112 0 Mon, 9:31pm
                   Collapse .. For any reason... Milieuterrien 102 1 Mon, 9:59pm
                       subject marillaraina 69 0 Tue, 2:42am
       Collapse No - improvement over Tolkien's characterization. Arannir 337 1 Mon, 2:00pm
           Totally agree with you on this, mae govannen 67 0 Tue, 4:29am
       Nah CathrineB 244 0 Mon, 4:54pm
       Collapse I thought Mithfânion 108 1 Mon, 10:00pm
           Well, even the Bible is inevitably interpreted mae govannen 59 0 Tue, 5:28am
       Collapse The movie portrayal is more realistic. Plurmo 75 1 Tue, 5:07am
           But Thranduil does dread Sauron actually, mae govannen 71 0 Tue, 5:39am

Collapse Thread Locked Smaug interview by Steven Colbert!!! NateGate 255 1 Mon, 2:35am Jump to last post in thread (by entmaiden)
       Thread Locked I know the boards are moving fast, but entmaiden 132 0 Mon, 3:22am

  Collapse The Witch-King in Dol Guldur Scene (SPOILERS) lastnickleft 1135 10 Mon, 2:31am Jump to last post in thread (by Dame Ioreth)
       Collapse well deskp 627 8 Mon, 2:44am
           Collapse No? Iarhen 554 7 Mon, 3:09am
               Collapse right. deskp 551 2 Mon, 3:10am
                   Collapse Yes. lastnickleft 509 1 Mon, 3:27am
                       They are pretty much the same // painjoiker 400 0 Mon, 6:33am
               Collapse I don't think so.... dormouse 350 3 Mon, 8:53am
                   Collapse I've seen it twice and... Bernhardina 317 1 Mon, 11:05am
                       Yeah adt100 165 0 Mon, 4:04pm
                   I think that flash of light Dame Ioreth 65 0 Tue, 4:13am
       Seen the film Mithfânion 109 0 Mon, 10:01pm

  Moved: The Last Goodbye - Fan Reaction Mashup to the Music Video blakedale - - Sun, 11:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by blakedale)

  Collapse 2 Details I noticed in BOFA (huge spoilers) Mcoull 1294 9 Sun, 11:04pm Jump to last post in thread (by ElendilTheShort)
       Collapse The elves QuackingTroll 672 8 Sun, 11:07pm
           Collapse I noticed this too Mcoull 567 7 Sun, 11:18pm
               Collapse I think it's just elves and orcs... QuackingTroll 525 6 Sun, 11:25pm
                   Collapse Interesting Mcoull 497 2 Sun, 11:28pm
                       Collapse yup LoremIpsum 360 1 Mon, 1:13am
                           disagree substantially ElendilTheShort 273 0 Mon, 6:24am
                   Collapse only the Eldar that have dwelt in the blessed realm (Valinor) ElendilTheShort 430 2 Mon, 12:37am
                       Collapse I'm by no means a Tolkien expert Mcoull 142 1 Mon, 1:26pm
                           not just them ElendilTheShort 88 0 Mon, 5:11pm

  Collapse Question to anyone who has seen the film MorganTime2 617 15 Sun, 10:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mcoull)
       There are a few more scenes, two or three, if I remember correctly kiwifan 334 0 Sun, 10:58pm
       Collapse Hmmm - best guess Spriggan 308 8 Sun, 11:03pm
           Collapse Perhaps a bit more? Mcoull 254 6 Sun, 11:11pm
               Collapse It's hard to be precise. Spriggan 233 5 Sun, 11:20pm
                   Collapse Indeed, it is hard to be precise! (spoiler) Mcoull 231 4 Sun, 11:24pm
                       Collapse Well let's think - what are the lines at Gundabad? Spriggan 210 3 Sun, 11:33pm
                           Yeah that's about it! Mcoull 191 0 Sun, 11:39pm
                           Collapse Second army Aitieuriskon 177 1 Mon, 12:25am
                               That might be my memory Spriggan 78 0 Mon, 11:42am
           Much less than that in my opinion... (studiers/spoilers) Milieuterrien 76 0 Mon, 12:19pm
       I've just come back from seeing it. Orc Berserker 304 0 Sun, 11:06pm
       a lot Me85 270 0 Sun, 11:07pm
       Yes, his fight scenes are long at the last 1/4, but macfalk 274 0 Sun, 11:11pm
       Collapse Screentime Bernhardina 91 1 Mon, 11:08am
           EE (spoilers?) Mcoull 60 0 Mon, 1:35pm

  Collapse Azog (spoilers) Shagrat 1059 28 Sun, 9:51pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse Surely not. Spriggan 556 20 Sun, 10:08pm
           Collapse I don't think they'd change such a major event for the EE QuackingTroll 519 19 Sun, 10:17pm
               Collapse I agree BlackFox 467 18 Sun, 10:29pm
                   Collapse Haven't seen the film... ecthelionsbeard 417 16 Sun, 10:53pm
                       Collapse Azog takes... **SPOILERS** BlackFox 492 15 Sun, 10:56pm
                           Collapse Nice... ecthelionsbeard 395 14 Sun, 11:10pm
                               Collapse We can see... **MORE SPOILERS** BlackFox 437 13 Sun, 11:13pm
                                   Yes!!! ecthelionsbeard 374 0 Sun, 11:19pm
                                   Collapse That shot from below the ice. Mcoull 390 11 Sun, 11:21pm
                                       Collapse One shot I seem to recall macfalk 369 1 Sun, 11:29pm
                                           I noticed that today Roheryn 140 0 Mon, 11:19am
                                       Collapse In both LOTR and Hobbit.. ecthelionsbeard 365 8 Sun, 11:29pm
                                           Collapse True (Huge spoilers) Mcoull 388 7 Sun, 11:34pm
                                               Collapse Yep, that annoyed me as well... ***SPOILERS*** Eleniel 231 6 Mon, 7:39am
                                                   I didn't find it unrealistic LoremIpsum 203 0 Mon, 8:08am
                                                   Re:Thorin (spoilers) Mcoull 112 0 Mon, 1:32pm
                                                   Collapse For what it is worth... Arannir 78 3 Mon, 2:06pm
                                                       Collapse Did you have a stomach wound as well??? ;) Eleniel 69 2 Mon, 2:13pm
                                                           Collapse Touché ;) Arannir 70 1 Mon, 2:20pm
                                                               If I may Cirashala 31 0 Tue, 12:39am
                   Right. I noticed that on Sting, well done...// mae govannen 212 0 Mon, 7:11am
       No. There is no chance they will give him a completely different death scene in the EE. Crunchable Birdses 431 0 Sun, 10:50pm
       I thought it was great Orc Berserker 384 0 Sun, 11:18pm
       It is how it is mirkwoodwanderer 282 0 Mon, 2:27am
       Collapse Another idea Shagrat 201 3 Mon, 9:11am
           Collapse I actually thought that worked very well - Spriggan 166 2 Mon, 10:52am
               Collapse But I don't see any ambiguity Shagrat 151 1 Mon, 11:09am
                   It's interesting that you see it that starkly Spriggan 137 0 Mon, 11:50am

Collapse First Box Office Numbers! NecromancerRising 1295 4 Sun, 8:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Excellent! macfalk 566 3 Sun, 8:43pm
         The Juggernaut that THATthis ..is,is Bombadil 509 0 Sun, 9:07pm
           Collapse From Box Office Mojo NecromancerRising 489 1 Sun, 9:53pm
             HOWE will this DAY END..// Bombadil 293 0 Sun, 11:43pm

  Collapse So excited for tomorrow! Ham_Sammy 470 12 Sun, 7:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ham_Sammy)
       Collapse I'm green with envy Cirashala 211 2 Sun, 8:38pm
           Collapse Ham-Sam Sweetie! we will "Mind Melt" together! Bombadil 165 1 Sun, 9:15pm
               I'll be thinking of all of you too! Ham_Sammy 105 0 Sun, 11:21pm
       I'm with ya Elessar 149 0 Sun, 9:37pm
       Collapse To all the marathoners BlackFox 169 1 Sun, 9:47pm
           ALL True FREAKS/GEEKS..tis the Bombadil 112 0 Mon, 12:00am
       Collapse Gah! MihailOMalley 92 1 Mon, 12:32am
           Yes! Ham_Sammy 99 0 Mon, 12:54am
       Collapse I'm going to the marathon with my daughter Dame Ioreth 40 1 Mon, 1:19pm
           You guys have a great time!!! Ham_Sammy 24 0 Mon, 3:10pm
       Collapse I have a ticket, but can't go :( entmaiden 20 1 Mon, 3:43pm
           Awwwww Ham_Sammy 17 0 Mon, 4:08pm

  Collapse Just seen the movie *spoilers* Remus 1485 37 Sun, 7:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by Dame Ioreth)
       Collapse I'm on record multiple times about wanting more Beorn Kimtc 584 31 Sun, 8:40pm
           Collapse I wonder if ANYONE likes these decisions?? AshNazg 557 29 Sun, 9:32pm
               Collapse I'm inclined to agree (on WB) Shagrat 512 9 Sun, 9:38pm
                   Collapse In one interview Name 512 4 Sun, 9:46pm
                       I was just thinking the same thing Aitieuriskon 445 0 Sun, 10:03pm
                       Collapse THIS is interesting! (Spoilers) Mcoull 387 2 Sun, 11:43pm
                           Collapse I couldn't really connect the scene up to much. Spriggan 331 1 Sun, 11:56pm
                             I felt this way too. (Spoiler) Mcoull 311 0 Mon, 12:15am
                   Funny, I was talking about this with a friend today! Kimtc 428 0 Sun, 10:13pm
                   Collapse One concern for non tolkien fans Remus 316 1 Mon, 12:03am
                       Well it does at the start of AUJ. Spriggan 301 0 Mon, 12:09am
                   Almost? painjoiker 204 0 Mon, 6:57am
               I do not think... Arannir 439 0 Sun, 10:03pm
               Collapse The difficulty in gauging that is that 99.99% of people Spriggan 439 1 Sun, 10:13pm
                   Yes, I agree Dame Ioreth 14 0 Tue, 2:14pm
               The whole issue of... patrickk 201 0 Mon, 7:02am
               Collapse It didn't bother me at the time... Eleniel 195 6 Mon, 7:43am
                   That's true. Mooseboy018 183 0 Mon, 7:52am
                   Collapse Sixty years have elapsed in between, mae govannen 165 4 Mon, 8:40am
                       Collapse I guess one could invent the head canon... Eleniel 110 3 Mon, 10:46am
                           Collapse Yes, it would work for me too...// mae govannen 61 2 Mon, 2:51pm
                               Collapse Cool... Eleniel 42 1 Mon, 8:03pm
                                 Voila, exactly!!!! Great... mae govannen 23 0 Tue, 4:06am
               Collapse I certainly like the 'Strider' inclusion, mae govannen 168 6 Mon, 9:08am
                   Collapse Questions Remus 136 5 Mon, 9:48am
                       Could be a number of reasons dubulous 120 0 Mon, 10:18am
                       i guess legless ElendilTheShort 113 0 Mon, 10:44am
                       Collapse Your own answers didn't need to be ridiculing mae govannen 104 2 Mon, 11:17am
                           Collapse I remember now! Remus 96 1 Mon, 12:53pm
                               Good then!... About that, mae govannen 62 0 Mon, 3:12pm
               Yup, I do. Roheryn 104 0 Mon, 10:55am
           Disappointed Remus 523 0 Sun, 9:34pm
       Collapse Strider kind of worked for me... macfalk 458 2 Sun, 10:08pm
           Collapse subject marillaraina 242 1 Mon, 4:28am
               Good reminder of chronological facts... Thank you!...// mae govannen 130 0 Mon, 9:11am
       I really loved Peters final epic movie terrymerry 334 0 Mon, 12:11am
       i really liked dain ElendilTheShort 182 0 Mon, 8:19am

  Collapse So..ummmm...Galadriel's appearance... Crunchable Birdses 1533 40 Sun, 6:16pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mithfânion)
       Collapse Speechless Arandir 873 3 Sun, 6:22pm
           Collapse I've seen it twice so far and I, too, think it is extreme kiwifan 410 2 Sun, 10:30pm
               Answer to your question BlackFox 353 0 Sun, 10:33pm
               Yes she had the phial in her hand. Spriggan 344 0 Sun, 10:36pm
       I was kinda expecting that to be honest malickfan 742 0 Sun, 6:22pm
       Collapse Am I the only one who kind of loved the bizarre visuals in this scene? thomasofrohan 735 4 Sun, 6:27pm
           Collapse It was bonkers Crunchable Birdses 692 1 Sun, 6:28pm
               I thought the CGI was quite good, honestly - might have just been more of a design issue. thomasofrohan 665 0 Sun, 6:29pm
           You're not BlackFox 604 0 Sun, 6:52pm
           I loved the scene and visuals.... except for the wraiths design! adt100 135 0 Mon, 4:13pm
       Collapse Does the film show the moment with Gandalf and Galadriel reaching for each other as shown in the banner and poster?// Bladerunner 658 1 Sun, 6:28pm
           Yes it does // Arandir 621 0 Sun, 6:29pm
       Collapse Not good dubulous 657 4 Sun, 6:33pm
           Collapse I think it's "The Kiss" *spoilers* Arandir 679 2 Sun, 6:36pm
               I Also thought it was the "kiss" syameese 599 0 Sun, 6:45pm
               I hadn't thought of that dubulous 547 0 Sun, 7:02pm
           She also says Spriggan 579 0 Sun, 7:02pm
       Galadriel thomasofrohan 639 0 Sun, 6:35pm
       Collapse Lady of light Nerven 574 6 Sun, 7:19pm
           Collapse "I think Tolkien would have hated it." thomasofrohan 581 3 Sun, 7:23pm
               . Nerven 496 0 Sun, 7:38pm
               Collapse The trouble is.... dubulous 495 1 Sun, 7:46pm
                   Yeah HiddenSpring 459 0 Sun, 7:53pm
           Collapse to those that haven't read the books, she's The Incredible Hulk Crunchable Birdses 287 1 Sun, 10:37pm
               Yeah dubulous 241 0 Sun, 11:22pm
       Collapse "All shall love me and despair" HiddenSpring 574 3 Sun, 7:33pm
           Collapse I got the impression this was the Galadriel of the Noldor Dame Ioreth 49 2 Tue, 2:40pm
               Collapse Noldor Nerven 39 1 Tue, 4:38pm
                   I thought she did look beautiful Dame Ioreth 35 0 Tue, 5:13pm
       PJ Nerven 433 0 Sun, 8:49pm
       I have seen the movie twice and I think... Bernhardina 197 0 Mon, 11:20am
       Mmmmm... Spalko 179 0 Mon, 11:36am
       Collapse Is this tremendous power hers or... Milieuterrien 167 7 Mon, 1:57pm
           Collapse . Nerven 121 6 Mon, 5:16pm
               Collapse I rather took it as a suggestion of her using her power for extreme aggression Spriggan 114 5 Mon, 6:56pm
                   Collapse Just listening to PB on the EMPIRE podcast... Eleniel 127 4 Mon, 7:44pm
                       . Nerven 101 0 Mon, 8:17pm
                       Collapse Lmao HiddenSpring 99 1 Mon, 9:19pm
                           I wil diminish...and remain Galadriel.... Girdle of Melian 73 0 Mon, 11:18pm
                       Boyens again Mithfânion 31 0 Tue, 10:27pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 913 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.