Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 842 (310425 posts in 12626 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 842 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Ticket Sales MEIGWIT 425 4 Oct 19, 8:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by cats16)
       I haven't seen or heard anything yet... Earl 124 0 Oct 19, 11:14pm
       I'm waiting to hear when they will start selling them too Old Toby 93 0 Oct 20, 1:05am
       For AUJ and DOS ... DanielLB 80 0 Oct 20, 6:15am
       My guess... cats16 18 0 Tue, 8:12am

  Collapse BOTFA Original Song! Peterthorn of Rohan 2802 68 Oct 19, 2:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by cats16)
       Collapse Thank you...thank you... *sobbing* Aragorn the Elfstone 1240 2 Oct 19, 3:03pm
           Collapse Agreed! Elessar 358 1 Oct 19, 10:09pm
               I plan to watch Elessar 351 0 Oct 19, 10:15pm
       Collapse The Last Goodbye hood815 1219 5 Oct 19, 3:11pm
           Collapse Enya NoelGallagher 1176 1 Oct 19, 3:18pm
               Oh Lord, I do hope not. Spriggan 967 0 Oct 19, 4:17pm
           Collapse Even the name JamesPaganini 1136 2 Oct 19, 3:19pm
               Collapse Hopefully hood815 1078 1 Oct 19, 3:21pm
                   time goes by too fast... NoelGallagher 1045 0 Oct 19, 3:27pm
       Sentiments of sadness NecromancerRising 1089 0 Oct 19, 3:18pm
       Collapse This is very promisng! dubulous 1057 1 Oct 19, 3:33pm
           I would think this is implied... Aragorn the Elfstone 1041 0 Oct 19, 3:37pm
       Unfortunately it´s not confirmed oficially... Merenwen Vardamir 985 0 Oct 19, 3:59pm
       Collapse Can someone please make this clickable Lindele 914 3 Oct 19, 4:18pm
           Collapse Clickable Fleuz 906 2 Oct 19, 4:26pm
               Collapse 77 haarp 892 1 Oct 19, 4:29pm
                   Wow where did you learn to be so optimistic? tsmith675 636 0 Oct 19, 5:26pm
       What a title! Scorchster 863 0 Oct 19, 4:37pm
       Collapse CONFIRMED and will be sung by Billy Boyd! Aragorn the Elfstone 1071 15 Oct 19, 4:42pm
           Great! I love Billy's voice.... Eleniel 857 0 Oct 19, 4:51pm
           Collapse This is interesting Shagrat 882 2 Oct 19, 4:57pm
               They submitted the same actors... Aragorn the Elfstone 836 0 Oct 19, 5:03pm
               Yeah, not a very promising dubulous 812 0 Oct 19, 5:07pm
           Collapse This deserves its own thread, if it doesn't have one yet. Lissuin 826 1 Oct 19, 4:59pm
               I can't take credit... Aragorn the Elfstone 757 0 Oct 19, 5:13pm
           Excellent - good find! dormouse 815 0 Oct 19, 4:59pm
           Collapse Thank you. Merenwen Vardamir 728 2 Oct 19, 5:18pm
               Collapse what a great news mo0on-light 609 1 Oct 19, 5:43pm
                   Backin' up..Taking a Tolkien World View? Bombadil 578 0 Oct 19, 6:05pm
           Collapse Sounds promising BlackFox 668 1 Oct 19, 5:19pm
               Could this be based on a poem by Tolkien? Otaku-sempai 303 0 Oct 19, 11:51pm
           Collapse My heart skipped a beat Earl 682 1 Oct 19, 5:23pm
               I think I know just what you mean.... // dormouse 562 0 Oct 19, 6:01pm
           So exciting!! LordotRings93 234 0 Oct 20, 2:37am
       Collapse No "The Road Goes Ever On" Arannir 629 23 Oct 19, 6:27pm
           Collapse I'm with you, Arannir KeenObserver 439 22 Oct 19, 7:40pm
               Collapse To be fair SafeUnderHill 422 3 Oct 19, 7:49pm
                   Collapse Care to elaborate, please? KeenObserver 377 2 Oct 19, 8:00pm
                       Collapse I think SafeUnderHill refers to (spoilers obviously)... Arannir 381 1 Oct 19, 8:02pm
                           That's what I was thinking KeenObserver 336 0 Oct 19, 8:18pm
               Collapse Yeah... Arannir 408 14 Oct 19, 7:50pm
                   Collapse What about the 'bookends'? KeenObserver 359 13 Oct 19, 8:13pm
                       Collapse Many of those things... Aragorn the Elfstone 341 11 Oct 19, 8:17pm
                           Collapse Fair enough KeenObserver 265 10 Oct 19, 9:14pm
                               Collapse It certainly works both ways. Arannir 256 9 Oct 19, 9:18pm
                                   I'm just a wee bit worried too // KeenObserver 250 0 Oct 19, 9:24pm
                                   Collapse Well, if you haven't liked their previous songwriting... dormouse 352 7 Oct 19, 10:21pm
                                       I think his style is more appropriate than the last three choices. Bumblingidiot 284 0 Oct 20, 1:16am
                                       Collapse No. Arannir 198 5 Oct 20, 7:14am
                                           Collapse Ah, but that was my point... dormouse 178 4 Oct 20, 7:50am
                                               Collapse No unnecessary application of worriedness. Arannir 141 3 Oct 20, 10:35am
                                                   Collapse I think it's a weak title, too, sadly... Kendalf 123 2 Oct 20, 11:57am
                                                       Collapse An 'the road goes ever on' isn't? I think it sounds promising. adt100 113 1 Oct 20, 12:10pm
                                                           Song Title Otaku-sempai 89 0 Oct 20, 2:26pm
                       He often said so. Arannir 327 0 Oct 19, 8:23pm
               Collapse 'The Road Goes Ever On' could well be featured in the film itself sycorax82 256 2 Oct 20, 2:11am
                   Roads go ever ever on... Otaku-sempai 240 0 Oct 20, 3:47am
                   That would be... Farficom 162 0 Oct 20, 8:58am
       Crongrats to Billy. Farficom 569 0 Oct 19, 6:32pm
       Great news! FrogmortonJustice65 531 0 Oct 19, 6:44pm
       How poignant. DanielLB 514 0 Oct 19, 6:55pm
       Collapse This has the makings of something great Arthael 507 1 Oct 19, 7:07pm
           Loving his Beecake songs as well NoelGallagher 433 0 Oct 19, 7:38pm
       Collapse *sniff* I'm not crying...I'm not crying... Eruvandi 404 1 Oct 19, 8:00pm
         Big Boys Don't Cry?...but Bombadil 333 0 Oct 19, 11:23pm
     Thrilled by this news! The Grey Elf 293 0 Oct 20, 1:37am
       Oh... I'm so glad they've given it to to Billy grammaboodawg 81 0 Oct 20, 3:54pm
       Fantastic. cats16 24 0 Tue, 8:10am

  Collapse Will there be another world wide fan event? hood815 452 2 Oct 19, 1:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by lidlessEye)
       I doubt it SafeUnderHill 214 0 Oct 19, 2:41pm
       The question should be... lidlessEye 150 0 Oct 19, 5:57pm

  Collapse What time will the DOS EE come out digitally on Tuesday? Annatar598 1333 26 Oct 19, 6:52am Jump to last post in thread (by The Grey Pilgrim)
       Collapse It should be available at midnight. Aragorn the Elfstone 703 6 Oct 19, 6:58am
           Collapse Yes . . Yes . . join us digital downloaders KeenObserver 681 5 Oct 19, 7:16am
               You could not have said anything... Aragorn the Elfstone 402 0 Oct 19, 2:54pm
               Collapse *snort* Avandel 321 3 Oct 19, 5:05pm
                   Collapse C'mon, it can't be that bad KeenObserver 188 1 Oct 19, 9:54pm
                       Yes it can be that bad Avandel 127 0 Oct 20, 2:30am
                   Never Been Spammed smtfhw 64 0 Oct 20, 8:19am
       Collapse How much will it cost? Also... QuackingTroll 579 13 Oct 19, 10:45am
           Collapse They're not forcing you.... dormouse 538 2 Oct 19, 11:40am
               Collapse Not in this instance... QuackingTroll 312 1 Oct 19, 5:36pm
                   I'm with you there dormouse 293 0 Oct 19, 6:00pm
           Collapse I'm not sure I understand what the issue Spriggan 526 9 Oct 19, 11:44am
               Collapse starting with if you are NOT tech savvie Avandel 354 7 Oct 19, 4:50pm
                   Collapse Oh apologies Spriggan 281 4 Oct 19, 6:19pm
                       Collapse It's intended to bring about the end of physical media... Aragorn the Elfstone 275 1 Oct 19, 6:34pm
                           I suppose at some point Spriggan 263 0 Oct 19, 6:54pm
                       Collapse I bet Avandel 135 1 Oct 20, 2:20am
                           Ha no, no idea I'm afraid Spriggan 81 0 Oct 20, 7:20am
                 Collapse Absolutely hilarious post KeenObserver 197 1 Oct 19, 9:47pm
                       *grins* that's what my multiple computer friends say Avandel 130 0 Oct 20, 2:28am
               Well, I can only speak for myself... dormouse 336 0 Oct 19, 4:54pm
       May as well... BlackCountry 484 0 Oct 19, 12:40pm
       Will buy both this and the physical Blu-ray Carne 431 0 Oct 19, 1:58pm
       Early I am sure... Bard'sBlackArrow 377 0 Oct 19, 4:07pm
       Collapse For those interested, it would appear that the iTunes version is available for pre-order now in the UK... Aragorn the Elfstone 164 1 Oct 20, 12:40am
           No iTunes in US still :( but VUDU is up for pre order The Grey Pilgrim 33 0 Oct 20, 3:18pm

Collapse Newish Calender images... NateGate 1003 4 Oct 18, 10:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       Discussed here Arannir 312 0 Oct 18, 11:28pm
       Collapse Well, if nothing else Kim 278 2 Oct 19, 12:29am
           Collapse Radagast NoelGallagher 163 1 Oct 19, 8:19am
               No, it's Gandalf BlackFox 150 0 Oct 19, 8:24am

Collapse Fill in the blank BlackFox 641 30 Oct 18, 3:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by cats16)
       Collapse White Warg NecromancerRising 280 3 Oct 18, 3:31pm
           Collapse You are supposed to come up with a funny alternative to the original. // BlackFox 265 2 Oct 18, 3:33pm
               Collapse Oh i am sorry NecromancerRising 298 1 Oct 18, 3:36pm
                 *snort* BlackFox 283 0 Oct 18, 3:37pm
     ... a guinea pig. // BlackFox 249 0 Oct 18, 3:43pm
       An obese teenage boy. // DeadRabbits 230 0 Oct 18, 4:10pm
       It almost works as it is.... Calmandcloudless 248 0 Oct 18, 4:15pm
       or perhaps..... dormouse 237 0 Oct 18, 4:17pm
       gotta keep that physique... Avandel 229 0 Oct 18, 4:22pm
       astride another pale orc Bishop 221 0 Oct 18, 4:26pm
       Astride a chihuahua puppy mariel 200 0 Oct 18, 4:50pm
       Why, that would be Kim 212 0 Oct 18, 4:52pm
       Legolas! Glorfindela 184 0 Oct 18, 5:58pm
       pink flamingo // dubulous 166 0 Oct 18, 6:13pm
       pogo stick // Loresilme 146 0 Oct 18, 7:16pm
       Collapse A human centipede. // DeadRabbits 142 1 Oct 18, 7:19pm
           Now that's some disturbing imagery BlackFox 151 0 Oct 18, 7:29pm
       Collapse ...a...shrubbery! Otaku-sempai 132 2 Oct 18, 8:05pm
           Collapse Ni! // Kim 82 1 Oct 19, 12:24am
               White Castle Yngwulff 75 0 Oct 19, 2:05am
       ... a tricycle // dormouse 104 0 Oct 18, 9:43pm
       Yo Momma! // NateGate 102 0 Oct 18, 9:52pm
       A giant rabid chicken... Farficom 92 0 Oct 18, 11:35pm
       What else? Kilidoescartwheels 73 0 Oct 19, 2:16am
       Yzma from Emperor's New Groove Cirashala 68 0 Oct 19, 2:41am
       ... Nyan Cat. // BlackFox 51 0 Oct 19, 12:08pm
       a talking donkey // Bard'sBlackArrow 34 0 Oct 19, 4:13pm
       ... a hobby horse? Or should that be hobbit horse.... // dormouse 29 0 Oct 19, 5:00pm
       ...brilliant green mechanism. // Eye's on Guard 29 0 Oct 19, 7:00pm
       Let's see... cats16 10 0 Tue, 8:08am

  Collapse The Hero Moments in BOT5A? Bombadil 891 18 Oct 18, 2:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
     Collapse LOL Bomby Avandel 409 10 Oct 18, 3:43pm
           And this thread heads off Kim 346 0 Oct 18, 5:06pm
           Collapse Archery question Cirashala 188 8 Oct 19, 2:59am
               Speculate AWay? Bombadil 156 0 Oct 19, 10:23am
               Collapse Archery: Your question? Otaku-sempai 132 6 Oct 19, 1:44pm
                   Collapse it wasn't my question Cirashala 105 5 Oct 19, 5:29pm
                       Collapse Okay, thanks! Otaku-sempai 80 4 Oct 19, 8:55pm
                           Collapse BALIN? Bombadil 74 3 Oct 19, 11:36pm
                               Collapse Don't know about Balin here. Otaku-sempai 57 2 Oct 20, 3:36am
                                   Collapse Not me! My only archery question would be *SPOILER* Avandel 28 1 Oct 20, 3:00pm
                                       You asked a question earlier in the thread. Otaku-sempai 28 0 Oct 20, 3:21pm
       Collapse BIFUR killing his nemesis Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 402 2 Oct 18, 5:10pm
         Collapse OKAY! Groovy Guyzz & Galzz..littl' ol' bom PICKZZ... Bombadil 317 1 Oct 18, 5:50pm
             LOL Bomby Avandel 304 0 Oct 18, 6:02pm
       Collapse Some may not appear until the extended edition (SPOILERS, natch')... Otaku-sempai 298 1 Oct 18, 8:43pm
         A BIFIR Fantasy Plot Line? Bombadil 220 0 Oct 19, 1:31am
       Dain and Fili Kilidoescartwheels 234 0 Oct 19, 2:10am
       A SPOILER !!!! "hero" thing I noticed re Thorin - SPOILER thought!! Avandel 128 0 Oct 19, 6:05pm

  Collapse New pictures of Kili? DuBekar 1611 28 Oct 17, 10:00pm Jump to last post in thread (by Arveldis)
       Thank you - think they are from the Annual and PR, higher res Avandel 622 0 Oct 17, 10:09pm
       Collapse I have the annual but haven't really looked at it fully LordotRings93 465 20 Oct 18, 4:20am
           Collapse I am not sure now where some images came from re calender images out now too Avandel 466 19 Oct 18, 5:27am
               That is a very interesting and tantalizing tidbit! Cirashala 449 0 Oct 18, 6:00am
               Oh, sounds interesting... LordotRings93 353 0 Oct 18, 12:52pm
               Collapse I've got the exact quote if anybody wants it. Arveldis 303 16 Oct 18, 6:29pm
                 Collapse That was great! Thanks! Avandel 255 9 Oct 18, 9:20pm
                       Collapse Yep. That's what I think too. Arveldis 248 8 Oct 18, 9:53pm
                         Collapse LOL indeed - from the BOFA trailer Avandel 252 7 Oct 18, 11:01pm
                               Collapse PS. Fili - larger w. link Avandel 257 4 Oct 18, 11:29pm
                                   I love him dearly too...// mae govannen 186 0 Oct 19, 5:45am
                                   Collapse Avandel, am I that transparent? Arveldis 76 2 Oct 19, 9:29pm
                                       Collapse some things are WORTH appreciating Avandel 65 1 Oct 20, 2:09am
                                           Well, that's good to hear. Arveldis 25 0 Tue, 4:24am
                               Collapse Your "saying "hi" to Dain,", etc...LOL!!! mae govannen 192 1 Oct 19, 5:51am
                                 *bows* "grin" - just having some fun Avandel 115 0 Oct 19, 5:28pm
                   Thanks to Aidan for this important comment...// mae govannen 191 0 Oct 19, 5:54am
                   Collapse thank you for posting this Bard'sBlackArrow 128 4 Oct 19, 4:27pm
                       Collapse you are welcome and re the armor Avandel 118 1 Oct 19, 5:49pm
                           costumes makes sense and more family dramas Bard'sBlackArrow 26 0 Tue, 1:27am
                       Collapse Interesting point. Arveldis 93 1 Oct 19, 8:15pm
                           very good points Bard'sBlackArrow 28 0 Tue, 1:34am
       Collapse Uruk-hai? leonmuse 460 1 Oct 18, 6:13am
           Nah Merovech 410 0 Oct 18, 8:34am
       Collapse Good!...I was missing him!!! mae govannen 193 3 Oct 19, 6:09am
         Collapse How do they acquire this CART? Bombadil 185 2 Oct 19, 9:08am
               Your reply is to the THREAD, not to me, I assume...// mae govannen 145 0 Oct 19, 2:28pm
               Lake-town? Otaku-sempai 151 0 Oct 19, 2:32pm

Moved: Fan Art: New Sauron Poster! caglarkuraner - - Oct 17, 8:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by caglarkuraner)

  Collapse Erebor and Dwarf society Cirashala 886 23 Oct 17, 6:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bard'sBlackArrow)
       Dwarves have mines and make things. Elizabeth 394 0 Oct 17, 7:26pm
       Collapse Good question! And then there's Gloin Kilidoescartwheels 396 20 Oct 17, 8:05pm
           Collapse *snirt* Eowyn of Penns Woods 360 11 Oct 17, 8:30pm
             Well... BlackFox 332 0 Oct 17, 8:36pm
             WHOA.... "E OF Pennsylvania"! *snert* Back @ CHa..! // Bombadil 319 0 Oct 17, 8:40pm
               Well that escalated rather quickly. Cillendor 323 0 Oct 17, 8:50pm
               MY bad! Kilidoescartwheels 291 0 Oct 17, 9:34pm
               Collapse I see a potential prequel here. Darkstone 292 5 Oct 17, 9:44pm
                   Collapse Potential fanfic??? Kilidoescartwheels 274 3 Oct 17, 9:51pm
                       Hmmm... Darkstone 272 0 Oct 17, 9:56pm
                       haha! Scorchster 213 0 Oct 18, 1:17am
                       LOLOL Bard'sBlackArrow 56 0 Oct 19, 4:16pm
                 Bwahahaha! // BlackFox 157 0 Oct 18, 8:52am
               Sorry to disappoint you Cirashala 214 0 Oct 18, 2:04am
           Collapse where did you see that Bofur was a farmer? Cirashala 220 7 Oct 18, 1:58am
               Collapse Where did I see that Bofur was a farmer? Kilidoescartwheels 207 3 Oct 18, 3:05am
                   Collapse Italy and Israel yes Cirashala 201 2 Oct 18, 3:27am
                       Collapse Farming .... Yngwulff 177 1 Oct 18, 7:53am
                           huh? Cirashala 167 0 Oct 18, 8:00am
               Where is the border? Elarie 146 0 Oct 18, 11:41am
               Collapse Perhaps fishing? FoundEntwife 99 1 Oct 18, 9:41pm
                   that sounds like a good possibility, especially with the River Running :) Cirashala 82 0 Oct 19, 2:14am
       Post-Smaug Retro315 257 0 Oct 17, 11:11pm

  Collapse DOS Chapter of the Week: It Is Our Fight DwellerInDale 719 45 Oct 17, 4:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by cats16)
       Collapse Ugh, no thank you! Glorfindela 363 14 Oct 17, 5:42pm
           Collapse Response to first response: DwellerInDale 348 13 Oct 17, 5:53pm
               Collapse Not sure you want that lol! Cirashala 321 12 Oct 17, 6:18pm
                   Collapse Indeed Glorfindela 268 11 Oct 17, 10:23pm
                       Collapse my apologies Cirashala 220 3 Oct 18, 2:14am
                           Collapse My apologies for my reaction, too Glorfindela 162 2 Oct 18, 9:53am
                               Collapse As Balin would say, DwellerInDale 156 1 Oct 18, 10:18am
                                   This is splitting hairs Glorfindela 153 0 Oct 18, 10:31am
                       Collapse At least there are positives ... DanielLB 153 6 Oct 18, 10:32am
                           Collapse For myself… Glorfindela 156 5 Oct 18, 10:42am
                               Collapse You've hit the nail on the head for me, Glorfindela Lurker in the Mirk 104 4 Oct 19, 12:31pm
                                 Collapse Great minds think alike, eh, Lurker! Glorfindela 99 3 Oct 19, 12:53pm
                                     Collapse I'd prefer to think the glass is half-full Lurker in the Mirk 100 2 Oct 19, 1:04pm
                                         Collapse I humbly bow before Your Majesty. Glorfindela 98 1 Oct 19, 1:20pm
                                             Your kindness becomes your avatar Lurker in the Mirk 51 0 Oct 20, 2:41am
       I'd just like to say SafeUnderHill 329 0 Oct 17, 6:16pm
       Collapse Fantastic! Darkstone 315 2 Oct 17, 7:40pm
           Thanks for the Bible quote DwellerInDale 210 0 Oct 18, 1:25am
           Yes, another oblique reference to King Lear DwellerInDale 193 0 Oct 18, 2:42am
       All elf scenes make me happy Eruvandi 244 0 Oct 17, 11:59pm
       Collapse *Shrugs* Avandel 253 4 Oct 18, 12:06am
           Collapse Captains going against orders DwellerInDale 221 3 Oct 18, 1:46am
               Collapse Hey Cirashala 204 2 Oct 18, 2:52am
                   Collapse Going against the fobbits DwellerInDale 190 1 Oct 18, 3:59am
                       LOL Cirashala 176 0 Oct 18, 4:57am
       Collapse Thanks Dweller! Kim 233 3 Oct 18, 1:03am
           Collapse A Point About Orcrist DwellerInDale 208 1 Oct 18, 2:21am
               Hmmm Kim 202 0 Oct 18, 2:44am
           LOL Kim - Legolas angst Avandel 174 0 Oct 18, 5:42pm
       Collapse Rosie the Riveter cats16 183 4 Oct 18, 6:50am
           Collapse Do mine eyes deceive me? Riven Delve 71 3 Oct 19, 7:34pm
               Collapse Haha! Well... cats16 23 2 Tue, 8:05am
                   Collapse Hee hee Riven Delve 21 1 Tue, 11:07am
                       Me too! :) // cats16 9 0 Tue, 9:13pm
       Collapse I like this scene Noria 215 7 Oct 18, 2:23pm
           Collapse Thanks for your comments Noria DwellerInDale 193 6 Oct 18, 3:11pm
             Collapse I'd disagree EL was born to play a female elf BUT Avandel 183 3 Oct 18, 5:18pm
                   I do remember when Saorise Ronan was supposed to be cast as an elf maiden Noria 155 0 Oct 18, 8:07pm
                   Collapse Itaril Otaku-sempai 155 1 Oct 18, 8:51pm
                       Thank you - and I could have seen this Itaril/Tauriel as up and coming Avandel 149 0 Oct 18, 9:38pm
               Collapse Oops Noria 159 1 Oct 18, 7:43pm
                   No worries... DwellerInDale 108 0 Oct 19, 6:46am
       My thoughts, though I usually don't post in these Elciryamo 142 0 Oct 19, 5:17am
       Does this chapter title have a double meaning? Riven Delve 79 0 Oct 19, 7:31pm
       I'll just briefly answer the first question... sauget.diblosio 37 0 Mon, 11:12pm

  Collapse My question about Galadriel and Gandalf Poster Wordofmask 1268 44 Oct 17, 1:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by ElendilTheShort)
       Collapse I don't see what problem people have with ROTK Earl 734 14 Oct 17, 1:44pm
           Collapse Yeah. Arannir 653 3 Oct 17, 1:51pm
               Pretty sure NoelGallagher 604 0 Oct 17, 1:56pm
               Collapse ROFLOL Avandel 495 1 Oct 17, 3:39pm
                   I bring that quote up a lot. Mooseboy018 394 0 Oct 17, 5:16pm
           Collapse Gandalf just didn't fall off of his horse... Bladerunner 271 9 Oct 17, 9:28pm
               Collapse Although the Nazgul at Minas Tirith Spriggan 248 3 Oct 17, 10:01pm
                   Collapse ??? I'm not concerned with the feelings of a fictional character... Bladerunner 259 2 Oct 18, 12:33am
                       Collapse I was speaking more generally but I mean that Spriggan 204 1 Oct 18, 9:11am
                           Thanks for clarifying! / Bladerunner 118 0 Oct 18, 5:14pm
               Collapse Well I don't think Gandalf's broken staff is a symbol of his weakness Earl 239 3 Oct 17, 10:05pm
                   Collapse I think the broken staff does symbolize superior strength... Bladerunner 253 2 Oct 18, 12:41am
                       Collapse I agree that scene leaves the viewer with the conclusion that the Witch-king overcame Gandalf Earl 247 1 Oct 18, 1:06am
                           I felt like the way Peter Jackson directed the scene was a literal "saved by the bell" moment; Bladerunner 130 0 Oct 18, 5:01pm
               And let's not forget sauget.diblosio 113 0 Oct 18, 7:06pm
       Collapse I wouldn't worry about it, wait and see.... dormouse 580 19 Oct 17, 1:58pm
           Collapse Absolutely- Was Merry more powerful than the Witch King? Spriggan 578 8 Oct 17, 2:04pm
               Collapse While I understand the point you all said Wordofmask 373 7 Oct 17, 5:28pm
                   Collapse It wasn't a duel, though dormouse 331 2 Oct 17, 6:17pm
                       Collapse As Tolkien himself says Voronwë_the_Faithful 321 1 Oct 17, 6:53pm
                           Quite true. mae govannen 175 0 Oct 18, 12:35pm
                   Collapse The whole concept of duels and power comparisons is just one that I think Spriggan 320 3 Oct 17, 6:25pm
                       Collapse Grima Wordofmask 227 2 Oct 18, 5:34am
                           Collapse Actually it's extremely vaild.... dormouse 139 1 Oct 18, 4:32pm
                               Exactly...// mae govannen 61 0 Oct 19, 6:29am
           totally agree Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 507 0 Oct 17, 2:43pm
           Right...Well said! mae govannen 496 0 Oct 17, 2:46pm
           Collapse But here's something I still don't get greenbalrog 457 4 Oct 17, 3:50pm
               Sauron understood power - and that was all he understood. dormouse 442 0 Oct 17, 4:05pm
               It is mentioned in the book dubulous 453 0 Oct 17, 4:06pm
               Thanks for the replies, they make perfect sense. However... greenbalrog 387 0 Oct 17, 5:04pm
               fair point and yes i would have guarded mt doom ElendilTheShort 55 0 Oct 19, 10:31am
           Collapse Exactly. Mooseboy018 377 2 Oct 17, 5:20pm
               Well, that's not exactly the way it happened... Salmacis81 143 0 Oct 18, 4:04pm
               in fairness mooseboy the headbutt was with a helmet that had a blimmin great spike on the top of it ElendilTheShort 45 0 Oct 19, 10:22am
       Collapse The Wiki vs Gandalf scene disappointed me most in ROTK.... adt100 515 1 Oct 17, 3:07pm
           I still thought it was disappointing too. Mooseboy018 387 0 Oct 17, 5:23pm
       Collapse The most powerful being in Middle Earth? Elizabeth 341 3 Oct 17, 7:39pm
           oooh nice! Avandel 277 0 Oct 17, 10:26pm
           You beat me to it...! mae govannen 184 0 Oct 18, 12:30pm
           Good one Elizabeth. Noria 158 0 Oct 18, 2:37pm
       Was also wondering this today! LordotRings93 245 0 Oct 18, 4:18am
       Collapse well FoundEntwife 92 1 Oct 18, 10:05pm
           i don't know about that MouthofSauron 77 0 Oct 19, 2:34am

  Collapse Prologue in Bo5A lidlessEye 1366 28 Oct 17, 11:25am Jump to last post in thread (by FoundEntwife)
       Yes Azaghâl 615 0 Oct 17, 11:42am
       Absolutely! Fleuz 578 0 Oct 17, 11:51am
       Yes, your lidless ee can see very properly Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 554 0 Oct 17, 12:00pm
       Story-telling-wise it imho has to be a meeting of the Dwarf-Lords Arannir 561 0 Oct 17, 12:01pm
       Collapse I concur... Shagrat 521 1 Oct 17, 12:25pm
           Good Change! Fleuz 488 0 Oct 17, 12:32pm
       my two cents :) schadowfax 482 0 Oct 17, 12:40pm
       Collapse I thought we weren't getting one? QuackingTroll 511 4 Oct 17, 12:48pm
           I hope you're wrong Azaghâl 470 0 Oct 17, 12:55pm
           Collapse Some people... Arannir 477 1 Oct 17, 12:57pm
               Yes I think a prologue is almost certain. Spriggan 470 0 Oct 17, 1:01pm
           In an interview PJ seems to imply not prologue... adt100 385 0 Oct 17, 3:40pm
       Dain should not be in that scene... Otaku-sempai 391 0 Oct 17, 3:09pm
       Collapse How about Thrain? LordGawain 361 6 Oct 17, 3:38pm
           Collapse Nice idea but problematic Shagrat 339 4 Oct 17, 3:49pm
               Collapse I wouldn't have any particular issue with a key giving scene Spriggan 316 3 Oct 17, 4:17pm
                   True Shagrat 303 0 Oct 17, 4:21pm
                   Collapse true LordGawain 296 1 Oct 17, 4:26pm
                       Yes I think any prologue with the dwarf clans would have to Spriggan 287 0 Oct 17, 4:38pm
           But surely the description of the meeting in the DOS prologue Spriggan 335 0 Oct 17, 4:07pm
       stupid question Jettorex 306 0 Oct 17, 4:35pm
       I like it but... Jettorex 284 0 Oct 17, 4:51pm
       Collapse Prologue in Bag End drewster81 208 1 Oct 17, 11:28pm
           d81...CooooOOL!// Bombadil 169 0 Oct 18, 12:30am
       Collapse Really hope it's the Ered Luin meeting LordotRings93 116 1 Oct 18, 4:15am
           There's one teensy, tiny problem with this.... Cirashala 113 0 Oct 18, 5:02am
       This is a prologue I would LOVE to see- and it's not what you're thinking- book spoiler Cirashala 124 0 Oct 18, 5:11am
       Prologue FoundEntwife 60 0 Oct 18, 9:57pm

Collapse Will We get to See Mount Gundabad? Bombadil 931 28 Oct 17, 8:16am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Maybe a short glimpse... Arannir 429 0 Oct 17, 8:22am
       Fingers crossed Shagrat 392 0 Oct 17, 8:32am
     Collapse Remember Bomby the huge BOTFA banner? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 453 6 Oct 17, 8:35am
         Collapse SSOoo.. CORRECT.. Yess...Even IF Bombadil 389 3 Oct 17, 8:49am
             Collapse Could it be that at the same time dwarves go to iron hills seeking for aid, orcs go to Gundabad for the same? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 370 2 Oct 17, 8:55am
                   Collapse Yap. Arannir 359 1 Oct 17, 8:58am
                       YOU jus' Hatched a GREAT Sub-Plot..? Bombadil 344 0 Oct 17, 9:16am
           Collapse Mount Gundabad as a breed hoard Fleuz 380 1 Oct 17, 8:51am
               Yes. Arannir 359 0 Oct 17, 8:53am
       Collapse as much as I love to see it... lidlessEye 348 1 Oct 17, 9:16am
           Gundabad and Iron Hills likely to be shown Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 337 0 Oct 17, 9:39am
       Collapse I'm not sure what this would mean to a non-reader audience Spriggan 321 13 Oct 17, 9:47am
           Collapse the same way Gundabad was named in AUJ when the wargs attacked... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 317 12 Oct 17, 10:04am
               Collapse I thought we were talking about a scene there Spriggan 293 11 Oct 17, 10:25am
                   Collapse Yeah you are right but Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 276 10 Oct 17, 10:38am
                       Collapse I think the difference, for me, is that Spriggan 240 9 Oct 17, 12:31pm
                           Collapse Do you think the casual viewer learns in his first or second view where is placed everythng?? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 224 8 Oct 17, 12:56pm
                               Collapse No not all. Spriggan 214 7 Oct 17, 1:06pm
                                   Collapse Thats why Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 206 6 Oct 17, 1:15pm
                                       Collapse Oh no I think the opposite Spriggan 200 5 Oct 17, 1:28pm
                                           Collapse Not at all Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 171 4 Oct 17, 2:05pm
                                               Collapse In that example we are told specifically Spriggan 173 3 Oct 17, 2:18pm
                                                   Collapse ok you are a winner Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 155 1 Oct 17, 2:38pm
                                                       Haha Spriggan 69 0 Oct 17, 3:06pm
                                                   A Related Question? Bombadil 76 0 Oct 17, 2:44pm
       hope so ! shaundobson 197 0 Oct 17, 1:33pm
       Possibly Carne 71 0 Oct 17, 2:57pm
       Not holding my breath... Otaku-sempai 81 0 Oct 17, 3:11pm

  Collapse BO5A run-time... delius82 817 1 Oct 17, 3:53am Jump to last post in thread (by Arannir)
       PJ said at CC... Arannir 430 0 Oct 17, 8:08am
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 842 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.