Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 961 (345649 posts in 14405 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 961 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Moved: Thought youALL might like to see this.. Bombadil - - Feb 5, 9:38am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)

  Collapse Does anyone wish that Dwalin had a one on one confrontation with Azog or Bolg? boldog 812 16 Feb 5, 6:25am Jump to last post in thread (by lionoferebor)
       Collapse It would have been glorious tattooed_dwarf 452 2 Feb 5, 6:30am
           That actually would have been perfect! boldog 412 0 Feb 5, 7:13am
           That would have been perfect! iduna 62 0 Feb 7, 9:15pm
       Collapse Why he had... TheHutt 437 1 Feb 5, 7:31am
           That's a good point! Riven Delve 370 0 Feb 5, 11:17am
       Well no..... dormouse 406 0 Feb 5, 8:42am
       Not at all Glorfindela 350 0 Feb 5, 12:29pm
       Never thought of it, lionoferebor 306 0 Feb 5, 1:44pm
       More screen time for all the dwarves would have been nice Elarie 317 0 Feb 5, 2:05pm
       Not me. Noria 290 0 Feb 5, 2:45pm
       Collapse My biggest fear Kilidoescartwheels 256 4 Feb 5, 8:36pm
           Collapse You do know.... He is a wizard, you know! 242 3 Feb 5, 9:12pm
               Collapse Well not in the book Kilidoescartwheels 124 1 Feb 6, 5:04pm
                   I can see your concern lionoferebor 61 0 Feb 7, 9:55pm
               This is true... lionoferebor 66 0 Feb 7, 10:10pm
       No. sauget.diblosio 138 0 Feb 6, 12:53pm

  Collapse Quint's cameo in BotFA ghost_matt 648 4 Feb 5, 5:07am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Cool, I was wondering if we'd hear any more from him Kim 312 2 Feb 5, 5:20am
           Collapse He finished them, but WB won't let him release them... AshNazg 257 1 Feb 5, 12:40pm
               A possible book? Otaku-sempai 184 0 Feb 5, 3:43pm
       WOW thanks for Reminding Bomby! Bombadil 159 0 Feb 5, 6:45pm

  Moved: On characters and journeys..... dormouse - - Feb 4, 11:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)

  Collapse what would you change about smaugs death balbo biggins 1342 142 Feb 4, 8:21pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse What do you mean by "change"? Spriggan 681 2 Feb 4, 8:27pm
           Collapse hmm balbo biggins 637 1 Feb 4, 8:47pm
               No, I'm afraid not. Spriggan 615 0 Feb 4, 8:51pm
       Collapse Well... Merovech 688 1 Feb 4, 8:28pm
           Perhaps you would like to edit that? Spriggan 635 0 Feb 4, 8:46pm
       I'd have... BlackFox 619 0 Feb 4, 8:40pm
       The improvised bow. Otaku-sempai 615 0 Feb 4, 9:13pm
       Smaug: "I'll see you in another life. When we are both cats." / Darkstone 551 0 Feb 4, 9:35pm
       Collapse How about not dying? Donry 571 6 Feb 4, 9:45pm
           Collapse They could form The Legion of Mount Doom! Darkstone 525 5 Feb 4, 10:02pm
               Collapse Ooooo! Can the Fellowship Friends ride in the Van??? Brethil 511 3 Feb 4, 10:04pm
                   Collapse Why not? Darkstone 519 2 Feb 4, 10:12pm
                       Collapse That was exactly what I always imagined Eledhwen 315 1 Feb 5, 4:59pm
                           You mean it's not? Darkstone 303 0 Feb 5, 5:12pm
               As long as we get to bring Donry 498 0 Feb 4, 10:30pm
       Personally Skaan 537 0 Feb 4, 10:02pm
       Collapse I can only say what I was hoping for Bishop 574 65 Feb 4, 10:20pm
           Collapse agree balbo biggins 509 64 Feb 4, 10:47pm
               Collapse Yes, this is baffling Bishop 501 63 Feb 4, 11:05pm
                   Collapse The reality for me is that this scene isnt actually THAT important... moreorless 361 62 Feb 5, 12:53am
                       Collapse It's not that I just want action though Bishop 341 61 Feb 5, 1:08am
                           Collapse Infact yes I would... moreorless 308 60 Feb 5, 6:42am
                               Collapse Well burrahobbit 280 12 Feb 5, 9:13am
                                   Collapse Perhaps the "Bond" arguement? moreorless 273 11 Feb 5, 10:17am
                                       Collapse Yes burrahobbit 260 10 Feb 5, 10:58am
                                           Agreed. Arannir 241 0 Feb 5, 11:29am
                                           Collapse In a way I think we got that... moreorless 246 8 Feb 5, 11:53am
                                               Collapse Sure burrahobbit 261 7 Feb 5, 6:57pm
                                                   Collapse I'm not sure I get the point about the riddles... moreorless 276 3 Feb 6, 2:04am
                                                     Ol' Bom just got back from the Last Bombadil 259 0 Feb 6, 3:25am
                                                       Collapse Inside Information burrahobbit 205 1 Feb 6, 8:00pm
                                                           Yes movie is different. arithmancer 176 0 Feb 6, 8:59pm
                                                   Collapse I was thinking about this while answering a poll in Pollantir Dame Ioreth 202 2 Feb 6, 1:36pm
                                                       I like that thought, it's an interesting way of looking at it // dormouse 181 0 Feb 6, 1:47pm
                                                       I like that Elessar 181 0 Feb 6, 1:50pm
                               Collapse We'll have to disagree Bishop 249 46 Feb 5, 7:06pm
                                   Collapse It does come up quite often moreorless 244 45 Feb 6, 7:32am
                                       Collapse Yes, I agree with this..... dormouse 214 2 Feb 6, 11:56am
                                           After Finally watching it for the 11th Time Bombadil 216 0 Feb 6, 12:25pm
                                           Look back in DOS as a whole... moreorless 133 0 Feb 6, 5:04pm
                                       Collapse You may be misunderstanding me Bishop 145 41 Feb 6, 4:29pm
                                           Again thats not the question I was answering... moreorless 133 0 Feb 6, 4:54pm
                                           Collapse I think it might be word "deserves" which is the troublesome one. Spriggan 128 39 Feb 6, 5:11pm
                                               Collapse I don't think so Bishop 119 38 Feb 6, 5:22pm
                                                   Collapse Oh I didn't think that you were making that point but it's one I think is straightforward Spriggan 114 37 Feb 6, 5:56pm
                                                       Collapse You're comparing things that clearly are different in scope though Bishop 106 36 Feb 6, 6:11pm
                                                           Collapse That's my point, though Spriggan 100 35 Feb 6, 6:18pm
                                                               Collapse I honestly don't understand what you're saying Bishop 96 34 Feb 6, 6:32pm
                                                                   Collapse The duration of scenes is entirely up to the author. Spriggan 233 33 Feb 6, 6:39pm
                                                                       Collapse The big picture Bishop 229 32 Feb 6, 6:41pm
                                                                           Collapse Happy to answer yours if you return the favour. Spriggan 228 31 Feb 6, 6:51pm
                                                                               Collapse I will happily answer, after you answer! Bishop 224 30 Feb 6, 6:58pm
  Collapse I'm saying that Spriggan 220 29 Feb 6, 7:07pm
       Collapse On Fatty Bolger you're wrong on so many levels Bishop 216 28 Feb 6, 7:15pm
           Collapse More page time for Fatty. Spriggan 205 27 Feb 6, 7:25pm
               Collapse We've been talking about the movie Bishop 198 26 Feb 6, 7:39pm
                   Collapse Screen time, as far as I'm aware Spriggan 204 25 Feb 6, 7:57pm
                       Collapse I actually don't understand your question Bishop 190 24 Feb 6, 8:08pm
                           Collapse No, of course not. Spriggan 187 23 Feb 6, 8:14pm
                               Collapse Wow! Go for it! Bishop 170 22 Feb 6, 9:00pm
                                   Collapse Scratching my head a bit. Spriggan 166 21 Feb 6, 9:16pm
                                       Collapse Well let me simplify a bit Bishop 157 20 Feb 6, 9:37pm
                                           Collapse Sure - that's fine Spriggan 153 18 Feb 6, 9:52pm
                                               Collapse There is no such thing as importance anyway, right? Bishop 127 17 Feb 7, 1:24am
                                                   Collapse I would say no, yes and no. Spriggan 110 16 Feb 7, 10:28am
                                                       Collapse Well I say yes, no, no, strawman, and no. Bishop 79 15 Feb 7, 5:54pm
                                                           Collapse Why wouldn't people make arguments about subjective issues? Spriggan 74 14 Feb 7, 6:33pm
                                                               Collapse Becuase there's no objective reality Bishop 66 13 Feb 7, 7:08pm
                                                                   Collapse This seems to have wandered off a bit? Spriggan 51 2 Feb 7, 7:52pm
                                                                       Collapse So you don't think Bishop 124 1 Feb 7, 8:07pm
                                                                           They often do Spriggan 114 0 Feb 7, 8:48pm
                                                                   Collapse If you compare Laketown time with Erebor time Milieuterrien 125 9 Feb 7, 8:32pm
                                                                       Collapse But wait..... dormouse 107 8 Feb 7, 11:41pm
                                                                           Collapse Quite simple to imagine : Milieuterrien 99 7 Feb 8, 12:25am
                                                                               Collapse I don't know.... dormouse 81 6 Feb 8, 9:25am
  Collapse A daytime verion Milieuterrien 79 5 Feb 8, 10:47am
       Well, yes, there are all sorts of different ways they could have done it... dormouse 73 0 Feb 8, 11:14am
       Collapse I think you might be misremembering - it's not daytime in the book. Spriggan 75 3 Feb 8, 11:14am
           Collapse daytime Milieuterrien 74 2 Feb 8, 12:38pm
               Collapse I'm sure you get more right than I would reading in French! Spriggan 69 1 Feb 8, 2:09pm
                   Yes of course, but not entirely Milieuterrien 64 0 Feb 8, 4:34pm
                                           I've been reading this subthread... arithmancer 168 0 Feb 6, 9:53pm
       Legolas should have killed him!! burrahobbit 504 0 Feb 4, 10:51pm
       I'd make it rain.... dormouse 486 0 Feb 4, 11:15pm
       Collapse if anything Ruxendil_Thoorg 498 13 Feb 4, 11:35pm
           Collapse I agree Glorfindela 456 9 Feb 5, 12:01am
               Collapse refer 2 OP balbo biggins 443 8 Feb 5, 12:13am
                   Collapse Actually I think this scene.... dormouse 305 7 Feb 5, 9:04am
                       Collapse thanks balbo biggins 236 3 Feb 5, 12:33pm
                           Collapse If you start a thread here with a question.... dormouse 394 2 Feb 5, 2:04pm
                               Agree, Dormouse Glorfindela 338 0 Feb 5, 4:36pm
                               Couldn't Have Put It Better Myself... smtfhw 188 0 Feb 5, 9:21pm
                       Collapse I agree with much of what you say Riven Delve 248 2 Feb 5, 12:48pm
                           Collapse Well said Dormouse and Riven Delve// Noria 345 1 Feb 5, 2:56pm
                               OK then, first Reuel 339 0 Feb 5, 4:13pm
           Collapse I suspect we'll get this in the EE.. moreorless 451 2 Feb 5, 12:22am
               Collapse whoops! i goofed. amendment needed. Ruxendil_Thoorg 342 1 Feb 5, 12:41am
                 Bomby VOTES w/ Rux_Tho.!..There? Bombadil 321 0 Feb 5, 1:50am
       Collapse Nothing! Kirly 444 4 Feb 5, 12:29am
           Collapse EE balbo biggins 377 3 Feb 5, 12:39am
               Collapse Actively ignoring obvious attempt at pot stirring. Have a nice day! Kirly 328 2 Feb 5, 4:10am
                   Collapse well balbo biggins 229 1 Feb 5, 12:32pm
                       Asked what would I change, I said nothing. Did you have a nice day? /// Kirly 148 0 Feb 5, 10:59pm
       Collapse thought about this since I saw it Barrow-Wight 327 1 Feb 5, 4:13am
           Yeah, I don't get why he gets shot on the ground, then "flies" up and dies? AshNazg 230 0 Feb 5, 12:46pm
       Lets see... Eowyn of Penns Woods 304 0 Feb 5, 4:59am
       Collapse Well... Arannir 280 2 Feb 5, 8:40am
           Collapse In my opinion... Anubis 247 1 Feb 5, 11:49am
               Agree to disagree Arannir 221 0 Feb 5, 1:19pm
       Chekhov's gun... elvish.mafia 243 0 Feb 5, 12:05pm
       Collapse Well, I’d look at some of the story-beats Reuel 239 1 Feb 5, 12:58pm
           Yap Arannir 222 0 Feb 5, 1:23pm
       Smaug's death is Elessar 382 0 Feb 5, 2:28pm
       Collapse as others have said... nymmerod 306 3 Feb 5, 5:22pm
           Collapse EE balbo biggins 288 1 Feb 5, 5:24pm
               the EE... nymmerod 287 0 Feb 5, 5:38pm
           It's not necessarily nitpicking.. Bishop 127 0 Feb 6, 1:05am
       Collapse I would agree with those who expected more closeness to the original Milieuterrien 235 19 Feb 5, 8:41pm
           Collapse How big is Lake-town in the book? Bishop 206 8 Feb 5, 8:53pm
               Collapse Lake-town Otaku-sempai 180 7 Feb 5, 10:12pm
                   Collapse Thanks for posting those pics Bishop 131 6 Feb 6, 12:50am
                       A good photo Otaku-sempai 163 0 Feb 6, 2:20pm
                       Collapse Lake-town: book vs. film Otaku-sempai 49 4 Feb 9, 1:06am
                           Collapse But where did Fonstad get those dimensions from? Spriggan 43 3 Feb 9, 8:37am
                               Collapse Fonstad's Lake-town Otaku-sempai 34 2 Feb 9, 1:08pm
                                   Collapse Ah so we might have a fair old margin of error in there then! Spriggan 23 1 Feb 9, 3:58pm
                                       Yes. Margin of error. Otaku-sempai 28 0 Feb 9, 4:21pm
           Collapse I agree with many if your ideas, but particularly this one Brethil 212 9 Feb 5, 8:56pm
               Collapse I'm with ya Elessar 195 8 Feb 5, 9:00pm
                   Collapse 100% agreed Elessar Brethil 195 7 Feb 5, 9:11pm
                       Collapse Wheelbarrow Elessar 194 6 Feb 6, 1:47pm
                           Collapse Yes that cut to black at the end of DOS Dame Ioreth 179 1 Feb 6, 1:56pm
                               I agree Elessar 169 0 Feb 6, 2:10pm
                           Collapse Yes, that moment give the Company more ownership of what happens Brethil 154 3 Feb 6, 3:41pm
                               Collapse Spot on Elessar 139 2 Feb 6, 4:34pm
                                   Collapse Yes - and that disturbing image of Thorin not caring at all, back turned to death and ruin Brethil 156 1 Feb 6, 10:04pm
                                       Exactly! Elessar 27 0 Feb 9, 3:16pm
       I wouldn't change it. DanielLB 211 0 Feb 5, 8:55pm
       Collapse Well since you asked Kilidoescartwheels 225 2 Feb 5, 8:57pm
           I puzzle about this myself, KDC Brethil 199 0 Feb 5, 9:06pm
           BotFA Chronicles Pandallo 261 0 Feb 6, 3:07am
       The only thing I would change Dame Ioreth 251 0 Feb 6, 6:06am

Moved: Ultimate Battle: Stone Giants VS Were-worms Legolas_Shoehorn - - Feb 4, 3:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by Legolas_Shoehorn)

  Collapse Hobbit Trilogy on BluRay with Bilbo's Journal! TheHutt 1233 7 Feb 4, 8:12am Jump to last post in thread (by balbo biggins)
       Daniel Reeve already made the RedBook, I think. Fleuz 527 0 Feb 4, 8:19am
       That's pretty cool! Elessar 395 0 Feb 4, 2:00pm
       Great news. Farficom 307 0 Feb 4, 5:22pm
       Collapse It's probably just a slipcase designed like the Red Book Earl 322 3 Feb 4, 5:42pm
           Collapse no bluray? balbo biggins 295 2 Feb 4, 6:20pm
               Collapse Wild guess - Earl owns no Bluray player?// arithmancer 194 1 Feb 5, 12:14am
                   really balbo biggins 214 0 Feb 5, 1:47am

  Collapse If you could design Kilis look what would you do. Thorins_apprentice 846 20 Feb 4, 7:45am Jump to last post in thread (by Bladerunner)
       Really marillaraina 488 0 Feb 4, 8:00am
       hard to say Mooseboy018 460 0 Feb 4, 8:01am
       If I could, I wouldn't.... dormouse 443 0 Feb 4, 8:24am
       I for one never had a problem with how Kili looks; however, since you asked.... Old Toby 455 0 Feb 4, 8:27am
       Collapse The problems begin with having an actor that looks similar to RA... Eleniel 473 7 Feb 4, 9:51am
           Yeah. Macfeast 389 0 Feb 4, 11:50am
           Hm... Arannir 352 0 Feb 4, 1:02pm
           Collapse When did they decide that MF wasn't leading man material? KingTurgon 249 4 Feb 4, 9:05pm
               Collapse I was meaning in terms of typical Hollywood rugged, charismatic action hero... Eleniel 148 3 Feb 5, 7:38am
                   Collapse Now I'm picturing Daniel Craig as Bilbo Baggins! ;0) Bladerunner 101 2 Feb 5, 10:48pm
                       Collapse And wouldn't she be fantastic!// Dame Ioreth 92 1 Feb 5, 11:26pm
                           Oh yes she would have! // Bladerunner 94 0 Feb 6, 1:46am
       Nothing Glorfindela 386 0 Feb 4, 11:42am
       ugly! balbo biggins 389 0 Feb 4, 12:17pm
       Collapse Well... lionoferebor 333 1 Feb 4, 2:13pm
           I like that Riven Delve 309 0 Feb 4, 3:23pm
       I wouldn't. RosieLass 221 0 Feb 4, 9:34pm
       Young dwarves Na Vedui 225 0 Feb 4, 10:14pm
       I like Kili just the way he is so I wouldn't. /// Kirly 176 0 Feb 5, 12:24am
       "Not the beard!" ...yes, the beard, I'd change the beard.// Bladerunner 178 0 Feb 5, 2:31am

  Moved: What's your "Arkenstone?" Kilidoescartwheels - - Feb 3, 10:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)

  Collapse March 24th Confirmed Bluray Release Date for BoFA? tsmith675 1395 28 Feb 3, 6:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Awesome!!! Nolane 565 0 Feb 3, 7:12pm
       Collapse Wonder if that's just the US, or if our date will be the same... // dormouse 527 1 Feb 3, 7:33pm
           Me, too! // Eleniel 501 0 Feb 3, 7:35pm
       Collapse Is there any chance Glorfindela 564 9 Feb 3, 7:44pm
           Collapse I would totally do that for you... tsmith675 531 3 Feb 3, 7:46pm
             Collapse It's the thought that counts Glorfindela 506 2 Feb 3, 7:50pm
                   Collapse Does this work? Faleel 506 1 Feb 3, 8:04pm
                     Thank you as well, Faleel Glorfindela 464 0 Feb 3, 8:09pm
           Collapse Here :) Ilmatar 540 4 Feb 3, 7:58pm
             Collapse Splendid! Thank you very much, Ilmatar Glorfindela 484 3 Feb 3, 8:08pm
                   Collapse Personally... tsmith675 472 1 Feb 3, 8:13pm
                       I'm hoping Elessar 146 0 Feb 4, 5:25pm
                   You're welcome :) Ilmatar 453 0 Feb 3, 8:15pm
       Collapse Don't care... Estel78 527 2 Feb 3, 8:08pm
           Same. tsmith675 473 0 Feb 3, 8:18pm
           Ditto! // Eleniel 253 0 Feb 4, 7:26am
       Collapse Still in theaters around me....at least 2-3 show times. Eruonen 488 4 Feb 3, 8:36pm
           Collapse You mean 45 - 60 minutes *minimum* right? ;) Earl 335 1 Feb 4, 3:24am
               Me too! // dormouse 237 0 Feb 4, 8:25am
         Collapse From your post to Sir Peter's ears, my friend! // Brethil 312 1 Feb 4, 3:59am
               Since this is the last film, empty the larder Peter! Eruonen 313 0 Feb 4, 4:04am
       pretty cool balbo biggins 448 0 Feb 3, 8:47pm
       3D combo pack for me... Queen of Erebor 394 0 Feb 3, 11:38pm
       First TE I am not going to get. Arannir 291 0 Feb 4, 8:27am
       Collapse I personally... TheHutt 305 2 Feb 4, 8:28am
           Collapse since you're involved in dvd production Cirashala 28 1 Feb 9, 5:32am
               Amazon... arithmancer 29 0 Feb 9, 2:01pm
       I have both the TE amd EE of the each movie in both trilogies. Farficom 169 0 Feb 4, 5:19pm

  Collapse How would YOU do the scene of the Dwarves arrival at Bagend differently? Thorins_apprentice 811 27 Feb 3, 1:03pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Not that way. Otaku-sempai 457 1 Feb 3, 2:19pm
           Agree entirely, O-S // Brethil 333 0 Feb 3, 4:57pm
       I wouldn't. dormouse 406 0 Feb 3, 2:55pm
       The only thing I'd change - Greenwood Hobbit 407 0 Feb 3, 3:46pm
       Collapse I honestly wouldn't change anything. FrogmortonJustice65 369 1 Feb 3, 4:41pm
           Nor I. Elizabeth 242 0 Feb 3, 8:56pm
       I wouldn't attempt to 'do' the scene differently Glorfindela 364 0 Feb 3, 4:53pm
       Collapse idea balbo biggins 359 4 Feb 3, 4:58pm
           Collapse Er.... dormouse 291 2 Feb 3, 7:42pm
               Collapse hypothetical balbo biggins 259 1 Feb 3, 8:21pm
                   And my answer to the question "what would you do differently"... dormouse 197 0 Feb 3, 11:08pm
           This type of visual humor could have worked nicely as a setup... Bladerunner 177 0 Feb 3, 11:54pm
       Dwarves poping out the toilet Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 330 0 Feb 3, 5:29pm
       I prefer to meet the Dwarves just as Bilbo does, so I wouldn't change anything. Noria 266 0 Feb 3, 7:53pm
       Just the arrival? Bishop 247 0 Feb 3, 8:39pm
       Collapse I always thought the way Reuel 230 3 Feb 3, 10:00pm
           I like this idea... Bladerunner 177 0 Feb 3, 11:48pm
           Collapse Indeed, I'm surprised no one has mentioned this before... Eleniel 104 1 Feb 4, 7:31am
               Not much of a problem. Otaku-sempai 89 0 Feb 4, 2:32pm
       The arrival was fine for me. RosieLass 222 0 Feb 3, 10:20pm
       I would have left it the same KingTurgon 210 0 Feb 3, 10:29pm
       Collapse the film intro was alright with me.. Bladerunner 178 1 Feb 4, 12:01am
           I agree balbo biggins 161 0 Feb 4, 12:04am
       I actually liked it Kirly 141 0 Feb 4, 3:45am
       Another satisfied customer Gwytha 143 0 Feb 4, 4:17am
       Things I would have liked to see - pettytyrant101 137 0 Feb 4, 5:18am
       Instruments / Darkstone 68 0 Feb 4, 2:16pm

  Collapse Would Kili's Morgul wound have stayed with him as Frodo's did? Ruxendil_Thoorg 907 28 Feb 3, 3:00am Jump to last post in thread (by Spriggan)
       Not in my opinion. arithmancer 519 0 Feb 3, 3:03am
       Collapse its a got of an odd one balbo biggins 495 2 Feb 3, 3:24am
           Collapse Morgul Arrow Pandallo 485 1 Feb 3, 4:05am
               disagree balbo biggins 458 0 Feb 3, 4:27am
       Hard to tell marillaraina 437 0 Feb 3, 6:10am
       Collapse On Morgul-wounds BlackFox 340 19 Feb 3, 6:22pm
           Collapse Well... Rembrethil 313 18 Feb 3, 6:34pm
               That is true BlackFox 290 0 Feb 3, 6:39pm
               Collapse Do we know that? Spriggan 286 12 Feb 3, 7:41pm
                   You're right, it isn't BlackFox 255 0 Feb 3, 8:39pm
                   Collapse Not explicitly, no... Rembrethil 239 10 Feb 3, 9:46pm
                       Collapse Actually HOME points us the other way. Spriggan 220 9 Feb 4, 12:04am
                           Collapse Ah.... Rembrethil 98 8 Feb 5, 10:58pm
                               Collapse Not at all - the thing I enjoy most about the adaptations Spriggan 99 7 Feb 5, 11:19pm
                                   hmmm. marillaraina 86 0 Feb 6, 1:15am
                                   Collapse Yes! Rembrethil 88 5 Feb 6, 2:31am
                                       Collapse I think you have read a lot into it to see it that way marillaraina 89 1 Feb 6, 4:12am
                                           As you say... Rembrethil 33 0 Feb 6, 2:46pm
                                       Collapse So two points here, I think. Spriggan 66 2 Feb 6, 10:49am
                                           Collapse Well... Rembrethil 34 1 Feb 6, 2:51pm
                                               A great pleasure. Spriggan 33 0 Feb 6, 4:25pm
               Collapse Well marillaraina 202 3 Feb 4, 1:55am
                   Collapse Though... arithmancer 191 1 Feb 4, 2:44am
                       Y'all are making this overly complicated :) marillaraina 191 0 Feb 4, 4:59am
                   Hmmm.... Maybe... Rembrethil 98 0 Feb 5, 11:02pm
       Collapse Shadow illnesses Silverlode 90 2 Feb 6, 8:49am
           Thanks so much! Ruxendil_Thoorg 58 0 Feb 6, 2:03pm
           Amazing! Rembrethil 38 0 Feb 6, 2:53pm

  Collapse With the benefit of hindsight Hamfast Gamgee 1288 73 Feb 2, 10:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       maybe Mooseboy018 566 0 Feb 2, 10:32pm
       Collapse Alas.... Jeffrodo 593 43 Feb 2, 10:36pm
           Collapse There's a very specific difference, for me. Bumblingidiot 490 3 Feb 2, 11:38pm
               Collapse For me Glorfindela 460 2 Feb 3, 12:20am
                   Collapse There are no noddy dwarves in The Hobbit, Bumblingidiot 408 1 Feb 3, 4:34am
                       FOR ME Glorfindela 337 0 Feb 3, 11:03am
           Couldn't agree more Glorfindela 454 0 Feb 3, 12:12am
           Collapse Hm Arannir 232 36 Feb 4, 1:16pm
               Collapse It's a matter of opinion, surely Glorfindela 210 32 Feb 4, 4:35pm
                   Collapse Just because a lot of people paid to see the film... Salmacis81 161 30 Feb 4, 11:04pm
                       Collapse The people I know in the UK who saw the film Glorfindela 156 28 Feb 4, 11:59pm
                           Collapse Same can be said for Transformers Arannir 125 27 Feb 5, 8:18am
                               Collapse I don't think that is what most reactions to criticisms get Elessar 129 26 Feb 5, 1:57pm
                                   Collapse I am sorry if I generalized too much. Arannir 109 1 Feb 5, 2:07pm
                                       It wasn't too harsh Elessar 104 0 Feb 5, 2:16pm
                                   Collapse Trouble is, you'd have to make allowance in your poll... dormouse 127 23 Feb 5, 2:12pm
                                       That is true Elessar 106 0 Feb 5, 2:26pm
                                       Collapse I'm sorry to hear that people are being snarky, and that it is driving people away. Macfeast 232 10 Feb 5, 2:32pm
                                           Collapse It's all a question of tone... dormouse 233 9 Feb 5, 2:39pm
                                               That's the key Elessar 219 0 Feb 5, 3:09pm
                                               Collapse again balbo biggins 234 3 Feb 5, 3:13pm
                                                   Collapse So I can dictate how people respond to my posts? Darkstone 223 2 Feb 5, 4:35pm
                                                       :-) Voronwë_the_Faithful 150 0 Feb 5, 6:55pm
                                                       Oh, very well Glorfindela 152 0 Feb 5, 6:57pm
                                               Collapse That comes from both sides, I think. Macfeast 222 1 Feb 5, 3:17pm
                                                   Perfectly said. 100% agreed. Arannir 96 0 Feb 5, 8:31pm
                                               Collapse A long tradition on TORn. Darkstone 107 1 Feb 5, 8:22pm
                                                   Wow, nefisa ... that is going back a while. Ataahua 82 0 Feb 5, 9:20pm
                                       Collapse I agree Glorfindela 196 10 Feb 5, 4:49pm
                                           A reminder to all Eledhwen 179 0 Feb 5, 5:29pm
                                           Collapse Perhaps people don't want echo chambers? Macfeast 173 8 Feb 5, 6:01pm
                                               Collapse I agree with you, Macfeast Glorfindela 162 1 Feb 5, 6:47pm
                                                   I do see where you're coming from. Macfeast 134 0 Feb 5, 7:37pm
                                               Collapse I agree but..... Elessar 143 4 Feb 5, 7:27pm
                                                   Collapse Well... Macfeast 131 3 Feb 5, 7:42pm
                                                       Collapse It seems Elessar 118 2 Feb 5, 7:55pm
                                                           Collapse Most topics have indeed been done, positive topics just as much as negative topics. Macfeast 107 1 Feb 5, 8:06pm
                                                               I'm sure lots have been repeated. Elessar 116 0 Feb 5, 8:10pm
                                               I agree, though then it seems a bit odd Spriggan 70 0 Feb 5, 10:57pm
                       While that's true of course... Ilmatar 124 0 Feb 5, 7:27am
                   I do not hate it and never said so ;) Arannir 116 0 Feb 5, 8:10am
               Collapse Funny, isn't it... dormouse 198 1 Feb 4, 4:42pm
                   In the end Elessar 186 0 Feb 4, 4:52pm
               I guess that's the good thing about opinions. Elessar 184 0 Feb 4, 4:50pm
           I do think this comes in to play Elessar 193 0 Feb 4, 4:45pm
       Collapse But the children of Indis were great and glorious, and their children also; Voronwë_the_Faithful 567 3 Feb 2, 10:42pm
           Collapse Precisely.... :-) // dormouse 499 1 Feb 2, 10:45pm
               I'm so happy you are around here Voronwë_the_Faithful 494 0 Feb 2, 10:58pm
           Thank you for this quote, Voronwe, absolutely perfect here mae govannen 327 0 Feb 3, 11:24am
       Well... tripecac 476 0 Feb 2, 11:04pm
       Putting LOTR on film was EomundDaughter 483 0 Feb 2, 11:30pm
       Collapse Who knows. Hindsight is notoriously unreliable. Spriggan 473 1 Feb 2, 11:32pm
           LOL... Unreliable indeed!...// mae govannen 305 0 Feb 3, 11:28am
       Collapse Do you not think that would have changed the tone of the films ? glor 467 1 Feb 2, 11:35pm
           LOTR would have been marketed differently too tiamy 254 0 Feb 3, 4:10pm
       I feel the way things have happened was MEANT mae govannen 318 0 Feb 3, 11:36am
       Maybe. Otaku-sempai 286 0 Feb 3, 2:26pm
       Collapse I don't understand how anyone Lindele 326 12 Feb 3, 2:29pm
           Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 291 8 Feb 3, 2:59pm
               Collapse Everyone that has talked about a "book-faithful" adaptation Pandallo 302 3 Feb 3, 3:04pm
                   Well, yes... Otaku-sempai 277 0 Feb 3, 3:08pm
                   Collapse I wish... RosieLass 290 1 Feb 3, 10:17pm
                       Mods Up! Eleniel 250 0 Feb 4, 7:39am
               Collapse If the animated version Lindele 266 3 Feb 3, 4:23pm
                   Collapse Proof of Concept. Otaku-sempai 301 2 Feb 3, 4:27pm
                       Collapse If it had been even 2 hours long... Eleniel 296 1 Feb 3, 4:59pm
                           The Rankin/Bass 'Hobbit' Otaku-sempai 300 0 Feb 3, 5:13pm
           If Fellowship of the Ring can be made in a single film... burrahobbit 273 0 Feb 3, 10:33pm
           Collapse LotR was truncated to fit into 3 3-hour films... Salmacis81 163 1 Feb 4, 11:00pm
               Oh, heck... Otaku-sempai 150 0 Feb 5, 12:43am
       Not the issue Arannir 242 0 Feb 4, 1:08pm
       I first read the books swordwhale 56 0 Feb 6, 5:20am
       Eh, i think that's the least of the trilogy's problems. sauget.diblosio 46 0 Feb 6, 1:32pm

  Collapse Wilderland- nature and chaos in The Hobbit burrahobbit 877 26 Feb 2, 7:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by burrahobbit)
       Thanks for this interesting post Elarie 344 0 Feb 2, 11:01pm
       Collapse They were certainly aware of the importance and significance of dormouse 368 19 Feb 2, 11:04pm
           Collapse Were they? burrahobbit 354 18 Feb 2, 11:38pm
               Collapse Not a sequel? dormouse 282 15 Feb 3, 8:41am
                   I second you totally on this beautifully expressed view. // mae govannen 211 0 Feb 3, 11:49am
                   Collapse PS - I did mean Saruman, not Sauron, with the crebain! ;-) // dormouse 197 2 Feb 3, 1:40pm
                     Collapse DMOUSE you ARE wonderful in Many ways! Bombadil 193 1 Feb 3, 2:24pm
                           Well, I'm not sure about the very elevated understanding.... dormouse 191 0 Feb 3, 2:52pm
                   Collapse So the Silmarillion is also a sequel to The Hobbit? burrahobbit 200 10 Feb 3, 8:25pm
                       Collapse Or is 'The Hobbit' a sequel to 'The Silmarillion'? Otaku-sempai 149 2 Feb 3, 10:41pm
                           Collapse No burrahobbit 156 1 Feb 3, 10:46pm
                               Well, you began the side-discussion of sequels. Otaku-sempai 138 0 Feb 3, 10:59pm
                       I'll state what I like if I think it's true..... dormouse 126 0 Feb 3, 11:55pm
                       Collapse I think it's very tricky to state, unproblematically, that LOTR is not a sequel. Spriggan 125 5 Feb 4, 12:12am
                           Collapse No one is saying that it's unproblematic burrahobbit 126 4 Feb 4, 12:32am
                               Collapse I think I'm saying that it appears to have fallen within Tolkien's definition. Spriggan 121 3 Feb 4, 12:35am
                                   Collapse Tolkien was well aware of the complexities burrahobbit 118 2 Feb 4, 1:17pm
                                       Well...okay. Otaku-sempai 101 0 Feb 4, 2:38pm
                                       It seemed rather bald, or at least thinning. Spriggan 82 0 Feb 4, 8:23pm
               Collapse This is where I have to disagree. Otaku-sempai 206 1 Feb 3, 2:36pm
                   Although, I always tend to think that we focus on the least impactful element Spriggan 192 0 Feb 3, 3:59pm
       I suppose we could ask the same of Tolkien Spriggan 328 0 Feb 2, 11:43pm
       Spot on there. Bumblingidiot 329 0 Feb 2, 11:56pm
       Film and book are different media, of course. Riven Delve 314 0 Feb 3, 12:37am
       Collapse my thoughts elostirion74 42 1 Feb 6, 6:29am
           Nice! burrahobbit 28 0 Feb 6, 7:46pm

Collapse When Silence izzz Golden..? Bombadil 440 6 Feb 2, 11:49am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
     Collapse Hi always enjoy your comments! Kirly 112 4 Feb 3, 2:26am
           Collapse Thang YO!.. Kirly..! Bombadil 86 3 Feb 3, 8:52am
             Back to Bilbo's Silences..? Bombadil 91 0 Feb 3, 9:09am
             Collapse I hope you go someday soon! I want to go back again too. /// Kirly 47 1 Feb 4, 12:53am
                 SUM people find Fault Bombadil 62 0 Feb 4, 3:37am
       Excellent observations Bomby Kim 58 0 Feb 3, 10:02pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 961 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.