Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 962 (346035 posts in 14424 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 962 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse EE Commentaries and extras? CathrineB 1095 16 Feb 9, 6:01pm Jump to last post in thread (by Starling)
       I liked the endless running scene in AUJ and the barrel scenes in DOS commentary. Eruonen 524 0 Feb 9, 6:53pm
       Collapse I found that they made a possibly dangerous incident it hilarious by KingTurgon 474 3 Feb 9, 8:31pm
         Collapse Bom Finds Dwalin Bombadil 426 1 Feb 9, 8:51pm
               Ken Stott KingTurgon 337 0 Feb 10, 12:59am
           Graham CathrineB 367 0 Feb 9, 10:29pm
       Collapse Some of the V-logs Kilidoescartwheels 437 4 Feb 9, 9:22pm
           Collapse It's not at all strange for an actor to be shy Starling 290 2 Feb 10, 7:18am
               Collapse That's a really fascinating article, thanks Starling Kim 52 1 Feb 13, 1:46am
                   When the staff at my school undertook some personality testing, Starling 50 0 Feb 13, 6:56am
           Actors Arannir 266 0 Feb 10, 9:25am
       I prefer the Hobbit EEs Glorfindela 408 0 Feb 9, 11:27pm
       I'm so with you Kirly 121 0 Feb 11, 2:04am
       Collapse My favorite moments Kim 131 2 Feb 11, 3:45am
           Collapse It is a Laketown castoff. arithmancer 116 1 Feb 11, 4:00am
               Yeah Kim 109 0 Feb 11, 4:08am
       The extras and commentaries are fantastic! Ithilisa 136 0 Feb 11, 4:30am

  Collapse a mile stone mirkwoodwanderer 1113 32 Feb 9, 10:17am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
     Is this true? Glorfindela 538 0 Feb 9, 12:09pm
       Well goodness! dormouse 496 0 Feb 9, 12:13pm
       Collapse Are you posting this from a theatre? DanielLB 494 1 Feb 9, 12:26pm
         LOL...! Good question indeed!!! // mae govannen 412 0 Feb 9, 2:20pm
       Collapse That's amazing Elarie 457 8 Feb 9, 1:27pm
         Collapse For myself Glorfindela 420 6 Feb 9, 3:45pm
               Collapse *snicker* *snicker* Bombadil 405 1 Feb 9, 4:03pm
                   yeay Bomby! swordwhale 290 0 Feb 9, 6:21pm
               Collapse Me too. Arannir 390 3 Feb 9, 4:15pm
                   me three// swordwhale 285 0 Feb 9, 6:22pm
                 Chuckling *high five* Arannir! Same here. // Brethil 164 0 Feb 9, 11:26pm
                   I have that trouble with my family Glorfindela 170 0 Feb 9, 11:43pm
           Ah, maybe that's it Loresilme 289 0 Feb 9, 6:43pm
       You have GOT Lindele 391 0 Feb 9, 4:53pm
       egad! swordwhale 312 0 Feb 9, 6:20pm
       Collapse hmmm balbo biggins 338 14 Feb 9, 6:20pm
           Collapse Agreed, must be lying LordotRings93 317 13 Feb 9, 6:34pm
               Collapse The OP said on Jan.26th ................ Moahunter 287 12 Feb 9, 8:07pm
                   Collapse More than a month before that, on Dec. 20 Voronwë_the_Faithful 286 11 Feb 9, 8:49pm
                     V_t_F Too Funny....// Bombadil 243 0 Feb 9, 8:54pm
                       That is a hilarious post Arannir 262 0 Feb 9, 8:54pm
                       Well now, to be fair... Elarie 245 0 Feb 9, 10:00pm
                       Collapse maybe they're not counting in base 10 // Magpie 221 3 Feb 9, 10:03pm
                           Collapse Maybe so Voronwë_the_Faithful 229 2 Feb 9, 10:29pm
                               Collapse But I've just sharpened my pitchfork! DanielLB 145 1 Feb 10, 8:18am
                                 A Run-on Sentence Izz Bombadil 71 0 Feb 11, 7:30am
                       Collapse Goodness Glorfindela 187 1 Feb 9, 11:44pm
                           my work here is done! Voronwë_the_Faithful 178 0 Feb 9, 11:52pm
                       Collapse peter jackson in disguise balbo biggins 177 1 Feb 10, 12:32am
                           That is what amuses me shadowdog 85 0 Feb 10, 7:58pm
       No, seriously Bishop 321 0 Feb 9, 6:41pm
       Wow, at least a $1000 contribution without popcorn and a drink. Eruonen 310 0 Feb 9, 7:00pm

  Collapse Box office update BlackFox 1108 20 Feb 9, 9:52am Jump to last post in thread (by Kirly)
       Collapse I think it's a great achievement for Peter and his team Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 584 3 Feb 9, 10:26am
           Collapse Steven Spielberg! Skaan 496 2 Feb 9, 1:56pm
               Collapse It depends... Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 434 1 Feb 9, 3:15pm
                   THANK You for the Hard Numbers... Bombadil 384 0 Feb 9, 3:53pm
     Brilliant stuff Glorfindela 492 0 Feb 9, 12:06pm
       Collapse Didn't they do well! dormouse 508 3 Feb 9, 12:08pm
           Collapse Not Sure..? But isn't it just Bombadil 453 1 Feb 9, 1:54pm
               No, alas Glorfindela 389 0 Feb 9, 3:43pm
         And I can't WAIT to spend so MORE Avandel 401 0 Feb 9, 3:53pm
       Pretty much right in line with what I predicted Voronwë_the_Faithful 460 0 Feb 9, 2:12pm
       Collapse I'm so happy and ridiculously proud!!! mae govannen 461 1 Feb 9, 2:16pm
           lol I know exactly what you mean :) Loresilme 111 0 Feb 10, 10:40pm
       Collapse Update on Chinese BO for last week? (Feb 2-8) Misty Mountain Hop 209 6 Feb 10, 5:38pm
           Collapse Current China total: $114.5 million Voronwë_the_Faithful 198 4 Feb 10, 6:22pm
               Collapse That's very good Glorfindela 186 3 Feb 10, 6:53pm
                   Collapse I think the average time from when a movie opens Elessar 171 2 Feb 10, 7:34pm
                       Collapse Studios shadowdog 157 1 Feb 10, 8:10pm
                           There ya go. Elessar 154 0 Feb 10, 8:13pm
           They have now BlackFox 170 0 Feb 10, 8:18pm
     The success of these movies and their makers makes me very happy! /// Kirly 110 0 Feb 11, 1:54am

  Collapse Alas no BAFTA for BOFTA elf_wannabee 645 11 Feb 9, 6:35am Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       Collapse IS Arannir 303 1 Feb 9, 1:20pm
           Apes really should have won. sauget.diblosio 41 0 Feb 11, 2:15pm
       Collapse I chuckled at the title... ;) // Estel78 179 7 Feb 9, 9:52pm
           It is rather chuckle-worthy! // dormouse 159 0 Feb 9, 10:48pm
           Collapse What does the T stand for? AshNazg 155 5 Feb 9, 11:14pm
               Collapse Sorry for my dyslexia. I meant BOT5A elf_wannabee 145 1 Feb 9, 11:23pm
                   It's fine, I was just kidding AshNazg 141 0 Feb 10, 12:36am
               Collapse BOFTA = ... Aruakar 117 2 Feb 10, 11:40am
                   Collapse Tolkien Loved the Letter "B" Bombadil 118 1 Feb 10, 2:45pm
                       It IS great! Kirly 64 0 Feb 11, 1:17am
       We did get some great moments though. Farficom 66 0 Feb 11, 12:19am

  Collapse Any Thranduil fans here? wriath3000 944 91 Feb 9, 6:19am Jump to last post in thread (by Kim)
       Collapse Boy have you come to the right place Ataahua 531 8 Feb 9, 6:26am
           Collapse OMG wriath3000 510 7 Feb 9, 6:38am
               Collapse You can post :) Ilmatar 491 4 Feb 9, 6:40am
                   Collapse thanks~ wriath3000 467 3 Feb 9, 6:49am
                       Collapse true Ilmatar 460 2 Feb 9, 6:55am
                           Collapse ~~ wriath3000 448 1 Feb 9, 7:03am
                               :) Ilmatar 437 0 Feb 9, 7:16am
               Collapse Welcome! Starling 455 1 Feb 9, 7:00am
                   haha wriath3000 442 0 Feb 9, 7:05am
     Collapse Yes, absolutely – Thranduil is wonderful! Glorfindela 410 1 Feb 9, 12:02pm
           Us Thrandy Fans Are Everywhere It Seems! KingTurgon 194 0 Feb 10, 7:45pm
       Collapse Ansolutely. Arannir 403 11 Feb 9, 1:39pm
           Collapse Me too Voronwë_the_Faithful 389 10 Feb 9, 2:19pm
               Collapse Silmarillion-style Elf? Otaku-sempai 397 3 Feb 9, 2:32pm
                   Collapse Deeply-flawed but also .... Voronwë_the_Faithful 378 2 Feb 9, 3:00pm
                       Collapse Okay. Otaku-sempai 369 1 Feb 9, 3:02pm
                           Galadriel is a special case Voronwë_the_Faithful 286 0 Feb 9, 6:25pm
               Collapse How kind of you. Arannir 390 5 Feb 9, 2:36pm
                   I don't want to invalidate your opinion Voronwë_the_Faithful 369 0 Feb 9, 2:58pm
                   Collapse I feel that way too Arannir... dormouse 369 3 Feb 9, 3:10pm
                       Add me to that opinion… Glorfindela 356 0 Feb 9, 3:48pm
                       Collapse In the end... Arannir 353 1 Feb 9, 3:53pm
                           You can add my echo to the others, Arannir Riven Delve 291 0 Feb 9, 5:36pm
       Me too - and welcome! dormouse 355 0 Feb 9, 3:16pm
     Collapse Welcome! And yes, many fans of the fey, magnificent Elven King! Avandel 367 3 Feb 9, 4:13pm
         Collapse Thanks very much for posting those lovely Thranduil images, Avandel Glorfindela 290 2 Feb 9, 5:20pm
               You are most welcome! - link Avandel 303 0 Feb 10, 4:16am
               this one is by my teacher nagaking 299 0 Feb 10, 5:16am
       Hi there! Eruvandi 341 0 Feb 9, 4:19pm
       Collapse Sorry but I hate Thranduil! Konrad S 364 17 Feb 9, 5:14pm
           Collapse Sorry Adrianna 304 16 Feb 9, 6:12pm
               well said// swordwhale 271 0 Feb 9, 6:28pm
               Collapse Thranduil book-verse lionoferebor 260 14 Feb 9, 9:49pm
                   Collapse One thing that perhaps should have been done, in my view Glorfindela 243 13 Feb 9, 11:38pm
                       I would agree! Adrianna 212 0 Feb 10, 12:46am
                       Collapse I agree lionoferebor 209 1 Feb 10, 12:48am
                           I see the Hobbit swordwhale 198 0 Feb 10, 12:57am
                       yeay Valinor! swordwhale 202 0 Feb 10, 12:54am
                       Collapse Welcome to Valinor and re Thranduil's backstory Avandel 314 5 Feb 10, 4:47am
                           Collapse Thanks for that Avandel Adrianna 283 4 Feb 10, 6:52am
                               Collapse When Thranduil looks at the incoming orcs is a great moment! Avandel 268 3 Feb 10, 2:05pm
                                   Collapse with BOFTA I started to really focus on Thranduil Lena 255 2 Feb 10, 3:01pm
                                       Collapse That is something I love about these movies... Arannir 257 1 Feb 10, 3:19pm
                                           I agree, Arannir Glorfindela 239 0 Feb 10, 3:37pm
                       Collapse It is just possible we might get something in the EE.. moreorless 283 2 Feb 10, 10:47am
                           Collapse I would love... Arannir 272 1 Feb 10, 11:17am
                               Certainly possible.. moreorless 255 0 Feb 10, 1:50pm
       Welcome! Riven Delve 291 0 Feb 9, 5:40pm
       Absolutely! Let's get this party started: Loresilme 294 0 Feb 9, 5:41pm
       Welcome! Adrianna 270 0 Feb 9, 6:17pm
       Collapse Thranduil was the first Elf I met reading the books... swordwhale 269 1 Feb 9, 6:37pm
           Yes - the first thing that caught my imagination with the Elvenking.... dormouse 226 0 Feb 9, 10:55pm
       Collapse For myself I see Adrianna 208 8 Feb 10, 12:54am
           Collapse I'd recommend that Riven Delve 194 7 Feb 10, 1:24am
               Collapse How should one read Adrianna 175 6 Feb 10, 2:42am
                   I forgot about the Unfinished tales series also Adrianna 168 0 Feb 10, 3:00am
                   There's no set way to read them Riven Delve 171 0 Feb 10, 3:06am
                   Collapse I would say just as you have them written is an excellent order Brethil 168 3 Feb 10, 3:07am
                       Collapse Thank Adrianna 164 2 Feb 10, 3:28am
                         Enjoy the journey! Brethil 157 0 Feb 10, 3:37am
                           I envy you Riven Delve 265 0 Feb 10, 1:05pm
       Collapse Do you think Adrianna 196 21 Feb 10, 1:54am
           Collapse *gloomily* Avandel 187 20 Feb 11, 1:44am
               Collapse Works for me too! Riven Delve 178 1 Feb 11, 2:05am
                   Me too! But then I am waiting for the super deluxe extended edition of all 6 films! /// Kirly 160 0 Feb 11, 3:24am
               Collapse A nice long movie! Adrianna 165 1 Feb 11, 2:21am
                   extended edition Lena 142 0 Feb 11, 7:35am
               Collapse couldn't agree more! Lena 148 1 Feb 11, 7:30am
                   Think Thranduil tried to control the situation Avandel 117 0 Feb 11, 4:38pm
               Collapse Six hours for an EE BoFA would be superb! Glorfindela 125 13 Feb 11, 12:33pm
                 Collapse I'd buy a six -hour movie too! Avandel 206 12 Feb 11, 5:08pm
                     Collapse Indeed… Glorfindela 205 10 Feb 11, 5:52pm
                           Collapse More Wardrobe wear Adrianna 197 3 Feb 11, 6:33pm
                               Collapse Lee Pace seems to have been a delight for the costumers! Avandel 181 2 Feb 11, 11:23pm
                                   Collapse pleasure looking at him Lena 154 1 Feb 12, 10:14am
                                       Oh yes, re Thrandui's armor Avandel 127 0 Feb 12, 4:50pm
                           Thorin and the raven a beuatiful moment Avandel 176 0 Feb 11, 11:12pm
                           Collapse I was going to say the same... Ilmatar 176 4 Feb 11, 11:45pm
                               Collapse I want that Avandel 135 3 Feb 12, 4:40pm
                                   Collapse Dwarf charm bracelet Kim 123 2 Feb 12, 6:53pm
                                     Collapse Adorable! Avandel 104 1 Feb 13, 2:22am
                                           Agreed, but Kim 95 0 Feb 13, 3:03am
                       two kings Lena 179 0 Feb 11, 10:12pm
       what can I say wriath3000 233 0 Feb 10, 4:29pm
       This is what I observed at my second viewing Adrianna 237 0 Feb 10, 6:31pm
       Oh yes Bernhardina 208 0 Feb 10, 7:27pm
       I liked his character and portrayal immensely as it showed the imperfections in Eruonen 189 0 Feb 10, 11:54pm
       Collapse There are many, many of us. I feel as you do ...... VeArkenstone 123 3 Feb 12, 7:00pm
           Collapse How close were they? Adrianna 117 2 Feb 13, 12:02am
               Collapse I could swear in LOTR FOTR book Avandel 105 1 Feb 13, 2:25am
                   "There was also a strange Elf clad in green and brown, Brethil 102 0 Feb 13, 2:38am

  Collapse So how long do you think it would take Cirashala 705 15 Feb 9, 5:47am Jump to last post in thread (by Kim)
       Everytime CathrineB 297 0 Feb 9, 9:58am
       It's an interesting question Ilmatar 274 0 Feb 9, 10:51am
       Collapse I would say maybe years Calithilel 261 1 Feb 9, 11:46am
         The stench would probably be no worse Glorfindela 258 0 Feb 9, 11:58am
       Collapse I think it might be months rather than years Elarie 226 1 Feb 9, 2:52pm
           I wonder if WETA designed Riven Delve 218 0 Feb 9, 4:21pm
       I foresee a large and profitable market in head and beard kerchiefs in Dale during the clean-up years Loresilme 210 0 Feb 9, 4:36pm
       And also shadowdog 202 0 Feb 9, 4:55pm
       the historical cleanups in Berlin... swordwhale 182 0 Feb 9, 6:44pm
       Really bad breath joec_34 157 0 Feb 9, 8:55pm
       Dragon poo... arithmancer 143 0 Feb 9, 11:20pm
       On the subject of dragon poop Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 117 0 Feb 10, 1:22am
       Dragon Poo Eruwestial37 95 0 Feb 10, 7:18am
       This is a fascinating topic! Might have response after reading others first./// Kirly 74 0 Feb 10, 4:38pm
       I kept thinking about this Kim 54 0 Feb 11, 4:05am

  Collapse Battle of the Five Armies: an extended third act? Jeffrodo 928 7 Feb 9, 1:10am Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       I agree Legomir 361 0 Feb 9, 2:11am
       Agreed! Thrain II 342 0 Feb 9, 2:17am
       Come to think of it... lionoferebor 345 0 Feb 9, 4:05am
       Collapse Dramatically I'm not sure I would.. moreorless 311 2 Feb 9, 7:20am
           Yes, I think I'd agree with this... dormouse 251 0 Feb 9, 9:21am
           neatly done swordwhale 148 0 Feb 9, 7:19pm
       Well lack of travel isn't what I complain about Kilidoescartwheels 93 0 Feb 10, 6:39pm

  Collapse In terms of different peoples' reactions to BOTFA Legomir 1214 51 Feb 8, 7:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       Collapse Same Glorfindela 637 13 Feb 8, 7:45pm
           Collapse The Hobbit films are as loved as LOTR BUT... moreorless 630 6 Feb 8, 8:35pm
               Collapse I think you have a point Legomir 491 1 Feb 8, 9:02pm
                   I would be careful Bishop 445 0 Feb 8, 9:39pm
               Collapse I agree with all this Glorfindela 411 3 Feb 8, 10:00pm
                   Collapse I don't particularly object to rudeness, myself. Spriggan 401 2 Feb 8, 10:15pm
                       I don't like it much Glorfindela 378 0 Feb 8, 10:23pm
                       Add in a health dose of sheeplike mentality... moreorless 274 0 Feb 9, 6:07am
           Collapse At the end of the day ... DanielLB 554 4 Feb 8, 8:41pm
               Collapse I'd never want to stop discussion Legomir 488 1 Feb 8, 8:59pm
                   The antipode is just as bad. DanielLB 474 0 Feb 8, 9:18pm
               Great post, thanks Bishop 429 0 Feb 8, 9:36pm
               Note that I was talking generally Glorfindela 394 0 Feb 8, 10:07pm
           you nailed it swordwhale 175 0 Feb 9, 7:14pm
       Collapse No - there's no uniform opinion on this forum, any other forum, or in real life. DanielLB 595 7 Feb 8, 8:06pm
           Collapse You 'tolerate it' ? AshNazg 411 6 Feb 8, 10:18pm
               Collapse Sure. DanielLB 280 5 Feb 9, 7:11am
                   Collapse What's so wrong with it? lurtz2010 275 2 Feb 9, 7:30am
                       Collapse I will be brief. DanielLB 259 1 Feb 9, 9:13am
                           Thank you Daniel Michelle Johnston 113 0 Feb 9, 11:59pm
                   Collapse Bland seems a little odd to me... moreorless 94 1 Feb 10, 7:40am
                       Opinions will be opinions. DanielLB 99 0 Feb 10, 8:16am
       No. Arannir 440 0 Feb 8, 9:49pm
       Well, Ataahua 424 0 Feb 8, 9:53pm
       No... Thrain II 391 0 Feb 8, 10:15pm
       The reaction to the film was mixed burrahobbit 412 0 Feb 8, 10:32pm
       On the subject of (Internet) Trolls Kilidoescartwheels 317 0 Feb 9, 2:46am
       Collapse Fans CathrineB 268 21 Feb 9, 9:44am
         Collapse Interestin' VERY Interesting...Humm Bombadil 321 20 Feb 9, 10:57am
               Collapse On hold. Arannir 304 19 Feb 9, 1:28pm
                   Collapse I agree CathrineB 261 1 Feb 9, 2:48pm
                     Sorry adout my Sorta Snarky Post Bombadil 250 0 Feb 9, 3:26pm
                   Collapse Come on now Elessar 269 16 Feb 9, 3:12pm
                       Collapse Have posts been deleted? Spriggan 241 1 Feb 9, 3:56pm
                           No just previous convo Elessar 235 0 Feb 9, 3:57pm
                       Collapse I am sorry if you feel that way. Arannir 254 13 Feb 9, 4:09pm
                           ok Elessar 212 0 Feb 9, 4:52pm
                           Collapse Could you point to a couple of examples? Spriggan 221 11 Feb 9, 5:30pm
                               Collapse I made my comments... Arannir 201 10 Feb 9, 6:17pm
                                   Collapse It just all seems a bit mysterious. Spriggan 181 9 Feb 9, 7:32pm
                                       Collapse Let's leave it here. Arannir 164 8 Feb 9, 8:09pm
                                           Collapse Well, obviously I can't force you to explain. Spriggan 162 7 Feb 9, 8:16pm
                                               Collapse That is why I didn't want to start the whole thing again. Arannir 159 6 Feb 9, 8:22pm
                                                   Collapse It's not for me to suggest. Spriggan 158 5 Feb 9, 8:28pm
                                                       Collapse Again Arannir 150 4 Feb 9, 8:31pm
                                                           Collapse If you want to keep bringing it up, that's fine. Spriggan 154 3 Feb 9, 8:38pm
                                                               Collapse I never did. Arannir 148 1 Feb 9, 8:40pm
                                                                   Thanks Arannir entmaiden 135 0 Feb 9, 9:55pm
                                                               You're made your point entmaiden 139 0 Feb 9, 9:56pm
       Everything varies Elessar 261 0 Feb 9, 3:07pm
       Personally sauget.diblosio 50 0 Feb 11, 2:27pm

  Collapse Why didn't Sauron just go to Gundabad instead of Dol Guldur? boldog 949 23 Feb 8, 9:26am Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       Interesting question... dormouse 500 0 Feb 8, 9:58am
       Collapse It's all about strategics. DanielLB 514 2 Feb 8, 10:13am
           You could I spose also consider it easier to hide... moreorless 438 0 Feb 8, 11:18am
           Could the deciding factor have been that Sauron just liked the place? squiggle 159 0 Feb 9, 5:53am
       Collapse He didn't by choice in the Movies did he? Hamfast Gamgee 403 2 Feb 8, 12:59pm
           No the Nazgul were buried elsewhere, in the High Fells. Spriggan 379 0 Feb 8, 2:05pm
           Tombs in the High Fells. Otaku-sempai 333 0 Feb 8, 4:28pm
       Collapse The Ring MedwedtoBeorn 362 14 Feb 8, 3:34pm
           Collapse It's a bit hard to tell. Spriggan 298 13 Feb 8, 6:41pm
               Collapse Do you mean "lost forever" or destroyed? I think Sauron would know if it was destroyed. Eruonen 290 12 Feb 8, 6:57pm
                   Collapse Seemingly not - hence I say is rather strange. Spriggan 266 11 Feb 8, 7:54pm
                       Collapse That would imply Sauron may not have understood that its destruction would leave him Eruonen 269 10 Feb 8, 7:58pm
                           Collapse It's rather tricky either way - the knowledge of the Ring is not the most tightly plotted element of the books. Spriggan 260 9 Feb 8, 8:22pm
                               Collapse Others have discussed this knot before on other sites and the mystery remains Eruonen 251 8 Feb 8, 8:39pm
                                   Collapse That's quite generous! Spriggan 232 7 Feb 8, 9:20pm
                                       Collapse Note how Gandalf said it - "And this is the dreadful chance, Frodo." Eruonen 207 6 Feb 8, 10:58pm
                                           Collapse I'm not sure what you mean. Spriggan 192 5 Feb 8, 11:17pm
                                               Collapse What I mean is that Gandalf cannot know the mind of Sauron, so when he says Eruonen 169 4 Feb 9, 1:14am
                                                   Collapse I'm still not sure how the "dreadful chance" line Spriggan 127 3 Feb 9, 8:34am
                                                       Collapse It all hinges on what Gandalf could possibly know for certain about the Eruonen 101 2 Feb 9, 3:09pm
                                                           Collapse Sure - with you, to that extent. Spriggan 100 1 Feb 9, 3:40pm
                                                               Too much Old Toby Saruman would say! Eruonen 120 0 Feb 9, 4:05pm
       As others have noted, Dol Guldur occupies a very strategic location. Eruonen 331 0 Feb 8, 5:37pm

  Collapse The key reasons for the switch to a trilogy... moreorless 1312 57 Feb 8, 7:51am Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Collapse The most obvious reason is ... Legolas_Shoehorn 697 2 Feb 8, 9:11am
           For the studio perhaps... moreorless 586 0 Feb 8, 11:24am
           Wow! Lindele 436 0 Feb 8, 5:44pm
       Collapse I think you're absolutely right..... dormouse 637 7 Feb 8, 9:43am
           Collapse Agree about early decision burrahobbit 569 2 Feb 8, 10:18am
               Collapse Well, I don't know..... dormouse 544 1 Feb 8, 10:29am
                   Yes burrahobbit 479 0 Feb 8, 1:46pm
           Collapse Its tough to know for sure... moreorless 519 1 Feb 8, 11:50am
               Well, yes.... dormouse 498 0 Feb 8, 12:32pm
           Agree, dormouse Glorfindela 493 0 Feb 8, 12:30pm
           I think you nailed it// swordwhale 217 0 Feb 10, 1:22am
       Collapse Interesting thoughts moreorless, and I agree with both you and dormouse. Noria 482 1 Feb 8, 1:35pm
           Seconded.// mae govannen 452 0 Feb 8, 1:38pm
       To be honest, I could never understand - Hanzkaz 499 0 Feb 8, 2:29pm
       Collapse Good answer....why not? EomundDaughter 440 1 Feb 8, 3:51pm
           Bomby Thinks he can speak for a... Bombadil 412 0 Feb 8, 4:45pm
       Too much in one film? Otaku-sempai 428 0 Feb 8, 4:37pm
       I think it contributed to orginality of the film trilogy squiggle 350 0 Feb 8, 9:04pm
       Collapse Lets looks at the original statement by PJ Arannir 359 35 Feb 8, 10:14pm
           Totally agree! Thrain II 315 0 Feb 8, 10:28pm
           Collapse What did we get by going two to three Michelle Johnston 273 14 Feb 9, 6:23am
               Collapse Maybe the people you've spoken to..... dormouse 252 13 Feb 9, 9:01am
                   Collapse Deep Fan Commitment V Once Only Michelle Johnston 247 12 Feb 9, 9:18am
                       Collapse Sorry, I should have been more precise.... dormouse 233 11 Feb 9, 9:47am
                           Collapse Dormouse, i'm not so sure squiggle 296 2 Feb 9, 10:35am
                               Collapse You are quite right to look at large scale indicators Spriggan 284 1 Feb 9, 10:41am
                                   Yes. You said what I was trying to say.... dormouse 272 0 Feb 9, 12:06pm
                           We have a bingo :) Elessar 261 0 Feb 9, 5:05pm
                           Collapse Torn View Michelle Johnston 275 6 Feb 9, 5:43pm
                               Collapse Brilliantly put. Arannir 225 5 Feb 10, 9:46am
                                   Collapse Spot On Michelle Johnston 187 1 Feb 10, 5:49pm
                                       Some thoughts Elessar 152 0 Feb 10, 8:08pm
                                   Collapse What's your issue with the DG stuff? Elessar 150 2 Feb 10, 8:09pm
                                       Collapse It is a mix Arannir 150 1 Feb 10, 8:25pm
                                           Got ya. Elessar 136 0 Feb 10, 8:33pm
           Collapse Honestly to me this is more how the Hobbit films could have gone wrong... moreorless 175 18 Feb 10, 7:47pm
               Collapse Excessive fanservice Arannir 165 17 Feb 10, 7:58pm
                   Collapse You mention quite a few areas that I think would be verging on that... moreorless 133 16 Feb 10, 9:31pm
                       Hm Arannir 126 0 Feb 10, 9:49pm
                       Collapse What we actually received as a result of moving from two to three Michelle Johnston 103 14 Feb 11, 12:27am
                           Collapse There seems to a be a good deal of assumption there but.. moreorless 92 13 Feb 11, 4:11am
                               Thanks for your response Michelle Johnston 77 0 Feb 11, 7:08am
                               Collapse Personal Gripes Michelle Johnston 76 9 Feb 11, 7:20am
                                   Collapse The point was really that I think there quite limited in their outlook moreorless 74 8 Feb 11, 7:38am
                                       Collapse The Theatrical Cut For Two Films Michelle Johnston 48 7 Feb 11, 4:57pm
                                           Collapse I'm afraid I really can't see the Hobbit working without Bagend/The Shire... moreorless 79 6 Feb 11, 5:58pm
                                               Collapse Don't forget its a prequel Michelle Johnston 70 1 Feb 11, 7:24pm
                                                   I'm sure he could have done something but.. moreorless 66 0 Feb 11, 7:51pm
                                               Collapse Three film Three Act Michelle Johnston 67 3 Feb 11, 7:27pm
                                                   Collapse I'm sure a two film script would have "worked" to some degree moreorless 61 2 Feb 11, 8:18pm
                                                       Collapse The LOSS in DOS Michelle Johnston 53 1 Feb 12, 4:36am
                                                           What I think we see is a shift in focus... moreorless 49 0 Feb 12, 8:25am
                               Collapse Bard benefitting from Alfrid Michelle Johnston 75 1 Feb 11, 7:31am
                                   Thats question I spose... moreorless 70 0 Feb 11, 8:55am
       Could it be pressure from WB? Kilidoescartwheels 295 0 Feb 9, 2:15am
       To add what amounted to sauget.diblosio 61 0 Feb 11, 2:04pm
       To Finish Michelle Johnston 42 0 Feb 12, 6:15am

  Collapse What was your favourite,practical scenery Thorins_apprentice 657 32 Feb 8, 7:10am Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       Dan Henna said they made over 100 sets Bombadil 380 0 Feb 8, 7:44am
       Collapse Can't beat Hobbiton.// Elizabeth 325 1 Feb 8, 8:01am
           Seconded. // BlackFox 295 0 Feb 8, 8:46am
       I dont really understand this.... Konrad S 346 0 Feb 8, 8:57am
       If you mean actual sets..... dormouse 328 0 Feb 8, 9:31am
       Collapse I'm crazy enough Eruwestial37 306 1 Feb 8, 10:12am
           bunny sled swordwhale 72 0 Feb 10, 1:24am
       OOOO i forgot Rhosgobel! Konrad S 272 0 Feb 8, 11:50am
       Collapse Not sure what is meant by 'practical scenery' Glorfindela 289 1 Feb 8, 12:27pm
           U take same big sencery that i´m Konrad S 267 0 Feb 8, 12:55pm
       Collapse What is "practical scenery"?// arithmancer 236 5 Feb 8, 2:29pm
           Collapse I'm assuming the OP means actual physical sets, not akmost exclusively CGI ones... Eleniel 204 1 Feb 8, 5:05pm
               Or locations? arithmancer 184 0 Feb 8, 5:58pm
           Collapse As a Former Scenery Painter (over 30 Shows) Bombadil 218 2 Feb 8, 5:09pm
             Collapse Sorry TA... is a Aussie...So Sorry Bombadil 194 1 Feb 8, 5:30pm
                   hee hee heee swordwhale 79 0 Feb 10, 1:27am
       Hobbiton, of course, but also.. Kirly 189 0 Feb 8, 6:20pm
       Collapse Hmmm... Avnar 164 1 Feb 8, 10:34pm
           You are correct Starling 109 0 Feb 9, 5:58am
       Hm Arannir 151 0 Feb 8, 10:40pm
       Hm... Thrain II 144 0 Feb 8, 10:43pm
       Collapse A few of my favorites Riven Delve 158 4 Feb 8, 10:51pm
           Collapse Oh, I forgot the giant lupines! Kirly 136 2 Feb 8, 11:13pm
               Collapse Lupins are nice in gardens, but Starling 104 1 Feb 9, 5:55am
                   I found that article about lupins very interesting - Greenwood Hobbit 45 0 Feb 10, 5:44pm
           Oh yes... dormouse 131 0 Feb 8, 11:16pm
       Collapse Hmm CathrineB 87 1 Feb 9, 9:53am
           Good ones I forgot! Riven Delve 102 0 Feb 9, 5:26pm
       Hobbiton for me. I want to live there. // Nuradar 53 0 Feb 10, 3:58pm
       The Prancing Pony Loresilme 30 0 Feb 11, 12:27am
       Bag End Kim 28 0 Feb 11, 3:56am
       Kind of sad sauget.diblosio 28 0 Feb 11, 1:56pm

  Collapse About the Hobbiton epilogue/prologue Hamfast Gamgee 629 4 Feb 8, 12:05am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Yes Kim 336 3 Feb 8, 12:21am
         Collapse Here is one quote that would help you Bombadil 335 2 Feb 8, 12:52am
               Collapse Belladonna Lonely Mountain 133 1 Feb 8, 7:25pm
                   You are Correct..// Bombadil 130 0 Feb 8, 7:55pm

  Collapse Vote in the SFX Awards Kim 315 9 Feb 7, 9:51pm Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       DONE..Thankss Kim!// Bombadil 130 0 Feb 7, 11:06pm
       Thanks, Kim! Brethil 130 0 Feb 7, 11:41pm
       Thank you much! demnation 120 0 Feb 8, 2:13am
       Collapse The only M-E vote I did was Shadow of Mordor... AshNazg 92 3 Feb 8, 1:33pm
           Collapse In your opinion, perhaps.... // dormouse 81 1 Feb 8, 2:09pm
               Sorry, I keep forgetting to say 'in my opinion' after every post I make... AshNazg 62 0 Feb 8, 10:07pm
           Even though i liked Shadow of Mordor sauget.diblosio 24 0 Feb 11, 1:49pm
       2014 was a great movie year. Arannir 58 0 Feb 8, 10:33pm
       Thanx for posting. Thrain II 66 0 Feb 8, 10:45pm

  Collapse Is Legolas... a CGI double in "Shores of the Long Lake"? Annatar598 1070 14 Feb 7, 12:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by swordwhale)
       My thoughts exactly! Arandir 545 0 Feb 7, 2:01pm
       No way is he fully CG... Bofur01 516 0 Feb 7, 2:45pm
       Collapse I didn't notice anything odd about him // dormouse 458 2 Feb 7, 2:46pm
           Collapse I didn't either KingTurgon 424 1 Feb 7, 3:10pm
               Agreed, it looked Normal// Bombadil 401 0 Feb 7, 3:25pm
       I think they CG "enhanced" him Beorn's Bees 463 0 Feb 7, 4:22pm
       I would say yes Glorfindela 402 0 Feb 7, 4:59pm
       IMO you are not wrong Avandel 396 0 Feb 7, 5:23pm
       No, of course not.// Aragorn the Elfstone 347 0 Feb 7, 5:35pm
       It looks wrong somehow... painjoiker 357 0 Feb 7, 6:51pm
       Indeed ... Legolas_Shoehorn 326 0 Feb 7, 8:15pm
       Yes he did look better in that shot SafeUnderHill 106 0 Feb 9, 11:19am
       Yeah. Arannir 96 0 Feb 9, 1:41pm
       now I have to wait for the DVD to look again.....// swordwhale 70 0 Feb 10, 1:15am

  Collapse CHOW: DOS TE Inside Information Hobbity Hobbit 673 16 Feb 7, 2:28am Jump to last post in thread (by Riven Delve)
       Unfortunately Hobbity Hobbit 334 0 Feb 7, 2:45am
       1, 2, 3 & 6... Bladerunner 296 0 Feb 7, 3:12am
       My answers arithmancer 285 0 Feb 7, 3:51am
       Collapse Mine: Glorfindela 191 2 Feb 7, 12:37pm
           Collapse The "bell" arithmancer 170 1 Feb 7, 3:13pm
               Thanks very much, arithmancer Glorfindela 152 0 Feb 7, 4:02pm
       Sorry Hobbity Hobbit 145 0 Feb 7, 5:14pm
       Dragon! Kim 134 0 Feb 7, 7:17pm
       Collapse Hello Dragon Riven Delve 120 6 Feb 7, 8:50pm
           Collapse Maybe he's just a mind reader .... Spriggan 98 1 Feb 7, 10:50pm
               Yes, there are definitely hints of that Riven Delve 96 0 Feb 7, 10:59pm
           Collapse Barrel Rider arithmancer 91 3 Feb 8, 2:50am
               Collapse I see what you mean, arithmancer Riven Delve 53 2 Feb 8, 6:21pm
                   Collapse Sniffing arithmancer 46 1 Feb 8, 8:00pm
                       I'd be interested to see what you think Riven Delve 54 0 Feb 8, 8:52pm
       My responses Noria 110 0 Feb 7, 9:30pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 962 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.