Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 816 (301017 posts in 12240 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 816 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Nazgul in the upcoming film boldog 1419 32 Aug 6, 9:50am Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       I hope Spalko 719 0 Aug 6, 9:54am
       CGI wraiths or real in black... Arannir 703 0 Aug 6, 9:56am
       The black hooded look wouldn't really make sense Shagrat 720 0 Aug 6, 9:57am
       Collapse They will be cgi Bishop 635 2 Aug 6, 11:30am
           Collapse don't know about that MouthofSauron 191 1 Aug 7, 5:43am
               They might still look like the men king they were Rickster 97 0 Aug 8, 12:13am
       Collapse Definitely CGI LordotRings93 586 10 Aug 6, 12:53pm
           Collapse Hold up ... DanielLB 567 9 Aug 6, 1:07pm
               Collapse All evidence points to it Bishop 421 7 Aug 6, 5:58pm
                   Collapse Well, to be fair... Salmacis81 396 1 Aug 6, 6:08pm
                       Yes, you're right Bishop 372 0 Aug 6, 6:18pm
                   Collapse As would I. DanielLB 371 4 Aug 6, 6:17pm
                       Yes agree... Salmacis81 363 0 Aug 6, 6:19pm
                       Collapse Post deleted by Bishop Bishop 359 2 Aug 6, 6:21pm
                           Collapse You'll have to remind me in 4 months time. ;-) / DanielLB 342 1 Aug 6, 6:29pm
                               I deleted my post by accident.... Bishop 342 0 Aug 6, 6:34pm
               He did do it with certain Orcs... Salmacis81 398 0 Aug 6, 6:03pm
       Collapse I'd like to see them in their wraith-world look burgahobbit 528 6 Aug 6, 1:12pm
           Collapse Well not necessarily - it may have to do with who is seeing them. Spriggan 516 5 Aug 6, 1:21pm
               Good point! burgahobbit 498 0 Aug 6, 1:24pm
               Collapse Without robes, they would have neither shape nor form. DanielLB 505 1 Aug 6, 1:30pm
                   Drop of the black breath? Spriggan 489 0 Aug 6, 1:51pm
               Collapse Weathertop ambush Aitieuriskon 64 1 Aug 8, 3:25pm
                   They didn't BlackFox 53 0 Aug 8, 4:54pm
       Don't count on them even being in the movie... sycorax82 303 0 Aug 6, 10:51pm
       Collapse Ringwraiths Glorfindela 276 6 Aug 6, 11:34pm
           Collapse I don't think they were CGI in LOTR Bishop 244 5 Aug 7, 1:18am
               Collapse I think Glorfindela 190 4 Aug 7, 8:49am
                   Collapse I believe they were much more terrifying in fotr boldog 193 3 Aug 7, 9:29am
                       Collapse I disagree Glorfindela 178 2 Aug 7, 10:13am
                           Do any of you have the movie "The Frighteners"? Bombadil 158 0 Aug 7, 3:35pm
                           But I'm curous.. Bishop 100 0 Aug 7, 10:41pm

  Collapse Is it possible that Thorin has a spouse/lover? boldog 899 14 Aug 6, 9:35am Jump to last post in thread (by Riven Delve)
       Collapse Sounds suspiciously a lot like Shrek 3 ... DanielLB 436 2 Aug 6, 9:47am
         O, get ogre it already. // cats16 359 0 Aug 6, 10:17am
           You forgot about Radagast (Merlin) FaramirAndEowynMorningStar 155 0 Aug 6, 11:34pm
       According to the Appendices in LOTR, Thorin was unmarried Elarie 393 0 Aug 6, 12:16pm
       ... minnymomo 341 0 Aug 6, 12:41pm
       Collapse In the movieverse Riven Delve 359 2 Aug 6, 1:02pm
           Collapse I put this in my back story... Queen of Erebor 187 1 Aug 6, 10:06pm
               That sounds plausible Riven Delve 166 0 Aug 6, 11:49pm
       Richard and Philippa used to discuss about this. ninquelote 369 0 Aug 6, 1:38pm
       Collapse Certainly Glorfindela 277 4 Aug 6, 5:09pm
           Collapse At this point, I think we should be asking... Elarie 216 2 Aug 6, 9:23pm
               Collapse I'm intrigued - why Tuesdays? dormouse 192 1 Aug 6, 10:14pm
                   Hmmm,,,well, Elarie 177 0 Aug 6, 10:49pm
           Wait, what? Kim 191 0 Aug 6, 10:50pm

  Collapse How would you like to see the Battle of Dol Guldur play out? Boromir Stark 888 40 Aug 6, 8:23am Jump to last post in thread (by Girdle of Melian)
       Collapse I'd like it to surprise me (in a good way!) dormouse 537 1 Aug 6, 8:40am
           Me too Ham_Sammy 386 0 Aug 6, 1:45pm
       I agree with doormouse Spalko 483 0 Aug 6, 9:03am
       Collapse So many possibilities... Arannir 481 2 Aug 6, 9:21am
           I would love to see a rendition of the weathertop scene from FOTR boldog 466 0 Aug 6, 9:44am
           I want to be surprised, yes Spalko 444 0 Aug 6, 9:51am
       Collapse Eh... Salmacis81 358 30 Aug 6, 6:16pm
           Collapse I'd be all for a screen death for Spriggan 352 1 Aug 6, 6:55pm
               Maybe... Ereinion Nénharma 311 0 Aug 6, 9:21pm
           Collapse Agree with this Glorfindela 282 27 Aug 6, 11:40pm
               Collapse Something we both agree on! :D Imladris18 207 26 Aug 7, 4:59pm
                   Collapse I guess Glorfindela 189 25 Aug 7, 5:29pm
                       Collapse Ahem. Or are nothing like that pen portrait Spriggan 177 24 Aug 7, 6:04pm
                           Collapse This is exactly the kind of writing off that bothers me, lol. Imladris18 166 10 Aug 7, 6:57pm
                               Collapse I'm afraid I don't understand the "principle" Spriggan 156 8 Aug 7, 7:24pm
                                   Collapse The principle of being an adaptation. Imladris18 138 7 Aug 7, 8:04pm
                                       Collapse Not one I follow, myself. Spriggan 126 6 Aug 7, 8:22pm
                                           Collapse What it boils down to, I suppose: Imladris18 119 5 Aug 7, 9:45pm
                                               Collapse I hope you don't mind that I keep sharing my thoughts. Spriggan 113 4 Aug 7, 10:22pm
                                                   Collapse No, of course not! Imladris18 101 3 Aug 7, 11:21pm
                                                       Collapse Ah yes, but being nice to characters Spriggan 131 2 Aug 8, 10:10am
                                                           Collapse Well, right. Imladris18 111 1 Aug 8, 2:52pm
                                                               Ha well that's very true. Spriggan 91 0 Aug 8, 5:55pm
                               Again Glorfindela 146 0 Aug 7, 7:29pm
                           Collapse I think the issue is just that... Salmacis81 89 12 Aug 8, 6:58pm
                               Collapse Not something that's an issue for me Spriggan 82 11 Aug 8, 7:07pm
                                   Collapse Well I guess it's just a matter of... Salmacis81 80 10 Aug 8, 7:14pm
                                       Collapse Absolutely. Spriggan 82 9 Aug 8, 7:51pm
                                           Collapse ... Salmacis81 72 1 Aug 8, 10:15pm
                                               I think that's what I was saying, basically. Spriggan 68 0 Aug 8, 10:26pm
                                           Collapse ??? sauget.diblosio 61 6 Aug 9, 3:31am
                                               Collapse How so? Spriggan 53 5 Aug 9, 9:47am
                                                   Collapse Ah, ha! Otaku-sempai 36 2 Aug 9, 6:50pm
                                                       Collapse Ah, ha, ha Spriggan 29 1 Aug 9, 7:52pm
                                                           I am not sure.... Girdle of Melian 15 0 Aug 12, 6:18pm
                                                   Collapse I'm sorry, sauget.diblosio 34 1 Aug 9, 7:22pm
                                                       Oh that falls under the word "altered" Spriggan 29 0 Aug 9, 7:32pm
       Radagast needs his moment Mad Hatter of Middle-Earth 302 0 Aug 6, 10:43pm
       Collapse music Gandy 110 1 Aug 7, 10:03pm
           *nods* Spalko 79 0 Aug 8, 8:07am

  Collapse Dragon Sickness and the effect on Thorin´s voice Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 537 4 Aug 6, 8:20am Jump to last post in thread (by Gandy)
       Collapse I thought that in the English version... dormouse 324 1 Aug 6, 8:41am
           And that is lovely, isnt it? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 256 0 Aug 6, 11:08am
       I don't think 'they' have altered Thorin's voice glor 253 0 Aug 6, 11:53am
       2 voices Gandy 79 0 Aug 7, 9:03pm

  Collapse A long and detailed interview with John Howe Sildarion~Valenar 666 2 Aug 6, 4:48am Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       Making a link... smtfhw 317 0 Aug 6, 7:47am
       Great read, sauget.diblosio 25 0 Aug 9, 9:20am

  Collapse Any more blogs? AncalagontheBlack 563 2 Aug 6, 2:22am Jump to last post in thread (by SafeUnderHill)
       I imagine... Arannir 276 0 Aug 6, 7:31am
       My guess SafeUnderHill 195 0 Aug 6, 10:55am

  Collapse The strange location on the trailer Númenórean 1017 15 Aug 6, 1:47am Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Yes, that's likely the old dwarven guardpost on Ravenhill. *story spoilers* Silverlode 574 0 Aug 6, 1:55am
       Collapse It looks like the big 'Town Hall' Dale structure behind Bilbo Seaber 337 1 Aug 6, 8:36am
           Yes... but it is how one would see it from Ravenhill. Arannir 323 0 Aug 6, 9:22am
       Collapse Is it certain they're all in the same place? dormouse 310 11 Aug 6, 10:54am
           The openings and stairs... Arannir 292 0 Aug 6, 11:14am
           Collapse All in the same place Númenórean 255 3 Aug 6, 12:45pm
               Collapse Ah - OK, thanks.... dormouse 236 2 Aug 6, 12:54pm
                   Collapse There might be more than one raven? Spriggan 229 1 Aug 6, 12:58pm
                       True! // dormouse 210 0 Aug 6, 1:17pm
           Collapse Eh? Glorfindela 97 5 Aug 7, 10:51pm
               Collapse Because it's about where Raven Hill would be in the book Cirashala 91 2 Aug 8, 12:15am
                   Collapse You and me both Earl 83 1 Aug 8, 1:28am
                       I visualized it Cirashala 71 0 Aug 8, 4:14am
               Collapse Oh - sorry. Not a real raven... dormouse 52 1 Aug 8, 11:18am
                   Or maybe I am wrong Glorfindela 49 0 Aug 8, 11:51am

  Collapse Pre-order The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Extended Edition News from Bree 840 26 Aug 6, 1:40am Jump to last post in thread (by KingTurgon)
       Collapse Judging by the prices TheHutt 471 8 Aug 6, 8:07am
           Collapse No DVD? burgahobbit 405 7 Aug 6, 12:42pm
               Collapse There will be a 5 disc DVD set LordotRings93 425 2 Aug 6, 12:54pm
                   Collapse Okay thank you both for setting my worries to rest burgahobbit 383 1 Aug 6, 1:06pm
                       Yep. BalrogTrainer 369 0 Aug 6, 2:10pm
               Collapse The Australians announced their DVD edition... TheHutt 427 3 Aug 6, 12:57pm
                   That looks like a similar style of packaging... dormouse 406 0 Aug 6, 1:01pm
                   Yay - is that the Arkenstone symbol from inside the secret door? // Eleniel 363 0 Aug 6, 3:05pm
                   Nice colour for that Australian box Glorfindela 292 0 Aug 6, 10:50pm
     Collapse Well I'm disappointed re the artwork - sigh Avandel 279 1 Aug 7, 2:43am
           The poster with the smoke-Smaug was much better, indeed. Arannir 220 0 Aug 7, 11:29am
       Collapse Spanish editions Vila 241 4 Aug 7, 10:19am
           Collapse Acorn? Arannir 221 2 Aug 7, 11:18am
               Collapse The Spanish yes Vila 202 1 Aug 7, 12:19pm
                   Also. TheHutt 190 0 Aug 7, 1:31pm
           I wonder Glorfindela 178 0 Aug 7, 2:32pm
       I can't see bilbo Jettorex 161 0 Aug 7, 3:49pm
       Hope the dwarven tapestry is integrated into the box art QuackingTroll 137 0 Aug 7, 6:07pm
       Collapse I have sickness Elessar 131 4 Aug 7, 6:31pm
           Collapse No no no... you have a collection! ;-) // dormouse 113 3 Aug 7, 7:04pm
               Collapse This is true. :-D Elessar 106 2 Aug 7, 7:10pm
                   Collapse No harm in patting yourself on the back now and then.... dormouse 96 1 Aug 7, 7:30pm
                       I do enjoy sharing Elessar 94 0 Aug 7, 7:38pm
       Collapse ... Faleel 77 2 Aug 7, 8:21pm
           Collapse I'm glad it's not "purple"... Queen of Erebor 54 1 Aug 7, 11:08pm
               See, I liked the purple the extended soundtrack used KingTurgon 19 0 Aug 12, 4:57pm

  Collapse Thread Locked Very interesting read that changes the way I see things in LOTR and The Hobbit JamesPaganini 894 12 Aug 5, 11:27pm Jump to last post in thread (by entmaiden)
       Thread Locked Fun to read SafeUnderHill 419 0 Aug 5, 11:31pm
       Collapse Thread Locked I'm going to post the rebuttal I gave to this earlier. Elutherian 463 1 Aug 5, 11:34pm
           Thread Locked Yes... dormouse 184 0 Aug 6, 8:53am
       Collapse Thread Locked Why should it change your view? Spriggan 397 2 Aug 5, 11:37pm
           Collapse Thread Locked What were his views on the eagles? QuackingTroll 352 1 Aug 6, 12:22am
               Thread Locked Well, they are published and still in print I think. Spriggan 348 0 Aug 6, 12:29am
       Collapse Thread Locked It's a funny idea... dreamflower 333 3 Aug 6, 1:03am
           Collapse Thread Locked Sparingly. Arannir 194 2 Aug 6, 8:09am
               Collapse Thread Locked That moth! dreamflower 133 1 Aug 6, 1:07pm
                   Thread Locked Don't pander to the complainers. FrostyLemon 116 0 Aug 6, 1:37pm
       Thread Locked No... it does not change anything for me. Arannir 201 0 Aug 6, 8:05am
       Thread Locked Thanks - also on the Movie:LOTR board// entmaiden 116 0 Aug 6, 1:46pm

  Collapse DOS SEE: Now what will that Collector's statue be?.. TheHutt 756 25 Aug 5, 9:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elessar)
       Collapse Sneaking suspicion Dcole4 457 17 Aug 5, 10:24pm
           Collapse I hope not... TheHutt 406 15 Aug 5, 10:29pm
               Collapse Well, I wouldn't mind if it was... Eleniel 292 14 Aug 6, 6:56am
                   Collapse Erm.... Shagrat 236 13 Aug 6, 5:05pm
                       That looks horrible. Arannir 224 0 Aug 6, 5:12pm
                       Tasteful. Spriggan 195 0 Aug 6, 5:25pm
                       Own thread. Arannir 187 0 Aug 6, 5:32pm
                       Collapse That will fit nicely with the AUJ Gollum/Bilbo statue. DanielLB 172 4 Aug 6, 5:52pm
                           Unfortunately... Arannir 166 0 Aug 6, 6:02pm
                           Collapse I missed it :( Elessar 91 2 Aug 6, 7:43pm
                               Collapse I made a thread about it. tsmith675 85 1 Aug 6, 7:51pm
                                   Just saw it Elessar 65 0 Aug 6, 8:01pm
                       They dropped the ball on this one, in my opinion. tsmith675 148 0 Aug 6, 6:27pm
                       Collapse Oh Good Grief! Eleniel 148 1 Aug 6, 6:27pm
                           They cannot TheHutt 106 0 Aug 6, 7:15pm
                       Bilbo looks like a goblin! There&ThereAgain 123 0 Aug 6, 6:48pm
                       Damn.. TheHutt 103 0 Aug 6, 7:16pm
           I think that's unlikely... Earl 389 0 Aug 5, 10:42pm
       How would a Dol Guldur environment look? QuackingTroll 386 0 Aug 5, 10:52pm
       Collapse I'm wondering that myself. Elessar 357 2 Aug 5, 11:24pm
           Collapse Figurative perhaps? Defiant 333 1 Aug 6, 12:19am
               I could see that Elessar 318 0 Aug 6, 12:50am
       Collapse When did we find out last year? tsmith675 332 1 Aug 6, 12:32am
           It was listed in Germany first.. TheHutt 289 0 Aug 6, 6:01am
       I'd like ... DanielLB 294 0 Aug 6, 6:14am

  Collapse Is anyone attached to the dwarves at this point? I'm not... CaptainObvious 1736 96 Aug 5, 6:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elciryamo)
       They still got more lines than Tolkien gave them. Crunchable Birdses 867 0 Aug 5, 6:42pm
       Well, let's put it this way, i'm more attached to the movie dwarves than the ones in the book Estel78 846 0 Aug 5, 6:50pm
       There have been plenty of lines with the other 11 dwarves Subaruman 820 0 Aug 5, 6:52pm
       Yes.// tsmith675 744 0 Aug 5, 6:55pm
       Collapse I would be pleased... architecthis 802 1 Aug 5, 6:59pm
           No! Bofur01 743 0 Aug 5, 7:07pm
       Yes. DanielLB 764 0 Aug 5, 7:00pm
       Collapse Gonna have to agree with everyone else Lindele 835 11 Aug 5, 7:01pm
           Collapse Why is it... architecthis 788 7 Aug 5, 7:03pm
               Collapse Can't speak for anyone else.... dormouse 751 2 Aug 5, 7:19pm
                   Collapse ... architecthis 708 1 Aug 5, 7:24pm
                       Yeah... Salmacis81 675 0 Aug 5, 7:34pm
               Collapse It isn't necessarily a criticism of the book Noria 708 1 Aug 5, 7:20pm
                   It's a justification, if not a criticism architecthis 685 0 Aug 5, 7:26pm
               Collapse To SafeUnderHill 607 1 Aug 5, 8:00pm
                   Yes, and proud of it... Queen of Erebor 327 0 Aug 5, 10:53pm
           Collapse Lindele CaptainObvious 321 2 Aug 6, 8:52am
               Collapse But I thought you said you didn't know the individual names..... dormouse 316 1 Aug 6, 9:09am
                   The answer will shock you. I identified them correctly... CaptainObvious 338 0 Aug 6, 9:32am
       How is Tauriel not a real character? There&ThereAgain 743 0 Aug 5, 7:05pm
       Yes, me dormouse 723 0 Aug 5, 7:12pm
       Me, too Elanor of Rohan 685 0 Aug 5, 7:21pm
       Yes, I'm attached Riven Delve 686 0 Aug 5, 7:27pm
       I agree with you... Salmacis81 679 0 Aug 5, 7:31pm
       In Pixar's 'UP' I really connected to the couple at the start - And they didn't speak! QuackingTroll 659 0 Aug 5, 7:36pm
       I think they did a good job. Arannir 653 0 Aug 5, 7:37pm
       Collapse We're just good friends..../ Darkstone 624 2 Aug 5, 7:52pm
           Thanks for the chuckle! // Voronwë_the_Faithful 334 0 Aug 5, 9:43pm
           Darkstone, you're classic! :-) // dormouse 326 0 Aug 5, 9:54pm
       I agree NamoMandos 614 0 Aug 5, 7:58pm
       You know Thranderz 412 0 Aug 5, 8:05pm
       Collapse Yes, definitely Elarie 382 1 Aug 5, 9:26pm
         I'm just going to ditto, ditto, ditto Elarie's post - luv these guys!!! Avandel 342 0 Aug 5, 10:06pm
       Yes marillaraina 357 0 Aug 5, 9:34pm
       Collapse It's a bit of an odd premise, really. Spriggan 377 22 Aug 5, 9:42pm
           Collapse Why is it weird? Bishop 313 6 Aug 5, 11:04pm
               Collapse That's why they are goblins, rather than humans. Spriggan 301 4 Aug 5, 11:20pm
                   Collapse I agree Bishop 292 1 Aug 5, 11:30pm
                       Sure. Spriggan 281 0 Aug 5, 11:47pm
                   Collapse Nailed it.. Elanor of Rohan 214 1 Aug 6, 12:47pm
                       Agree - nice Avandel 157 0 Aug 6, 3:52pm
               They do have families. CaptainObvious 297 0 Aug 5, 11:28pm
           Collapse Spriggan... CaptainObvious 307 14 Aug 5, 11:39pm
               Collapse Not at all. Spriggan 292 12 Aug 5, 11:48pm
                   Collapse Spriggan CaptainObvious 325 11 Aug 6, 8:39am
                       Collapse Ultimately up to you, I suppose. Spriggan 294 10 Aug 6, 9:39am
                           This.... dormouse 284 0 Aug 6, 9:43am
                           Collapse Spriggan, Spriggan, Spriggan... CaptainObvious 284 8 Aug 6, 10:04am
                               Collapse I don't think I would agree with that Spriggan 271 7 Aug 6, 10:28am
                                   Collapse I appreciate your input. CaptainObvious 259 6 Aug 6, 10:40am
                                       Collapse Interesting (or perhaps not) little analysis of line numbers. Spriggan 241 5 Aug 6, 11:53am
                                           Collapse Here's a fascinating graph from Reddit. CaptainObvious 230 2 Aug 6, 12:27pm
                                               Useful thanks. Spriggan 207 0 Aug 6, 12:50pm
                                               Here's one for DoS... sauget.diblosio 49 0 Aug 9, 6:15pm
                                           Collapse Number of lines is a very poor indicator, I'd say... dormouse 199 1 Aug 6, 1:16pm
                                               Yes... Arannir 191 0 Aug 6, 1:31pm
               13th Warrior Kilidoescartwheels 173 0 Aug 6, 3:21pm
       Yes, I care about all of them! VeArkenstone 343 0 Aug 5, 10:18pm
       Nope Avnar 286 0 Aug 6, 12:09am
       Collapse Valid criticism, wrong reason (in my view) Kendalf 314 3 Aug 6, 12:19am
           Collapse I can see your point but Avandel 257 1 Aug 6, 3:48am
               Invulnerability. glor 248 0 Aug 6, 11:41am
           I disagree I think it comes down much more to a lack of drama moreorless 293 0 Aug 6, 7:04pm
       Collapse Are men and women reacting to the dwarves differently? Elarie 302 16 Aug 6, 1:05am
           Collapse Didn't think about it but it raises an interesting topic IMO Avandel 265 14 Aug 6, 3:28am
               Collapse I'm not comfortable with generalizations... Aragorn the Elfstone 255 13 Aug 6, 3:49am
                   Collapse I happen to agree Elciryamo 254 12 Aug 6, 4:10am
                       Collapse Aw thanks sweetheart! :D Cirashala 301 11 Aug 6, 8:21pm
                           Collapse Wow, Cirashala. CaptainObvious 242 5 Aug 7, 1:50am
                               Collapse I think the ability to emotionally connect to a character varies from person to person Cirashala 223 4 Aug 7, 5:16am
                                   Collapse Still... CaptainObvious 124 3 Aug 8, 8:38am
                                       He has done that with so many of us Elessar 112 0 Aug 8, 1:47pm
                                       I second what Elessar says... dormouse 112 0 Aug 8, 2:23pm
                                       But, different personalities respond differently Elciryamo 31 0 Aug 11, 3:54am
                           Collapse Pretty Spot On Analysis. fiveforchaos 232 1 Aug 7, 2:25am
                               I wouldn't necessarily call myself a fan girl Cirashala 223 0 Aug 7, 4:55am
                           Collapse Very, very impressive analysis Cirashala ltnjmy 98 1 Aug 8, 5:34pm
                               thanks! Cirashala 82 0 Aug 9, 12:12am
                           Wow, well done! Na Vedui 32 0 Aug 10, 10:01pm
           Well, I'm female, and I totally agree with what Kendalf just posted above... Eleniel 226 0 Aug 6, 7:08am
       Yep. // cats16 237 0 Aug 6, 3:33am
       Collapse Only one redgiraffe 356 2 Aug 6, 8:14am
           I am really not sure... Arannir 295 0 Aug 6, 10:07am
           You hit the nail on the head, red giraffe. NamoMandos 189 0 Aug 6, 2:19pm
       Really the way to avoid the criticism would have been to cut back on the number of Dwarves in the movies Noria 210 0 Aug 6, 1:05pm
       The thing is, why should we care? greenbalrog 204 0 Aug 6, 2:21pm
       Strange question Kilidoescartwheels 185 0 Aug 6, 3:13pm
       Poor hobbits Axeman21 165 0 Aug 6, 4:16pm
       Collapse Movies this complex are worth some extra effort Elarie 329 4 Aug 6, 5:11pm
           Collapse I think extra effort was put in every scene Elciryamo 229 3 Aug 7, 5:04am
               Collapse Extra effort Elarie 183 2 Aug 7, 12:49pm
                   pretty confident he meant extra effort on the part of the cast Cirashala 145 0 Aug 7, 11:22pm
                   I misunderstood and for that, I apologize Elciryamo 134 0 Aug 8, 4:20am
       Of course! Elessar 277 0 Aug 6, 8:33pm
       no, only to the elfs Rickster 148 0 Aug 8, 12:16am
       I do like some of them. sauget.diblosio 77 0 Aug 9, 10:53am

  Hobbit DOS SEE Preorder up on Amazon.de! TheHutt 446 0 Aug 5, 6:01pm Jump to last post in thread (by TheHutt)

  Collapse The Portrait of Bilbo in AUJ SGH9564 722 24 Aug 5, 5:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by Lurker in the Mirk)
       Collapse Daniel Reeve confirmed who drew the picture of (young) Bilbo last year. DanielLB 437 3 Aug 5, 6:56pm
           Collapse My Thanks SGH9564 343 2 Aug 5, 7:15pm
               Hey, no problem! DanielLB 307 0 Aug 5, 7:41pm
               I'm glad you brought it up Ham_Sammy 257 0 Aug 5, 9:44pm
       Collapse Daniel Reeve... TheHutt 320 1 Aug 5, 8:01pm
         An OLD TRIVA ...answer & source? Bombadil 307 0 Aug 5, 8:30pm
       Collapse I have one Elessar 246 16 Aug 5, 11:29pm
         Collapse TIS Possible...thaa-at... DURIn?.ing these FINAL.. Bombadil 209 2 Aug 6, 2:14am
               I'm sure I'll be emotional. Elessar 201 0 Aug 6, 2:26am
               Yes, I'm quite sure of it Kim 196 0 Aug 6, 3:04am
           Collapse I just showed my Redbook grammaboodawg 204 12 Aug 6, 4:39am
             This has been written about?.. .. ... ... Bombadil 165 0 Aug 6, 10:15am
               Collapse Nice! Elessar 154 10 Aug 6, 11:17am
                   Collapse Book? // dormouse 130 9 Aug 6, 2:44pm
                       Collapse It's a custom Elessar 109 8 Aug 6, 6:25pm
                           Collapse Could you send it to me too? Eruclauron 100 1 Aug 6, 6:37pm
                               I sure can. :) Elessar 90 0 Aug 6, 7:00pm
                           Collapse Yes please... dormouse 96 5 Aug 6, 6:42pm
                               It's fantastic! Elessar 89 0 Aug 6, 7:01pm
                               Collapse As a suggestion ... DanielLB 87 3 Aug 6, 7:07pm
                                   Collapse Would you be interested, Daniel? dormouse 64 2 Aug 6, 10:17pm
                                       Collapse It's a thumbs up from me. DanielLB 56 1 Aug 7, 1:14am
                                           I hope you all can Elessar 56 0 Aug 7, 1:16am
       Enjoying the discussion... Lurker in the Mirk 30 0 Aug 7, 3:35pm

  Collapse How did Smaug know? I mean, how did he know for sure? greenbalrog 715 12 Aug 5, 2:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by Rickster)
       He guessed from Bilbo calling himself Barrel Rider. Boromir Stark 350 0 Aug 5, 2:44pm
       Collapse From what I remember from the book shadowdog 341 2 Aug 5, 3:09pm
           Collapse Ok, but still... greenbalrog 271 1 Aug 5, 4:04pm
               True shadowdog 223 0 Aug 5, 4:36pm
       Collapse Yes, it's the barrels. This from the book: dormouse 315 1 Aug 5, 3:13pm
           Thanks for the quote greenbalrog 254 0 Aug 5, 4:02pm
       doesn't Smaug mention Bilbo smelling like Laketown too? FrogmortonJustice65 266 0 Aug 5, 3:42pm
       Collapse I don't believe that he "suddenly" knew when they entered the Hall Sebastian the Hedgehog 260 3 Aug 5, 4:01pm
           Collapse You know, I got the opposite impression myself greenbalrog 254 2 Aug 5, 4:07pm
               Collapse Here's an excerpt from the conversation between Bilbo and Smaug BlackFox 225 1 Aug 5, 4:58pm
                   "Barrels? Now that is interesting." <-- Agreed, but greenbalrog 156 0 Aug 5, 7:58pm
       that is an easy one. He caled himself a Barrel rider.. Rickster 30 0 Aug 8, 12:18am

  Collapse Dwarf Rings Kagemusha 716 24 Aug 5, 12:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by burgahobbit)
       The Lord of the Rings wants the rings to come back to him. Michelle Johnston 382 0 Aug 5, 1:34pm
       Collapse I feel like the Thrain subplot is one that'll be moved entirely to the EE's. Boromir Stark 378 18 Aug 5, 1:40pm
           Collapse I don't think Moria makes obvious sense as the meeting place. Spriggan 357 16 Aug 5, 1:47pm
               Collapse But... Shagrat 350 6 Aug 5, 1:54pm
                   Collapse Who knows? Spriggan 340 5 Aug 5, 2:02pm
                       Collapse I suppose... Shagrat 333 4 Aug 5, 2:14pm
                           Collapse OK Question shadowdog 291 2 Aug 5, 3:08pm
                             Collapse There is one tiny hint? Bombadil 264 1 Aug 5, 4:15pm
                                   Post Script? Bombadil 253 0 Aug 5, 4:28pm
                           Well the simplest explanation is.... Spriggan 211 0 Aug 5, 6:01pm
               Collapse Working backwards Michelle Johnston 279 8 Aug 5, 3:46pm
                   I really like the idea of a gap between Azanulbizar and Thrain going missing Shagrat 269 0 Aug 5, 4:01pm
                   Collapse I agree with all this bar the last point. Spriggan 201 6 Aug 5, 6:04pm
                     Collapse Why did Sauron NOT find the Last Ring ON... THRAIN? Bombadil 200 5 Aug 5, 6:44pm
                           Collapse Presumably, Sauron DID recover the Dwarf-ring from Thrain Otaku-sempai 143 4 Aug 5, 8:46pm
                               Collapse Definitely, rather than presumably. It's in the appendices. Spriggan 130 2 Aug 5, 9:02pm
                                   Collapse Yes. In the legendarium. Otaku-sempai 122 1 Aug 5, 9:27pm
                                       Oh I see. I thought you were referring to the text. Spriggan 117 0 Aug 5, 9:38pm
                               That he did Shagrat 126 0 Aug 5, 9:06pm
           this! Dcole4 179 0 Aug 5, 7:26pm
       Collapse It was likely the ring, not the 'dragon sickness', that caused Thror's greed. QuackingTroll 169 2 Aug 5, 8:28pm
           I agree with some of this Shagrat 157 0 Aug 5, 8:39pm
           The answer to my question, if anyone's interested QuackingTroll 105 0 Aug 6, 12:39am
       I think burgahobbit 56 0 Aug 6, 1:16pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 816 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.