Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 8 of 1053 (372695 posts in 15794 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 1053 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
Collapse Will we get a 48 FPS or 4K version of Hobbit? NateGate 1546 18 Jan 11, 6:08am Jump to last post in thread (by Omnigeek)
       Collapse Seeing as none of the VFX were rendered in 4K, but only 2K... Bofur01 1455 1 Jan 11, 11:12am
           I would love to see a 48 fps version of DOS and BOTFA! ThorinsNemesis 1444 0 Jan 11, 12:14pm
       Collapse UHD Blu-rays don't support 48fps or 4K 3D. But they do support 60fps... AshNazg 1428 1 Jan 11, 2:04pm
           Hmmmmm NateGate 1373 0 Jan 11, 4:46pm
       Collapse 4K is worthless.... TheHutt 1219 5 Jan 12, 3:52pm
           Ugh... NateGate 1200 0 Jan 12, 4:15pm
           Collapse They could use the IMAX DMR copies... AshNazg 1146 3 Jan 12, 10:48pm
               Collapse The "No black bars" thing isn't really a good thing in this case... Bofur01 1134 1 Jan 12, 11:51pm
                   No, it's not necessarily a good thing... AshNazg 1093 0 Jan 13, 11:52am
               Upscale = no buy TheHutt 1094 0 Jan 13, 11:23am
       Collapse The point of 4K for home viewing? Bumblingidiot 1042 7 Jan 14, 2:05am
           Collapse Other benefits... AshNazg 994 6 Jan 14, 2:12pm
               Collapse Wrong... TheHutt 959 5 Jan 14, 9:55pm
                 Bomby Always Agrees W/ The Hutt Bombadil 895 0 Jan 16, 10:05am
                   Collapse Not wrong.... AshNazg 877 2 Jan 16, 5:13pm
                       Collapse Actually... TheHutt 856 1 Jan 17, 12:18am
                           4K is useless but HDR is NOT a gimmick hutch 786 0 Jan 19, 3:15am
                   Resolution is largely irrelevant Omnigeek 561 0 Jan 28, 3:55am

  Collapse Coincidence or uncanny? Neat either way TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1734 31 Jan 9, 8:34am Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Collapse 11 months? Smaug the iron 1637 2 Jan 9, 9:15am
           Collapse Ah, you're totally right TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1609 1 Jan 9, 10:09am
               To be fair TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1584 0 Jan 9, 11:15am
       Collapse this may be true lonelymountainhermit 1545 24 Jan 9, 2:50pm
           Collapse You really need to watch the appendices. Smaug the iron 1538 23 Jan 9, 2:58pm
               Collapse I've seen enough. lonelymountainhermit 1533 16 Jan 9, 3:07pm
                   Collapse Why is the 3-movie Hobbit such a problem to you? ThorinsNemesis 1475 15 Jan 9, 6:13pm
                       Collapse yes lonelymountainhermit 1463 14 Jan 9, 6:35pm
                           Collapse If you mean Tauriel and Legolas ThorinsNemesis 1441 5 Jan 9, 7:21pm
                               Collapse ... lonelymountainhermit 1417 3 Jan 9, 8:35pm
                                   For the book it worked... ThorinsNemesis 1411 0 Jan 9, 8:42pm
                                   Women in The Hobbit Otaku-sempai 1382 0 Jan 9, 9:55pm
                                   are you living under a rock? Lindele 495 0 Jan 12, 10:12pm
                               Legolas Sarahbor 1381 0 Jan 9, 9:54pm
                           Collapse Tell me how Avandel 1233 6 Jan 10, 6:00pm
                               ^ Agree all around Sarahbor 1204 0 Jan 10, 6:34pm
                               Collapse Time and Distances Otaku-sempai 1196 1 Jan 10, 6:59pm
                                   True, but Avandel 1128 0 Jan 11, 12:57am
                               Collapse Great post, Avandel TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1153 1 Jan 10, 11:09pm
                                   Thank you! Avandel 1134 0 Jan 11, 12:39am
                               Yes to this.... dormouse 1143 0 Jan 11, 12:09am
                           Really though I see very little substance in your posting... moreorless 301 0 Jan 23, 5:12pm
               Collapse Uhm. Gandalf the Green 896 5 Jan 12, 12:52pm
                   Uhm, no. Smaug the iron 866 0 Jan 12, 2:50pm
                   Collapse Explain... Otaku-sempai 520 3 Jan 12, 3:54pm
                       I was just about to say this TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 445 0 Jan 14, 1:48am
                       Collapse If this is long enough to explain what I meant... Gandalf the Green 403 1 Jan 15, 12:00pm
                           Okay... Otaku-sempai 388 0 Jan 15, 3:16pm
       I noticed that a while ago Sarahbor 1480 0 Jan 9, 6:04pm
       Collapse As soon as I read again TH the book after knowing LOTR the movie Milieuterrien 1055 1 Jan 11, 3:32pm
           I think thats a very good point... moreorless 299 0 Jan 23, 5:08pm

  Moved: plastic bag in Rohan Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) - - Jan 8, 1:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mr. Arkenstone (isaac))

  Collapse Smaug knowing Thorin's identity ProudFeet 1205 52 Jan 7, 5:55pm Jump to last post in thread (by TheHutt)
       Well Smaug the iron 1123 0 Jan 7, 6:11pm
       It was intentional Lindele 1128 0 Jan 7, 6:12pm
       More than sixty years... Otaku-sempai 1101 0 Jan 7, 6:39pm
       Collapse Possible explanation Sarahbor 1078 2 Jan 7, 8:05pm
           Collapse About Thorin's name Smaug the iron 1060 1 Jan 7, 8:26pm
               Yeah Sarahbor 1051 0 Jan 7, 8:57pm
       Collapse The explanation Shagrat 962 3 Jan 8, 9:56am
           Collapse Is this explanation in the Art of War book? ThorinsNemesis 951 2 Jan 8, 10:42am
               Collapse Yes Smaug the iron 948 1 Jan 8, 10:51am
                   Then I'll be sure to get it as soon as possible! ThorinsNemesis 940 0 Jan 8, 11:22am
       Collapse According to Tolkien Bracegirdle 935 34 Jan 8, 2:12pm
           Collapse I don't believe ThorinsNemesis 925 29 Jan 8, 2:56pm
               Smaug learning of Oakenshield Otaku-sempai 911 0 Jan 8, 4:04pm
               Collapse Never laugh at live dragons Bracegirdle 859 27 Jan 8, 9:35pm
                   When i said about the palantir ThorinsNemesis 846 0 Jan 8, 10:21pm
                   Collapse Okay, but this isn't Tolkien's legendarium Otaku-sempai 816 25 Jan 9, 1:00am
                       Correcto OS Bracegirdle 785 0 Jan 9, 4:27am
                       Collapse We don't. TheHutt 418 23 Jan 12, 4:10pm
                           Collapse We do... Otaku-sempai 412 22 Jan 12, 4:37pm
                               Collapse Thorin's age is confirmed in the films. Smaug the iron 402 2 Jan 12, 4:57pm
                                   Collapse The Lake-town Tapestry Otaku-sempai 396 1 Jan 12, 5:57pm
                                       Sure we can. TheHutt 346 0 Jan 13, 11:44am
                               Collapse Contradiction on the filmmakers' part? Sarahbor 391 4 Jan 12, 6:28pm
                                   Age LSF 384 0 Jan 12, 6:38pm
                                   Collapse TH:BotFA Chronicles: The Art of War Otaku-sempai 383 1 Jan 12, 6:44pm
                                       It's near the end Sarahbor 377 0 Jan 12, 7:31pm
                                   QED. TheHutt 348 0 Jan 13, 11:30am
                               Collapse You do. TheHutt 345 13 Jan 13, 11:58am
                                   Collapse The Dwarven Tapestry Otaku-sempai 331 12 Jan 13, 2:37pm
                                       Collapse Validity TheHutt 312 11 Jan 13, 4:13pm
                                           Collapse Contradictory Evidence Otaku-sempai 306 10 Jan 13, 4:28pm
                                               Collapse Tolkien's Universe is more fictive than P Jackson's universe Milieuterrien 282 1 Jan 13, 7:32pm
                                                   I'm not comparing the films to the book though Otaku-sempai 270 0 Jan 13, 8:24pm
                                               Collapse There's another factor here which no one seems to be taking.... dormouse 278 6 Jan 13, 7:52pm
                                                   Collapse True, dormouse... Otaku-sempai 271 5 Jan 13, 8:31pm
                                                       Smaug in the movies... No One in Particular 251 0 Jan 13, 10:17pm
                                                       Collapse 'course you can if it amuses you... ;-) dormouse 245 3 Jan 13, 10:39pm
                                                           Collapse Smaug and the Precious Otaku-sempai 324 2 Jan 13, 11:13pm
                                                               Smaug and the Ring No One in Particular 292 0 Jan 15, 5:14am
                                                               Precious TheHutt 251 0 Jan 17, 12:22am
                                               You're right... TheHutt 250 0 Jan 13, 10:25pm
           Collapse Film timeline vs book... Otaku-sempai 911 3 Jan 8, 3:58pm
               Collapse Where? TheHutt 416 2 Jan 12, 4:06pm
                   Collapse Not spelled out on-screen Otaku-sempai 413 1 Jan 12, 4:24pm
                       Nope. TheHutt 344 0 Jan 13, 11:51am
       Well Darkstone 914 0 Jan 8, 3:53pm
       Collapse For me, obviously Sauron has got many means Milieuterrien 811 5 Jan 9, 1:20am
           Collapse Palantíri Otaku-sempai 755 4 Jan 9, 1:40pm
               Collapse My mistake Milieuterrien 710 3 Jan 9, 10:13pm
                   Collapse The Ithil-stone Otaku-sempai 699 2 Jan 9, 11:05pm
                       Collapse More palantiri Bracegirdle 669 1 Jan 10, 4:06am
                           By the way, the fact that Sauron needed a palantir Milieuterrien 461 0 Jan 10, 11:20am

  Collapse Awful portrayal of Tolkien characters lonelymountainhermit 1814 87 Jan 7, 5:22pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elthir)
       Collapse Disagree Smaug the iron 1698 31 Jan 7, 5:29pm
           Collapse Seconded NoelGallagher 1683 30 Jan 7, 6:00pm
               Collapse I like the actor lonelymountainhermit 1671 29 Jan 7, 6:19pm
                   Well,no NoelGallagher 1658 0 Jan 7, 6:29pm
                   Collapse do you own birds, by chance? nusilver 1625 27 Jan 7, 8:09pm
                       Collapse I have 4 budgies Sarahbor 1613 1 Jan 7, 8:15pm
                           Personally Avandel 1525 0 Jan 7, 10:13pm
                       If more of us were naive goofballs, Lissuin 1609 0 Jan 7, 8:19pm
                       Collapse Fair enough lonelymountainhermit 1586 2 Jan 7, 8:40pm
                           haha... nusilver 1569 0 Jan 7, 8:58pm
                           Asolutely. Cats and birds have two channels Milieuterrien 583 0 Jan 9, 1:32am
                       Collapse There was a famous birdman Starling 1573 4 Jan 7, 8:57pm
                           Collapse For all we know Sarahbor 1568 3 Jan 7, 8:59pm
                               That has been speculated upon before Starling 1559 0 Jan 7, 9:08pm
                               Collapse I always thought it was TH White's Merlyn Darkstone 1545 1 Jan 7, 9:28pm
                                   So did I // dormouse 1489 0 Jan 7, 11:09pm
                       Collapse a question, tho.... Avandel 1519 13 Jan 7, 10:24pm
                           Collapse lol lonelymountainhermit 1465 1 Jan 8, 12:08am
                               Not really Sarahbor 1399 0 Jan 8, 4:12am
                           Actually Sarahbor 1410 0 Jan 8, 3:42am
                           Collapse Radagast and the bird poop No One in Particular 1404 8 Jan 8, 4:09am
                               Collapse The bunny sled. Smaug the iron 1343 7 Jan 8, 8:40am
                                   I don't get the unabashed hate for the sled either. Imladris18 689 0 Jan 8, 3:26pm
                                   Collapse Riding Animals Otaku-sempai 672 1 Jan 8, 4:11pm
                                       It is not Smaug the iron 657 0 Jan 8, 4:24pm
                                   I like the sled Sarahbor 626 0 Jan 8, 5:59pm
                                   Collapse The bunny sled No One in Particular 621 2 Jan 8, 6:15pm
                                       Collapse Why not both Smaug the iron 622 1 Jan 8, 6:28pm
                                           I have to agree. Nieriel 548 0 Jan 8, 9:18pm
                           That oft quoted wizard Google informs me Nieriel 1393 0 Jan 8, 4:19am
                       TH White, the fuller story Elthir 1306 0 Jan 8, 1:29pm
                       animal lover = ? Elthir 1300 0 Jan 8, 1:42pm
       Collapse Agree completely Goldeneye 696 6 Jan 8, 3:22pm
           Disagree completely Smaug the iron 691 0 Jan 8, 3:36pm
           But Avandel 653 0 Jan 8, 5:10pm
           Collapse yes lonelymountainhermit 633 3 Jan 8, 5:39pm
               He is serious Smaug the iron 630 0 Jan 8, 6:03pm
               But Starling 605 0 Jan 8, 8:17pm
               True enough..... Avandel 666 0 Jan 8, 10:10pm
       Collapse and lonelymountainhermit 603 27 Jan 8, 8:35pm
           Collapse You are not getting any more food from me. // Starling 589 2 Jan 8, 8:39pm
               ? lonelymountainhermit 588 0 Jan 8, 8:47pm
               Lol Goldeneye 684 0 Jan 8, 10:01pm
           Collapse Well Smaug the iron 593 23 Jan 8, 8:49pm
               Collapse Smaug? Otaku-sempai 581 9 Jan 8, 8:59pm
                   Collapse I find it is sometimes worth checking Starling 570 1 Jan 8, 9:07pm
                       Yes... Otaku-sempai 563 0 Jan 8, 9:10pm
                   Collapse Sorry Smaug the iron 694 2 Jan 8, 9:41pm
                       Collapse That's okay; I missed up too... Otaku-sempai 612 1 Jan 9, 12:45am
                           or lonelymountainhermit 599 0 Jan 9, 1:04am
                   Collapse I believe there are many here who don't speak English as their native language. Bumblingidiot 322 3 Jan 11, 6:15am
                       Yes... Otaku-sempai 294 0 Jan 11, 4:04pm
                       Collapse Yup Darkstone 637 1 Jan 11, 4:14pm
                           I've never known a native English speaker to struggle with the Texan dialect. Bumblingidiot 551 0 Jan 14, 2:17am
               Collapse ... lonelymountainhermit 582 12 Jan 8, 8:59pm
                   Collapse It would never have worked out... Otaku-sempai 574 1 Jan 8, 9:02pm
                       lol lonelymountainhermit 565 0 Jan 8, 9:09pm
                   Collapse Dunno Darkstone 560 9 Jan 8, 9:13pm
                       Collapse ... lonelymountainhermit 553 8 Jan 8, 9:19pm
                           Collapse This sub-thread is going somewhere! Darkstone 701 7 Jan 8, 9:39pm
                               From now on, Starling 680 0 Jan 8, 10:05pm
                               Collapse oh my goodness lonelymountainhermit 667 5 Jan 8, 10:19pm
                                   Collapse Well Smaug the iron 658 3 Jan 8, 10:33pm
                                       Collapse but lonelymountainhermit 647 2 Jan 8, 10:44pm
                                           Collapse That is a great scene. Smaug the iron 638 1 Jan 8, 10:57pm
                                               hmm lonelymountainhermit 627 0 Jan 8, 11:05pm
                                   "No sex, please. We're hobbits." Darkstone 658 0 Jan 8, 10:38pm
       Collapse oh boy lonelymountainhermit 532 11 Jan 9, 3:25pm
           Legolas Otaku-sempai 463 0 Jan 9, 9:59pm
           Collapse Actually, Laineth 414 9 Jan 26, 9:38pm
               Collapse Yes. Darkstone 409 1 Jan 26, 9:59pm
                   I didn't get that impression. Laineth 390 0 Jan 27, 5:05am
               General observation LSF 409 0 Jan 26, 10:07pm
               Collapse Ninja Hollywood Elves Elthir 368 5 Jan 27, 3:41pm
                   Collapse low to high Elthir 353 4 Jan 27, 4:30pm
                       Collapse Actually... Laineth 316 3 Jan 28, 2:57am
                           Collapse leaps and bounds Elthir 298 2 Jan 28, 1:04pm
                               Collapse Cont. Laineth 214 1 Feb 5, 12:27am
                                   running on empty Elthir 197 0 Feb 5, 1:00pm
       Collapse :( lonelymountainhermit 512 7 Jan 9, 6:42pm
           Collapse There is a decent explanation about Thorin's beard ThorinsNemesis 489 4 Jan 9, 8:07pm
               Collapse ... lonelymountainhermit 480 2 Jan 9, 8:31pm
                   Collapse Well, I for one wouldn't have liked 13 identical Dwarves... ThorinsNemesis 476 1 Jan 9, 8:47pm
                       True enough and I will never understand the beard obsession Avandel 390 0 Jan 10, 5:25pm
               What an unmitigated load of poop Omnigeek 311 0 Jan 28, 4:17am
           Collapse Disagree profoundly with one comment…100% agree on another Glorfindela 378 1 Jan 10, 6:31pm
               Thorin's beard Nieriel 349 0 Jan 10, 11:21pm

  Collapse Sebastian's Fate Legomir 1230 28 Jan 7, 1:34am Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       Collapse I believe... LSF 1169 2 Jan 7, 1:43am
           Collapse That could not happen. Smaug the iron 1160 1 Jan 7, 1:55am
               I know LSF 1156 0 Jan 7, 2:00am
       Collapse Not confirmed in the film...didn't happen... Aragorn the Elfstone 1157 2 Jan 7, 2:07am
           Yeah Legomir 1145 0 Jan 7, 2:10am
           If it's not explicitly stated or implied by the film itself TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1084 0 Jan 7, 7:19am
       Not possible Sarahbor 1120 0 Jan 7, 4:50am
       Collapse Nooooooo! Eruwestial37 1107 4 Jan 7, 5:53am
           Collapse You brought one home? Starling 1090 3 Jan 7, 7:02am
               Collapse Sweet pets Eruwestial37 1070 1 Jan 7, 7:48am
                   Well Starling 900 0 Jan 7, 6:22pm
               They are an important part of the British fauna. Bumblingidiot 271 0 Jan 14, 3:14am
       Collapse Rest easy, it's not Sebastian.... dormouse 1038 9 Jan 7, 10:44am
           Collapse That lines seems to confirm it to me... adt100 1017 8 Jan 7, 11:57am
               Collapse Well no, it doesn't.... dormouse 1014 7 Jan 7, 12:11pm
                   Collapse The fact that they were even considering filming a longer version is more disturbing to me... Imladris18 947 5 Jan 7, 3:44pm
                       Collapse I really don't think they were.... dormouse 927 3 Jan 7, 4:38pm
                         Collapse Agree Avandel 890 2 Jan 7, 6:42pm
                               Collapse That cat Sarahbor 717 1 Jan 8, 6:06pm
                                 That was great Avandel 386 0 Jan 9, 5:11pm
                       Maybe they are exploring Starling 893 0 Jan 7, 6:25pm
                   hmmmm, not really sure I agree with that.... adt100 335 0 Jan 11, 2:10pm
       Nooooooooooo!!! Gianna 975 0 Jan 7, 2:35pm
       Collapse It's definitely Sebastian Earl 916 3 Jan 7, 5:41pm
           Collapse He wasn't saying there was music written for it. Imladris18 753 2 Jan 8, 3:19pm
               Collapse I'm pretty sure there must have been music written for it Earl 664 1 Jan 9, 6:47am
                   I don't think it's that cut and dry. Imladris18 322 0 Jan 11, 5:11pm
       Hmm, that was his wife and he did have his revenge when Radagast turned him into Eruonen 860 0 Jan 7, 8:18pm

  Collapse Where was Tauriel when Smaug invaded Erebor? Otaku-sempai 1057 49 Jan 6, 9:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse I hadn't thought about that until now... ThorinsNemesis 995 21 Jan 6, 10:03pm
           Collapse My thoughts on this Kilidoescartwheels 988 1 Jan 6, 10:08pm
               my thoughts too LSF 984 0 Jan 6, 10:10pm
           Collapse Thranduil's Motive Otaku-sempai 975 18 Jan 6, 10:45pm
               Collapse I'd agree Avandel 926 17 Jan 7, 1:16am
                   Asking for aid... Otaku-sempai 903 0 Jan 7, 2:44am
                   Collapse Why the dwarves came back after being refused Sarahbor 888 2 Jan 7, 4:28am
                       Collapse Although.... Avandel 760 1 Jan 7, 5:19pm
                           He could've let the dwarves go alone Sarahbor 727 0 Jan 7, 8:08pm
                   Collapse I don't think he did. Laineth 291 12 Jan 26, 9:15pm
                       Collapse How much warning did Thranduil have? Otaku-sempai 282 11 Jan 26, 11:16pm
                           Collapse I should have given Laineth 278 10 Jan 27, 1:08am
                               Collapse Yes, but I'm thinking of the films. Otaku-sempai 274 9 Jan 27, 3:30am
                                   Collapse You're right Laineth 252 8 Jan 28, 2:18am
                                       Collapse Yeah... Otaku-sempai 248 7 Jan 28, 2:52am
                                           Collapse Well, Laineth 245 6 Jan 28, 3:04am
                                               Collapse Tauriel and Legolas Otaku-sempai 242 5 Jan 28, 3:24am
                                                   Collapse About Legolas and Tauriel Smaug the iron 238 4 Jan 28, 8:57am
                                                       They had to go around? LSF 229 0 Jan 28, 1:25pm
                                                       Collapse Legolas and Tauriel at Lake-town Otaku-sempai 225 2 Jan 28, 3:10pm
                                                           Collapse Yes, Laineth 216 1 Jan 28, 4:17pm
                                                               Dwarves from Lake-town to Erebor Otaku-sempai 211 0 Jan 28, 5:02pm
       Collapse Same place as Gondor when the Westfold fell? / Darkstone 969 1 Jan 6, 10:47pm
           Lol! // Starling 963 0 Jan 6, 10:51pm
       Collapse Woodland Guard vs. the army Sarahbor 948 2 Jan 6, 11:44pm
           Collapse Did Thranduil have a standing army? Otaku-sempai 906 1 Jan 7, 2:37am
               Don't know Sarahbor 893 0 Jan 7, 4:21am
       Collapse At home, patrolling the wood? dormouse 850 5 Jan 7, 10:14am
           Collapse Our thoughts are similar... Otaku-sempai 819 4 Jan 7, 1:50pm
               Collapse Well, I was trying to avoid the word 'regiment'.... dormouse 805 3 Jan 7, 2:46pm
                   Collapse Quite possibly... Otaku-sempai 804 1 Jan 7, 2:52pm
                       Yes Darkstone 788 0 Jan 7, 3:12pm
                   I think the BOTFA Art and Design has some info on this... ThorinsNemesis 801 0 Jan 7, 3:00pm
       Collapse I believe Nieriel 631 15 Jan 10, 12:17am
           Collapse Thranduil aiding Dale? Otaku-sempai 616 14 Jan 10, 1:24am
               Collapse But it seems remarkably coincidental Nieriel 605 8 Jan 10, 2:05am
                   Collapse Maybe... Otaku-sempai 601 7 Jan 10, 2:19am
                       Abolutely! Nieriel 520 0 Jan 10, 2:40am
                       Collapse Traveling time Sarahbor 511 5 Jan 10, 3:23am
                           Collapse Lake-town to Erebor Otaku-sempai 506 4 Jan 10, 3:51am
                               Collapse Yeah I noticed that Sarahbor 499 3 Jan 10, 4:12am
                                   Collapse I don't (entirely) agree... Otaku-sempai 490 2 Jan 10, 6:43am
                                       Collapse Well Sarahbor 479 1 Jan 10, 1:34pm
                                           You're right... Otaku-sempai 473 0 Jan 10, 2:50pm
               Collapse There actually are Cirashala 470 4 Jan 10, 3:21pm
                   Collapse Some Elves for sure... Otaku-sempai 467 3 Jan 10, 3:33pm
                       Collapse I didn't realize you meant an army of elves in Dale Cirashala 465 2 Jan 10, 3:38pm
                           Collapse That's right... Otaku-sempai 461 1 Jan 10, 3:43pm
                               maybe that fuelled Thorin's fury Cirashala 459 0 Jan 10, 3:45pm

  Collapse An Unexpected Journey scene - the Blue Mountains? ThorinsNemesis 973 15 Jan 6, 8:58pm Jump to last post in thread (by Earl)
       Collapse Those could be the Blue Mountains... Otaku-sempai 940 6 Jan 6, 9:08pm
           Collapse I actually hadn't thought about the Gap of Rohan ThorinsNemesis 926 5 Jan 6, 9:51pm
               Collapse The River Lhûn... Otaku-sempai 911 4 Jan 6, 10:12pm
                   Collapse If you mean about where Thorin is standing ThorinsNemesis 899 3 Jan 6, 10:34pm
                       Collapse Thorin's Perspective Otaku-sempai 889 2 Jan 6, 10:53pm
                           Collapse We don't know for sure where Thorin's halls were located... ThorinsNemesis 876 1 Jan 6, 11:19pm
                               Thorin's Halls Otaku-sempai 824 0 Jan 7, 2:31am
       no balbo biggins 849 0 Jan 7, 1:40am
       Collapse I may be mistaken, but... Earl 704 6 Jan 7, 5:38pm
           Collapse ^^In which of the Hobbit movies' Appendices exactly? ThorinsNemesis 693 5 Jan 7, 6:30pm
               Collapse I honestly do not recall Earl 688 4 Jan 7, 6:36pm
                   Collapse Could it be Smaug the iron 683 1 Jan 7, 6:49pm
                       It could be... ThorinsNemesis 672 0 Jan 7, 7:18pm
                   Collapse It is the Blue Mountains! ThorinsNemesis 657 1 Jan 7, 8:54pm
                       Aha! So it was Richard :-) Earl 605 0 Jan 8, 5:16am

  Collapse How would you rank all 6 extended editions and why? TheImaginator 1133 10 Jan 6, 6:42pm Jump to last post in thread (by KingTurgon)
       For me this is just ranking the films re favorites, probably Avandel 1035 0 Jan 6, 10:12pm
       Hmmmmmmmm CathrineB 1026 0 Jan 6, 10:29pm
       Collapse Interesting idea to rank the EE grimbeorn15 1010 1 Jan 6, 11:02pm
           I haven't seen it yet either... Queen of Erebor 536 0 Jan 14, 11:15pm
       Collapse I can't amalgamate the two trilogies Glorfindela 845 2 Jan 7, 11:51pm
           Collapse 1. The Return of the King TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 814 1 Jan 8, 6:33am
               Needless to say TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 810 0 Jan 8, 6:36am
       1 - The Two Towers (EE) Milieuterrien 774 0 Jan 8, 12:54pm
       My rankings Elessar 766 0 Jan 8, 1:51pm
       I have two sets of rankings KingTurgon 284 0 Jan 30, 7:20am

  Collapse Would you have preferred a four-legged Smaug? ThorinsNemesis 1421 28 Jan 4, 1:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kassandros)
       Well Smaug the iron 1338 0 Jan 4, 2:16pm
       Collapse The moment when PJ Lindele 1329 1 Jan 4, 2:37pm
           I agree ThorinsNemesis 1315 0 Jan 4, 2:53pm
       I think that decision was a stroke of genius.... dormouse 1313 0 Jan 4, 3:12pm
       Collapse I'm split... Otaku-sempai 1295 1 Jan 4, 3:41pm
           Actually I've also noticed that ThorinsNemesis 1288 0 Jan 4, 3:55pm
       Hmm Gandalf the Green 1265 0 Jan 4, 4:18pm
       He's fine Glorfindela 1261 0 Jan 4, 4:25pm
       I like 2-legged Smaug Sarahbor 1238 0 Jan 4, 5:21pm
       The balance may be positive but not overly Milieuterrien 1230 0 Jan 4, 5:46pm
       Love two-legged LSF 1195 0 Jan 4, 7:03pm
       I love two-legged Smaug Noria 1146 0 Jan 4, 9:41pm
       I like the two legged one! OldestDaughter 1117 0 Jan 4, 11:37pm
       Collapse Four legs bad. Bumblingidiot 1089 2 Jan 5, 3:49am
           Collapse Smaug has always had four legs... Otaku-sempai 1079 1 Jan 5, 4:59am
               Yes, two of the four legs are forelegs Bumblingidiot 864 0 Jan 6, 2:35am
       Sadly Elessar 1022 0 Jan 5, 12:54pm
       No, as 4 legged dragons just look too ponderous. Eruonen 988 0 Jan 5, 3:05pm
       Collapse Almost everything about Smaug was wrong Kassandros 559 7 Jan 10, 2:44am
           Dragons Otaku-sempai 556 0 Jan 10, 3:01am
           Collapse It was not about Smaug Milieuterrien 528 5 Jan 10, 11:37am
               Smaug and Lake-town's Size Otaku-sempai 521 0 Jan 10, 2:58pm
               Collapse Not how I saw it Kassandros 498 3 Jan 10, 7:42pm
                   Lots of disappointment comments don't seem to bother Milieuterrien 252 0 Jan 10, 8:33pm
                   Collapse Funnily enough.... dormouse 244 1 Jan 11, 12:04am
                       Just sharing my point of view Kassandros 195 0 Jan 12, 5:39pm
       I change my mind Nieriel 548 0 Jan 10, 3:30am
       We still have the four-legged Smaug... TheHutt 208 0 Jan 12, 4:00pm

  Collapse Cumulative dialogue per character in the Hobbit trilogy Goldeneye 1501 56 Jan 3, 2:50am Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse It's interesting, but I think it's a useless barometer.... dormouse 1342 7 Jan 3, 9:58am
           Collapse Also Sarahbor 1304 2 Jan 3, 1:28pm
               Collapse About Beorn Smaug the iron 1296 1 Jan 3, 1:46pm
                   Yes Sarahbor 1195 0 Jan 3, 6:57pm
           Collapse I'd wager... Goldeneye 1241 3 Jan 3, 5:06pm
               Collapse Well Smaug the iron 1235 1 Jan 3, 5:16pm
                   One more mistake Smaug the iron 1226 0 Jan 3, 5:43pm
               Well.... dormouse 1199 0 Jan 3, 6:55pm
       Collapse Well Smaug the iron 1339 8 Jan 3, 10:05am
           Collapse Well Goldeneye 1234 1 Jan 3, 5:14pm
               Yes it dose. Smaug the iron 1230 0 Jan 3, 5:31pm
           Collapse Ori lionoferebor 1153 5 Jan 3, 8:16pm
               Collapse ori LSF 1151 4 Jan 3, 8:17pm
                   That's right... lionoferebor 1145 0 Jan 3, 8:19pm
                   Collapse Not only that but Smaug the iron 1144 2 Jan 3, 8:23pm
                       Collapse wait DainPig 1115 1 Jan 3, 10:13pm
                           Well Smaug the iron 1107 0 Jan 3, 10:23pm
       Collapse ... StingingFly 1194 31 Jan 3, 7:04pm
           Collapse No Smaug the iron 1188 30 Jan 3, 7:12pm
               Collapse And even with less dialogue, he *still* has the most screentime TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1168 29 Jan 3, 8:02pm
                   Collapse ... StingingFly 1127 4 Jan 3, 9:43pm
                       Well Smaug the iron 1121 0 Jan 3, 9:59pm
                       Collapse I don't see a problem TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1107 2 Jan 3, 10:26pm
                           And, to clarify TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1103 0 Jan 3, 10:29pm
                           I thought... LSF 612 0 Jan 3, 10:50pm
                   Collapse Yes to this.... dormouse 611 23 Jan 3, 11:13pm
                       Collapse Actually... Goldeneye 587 9 Jan 4, 2:25am
                           Collapse Unbalanced Starling 569 2 Jan 4, 4:12am
                               Collapse The point? Goldeneye 490 1 Jan 4, 2:45pm
                                   Thank you Starling 430 0 Jan 4, 6:41pm
                           Collapse Question Sarahbor 565 1 Jan 4, 4:20am
                               You're right Goldeneye 494 0 Jan 4, 2:39pm
                           Collapse significance? LSF 562 1 Jan 4, 4:37am
                               ... aragorn2015 558 0 Jan 4, 4:47am
                           Why not just say.... dormouse 546 0 Jan 4, 9:29am
                           The only thing Smaug the iron 536 0 Jan 4, 9:51am
                       Collapse It's just another way to take a jab Elessar 523 12 Jan 4, 12:51pm
                           Collapse Yes, it is..... dormouse 514 11 Jan 4, 1:47pm
                               Collapse "Meaningful screentime" Voronwë_the_Faithful 497 10 Jan 4, 2:35pm
                                   Collapse Sorry Voronwe, that one's my fault.... dormouse 489 9 Jan 4, 3:06pm
                                       Collapse Meaningful Screentime Otaku-sempai 476 1 Jan 4, 3:50pm
                                           Fair enough - I'd go with that. // dormouse 466 0 Jan 4, 3:58pm
                                       Collapse Yes but he twisted your phrase Voronwë_the_Faithful 469 6 Jan 4, 4:08pm
                                           That it certainly is! // dormouse 453 0 Jan 4, 4:59pm
                                           Collapse Screentime is screentime Goldeneye 453 4 Jan 4, 5:26pm
                                               Collapse They are not alone in their screentime Milieuterrien 442 3 Jan 4, 6:09pm
                                                   Collapse Alfrid Sarahbor 407 2 Jan 4, 7:50pm
                                                       Collapse Agreed Goldeneye 394 1 Jan 4, 8:28pm
                                                           Well Smaug the iron 389 0 Jan 4, 8:41pm
       Collapse There have been various threads discussing this topic in the past... Bladerunner 469 2 Jan 4, 11:13pm
           Legolas, Alfrid, Tauriel & Radagast squiggle 451 0 Jan 5, 12:56am
         Highs and lows for me Avandel 400 0 Jan 5, 12:21pm
       Collapse A changed line of dialogue Kerewyn 280 2 Jan 6, 9:38pm
           Collapse It's twirly-whirlies Sarahbor 253 1 Jan 7, 4:53am
               That's right, it is. Kerewyn 220 0 Jan 7, 8:30pm
       But did this list Cirashala 205 0 Jan 7, 11:41pm

  Collapse Favorite weapon(s) in the Hobbit movies Sarahbor 1119 30 Jan 2, 10:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Sarahbor)
       Collapse All the weapons are awesome LSF 1047 1 Jan 2, 11:02pm
           Good choice! Sarahbor 1041 0 Jan 2, 11:17pm
       I can't decide so... ThorinsNemesis 1036 0 Jan 2, 11:33pm
       Orcrist, definitely Elarie 1029 0 Jan 2, 11:54pm
       I like Glorfindela 1025 0 Jan 3, 12:16am
       Bifur's squiggly spear thing MyWeeLadGimli 998 0 Jan 3, 2:06am
       The weapons are the most extraordinary pieces of design.... dormouse 957 0 Jan 3, 10:01am
       My favorite is Smaug the iron 950 0 Jan 3, 10:22am
     Collapse Magnificent designs...... Avandel 910 9 Jan 3, 8:24pm
           :-) // dormouse 880 0 Jan 3, 11:14pm
           Collapse must be the only one... LSF 883 1 Jan 3, 11:19pm
             vive la différence! Avandel 820 0 Jan 4, 12:11pm
           Collapse Excellent list, but you missed a few Kim 875 4 Jan 3, 11:48pm
               I also love Thranduil's sword Glorfindela 864 0 Jan 4, 1:05am
             Collapse It's so hard, tho.... Avandel 819 2 Jan 4, 12:26pm
                   Collapse Yes, even the walls noticed Kilidoescartwheels 620 1 Jan 6, 4:48am
                     Ah, the FEVER of FANDOM Avandel 448 0 Jan 7, 11:35pm
           The eyes have it! Kilidoescartwheels 757 0 Jan 4, 10:35pm
       Collapse You mean besides Orchrist? Kilidoescartwheels 755 2 Jan 4, 10:44pm
           Collapse I have a recurve bow Sarahbor 753 1 Jan 4, 11:03pm
               That's weird Sarahbor 746 0 Jan 4, 11:31pm
     Collapse Not just swords Miss-Merriweather 437 1 Jan 8, 3:30am
         LOL Avandel 418 0 Jan 8, 4:02pm
       Collapse my chocie ;D Galathil 373 1 Jan 9, 7:13pm
           Fili LSF 227 0 Jan 9, 8:22pm
       Collapse I'm an archer myself, so Cirashala 201 3 Jan 10, 3:34pm
         Whack and Thud... Miss-Merriweather 191 0 Jan 10, 4:57pm
           Mace LSF 186 0 Jan 10, 5:09pm
           Kili's bow Sarahbor 177 0 Jan 10, 6:40pm
       It's hard to choose Nieriel 182 0 Jan 10, 5:52pm

  Collapse Legolas fighting old version of Bolg Lio 948 3 Jan 2, 9:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by peterLF)
       pre-vis LSF 937 0 Jan 2, 9:52pm
       Well Smaug the iron 933 0 Jan 2, 9:54pm
       Not much to see here peterLF 690 0 Jan 4, 5:10am

  Collapse Elven music in hobbit movies Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 528 2 Jan 2, 8:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by OldestDaughter)
       Yes Smaug the iron 491 0 Jan 2, 10:04pm
       Yes! OldestDaughter 483 0 Jan 2, 10:36pm

  Collapse Would you like an ultra-faithful Hobbit movie? MyWeeLadGimli 1913 52 Jan 1, 7:26pm Jump to last post in thread (by lonelymountainhermit)
       Not Entirely Otaku-sempai 1766 0 Jan 1, 7:36pm
       Collapse Ultra faithful? Not sure. More faithful? Yes. Aragorn the Elfstone 1762 5 Jan 1, 7:47pm
           Collapse Also... Aragorn the Elfstone 1705 4 Jan 1, 9:05pm
               Collapse No TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1673 3 Jan 1, 10:51pm
                   Collapse SACRILEGE!!! Aragorn the Elfstone 1666 1 Jan 1, 10:59pm
                       Well, I'm glad it was you - at least you're polite about it! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1642 0 Jan 1, 11:24pm
                   nice to know... LSF 1635 0 Jan 1, 11:36pm
       Not sure... malickfan 1743 0 Jan 1, 7:56pm
       No for me Kilidoescartwheels 1719 0 Jan 1, 8:50pm
       I think keeping the tone of the book would be very difficult Elarie 1660 0 Jan 1, 11:04pm
       Collapse No idea dormouse 1635 3 Jan 2, 12:01am
           Collapse I would actually like to see a Lee/Howe style animation.. moreorless 1509 1 Jan 2, 10:32am
               So would I... dormouse 1495 0 Jan 2, 11:18am
           What Dormouse said Avandel 1357 0 Jan 2, 6:53pm
       Collapse yes balbo biggins 1578 1 Jan 2, 2:53am
           It is true Starling 1567 0 Jan 2, 3:47am
       Collapse We sort of had that Sarahbor 1558 2 Jan 2, 4:22am
           Collapse I think animation would actually be the best route to go... moreorless 1507 1 Jan 2, 10:27am
               Yeah Sarahbor 1370 0 Jan 2, 6:21pm
       Hmm CathrineB 1514 0 Jan 2, 9:20am
       Collapse Yes of course! Thrain II 1441 1 Jan 2, 3:22pm
           I too am surprised Gianna 1416 0 Jan 2, 4:03pm
       Collapse Speaking from my own experience... Gianna 1430 4 Jan 2, 3:58pm
           Collapse Bard Otaku-sempai 747 1 Jan 2, 7:48pm
               I like your idea for his introduction. Gianna 726 0 Jan 2, 9:27pm
           Collapse You made a film from scratch? MyWeeLadGimli 707 1 Jan 3, 1:59am
               Yes, I did Gianna 700 0 Jan 3, 4:09am
       Maybe, maybe not. Noria 1380 0 Jan 2, 6:03pm
       Collapse If there was going to be one... Na Vedui 683 2 Jan 3, 5:30pm
           That's cool Sarahbor 648 0 Jan 3, 6:52pm
           That's beautiful! // dormouse 640 0 Jan 3, 7:01pm
       Collapse give pete another go Cunir 660 11 Jan 3, 6:16pm
           Collapse Perhaps lonelymountainhermit 587 10 Jan 4, 7:30pm
               Collapse He never Smaug the iron 583 9 Jan 4, 7:35pm
                   Collapse ... lonelymountainhermit 577 8 Jan 4, 7:45pm
                       Collapse Well Smaug the iron 574 7 Jan 4, 7:50pm
                           Collapse Ok lonelymountainhermit 520 6 Jan 5, 12:08pm
                               Collapse I'd like a more faithful adaptation... Lond-Daer 449 5 Jan 5, 6:58pm
                                   Collapse Yes lonelymountainhermit 437 4 Jan 5, 7:30pm
                                       Collapse He did hade the book. Smaug the iron 436 3 Jan 5, 7:37pm
                                           Collapse Interesting lonelymountainhermit 398 2 Jan 5, 9:43pm
                                               Yes I am certain. Smaug the iron 396 0 Jan 5, 9:45pm
                                               Have you watched the EE appendices? dormouse 379 0 Jan 5, 11:53pm
       Collapse Well, yeah Darkstone 578 2 Jan 4, 8:04pm
           LOL Sarahbor 567 0 Jan 4, 8:11pm
           Agreed (mostly)... Otaku-sempai 555 0 Jan 4, 8:49pm
       Collapse Not for me....see the Rankin and Bass animated for that. Eruonen 418 4 Jan 5, 9:06pm
           Collapse The Rankin/Bass isn't very faithful either MyWeeLadGimli 369 3 Jan 6, 1:22am
               Collapse Yes lonelymountainhermit 266 2 Jan 6, 12:37pm
                   Collapse Well Smaug the iron 264 1 Jan 6, 12:50pm
                       Even still lonelymountainhermit 260 0 Jan 6, 1:11pm
       Yes!!!!!!!! beorn58 398 0 Jan 5, 9:42pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... 1053 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.