Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 7 of 878 (320400 posts in 13162 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 878 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Thread Locked Are we sure that these speculations are true? erdildeniz 2006 22 Nov 19, 1:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Altaira)
       Thread Locked Of course not! dave_lf 900 0 Nov 19, 2:01pm
       Thread Locked neither i can NoelGallagher 783 0 Nov 19, 2:05pm
       Thread Locked We already do have two threads. Arannir 794 0 Nov 19, 2:06pm
       Collapse Thread Locked Just Ignore them and wait for the film dormouse 627 1 Nov 19, 3:28pm
           Thread Locked Agreed! I'm trying not to spoil myself in the same was as I was for ROTK // adt100 535 0 Nov 19, 4:06pm
       Thread Locked It's on the internet. Darkstone 617 0 Nov 19, 4:02pm
       Thread Locked Frodo gave responses prior to AUJ's release via private messaging that were all accurate thomasofrohan 640 0 Nov 19, 4:03pm
       Collapse Thread Locked No tsmith675 652 2 Nov 19, 4:13pm
           Collapse Thread Locked Agreed Smaug Report 552 1 Nov 19, 4:32pm
               Thread Locked Very well put. // adt100 493 0 Nov 19, 4:39pm
       Thread Locked No Name 540 0 Nov 19, 4:32pm
       Collapse Thread Locked Very likely, yes Voronwë_the_Faithful 554 1 Nov 19, 4:47pm
           Thread Locked His post history also raises some flags for me. Imladris18 536 0 Nov 19, 5:05pm
       Collapse Thread Locked Oh dear Arannir 529 5 Nov 19, 5:00pm
           Thread Locked Agreed dubulous 434 0 Nov 19, 5:12pm
           Collapse Thread Locked Don't Panic!!! adt100 475 2 Nov 19, 5:14pm
               Collapse Thread Locked We should all put this as our profile picture ;) Arannir 420 1 Nov 19, 5:19pm
                   Thread Locked That would be funny. Elessar 389 0 Nov 19, 5:22pm
           Thread Locked But... but..... dormouse 407 0 Nov 19, 5:24pm
       Thread Locked Just waiting for him to answer my question. Carne 441 0 Nov 19, 5:24pm
       Thread Locked If it's true, I'm done. aifeme 486 0 Nov 19, 5:27pm
       Thread Locked ---> Please post in one of the existing thread below. Thanks! // Altaira 423 0 Nov 19, 5:32pm

Collapse BotFA Running Time caglarkuraner 1371 8 Nov 19, 1:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by caglarkuraner)
       Collapse With or without credits? Fleuz 564 1 Nov 19, 1:16pm
           with credits Arannir 594 0 Nov 19, 1:19pm
       They gawe we ne oglum erdildeniz 497 0 Nov 19, 2:06pm
       SF Norge/Sweden are legit Carne 467 0 Nov 19, 2:40pm
       My theater still says 160, but... tsmith675 269 0 Nov 19, 10:45pm
       Collapse LOL Aragorn the Elfstone 131 1 Nov 20, 4:42pm
           That is a command you do not hear every day with PJ movies ;) Arannir 115 0 Nov 20, 5:50pm
       IMAX! caglarkuraner 26 0 Sat, 6:09pm

Collapse WHAT? a Unique SPOT Andy & PJ have carved OUT... Bombadil 930 3 Nov 19, 1:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bishop)
       Collapse Great point Bomby. MJM 268 1 Nov 19, 1:30pm
         NOT ONLY did we get... Bombadil 237 0 Nov 19, 2:26pm
       To be fair Bishop 70 0 Nov 20, 1:34pm

  Collapse Concerning those who received a download of "Ironfoot" JamesPaganini 684 3 Nov 19, 12:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Hobbity Hobbit)
       Collapse Give it a week or two Smaug Report 215 1 Nov 19, 2:57pm
           I wonder Fleuz 174 0 Nov 19, 4:02pm
       You have to download it from the Watertower site Hobbity Hobbit 132 0 Nov 19, 9:17pm

  Collapse BOFA Spoiler Questions Requested - Answers frodo284 7227 153 Nov 19, 6:40am Jump to last post in thread (by The Mitch King)
       Collapse Very disappointed if this is true. thomasofrohan 2738 4 Nov 19, 6:46am
           Very disappointing, indeed KeenObserver 2503 0 Nov 19, 6:50am
           Collapse Thranduil frodo284 2628 2 Nov 19, 6:51am
               Collapse How well does the film portray Thorin's "dragon sickness"? thomasofrohan 2344 1 Nov 19, 6:52am
                   dragon sickness frodo284 2504 0 Nov 19, 7:13am
       Can you elaborate on Dain's dialogue? thomasofrohan 2296 0 Nov 19, 6:57am
       Collapse If this is true, MatthewJer18 2294 3 Nov 19, 7:11am
           Collapse Bard's role frodo284 2521 2 Nov 19, 7:15am
               How does the Master die, if I may ask? MatthewJer18 2212 0 Nov 19, 7:20am
               Glad that Alfrid finally plays some useful role mae govannen 863 0 Nov 19, 1:09pm
       Beorn Looke89 2242 0 Nov 19, 7:14am
       There are some identical and some really contradictory NecromancerRising 2331 0 Nov 19, 7:14am
       Collapse Spoiling Danielos 2354 14 Nov 19, 7:26am
           Collapse this is depressing boldog 2259 13 Nov 19, 7:40am
               Collapse but if your not a troll boldog 2181 4 Nov 19, 7:41am
                   Collapse I can answer that KeenObserver 2132 3 Nov 19, 7:57am
                     Collapse i sure hope that reference makes the cut boldog 2021 2 Nov 19, 8:05am
                           Collapse I'd venture to guess . . . KeenObserver 1982 1 Nov 19, 8:17am
                               ok This is hard for me to do boldog 1248 0 Nov 19, 8:19am
               Collapse I share the sentiment, boldog KeenObserver 2055 6 Nov 19, 7:52am
                   Collapse Bilbo doesn't finish the book until he reaches Rivendell right? There&ThereAgain 2032 4 Nov 19, 7:55am
                       Collapse That's right KeenObserver 1983 3 Nov 19, 8:12am
                           Collapse writing Mooseboy018 1963 2 Nov 19, 8:19am
                               Exactly KeenObserver 1186 0 Nov 19, 8:25am
                               haha good point! There&ThereAgain 1160 0 Nov 19, 8:32am
                   I hate if Dain is like that tattooed_dwarf 1259 0 Nov 19, 8:19am
               I think that might be quite a specific assumption Spriggan 1962 0 Nov 19, 8:19am
       From the Visual-Companion Book lidlessEye 2212 0 Nov 19, 7:43am
       I hate to say it.... nobofthepony 2186 0 Nov 19, 8:07am
       this is depressing Olorin2607 1220 0 Nov 19, 9:18am
     Need more of Beorn than there was in DoS Glorfindela 1127 0 Nov 19, 9:43am
     Collapse Hold up KeenObserver 1215 10 Nov 19, 9:58am
           Collapse Blog Spriggan 1122 6 Nov 19, 10:38am
               Collapse Oops! KeenObserver 1056 5 Nov 19, 10:46am
                   Collapse No worries but it is interesting Spriggan 972 4 Nov 19, 11:25am
                       Collapse My preference KeenObserver 902 3 Nov 19, 12:04pm
                           Collapse Interesting Spriggan 892 2 Nov 19, 2:09pm
                               Collapse Thank you, Spriggan KeenObserver 857 1 Nov 19, 11:46pm
                                   That's awfully nice of you to say. Spriggan 482 0 Nov 20, 1:52pm
           Collapse I think he just means that the people who die in the book die in the movie. Boromir Stark 1010 2 Nov 19, 10:43am
               Collapse Indeed KeenObserver 969 1 Nov 19, 11:04am
                   Yeah, Thrain II 913 0 Nov 19, 11:30am
       Deleted my earlier response here. Arannir 1123 0 Nov 19, 10:00am
       I am a little bit proud... Arannir 1147 0 Nov 19, 10:15am
       Thranduil? stn5 1063 0 Nov 19, 10:49am
       Couple of questions I'd love to see answered Mithfânion 1006 0 Nov 19, 11:25am
       Sigh... BornOutOfTheWest 1004 0 Nov 19, 11:26am
       Galadriel Nerven 859 0 Nov 19, 1:03pm
       Collapse I come to you at the turn of the tide... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 959 6 Nov 19, 1:04pm
           Collapse So much THIS! NoelGallagher 857 1 Nov 19, 1:15pm
               Agreed. There's nothing too new here Annatar598 820 0 Nov 19, 1:19pm
           Collapse He had seen AuJ... Arannir 844 3 Nov 19, 1:21pm
               so then it shouldnt be a problem for him NoelGallagher 1005 0 Nov 19, 1:33pm
               Collapse wow, you're right Fàfnir 1028 1 Nov 19, 1:34pm
                   actually NoelGallagher 975 0 Nov 19, 1:47pm
       Thanks! MJM 999 0 Nov 19, 1:25pm
       Well damn.. Drakblod 918 0 Nov 19, 2:09pm
       Collapse eh... jackster 919 3 Nov 19, 2:22pm
           Collapse Billy Connolu stated JamesPaganini 991 1 Nov 19, 2:25pm
               I was about to say the same thing! Eleniel 879 0 Nov 19, 2:29pm
           Yes.That is true NecromancerRising 844 0 Nov 19, 2:40pm
       Collapse Questions about Rings and staves. xxxyyy 796 4 Nov 19, 2:55pm
           Collapse You forgot about the flaming and significant matter of NecromancerRising 795 3 Nov 19, 2:58pm
               Collapse im really in a struggle NoelGallagher 767 1 Nov 19, 3:03pm
                   Seems plausible to me. Spriggan 750 0 Nov 19, 3:05pm
               Yeah... those birds... xxxyyy 712 0 Nov 19, 3:17pm
       Collapse Not convinced Smaug Report 874 15 Nov 19, 2:56pm
           Collapse well I believe you are mistaken Olorin2607 834 9 Nov 19, 3:02pm
               I do not remember him doing the same for DOS in public. NecromancerRising 782 0 Nov 19, 3:05pm
               Collapse People are acting like this is The Phantom Menace now... Smaug Report 811 7 Nov 19, 3:07pm
                   Collapse wouldnt you be disappointed ? Olorin2607 775 1 Nov 19, 3:11pm
                       Not at all! NecromancerRising 745 0 Nov 19, 3:14pm
                   Collapse He answered more specifically via messages in 2012 Arannir 793 3 Nov 19, 3:14pm
                       Well to be fair... tsmith675 705 0 Nov 19, 3:51pm
                       Collapse Ultimately though DjU 983 1 Nov 19, 4:30pm
                           not to mention Smaug Report 970 0 Nov 19, 4:37pm
                   Hear, hear...! Well said. mae govannen 556 0 Nov 20, 11:53am
           Collapse Smaug Report wrong Mithfânion 804 4 Nov 19, 3:57pm
               Cue Crunchable Birdses 694 0 Nov 19, 4:00pm
               Ripping off Alexander Nevsky? / Darkstone 1028 0 Nov 19, 4:09pm
               Collapse regardless... Smaug Report 1002 1 Nov 19, 4:25pm
                   one thing we all must remember.... Snowghost77 905 0 Nov 19, 7:41pm
       Collapse Okay, that's it - Hanzkaz 1089 2 Nov 19, 4:24pm
           Collapse This is sad tsmith675 1027 1 Nov 19, 4:27pm
               After the mostly awesome 4chan 'spoilers', Hanzkaz 1017 0 Nov 19, 4:41pm
     Collapse ---> Spoilers have been edited out of subject lines Altaira 1018 7 Nov 19, 5:01pm
           Collapse A small English language question mae govannen 538 6 Nov 20, 12:54pm
               Collapse What you're seeing Silverlode 510 5 Nov 20, 1:37pm
                   Collapse Thanks for your kind clarification, Silverlode! mae govannen 455 4 Nov 20, 2:21pm
                       Collapse Yep Altaira 417 3 Nov 20, 3:30pm
                           Collapse Frodo has not returned Mithfânion 318 1 Nov 20, 10:23pm
                               At some point, for a brief quarter of a second Guert 310 0 Nov 20, 10:47pm
                           No problem! Now I'll know, thank you... mae govannen 331 0 Nov 21, 4:45am
       Collapse If Thorin's gkgyver 950 15 Nov 19, 5:45pm
           Collapse Looks more like an alcove of Dale to me Shagrat 878 14 Nov 19, 5:47pm
               Collapse Why? gkgyver 831 13 Nov 19, 5:56pm
                   Collapse Because Shagrat 825 10 Nov 19, 5:57pm
                       Collapse Yes, but ... gkgyver 802 9 Nov 19, 6:02pm
                           Collapse The main poster for BoFA Crunchable Birdses 815 8 Nov 19, 6:06pm
                               Collapse It's not a montage gkgyver 792 7 Nov 19, 6:10pm
                                   Collapse I know I'm just saying Crunchable Birdses 782 4 Nov 19, 6:14pm
                                       Collapse Soundtrack sample gkgyver 772 3 Nov 19, 6:25pm
                                           Collapse Or MatthewJer18 738 2 Nov 19, 6:28pm
                                               Collapse No, but ... gkgyver 729 1 Nov 19, 6:36pm
                                                   LOL...Right!!! // mae govannen 508 0 Nov 20, 1:01pm
                                   Collapse subject marillaraina 812 1 Nov 19, 8:19pm
                                       I fully disagree with you on everything you say here. // mae govannen 511 0 Nov 20, 1:03pm
                   Collapse Because it provides a nice, dramatic pose for a poster. Doesn't mean it's in the film thomasofrohan 818 1 Nov 19, 6:01pm
                       But doesn't mean either that it is not in the film. // mae govannen 504 0 Nov 20, 1:05pm
       Collapse Well the Dol Guldur details in the post further up Spriggan 752 1 Nov 19, 6:53pm
           Yes dubulous 662 0 Nov 19, 7:08pm
       Collapse Here's what Frodo just posted, detailing the entire Dol Guldur sequence (spoilers!): MatthewJer18 1302 35 Nov 19, 6:59pm
           Sounds good NoelGallagher 721 0 Nov 19, 7:03pm
           Collapse Is Galadriel suppose to be that powerful? nhui06 695 18 Nov 19, 7:11pm
               Sigh. I do hope the warhammer Spriggan 999 0 Nov 19, 7:17pm
               Collapse Changes made I believe Carne 997 3 Nov 19, 7:20pm
                   Could that have been replaced with the scene of him battling Sauron himself in DOS? // dubulous 953 0 Nov 19, 7:25pm
                   Collapse I like the described stuff NoelGallagher 941 1 Nov 19, 7:31pm
                       And great things already in DOS itself, vs Sauron for example.// mae govannen 503 0 Nov 20, 1:25pm
               Collapse Well, Hanzkaz 923 12 Nov 19, 7:47pm
                   Collapse I disagree Name 863 11 Nov 19, 8:07pm
                       I agree. AncalagontheBlack 827 0 Nov 19, 8:12pm
                       Collapse Jackson - Hanzkaz 813 5 Nov 19, 8:33pm
                           Collapse I don't think any of the characters have static "power levels" Spriggan 749 1 Nov 19, 8:50pm
                               Needs to be repeted hundred times probably...! // mae govannen 488 0 Nov 20, 1:31pm
                           Collapse Completely agree with you Name 732 2 Nov 19, 8:56pm
                               Collapse Interesting, so Boyens gets her way Mithfânion 749 1 Nov 19, 9:03pm
                                   No need to incriminate this or that person, they were a team mae govannen 485 0 Nov 20, 1:40pm
                       Collapse If that was the case... Eleniel 759 3 Nov 19, 8:47pm
                           Collapse Getting beside the point of this thread but dubulous 743 1 Nov 19, 8:54pm
                               Quite correct, I would say. // mae govannen 475 0 Nov 20, 1:45pm
                           Sure, in a way. Name 685 0 Nov 19, 9:06pm
           Collapse Doesn't explain Radagast's staff gkgyver 1020 1 Nov 19, 7:18pm
               This is only what pertains to the Dol Guldur sequence... (SPOILER) mae govannen 519 0 Nov 20, 1:53pm
           If true sounds pretty cool to me. Elessar 982 0 Nov 19, 7:26pm
           Collapse Sorry if I'm oblivious here Name 1002 3 Nov 19, 7:44pm
               Collapse It was posted in a thread that was then removed by the mods // Voronwë_the_Faithful 882 2 Nov 19, 8:10pm
                   Collapse Why removed? Olorin2607 555 1 Nov 19, 10:25pm
                       Removed because the thread was redundant with this one Voronwë_the_Faithful 933 0 Nov 19, 10:31pm
           Collapse This sounds excellent if true. NecromancerRising 825 3 Nov 19, 9:07pm
             Collapse 'If true' KeenObserver 708 1 Nov 19, 9:36pm
                   Yeah,we do not really have NecromancerRising 648 0 Nov 19, 9:48pm
               Gleefully agree...! Had the same concern there...// mae govannen 479 0 Nov 20, 2:01pm
           . Nerven 654 0 Nov 19, 9:45pm
           *Goosebumps all over* Wow!... mae govannen 553 0 Nov 20, 1:19pm
           Collapse Three More recycled lines from Saruman and Theoden in The Two Towers and Gothmog in Return of the King :0P... Bladerunner 239 1 Fri, 10:51pm
               Yeah, I know, right? Eleniel 193 0 Sat, 8:44am
     Collapse --> Please remember to take rumors with a grain of salt Altaira 918 1 Nov 20, 12:46am
           At least tonight I'll go to bed happy right now, mae govannen 452 0 Nov 20, 3:03pm
       Collapse Where is Frodo? Danielos 833 2 Nov 20, 4:10am
           its being interrogated by Beorn Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 717 0 Nov 20, 8:37am
           LOL...! At first I was surprised as you seemed to be quoting mae govannen 519 0 Nov 20, 2:32pm
       Skeptical The Mitch King 144 0 Sun, 1:10am

  Collapse DoS Extended Edition went on sale here in NZ today. Moahunter 460 11 Nov 19, 4:27am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Funny how the release dates are so different but glad you finally got it. Eruonen 197 0 Nov 19, 6:03am
       Cool! Kim 184 0 Nov 19, 6:16am
       Collapse Cool! TheHutt 162 8 Nov 19, 8:04am
           Collapse The cover art is the more or less identical...... Moahunter 157 2 Nov 19, 8:55am
               How do the spines align?.. TheHutt 124 0 Nov 19, 11:27am
               MOa..SSOoo. Glad an Old Tolkien Friend like you Bombadil 119 0 Nov 19, 11:37am
         Collapse HUTT, bom is curious JUS' how many languages... Bombadil 125 4 Nov 19, 11:26am
               Collapse I dunno... TheHutt 130 3 Nov 19, 11:29am
                 Collapse NOW? that makes PERFECT sense..SINCE Bombadil 125 2 Nov 19, 11:44am
                     Collapse Now Bomby Avandel 68 1 Nov 20, 12:10am
                         13 Thumbzz UP... for THAT!..// Bombadil 62 0 Nov 20, 1:45am

  Collapse New themes in "ironfoot" The Grey Pilgrim 628 2 Nov 19, 2:08am Jump to last post in thread (by MJM)
       It Faleel 289 0 Nov 19, 2:09am
     I love it! MJM 261 0 Nov 19, 3:03am

  Collapse Early BOTF Review - - SPOILERS at request! frodo284 6201 135 Nov 19, 1:38am Jump to last post in thread (by Merovech)
       What Faleel 2443 0 Nov 19, 1:40am
       Collapse Does it have a prologue? And Thrain II 2469 1 Nov 19, 1:44am
           Spoilers Spoilers Spoilers - - frodo284 2864 0 Nov 19, 1:48am
       Collapse Without going into too much detail... Joe20 2354 1 Nov 19, 1:44am
           Can you say how the Laketown destruction and Dol Guldur sections were? frodo284 2562 0 Nov 19, 1:54am
       Collapse Questions Dcole4 2331 3 Nov 19, 1:46am
           Collapse Questions by Dcole4 frodo284 2587 2 Nov 19, 1:50am
               Collapse Thank you! Dcole4 2140 1 Nov 19, 1:58am
                   Thank you frodo284 2248 0 Nov 19, 2:09am
       Collapse Questions jackster 2254 7 Nov 19, 1:52am
           Collapse Questions frodo284 2467 6 Nov 19, 2:05am
               Collapse Alfrid Faleel 2145 1 Nov 19, 2:07am
                   Alfred - comedy frodo284 2317 0 Nov 19, 2:08am
               Collapse ? jackster 1335 2 Nov 19, 2:12am
                   Collapse Also-last question :) jackster 1369 1 Nov 19, 2:15am
                       Also - Last Question frodo284 1581 0 Nov 19, 2:23am
             FRO284..You might want of Allow people to ask Questions through Bombadil 1335 0 Nov 19, 2:15am
       Collapse Any nods to the future of the remaining Dwarves? Joe20 2171 1 Nov 19, 1:53am
           Any nod to future Dwarves? frodo284 2422 0 Nov 19, 1:56am
       Collapse Can you prove you saw the film in any way? MatthewJer18 2194 8 Nov 19, 1:55am
           Collapse If you look at his posting history... skyofcoffeebeans 2281 6 Nov 19, 1:57am
               Collapse AUJ thread isn't much to go by. MatthewJer18 2085 2 Nov 19, 2:01am
                   Collapse AUJ thread - clarification frodo284 1582 1 Nov 19, 2:11am
                       Put my hand into the final scene/nod to FOTR question skyofcoffeebeans 1333 0 Nov 19, 2:14am
               Collapse Post deleted by tsmith675 tsmith675 2060 2 Nov 19, 2:01am
                   Collapse What points, specifically? MatthewJer18 2050 1 Nov 19, 2:02am
                       Oops tsmith675 1284 0 Nov 19, 2:15am
           Can you prove you saw the film in any way? frodo284 2405 0 Nov 19, 1:58am
       Collapse A few questions The Grey Pilgrim 2150 3 Nov 19, 2:01am
           Collapse A few questions frodo284 2350 2 Nov 19, 2:07am
               Collapse Score Faleel 1308 1 Nov 19, 2:13am
                   Score frodo284 1450 0 Nov 19, 2:15am
       Collapse Question on CGI... NateGate 2027 3 Nov 19, 2:11am
           Collapse Question on CGI frodo284 1528 2 Nov 19, 2:14am
               Collapse What do you mean? NateGate 1248 1 Nov 19, 2:24am
                   What do you mean? frodo284 1435 0 Nov 19, 2:26am
       Collapse Still a little skeptical, but can you describe the Sauron/Saruman confrontation at Dol Guldur? MatthewJer18 1323 10 Nov 19, 2:15am
           Collapse Still a little skeptical, but can you describe the Sauron/Saruman confrontation at Dol Guldur? frodo284 1651 9 Nov 19, 2:24am
               Collapse cliffhanger...? Mooseboy018 1150 8 Nov 19, 3:58am
                   Collapse I think... FiliSonOfDis 1114 7 Nov 19, 4:23am
                       Collapse You are correct frodo284 1462 6 Nov 19, 5:58am
                           Collapse still sounds terrible Olorin2607 1179 5 Nov 19, 6:17am
                               Collapse Strange they'd have the final line of this scene in the trailer then :/ adt100 576 4 Nov 19, 4:03pm
                                   Collapse I doubt it is. Imladris18 573 3 Nov 19, 4:11pm
                                       Collapse I'd have thought it would be a stuntman Crunchable Birdses 549 2 Nov 19, 4:19pm
                                           Correct. Carne 532 0 Nov 19, 4:24pm
                                           Judging from the EE stuff... Imladris18 546 0 Nov 19, 4:24pm
       Do any of the 'lesser' dwarves get a cool moment? There&ThereAgain 1246 0 Nov 19, 2:21am
       Inbox your requests frodo284 1428 0 Nov 19, 2:27am
       Who kills... StarGodziller 1211 0 Nov 19, 2:55am
       Critic reaction?! MJM 1169 0 Nov 19, 3:01am
       About the Three Rings of Power. xxxyyy 1160 0 Nov 19, 3:02am
       Collapse Terrible news Danielos 1279 23 Nov 19, 4:18am
           Collapse What Danielos said KeenObserver 1068 20 Nov 19, 4:34am
               Collapse but still Mooseboy018 969 19 Nov 19, 5:14am
                   Collapse Moreover,he said NecromancerRising 1215 16 Nov 19, 5:30am
                       Collapse I think we are all getting carried away here with this discussion Annatar598 1199 1 Nov 19, 5:34am
                           This guy/girl is pretty legit Joe20 1170 0 Nov 19, 6:08am
                       Collapse Moreover frodo284 1453 13 Nov 19, 6:01am
                           Collapse Fili xeia 1164 9 Nov 19, 6:04am
                               Collapse Fili & Kili frodo284 1430 8 Nov 19, 6:06am
                                   Collapse How was the Azog vs Thorin fight? Joe20 1160 5 Nov 19, 6:11am
                                       Collapse Azog vs Thorin frodo284 1385 4 Nov 19, 6:44am
                                           Collapse no NoelGallagher 1029 3 Nov 19, 7:23am
                                               Collapse ... Saneliur 995 2 Nov 19, 7:27am
                                                   Collapse yes but NoelGallagher 983 1 Nov 19, 7:29am
                                                       BUT NoelGallagher 932 0 Nov 19, 7:54am
                                   One last question by me NecromancerRising 1109 0 Nov 19, 6:15am
                                   spoilers xeia 1134 0 Nov 19, 6:23am
                           Collapse Looks like PJ continues to mess up the scenes we want the most Mithfânion 825 1 Nov 19, 12:21pm
                               YOU HAVEN'T SEEN THE MOVIE. tsmith675 590 0 Nov 19, 4:18pm
                           Beorn AncalagontheBlack 752 0 Nov 19, 2:11pm
                   Collapse While the cut we'll get in Dec. might be 'great' . . . KeenObserver 1140 1 Nov 19, 6:23am
                       If this is genuine Glorfindela 854 0 Nov 19, 9:35am
           Collapse Same dubulous 528 1 Nov 19, 4:19pm
               Unless... Crunchable Birdses 521 0 Nov 19, 4:21pm
       Is Bilbo the main character? Peterthorn of Rohan 975 0 Nov 19, 4:32am
       Heroic dwarf moments? tattooed_dwarf 1049 0 Nov 19, 6:36am
       Thranduil? stn5 903 0 Nov 19, 8:51am
       Collapse Aren't you violating some confidentiality clause ? Fàfnir 957 6 Nov 19, 9:04am
           Collapse . skyofcoffeebeans 924 3 Nov 19, 9:23am
             Collapse I kinda agree with Fàfnir KeenObserver 831 2 Nov 19, 10:11am
                   Collapse what im missing NoelGallagher 741 1 Nov 19, 11:10am
                       Yes, it feels to me like the guy from 4chan who just learned his lesson Fàfnir 737 0 Nov 19, 12:55pm
           You would think so wouldn't you! // adt100 654 0 Nov 19, 1:14pm
           Probably, but... Darkstone 654 0 Nov 19, 4:32pm
       How does Bard get out of jail? // Carne 792 0 Nov 19, 9:46am
       Collapse I'm inclined not to believe you Crunchable Birdses 924 35 Nov 19, 11:16am
           Collapse Rubbish... Arannir 953 29 Nov 19, 11:26am
               Collapse That's...pretty depressing if true Crunchable Birdses 896 12 Nov 19, 11:33am
                   Collapse Agreed. Arannir 846 7 Nov 19, 11:38am
                       Collapse Can't see the strength of reaction. Spriggan 836 5 Nov 19, 11:59am
                           Collapse To be fair though Spriggan Mithfânion 770 4 Nov 19, 12:24pm
                               Collapse It's the other way around... arithmancer 731 2 Nov 19, 12:38pm
                                   Collapse Since you ask (well sort of ask!) Spriggan 721 1 Nov 19, 2:23pm
                                       Orcrist/emotion arithmancer 366 0 Nov 20, 1:59am
                               Well, I'm very open to you offering a view on why it is important, rather than a personal comment. Spriggan 733 0 Nov 19, 2:13pm
                       i REALLY hope NoelGallagher 786 0 Nov 19, 12:07pm
                   Collapse Totally DISAGREE... adt100 689 3 Nov 19, 1:19pm
                       Collapse Nope Crunchable Birdses 642 2 Nov 19, 1:28pm
                           Collapse TBF, I thought AUJ had too much bloat, but DOS was well paced...... adt100 624 1 Nov 19, 1:34pm
                               Well... Crunchable Birdses 728 0 Nov 19, 2:15pm
               Collapse Well, that sounds uplifting macfalk 853 1 Nov 19, 11:33am
                   Sounds like the Kingdom of Heaven debacle Crunchable Birdses 842 0 Nov 19, 11:38am
               Collapse How can someone already know it's the best CGI ? Fàfnir 729 4 Nov 19, 12:51pm
                 you remain my hope,Fafnir! NoelGallagher 717 0 Nov 19, 12:53pm
                   Collapse By now... Arannir 718 2 Nov 19, 12:59pm
                       Collapse I am feeling pretty deflated but the source seems for real Mithfânion 745 1 Nov 19, 1:04pm
                           This is EXACTLY what happened with ROTK! adt100 695 0 Nov 19, 1:30pm
               Collapse Those are the core checkboxes I'm looking for at this point. Imladris18 804 8 Nov 19, 1:53pm
                   Collapse I'm sorry Elessar 777 7 Nov 19, 2:04pm
                       Collapse concerning Dol Guldur NoelGallagher 794 1 Nov 19, 2:09pm
                           I could see that Elessar 503 0 Nov 19, 4:28pm
                       Collapse I get that he has credibility due to AUJ... Imladris18 656 4 Nov 19, 3:18pm
                           Collapse I'm with you 100% Elessar 580 3 Nov 19, 3:50pm
                               Collapse People are calm Mithfânion 547 2 Nov 19, 4:05pm
                                   No tsmith675 537 0 Nov 19, 4:14pm
                                   Doesn't appear that way Elessar 652 0 Nov 19, 4:31pm
           Collapse As much as I want to agree... Shagrat 801 4 Nov 19, 12:31pm
               Collapse the funeral was shot... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 782 3 Nov 19, 12:58pm
                   Collapse Yes, the funeral has been filmed Carne 741 2 Nov 19, 2:49pm
                       Collapse i just hate the fact NoelGallagher 714 1 Nov 19, 2:53pm
                           That would be really, really bad news Glorfindela 398 0 Nov 20, 12:49am
       No zombie Smaug, right? macfalk 861 0 Nov 19, 11:19am
       Kili and Fili sueb1863 900 0 Nov 19, 11:29am
       Seriously everyone needs to calm down tsmith675 677 0 Nov 19, 3:31pm
       Collapse It sounds like you're copying the info we already know sycorax82 559 5 Nov 19, 4:20pm
           Collapse He provided accurate information about AUJ around this time in 2012. thomasofrohan 549 4 Nov 19, 4:24pm
               Collapse I've said this a few times and I'll say it again. tsmith675 777 2 Nov 19, 4:29pm
                   Collapse If he's truly trying to troll this board for attention... thomasofrohan 731 1 Nov 19, 4:35pm
                       The user on 4chan did the exact same thing tsmith675 763 0 Nov 19, 4:38pm
               Also... tsmith675 751 0 Nov 19, 4:32pm
       Collapse The most convincing reason this seems legit Bishop 548 1 Nov 20, 12:32am
           Unfortunately... Merovech 168 0 Sat, 3:02am
       New question arithmancer 473 0 Nov 20, 2:00am

  Collapse Another vent – Smaug Glorfindela 840 18 Nov 19, 1:10am Jump to last post in thread (by Lurker in the Mirk)
     Agree with your whole post Avandel 359 0 Nov 19, 1:33am
       Collapse Agree 100% Name 351 4 Nov 19, 1:35am
           Collapse agree again Avandel 331 3 Nov 19, 1:54am
               lol yeah, although I was just joking Name 322 0 Nov 19, 2:00am
               Collapse Moreover Glorfindela 80 1 Nov 20, 12:44am
                   the EE flowed better than the TE MouthofSauron 59 0 Nov 20, 7:17am
       Totally agree Glaurung63 295 0 Nov 19, 3:21am
       smaug is da sh**z MouthofSauron 296 0 Nov 19, 3:25am
       Collapse Yup, yup MJM 291 1 Nov 19, 3:32am
           WHEN in doubt? Thank Andy SERKIS.....// Bombadil 280 0 Nov 19, 3:55am
       Collapse Absolutely dormouse 246 4 Nov 19, 8:32am
         Collapse Bom izz a Bit Bummmm-ed...But it izz a Tradition Bombadil 210 2 Nov 19, 11:55am
               Collapse Same here, Bomby Eruvandi 145 1 Nov 19, 6:01pm
                   Eru...IT is Somethingie..? Bombadil 117 0 Nov 19, 7:48pm
           So agree Avandel 87 0 Nov 19, 11:05pm
       Smaug more than fulfilled all my hopes Elarie 199 0 Nov 19, 1:20pm
       Agree. Imladris18 143 0 Nov 19, 6:14pm
       Hear, hear! Lurker in the Mirk 34 0 Nov 21, 6:35am

  Collapse Why Thranduil is possibly mad at Tauriel? Hobbity Hobbit 1315 22 Nov 18, 9:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by MouthofSauron)
       Collapse From other sources dave_lf 738 4 Nov 18, 9:32pm
           Collapse He doesn't slap her... Thranduiliel 602 3 Nov 18, 10:24pm
               Collapse So, why did she do that? Kilidoescartwheels 494 2 Nov 18, 11:20pm
                   subject marillaraina 402 0 Nov 19, 12:41am
                 That's a good idea Hobbity Hobbit 336 0 Nov 19, 1:29am
     Collapse She's stealing his valuable screentime and close-ups // dubulous 563 1 Nov 18, 9:44pm
           I'm in agreement with the Elvenking Thranduiliel 519 0 Nov 18, 10:28pm
       Hmmm... Bernhardina 539 0 Nov 18, 9:59pm
       Collapse Desertion. Darkstone 525 1 Nov 18, 10:26pm
           Well said Thranduiliel 488 0 Nov 18, 10:32pm
     Collapse Because she appears in the films when she has no business there? Glorfindela 497 1 Nov 18, 10:30pm
           I agree... Pipe Dream 438 0 Nov 18, 11:06pm
       My guess is that she reminds him of his late wife... sycorax82 428 0 Nov 18, 11:38pm
       Collapse it has to be more than just running off with Lego MouthofSauron 314 3 Nov 19, 3:20am
           Collapse For a second Ataahua 320 2 Nov 19, 3:42am
               now that would definitely be a reason for MouthofSauron 302 0 Nov 19, 3:43am
               So did I! That threw me for a few seconds // dormouse 226 0 Nov 19, 8:33am
       Collapse You do realise that Tauriel is a young male elf, Bumblingidiot 319 4 Nov 19, 4:46am
           Whaaa ?? MouthofSauron 260 0 Nov 19, 7:58am
           Collapse LOL! Poor Kili Elarie 201 2 Nov 19, 1:23pm
             WHY? IZzz Kili Such a FLIRT? Bombadil 182 0 Nov 19, 1:36pm
               LOL MouthofSauron 154 0 Nov 19, 5:33pm

  Collapse "Beyond Sorrow and Grief" track featuring Smaug's theme very preminently Fàfnir 743 11 Nov 18, 7:58pm Jump to last post in thread (by Fàfnir)
       As far as the theme goes I'll take your word for it.... dormouse 316 0 Nov 18, 8:37pm
       I think it's dragon-sickness Hobbity Hobbit 250 0 Nov 18, 9:05pm
       Collapse There's 3 possibilities Name 273 3 Nov 18, 9:07pm
           Collapse Unlikely Fàfnir 262 2 Nov 18, 9:13pm
               Collapse Are you sure you're not just thinking of the Interstellar OST? There&ThereAgain 115 1 Nov 19, 12:09am
                   Just saw Interstellar Fàfnir 12 0 Nov 21, 5:05pm
       Collapse It appears in "Mithril" as well dave_lf 236 1 Nov 18, 9:27pm
           Hmm... That's a great interpretation Fàfnir 200 0 Nov 18, 9:48pm
       I noticed this too... Bernhardina 180 0 Nov 18, 10:03pm
       Zombie Smaug!!! :D sycorax82 153 0 Nov 18, 10:43pm
       Thranduil flashback fighting dragons, and the death of his wife? // xxxyyy 131 0 Nov 18, 11:45pm

Collapse Will Azog acknowledge his son? NateGate 856 15 Nov 18, 4:12pm Jump to last post in thread (by MouthofSauron)
       I'm hoping.. Drakblod 461 0 Nov 18, 4:24pm
       Collapse "Bolg, I am your father!" Darkstone 445 2 Nov 18, 4:37pm
           Collapse I got that robot chicken reference Fàfnir 232 1 Nov 18, 7:26pm
               Yeah, that was a good episode! Darkstone 162 0 Nov 18, 9:29pm
       Collapse To be honest Glorfindela 419 2 Nov 18, 4:39pm
         Collapse Bomzz IZzz..with Glor, on thizzz ONE! Bombadil 351 1 Nov 18, 4:57pm
               Believe it or not... NateGate 349 0 Nov 18, 5:01pm
       Racism against orchs Danielos 361 0 Nov 18, 5:09pm
       Dunno, maybe not Crunchable Birdses 288 0 Nov 18, 5:54pm
       Collapse Well, there are two questions there.... dormouse 290 2 Nov 18, 6:31pm
         Collapse It has been used *spoiler* KeenObserver 377 1 Nov 18, 7:33pm
               Way back when dave_lf 215 0 Nov 18, 7:40pm
       I don't see why he should Fàfnir 246 0 Nov 18, 7:23pm
       I sure hope not... adu 162 0 Nov 18, 9:33pm
       its kinda obvious MouthofSauron 106 0 Nov 19, 3:22am

  Collapse More speculation on Kili and Tauriel - she thought he was dead Kilidoescartwheels 820 4 Nov 18, 3:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
     GREAT Post! "Anna Friel"...Very Sound Thinkin' Bombadil 272 0 Nov 18, 5:30pm
       Collapse Good post - I like your thinking! // dormouse 220 1 Nov 18, 6:33pm
           Well, that's exactly what I meant to write!!! mae govannen 65 0 Nov 19, 1:31pm
       Related - what of Legolas..... Avandel 128 0 Nov 19, 1:45am

  Collapse Opening themes Old Pilgrim 526 2 Nov 18, 3:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by Hobbity Hobbit)
     Interestin'...& think about thizz.. Bombadil 167 0 Nov 18, 5:54pm
       I think that BOFTA will have Hobbity Hobbit 100 0 Nov 18, 9:23pm

  Collapse Language of The Enemy and Black Speech of Mordor? Girdle of Melian 834 20 Nov 18, 11:34am Jump to last post in thread (by Elthir)
       Collapse I think Faramir74 438 1 Nov 18, 1:36pm
           Interesting Reply.... Girdle of Melian 383 0 Nov 18, 1:45pm
       Collapse I would have thought that it would be an indication of her "temptation" Spriggan 380 2 Nov 18, 2:21pm
           Collapse You mean to say... Girdle of Melian 315 1 Nov 18, 3:32pm
               I'm not sure that offers us much clue either way. Spriggan 308 0 Nov 18, 3:39pm
       Collapse Well... Darkstone 344 10 Nov 18, 3:33pm
           Collapse Thanks, Darkstone... Girdle of Melian 311 9 Nov 18, 3:41pm
               Collapse Evil Galadriel Darkstone 311 4 Nov 18, 4:31pm
                   I like your thinking there, Darkstone dormouse 280 0 Nov 18, 4:35pm
                   Collapse I like that too... Girdle of Melian 258 1 Nov 18, 5:02pm
                       I don't think he has. Mooseboy018 227 0 Nov 18, 6:18pm
                   I like that thought dubulous 186 0 Nov 18, 8:08pm
             Collapse Gandalf knows Black Speech SSOoo.. Why wouldn't Galadriel TOO? Bombadil 283 3 Nov 18, 4:50pm
                 Collapse IT would be.."Bone Chilling" to HEAR Sir Christopher Lee Bombadil 209 2 Nov 18, 7:38pm
                     Collapse Here iz a Question? Does David Salo...know Black Speach? Bombadil 182 1 Nov 18, 8:17pm
                           No one knows the Black Speech Elthir 99 0 Nov 19, 1:17pm
       Collapse Galadriel learning Black Speech Elarie 97 1 Nov 19, 1:52pm
           True Enough... Girdle of Melian 80 0 Nov 19, 3:01pm
       Collapse B. S. Elthir 76 1 Nov 19, 3:49pm
           P.S. on my B.S. Elthir 62 0 Nov 19, 4:53pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 878 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.