Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 7 of 794 (293342 posts in 11902 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 794 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Scene of Elrond casting Morgul blade into WitchKing's tomb? TheHutt 1583 29 Jun 18, 8:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Dcole4)
       Hmm... Dcole4 780 0 Jun 18, 8:56pm
       Fingers crossed we see a flashback to the Battle of Fornost Shagrat 780 0 Jun 18, 9:08pm
       Collapse It sounds like one of those scenes ... DanielLB 793 2 Jun 18, 9:12pm
           Yep Shagrat 721 0 Jun 18, 9:13pm
           I'm still holding out hope Kim 582 0 Jun 18, 11:15pm
       How very cool, thank you Earl 689 0 Jun 18, 9:18pm
       Collapse I think we will get to see this scene. Name 654 18 Jun 18, 10:57pm
           Collapse When the Hobbit was announced as three films... Dcole4 643 17 Jun 18, 11:04pm
               Collapse The weird thing is... Earl 617 16 Jun 18, 11:10pm
                   Collapse I think that was done on purpose... Dcole4 598 2 Jun 18, 11:13pm
                       Collapse About that Thrain scene... Earl 596 1 Jun 18, 11:17pm
                           ... Dcole4 563 0 Jun 18, 11:20pm
                   Collapse The High Fells KeenObserver 571 3 Jun 19, 12:27am
                       Collapse Ah yes Earl 529 2 Jun 19, 12:32am
                           Collapse The morgul Arrow that struck Kili... leonmuse 448 1 Jun 19, 5:50am
                               Morgul/ Smorgul Michelle Johnston 372 0 Jun 19, 9:35am
                   Collapse Thats the thing DjU 189 8 Jun 20, 12:00am
                     Collapse Wowie! Like the "Bucket Scene" @ Balin's Tomb..? Bombadil 191 1 Jun 20, 12:12am
                         EDit: Caught by "TheWitchKing"...Oppzz? Bombadil 167 0 Jun 20, 1:47am
                       It does sound like a flashback scene though... Earl 168 0 Jun 20, 2:28am
                       I like it! Rembrethil 75 0 Jun 20, 5:01pm
                       Collapse I think you nailed it Dcole4 73 3 Jun 20, 5:03pm
                           Collapse more of the High Fells ? NoelGallagher 62 2 Jun 20, 6:19pm
                               Collapse I don't think so. Dcole4 60 1 Jun 20, 6:30pm
                                   Perhaps Dcole4 71 0 Jun 20, 6:33pm
       Collapse Thank you for unearthing this Michelle Johnston 457 1 Jun 19, 5:39am
           Fingers Crossed! Laineth 109 0 Jun 20, 4:12pm
       Collapse Sounds like a flashback... Arannir 353 1 Jun 19, 11:43am
           Exactly NoelGallagher 315 0 Jun 19, 12:17pm

  Collapse Sylvester McCoy set for pickups in July, so I guess it will be another videoblog any day "soon" Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 925 9 Jun 18, 7:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ham_Sammy)
       Collapse Source? / DanielLB 453 6 Jun 18, 7:23pm
           Collapse theonering.net Voronwë_the_Faithful 505 5 Jun 18, 7:24pm
               Collapse Thanks Voronwë. DanielLB 466 3 Jun 18, 7:26pm
                   Collapse In London Voronwë_the_Faithful 469 1 Jun 18, 7:30pm
                       Many of the actors are back in the UK Ham_Sammy 163 0 Jun 19, 1:28pm
                   Is this scene actually a possibility? Imladris18 470 0 Jun 18, 7:39pm
               I also read this as ADR painjoiker 216 0 Jun 19, 6:18am
       Collapse Very misleading Dcole4 483 1 Jun 18, 8:09pm
           Yeah. Arannir 372 0 Jun 18, 9:12pm

  Collapse Thread Locked I think the first trailer may be released together with Transformers! caglarkuraner 818 5 Jun 18, 2:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by entmaiden)
       Thread Locked I hope so DaughterofLaketown 363 0 Jun 18, 3:06pm
       Thread Locked flippin' eck.... adt100 341 0 Jun 18, 3:13pm
       Thread Locked Neither will it be PJ's decision only... Arannir 338 0 Jun 18, 3:17pm
       Thread Locked And the award for 27th trailer thread goes to... Mooseboy018 295 0 Jun 18, 4:22pm
       Thread Locked Let's continue the discussion in the existing thread. entmaiden 263 0 Jun 18, 5:02pm

  Collapse Can PJ use the BOFA to save the Eagles' current (bad) reputation? *book spoilers* Arandir 908 23 Jun 18, 12:09pm Jump to last post in thread (by Arannir)
       Collapse Well... Arannir 520 4 Jun 18, 12:23pm
           That rumoured scene would certainly have helped... Eleniel 483 0 Jun 18, 12:41pm
           Collapse About that scene! painjoiker 451 1 Jun 18, 12:53pm
               I have no problem leaving casual movie-goers in their ignorance xxxyyy 386 0 Jun 18, 1:55pm
           Really hope this gets on the EE.. btw, when will we get to know what's the new stuff? Lurker in the Mirk 417 0 Jun 18, 12:56pm
       Yes Name 405 0 Jun 18, 1:13pm
       The Eagles have a bad reputation? dormouse 397 0 Jun 18, 1:58pm
       Collapse Huh? J Pierpont Flathead 346 6 Jun 18, 3:28pm
           Collapse In the book Arandir 312 5 Jun 18, 4:51pm
             Collapse A Far-Flown BombyTheory? Bombadil 291 4 Jun 18, 6:04pm
                   Collapse Well, Bomby. Otaku-sempai 245 2 Jun 18, 8:30pm
                       I'm with you KeenObserver 205 0 Jun 19, 1:01am
                     Why Bomby wantzz Raddy there? Bombadil 183 0 Jun 19, 4:18am
                 I like it!! Rembrethil 63 0 Jun 19, 7:11pm
       2 cents from someone who didn't read The Hobbit greenbalrog 313 0 Jun 18, 6:19pm
       Collapse Yes, this is a real risk Kendalf 145 1 Jun 19, 10:01am
           Not completely. Arannir 129 0 Jun 19, 12:00pm
       Collapse I agree with some others Skaan 125 2 Jun 19, 12:07pm
           Collapse But the Eagles appeared, without warning, only once in the films. Otaku-sempai 96 1 Jun 19, 3:45pm
               Moth or not, Skaan 83 0 Jun 19, 4:03pm
       Collapse Why explain anything? Darkstone 94 2 Jun 19, 4:15pm
           This! Noria 66 0 Jun 19, 7:19pm
           Awesome quote! Arannir 72 0 Jun 19, 8:59pm

  Collapse (With all respects) Mooooooother of the boringnessss!PJ pease give us that trailer! Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1140 13 Jun 18, 11:44am Jump to last post in thread (by KeenObserver)
       Collapse or just some words...!? Silmaril 583 2 Jun 18, 11:53am
           Personally Glorfindela 559 0 Jun 18, 12:29pm
           Yeah... expecially nowadays... xxxyyy 441 0 Jun 18, 1:58pm
       Collapse Hm Arannir 558 2 Jun 18, 12:31pm
           Adding to this... Arannir 517 0 Jun 18, 12:53pm
           The sneak peek WAS glorious Avandel 240 0 Jun 18, 8:23pm
       Hopefully we get some news soon. The warner tv asia channel... Lurker in the Mirk 532 0 Jun 18, 1:04pm
       Collapse It'll come. dormouse 458 2 Jun 18, 2:03pm
           Collapse Hey, it won't be over quite so soon MechaGodzilla 427 1 Jun 18, 2:28pm
               :-) // dormouse 367 0 Jun 18, 2:51pm
       Maybe.. Oleander Took 344 0 Jun 18, 4:25pm
       Kinda feel sorry for You... aifeme 274 0 Jun 18, 7:13pm
       Mark your calendar KeenObserver 229 0 Jun 18, 11:41pm

  Collapse Beyond the Forest Lyrics Faleel 837 18 Jun 17, 2:55pm Jump to last post in thread (by Earl)
       Nice! Eruvandi 420 0 Jun 17, 3:03pm
       Collapse I was meaning to post about this also... Eleniel 442 15 Jun 17, 3:08pm
           Nice try! SafeUnderHill 403 0 Jun 17, 4:04pm
           Collapse For me... Arannir 387 10 Jun 17, 4:19pm
               Collapse The fact of the matter is he wasn't SafeUnderHill 356 9 Jun 17, 4:48pm
                   Collapse Well... Arannir 344 8 Jun 17, 4:52pm
                       Collapse All I thought was SafeUnderHill 344 7 Jun 17, 5:08pm
                           Collapse Me too Eruvandi 313 6 Jun 17, 6:35pm
                               Same here // dormouse 276 0 Jun 17, 6:57pm
                               What Eruvandi said // KeenObserver 268 0 Jun 17, 7:08pm
                               Collapse me three wonderinglinguist 223 3 Jun 17, 10:04pm
                                   Collapse ? Arannir 223 2 Jun 17, 10:14pm
                                       Collapse "Fondness" doesn't have to mean romantic love Eruvandi 190 1 Jun 18, 1:58am
                                           Yeah wonderinglinguist 102 0 Jun 18, 1:20pm
           Collapse I think the lyrics in Feast Of Starlight are different from those in Beyond The Forest Earl 179 2 Jun 18, 2:40am
               Collapse The lines I quoted from the liner notes come just above a transcription of the Tauriel and Kili theme... Eleniel 155 1 Jun 18, 7:04am
                   The liner notes follow the story don't they? Earl 64 0 Jun 18, 9:14pm
       Oooh! Thank you for this... Earl 182 0 Jun 18, 2:25am

  Collapse Interesting find at 4.32, in Vlog 13 boldog 1249 7 Jun 17, 10:52am Jump to last post in thread (by SafeUnderHill)
       um deskp 551 0 Jun 17, 11:04am
       Collapse SEE stuff Fleuz 513 1 Jun 17, 12:06pm
           Dale not Laketown Arandir 351 0 Jun 17, 3:04pm
       Collapse There is another interesting shot at 4:24 Aitieuriskon 399 3 Jun 17, 3:09pm
           Collapse That scene is actually in the film Arandir 357 2 Jun 17, 3:59pm
               Collapse Thanks Arandir Aitieuriskon 296 1 Jun 17, 4:27pm
                   In Blog 12 SafeUnderHill 70 0 Jun 19, 5:02pm

  Collapse How strong will the tension be between Azog and Thorin in the next film? boldog 620 14 Jun 17, 10:07am Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       Collapse I have a few questions for you, boldog KeenObserver 370 4 Jun 17, 10:50am
           Collapse well boldog 346 3 Jun 17, 10:58am
               Imho does not require love at all. Arannir 304 0 Jun 17, 11:26am
               Understood KeenObserver 284 0 Jun 17, 11:50am
               Well technically... Salmacis81 161 0 Jun 17, 7:56pm
       Collapse Zero tension. sauget.diblosio 332 7 Jun 17, 11:01am
           Collapse Hmmm Name 266 1 Jun 17, 12:55pm
               I agree. Arannir 252 0 Jun 17, 1:16pm
           Collapse Can you give examples? tsmith675 246 4 Jun 17, 1:38pm
               Collapse The unnecessary insertion of Azog into a story he doesn't belong in... Salmacis81 175 2 Jun 17, 8:00pm
                   Their relationship.. delius82 146 0 Jun 17, 9:02pm
                   That's a completely different point altogether, though. tsmith675 118 0 Jun 18, 12:44am
               Well, sauget.diblosio 26 0 Jun 21, 6:57pm
       I expect both will want each other dead Elessar 128 0 Jun 17, 9:44pm

  Collapse DOS reached 700m foreign total! NecromancerRising 674 2 Jun 17, 5:09am Jump to last post in thread (by NecromancerRising)
       Collapse Better late than never ;) // Estel78 251 1 Jun 17, 6:23am
           The third film will be released NecromancerRising 349 0 Jun 17, 7:10am

  Collapse BOTFA footage shown by Warners to CineEurope Lissuin 1862 7 Jun 16, 9:45pm Jump to last post in thread (by Demosthenes)
       Collapse Any twitter reports about what was shown? // Voronwë_the_Faithful 742 1 Jun 16, 10:05pm
           One Tweet Arannir 995 0 Jun 16, 10:21pm
       Sounds like a re-roll of CinemaCon? // Demosthenes 642 0 Jun 17, 1:31am
       Collapse Speaking of footage/trailer news... Arannir 228 3 Jun 18, 11:02am
           Collapse Saw that. Appalling distortion and not true at all. // Demosthenes 131 2 Jun 18, 3:20pm
               Collapse Especially since... Arannir 138 1 Jun 18, 3:24pm
                   Yeah. Purple monkey dishwasher and etc. Demosthenes 140 0 Jun 18, 3:37pm

  Collapse Manu Bennett to do pickups in July News from Bree 1407 31 Jun 16, 8:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Poor Manu KeenObserver 755 11 Jun 17, 3:09am
           Collapse Think about SafeUnderHill 458 6 Jun 17, 10:56am
               Collapse I can't imagine KeenObserver 400 5 Jun 17, 12:22pm
                   Collapse "Acting can be tough" Avandel 319 4 Jun 17, 4:05pm
                       That's the nature of the business SafeUnderHill 297 0 Jun 17, 4:14pm
                       Collapse hi avendel Maciliel 276 1 Jun 17, 4:42pm
                           Sure! Avandel 146 0 Jun 17, 9:23pm
                       Likewise KeenObserver 200 0 Jun 17, 8:13pm
           Collapse Hmmm Skaan 399 3 Jun 17, 12:03pm
               Collapse That's right. Mr. Bennett had it worse // KeenObserver 376 2 Jun 17, 12:25pm
                   Collapse I'm not sure it's particularly bad SafeUnderHill 375 1 Jun 17, 12:39pm
                       Good points KeenObserver 257 0 Jun 17, 5:18pm
       oh dear... Joe20 695 0 Jun 17, 3:31am
       Collapse Jeez sauget.diblosio 698 17 Jun 17, 3:36am
         AZOG iz "Taking OVER the Throne" from Darth Vadar...? Bombadil 632 0 Jun 17, 4:56am
           Collapse If anything ... DanielLB 578 1 Jun 17, 6:25am
               You're probably right. sauget.diblosio 420 0 Jun 17, 10:51am
           Collapse why the hate? MouthofSauron 521 10 Jun 17, 8:31am
               Collapse Of course he is. NecromancerRising 499 8 Jun 17, 8:35am
                   Collapse Correct... Salmacis81 213 7 Jun 17, 8:12pm
                       Collapse Right! NecromancerRising 204 6 Jun 17, 8:28pm
                           Hear, hear! // KeenObserver 174 0 Jun 17, 8:31pm
                           Collapse I must say that. . . KeenObserver 172 2 Jun 17, 9:04pm
                               Collapse I agree that Azog was not an absolute requirement NecromancerRising 137 1 Jun 17, 9:30pm
                                 Maybe look @ Azog as a Simple Plot Device? Bombadil 145 0 Jun 17, 10:06pm
                           Collapse Well fair enough... Salmacis81 166 1 Jun 17, 9:06pm
                               First of all, NecromancerRising 156 0 Jun 17, 9:19pm
               Not a fan. sauget.diblosio 426 0 Jun 17, 10:51am
           Collapse It may not be more... dormouse 482 2 Jun 17, 10:17am
               Yes. Arannir 442 0 Jun 17, 10:50am
               ... an early death only to be shown in the EE ;) adt100 378 0 Jun 17, 12:46pm

  Collapse I was rewatching AUJ Calithilel 1661 57 Jun 16, 10:28am Jump to last post in thread (by Lurker in the Mirk)
       Collapse It will be interesting boldog 739 1 Jun 16, 10:47am
           Already getting chills Calithilel 602 0 Jun 16, 1:22pm
       Collapse Thorin's left-hand man? KeenObserver 675 1 Jun 16, 11:22am
           Oh my D: Calithilel 583 0 Jun 16, 1:24pm
       Collapse I think Dwalin is Thorin's best friend Elarie 645 4 Jun 16, 12:19pm
           Collapse I love that moment too Calithilel 569 3 Jun 16, 1:30pm
               Collapse Agree here too! Avandel 427 2 Jun 16, 7:27pm
                   Collapse It comes out in July? Calithilel 422 1 Jun 16, 7:35pm
                       Sad, yes! Avandel 388 0 Jun 16, 8:26pm
       Collapse I love Dwalin but I don’t think Balin was wrong when he said in Bag End that he was sharp enough for both himself and his brother. Noria 618 1 Jun 16, 12:55pm
           My thinking too Calithilel 470 0 Jun 16, 5:23pm
       Collapse Nice observation. Now where's Avandel... Lurker in the Mirk 595 35 Jun 16, 1:24pm
           Collapse LOL Lurker *grins* Avandel 539 34 Jun 16, 3:58pm
               Collapse I do sometimes wonder Elarie 498 4 Jun 16, 4:53pm
                   Collapse LOL unthinkable Avandel 442 3 Jun 16, 6:54pm
                       Collapse Dwalin is so badass with those... Calithilel 436 1 Jun 16, 6:57pm
                           Knuckledusters Avandel 435 0 Jun 16, 6:59pm
                       Dragon Airways? Elarie 380 0 Jun 16, 8:40pm
               Collapse Loved this :) Calithilel 484 8 Jun 16, 5:25pm
                   Collapse LOL "what's it to you?" Avandel 474 7 Jun 16, 6:40pm
                       I KNOOOOWWW!!! hahahhaha Calithilel 453 0 Jun 16, 6:53pm
                       Collapse Hello, Avandel! KeenObserver 304 5 Jun 17, 4:10am
                           Collapse Thank you! *bows* but alas Avandel 286 4 Jun 17, 7:48pm
                               Collapse No, thank you! KeenObserver 241 3 Jun 17, 11:17pm
                                   Collapse *snicker* Avandel 229 2 Jun 18, 1:34am
                                       Collapse *Chuckles* KeenObserver 151 1 Jun 19, 1:44am
                                           *gets a cuppa and makes self comfotable* Lurker in the Mirk 101 0 Jun 19, 11:14am
               Collapse Dwarven insights, Dwalin... and a thought about 6 degrees Lurker in the Mirk 374 19 Jun 17, 9:45am
                   Collapse Thank you! Avandel 279 18 Jun 17, 8:57pm
                       Collapse LOL! This post cracked me up. KeenObserver 243 2 Jun 17, 11:28pm
                           Collapse oh no - love that Avandel 224 1 Jun 18, 1:50am
                               You're a force to be reckoned with // KeenObserver 117 0 Jun 19, 2:54am
                       Collapse Welcome! Lurker in the Mirk 194 14 Jun 18, 12:45pm
                           Collapse Ah - weaponry, badassery, and the (perfectly directioned) winds of the hair wars Avandel 172 11 Jun 18, 8:01pm
                               Collapse Badass hair, curls, and the goodness of rabbit food Lurker in the Mirk 113 10 Jun 19, 12:22pm
                                   Collapse Some of this stuff is really, really funny. I too love the books and the movies, VeArkenstone 68 5 Jun 19, 11:54pm
                                       Collapse heh... just passing time until new news come along Lurker in the Mirk 62 2 Jun 20, 12:22am
                                           Collapse I will be popping in to your King Thranduil appreciate thread ! VeArkenstone 65 1 Jun 20, 4:53pm
                                             Thranduil images, gifs, fanart, humour and more Lurker in the Mirk 27 0 Jun 22, 1:20am
                                       Collapse Appreciated that, thank you! Avandel 58 1 Jun 20, 12:37am
                                           I would love a Oropher/Thranduil prologue! There is much more to VeArkenstone 62 0 Jun 20, 5:19pm
                                   Collapse Swords, elves, and developing life skills Avandel 77 3 Jun 20, 12:03am
                                       Collapse LoL. I do think Orlando Bloom's Legolas may be a tad VeArkenstone 61 1 Jun 20, 12:31am
                                           *grins* - oh, I appreciate Legolas Avandel 60 0 Jun 20, 12:44am
                                       Unrequited squee, Legolas and Dwarven aka Atkens' diet Lurker in the Mirk 78 0 Jun 20, 7:16am
                           Collapse Gotta give you props too, Lurker in the Mirk KeenObserver 137 1 Jun 19, 2:43am
                               Glad you enjoyed that Lurker in the Mirk 91 0 Jun 19, 12:51pm
       Collapse Well SaulComposer 351 2 Jun 17, 12:10am
           Collapse hehe funny :P Calithilel 275 1 Jun 17, 6:28am
               Hmmmmm SaulComposer 317 0 Jun 17, 5:49pm
       Collapse Pls know that I love Dwalin, but there are a few more movies I have seen Lee Pace VeArkenstone 294 2 Jun 17, 7:44pm
           Totally agree re Lincoln Avandel 280 0 Jun 17, 7:56pm
           Definitely both films are must sees =) // Lurker in the Mirk 95 0 Jun 19, 11:15am
       Collapse Hey, I apologize that this thread sort of morphed into something VeArkenstone 60 3 Jun 20, 5:26pm
           Collapse There and back again type threads - Dwalin, Legolas, and no telling where the road will take you Avandel 62 1 Jun 20, 9:37pm
               There & there again... with apologies to the OP Lurker in the Mirk 34 0 Jun 22, 2:43am
           Not your fault :) Calithilel 38 0 Jun 21, 2:54pm

  Collapse Could Radagast and Beorn turn the tide in the BOT5A? boldog 598 8 Jun 16, 9:12am Jump to last post in thread (by TnuaccayM)
       Hm Arannir 310 0 Jun 16, 9:30am
       Imho Beorn's arrival Arandir 313 0 Jun 16, 10:01am
       This sounds like a grin-inducing entrance KeenObserver 294 0 Jun 16, 10:03am
       Collapse Radagast at Dol Guldur, yes. At Bo5A? No. Otaku-sempai 241 3 Jun 16, 2:48pm
           Collapse I agree DaughterofLaketown 176 1 Jun 16, 5:29pm
               actually NoelGallagher 154 0 Jun 16, 7:36pm
           Agree Avandel 147 0 Jun 16, 7:34pm
       I think that Radagast will arrive with the eagles at the battle TnuaccayM 35 0 Jun 19, 2:35pm

  Collapse Could Peter Jackson have kept everyone happy? Avnar 1908 194 Jun 16, 6:46am Jump to last post in thread (by Laineth)
       Wouldn't have keep the studios happy. Elizabeth 896 0 Jun 16, 7:17am
       Collapse No. Nothing would have made everyone happy dormouse 932 2 Jun 16, 7:37am
           Well said, dormouse! Arandir 806 0 Jun 16, 8:18am
           Yes SafeUnderHill 739 0 Jun 16, 10:25am
       Collapse Not likely KeenObserver 755 4 Jun 16, 10:50am
           Collapse Yes, he could have pleased more but never all Kendalf 681 3 Jun 16, 2:25pm
               Thanks J Pierpont Flathead 622 0 Jun 16, 3:46pm
               Collapse Once again you have nailed it :-) imin 325 1 Jun 17, 9:46pm
                   Thank you Kendalf 314 0 Jun 17, 9:50pm
       No – the audience for these movies is too diverse. Noria 712 0 Jun 16, 12:08pm
       It was impossible for PJ and Co to make everyone happy - Hanzkaz 682 0 Jun 16, 1:47pm
       "You see, you can't please everyone..." Darkstone 656 0 Jun 16, 2:40pm
       Not a chance. Elessar 634 0 Jun 16, 3:17pm
       Collapse One word: tsmith675 646 1 Jun 16, 3:28pm
           Agreed Avandel 528 0 Jun 16, 6:57pm
       no one can make everyone happy Magpie 624 0 Jun 16, 3:43pm
       As I said previously SaulComposer 612 0 Jun 16, 4:06pm
       I think these films are already the "mature" version TnuaccayM 574 0 Jun 16, 5:29pm
       Collapse I'm not sure anyone would like my adaptation of The Hobbit, DanielLB 563 5 Jun 16, 7:15pm
           Sounds pretty solid to me. Elessar 518 0 Jun 16, 7:25pm
           Collapse All of the above and...... dormouse 514 2 Jun 16, 7:46pm
             As the Immortal Mick Jaggur SANG? "You Don't Get what you WANT... Bombadil 496 0 Jun 16, 8:07pm
               Agreed! DanielLB 486 0 Jun 16, 8:09pm
           *mods up* // cats16 444 0 Jun 16, 10:37pm
       Collapse In a word Ham_Sammy 417 1 Jun 17, 2:07am
           I agree DaughterofLaketown 406 0 Jun 17, 2:28am
       Collapse How many dichotomies do you want Michelle Johnston 432 8 Jun 17, 5:17am
           Collapse Really interesting to read this. Arannir 403 7 Jun 17, 7:40am
               Collapse My taste, the comparison with both TH Book and LOTR film Michelle Johnston 252 6 Jun 17, 7:04pm
                   Collapse Sorry... Arannir 234 1 Jun 17, 7:12pm
                       I understood Michelle Johnston 259 0 Jun 18, 5:43am
                   Collapse Fate J Pierpont Flathead 282 3 Jun 18, 1:01am
                       Collapse Behold your music Michelle Johnston 267 2 Jun 18, 5:38am
                           Collapse Yikes J Pierpont Flathead 186 1 Jun 18, 3:32pm
                               Silmarillion Page 17 of the hard back version from 1977 Michelle Johnston 178 0 Jun 18, 4:37pm
       Collapse Of course not TheSexyBeard 374 2 Jun 17, 12:13pm
           Collapse LOTR Realism, The Hobbit, And Customer Satisfaction J Pierpont Flathead 375 1 Jun 17, 2:11pm
               Propaganda? No. TheSexyBeard 237 0 Jun 17, 7:13pm
       Collapse It is not his job pettytyrant101 351 135 Jun 17, 3:27pm
           Collapse You must be joking... Bofur01 331 1 Jun 17, 3:49pm
               I dont count background deaths in either set of films pettytyrant101 301 0 Jun 17, 4:32pm
           Collapse Not sure. Arannir 321 8 Jun 17, 4:00pm
               For me pettytyrant101 303 0 Jun 17, 4:26pm
               Collapse Learning J Pierpont Flathead 293 6 Jun 17, 4:41pm
                   Of course. Arannir 288 0 Jun 17, 4:48pm
                   Collapse There's no such thing as 'the wish of the audience'... dormouse 291 4 Jun 17, 5:17pm
                       Collapse There you go again Voronwë_the_Faithful 265 2 Jun 17, 5:50pm
                           Lol Elessar 239 0 Jun 17, 6:18pm
                           Sometimes, so do I! :-) // dormouse 215 0 Jun 17, 6:56pm
                       The Path J Pierpont Flathead 258 0 Jun 17, 5:55pm
           Collapse No, his job was to make a profit for the studio entmaiden 317 123 Jun 17, 4:23pm
               Collapse Yes. Arannir 306 10 Jun 17, 4:36pm
                   Collapse Other classics manage it pettytyrant101 291 9 Jun 17, 4:51pm
                       Collapse Totally fine as your opinion... Arannir 289 8 Jun 17, 4:55pm
                           Collapse Great posts Dormouse, Entmaiden, Arannir. Noria 217 7 Jun 18, 12:55pm
                               Collapse Strategic and Tactical criticism Michelle Johnston 178 6 Jun 18, 4:56pm
                                   Collapse Michelle, I can’t agree with you about Azog, at least not yet. Noria 113 5 Jun 19, 7:17pm
                                       Collapse A Few Years Ago J Pierpont Flathead 107 1 Jun 19, 8:39pm
                                           So would I Noria 103 0 Jun 19, 8:43pm
                                       Your exclusions Michelle Johnston 224 0 Jun 19, 11:41pm
                                       Collapse Postscript Michelle Johnston 199 1 Jun 20, 6:16am
                                           Michelle Noria 186 0 Jun 20, 1:47pm
               Collapse maybe that was the problem Sinister71 110 111 Jun 19, 10:31pm
                   Collapse Reverance Elessar 215 110 Jun 20, 1:19am
                       Collapse there were bits and pieces Sinister71 215 2 Jun 20, 3:11am
                           Agree to disagree I suppose. Elessar 206 0 Jun 20, 3:38am
                           just please do me a favor Cirashala 101 0 Jun 29, 3:48am
                       Collapse Specific Choices as Opposed To Wholesale Condemnation Michelle Johnston 205 106 Jun 20, 6:00am
                           Collapse Re:Specific Choices as Opposed To Wholesale Condemnation by Michelle Johnston Elessar 175 2 Jun 20, 10:27pm
                               Collapse Re:Specific Choices as Opposed To Wholesale Condemnation by Michelle Johnston and Elessar Noria 167 1 Jun 21, 12:19am
                                   Re:Specific Choices as Opposed To Wholesale Condemnation Elessar 167 0 Jun 21, 12:38am
                           Collapse These films pettytyrant101 158 102 Jun 21, 2:16pm
                               Collapse Of course a lot of the changes to The Hobbit movie were choices. Noria 153 7 Jun 21, 3:29pm
                                   Collapse Your right to enjoy pettytyrant101 154 6 Jun 21, 4:17pm
                                       Collapse Being True To The Origins J Pierpont Flathead 140 2 Jun 21, 5:07pm
                                           Collapse I can’t agree with this. Noria 132 1 Jun 21, 8:54pm
                                               The Hobbit J Pierpont Flathead 131 0 Jun 21, 9:15pm
                                       Collapse My basic premise Noria 146 2 Jun 21, 8:31pm
                                           Collapse Nailed it IMO Elessar 135 1 Jun 21, 8:46pm
                                               Thanks, Elessar.// Noria 125 0 Jun 21, 8:56pm
                               Collapse Yes and No some where choices but some where imperatives. Michelle Johnston 113 93 Jun 22, 9:34am
                                   Collapse Imperatives versus art pettytyrant101 105 92 Jun 22, 1:25pm
                                       Collapse Not Walsh J Pierpont Flathead 250 8 Jun 22, 3:20pm
                                           Collapse Well, neither Arwen nor Eowyn pass that test... Earl 243 6 Jun 22, 3:32pm
                                               Collapse Pants J Pierpont Flathead 237 5 Jun 22, 3:42pm
                                                   Collapse I will admit not all the dialogues are great... Earl 230 4 Jun 22, 4:20pm
                                                       Collapse Okayyyyy J Pierpont Flathead 225 2 Jun 22, 4:30pm
                                                           Collapse Yes, of course it is a rationalization... Earl 218 1 Jun 22, 4:41pm
                                                               Okay J Pierpont Flathead 201 0 Jun 22, 6:25pm
                                                       remember also Cirashala 95 0 Jun 29, 4:28am
                                           Quite right, my mistake pettytyrant101 210 0 Jun 22, 5:55pm
                                       Collapse I don't feel you could be more wrong. Elessar 233 82 Jun 22, 4:05pm
                                           Collapse I feel its justified pettytyrant101 217 81 Jun 22, 5:45pm
                                               Collapse Opinions are like bellybuttons I guess Elessar 202 80 Jun 22, 6:29pm
                                                   Collapse Its not a matter pettytyrant101 191 79 Jun 22, 7:15pm
                                                       Collapse Agree to disagree Elessar 185 71 Jun 22, 7:35pm
                                                           That is a pity pettytyrant101 174 0 Jun 22, 7:58pm
                                                           Collapse I would like to see the argument too... Elthir 140 69 Jun 23, 12:53pm
                                                               Collapse It does happen pettytyrant101 131 2 Jun 23, 2:15pm
                                                                   Collapse LOL Elthir 252 1 Jun 23, 4:05pm
                                                                       I liked the script compared to PJ's! pettytyrant101 240 0 Jun 23, 4:31pm
                                                               Collapse I don't have the time and energy Elessar 124 65 Jun 23, 3:22pm
                                                                   Collapse In fairness to me pettytyrant101 121 64 Jun 23, 3:51pm
                                                                       Collapse Same thing IMO Elessar 237 1 Jun 23, 5:00pm
                                                                           That is a shame pettytyrant101 224 0 Jun 23, 5:21pm
                                                                       Collapse Maybe PJ 'gets' Tolkien imin 204 61 Jun 23, 6:08pm
                                                                           I dunno... Elthir 200 0 Jun 23, 6:25pm
                                                                           Collapse Quite possibly pettytyrant101 204 59 Jun 23, 6:32pm
                                                                               Collapse We’ll have to agree to disagree. Noria 175 58 Jun 24, 11:54am
  Collapse Instinct - and where it comes from. Michelle Johnston 180 57 Jun 24, 4:19pm
       Collapse Your perceptions resonate with me too, Noria 169 1 Jun 24, 5:04pm
           Feeling good Elessar 158 0 Jun 24, 6:22pm
       Nailed it Michelle :) Elessar 160 0 Jun 24, 6:12pm
       Collapse If you have been reading through the posts since your last contribution pettytyrant101 159 53 Jun 24, 6:43pm
           Collapse A quick answer on peer pressure and some more Michelle Johnston 145 52 Jun 24, 7:44pm
               Collapse Thankyou for the reply Michelle pettytyrant101 139 50 Jun 24, 8:17pm
                   Collapse Tauriel & Galadriel Michelle Johnston 135 48 Jun 24, 9:16pm
                       Collapse For me pettytyrant101 126 2 Jun 24, 9:59pm
                           Collapse Dialogue & Tone Michelle Johnston 103 1 Jun 25, 4:44am
                               I agree with very much of this, Michelle. Arannir 223 0 Jun 25, 7:57am
                       Collapse Boyens & Galadriel J Pierpont Flathead 120 44 Jun 24, 10:07pm
                           Collapse Motivation Michelle Johnston 96 43 Jun 25, 5:18am
                               Collapse Remedy J Pierpont Flathead 92 15 Jun 25, 5:36am
                                   Dialogue In film always tells us some thing of now Michelle Johnston 233 0 Jun 25, 7:26am
                                   Collapse Have to Disagree Laineth 126 13 Jun 30, 6:13pm
                                       Collapse I think Name 125 8 Jun 30, 6:30pm
                                           Collapse Actually Laineth 105 7 Jul 1, 12:32am
                                               Collapse Ok, perfectly fine reasoning. Name 102 6 Jul 1, 3:02am
                                                   Collapse Yeah.. Laineth 62 5 Jul 1, 6:20pm
                                                       Collapse WC J Pierpont Flathead 60 4 Jul 1, 6:41pm
                                                           Collapse Hm... Arannir 45 2 Jul 1, 9:30pm
                                                               Oh so it's not just me. Name 35 0 Jul 2, 1:45am
                                                               Okay... Laineth 38 0 Jul 2, 5:24am
                                                           Probably :) Laineth 35 0 Jul 2, 12:19am
                                       Collapse I don't understand pettytyrant101 85 3 Jul 1, 2:51pm
                                           Collapse Boyens J Pierpont Flathead 81 1 Jul 1, 3:13pm
                                               Yes Laineth 56 0 Jul 1, 6:39pm
                                           No Laineth 59 0 Jul 1, 6:35pm
                               Collapse Galadriel As Superior To Gandalf J Pierpont Flathead 240 26 Jun 25, 5:57am
                                   Collapse Volume does not equal value. Michelle Johnston 235 25 Jun 25, 7:36am
                                       Collapse Have to response to this as well... Arannir 228 24 Jun 25, 8:01am
                                           Collapse I think we have to be careful pettytyrant101 187 23 Jun 28, 5:23pm
                                               Collapse Don't know what this says about the Galadriel/Gandalf scene... Arannir 180 22 Jun 28, 5:33pm
                                                   Collapse I should have been clearer Arannir sorry. pettytyrant101 174 12 Jun 28, 5:52pm
                                                       Collapse Ah okay. Arannir 169 11 Jun 28, 6:00pm
                                                           Collapse That depends pettytyrant101 170 3 Jun 28, 6:10pm
                                                               Collapse I think... Arannir 151 2 Jun 28, 6:38pm
                                                                   Collapse The difference I think pettytyrant101 151 1 Jun 28, 7:09pm
                                                                       I guess this now really is a moment... Arannir 132 0 Jun 28, 7:36pm
                                                           Collapse Subtle Elessar 134 6 Jun 28, 7:32pm
                                                               Collapse I think Viggo pettytyrant101 132 5 Jun 28, 7:39pm
                                                                   Collapse I'm sorry Elessar 128 4 Jun 28, 7:54pm
                                                                       Collapse I dislike the scripts, pettytyrant101 124 3 Jun 28, 8:10pm
                                                                           Collapse Listen Elessar 121 2 Jun 28, 8:19pm
                                                                               Collapse You say pettytyrant101 116 1 Jun 28, 8:33pm
  I'm sorry you feel that way Elessar 112 0 Jun 28, 8:45pm
                                                   Collapse the past Elthir 85 8 Jun 29, 4:35pm
                                                       Collapse White Council Arannir 68 7 Jun 30, 7:45am
                                                           Collapse Hey old sage figure... don't I know you from somewhere? Elthir 62 3 Jun 30, 11:11am
                                                               Collapse Agreed, most of all this is interpretation and perception. Arannir 166 2 Jun 30, 11:34am
                                                                   Collapse by the wayside Elthir 164 1 Jun 30, 11:57am
                                                                       Yes, I know. Arannir 151 0 Jun 30, 1:02pm
                                                           Collapse Did They Know? J Pierpont Flathead 148 2 Jun 30, 1:48pm
                                                               They knew. Arannir 146 0 Jun 30, 2:21pm
                                                               Gandalf's healing Elthir 133 0 Jun 30, 4:48pm
                   Selected Topics J Pierpont Flathead 116 0 Jun 24, 10:35pm
               FYI J Pierpont Flathead 120 0 Jun 24, 10:16pm
                                                       Collapse Interesting point of view. Arannir 185 2 Jun 22, 7:39pm
                                                           Surely pettytyrant101 181 0 Jun 22, 7:44pm
                                                           This is what it boils down to in the end imin 122 0 Jun 23, 2:55pm
                                                       Collapse You may not be wrong about Jackson’s version of the Cracks of Doom Noria 160 3 Jun 23, 1:00am
                                                           Collapse I believe pettytyrant101 146 2 Jun 23, 12:39pm
                                                               Collapse What I Like J Pierpont Flathead 237 1 Jun 23, 4:44pm
                                                                   I agree actually pettytyrant101 232 0 Jun 23, 5:03pm
       Collapse No, definitely not... Salmacis81 221 17 Jun 17, 8:23pm
           Collapse Tbh,if i were him, NecromancerRising 228 16 Jun 17, 8:33pm
               Collapse You're wrong about that... Salmacis81 374 11 Jun 17, 9:00pm
                   Collapse I basically agree with your assessment here. Name 279 10 Jun 18, 1:45am
                       Collapse I could have done without Aragorn frenching his horse.... Morthoron 231 7 Jun 18, 12:16pm
                           Collapse A fair assessment. Name 212 6 Jun 18, 1:05pm
                               Collapse Well... Salmacis81 189 5 Jun 18, 3:28pm
                                   Of course! Name 178 0 Jun 18, 3:35pm
                                   Collapse Changes aren't bad per se, sauget.diblosio 127 3 Jun 21, 6:03pm
                                       Collapse Interesting how things look different to different people. Noria 100 2 Jun 22, 1:38pm
                                           The starlight speech pettytyrant101 100 0 Jun 22, 2:02pm
                                           Agreed Elessar 234 0 Jun 22, 4:08pm
                       Collapse The reason I used that line of thinking... Salmacis81 201 1 Jun 18, 3:18pm
                           Fair enough Name 188 0 Jun 18, 3:24pm
               Collapse Not true. Arannir 377 3 Jun 17, 9:00pm
                   Collapse Of course it was an exaggeration,but i firmly believe it has some signs of truth. NecromancerRising 355 2 Jun 17, 9:12pm
                       Collapse No. Arannir 339 1 Jun 17, 9:27pm
                           Apology accepted and indeed it is better to move on. NecromancerRising 329 0 Jun 17, 9:37pm
       Collapse *snigger* Of course not grammaboodawg 92 1 Jun 22, 2:09pm
           "If I want the book, I'll read it" pettytyrant101 269 0 Jun 22, 2:15pm

  Collapse Any news from Denver Comic Con? Silmaril 535 2 Jun 16, 6:26am Jump to last post in thread (by Silmaril)
       Collapse As far as I know, nothing major. Arandir 268 1 Jun 16, 8:24am
           Thanks! Silmaril 204 0 Jun 16, 8:46am
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 794 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.