Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 7 of 1002 (358197 posts in 15023 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 1002 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Thought experiment Goblin Mutant 652 14 Aug 14, 4:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Susan)
       Collapse The originality is what gives it its quality... QuackingTroll 576 9 Aug 14, 5:00pm
           Collapse Poor adaptation was your choice of words Goblin Mutant 541 5 Aug 14, 5:17pm
               Collapse I don't think it's a strange way to look at fiction at all... QuackingTroll 504 4 Aug 14, 5:59pm
                   Collapse Shakespear copied A LOT Goblin Mutant 478 1 Aug 14, 6:11pm
                       I wasn't talking about Shakespeare... QuackingTroll 471 0 Aug 14, 6:17pm
                   Collapse The reason adaptations work for movies... QuackingTroll 476 1 Aug 14, 6:15pm
                       It works the same way when adapting a film to the page Goblin Mutant 458 0 Aug 14, 6:33pm
           Collapse That would not turn out well... Susan 361 2 Aug 14, 8:24pm
               Collapse You missed my point. Goblin Mutant 329 1 Aug 14, 8:50pm
                   Ah, I think I replied to the wrong post Susan 269 0 Aug 15, 12:51am
       Those who like literal adaptation Spriggan 502 0 Aug 14, 5:51pm
       Collapse . MyWeeLadGimli 429 2 Aug 14, 6:59pm
           Collapse which characters in particular? Goblin Mutant 415 1 Aug 14, 7:10pm
               Galadriel and Saruman MyWeeLadGimli 397 0 Aug 14, 7:29pm

  Collapse would Battle of the Five Armies had done better at the box office if they had release the EE in theaters 1924 1209 35 Aug 13, 10:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Goldeneye)
       too soon CathrineB 1126 0 Aug 13, 11:04pm
       Collapse I'm not sure... Dcole4 1114 11 Aug 13, 11:21pm
           Thoroughly seconded Glorfindela 1080 0 Aug 13, 11:35pm
           Third-ed? Thrain II 1044 0 Aug 14, 12:00am
           Hear, hear Avandel 1005 0 Aug 14, 12:31am
           PJ also said he was enjoying diverging from the book Earl 889 0 Aug 14, 5:36am
           Collapse Completely agree... Eleniel 847 5 Aug 14, 6:44am
               Collapse Me thinking the same Dipling 796 3 Aug 14, 8:03am
                   Collapse Pointing the finger at the studio Glorfindela 765 2 Aug 14, 8:36am
                       Collapse The 'official' line Shagrat 736 1 Aug 14, 9:20am
                         Oh, sure Glorfindela 686 0 Aug 14, 10:56am
               Well, the critics and most everyone else... Spriggan 740 0 Aug 14, 9:23am
           Above "the" material arithmancer 114 0 Aug 16, 2:40pm
       Hmmm I think you might need to separate the few folks here Spriggan 1104 0 Aug 13, 11:24pm
       For my part.... Avandel 1069 0 Aug 13, 11:44pm
       Let me just say... Otaku-sempai 1024 0 Aug 14, 12:19am
       DOS theatrical wasn't as good as AUJs overall so... squiggle 876 0 Aug 14, 5:58am
       Collapse Until we've seen the EE.... dormouse 665 8 Aug 14, 11:18am
           Collapse BOFA probably sold more tickets than AUJ. Spriggan 631 7 Aug 14, 12:12pm
               Collapse Worldwide Box Office Earnings lionoferebor 555 6 Aug 14, 2:15pm
                   Collapse Yes, earnings - not number of tickets sold. Spriggan 550 4 Aug 14, 2:22pm
                       Collapse Well... lionoferebor 511 3 Aug 14, 3:06pm
                           Collapse Well, not necessarily.... dormouse 493 1 Aug 14, 3:23pm
                               And 10 years of technology with an explosion in home viewing Avandel 348 0 Aug 14, 3:57pm
                           I'm not quite sure what you mean. Spriggan 482 0 Aug 14, 3:32pm
                   Box Office error Goldeneye 61 0 Aug 17, 5:56pm
       Collapse A premature question Goblin Mutant 488 1 Aug 14, 3:28pm
           IMO very good points Avandel 335 0 Aug 14, 4:16pm
       Collapse Mega budget films are for the masses Crunchable Birdses 365 3 Aug 14, 3:37pm
           Being appealing to the masses does not equal being bad Goblin Mutant 351 0 Aug 14, 3:55pm
           The simple fact that all the crew (including PJ) Milieuterrien 286 0 Aug 14, 6:31pm
           The problem is, they didn't... QuackingTroll 285 0 Aug 14, 6:39pm
       Collapse It did fine at the box office... Salmacis81 299 1 Aug 14, 6:13pm
           I agree! Spriggan 231 0 Aug 14, 9:02pm
       A case maybe that Jackson got the Hobbit TE's a bit backwards? moreorless 140 0 Aug 16, 1:56pm

  Collapse Let's talk about Fili's ear lionoferebor 842 13 Aug 13, 9:27pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ilmatar)
       Collapse Not a bad prosthetic Kilidoescartwheels 769 1 Aug 13, 9:40pm
           I know... lionoferebor 731 0 Aug 13, 10:05pm
       Collapse this is disgusting DainPig 739 1 Aug 13, 10:01pm
           Sorry, but I did warn you... lionoferebor 725 0 Aug 13, 10:06pm
       Collapse I hated having to look Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 713 1 Aug 13, 10:14pm
           I noticed... lionoferebor 701 0 Aug 13, 10:20pm
       Collapse Eh CathrineB 680 3 Aug 13, 10:39pm
         Collapse Well Avandel 647 1 Aug 13, 11:05pm
               yes! CathrineB 639 0 Aug 13, 11:07pm
           Speaking of noses... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 638 0 Aug 13, 11:14pm
       Collapse There's nothing there anymore Ilmatar 449 2 Aug 14, 10:20am
           Collapse Try this link... lionoferebor 423 1 Aug 14, 11:21am
               A late thank you Ilmatar 120 0 Aug 18, 12:17am

  Collapse First artworks: 3D BluRay, Collector's Giftset, Trilogy boxes! TheHutt 2247 32 Aug 13, 12:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by grammaboodawg)
       You made my day! Arandir 2015 0 Aug 13, 1:07pm
       Collapse nice balbo biggins 1986 1 Aug 13, 1:15pm
           For ROTK SEE... TheHutt 1948 0 Aug 13, 1:23pm
       Collapse Link fixed: TheHutt 2000 1 Aug 13, 1:16pm
           I really want the statue grammaboodawg 30 0 Aug 27, 12:21pm
       LOVE both trilogy box sets. tsmith675 1867 0 Aug 13, 1:57pm
       Collapse So Thrain II 1864 2 Aug 13, 1:59pm
           Collapse Yeah... TheHutt 1849 1 Aug 13, 2:03pm
               Let's hope so! Thrain II 1787 0 Aug 13, 2:17pm
       Collapse So what do we think the Collector's Edition statue is going to be? tsmith675 1836 13 Aug 13, 2:09pm
           My sources say... TheHutt 1779 0 Aug 13, 2:23pm
           Collapse Not much to do? dormouse 1576 11 Aug 13, 3:41pm
               Collapse I meant not much to do that's worthy of a statue. tsmith675 1559 10 Aug 13, 3:46pm
                   I don't know... dormouse 1501 0 Aug 13, 4:07pm
                   IMO *urgh* Avandel 1237 0 Aug 13, 6:42pm
                   Collapse I also guess Bilbo with Thorin dying Milieuterrien 924 7 Aug 13, 10:35pm
                       Collapse I feel like that would be a huge spoiler for people walking around in the store/seeing the image online Imladris18 620 6 Aug 14, 3:23pm
                           Collapse Not so much a spoiler Milieuterrien 604 5 Aug 14, 3:41pm
                               Collapse Those are good points, but I still don't see it happening. Imladris18 591 1 Aug 14, 3:54pm
                                   Absolutely, Milieuterrien 310 0 Aug 14, 6:14pm
                               Collapse Okay... QuackingTroll 341 2 Aug 14, 5:12pm
                                   Collapse Quack, quack. Milieuterrien 310 1 Aug 14, 6:18pm
                                       Yesteryear release dates Milieuterrien 189 0 Aug 15, 4:05pm
       Collapse Fake? QuackingTroll 1743 4 Aug 13, 2:35pm
           Collapse not an actual photo seelbach 1534 1 Aug 13, 3:57pm
               Hope so QuackingTroll 1525 0 Aug 13, 4:00pm
           Collapse Not a fake... TheHutt 104 1 Aug 17, 3:16pm
               Finally something about the Hobbit that rivals LOTR :) Earl 91 0 Aug 17, 3:39pm
       Luckily we'll get the ones without any bad photoshopped floating heads! adt100 1620 0 Aug 13, 3:25pm
       Yay! Mooseboy018 1381 0 Aug 13, 5:08pm
       Names... Evernight 591 0 Aug 14, 3:56pm
       OK BalrogTrainer 211 0 Aug 15, 2:47pm

  Collapse Leakage...what is the hold up? lionoferebor 1496 18 Aug 13, 5:54am Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse perhaps if it is only two months away... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1397 7 Aug 13, 6:38am
           Collapse That is what I fear... lionoferebor 1383 2 Aug 13, 6:48am
               Collapse It could be Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1371 1 Aug 13, 6:55am
                   This is true... lionoferebor 1339 0 Aug 13, 7:15am
           Collapse That doesn't make any sense. Mooseboy018 1361 3 Aug 13, 7:05am
               well it could be Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1347 0 Aug 13, 7:08am
               Collapse This maybe so... lionoferebor 1288 1 Aug 13, 7:54am
                   something weird is going on behind the curtain Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1249 0 Aug 13, 8:34am
       Collapse lol, Why is everyone always so IMPATIENT? adt100 934 9 Aug 13, 3:29pm
           Collapse 20 minutes Mooseboy018 842 5 Aug 13, 5:11pm
               Collapse It can only be a matter of time before this becomes a defence in court. Spriggan 801 4 Aug 13, 5:40pm
                   Priceless - thanks for the laugh! // dormouse 752 0 Aug 13, 6:08pm
                 Funny, but you are probably right!!!! // Brethil 664 0 Aug 13, 7:50pm
                   Collapse "The Twinkie Defense" becomes "The Twenty Defense". / Darkstone 590 1 Aug 13, 8:44pm
                       I'm not sure what that means... lionoferebor 585 0 Aug 13, 8:49pm
           Because PJ said it was fun to tweak the fans... Avandel 473 0 Aug 13, 10:55pm
           Collapse Reasons! Otaku-sempai 439 1 Aug 14, 12:26am
               And it could be a good thing? Avandel 423 0 Aug 14, 12:49am

  Collapse Radagast - The Original Plan? Dcole4 1111 24 Aug 12, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       completely agree about your tauriel legolas final statement Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1026 0 Aug 12, 11:20pm
       I don't think I follow the logic .. Spriggan 1007 0 Aug 12, 11:46pm
       Collapse Well I don't think so, here's why Kilidoescartwheels 956 3 Aug 13, 12:36am
           Collapse No, the OP is correct... Eleniel 800 2 Aug 13, 6:34am
               Collapse Well they clearly changed it Kilidoescartwheels 465 1 Aug 13, 9:48pm
                   That was pickups Smaug the iron 454 0 Aug 13, 9:55pm
     Collapse I would ask tho - Avandel 930 9 Aug 13, 1:21am
           Collapse I've definitely liked the Legolas style fighting stuff squiggle 910 8 Aug 13, 2:05am
               Hi Goldeneye 327 0 Aug 14, 1:55pm
               Collapse Completely agree. Imladris18 305 6 Aug 14, 3:20pm
                   Collapse One of the things that really pleased me in the original films.... dormouse 301 5 Aug 14, 3:33pm
                       Collapse Yes Dipling 294 3 Aug 14, 3:43pm
                           Collapse Does he? Otaku-sempai 251 2 Aug 14, 8:44pm
                               Collapse Yes Dipling 235 1 Aug 14, 9:23pm
                                   We may be discussing two different things. Otaku-sempai 213 0 Aug 14, 11:56pm
                       Great point, I think that is a large reason why I like the character. Imladris18 291 0 Aug 14, 3:49pm
       Collapse I echo your sentiments, especially this: Glorfindela 744 1 Aug 13, 8:23am
           totally true Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 735 0 Aug 13, 8:31am
       Collapse I'm not convinced that Radagast's role was changed... dormouse 739 5 Aug 13, 8:35am
           Collapse I'd agree with that... what was there for him to do in later films? adt100 576 4 Aug 13, 4:12pm
               Collapse For me - disagree re Beorn Avandel 426 3 Aug 13, 11:34pm
                   Yes – I agree with you Glorfindela 422 0 Aug 13, 11:42pm
                   The First Image Dcole4 413 0 Aug 13, 11:55pm
                   Agreed Thrain II 399 0 Aug 14, 12:20am

  Collapse can you explain me those orc war beasts and Beorn's axes from WETA's Book??? DainPig 575 6 Aug 12, 10:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Defiant)
       The war beasts was just ideas Smaug the iron 539 0 Aug 12, 10:50pm
       Collapse Shame there were no wargs in the battle // QuackingTroll 516 3 Aug 12, 11:17pm
           there should be on the EE Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 498 0 Aug 12, 11:34pm
           there should be on the EE Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 498 0 Aug 12, 11:34pm
           The soundtrack also hints at wargs Earl 400 0 Aug 13, 3:40am
       Buy the book, man. It's totally worth it. :) Defiant 385 0 Aug 13, 4:08am

  Collapse Speculation : RA's Mention of a New Thrain scene Dcole4 1122 14 Aug 12, 5:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by glor)
       Collapse That was probably part of the missing ten minutes Voronwë_the_Faithful 1079 5 Aug 12, 5:59pm
           what ten minutes? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1039 0 Aug 12, 6:14pm
           Collapse I think that missing ten minutes.... dormouse 972 3 Aug 12, 6:45pm
               Collapse We could make a three hour movie Voronwë_the_Faithful 783 2 Aug 12, 8:49pm
                   Or perhaps a trilogy..... dormouse 682 0 Aug 12, 9:50pm
                   Nah Mooseboy018 603 0 Aug 12, 11:21pm
       Collapse I think Thrain II 991 2 Aug 12, 6:34pm
           Collapse *sob* Avandel 528 1 Aug 13, 2:00am
               Agreed... Thrain II 389 0 Aug 13, 10:37am
       Collapse I can't imagine what the point of the first would be.. Spriggan 944 1 Aug 12, 6:56pm
           Not only is it redundant... lionoferebor 575 0 Aug 13, 12:15am
       Collapse it will not happen mirkwoodwanderer 780 1 Aug 12, 8:49pm
           Saruman? Mooseboy018 607 0 Aug 12, 11:19pm
       The Appendices ? glor 178 0 Aug 14, 10:35pm

  Collapse Bring the Press Release on! Olorin2607 915 6 Aug 12, 2:28pm Jump to last post in thread (by Númenórean)
       Collapse Seconded! Dcole4 866 2 Aug 12, 2:34pm
           Collapse i have NoelGallagher 679 1 Aug 12, 4:22pm
               Perhaps it's shy.... dormouse 673 0 Aug 12, 4:23pm
       Collapse What gets me... lionoferebor 521 1 Aug 12, 6:12pm
           exactly... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 492 0 Aug 12, 6:24pm
       nothing... ? Númenórean 339 0 Aug 12, 8:57pm

  Collapse what's the buzz? tell me what's happening! incongruent things... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 922 12 Aug 12, 7:48am Jump to last post in thread (by AshNazg)
       Collapse With regard PJ being 'secretive' about production... adt100 866 2 Aug 12, 8:23am
           i guess so and i understand Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 853 0 Aug 12, 8:30am
           I think them being secretive about some aspects is simply... AshNazg 482 0 Aug 12, 2:07pm
       Collapse I would imagine Spriggan 837 1 Aug 12, 8:43am
           I hope we see Radagast use his cross-eye powers again... AshNazg 479 0 Aug 12, 2:09pm
       Why? Glorfindela 753 0 Aug 12, 10:31am
     The answer to your question is in your question squiggle 742 0 Aug 12, 10:43am
       Collapse beorn was lying Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 601 4 Aug 12, 12:47pm
           Collapse Beorn was NOT lying Otaku-sempai 554 3 Aug 12, 1:27pm
               Collapse I was refering movieverse Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 545 2 Aug 12, 1:29pm
                   Collapse So was I Otaku-sempai 534 1 Aug 12, 1:35pm
                       yes I give you that Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 514 0 Aug 12, 1:44pm

  Collapse Possible reasons for the "R" rating (a bit naughty!) Kilidoescartwheels 831 5 Aug 12, 3:24am Jump to last post in thread (by Eruvandi)
       Absolutely the Dwarf calendar credits!! Elanor of Rohan 618 0 Aug 12, 9:17am
       Meh Gandalf the Green 460 0 Aug 12, 2:44pm
       Collapse LOL! Elarie 317 1 Aug 13, 12:24am
           Oh, at LEAST 3 months! Kilidoescartwheels 312 0 Aug 13, 12:39am
       *snert* Eruvandi 168 0 Aug 14, 2:55pm

  Collapse These are dark days bilbo1997 732 2 Aug 11, 9:30pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
       Funeral? DainPig 685 0 Aug 11, 9:39pm
       Trailer line Mooseboy018 611 0 Aug 11, 10:07pm

  Collapse Eagles / Bats - What Happened? Dcole4 754 10 Aug 11, 9:14pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cillendor)
       Collapse the battle itself could have been a unique thing Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 701 2 Aug 11, 9:24pm
           Collapse Maybe... Ilmatar 620 1 Aug 11, 10:20pm
               all the same could have been done by orcs. even bats carrying orcs Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 372 0 Aug 12, 7:50am
       Collapse The Eagles Shagrat 557 3 Aug 11, 11:37pm
           Collapse Yes.. Dcole4 554 2 Aug 11, 11:45pm
               Collapse That plan Shagrat 550 1 Aug 11, 11:49pm
                   Probably... Dcole4 533 0 Aug 12, 12:04am
       Collapse Sorry for sounding bitter.. Arannir 233 1 Aug 12, 6:39pm
           im agree but i think beorn arrival Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 207 0 Aug 12, 7:41pm
       "What happened" is my biggest question during the battle. Cillendor 46 0 Aug 18, 6:34pm

  Collapse Bifur`s axe Smaug the iron 593 12 Aug 11, 8:51pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mr. Arkenstone (isaac))
       Collapse Doubtful... Dcole4 548 2 Aug 11, 8:55pm
           Collapse And Smaug the iron 519 1 Aug 11, 9:03pm
               im afraid Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 258 0 Aug 12, 7:53am
       Collapse What do you think will happen with the axe? QuackingTroll 546 8 Aug 11, 8:56pm
           great question: DainPig 521 0 Aug 11, 9:01pm
           Collapse I'm pretty sure this is it MyWeeLadGimli 518 5 Aug 11, 9:03pm
               Collapse Link Dcole4 505 4 Aug 11, 9:08pm
                   Collapse Here Smaug the iron 492 2 Aug 11, 9:16pm
                       Collapse That's the one MyWeeLadGimli 403 1 Aug 11, 10:43pm
                           No problem. Smaug the iron 399 0 Aug 11, 10:44pm
                   I thought it was one of the BOFA special features MyWeeLadGimli 482 0 Aug 11, 9:23pm
           I can see this happen Smaug the iron 512 0 Aug 11, 9:06pm

  Collapse Looks like a sneak peek of EE was shown today JamesPaganini 1504 9 Aug 11, 8:21pm Jump to last post in thread (by Vila)
       so its likely that rumours will begin spreading? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1398 0 Aug 11, 8:34pm
       Chariot Sequence Dcole4 1348 0 Aug 11, 8:48pm
       Collapse It is time Olorin2607 1291 3 Aug 11, 9:04pm
           Collapse AGREED! Dcole4 1275 2 Aug 11, 9:06pm
               Collapse but what has to do the cinema list ? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1236 1 Aug 11, 9:15pm
                   Press Dcole4 1232 0 Aug 11, 9:16pm
     Collapse Typical Avandel 1080 1 Aug 11, 10:28pm
           lol, because they are the people that make, pay for and market the films for US! adt100 693 0 Aug 12, 8:27am
       It was the chariot scene Vila 115 0 Aug 15, 9:17pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 1002 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.