Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 7 of 974 (349578 posts in 14605 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 974 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Surprisingly canonical film deviations marary 1328 40 Apr 2, 7:56am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       There are lots of lines of dialogue... AshNazg 1097 0 Apr 2, 1:33pm
       Interesting observation re: Fili & Kili Kilidoescartwheels 1097 0 Apr 2, 1:39pm
       Collapse Yes.... dormouse 1075 3 Apr 2, 2:07pm
           Collapse The Thranduil-Thorin scene marary 1044 2 Apr 2, 2:57pm
               Yes, I can imagine just how they would say that! // dormouse 1028 0 Apr 2, 2:59pm
               don't remind me... Mooseboy018 925 0 Apr 2, 5:56pm
       book to movie and back again lionoferebor 940 0 Apr 2, 5:37pm
       Collapse Another... CathrineB 924 1 Apr 2, 5:54pm
           *weeps* marary 912 0 Apr 2, 6:07pm
       Thorin Faleel 920 0 Apr 2, 5:55pm
       Totally agree shadowdog 895 0 Apr 2, 6:24pm
       Collapse In AUJ... BlackFox 860 1 Apr 2, 7:25pm
           Good one! marary 837 0 Apr 2, 7:42pm
       Collapse My favorite is the golden cup - Brethil 854 20 Apr 2, 7:32pm
           Collapse In the credits... CathrineB 837 19 Apr 2, 7:48pm
             Collapse Oh, now I have to look for that. NICE! // Brethil 812 18 Apr 2, 8:03pm
                   Collapse A few more out-of-place quotes marary 796 10 Apr 2, 8:45pm
                       Collapse Legolas defying gravity in canon? Sure! arithmancer 721 8 Apr 2, 11:38pm
                           Collapse Legolas walking on snow was used in LOTR marary 378 7 Apr 3, 8:47am
                               Collapse It's debatable. arithmancer 349 1 Apr 3, 11:54am
                                   wow, interesting! marary 333 0 Apr 3, 12:51pm
                               Collapse Tauriel has a lot of the Silmarillion about her.... dormouse 325 1 Apr 3, 1:18pm
                                   Thanks! marary 320 0 Apr 3, 1:27pm
                               Collapse Found it! Bombadil 285 2 Apr 3, 3:57pm
                                   Collapse nice find! marary 277 1 Apr 3, 4:04pm
                                       Also, Gollum paddles his boat without making a ripple... AshNazg 278 0 Apr 3, 4:06pm
                       Yes, that line is very touching in that place. And how it is delivered. // Brethil 397 0 Apr 3, 2:46am
                   Collapse Here's a screencap BlackFox 788 6 Apr 2, 8:59pm
                       Collapse Yup CathrineB 771 1 Apr 2, 9:14pm
                           Catherine, THAT is a great and fun catch. Makes me smile, it does. Thanks! // Brethil 753 0 Apr 2, 9:35pm
                     Collapse Very cool BF! Nice image hunting. // Brethil 754 1 Apr 2, 9:34pm
                         Heh... BlackFox 364 0 Apr 3, 9:23am
                       Collapse You should post that one... arithmancer 715 1 Apr 2, 11:41pm
                           "To think that I've Lived long enough to be... Bombadil 692 0 Apr 3, 1:15am
       Collapse Oin and Gloin Smaug the iron 338 2 Apr 3, 12:41pm
           Collapse Oin will get it Goin,... Gloin will get it Glowing" Bombadil 267 1 Apr 3, 4:08pm
               Oin seemed rather appreciative of Tauriel's "glowing" marary 260 0 Apr 3, 4:27pm
       Collapse prophecy Smaug the iron 312 2 Apr 3, 1:57pm
           Collapse good one! marary 296 1 Apr 3, 2:49pm
             PJ has the Rights & "The Right" to...use Bombadil 212 0 Apr 4, 12:38am

  Collapse How would Bard go against Azog/Bolg? boldog 433 3 Apr 2, 1:25am Jump to last post in thread (by squiggle)
       Thankfully he never had to... dormouse 316 0 Apr 2, 12:42pm
       Well he did take on a dragon Kilidoescartwheels 299 0 Apr 2, 1:42pm
       More so against Bolg than Azog squiggle 149 0 Apr 6, 5:17am

  Moved: Details of the Hobbit Trilogy EE Box Set! dernwyn - - Apr 1, 9:13pm Jump to last post in thread (by dernwyn)

  Collapse Top 10 Smaug the iron 898 20 Apr 1, 5:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       I'll list mine chronologically BlackFox 807 0 Apr 1, 6:18pm
       Here's mine... Elutherian 789 0 Apr 1, 6:30pm
     Argh...subject to change without notice Avandel 715 0 Apr 1, 8:33pm
       Now that is quite a difficult question, but I will try my best... Gianna 616 0 Apr 2, 1:29am
       Collapse Only 10? lionoferebor 597 1 Apr 2, 2:15am
           The Eagles arrive Kilidoescartwheels 505 0 Apr 2, 1:33pm
       Top ten scenes... Brethil 597 0 Apr 2, 2:21am
       in no particular order marary 568 0 Apr 2, 5:42am
       Oh, why the deaths??? Kilidoescartwheels 509 0 Apr 2, 1:32pm
       Mine CathrineB 475 0 Apr 2, 4:07pm
       Here goes. Macfeast 397 0 Apr 3, 8:44am
       Collapse I'm useless at this.... dormouse 392 7 Apr 3, 10:16am
         I forgot that one! // Brethil 361 0 Apr 3, 4:16pm
           Collapse No Riddles in the Dark? No Good morning? VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 353 5 Apr 3, 6:09pm
               Collapse I know.... dormouse 351 4 Apr 3, 6:26pm
                   Collapse These films were such disappointments! VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 351 3 Apr 3, 6:28pm
                       Collapse Mmmm..... Shame, wasn't it? dormouse 341 2 Apr 3, 6:52pm
                         Collapse Hoom, hm! BlackFox 329 1 Apr 3, 7:29pm
                               Mmmm.... dormouse 264 0 Apr 4, 3:28pm
       Tough choices Jeffrodo 282 0 Apr 4, 1:06pm

Collapse Alfrid Lickspittle & Grima Wormtongue Bombadil 802 17 Apr 1, 5:34pm Jump to last post in thread (by squiggle)
       Collapse eyebrows marary 721 1 Apr 1, 6:34pm
         I laughed inappropriately loud at this! // BlackFox 652 0 Apr 1, 8:17pm
       Collapse Grima seems uglier, but look again Milieuterrien 672 1 Apr 1, 8:00pm
           Alfrid doesn't remind me of Grima S˙leth 583 0 Apr 1, 9:56pm
       Collapse Alfrid is a simple toady while Grima is a man with a plan Eruonen 669 2 Apr 1, 8:05pm
           Cronies with 'Forked Tongues' . . . chauvelin2000 644 0 Apr 1, 8:24pm
           Absolutely. Milieuterrien 638 0 Apr 1, 8:26pm
       Collapse I think Grima was more complex as a character Greenwood Hobbit 562 1 Apr 1, 10:30pm
         One Shared aspect..Sociopath Bombadil 454 0 Apr 2, 1:22pm
       Collapse Alfrid is a bargain bin Grima The Grey Pilgrim 436 7 Apr 2, 2:53pm
         Collapse Just finished the LOTR, One MORE time? Bombadil 357 6 Apr 3, 6:51pm
             Collapse Alfrid's Fore-Told Demise..? Bombadil 312 5 Apr 4, 10:47am
                   Well, apparently he was supposed to.. Bofur01 308 0 Apr 4, 11:26am
                   Collapse Done in by G. Otaku-sempai 308 2 Apr 4, 11:27am
                     Collapse Gollum Kills Alfrid !!! He eats him whole..?// Bombadil 273 1 Apr 5, 12:11am
                           Could be. Otaku-sempai 259 0 Apr 5, 5:15am
                   I thought Alfrid was a worthwhile character in DOS, particularly ee squiggle 257 0 Apr 5, 5:42am

  Collapse BOFA Character Connections: An Interactive Infographic BlackFox 585 10 Apr 1, 12:35pm Jump to last post in thread (by AshNazg)
       Meh CathrineB 428 0 Apr 1, 7:57pm
       Collapse I'm confused... lionoferebor 372 8 Apr 1, 10:33pm
           Collapse Have you seen the film?? AshNazg 370 7 Apr 1, 10:38pm
               Collapse Of course I've seen the films....several times lionoferebor 360 2 Apr 1, 11:06pm
                   My thoughts exactly CathrineB 342 0 Apr 1, 11:25pm
                   I was being ironic, by the way... AshNazg 334 0 Apr 2, 12:02am
               Collapse Laketown extras lionoferebor 351 3 Apr 1, 11:15pm
                   Collapse I'm quite fond of her. Does she have a name? AshNazg 333 2 Apr 2, 12:06am
                       Collapse She's does. Silverlode 329 1 Apr 2, 12:19am
                           Oh wow! AshNazg 321 0 Apr 2, 12:31am

  Collapse Favorite OST track Skaan 569 13 Apr 1, 12:13pm Jump to last post in thread (by Smaug the iron)
       My top favorites Brethil 511 0 Apr 1, 12:50pm
       My Top 3: Silmaril 489 0 Apr 1, 1:22pm
       So many! Smaug the iron 467 0 Apr 1, 2:15pm
       Top 5 macfalk 392 0 Apr 1, 7:38pm
       Collapse I'm often surprised Lindele 378 1 Apr 1, 8:36pm
           You are right Skaan 327 0 Apr 1, 10:20pm
       OST makes me laugh... CathrineB 366 0 Apr 1, 9:04pm
       Collapse For each film The Grey Pilgrim 270 5 Apr 2, 2:54pm
           Collapse Does anyone know... marary 254 4 Apr 2, 3:35pm
               Collapse Yoy can hear it in Smaug the iron 249 3 Apr 2, 3:50pm
                   Thanks! :) marary 246 0 Apr 2, 3:52pm
                   Collapse Am I right in calling it... Bofur01 241 1 Apr 2, 4:33pm
                       Don┤t know Smaug the iron 235 0 Apr 2, 4:51pm

  Collapse The Hobbit Survey (Part 2 of 3) grimbeorn15 576 10 Apr 1, 1:24am Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Collapse The link does not work lionoferebor 513 2 Apr 1, 1:33am
           Done! // Eleniel 436 0 Apr 1, 6:53am
           Awesome thanks! grimbeorn15 303 0 Apr 1, 9:18pm
       Done! Nice survey, very comprehensive. // Brethil 504 0 Apr 1, 1:35am
       Done! // Gianna 504 0 Apr 1, 1:36am
       I added a clickable link to the original post entmaiden 495 0 Apr 1, 2:17am
       Done! BlackFox 408 0 Apr 1, 9:28am
       Collapse Done! MyWeeLadGimli 261 1 Apr 2, 3:13am
           Done! Well, Done by Whoever made it// Bombadil 227 0 Apr 2, 1:47pm
       Well I think I got blown out Kilidoescartwheels 229 0 Apr 2, 1:59pm

  Collapse Ok dumb question....what are the five armies exactly? Jeffrodo 520 4 Mar 31, 11:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       Collapse Three official and correct answers... AshNazg 504 1 Mar 31, 11:26pm
           Jackson's option is interesting Milieuterrien 359 0 Apr 1, 10:42am
       Definitely not a dumb question. Mooseboy018 452 0 Apr 1, 12:52am
       Everyone's wrong. The fifth army is... QuackingTroll 264 0 Apr 1, 7:41pm

  Collapse Radagast Smaug the iron 460 1 Mar 31, 9:22pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Could be. Otaku-sempai 428 0 Mar 31, 9:51pm

  Collapse Geography error between DOS and BOFA Goldeneye 1189 42 Mar 31, 7:16pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       Another one! Otaku-sempai 1044 0 Mar 31, 8:05pm
       Collapse And how far is Esgaroth from Erebor anyway...? marary 1028 12 Mar 31, 8:16pm
           Collapse Esgaroth to Erebor Otaku-sempai 976 11 Mar 31, 9:04pm
               Ack! Typo! Otaku-sempai 933 0 Mar 31, 9:55pm
               Collapse I didn't feel Thorin's trip to Erebor took only one day Milieuterrien 496 9 Apr 1, 5:51pm
                   It did BlackFox 481 0 Apr 1, 6:12pm
                   Collapse Sorry, you are mistaken Otaku-sempai 458 7 Apr 1, 6:46pm
                       Collapse I also heard that and asked myself about it Milieuterrien 345 3 Apr 1, 7:27pm
                           Collapse It seems pretty straightforward on screen. Otaku-sempai 345 2 Apr 1, 7:32pm
                               Collapse Most probably, P Jackson felt that the audience wouldn't show patience Milieuterrien 330 1 Apr 1, 8:18pm
                                   Time Compression Otaku-sempai 237 0 Apr 2, 12:03pm
                       Collapse Missing Day lionoferebor 266 2 Apr 2, 5:53am
                           Collapse Possibly, but Thorin is in a rush. Otaku-sempai 218 1 Apr 2, 1:00pm
                               It's all I got at the moment lionoferebor 206 0 Apr 2, 1:46pm
       Collapse Well, that's one way of spiking the fan editors, isn't it! ;-) dormouse 907 3 Mar 31, 10:39pm
           Collapse *sigh* Goldeneye 857 2 Mar 31, 11:56pm
               Same reason the trolls are unaffected by the sun // AshNazg 839 0 Apr 1, 12:08am
               When The Hobbit was two movies.... dormouse 729 0 Apr 1, 7:53am
       Collapse two suns Mooseboy018 820 1 Apr 1, 12:54am
           Were? Smaug the iron 537 0 Apr 1, 4:44pm
       Collapse That's pure movie-making need Milieuterrien 686 4 Apr 1, 11:28am
           Collapse Noted the lunar phase discrepency weeks ago. Otaku-sempai 623 3 Apr 1, 2:35pm
               Collapse It's a bit annoying, because they changed Thror's map... AshNazg 573 2 Apr 1, 4:04pm
                   Collapse The Secret Door Otaku-sempai 557 1 Apr 1, 4:22pm
                       The fact is you can't have any 'good moon' Milieuterrien 511 0 Apr 1, 5:32pm
       Collapse Hadn't noticed that before I don't recall Elessar 626 11 Apr 1, 2:48pm
           Collapse Ditto Avandel 594 10 Apr 1, 3:52pm
               Collapse avandel Goldeneye 554 5 Apr 1, 4:26pm
                   Collapse Just take out the DoS shots where it's visible? Bofur01 521 1 Apr 1, 5:21pm
                       DOS shots Goldeneye 488 0 Apr 1, 6:06pm
                 Collapse For you - Avandel 301 2 Apr 1, 11:09pm
                       Collapse That sums it up for me. // Brethil 290 1 Apr 1, 11:22pm
                           For me too Ilmatar 266 0 Apr 2, 5:51am
               Collapse ROFLOL lionoferebor 355 3 Apr 1, 7:22pm
                 Collapse Questions! Questions that need anwering! Avandel 302 2 Apr 1, 10:54pm
                       You and me both lionoferebor 292 0 Apr 1, 11:18pm
                       Since basically the only other shot of them searching... Bofur01 289 0 Apr 1, 11:26pm
       Another victory for Ralph Waldo Emerson // VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 572 0 Apr 1, 4:03pm
       Collapse Man alive! Spriggan 297 2 Apr 1, 11:31pm
           No - really? // dormouse 233 0 Apr 2, 12:34pm
         No way! // BlackFox 226 0 Apr 2, 12:50pm
       It might just be due to confusing directions beteen our normal compass points and the Eruonen 204 0 Apr 2, 2:22pm

  Collapse Thorin vs Boromir Smaug the iron 1044 29 Mar 31, 2:09pm Jump to last post in thread (by GhostofMacbeth)
       Tough call! marary 906 0 Mar 31, 2:34pm
       Boromir tsmith675 873 0 Mar 31, 3:16pm
       Thorin's death Skaan 852 0 Mar 31, 3:41pm
       They were both so good. RosieLass 787 0 Mar 31, 5:19pm
       Collapse I can't choose! arithmancer 783 1 Mar 31, 5:22pm
           I have it the same way with The Hobbit BlackFox 403 0 Apr 1, 8:15pm
       Collapse Boromir Aragorn the Elfstone 781 8 Mar 31, 5:32pm
           Indeed Elessar 727 0 Mar 31, 6:48pm
           Why? shadowdog 716 0 Mar 31, 7:00pm
           Collapse Can you imagine if Boromir's madness was handled like Thorin's? AshNazg 611 5 Apr 1, 12:01am
               Collapse Caring about Boromir Elizabeth 540 4 Apr 1, 7:15am
                   Collapse Boromir's character Roheryn1 512 3 Apr 1, 10:46am
                       I often think... Aragorn the Elfstone 510 0 Apr 1, 11:01am
                       Collapse boromir....so misunderstood by many readers ElendilTheShort 455 1 Apr 1, 5:02pm
                           Couldn't agree more if I tried! elf-lady 431 0 Apr 1, 5:58pm
       Collapse For me, Boromir's by a mile emre43 680 2 Mar 31, 8:40pm
           Collapse Not stupid Kim 652 1 Mar 31, 9:58pm
               Agree lionoferebor 588 0 Apr 1, 1:01am
       Thorin by a mile Kim 650 0 Mar 31, 10:01pm
       Thorin's, without a doubt! Old Toby 554 0 Apr 1, 4:44am
       Collapse I can't forget Milieuterrien 396 8 Apr 1, 8:54pm
           Collapse Tolkien trouble marary 339 5 Apr 2, 5:57am
               Collapse There's no dragon sickness in the book Milieuterrien 165 4 Apr 2, 10:22pm
                   Bingo marary 156 0 Apr 2, 10:39pm
                   Dragon-sickness Otaku-sempai 145 0 Apr 3, 12:44am
                   Collapse One of the most agressive examples of the "retelling" aspect of the films... Aragorn the Elfstone 143 1 Apr 3, 1:21am
                       Boromir all the way GhostofMacbeth 109 0 Apr 4, 2:48am
           if boromir was turning dark ElendilTheShort 322 0 Apr 2, 8:06am
           Well put! BlackFox 303 0 Apr 2, 11:25am

  An Unexpected Journey . . . (Part 2) chauvelin2000 459 0 Mar 31, 12:03am Jump to last post in thread (by chauvelin2000)

  Collapse Your favorite line. Smaug the iron 886 19 Mar 30, 7:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Adrianna)
       Collapse If more people valued home... CathrineB 804 1 Mar 30, 8:22pm
           This greenbalrog 749 0 Mar 30, 9:16pm
       Collapse Mine is... Iarhen 795 1 Mar 30, 8:31pm
           Was that in the book? He is a wizard, you know! 759 0 Mar 30, 9:07pm
       Mine... Elutherian 748 0 Mar 30, 9:19pm
       Too many to choose Avandel 737 0 Mar 30, 9:29pm
       Collapse Not as familiar with the book, but I'll try Kilidoescartwheels 731 1 Mar 30, 9:34pm
           actually Smaug the iron 720 0 Mar 30, 9:53pm
       Bilbo's quote CathrineB 697 0 Mar 30, 10:42pm
       1) "In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit." (sigh) Lissuin 600 0 Mar 31, 4:15am
       So many fine lines to choose from... BlackFox 540 0 Mar 31, 8:04am
       Not your usual suspect! Timdalf 488 0 Mar 31, 12:03pm
       Collapse You're a very fine person, Mr. Baggins. Arannir 486 3 Mar 31, 12:09pm
           Indeed! VoronwŰ_the_Faithful 476 0 Mar 31, 12:35pm
           Collapse Yes, to this.... dormouse 469 1 Mar 31, 12:52pm
               That is a great line. Elessar 425 0 Mar 31, 4:17pm
       My favourite line Gianna 412 0 Mar 31, 5:14pm
       Collapse to be completely honest... marary 403 1 Mar 31, 5:30pm
           There are several Adrianna 272 0 Apr 2, 7:41am

  Collapse Trolls in the Battle - how did that work? Kilidoescartwheels 970 25 Mar 30, 7:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by Spriggan)
       Different Species gliido 856 0 Mar 30, 7:57pm
       Hmm... Starglass 855 0 Mar 30, 7:57pm
       Olog Hai MadgeBishop 770 0 Mar 30, 10:13pm
       Collapse Indirect Sunlight? Otaku-sempai 764 15 Mar 30, 10:21pm
           missed opportunities Mooseboy018 755 0 Mar 30, 10:42pm
           Collapse What of goblins and orcs? lionoferebor 422 13 Apr 1, 1:24am
               Collapse book or film Elthir 382 6 Apr 1, 11:37am
                   Collapse I just made a gigantic list of every reference AshNazg 351 4 Apr 1, 1:54pm
                       Collapse I'll try again... AshNazg 328 3 Apr 1, 3:03pm
                           Collapse Trolls at the black gate. Smaug the iron 313 1 Apr 1, 3:47pm
                               As I said, those trolls are sheltered by Mordor's smog AshNazg 307 0 Apr 1, 3:54pm
                           Gave troll Smaug the iron 274 0 Apr 1, 4:21pm
                   Awesome layout of things Elessar 334 0 Apr 1, 2:28pm
               Collapse Common Orcs vs. Elite Soldiers Otaku-sempai 351 5 Apr 1, 1:38pm
                   If this was Facebook Elessar 328 0 Apr 1, 2:32pm
                   Collapse the word goblin Elthir 298 3 Apr 1, 4:03pm
                       Collapse Goblin vs. Orc Otaku-sempai 280 2 Apr 1, 4:14pm
                           Collapse Orc versus goblin Elthir 270 1 Apr 1, 4:29pm
                               "orc" users Elthir 243 0 Apr 1, 5:32pm
       Collapse I think he didn't really care Bishop 733 3 Mar 30, 11:17pm
           Collapse I think it's result of unfortunate cinematography changes... AshNazg 722 1 Mar 30, 11:41pm
               The original battle was also by day. Otaku-sempai 544 0 Mar 31, 2:02pm
           'His arm has grown long.' Otaku-sempai 545 0 Mar 31, 1:52pm
       I took it that they're different breeds of Trolls Elessar 538 0 Mar 31, 2:08pm
       If you find out, you could tell Hurin? Spriggan 113 0 Apr 1, 11:55pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 974 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.