Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 7 of 980 (351796 posts in 14697 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 980 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Are You A Baggins or A Took? lionoferebor 612 15 Apr 27, 9:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Greenwood Hobbit)
       A Took in my younger days, Lissuin 557 0 Apr 27, 9:49pm
       I'm a Baggins... Riven Delve 551 0 Apr 27, 9:56pm
       Collapse Took... Queen of Erebor 537 1 Apr 27, 11:05pm
         SING IT.."Somedays I feel like a Took..Somedays, NOT.."// Bombadil 506 0 Apr 28, 1:23am
       Good question! Eruwestial37 478 0 Apr 28, 4:10am
       Hmm CathrineB 446 0 Apr 28, 8:07am
       A Baggins BlackFox 444 0 Apr 28, 8:13am
       I would love Adrianna 425 0 Apr 28, 9:25am
       Collapse I'm a Taggins.... dormouse 421 1 Apr 28, 10:53am
         Leave it to you?...dmouse...BWAhaHAha.../// Bombadil 400 0 Apr 28, 11:58am
       Possibly more of a Brandybuck. Otaku-sempai 394 0 Apr 28, 12:45pm
       You tell me Kilidoescartwheels 386 0 Apr 28, 1:40pm
       Collapse Blockheaded Bracegirdle from Hardbottle.// L. Ron Halfelven 305 1 Apr 29, 3:27am
           WHAzzz IT like? in the Hamlet of "Hardbottle" anyway? Bombadil 270 0 Apr 29, 4:10pm
       Oh, Baggins... Greenwood Hobbit 246 0 Apr 29, 9:29pm

  Collapse Thorin's Halls in the Ered Luin? ThorinsNemesis 775 56 Apr 27, 8:00pm Jump to last post in thread (by ThorinsNemesis)
       Collapse I think Tolkien Gateway is right Hobbity Hobbit 698 2 Apr 27, 8:23pm
           Collapse Ered Luin ThorinsNemesis 656 1 Apr 27, 9:11pm
               Mount Dolmed Otaku-sempai 642 0 Apr 27, 9:46pm
       Collapse Thorin's Halls Otaku-sempai 649 52 Apr 27, 9:37pm
           Collapse If indeed "halls" is the right idea. Spriggan 638 51 Apr 27, 9:57pm
               Collapse Thorin's digs needn't have been very grand. Otaku-sempai 619 50 Apr 27, 11:07pm
                   Collapse I meant in the book. Spriggan 618 49 Apr 27, 11:16pm
                       Collapse Location ThorinsNemesis 555 46 Apr 28, 5:09am
                           Collapse Probable? Otaku-sempai 486 45 Apr 28, 12:53pm
                               Collapse At least in the book? ThorinsNemesis 484 44 Apr 28, 1:08pm
                                   Collapse Northern Ered Luin Otaku-sempai 469 43 Apr 28, 1:54pm
                                       Collapse Already known ThorinsNemesis 456 42 Apr 28, 2:44pm
                                           Collapse Okay Otaku-sempai 454 41 Apr 28, 2:55pm
                                               Collapse Confused a bit :P ThorinsNemesis 419 40 Apr 28, 3:38pm
                                                   Collapse Let me help. Otaku-sempai 411 39 Apr 28, 4:03pm
                                                       Collapse What about Tolkien gateway? ThorinsNemesis 399 38 Apr 28, 4:29pm
                                                           Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 394 37 Apr 28, 4:52pm
                                                               Collapse Sounds possible ThorinsNemesis 387 36 Apr 28, 5:26pm
                                                                   Collapse Thorin and Elves Otaku-sempai 372 35 Apr 28, 6:04pm
                                                                       Collapse Great East Road ThorinsNemesis 364 1 Apr 28, 6:16pm
                                                                           The Great East Road Otaku-sempai 349 0 Apr 28, 6:34pm
                                                                       Collapse The wood-elves grudge marary 357 32 Apr 28, 6:32pm
                                                                           Collapse The Animosity of Thranduil. Otaku-sempai 219 31 Apr 28, 6:53pm
                                                                               Collapse Lotro location true? ThorinsNemesis 211 7 Apr 28, 7:15pm
  Collapse distance of Thorin's halls to the Shire? marary 203 1 Apr 28, 7:22pm
       Thorin's Halls to The Shire Otaku-sempai 194 0 Apr 28, 7:43pm
  Collapse Close enough. Otaku-sempai 199 4 Apr 28, 7:29pm
       Collapse Gate on the western side of Ered Luin? ThorinsNemesis 194 3 Apr 28, 7:44pm
           Collapse LOTRO Map? Otaku-sempai 185 2 Apr 28, 7:56pm
               Collapse It is on the Eastern side of the Blue Mountains ThorinsNemesis 183 1 Apr 28, 8:04pm
                   Okay. Otaku-sempai 178 0 Apr 28, 8:18pm
                                                                               Collapse Very true about Dol Guldur marary 209 22 Apr 28, 7:18pm
  Collapse Tauriel and the Darkening of Mirkwood Otaku-sempai 192 21 Apr 28, 7:46pm
       Collapse The T-Girl marary 186 20 Apr 28, 7:55pm
           Collapse Oh yes! Otaku-sempai 179 19 Apr 28, 8:15pm
               Collapse Sauron takes his time marary 176 18 Apr 28, 8:21pm
                   Collapse Weta map of the High Fells? ThorinsNemesis 168 16 Apr 28, 8:26pm
                       Collapse The High Fells Otaku-sempai 162 15 Apr 28, 8:45pm
                           Collapse The High Fells near Ettenmoors? ThorinsNemesis 157 14 Apr 28, 8:55pm
                               Collapse Could be... Otaku-sempai 153 13 Apr 28, 9:07pm
                                   Collapse Talking about Angmar... ThorinsNemesis 150 12 Apr 28, 9:17pm
                                       Collapse I think that the Nazgul do still have bodies. Otaku-sempai 143 10 Apr 28, 9:35pm
                                           Collapse How were they killed? ThorinsNemesis 140 9 Apr 28, 9:38pm
                                               Collapse Not killed. Otaku-sempai 131 8 Apr 28, 10:42pm
                                                   Collapse Bodies? ThorinsNemesis 112 7 Apr 29, 4:33am
                                                       Collapse Because that's pretty much how Tolkien describes it... dormouse 194 3 Apr 29, 8:00am
                                                           Collapse Undead and their tombs ThorinsNemesis 190 2 Apr 29, 8:31am
                                                               Collapse Not sure... Ereinion Nénharma 135 1 Apr 29, 5:02pm
                                                                   Lol ThorinsNemesis 131 0 Apr 29, 5:22pm
                                                       Collapse It is debatable. Otaku-sempai 175 2 Apr 29, 12:38pm
                                                           Collapse Kinda like what happened to Sauron's fortress in Mordor marary 163 1 Apr 29, 1:47pm
                                                               Good thoughts ThorinsNemesis 154 0 Apr 29, 2:54pm
                                       Tolkien's Nazgul had bodies too. Spriggan 133 0 Apr 28, 10:23pm
                   The Corruption of the Greenwood. Otaku-sempai 166 0 Apr 28, 8:38pm
                       Collapse Actually a good quote from the thread further up Spriggan 365 1 Apr 28, 6:15pm
                           "fair halls" - as Balin in the film said marary 357 0 Apr 28, 6:28pm

Collapse Rank the Armor & Costumes..? Bombadil 915 24 Apr 27, 2:20am Jump to last post in thread (by Queen of Erebor)
       Collapse my top ten Mooseboy018 825 2 Apr 27, 2:45am
           Collapse Tauriel's armor marary 754 1 Apr 27, 10:44am
               JUS' a Side Note... Bombadil 746 0 Apr 27, 10:54am
       Collapse Easy CathrineB 726 5 Apr 27, 12:50pm
           Collapse yay! marary 718 4 Apr 27, 1:23pm
               Collapse About the V-necks Kilidoescartwheels 588 1 Apr 27, 6:47pm
                   sexy v-necks are an important part of Middle Earth mythology marary 573 0 Apr 27, 7:18pm
               Collapse Can't leave out Thorin Kilidoescartwheels 573 1 Apr 27, 7:22pm
                   :) marary 563 0 Apr 27, 7:32pm
       Collapse As for the unfortunate gaps in the chain mail... Greenwood Hobbit 710 1 Apr 27, 1:39pm
           Regarding the gaps in the chain mail CathrineB 681 0 Apr 27, 2:55pm
       Collapse Well I did a "rate the armour" post once Kilidoescartwheels 696 3 Apr 27, 2:09pm
           Collapse KDCW..can you link us back to your "RATE the Armour" post?// Bombadil 656 2 Apr 27, 3:21pm
               Collapse Here it is Kilidoescartwheels 633 1 Apr 27, 4:34pm
                 Thang you Berry Buch!..Forgot about Elrond's// Bombadil 615 0 Apr 27, 5:22pm
       Collapse My picks Kim 503 5 Apr 28, 4:13am
           Collapse Among others Ilmatar 343 4 Apr 30, 10:01am
               Collapse Thorin's bathrobe marary 335 1 Apr 30, 10:50am
                   I see now Ilmatar 290 0 Apr 30, 8:17pm
               Oooh I forgot! CathrineB 287 0 Apr 30, 8:27pm
               You do have a point Kim 262 0 May 1, 2:33am
       Collapse My favourite Súleth 385 1 Apr 29, 6:30pm
           This is pretty much my list as well... Queen of Erebor 209 0 May 2, 10:53pm
       There are too many to list... BlackFox 281 0 Apr 30, 8:36pm

  Collapse Thorin vs. Azog Kilidoescartwheels 1010 21 Apr 26, 7:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by AshNazg)
       I reject... Angharad73 840 0 Apr 26, 8:46pm
       Collapse At last! Elarie 793 6 Apr 26, 9:53pm
           Collapse Check out my new one! Kilidoescartwheels 207 5 May 6, 4:02am
               Collapse I love them both Elarie 186 1 May 6, 1:06pm
                   Thank you, I appreciate it! Kilidoescartwheels 162 0 May 6, 8:28pm
               Collapse This is silly, since when have Forums not been allowed to link to Youtube videos?! AshNazg 190 2 May 6, 3:20pm
                   Collapse Yes, well Kilidoescartwheels 163 1 May 6, 8:31pm
                       Sorry to hear about that, it does seem ridiculous to me... AshNazg 149 0 May 7, 1:56am
       Ooh! Starglass 780 0 Apr 26, 10:18pm
       Collapse Worth delurking… Glorfindela 761 1 Apr 27, 12:03am
         You, "THORIN-ISTAzz" always CRACK bomby UP!../// Bombadil 740 0 Apr 27, 12:30am
       Nice edit! MEM 719 0 Apr 27, 3:00am
       Collapse Sorry but i cant find it can someone do a direct link? Konrad S 699 1 Apr 27, 3:58am
           Here you go... Queen of Erebor 562 0 Apr 27, 11:26pm
       Collapse The admins discussed this video entmaiden 505 6 Apr 28, 1:54pm
           Collapse How can you discuss a video with people who haven't seen it? Kilidoescartwheels 448 5 Apr 28, 7:36pm
               Collapse Really? entmaiden 429 4 Apr 28, 11:40pm
                   Collapse Yes, really Kilidoescartwheels 420 3 Apr 29, 12:52am
                       Collapse Other options Goldeneye 356 2 Apr 29, 6:47pm
                           Keeping Thorin alive Kilidoescartwheels 323 0 Apr 29, 9:46pm
                           If you want to know, the answer is out there Kilidoescartwheels 202 0 May 6, 4:03am

  Collapse UT-OH..? Bomby founda Major Spoiler..? Bombadil 1202 8 Apr 26, 3:37pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
     Collapse Think it's already spoiled Avandel 1117 4 Apr 26, 4:02pm
         Hear! Hear! // Brethil 1038 0 Apr 26, 5:34pm
           Collapse Bomby is giving out one little piece of info..? Bombadil 1021 2 Apr 26, 5:55pm
               Well, it's Thorin Kilidoescartwheels 945 0 Apr 26, 7:37pm
               Well, no not really Avandel 472 0 Apr 27, 11:34pm
       Collapse So I watched it Kilidoescartwheels 758 2 Apr 27, 3:03am
           Collapse Thorin died! Get over it! He is a wizard, you know! 749 1 Apr 27, 3:24am
               WE knew THAT goin' in... Bombadil 678 0 Apr 27, 10:37am

  Collapse Hands-on photo review: The Hobbit Trilogy (German Steelbook Boxset with Bilbo's Journal) TheHutt 778 20 Apr 26, 3:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elessar)
     Collapse Thank you! Avandel 718 2 Apr 26, 4:26pm
           These are region free TheHutt 679 0 Apr 26, 5:45pm
           The Blu--Rays smtfhw 456 0 Apr 27, 12:45pm
       Collapse If I'm honest ... DanielLB 657 10 Apr 26, 6:17pm
           Collapse Will you see the ee? Elessar 534 9 Apr 27, 3:39am
               Collapse Absolutely. DanielLB 482 4 Apr 27, 10:56am
                   Collapse Got ya Elessar 482 3 Apr 27, 11:04am
                       I second that // dormouse 477 0 Apr 27, 11:06am
                       Collapse As long as it doesn't contain more of the same! / DanielLB 393 1 Apr 27, 4:47pm
                           I hope for you that happens. Elessar 388 0 Apr 27, 5:22pm
               Collapse Of course... TheHutt 473 3 Apr 27, 11:35am
                   Collapse I still haven't bought the digital of the te yet. Elessar 461 2 Apr 27, 12:42pm
                       Collapse I don't buy digital... TheHutt 458 1 Apr 27, 12:46pm
                           I do Elessar 445 0 Apr 27, 1:43pm
       Collapse One question... Timdalf 588 4 Apr 26, 10:47pm
           I assume Timdalf 578 0 Apr 26, 11:11pm
           Collapse Both TheHutt 547 2 Apr 27, 2:43am
               Now that is interesting! Timdalf 540 0 Apr 27, 3:08am
               WOW..That's GREAT! Bombadil 484 0 Apr 27, 10:48am
       Nice review! Elessar 535 0 Apr 27, 3:39am

  Collapse Rank the credit songs. Smaug the iron 743 20 Apr 26, 2:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
       Collapse I have heard 3 of these songs so i rank them. Konrad S 660 1 Apr 26, 2:50pm
           only three? Mooseboy018 345 0 Apr 27, 5:29pm
       My rankings Elessar 645 0 Apr 26, 3:34pm
       I suspect this is quite revealing Spriggan 640 0 Apr 26, 3:45pm
       Mine... Elutherian 626 0 Apr 26, 4:29pm
       My Rankings MEM 621 0 Apr 26, 4:39pm
       Mine Hobbity Hobbit 595 0 Apr 26, 5:52pm
       Not sure I like I See Fire too much... Bofur01 568 0 Apr 26, 6:57pm
       For me Súleth 547 0 Apr 26, 8:03pm
       First two are a toss up for me. Arthael 538 0 Apr 26, 8:24pm
       Not a great field to choose from for me... MadgeBishop 524 0 Apr 26, 8:37pm
       This is tough... Queen of Erebor 510 0 Apr 26, 8:50pm
       My answers Starglass 482 0 Apr 26, 11:02pm
       M'okay CathrineB 471 0 Apr 26, 11:23pm
       Mine Noria 461 0 Apr 26, 11:46pm
       Billy did an amazing job! Silmaril 411 0 Apr 27, 7:27am
       First off... smtfhw 396 0 Apr 27, 12:15pm
       Collapse Wait wait wait is gollums song the song hes sing in The hobbit/lotr? Konrad S 390 2 Apr 27, 12:53pm
           Collapse Emiliana Torrini CathrineB 390 1 Apr 27, 1:00pm
               Thanks for Heads UP! I'll find her on Pandora!// Bombadil 361 0 Apr 27, 3:31pm

Collapse What do you make of the SIZE of the Armies? Bombadil 773 34 Apr 26, 11:09am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Grrr 8 Konrad S 709 0 Apr 26, 11:49am
       Collapse Just a small note Spriggan 688 23 Apr 26, 12:26pm
           Collapse In Looking @ "The Clouds Burst" Chapter... Bombadil 671 22 Apr 26, 12:59pm
               Collapse Copy from lotr wiki Konrad S 664 1 Apr 26, 1:07pm
                   The trouble with such wikis is that they are simply conjecture. Spriggan 583 0 Apr 26, 3:38pm
               Collapse If there was 200 lakemen then they must have lost few and even if all survived... Konrad S 660 8 Apr 26, 1:12pm
                   Collapse Estimate of 200 from the book. Otaku-sempai 590 7 Apr 26, 3:31pm
                       Collapse Ok but i talk about the film, and i thought the 200 was the others that was in the city of dale to. Konrad S 556 6 Apr 26, 5:42pm
                           Collapse In the film - no "200" I don't think. Spriggan 543 1 Apr 26, 6:02pm
                               I dont think 200 Konrad S 540 0 Apr 26, 6:07pm
                           Collapse Hard to estimate. Otaku-sempai 499 3 Apr 26, 8:45pm
                               Collapse Maybe? Likely? PJ & Phillipa will give us the answer Bombadil 469 1 Apr 27, 12:25am
                                   Yes. The EE might clarify the numbers. Otaku-sempai 403 0 Apr 27, 3:14pm
                               Okay 1000-2000 pepoles and 200 - 400 Soldiers Konrad S 448 0 Apr 27, 4:59am
               Collapse I did a rough screen count estimation before and it was discussed, and if I recall Eruonen 224 10 Apr 30, 2:44am
                   Actually, a good count of the pixeled elves shows at least 350 across and 60 deep for Eruonen 168 0 Apr 30, 3:01am
                   Collapse So... Otaku-sempai 151 8 Apr 30, 12:01pm
                       Collapse If I use the 21,000 elven army number and guess that it represents Eruonen 138 7 Apr 30, 3:05pm
                           Collapse Population of the Mirkwood Elves Otaku-sempai 134 6 Apr 30, 3:47pm
                               Collapse Yes, it does, but it is just based on the movie figures. Eruonen 131 5 Apr 30, 4:00pm
                                   Collapse Yes, I know. Otaku-sempai 129 4 Apr 30, 4:27pm
                                       Collapse Or it could have been a lot more in the book. Spriggan 118 3 Apr 30, 10:23pm
                                           Collapse The total was almost certainly higher. Otaku-sempai 116 2 Apr 30, 10:34pm
                                               Collapse Who knows about Elven food consumption? Spriggan 111 1 Apr 30, 11:09pm
                                                   It's not just the food. Otaku-sempai 108 0 Apr 30, 11:42pm
       Collapse and it isn´t only archers in the film many spearmen and swordmens. Konrad S 680 2 Apr 26, 12:38pm
           Collapse A Line form the Movie..." A couple of hundred upset Laketown survivors.."// Bombadil 655 1 Apr 26, 1:15pm
               How many of the lakemens died? Konrad S 655 0 Apr 26, 1:19pm
       Collapse Copy from lotr wiki Strength (film) Konrad S 644 4 Apr 26, 1:45pm
           Collapse WETA Digital said the Orc army was 30000 strong. // Bofur01 621 2 Apr 26, 2:17pm
               Collapse Many more combatants in the movie than in the book. Otaku-sempai 601 1 Apr 26, 3:09pm
                   I can't remember, I think Azog's, but I'm not sure // Bofur01 592 0 Apr 26, 3:23pm
           Bom will go with WETA over WIKI..// Bombadil 619 0 Apr 26, 2:20pm
       Now i and you have answears on our questions ! i think! Konrad S 640 0 Apr 26, 1:47pm

  Collapse Favorite Martin Freeman moment in each film. Smaug the iron 959 21 Apr 25, 4:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ham_Sammy)
       All of them! // BlackFox 838 0 Apr 25, 6:06pm
       Collapse Isn't it kind of pathetic AshNazg 783 3 Apr 25, 9:29pm
           This is best of Martin Freemen not Bilbo. Smaug the iron 776 0 Apr 25, 9:45pm
           Collapse For me actually thanks to MF's ability Avandel 552 1 Apr 26, 4:49pm
               MF's ability Roheryn1 527 0 Apr 26, 6:19pm
       Collapse I'll go with... frodolives 746 1 Apr 25, 10:45pm
         Bomby loves one that might be MISSED? Bombadil 731 0 Apr 25, 11:33pm
       Collapse mine DisDwarfWoman 715 2 Apr 26, 12:23am
           Collapse You are Right, Bomby mis-Quoted Bilbo.. Bombadil 710 1 Apr 26, 12:30am
               haha, I didn't even notice! DisDwarfWoman 708 0 Apr 26, 12:36am
       There are so many! sycorax82 700 0 Apr 26, 1:36am
       Tough to choose, but Arthael 689 0 Apr 26, 2:28am
       Tough to choose Eruwestial37 649 0 Apr 26, 5:47am
       my fav are mo0on-light 612 0 Apr 26, 9:43am
       Hmmm Kilidoescartwheels 504 0 Apr 26, 7:44pm
       There are so, so many. Noria 476 0 Apr 26, 11:52pm
       Quick hitters Elessar 473 0 Apr 27, 12:01am
       I'm with BlackFox here - all of them! dormouse 450 0 Apr 27, 7:28am
       My favourite Martin-as-Bilbo-moments Bernhardina 291 0 Apr 28, 6:36pm
       Mines. ;-) Milieuterrien 281 0 Apr 28, 8:34pm
       So so many Ham_Sammy 150 0 May 4, 4:40am

Collapse Different release dates a bummer! Do all have the TE that wanted it? Avandel 714 9 Apr 25, 4:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Collapse Did you mean this? BlackFox 610 1 Apr 25, 6:07pm
           Thank you! Avandel 399 0 Apr 26, 3:42pm
       Collapse It's out in the UK now.... dormouse 594 6 Apr 25, 6:41pm
         Collapse Rewatchability! Avandel 392 5 Apr 26, 3:52pm
               I never rewatch scenes... Queen of Erebor 365 0 Apr 26, 8:41pm
               Collapse Absolutely! dormouse 350 1 Apr 26, 10:09pm
                 bom is SSOooo..Pleased you FINALLY got your Copy!// Bombadil 336 0 Apr 27, 1:15am
               Collapse Good thing the EE is coming out in November Riven Delve 284 1 Apr 27, 5:12pm
                   And get to know the TE really well... dormouse 275 0 Apr 27, 6:21pm

  Collapse "Was Bofur Left in Laketown On Purpose?" KRRouse 1027 17 Apr 25, 2:51am Jump to last post in thread (by Milieuterrien)
       Fun read CathrineB 898 0 Apr 25, 7:42am
       thanks for sharing! marary 848 0 Apr 25, 9:45am
       Collapse No DjU 753 5 Apr 25, 3:12pm
           Collapse Erm... SafeUnderHill 705 4 Apr 25, 6:42pm
               uruk-hai Mooseboy018 685 0 Apr 25, 7:29pm
               Collapse Erm... DjU 447 2 Apr 26, 4:20pm
                   Collapse Thank you for the Facts, Instead of conjecture...// Bombadil 424 1 Apr 26, 5:58pm
                       what's wrong with conjecture? He is a wizard, you know! 405 0 Apr 26, 11:18pm
       Collapse I think it was much simpler lionoferebor 652 3 Apr 25, 8:50pm
           Collapse THREE more angles to look AT..? Bombadil 589 1 Apr 26, 12:08am
               POST SCRIPT..Umm? Forgot this.. Bombadil 584 0 Apr 26, 12:26am
           I think PB's comments refer to the cut scene.. Eleniel 536 0 Apr 26, 7:03am
       Great blog Kerewyn 370 0 Apr 27, 11:45am
       That's ingeneous - a fun read... dormouse 365 0 Apr 27, 12:50pm
       Collapse Well I don't think so, but... Kilidoescartwheels 359 1 Apr 27, 1:50pm
           Hmm - OK, let's debate it... ;-) dormouse 350 0 Apr 27, 2:19pm
       A mix of all these Milieuterrien 207 0 Apr 28, 9:37pm

  Collapse The Positive Outcomes of Changes from Book-AUJ Hobbity Hobbit 1026 14 Apr 24, 2:00pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elthir)
       Collapse Thorin and Co.'s motivation marary 970 4 Apr 24, 2:10pm
           Thorin and Gandalf Elessar 954 0 Apr 24, 2:36pm
           Collapse Re: Thorin & Co's motivation MEM 881 2 Apr 24, 5:37pm
               I agree with your Dad Elessar 852 0 Apr 24, 6:43pm
               rewriting The Hobbit Elthir 421 0 Apr 26, 1:48pm
       Thoughts on these changes. Elessar 959 0 Apr 24, 2:32pm
       Collapse Difference between book & movie Kilidoescartwheels 820 1 Apr 24, 7:39pm
           agreed! DisDwarfWoman 485 0 Apr 26, 12:07am
       A few things dubulous 794 0 Apr 24, 8:45pm
       Collapse Positive changes Goldeneye 790 4 Apr 24, 8:59pm
           Collapse to be fair marary 762 3 Apr 24, 9:44pm
             Collapse ALL of what has been written here is SSOoo..Correct Bombadil 723 2 Apr 24, 11:39pm
                   Collapse Appendices 8..IT's ALL there.// Bombadil 716 1 Apr 24, 11:47pm
                     Maybe we jus' List what was Perfect..? Bombadil 663 0 Apr 25, 2:34am

  Collapse mixed, so mixed feelings right now Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1565 31 Apr 24, 10:45am Jump to last post in thread (by adt100)
       Agree with a lot. Arannir 1409 0 Apr 24, 11:15am
       Collapse Is it good? Yes. Could it be better? Yes. Is it better than LotR? No. greenbalrog 1349 3 Apr 24, 12:39pm
           Collapse That's how I feel Elessar 1294 2 Apr 24, 1:44pm
               Part of enjoying these films was letting go of expectations marary 1284 0 Apr 24, 1:54pm
               Which is it?:P imin 519 0 Apr 26, 8:15am
       Collapse But, but but.... Avandel 1242 2 Apr 24, 3:06pm
           Collapse Bomby thinks it's a Natural thing to experience.. Bombadil 1114 1 Apr 24, 6:22pm
               Yeah Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 883 0 Apr 25, 6:52am
       Collapse Sorry you feel that way... dormouse 1121 5 Apr 24, 6:27pm
           Collapse Well, first of all Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 887 4 Apr 25, 6:58am
               Collapse Well, here's the thing... dormouse 864 3 Apr 25, 8:21am
                   Collapse not references needed in fact, only a coherent ahestetic or imaginaery would have been enough Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 810 2 Apr 25, 11:02am
                       Collapse But the aesthetic is coherent, consistent and true... dormouse 800 1 Apr 25, 11:37am
                           in the design backdoor perhaps Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 794 0 Apr 25, 11:46am
       Collapse Sadly, I concur frodolives 658 8 Apr 25, 10:40pm
           Collapse yes Goldeneye 619 7 Apr 26, 12:29am
               Collapse Percentages seem to such a different way of viewing. Spriggan 615 6 Apr 26, 12:45am
                   Collapse re: spriggan Goldeneye 602 5 Apr 26, 1:13am
                       Collapse Of course not. Spriggan 593 4 Apr 26, 1:35am
                           I agree Elessar 588 0 Apr 26, 1:53am
                           Collapse percentages Goldeneye 566 2 Apr 26, 4:11am
                               Not really Elessar 548 0 Apr 26, 5:31am
                               I think it is probably very revealing Spriggan 495 0 Apr 26, 9:43am
       Collapse I know exactly what you mean imin 525 6 Apr 26, 8:13am
           Collapse People are saying leave the movies and come back to them.... dormouse 316 1 Apr 26, 11:35am
               Yeah you are right on the approach you made to myself Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 280 0 Apr 26, 5:47pm
           Collapse I am not talking about liking or disliking, Im talking about that from an objective point of view, cinematically, something was made wrong Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 281 3 Apr 26, 6:00pm
               I agree again with basically everything you wrote here. // imin 252 0 Apr 26, 7:30pm
               Collapse These are your opinions of the Hobbit trilogy Noria 194 1 Apr 27, 5:35pm
                   And mine // dormouse 171 0 Apr 27, 6:13pm
       The difference with SW is the filmmakers have total free reign... adt100 101 0 Apr 30, 12:32pm

  Collapse German Hobbit BluRay trilogy... WHY?.. TheHutt 883 8 Apr 24, 8:13am Jump to last post in thread (by adt100)
       *twitch* // BlackFox 808 0 Apr 24, 8:39am
       To be annoying... smtfhw 776 0 Apr 24, 10:16am
       Oh god! Arthael 648 0 Apr 24, 4:04pm
       Not all wandering logos are lost! n/m Brandybuckled 614 0 Apr 24, 4:50pm
       Give it to me then Starling 547 0 Apr 24, 8:08pm
       Think of it this way...if it is an error...it might be worth more. Eruonen 510 0 Apr 24, 9:49pm
       That would bug the heck out of me. / Ataahua 489 0 Apr 24, 10:28pm
       'Because it's Warner Bros" *shrugs* adt100 142 0 Apr 30, 12:22pm

  Collapse From the Shire to rivendell Smaug the iron 743 6 Apr 23, 4:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by MyWeeLadGimli)
       hmmm Mooseboy018 666 0 Apr 23, 5:46pm
       Each is close in its own way... dormouse 649 0 Apr 23, 6:11pm
       Collapse Forget the book mirkwoodwanderer 476 2 Apr 24, 3:34am
           But I don't want to! BlackFox 428 0 Apr 24, 8:35am
         "Forget the book", OUCH! Traitorous! // Bracegirdle 380 0 Apr 24, 2:29pm
       I'd Say The Hobbit MyWeeLadGimli 267 0 Apr 26, 4:00am
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 980 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.