Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 7 of 1054 (372747 posts in 15796 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 1054 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Imdb ratings DainPig 583 14 Feb 6, 7:01am Jump to last post in thread (by wizzardly)
       Collapse Possibly... Gandalf the Green 521 2 Feb 6, 10:52am
           Collapse On the contrary Lindele 472 1 Feb 6, 3:11pm
               Such was its doom. ange1e4e5 467 0 Feb 6, 3:24pm
       The Hobbit Extended editions would have received better reviews Milieuterrien 458 0 Feb 6, 3:47pm
       Collapse I agree with... HOBBITFAN13 424 3 Feb 6, 5:53pm
           Collapse They should all be higher TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 404 2 Feb 6, 7:04pm
               Collapse vocal minority LSF 401 1 Feb 6, 7:07pm
                   More vocal, Milieuterrien 396 0 Feb 6, 7:14pm
       Collapse I think they are overly generous imin 344 5 Feb 7, 1:13am
           Collapse So why do you still feel the need to post on those "average movies" Milieuterrien 336 2 Feb 7, 1:23am
               To give my opinion of them imin 193 0 Feb 14, 10:39am
               and why not? wizzardly 160 0 Feb 15, 9:29pm
           Collapse I think IMDB HeadingSouth 333 1 Feb 7, 1:24am
               Completely agree // imin 191 0 Feb 14, 10:40am

  Collapse Dain and Bard's coronation & Sharing the gold ProudFeet 543 15 Feb 5, 6:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse well... LSF 516 3 Feb 5, 7:01pm
           Collapse On Thranduil's gems ange1e4e5 513 2 Feb 5, 7:12pm
               Collapse He did get them back LSF 512 1 Feb 5, 7:23pm
                   Lovely white gems No One in Particular 507 0 Feb 5, 7:28pm
       Collapse Dáin and Bard Otaku-sempai 502 3 Feb 5, 7:36pm
           Collapse Correct me if I'm wrong, but ... Kilidoescartwheels 489 2 Feb 5, 8:10pm
               Partially correct... Otaku-sempai 477 0 Feb 5, 8:22pm
               Oh! Bilbo's gift! Otaku-sempai 442 0 Feb 5, 8:51pm
       Collapse We mustn't forget Milieuterrien 482 6 Feb 5, 8:14pm
           Collapse GdT's Hobbit Otaku-sempai 474 2 Feb 5, 8:25pm
               Collapse Yes but when did GDT left the project ? Milieuterrien 453 1 Feb 5, 8:38pm
                   The Bridge Film Otaku-sempai 429 0 Feb 5, 9:03pm
           Collapse don't htink so LSF 461 2 Feb 5, 8:33pm
               And then Ryan Gage became Alfrid. ange1e4e5 457 0 Feb 5, 8:36pm
               If they did cast Drogo with Ryan Gage, who is not a nobody Milieuterrien 446 0 Feb 5, 8:44pm

  Collapse What would Tolkien think of the Hobbit films? HOBBITFAN13 941 66 Feb 5, 1:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by Hamfast Gamgee)
       Hm. Fereth 855 0 Feb 5, 2:03pm
       That no one knows, that no one knows, and no one ever will.... dormouse 851 0 Feb 5, 2:12pm
       Well Darkstone 850 0 Feb 5, 2:26pm
       It doesn't really matter; I'll bite anyhow TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 848 0 Feb 5, 2:27pm
       Collapse My Guess? Otaku-sempai 828 1 Feb 5, 3:35pm
           My opinion ange1e4e5 818 0 Feb 5, 3:52pm
       Well Smaug the iron 806 0 Feb 5, 4:52pm
       Reply: HeadingSouth 722 0 Feb 5, 10:01pm
       Collapse Let's not mince words... Morthoron 692 48 Feb 6, 1:29am
           I have to say, HeadingSouth 684 0 Feb 6, 1:44am
           Collapse Eviscerated ? Milieuterrien 628 45 Feb 6, 9:39am
               Collapse Eviscerated. Gandalf the Green 620 37 Feb 6, 10:51am
                   Collapse Receipes Milieuterrien 613 36 Feb 6, 11:34am
                       Collapse It appears you are unwaware... Morthoron 566 35 Feb 6, 2:42pm
                           Collapse it appears that I'm aware Milieuterrien 558 34 Feb 6, 2:50pm
                               Collapse Publishers, not editors... Morthoron 547 33 Feb 6, 3:11pm
                                   Sorry but, Milieuterrien 539 0 Feb 6, 3:35pm
                                   Collapse In fact, LotR consists of six books. Otaku-sempai 483 31 Feb 6, 8:44pm
                                       Collapse Those were apparently suggestions sent to the publisher Milieuterrien 393 30 Feb 6, 9:03pm
                                           Collapse Um...no. Otaku-sempai 382 29 Feb 6, 9:13pm
                                               Collapse My sources Milieuterrien 376 28 Feb 6, 9:23pm
                                                   Collapse Stuff your sources. Otaku-sempai 373 27 Feb 6, 9:43pm
                                                       Collapse If there are no individual book titles Milieuterrien 364 24 Feb 6, 10:03pm
                                                           Collapse Wha??? Otaku-sempai 355 23 Feb 6, 10:10pm
                                                               Collapse You introduce 'books', I jump on the 'Book' wagon Milieuterrien 339 19 Feb 6, 10:34pm
                                                                   Collapse Back to the Films Otaku-sempai 332 18 Feb 6, 10:49pm
                                                                       Collapse Exactly, HeadingSouth 322 4 Feb 6, 11:02pm
                                                                           Collapse But they are Smaug the iron 314 3 Feb 6, 11:42pm
                                                                               Collapse It really isn't, HeadingSouth 291 2 Feb 7, 12:17am
  Collapse I think The Children of Hurin expanded on the battles part, particularly with the Nirnaeth Arnoediad. ange1e4e5 288 1 Feb 7, 12:18am
       Yes, HeadingSouth 277 0 Feb 7, 12:31am
                                                                       Collapse That's where we differ Milieuterrien 316 12 Feb 6, 11:43pm
                                                                           Collapse You are mistaken... Otaku-sempai 303 11 Feb 7, 12:00am
                                                                               Collapse What you call 'additions' are interpretations Milieuterrien 272 10 Feb 7, 12:53am
  Collapse Pretty much, HeadingSouth 264 6 Feb 7, 1:19am
       Collapse Facing negative generalities as usual Milieuterrien 254 5 Feb 7, 1:35am
           Collapse Why do you find it so hard to accept HeadingSouth 247 2 Feb 7, 1:36am
               Collapse Well, the fact that someone managed to get such an ambitious project off the ground (The Lord of the Rings) and have the critics and public like it. ange1e4e5 240 1 Feb 7, 1:44am
                   So because some critics and the general audience like it, HeadingSouth 237 0 Feb 7, 1:47am
           Collapse Wait...what? Morthoron 223 1 Feb 7, 2:28am
               I'm leaving this board Milieuterrien 382 0 Feb 7, 2:46am
  Collapse Ch-ch-ch-changes Otaku-sempai 255 2 Feb 7, 1:31am
       Collapse Well Smaug the iron 345 1 Feb 7, 8:06am
           The Stone-giants. Otaku-sempai 338 0 Feb 7, 8:19am
                                                               Collapse As a matter of interest - geordie 293 2 Feb 7, 6:58pm
                                                                   As a further matter of interest - geordie 284 0 Feb 7, 7:10pm
                                                                   Thanks. Otaku-sempai 276 0 Feb 7, 7:20pm
                                                       Collapse just a quick note - geordie 296 1 Feb 7, 6:50pm
                                                           Thanks for the correction. Otaku-sempai 279 0 Feb 7, 7:14pm
               Collapse Credit where credit is due. Otaku-sempai 583 6 Feb 6, 1:30pm
                   Collapse If credit is to put where credit is due Milieuterrien 564 3 Feb 6, 2:43pm
                       Collapse Nonetheless... Otaku-sempai 403 1 Feb 6, 8:50pm
                           Christopher has HeadingSouth 353 0 Feb 6, 10:09pm
                       Christopher's sons are called Simon and Adam geordie 300 0 Feb 7, 6:47pm
                   Collapse Yes, I think he would like them TaliaEmerald 190 1 Feb 10, 1:30am
                       Well... Otaku-sempai 185 0 Feb 10, 3:33am
           You nailed it! hamlet 477 0 Feb 6, 8:48pm
       Collapse I think Silverlode 684 1 Feb 6, 2:01am
           I think you're right... dormouse 323 0 Feb 7, 2:45pm
       Collapse To answer the question Milieuterrien 607 1 Feb 6, 11:50am
           And sensitive treat Milieuterrien 578 0 Feb 6, 1:42pm
       Collapse Well, to answer Hamfast Gamgee 257 3 Feb 8, 12:05am
           Collapse Funny, that.... dormouse 251 2 Feb 8, 9:53am
               According to Appendix A, ange1e4e5 232 0 Feb 8, 3:14pm
               Yes, I guess you are right Hamfast Gamgee 146 0 Feb 11, 12:43am
       I think he'd like some and not like some Elessar 162 0 Feb 10, 2:49pm

  Collapse Who did look at LOTR during The Hobbit years Milieuterrien 1453 105 Feb 1, 4:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense)
       Collapse 11 years LSF 1276 1 Feb 1, 4:38pm
           I'm glad that there are people who think the same way as me! ThorinsNemesis 1123 0 Feb 1, 9:34pm
       I have been seeing LOTR repeatedly since 2002 Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1243 0 Feb 1, 5:49pm
       LotR EE marathons every December... Aragorn the Elfstone 1221 0 Feb 1, 6:19pm
       Came home from DOS and my little sisters were watching TTT Gianna 1213 0 Feb 1, 6:22pm
       Collapse But, Gandalf the Green 1188 51 Feb 1, 7:32pm
           Collapse I sort of agree with you, except… Glorfindela 1170 47 Feb 1, 7:52pm
               Collapse ? balbo biggins 1038 46 Feb 2, 3:02am
                   Collapse Back to the question please Milieuterrien 988 2 Feb 2, 9:31am
                       Collapse He's right, you utter the words of an apologist... Gandalf the Green 976 1 Feb 2, 9:59am
                           Once again, this topic is about your recent watches of LOTR Milieuterrien 964 0 Feb 2, 10:27am
                   Collapse No, sorry Glorfindela 967 42 Feb 2, 11:30am
                       Collapse really! balbo biggins 545 41 Feb 2, 7:35pm
                           .. Except that in Middle Ages, Milieuterrien 518 0 Feb 2, 8:43pm
                           There's no point ranking performances in these films, really... Bofur01 497 0 Feb 2, 9:22pm
                           Collapse Indeed Glorfindela 478 11 Feb 3, 12:18am
                               Collapse no balbo biggins 444 10 Feb 3, 2:30am
                                   Collapse More than three messages Milieuterrien 430 9 Feb 3, 3:23am
                                       Collapse Making notations here... TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 407 8 Feb 3, 5:56am
                                           One more thought TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 397 0 Feb 3, 6:18am
                                           Collapse LOL, yes. Aragorn the Elfstone 401 6 Feb 3, 6:19am
                                               Collapse On this one issue I'm sort of in the middle ground TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 388 3 Feb 3, 6:28am
                                                   Collapse Me too. And I'm wondering why on earth it has to be a competition... dormouse 367 2 Feb 3, 9:40am
                                                       Comparison is reason Milieuterrien 342 0 Feb 3, 11:48am
                                                       IMO it doesn't Avandel 496 0 Feb 3, 7:52pm
                                               Collapse Indeed Glorfindela 341 1 Feb 3, 11:42am
                                                   You may try it shorter Milieuterrien 338 0 Feb 3, 11:55am
                           Collapse That's one of my least favorite scenes in The Two Towers entmaiden 281 26 Feb 3, 4:25pm
                               I watched the Lord of the Rings while the Hobbit films were in theaters ange1e4e5 536 0 Feb 3, 4:31pm
                               Collapse gotta be kidding me. balbo biggins 526 6 Feb 3, 7:18pm
                                   Collapse Before you give up, Milieuterrien 504 3 Feb 3, 7:36pm
                                       Collapse *chuckle* Unfortunately Ettelewen 494 2 Feb 3, 8:43pm
                                           Collapse film balbo biggins 339 1 Feb 4, 2:52am
                                               No, sorry, your first statement is blatantly untrue TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 333 0 Feb 4, 3:10am
                                   Collapse Must be lonely entmaiden 520 1 Feb 4, 4:36am
                                       exscuse me? balbo biggins 432 0 Feb 4, 10:01pm
                               Collapse Is it? Otaku-sempai 482 17 Feb 3, 9:06pm
                                   Collapse Well Darkstone 481 16 Feb 3, 9:16pm
                                       Maybe BH proposed the change because he thought Milieuterrien 452 0 Feb 3, 9:54pm
                                       Collapse Okay Otaku-sempai 446 14 Feb 3, 10:04pm
                                           Collapse So, it's an occasion here to tell about your own feelings about it Milieuterrien 434 13 Feb 3, 10:17pm
                                               Collapse It's an occasion for a Pants Thread! "So comes snow after fire, and even dragons have their pants!" / Darkstone 425 5 Feb 3, 10:29pm
                                                   Collapse Then feel free to open that thread. Milieuterrien 415 4 Feb 3, 10:56pm
                                                       "His only comfort was he couldn’t be mistaken for a dwarf, as he had no pants." / Darkstone 407 0 Feb 3, 11:00pm
                                                       Collapse Ha ha - right on..... Avandel 373 2 Feb 4, 12:21am
                                                           Collapse Tolkien did not write a LOTR 2, but he wrote a Hobbit 2 with LOTR Milieuterrien 367 1 Feb 4, 12:58am
                                                               Excellent post TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 334 0 Feb 4, 2:53am
                                               Collapse Since you asked... Otaku-sempai 416 6 Feb 3, 10:51pm
                                                   Collapse .. Just to check one point ? Milieuterrien 408 5 Feb 3, 11:02pm
                                                       Collapse Research Otaku-sempai 407 4 Feb 3, 11:05pm
                                                           That can't be bought. Milieuterrien 396 0 Feb 3, 11:20pm
                                                           Collapse Oh, noes!! Darkstone 387 2 Feb 3, 11:41pm
                                                               Collapse or... Otaku-sempai 342 1 Feb 4, 2:16am
                                                                   101 uses! Darkstone 330 0 Feb 4, 2:55am
           Collapse But... Milieuterrien 1165 2 Feb 1, 7:55pm
               Collapse - Gandalf the Green 979 1 Feb 2, 9:38am
                   Wow. Milieuterrien 971 0 Feb 2, 10:11am
       You are not alone Glorfindela 1171 0 Feb 1, 7:44pm
       Collapse All the time. Darkstone 1166 2 Feb 1, 8:13pm
           Collapse What do you mean by 'all the time' ? Milieuterrien 1158 1 Feb 1, 8:26pm
               You're wrong. Darkstone 1115 0 Feb 1, 9:44pm
       When BOFA was released last year... Belegdir 1130 0 Feb 1, 9:20pm
       To answer your question Kilidoescartwheels 1120 0 Feb 1, 9:37pm
       Me... dormouse 1090 0 Feb 1, 11:26pm
       Off and on... Avandel 1056 0 Feb 2, 1:02am
       I've watched all six lots of times in the last several years Riven Delve 1045 0 Feb 2, 1:36am
       I think I watched bits and pieces of LOTR Elarie 588 0 Feb 2, 12:29pm
       Yes and no Jeffrodo 581 0 Feb 2, 1:27pm
       re: ghost_matt 540 0 Feb 2, 7:12pm
       Yeah CathrineB 468 0 Feb 2, 11:58pm
       Collapse Time and again... Miss-Merriweather 462 2 Feb 3, 1:01am
           Same here. Milieuterrien 435 0 Feb 3, 2:28am
           Yes, me too. Ettelewen 281 0 Feb 3, 3:34pm
       Collapse Haven't watched them. Noria 323 2 Feb 3, 1:26pm
           At least but not at last... Milieuterrien 300 0 Feb 3, 2:23pm
           I watch LOTR regularly, Ettelewen 281 0 Feb 3, 3:38pm
       Collapse I have HeadingSouth 410 16 Feb 4, 11:05pm
           Collapse Bitte, tell us more about the circumstances of your viewing : Milieuterrien 404 15 Feb 4, 11:11pm
               Collapse I watched the LOTR films again HeadingSouth 390 14 Feb 4, 11:38pm
                   Collapse So, the more you dislike, the more you look again Milieuterrien 351 13 Feb 5, 12:16am
                       Collapse I chose to view them again, as opinions change. HeadingSouth 329 12 Feb 5, 12:28am
                           Collapse Each and every book written by Tolkien ends with some battle Milieuterrien 311 11 Feb 5, 12:51am
                               Collapse I have no problem with you liking it HeadingSouth 302 10 Feb 5, 1:07am
                                   Collapse I don't like battles either Milieuterrien 296 9 Feb 5, 1:29am
                                       Collapse Yes, I get that, HeadingSouth 290 8 Feb 5, 1:33am
                                           Collapse Tolkien had fought on a battlefield himself Milieuterrien 284 7 Feb 5, 2:03am
                                               Collapse You see, HeadingSouth 273 6 Feb 5, 2:14am
                                                   Collapse The thread is about your recent viewings of LOTR Milieuterrien 274 5 Feb 5, 2:30am
                                                       I haven't watched it for a year HeadingSouth 265 0 Feb 5, 2:33am
                                                       Collapse You do realize you're on the Hobbit board? entmaiden 254 1 Feb 5, 4:49am
                                                           It's a topic about LOTR watches during The Hobbit years, so reflecting those. Milieuterrien 223 0 Feb 5, 8:29am
                                                       Collapse Those are humorous moments, not parody. Aragorn the Elfstone 240 1 Feb 5, 7:13am
                                                           TH is supposed to be a children tale, LOTR a more adult tale Milieuterrien 219 0 Feb 5, 8:46am
     Collapse Posts in this thread have been edited for personal comments. Ataahua 357 4 Feb 5, 12:18am
           Collapse I guess one of my posts has been removed, right? ange1e4e5 347 3 Feb 5, 12:21am
               Collapse No, actually. / Ataahua 330 2 Feb 5, 12:26am
                   Collapse Reason that I was wondering was because I couldn't find one of my posts. ange1e4e5 325 1 Feb 5, 12:30am
                       Have you tried Ataahua 325 0 Feb 5, 12:33am
       Collapse ... StingingFly 208 2 Feb 5, 10:03am
           Collapse Let time do its office Milieuterrien 349 1 Feb 5, 10:35am
               To be honest, HeadingSouth 291 0 Feb 5, 9:52pm
       I constantly re-watch LOTR as well as the special features. Misty Mountain Hop 304 0 Feb 5, 9:20pm
       Collapse Yes i have watched again LOTR imin 282 2 Feb 5, 11:19pm
           Collapse . aragorn2015 219 1 Feb 7, 7:13am
               I'm amazed at how "LotR" has been enhanced by "The Hobbit" TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 205 0 Feb 7, 11:02am

  Collapse Bilbo wearing the ring during the conversation with Smaug. Smaug the iron 795 26 Feb 1, 12:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse I think it was an excellent change visually.... dormouse 752 1 Feb 1, 1:44pm
           So True AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 535 0 Feb 2, 4:06am
       As usual I agree with dormouse Noria 746 0 Feb 1, 1:48pm
       Collapse Bilbo taking the ring off was stupid Omnigeek 743 14 Feb 1, 2:16pm
           Collapse They covered that very well in the film... dormouse 739 8 Feb 1, 2:31pm
               Competing arguments Voronwë_the_Faithful 729 0 Feb 1, 2:39pm
               Collapse Rationalization Omnigeek 715 6 Feb 1, 3:10pm
                   Collapse I'm talking about the film, not the book... dormouse 708 4 Feb 1, 3:31pm
                       Collapse Smaug's "treasure sense" is tingling!!! No One in Particular 529 3 Feb 2, 5:36am
                           Not mentioning the fact that Bilbo had to speak to the dragon Milieuterrien 492 0 Feb 2, 11:33am
                           Collapse McGuffin? No Omnigeek 169 1 Feb 6, 8:38pm
                               The Hobbit stood alone (at first) Otaku-sempai 160 0 Feb 6, 9:53pm
                   Does it really hurt that Smaug 'smells' the Ring ? Milieuterrien 683 0 Feb 1, 3:55pm
           Collapse stupid ? hmmm.. Milieuterrien 727 3 Feb 1, 2:53pm
               Collapse Yes, stupid Omnigeek 705 2 Feb 1, 3:33pm
                   Collapse My understanding of the scene is that .. Noria 694 1 Feb 1, 3:46pm
                       Right. Milieuterrien 670 0 Feb 1, 4:05pm
           That would not work. Smaug the iron 618 0 Feb 1, 6:43pm
       approve LSF 666 0 Feb 1, 4:19pm
       Collapse I thought it was ridiculous. Gianna 662 5 Feb 1, 4:45pm
           Thought it was obvious LSF 657 0 Feb 1, 4:52pm
           I don't understand what you mean? Smaug the iron 616 0 Feb 1, 6:49pm
           "You have nice manners for a thief" Milieuterrien 595 0 Feb 1, 8:15pm
           Collapse Of course Smaug could have caught Bilbo at any time.... dormouse 564 1 Feb 1, 11:32pm
               From the book: Darkstone 367 0 Feb 3, 10:37pm
       It was appropriate for the movie Elarie 486 0 Feb 2, 12:22pm

  Collapse the never venure east scene lacika 1084 35 Jan 31, 9:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Milieuterrien)
       Collapse nice find LSF 1014 1 Jan 31, 9:48pm
           May not have added to the film, but the AUJ Thorin dialogue in a trailer Avandel 773 0 Feb 2, 12:47am
       Never venture East Otaku-sempai 965 0 Feb 1, 12:31am
       live event Mooseboy018 950 0 Feb 1, 2:36am
       Collapse At 2:08 Lissuin 922 27 Feb 1, 5:01am
           Collapse So, why did he? Kilidoescartwheels 679 25 Feb 2, 8:52pm
               Because Cirashala 586 0 Feb 3, 10:36pm
               Collapse I guess that if that scene is missing from the final cut Milieuterrien 575 23 Feb 3, 11:52pm
                   Collapse totally understandable LSF 572 20 Feb 3, 11:57pm
                       Collapse What was missing is Bard asking questions Milieuterrien 566 19 Feb 4, 12:09am
                           Collapse Bard LSF 554 1 Feb 4, 12:18am
                               Of course Bard is a candidate for suspicion - for they decided him to be so Milieuterrien 550 0 Feb 4, 12:26am
                           Bilbo??? Otaku-sempai 523 0 Feb 4, 2:34am
                           Collapse Problem with that theory Kilidoescartwheels 523 15 Feb 4, 2:40am
                               Collapse Thorin and Bilbo Otaku-sempai 513 14 Feb 4, 3:05am
                                   Collapse Sketchy Bilbo No One in Particular 502 11 Feb 4, 3:21am
                                       Collapse Thorin did suspect Bilbo twice in Erebor Milieuterrien 445 10 Feb 4, 5:36pm
                                           Collapse About that acorn scene - not just Bilbo Kilidoescartwheels 370 9 Feb 5, 3:15pm
                                               Collapse The movie shows you're right - and Cirashala too Milieuterrien 306 8 Feb 5, 7:49pm
                                                   trailers LSF 299 0 Feb 5, 7:57pm
                                                   Collapse I'm trying to figure out LSF 295 6 Feb 5, 8:15pm
                                                       Collapse It can help you to figure that out, Milieuterrien 255 5 Feb 6, 3:00pm
                                                           Collapse trailers LSF 231 3 Feb 6, 6:11pm
                                                               Collapse You get what I mean Milieuterrien 217 2 Feb 6, 7:05pm
                                                                   Collapse yes... LSF 210 1 Feb 6, 7:11pm
                                                                       No, I mostly quit thinking that Milieuterrien 205 0 Feb 6, 7:36pm
                                                           forgot to say in previous reply LSF 220 0 Feb 6, 6:54pm
                                   Collapse Well, that's the thing Kilidoescartwheels 374 1 Feb 5, 3:07pm
                                       Agreed... Otaku-sempai 324 0 Feb 5, 4:08pm
                   Collapse Erm... Cirashala 539 1 Feb 4, 1:35am
                       Too thin are my arguments towards Bilbo Milieuterrien 506 0 Feb 4, 3:19am
           reply lacika 468 0 Feb 4, 3:30pm
       Wasn't it shown during PJ's "Sneak Peek" event in March or April 2013? Eleniel 893 0 Feb 1, 7:59am
       Another part of the scene Hanarr 430 0 Feb 4, 6:06pm
       Here it is PredatoR 264 0 Feb 6, 1:48pm

  Collapse A crazy petition and a crazy script? NManfredi 1403 75 Jan 29, 10:12pm Jump to last post in thread (by NManfredi)
       Collapse WB is already aware of potential for a bridge movie... AshNazg 1260 19 Jan 30, 1:48am
           Collapse not at all Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1198 2 Jan 30, 10:52am
               Collapse Oh, I think it will be a while... AshNazg 1190 1 Jan 30, 11:32am
                   None of those movies Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1184 0 Jan 30, 12:10pm
           Collapse I don't think there's a declining interest in the franchise NManfredi 1099 15 Jan 30, 6:23pm
               Collapse I'm not saying there's no audience/no interest... AshNazg 1015 1 Jan 30, 9:42pm
                   I agree with what you've said NManfredi 984 0 Jan 31, 12:01am
               Collapse I agree Misty Mountain Hop 733 12 Feb 1, 2:14pm
                   Collapse Risks Otaku-sempai 308 11 Feb 1, 3:51pm
                       Collapse I agree with all of those points. Misty Mountain Hop 303 1 Feb 1, 3:55pm
                           Potential films Otaku-sempai 302 0 Feb 1, 4:10pm
                       Collapse If I were involved in the brainstorming of such a film NManfredi 296 7 Feb 1, 4:22pm
                           Collapse The Eagle of the Star Otaku-sempai 288 6 Feb 1, 4:32pm
                               Collapse I agree NManfredi 280 5 Feb 1, 4:42pm
                                   Collapse General plot-points Otaku-sempai 269 4 Feb 1, 5:14pm
                                       Collapse Those points could definitely work NManfredi 261 3 Feb 1, 5:28pm
                                           Collapse Potential film outline Otaku-sempai 260 2 Feb 1, 5:31pm
                                               Collapse it's a terrific timeline and essay NManfredi 254 1 Feb 1, 5:45pm
                                                   Thank you Otaku-sempai 248 0 Feb 1, 6:04pm
                       About point number 2 NManfredi 290 0 Feb 1, 4:31pm
       Collapse you think Estel a brat? geordie 1142 5 Jan 30, 3:33pm
           Collapse Sorry, I didn't understand your post NManfredi 1103 4 Jan 30, 6:06pm
               Collapse The word brat Starling 1088 3 Jan 30, 6:48pm
                   Yes, it was wrong to write that NManfredi 1080 0 Jan 30, 6:54pm
                   Collapse yep - geordie 1079 1 Jan 30, 6:55pm
                       My mistake, then NManfredi 1075 0 Jan 30, 7:18pm
       Collapse Yes, and no. Otaku-sempai 1061 1 Jan 30, 7:33pm
           Thank you! NManfredi 1050 0 Jan 30, 7:53pm
       Collapse Script notes Otaku-sempai 1036 1 Jan 30, 8:39pm
           You are quite right! NManfredi 980 0 Jan 31, 12:09am
       Collapse I think attaching a basic script to such a petition is a good idea Gianna 801 30 Feb 1, 2:42am
           Collapse Been there, done that... Eleniel 771 8 Feb 1, 8:15am
               Collapse Still by far the best effort of its type that I have seen Voronwë_the_Faithful 728 2 Feb 1, 2:50pm
                   Collapse Thanks! // Eleniel 284 1 Feb 1, 4:38pm
                       Thank YOU! NManfredi 279 0 Feb 1, 4:46pm
               Collapse D'you know what.... dormouse 707 1 Feb 1, 3:42pm
                   Glad you enjoyed it, DM... Eleniel 254 0 Feb 1, 5:53pm
               Collapse Are you really offering me this possibility? NManfredi 296 2 Feb 1, 4:27pm
                   Collapse Not suggesting you copy it word for word, of course.. Eleniel 278 1 Feb 1, 4:48pm
                       I daren't do that NManfredi 274 0 Feb 1, 4:58pm
           Script? or outline? Otaku-sempai 708 0 Feb 1, 3:35pm
           Collapse I would deeply appreciate your help NManfredi 272 19 Feb 2, 2:30pm
               Collapse Synopsis and Outlines Otaku-sempai 263 16 Feb 2, 3:40pm
                   Collapse Amazing! NManfredi 236 15 Feb 2, 4:15pm
                       Collapse Denethor's jealousy isn't my idea Otaku-sempai 230 14 Feb 2, 4:20pm
                           Collapse Yes, I learnt that a couple of days ago NManfredi 224 13 Feb 2, 4:35pm
                               Collapse Location! Location! Location! Otaku-sempai 221 12 Feb 2, 4:46pm
                                   Collapse On Location (pun intended) ange1e4e5 218 4 Feb 2, 4:47pm
                                       Collapse Hmmm... Otaku-sempai 213 2 Feb 2, 5:12pm
                                           Collapse On Location 2 ange1e4e5 202 1 Feb 2, 5:31pm
                                               Previs for the Sea of Rhun Otaku-sempai 199 0 Feb 2, 5:44pm
                                       Locations (cont'd) Otaku-sempai 205 0 Feb 2, 5:29pm
                                   Collapse Totally NManfredi 195 6 Feb 2, 5:49pm
                                       Collapse Aragorn's Great Journeys Otaku-sempai 189 5 Feb 2, 6:18pm
                                           Collapse Correct me if im wrong NManfredi 172 4 Feb 2, 7:16pm
                                               Collapse Sixteenth and Last Chieftain of the Dúnedain Otaku-sempai 162 3 Feb 2, 8:43pm
                                                   Collapse It would be interesting NManfredi 156 2 Feb 2, 8:52pm
                                                       Collapse Leading the Dúnedain Otaku-sempai 154 1 Feb 2, 8:56pm
                                                           Haha NManfredi 215 0 Feb 2, 9:03pm
               Collapse I'll do some thinking about possible scenes Gianna 218 1 Feb 2, 4:56pm
                   I'm totally in! NManfredi 192 0 Feb 2, 5:53pm
       Collapse I agree with Gianna Nieriel 781 4 Feb 1, 4:45am
           Collapse I would also appreciate your help NManfredi 270 3 Feb 2, 2:32pm
               Collapse Casting Suggestions for The Silmarillion ange1e4e5 261 2 Feb 2, 3:36pm
                   Collapse Okay... Otaku-sempai 255 1 Feb 2, 3:50pm
                       On Aragorn Prequel ange1e4e5 248 0 Feb 2, 4:03pm
       Collapse The Pitch Otaku-sempai 242 6 Feb 1, 7:29pm
           Collapse Otaku-sempai, you have great ideas NManfredi 215 5 Feb 1, 9:00pm
               Thanks! Otaku-sempai 210 0 Feb 1, 9:09pm
               Collapse Or you could just set your notional target audience.... dormouse 199 3 Feb 1, 11:38pm
                   You're absolutely right, Dormouse NManfredi 187 0 Feb 2, 1:49am
                   Collapse On a side note NManfredi 277 1 Feb 2, 1:57pm
                       Target Audience Otaku-sempai 265 0 Feb 2, 3:28pm
       Collapse Studio and Television Executives Otaku-sempai 226 1 Feb 1, 7:52pm
           I cracked reading this! Haha NManfredi 213 0 Feb 1, 9:05pm

  Collapse Why Galadriel became weak... AshNazg 813 7 Jan 29, 9:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       That all makes sense LSF 777 0 Jan 29, 9:37pm
       Collapse She goes weak Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 696 4 Jan 30, 10:58am
           Collapse But the way I see it... AshNazg 690 3 Jan 30, 11:49am
               Elrond LSF 666 0 Jan 30, 4:18pm
               Collapse My take is... Iarhen 488 1 Feb 1, 5:31pm
                 GREAT Nuisances!..Gleaned from a.. Bombadil 346 0 Feb 7, 7:44am
       I don't see it. Otaku-sempai 621 0 Jan 30, 7:35pm

  Collapse We are definitely in the post movies doldrums.... Eruonen 1868 23 Jan 25, 8:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by Riven Delve)
       I'm planning on starting a semi-regular Hobbit music-themed discussion series Earl 1642 0 Jan 26, 8:51am
       All quiet on the Hobbit front Kilidoescartwheels 1529 0 Jan 26, 6:27pm
     Collapse I'm not..... Avandel 1503 5 Jan 26, 8:08pm
           Yeah, fanfics Kilidoescartwheels 1451 0 Jan 26, 11:07pm
           Collapse I've never tried fanfic Belegdir 1274 3 Jan 27, 4:50pm
               Collapse A lot of questionable stuff, but.... Avandel 1253 2 Jan 27, 6:51pm
                   Collapse Thanks for the list Belegdir 1241 1 Jan 27, 6:54pm
                       another suggestion sevilodorf 1158 0 Jan 28, 4:26am
       Music, art, fan films!! Glaurung63 1399 0 Jan 27, 2:41am
       Collapse I've been rationing Nieriel 1398 13 Jan 27, 2:56am
         Collapse Too much is not enough Avandel 1261 12 Jan 27, 6:34pm
               Collapse A special request Kilidoescartwheels 1050 11 Jan 28, 9:13pm
                   Collapse well..... Avandel 1009 10 Jan 29, 12:15am
                       Collapse This clearly fills one of those "plot holes" people complain about Riven Delve 1003 7 Jan 29, 12:34am
                         Collapse Ain't it the TRUTH????!!!! Avandel 989 6 Jan 29, 1:50am
                               Collapse And all this ... Riven Delve 917 5 Jan 29, 12:21pm
                                 Collapse *sob* Avandel 822 4 Jan 30, 1:31am
                                       Collapse Just thought I'd ... Nieriel 811 3 Jan 30, 1:56am
                                           Collapse I think that picture is very sad. Riven Delve 809 2 Jan 30, 2:05am
                                               Collapse LOL! Nieriel 801 1 Jan 30, 2:47am
                                                   ;) // Riven Delve 715 0 Jan 30, 10:57pm
                       Collapse Mucho Gracias! Kilidoescartwheels 991 1 Jan 29, 12:51am
                           You are on! Avandel 982 0 Jan 29, 1:52am

  Collapse I See Fire is not a good credits music at all DainPig 1514 50 Jan 24, 3:37am Jump to last post in thread (by RosieLass)
       Na... it´s perfect EgyptRaider 1364 0 Jan 24, 7:51am
       Um... thanks for the input? Aragorn the Elfstone 1367 0 Jan 24, 8:01am
       Nothing to do with rest of the movie? LSF 1356 0 Jan 24, 8:15am
       You may not like it - which is fair enough.... dormouse 1343 0 Jan 24, 9:07am
       Well Smaug the iron 1327 0 Jan 24, 9:58am
       Collapse Whilst I don't personally care for the song very much... malickfan 1315 3 Jan 24, 12:14pm
           Collapse Well.. EgyptRaider 1306 1 Jan 24, 12:52pm
               Well, as a 24 year old male... malickfan 1295 0 Jan 24, 1:02pm
           Agreed Kilidoescartwheels 966 0 Jan 25, 2:46pm
       Well Glorfindela 1295 0 Jan 24, 12:57pm
       Collapse The lyrics fit, but not the style MyWeeLadGimli 1250 1 Jan 24, 4:05pm
           "I See Fire" Otaku-sempai 1231 0 Jan 24, 4:39pm
       It's only post credits song that doesn't feel like a Middle-earth song. Thrain II 1184 0 Jan 24, 7:05pm
       Collapse Mixed feelings.... Avandel 1156 4 Jan 24, 9:54pm
           Collapse I agree with Boyens LSF 492 3 Jan 26, 3:05pm
               Collapse I'd still disagree.... Avandel 473 2 Jan 26, 7:38pm
                   Collapse Not at all jarring for me. LSF 461 1 Jan 26, 8:18pm
                       *smiles and bows* - agree to disagree Avandel 437 0 Jan 26, 11:05pm
       Collapse I like it fine, but... TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1084 1 Jan 25, 4:12am
           Wow! Ettelewen 566 0 Jan 25, 7:55pm
       Collapse Echoes of Great Mining Songs Michelle Johnston 1061 15 Jan 25, 6:41am
           Collapse Something so tragic I never noticed... Pandallo 1049 4 Jan 25, 7:23am
               Collapse Thorin's perspective in I See Fire Hanarr 375 3 Jan 27, 8:19pm
                   Collapse hmm... LSF 358 1 Jan 27, 9:03pm
                       Lonely town Hanarr 238 0 Jan 28, 10:39pm
                   Thank you Avandel 331 0 Jan 28, 12:17am
           Collapse Yes to this, and well said.... dormouse 1024 1 Jan 25, 9:35am
               Thank you D M Michelle Johnston 514 0 Jan 26, 9:31am
           Collapse That's funny, Kilidoescartwheels 969 7 Jan 25, 2:51pm
               Collapse Lol, so did I EgyptRaider 955 1 Jan 25, 3:34pm
                   So did I - I does sound like that // dormouse 950 0 Jan 25, 3:36pm
               Collapse You are right Starling 924 4 Jan 25, 6:29pm
                   Collapse What an entirely disappointing and uninteresting response Michelle Johnston 524 3 Jan 26, 9:30am
                       Collapse You can take up your disappointment with Ed Sheeran Starling 515 2 Jan 26, 10:10am
                           Collapse You misunderstood Michelle Johnston 366 1 Jan 27, 8:45pm
                               Clearly Starling 346 0 Jan 27, 11:03pm
       I probably wouldn't be a big fan Kilidoescartwheels 965 0 Jan 25, 2:50pm
       Generally speaking LSF 920 0 Jan 25, 6:03pm
       It grew upon me and now I enjoy quite a lot. Eruonen 559 0 Jan 25, 8:23pm
       I like the song all right, though it would not be the highest in my ranking. Noria 493 0 Jan 26, 2:37pm
       Another disappointment shadow0421 452 0 Jan 26, 9:51pm
       Collapse Dunno Darkstone 456 4 Jan 26, 10:42pm
           Collapse That one... LSF 452 2 Jan 26, 10:51pm
               Yes Starling 443 0 Jan 26, 11:02pm
               Magpie... Darkstone 432 0 Jan 27, 1:02am
           That's the only one I still loathe. RosieLass 222 0 Jan 29, 8:57pm
       Collapse I think it's just "one song too early" Ilmatar 295 2 Jan 28, 1:32pm
           It was the same here in Sweden DeadRabbits 281 0 Jan 28, 3:10pm
           I never heard it on the radio....not sure it was an official release for airplay. Eruonen 245 0 Jan 28, 10:21pm
       None of the ending songs are particularly relevant to the films. // RosieLass 193 0 Jan 29, 8:53pm

  Collapse SnowpocaHobbitlypse Glaurung63 848 8 Jan 24, 12:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse What a brilliant idea! Nieriel 813 3 Jan 24, 1:23am
           Collapse Just finished DOS! Glaurung63 775 2 Jan 24, 4:45am
               Collapse Smaug is the best dragon on film Glaurung63 766 1 Jan 24, 5:20am
                   Agreed Otaku-sempai 687 0 Jan 24, 3:51pm
     Collapse Procrastination the day after Avandel 664 2 Jan 24, 6:18pm
           Collapse Evankart is amazing, love their work. Fereth 649 1 Jan 24, 7:01pm
             Beautiful and agree about Evankart.... Avandel 620 0 Jan 24, 9:36pm
       Great idea, enjoy! Thrain II 643 0 Jan 24, 7:07pm

  Collapse Lack of Music in the Hobbit MyWeeLadGimli 947 8 Jan 23, 8:26pm Jump to last post in thread (by CathrineB)
       mmm I can't say I've noticed that Nieriel 904 0 Jan 23, 8:39pm
       the musically-silent bits LSF 902 0 Jan 23, 8:43pm
       PJ used lack of music to good effect in LOTR. Ataahua 887 0 Jan 23, 9:43pm
       I've noticed Mooseboy018 877 0 Jan 23, 9:54pm
       For me Glorfindela 834 0 Jan 24, 12:55am
       Collapse Well... Arannir 726 1 Jan 24, 2:40pm
           I agree with Arannir. Noria 542 0 Jan 26, 2:42pm
       Yeah CathrineB 446 0 Jan 29, 2:44pm

  Moved: Tolkien Anthology Films HOBBITFAN13 - - Jan 16, 11:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by HOBBITFAN13)

  Collapse can't wait for the generation that watches all 6 in chronological order makingstarwars 1977 67 Jan 15, 12:45pm Jump to last post in thread (by verdealex79)
       and of course (my edit button disappeared sorry) makingstarwars 1800 0 Jan 15, 1:32pm
       I am very much Lindele 1774 0 Jan 15, 2:35pm
       Made me smile :) Gianna 1773 0 Jan 15, 2:38pm
       Collapse ... StingingFly 1481 2 Jan 17, 6:11pm
           Don't think so. Smaug the iron 1468 0 Jan 17, 6:31pm
           Well, I wouldn't feel too sad.... dormouse 1445 0 Jan 17, 7:03pm
       Collapse I will go to my grave pushing for publication/release order in ALL things... Aragorn the Elfstone 1465 5 Jan 17, 6:51pm
           Collapse It's a fair point... dormouse 1436 3 Jan 17, 7:12pm
               Collapse Well, the books are the books and the films are the films... Aragorn the Elfstone 1433 2 Jan 17, 7:38pm
                   Collapse The films do work as a whole for me, but..... dormouse 1426 1 Jan 17, 7:43pm
                       Yes to appendices in this order TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1380 0 Jan 17, 10:43pm
           Disagree KingTurgon 393 0 Jan 30, 7:27am
     That'll be me over the next evening or two squiggle 1366 0 Jan 17, 11:36pm
       Collapse I'll be warning the next generation... Avnar 1240 43 Jan 19, 1:53am
           Or you might just trust them to make their own judgement... // dormouse 1187 0 Jan 19, 11:37am
           Collapse At least for the next generation in my family Goldeneye 1173 40 Jan 19, 3:41pm
               Collapse And people wonder why I don't condone these practices... TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1079 5 Jan 19, 9:49pm
                   Collapse I put Elessar 569 4 Jan 20, 6:18pm
                       Collapse I'm going to pretend I didn't hear that. Aragorn the Elfstone 561 3 Jan 20, 6:24pm
                           Collapse Sorry man Elessar 449 2 Jan 20, 11:34pm
                               Collapse I'm glad the Oscar voters didn't agree with you... Aragorn the Elfstone 449 1 Jan 20, 11:39pm
                                   I wish they had. Elessar 417 0 Jan 21, 4:18am
               Collapse ... Anubis 576 27 Jan 20, 6:07pm
                   Collapse Fair enough Goldeneye 550 26 Jan 20, 6:44pm
                       Collapse Except your spliced up "edit"... Aragorn the Elfstone 549 25 Jan 20, 6:57pm
                           Collapse Yes Goldeneye 540 24 Jan 20, 7:05pm
                               Collapse You are taking credit for Peter Jackson and co.'s work TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 523 23 Jan 20, 8:27pm
                                   Collapse Ha Goldeneye 508 22 Jan 20, 8:57pm
                                       Collapse That's not what I said TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 500 20 Jan 20, 9:13pm
                                           Collapse Yes Goldeneye 499 19 Jan 20, 9:20pm
                                               You know... ThorinsNemesis 488 0 Jan 20, 9:32pm
                                               Collapse If Lindele 484 16 Jan 20, 9:38pm
                                                   Collapse ... Goldeneye 474 15 Jan 20, 10:02pm
                                                       Collapse I read and loved the Hobbit book way before the movies came out.. ThorinsNemesis 470 14 Jan 20, 10:16pm
                                                           Sure he is Milieuterrien 757 0 Jan 21, 3:19pm
                                                           Collapse This! Jeffrodo 589 12 Jan 25, 4:17pm
                                                               Collapse Bloat Otaku-sempai 572 2 Jan 25, 8:23pm
                                                                   Collapse My kids will be raised with LotR, sauget.diblosio 544 1 Jan 26, 9:40am
                                                                       Don't get me wrong... Otaku-sempai 532 0 Jan 26, 3:04pm
                                                               Collapse Less is more. Gandalf the Green 384 8 Jan 30, 9:49am
                                                                   Wait, or - OR! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 343 0 Jan 31, 10:18pm
                                                                   Collapse Or maybe they just enjoyed the films.... dormouse 322 1 Feb 1, 8:49am
                                                                       What dormouse and TheOnlyOne said Noria 307 0 Feb 1, 1:45pm
                                                                   Collapse Not necessarily Omnigeek 300 4 Feb 1, 2:43pm
                                                                       Collapse Do you always object to things you don't understand? dormouse 291 3 Feb 1, 3:45pm
                                                                           Collapse Nope Omnigeek 287 2 Feb 1, 4:00pm
                                                                               Collapse Returning to the screening order, Milieuterrien 281 1 Feb 1, 4:24pm
  These are wonderful films. verdealex79 184 0 Feb 10, 10:05am
                                               So you will keep in the torturing of the orc by Beorn in the book Milieuterrien 371 0 Jan 21, 2:59pm
                                       Just a question Smaug the iron 484 0 Jan 20, 9:40pm
               ............ ThorinsNemesis 555 0 Jan 20, 6:28pm
               Collapse Yeah... no... LSF 514 4 Jan 20, 8:42pm
                   Collapse Sorry Goldeneye 501 3 Jan 20, 9:09pm
                       That's where we defintely differ LSF 488 0 Jan 20, 9:29pm
                       Collapse Again, you're under the mistaken belief... Aragorn the Elfstone 469 1 Jan 20, 10:15pm
                           The key right here! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 409 0 Jan 21, 6:10am
           Really? KingTurgon 394 0 Jan 30, 7:22am
       Collapse Watch LOTR first Jeffrodo 1157 3 Jan 19, 4:05pm
           Collapse I think we've been given a rare opportunity Lindele 1150 2 Jan 19, 4:29pm
               Collapse I see Jeffrodo 1143 1 Jan 19, 4:33pm
                   I see that Lindele 1136 0 Jan 19, 4:39pm
       Chronological order LSF 1129 0 Jan 19, 4:43pm
       I will be curious to see Elessar 1115 0 Jan 19, 5:31pm
       Or else... Darkstone 1112 0 Jan 19, 6:02pm
       The Order of Films QuiteALittleFellow 1063 0 Jan 19, 10:05pm
       Collapse Publication/release order for me Omnigeek 468 1 Jan 28, 3:43am
           *Shriek!!!* Aragorn the Elfstone 442 0 Jan 28, 9:38pm

  Collapse More Middle earth movies Dain Jackson 2172 66 Jan 14, 9:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Omnigeek)
       Collapse Probably TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1936 1 Jan 14, 10:24am
           What the story ? Dain Jackson 1916 0 Jan 14, 11:06am
       Collapse Not for a while at least... Otaku-sempai 1856 2 Jan 14, 2:45pm
           Collapse I think there's a possible documentary coming... AshNazg 1851 1 Jan 14, 2:58pm
               Yes... Otaku-sempai 1804 0 Jan 14, 4:15pm
       Collapse It's so unfortunate that the world of Middle Earth on the big screen is dying... Misty Mountain Hop 1842 9 Jan 14, 3:25pm
           Collapse Franchising Goldeneye 1819 4 Jan 14, 3:57pm
               I agree, great points Misty Mountain Hop 1801 0 Jan 14, 4:05pm
               Collapse I don't know why, Goldeneye Glorfindela 1732 2 Jan 14, 6:18pm
                   whether good or bad, Lindele 1724 0 Jan 14, 6:23pm
                   Yes, but... Goldeneye 1710 0 Jan 14, 6:56pm
           Collapse No thanks. Bumblingidiot 1686 2 Jan 14, 7:33pm
               Collapse Disney... LSF 1651 1 Jan 14, 8:18pm
                   Disney and their movie merchandise... Gianna 1633 0 Jan 14, 8:54pm
           I must say Hamfast Gamgee 836 0 Jan 20, 12:25am
       Hmm... LSF 1644 0 Jan 14, 8:25pm
       Collapse Reboot! / Darkstone 1620 41 Jan 14, 9:19pm
           Collapse Impossible Lindele 1615 11 Jan 14, 9:36pm
               Collapse Possible! Darkstone 1605 9 Jan 14, 10:21pm
                   Collapse Maybe a different format as well? TV series? longer film series? moreorless 706 8 Jan 16, 4:50pm
                       Collapse Very On Point Michelle Johnston 662 7 Jan 16, 7:23pm
                           Collapse I think a LOTR Tv series would be more likely and probably superior though.. moreorless 600 6 Jan 17, 2:15am
                               Collapse Yes Thats the Kind Of Thing for the LOTR. Michelle Johnston 491 5 Jan 18, 5:29am
                                   Collapse I think things have clearly gotten worse since the days of Jacksons LOTR... moreorless 476 4 Jan 18, 8:52am
                                       Collapse Hobbit almost a blank cheque endorsed of course by Tolkien Michelle Johnston 898 3 Jan 19, 5:48am
                                           Collapse Tha Animated Hobbit Otaku-sempai 871 2 Jan 19, 4:54pm
                                               Collapse David Wenzel is the Co Author Michelle Johnston 799 1 Jan 20, 8:34am
                                                   Oh, that! Otaku-sempai 768 0 Jan 20, 3:10pm
               Always room for improvement... Otaku-sempai 1579 0 Jan 14, 10:43pm
           Collapse I'd be interested in a reboot. Ettelewen 1565 28 Jan 14, 11:51pm
               Collapse You think you're scarred? Starling 1556 2 Jan 15, 12:06am
                   Yuck TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1535 0 Jan 15, 12:45am
                   Polyester abuse is appalling and Nieriel 1534 0 Jan 15, 12:53am
               Collapse If anyone can make an adaptation Lindele 1529 24 Jan 15, 1:30am
                   Screenshot! Darkstone 887 0 Jan 15, 3:01am
                   Collapse Never say 'never'! Otaku-sempai 867 10 Jan 15, 4:33am
                       Collapse Since there Lindele 867 9 Jan 15, 4:52am
                           I feel the same way // dormouse 815 0 Jan 15, 2:03pm
                           Collapse I totally agree with Lindele // Nieriel 774 7 Jan 15, 11:52pm
                               Collapse I'm inclined to agree, too TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 777 6 Jan 16, 12:12am
                                   Collapse Who indeed? Nieriel 774 5 Jan 16, 12:31am
                                       I agree with the sentiment Ettelewen 748 0 Jan 16, 4:43am
                                       Collapse What about Ted Nasmith? malickfan 728 3 Jan 16, 1:22pm
                                           Collapse It's not heresy... dormouse 723 1 Jan 16, 2:11pm
                                               Lee and Howe's sucess for me hints at Tolkiens ponteital for different interpretations.. moreorless 490 0 Jan 18, 5:33am
                                           I don't know if you know this... Silverlode 625 0 Jan 17, 12:29am
                   Collapse Thanks for the cash... or not Elthir 705 10 Jan 16, 5:07pm
                       Collapse If you can prove Lindele 645 9 Jan 16, 11:36pm
                           Let's not be too silly! Otaku-sempai 634 0 Jan 16, 11:45pm
                           the point was Elthir 613 0 Jan 17, 1:19am
                           Collapse Well, right off the bat... Darkstone 982 6 Jan 18, 3:21pm
                               Collapse If we are playing cricket Michelle Johnston 899 3 Jan 19, 5:53am
                                   Collapse Perhaps you misunderstood Lindele 750 2 Jan 20, 5:30pm
                                       I wasn't mistaken Michelle Johnston 730 0 Jan 20, 6:43pm
                                       Off your rocker Omnigeek 379 0 Jan 28, 4:34am
                               Collapse I'd challenge anyone Lindele 750 1 Jan 20, 5:34pm
                                   Shall they do it while standing on one foot? Darkstone 685 0 Jan 21, 2:59pm
                   The art design, music and locations weren't the problem with the first adaptation. RosieLass 516 0 Jan 18, 3:56am
       Collapse Yes HOBBITFAN13 687 2 Jan 16, 5:35pm
           Collapse I don't think so. Smaug the iron 683 1 Jan 16, 6:02pm
               A TV show? Weed 679 0 Jan 16, 6:09pm
       Collapse Yes! I'd love it Jeffrodo 663 3 Jan 21, 4:30pm
           Collapse Bridge Trilogy? Otaku-sempai 655 2 Jan 21, 5:06pm
               Collapse I see your point Jeffrodo 650 1 Jan 21, 5:10pm
                   A Fair Question Otaku-sempai 650 0 Jan 21, 5:25pm
       With the proper director and producer paperC 450 0 Jan 25, 12:31pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 1054 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.