Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 7 of 930 (332840 posts in 13946 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 930 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Two different films? LeglessLegolas 905 5 Dec 22, 11:51pm Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Collapse Yes, agreed Glorfindela 419 2 Dec 23, 12:12am
           Collapse I agree... ecthelionsbeard 326 1 Dec 23, 12:56am
               I think it's one of those MasterOrc 291 0 Dec 23, 1:47am
       I think many don't really know how to comprehend it MEIGWIT 104 0 Dec 23, 1:32pm
       When it comes to the net alot of predesposition exists.. moreorless 57 0 Tue, 8:18pm

  Collapse $89,131,544 priell3 751 3 Dec 22, 8:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Collapse Tally Glorfindela 323 1 Dec 22, 10:17pm
           It doesn't BlackFox 294 0 Dec 22, 10:36pm
       It is quite interesting how blockbusters seem to be "spilt" these days... moreorless 125 0 Dec 23, 5:17am

  Collapse Jackson, the man who went up against the trends he helped create? moreorless 757 6 Dec 22, 8:45pm Jump to last post in thread (by cartermoulton)
       BUT who'se tone is larger than life and somewhat cartoonish... patrickk 310 0 Dec 22, 9:10pm
       Collapse Definitely disagree Lindele 312 3 Dec 22, 9:10pm
           7 haarp 199 0 Dec 22, 11:00pm
           When I say "tamed CGI".. moreorless 94 0 Dec 23, 7:41am
           i think people need to focus more.... cartermoulton 81 0 Dec 23, 9:27am
       LOTR pushed CGI to the limits available at the time. glor 196 0 Dec 22, 11:15pm

  Collapse Why no Warg Riders? If they were present I missed them. Eruonen 896 43 Dec 22, 7:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Faleel)
       They were fed to the worms and trolls. Brandybuckled 464 0 Dec 22, 7:59pm
       Collapse The complaint about the Bagend dinner scene is getting on my nerves. Azaghâl 503 1 Dec 22, 8:01pm
           Are you referring to critics of AUJ? Wrong thread. Eruonen 434 0 Dec 22, 8:02pm
       Collapse Long shot but dubulous 441 1 Dec 22, 8:08pm
           Well, PJ is fond of repeating other things so I think it had to do more Eruonen 398 0 Dec 22, 8:21pm
       I thought they were unnecessary Glorfindela 371 0 Dec 22, 8:35pm
       Collapse What was their key part? Spriggan 348 18 Dec 22, 9:05pm
           Collapse Refer to The Hobbit Eruonen 336 17 Dec 22, 9:14pm
               Collapse Sorry, yes I'm aware they were in the book. Spriggan 300 16 Dec 22, 9:40pm
                   Collapse Visual and audio impact plus ferocity. Eruonen 297 15 Dec 22, 9:41pm
                       Collapse In the book? Spriggan 294 14 Dec 22, 9:47pm
                           LOL!// arithmancer 265 0 Dec 22, 10:06pm
                           Collapse The thread title is "Why no warg riders" Eruonen 266 12 Dec 22, 10:13pm
                               Collapse Apologies. I'm not trying to be obtuse. Spriggan 251 11 Dec 22, 10:33pm
                                   Collapse Ok, then it is the Battle of 4 Armies.... Eruonen 225 10 Dec 22, 10:53pm
                                       Collapse Warg riders, or more precisely wolf riders Spriggan 211 9 Dec 22, 11:05pm
                                           Collapse Really? Perhaps you should tell John Rateliff... Eleniel 189 1 Dec 22, 11:20pm
                                               Alas I don't know him but he is incorrect, slightly. Spriggan 137 0 Dec 23, 12:07am
                                           Collapse This is what I said "They were a key part of the book battle." Eruonen 170 6 Dec 22, 11:46pm
                                               Collapse "key" arithmancer 136 5 Dec 22, 11:57pm
                                                   Collapse How many angels can dance on the head of a pin? Eruonen 134 2 Dec 23, 12:03am
                                                       Collapse Oh, OK arithmancer 125 1 Dec 23, 12:08am
                                                           Possibly, but orcs/goblins, coming from various places were Eruonen 104 0 Dec 23, 1:13am
                                                   Collapse I'm afraid it seems rude of me to persevere but Spriggan 130 1 Dec 23, 12:09am
                                                       The think... ecthelionsbeard 114 0 Dec 23, 12:40am
       Collapse Darn! Now I know what was missing from this film... Elarie 254 9 Dec 22, 10:46pm
           Collapse Can you imagine Beorn covered in wargs? QuackingTroll 237 1 Dec 22, 10:50pm
               Yes! Beorn flinging wargs around would have been impressive! Eruonen 222 0 Dec 22, 10:54pm
         Fingers crossed! // BlackFox 226 0 Dec 22, 10:52pm
           Collapse Imagine Dain on Boris meeting Azog or Bolg on Daisy Eruonen 225 5 Dec 22, 10:56pm
               Collapse We know what happened to Boris BlackFox 225 4 Dec 22, 11:04pm
                   Collapse Poor Daisy Elarie 116 3 Dec 23, 1:16am
                       Collapse He would probably shack up with her as he is used to living with a pig. Eruonen 107 1 Dec 23, 1:41am
                         Hehehe! // BlackFox 43 0 Dec 23, 10:26am
                     That goes straight to the top of my EE wishlist! BlackFox 46 0 Dec 23, 10:26am
       Collapse All I can think of reading through this thread Silverlode 101 1 Dec 23, 2:56am
           True, but we already have whole cgi armies of goblins, dwarves, elves. Eruonen 84 0 Dec 23, 3:12am
       THANK GOD MouthofSauron 90 0 Dec 23, 3:29am
       Collapse Second, and more serious thoughts on this... Silverlode 87 3 Dec 23, 4:26am
           Collapse Good points and I won't ask you the meaning of "serious" ;) Eruonen 74 1 Dec 23, 5:01am
               Or what the meaning of "is" is...? Silverlode 69 0 Dec 23, 5:32am
           yes, I would have preferred a classical interpretation of the fifth army. Bladerunner 47 0 Dec 23, 12:40pm
       The warg Faleel 6 0 Fri, 12:36am

  Collapse Today's experience at the cinema Glorfindela 916 7 Dec 22, 7:20pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Almost everyone stayed through the credits in my viewing too... AshNazg 368 0 Dec 22, 7:40pm
       Ironfoot CathrineB 389 0 Dec 22, 7:42pm
       My first experience with HFR... tsmith675 293 0 Dec 22, 8:54pm
       Collapse 3rd viewing for me too today, 3D this time Loresilme 267 3 Dec 22, 9:13pm
           Collapse mhm CathrineB 218 2 Dec 22, 10:00pm
               Collapse Yep, exactly Loresilme 183 1 Dec 22, 10:35pm
                   TODAY? Bomby saw it TWICE for Free? Bombadil 144 0 Dec 23, 2:22am

  Collapse PJ says the industry has lost its way by focusing on franchises and technology AshNazg 1348 18 Dec 22, 6:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       In spite of the fact Ham_Sammy 749 0 Dec 22, 6:52pm
       Collapse Wow! R11 611 8 Dec 22, 8:12pm
           Wha? Brandybuckled 537 0 Dec 22, 8:20pm
           Collapse There's a difference Ataahua 519 4 Dec 22, 8:41pm
               that was my take as well Ataahua Ham_Sammy 446 0 Dec 22, 8:51pm
               Collapse Me thinks you're splitting hairs R11 220 1 Dec 23, 1:09am
                   ron... patrickk 192 0 Dec 23, 2:10am
               If he was so concerned about the oversaturation of franchises... Morthoron 167 0 Dec 23, 2:59am
           If you are into reading one thing Lindele 394 0 Dec 22, 9:23pm
           This whole thing about Franchises... patrickk 379 0 Dec 22, 9:31pm
       Thank you Ashnazg - would also like to post this link Loresilme 476 0 Dec 22, 8:28pm
       What I sort of got from this article was... Misty Mountain Hop 430 0 Dec 22, 9:14pm
       Collapse PJ doesn't hate franchises, he just says there are too many QuackingTroll 337 3 Dec 22, 10:43pm
           Ding ding ding ding ding Ham_Sammy 299 0 Dec 22, 11:10pm
           Collapse The studios or, the audiences ? glor 279 1 Dec 22, 11:27pm
               I think its "the industry"... moreorless 97 0 Dec 23, 9:02am
       Look, PJ seems like a cool guy demnation 151 0 Dec 23, 5:06am
       Define "franchise" Silverlode 126 0 Dec 23, 6:37am

  Collapse The Butchering of Howard Shore Gandy 1209 21 Dec 22, 6:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by Aragorn the Elfstone)
       Collapse I find it hard to believe Lindele 628 1 Dec 22, 6:47pm
           Again... smtfhw 476 0 Dec 22, 7:02pm
       Collapse Poor Howard. Did they find enough body parts for a burial? Spriggan 537 2 Dec 22, 6:48pm
           LOL! Ham_Sammy 468 0 Dec 22, 6:53pm
         *mods up* // BlackFox 422 0 Dec 22, 7:12pm
       About the score [STARS}TyranT 490 0 Dec 22, 6:58pm
       Sorry you feel that way Glorfindela 448 0 Dec 22, 7:06pm
       After the first few moments... priell3 447 0 Dec 22, 7:10pm
       There are some great documentaries that explain the power of quiet, minimalist soundtracks QuackingTroll 438 0 Dec 22, 7:10pm
       Kind of agree CathrineB 386 0 Dec 22, 7:45pm
       Collapse The score is now the musical expression of a story over 6 movies, not 3 Loresilme 415 2 Dec 22, 8:02pm
           Perfect Lindele 352 0 Dec 22, 8:19pm
           Excellently put! BlackFox 315 0 Dec 22, 9:03pm
       Collapse I agree Dipling 348 1 Dec 22, 8:29pm
           I definitely noticed that the music was hard to hear too hobbitylass 284 0 Dec 22, 9:48pm
       Collapse hyperbole nymmerod 288 2 Dec 22, 10:03pm
           I agree with this Glorfindela 258 0 Dec 22, 10:22pm
           This. So much. Aragorn the Elfstone 106 0 Dec 23, 7:46am
       Collapse Mostly agree with your points Skaan 233 1 Dec 22, 11:24pm
           Yes... Dipling 109 0 Dec 23, 7:31am
       Great post-- elentari3018 140 0 Dec 23, 4:14am

  Collapse It's 2.5 days later and I still can't decide how I feel about this movie KingTurgon 1077 27 Dec 22, 6:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Lurker in the Mirk)
       Collapse In some ways yes, that is why I hope the EE evens out some scenes. Eruonen 547 1 Dec 22, 6:19pm
           Just watched the RA/LP Apple interview Avandel 279 0 Dec 22, 11:21pm
       Collapse It is unfortunate Lindele 545 5 Dec 22, 6:28pm
           Collapse I think Alfrid provided some important light comic break from Eruonen 408 4 Dec 22, 7:19pm
               Collapse That was a role that would have been better left to the "other" dwarves. n/m Brandybuckled 388 1 Dec 22, 7:24pm
                   But, he was tied in to the Laketown governance and the Master so Eruonen 375 0 Dec 22, 7:27pm
               About Alfrid Kilidoescartwheels 384 0 Dec 22, 7:34pm
               I liked the way he didnt come to a sticky end... moreorless 333 0 Dec 22, 8:18pm
       I get it... Brandybuckled 478 0 Dec 22, 6:34pm
       Collapse What I Found Interesting smtfhw 509 6 Dec 22, 6:35pm
           Collapse I often think Lindele 459 5 Dec 22, 6:38pm
               Yep... smtfhw 427 0 Dec 22, 6:41pm
               Collapse Really? I tend to manage. Spriggan 436 1 Dec 22, 6:46pm
                   Well it depends on the film Lindele 417 0 Dec 22, 6:54pm
               Collapse Perhaps moreso with fans... moreorless 322 1 Dec 22, 8:22pm
                   Very true Ham_Sammy 305 0 Dec 22, 8:31pm
       I can see why Belegdir 408 0 Dec 22, 7:11pm
       Collapse I agree with the OP priell3 394 2 Dec 22, 7:28pm
           Collapse Totally immersed in.. patrickk 297 1 Dec 22, 9:36pm
               Agree, I have no issue with turning this into 3 movies by Eruonen 238 0 Dec 22, 11:09pm
       Collapse Very much so Avandel 287 3 Dec 22, 10:40pm
           Collapse Avandel the... patrickk 178 1 Dec 23, 2:17am
               Thank you Avandel 156 0 Dec 23, 2:59am
           It seems Dipling 68 0 Dec 23, 7:34am
       The good stuff they did really well elentari3018 151 0 Dec 23, 4:28am
       All I can say is lionoferebor 97 0 Dec 23, 4:41am
       I think I can understand your feelings. Lurker in the Mirk 70 0 Dec 23, 9:09am

  Collapse Your favourite 'Hobbit Rumour' from the last few years BornOutOfTheWest 979 26 Dec 22, 5:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Rembrethil)
       Collapse zombie Smaug brought back from the dead by the necromancer fighting in the battle LoremIpsum 491 1 Dec 22, 5:54pm
           And when he dies he explodes into a fireball and becomes the Eye // AshNazg 429 0 Dec 22, 6:07pm
       Collapse Galadriel/Gandalf romance Ataahua 494 3 Dec 22, 5:57pm
           But Gandalf's dialogue in BotFA still vaguely suggests this // AshNazg 452 0 Dec 22, 6:08pm
           LOL! // Loresilme 266 0 Dec 22, 9:18pm
         ROTFL.. re. Celeborn's quote!!! mae govannen 77 0 Dec 23, 12:46pm
       Whilst... DjU 486 0 Dec 22, 5:58pm
       A couple Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 469 0 Dec 22, 6:04pm
       Collapse Necromancer subplot Danielos 481 3 Dec 22, 6:05pm
           Collapse The Necromancer stuff was an area that PJ could really have expanded and made his own AshNazg 446 2 Dec 22, 6:15pm
               Collapse The funny thing is... Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 434 1 Dec 22, 6:33pm
                   Everything else was completely made up... patrickk 259 0 Dec 22, 9:39pm
       Collapse That one or more of the dwarves would be female Loresilme 312 6 Dec 22, 9:20pm
           Collapse That was really bad Ham_Sammy 292 5 Dec 22, 9:28pm
               Collapse A casting one glor 227 4 Dec 22, 11:32pm
                   Collapse I remember that one Ham_Sammy 196 3 Dec 22, 11:54pm
                       Collapse Ian Mcshane Mcoull 193 2 Dec 23, 12:21am
                           Oh absolutely Ham_Sammy 174 0 Dec 23, 12:23am
                           Well I think shadowdog 148 0 Dec 23, 1:34am
       Rumor about Thorin's death. Holly Hobbit 250 0 Dec 22, 11:37pm
       Sauron/Annatar and Rings flashback // xxxyyy 146 0 Dec 23, 1:39am
       Collapse the ones I thought were absurd/humourous Cirashala 185 1 Dec 23, 1:44am
           Just no... Ham_Sammy 142 0 Dec 23, 1:51am
       That Thorin would survive BlackFox 80 0 Dec 23, 12:51pm
       That Thranduil and Tauriel were lovers Eruvandi 46 0 Wed, 4:49pm
       Bombur was a female...hence his/her silence. Rembrethil 19 0 Fri, 4:01am

  Collapse Sting Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 400 4 Dec 22, 5:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Collapse In Rivendell on the way home // AshNazg 183 1 Dec 22, 5:51pm
           I like that idea // Loresilme 94 0 Dec 22, 8:31pm
       Collapse IF this were to be in the film Lindele 166 1 Dec 22, 6:29pm
           As I said... Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 145 0 Dec 22, 6:37pm

  Collapse My theater is pulling the 3D after tomorrow... ghost_matt 525 8 Dec 22, 5:38pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)
       Collapse Whereas.... smtfhw 266 1 Dec 22, 5:43pm
           What was interesting for me to note was that I was not that aware Eruonen 215 0 Dec 22, 6:24pm
       Sorry to hear that Ham_Sammy 214 0 Dec 22, 5:45pm
       Collapse Talk your family into it re the performances Avandel 228 4 Dec 22, 5:46pm
           Collapse HFR ghost_matt 163 3 Dec 22, 7:22pm
               Collapse Never see 24 fps 3D Finrod 98 2 Dec 22, 9:59pm
                   Collapse That is not the film, it is the cinema glor 77 1 Dec 22, 11:45pm
                       Yep. Silverlode 37 0 Dec 23, 4:54am

  Collapse So much for a 'Winter Battle'... BornOutOfTheWest 930 7 Dec 22, 5:28pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       The trilogy of missed upportunities Azaghâl 448 0 Dec 22, 5:56pm
       Collapse Not to mention.... tiamy 404 3 Dec 22, 5:58pm
           Collapse Who knows, it could have been a day above freezing and not every Eruonen 338 2 Dec 22, 6:26pm
               Collapse Breath condensation... Elizabeth 96 1 Dec 23, 8:50am
                   And things looked pretty dry, not unusual in winter. Eruonen 63 0 Dec 23, 2:53pm
       Weird Danielos 352 0 Dec 22, 6:10pm
       It was a winter battle... Annatar598 342 0 Dec 22, 7:01pm

  Collapse What happens to the Elvish army? Did they all die? Aranarth 798 7 Dec 22, 5:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       I shouldn't think so Glorfindela 424 0 Dec 22, 5:14pm
       Collapse Elves evaporate after battles... Brandybuckled 390 3 Dec 22, 5:35pm
           lol ... horses too Loresilme 222 0 Dec 22, 8:36pm
           Yes, they are like spun sugar in the rain ;D // Morthoron 94 0 Dec 23, 3:56am
           Actually in Helm's Deep they do all die... QuackingTroll 82 0 Dec 23, 10:57am
       If I remember correctly... Scorchster 382 0 Dec 22, 5:50pm
       If I recall, there were scattered units fighting all over the field. Eruonen 272 0 Dec 22, 7:25pm

  Collapse So who's decision was the 3 movie split? LoremIpsum 1014 37 Dec 22, 3:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       Collapse It was Peter Jackson and co's idea Lindele 594 2 Dec 22, 3:52pm
           Collapse Not so sure Fleuz 522 1 Dec 22, 4:06pm
               I do. Lindele 495 0 Dec 22, 4:11pm
       It was purely creative DigificWriter 496 0 Dec 22, 4:04pm
       Collapse There's no doubt in my mind... tsmith675 526 1 Dec 22, 4:04pm
           Re: There is no doubt in my mind DigificWriter 475 0 Dec 22, 4:12pm
       PJ's decision DjU 499 0 Dec 22, 4:04pm
       PJ Aragorn the Elfstone 392 0 Dec 22, 4:37pm
       Collapse Ideas Danielos 414 10 Dec 22, 4:42pm
           That, I don't know, but Lindele 388 0 Dec 22, 4:46pm
           Collapse Definitely not PJ's idea macfalk 417 5 Dec 22, 4:48pm
               Collapse Evangeline Lily Danielos 417 2 Dec 22, 4:51pm
                   The triangle was added... Aragorn the Elfstone 396 0 Dec 22, 4:55pm
                   Tauriel isnt involved in a love triangle DigificWriter 383 0 Dec 22, 4:59pm
               Agreed. RabidWolverine 362 0 Dec 22, 4:55pm
               Ya, I get the impression that PJ was never a big fan of that KingTurgon 298 0 Dec 22, 6:00pm
           It was always there. Aragorn the Elfstone 377 0 Dec 22, 4:53pm
           Almost certainly... RabidWolverine 364 0 Dec 22, 4:53pm
           I believe lionoferebor 52 0 Dec 23, 4:57am
       Collapse Why does it matter? Glorfindela 352 4 Dec 22, 5:10pm
           Collapse Because Lindele 333 3 Dec 22, 5:19pm
               Collapse I'm thinking Ham_Sammy 302 2 Dec 22, 5:28pm
                   Collapse It was driven far more by creative concerns... DigificWriter 266 1 Dec 22, 6:06pm
                       Agreed Ham_Sammy 228 0 Dec 22, 6:55pm
       Collapse Are we all even talking about the same 3 films? Brandybuckled 259 1 Dec 22, 6:38pm
           There were never originally going to be more than two films DigificWriter 190 0 Dec 22, 7:05pm
       Collapse It was PJ's decision, not WB's... Salmacis81 190 2 Dec 22, 7:13pm
           Collapse Most of what's in the films was dreamed up by Pete, Fran, Phillipa, and GDT DigificWriter 180 1 Dec 22, 7:30pm
               I only mention PJ... Salmacis81 169 0 Dec 22, 7:38pm
       Collapse I suspect a key issue was the way the break changed latter stages of the story.. moreorless 186 3 Dec 22, 8:07pm
           Collapse TDoS's climax was added after the decision to make things into a trilogy of films and wasn't filmed until 2013.... DigificWriter 160 2 Dec 22, 9:27pm
               Collapse Most definitely... Eleniel 124 1 Dec 22, 11:01pm
                   I think thats quite telling as well... moreorless 57 0 Dec 23, 5:44am
       Collapse Well, the way it was reported at the time.... Silverlode 100 3 Dec 23, 12:59am
           Collapse I'm interested in these '3rd film' rumors... DigificWriter 64 2 Dec 23, 5:16am
               Collapse As I recall.... Silverlode 49 1 Dec 23, 7:04am
                   About the "bridge film" DigificWriter 53 0 Dec 23, 7:34am

  Collapse The test videos CathrineB 508 1 Dec 22, 3:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by shaundobson)
       these are great! shaundobson 174 0 Dec 22, 5:10pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 930 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.