Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 7 of 962 (346127 posts in 14430 threads)
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 962 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Would Thrain have gotten the "dragon-sickness"? Kilidoescartwheels 318 16 Feb 13, 2:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       The films did seem to hint at a different personality moreorless 161 0 Feb 13, 3:16pm
       Collapse Apparently he did fall under dragon-sickness... AshNazg 157 13 Feb 13, 3:31pm
           Collapse Perhaps. Otaku-sempai 139 4 Feb 13, 3:43pm
               Collapse Thror gave Thrain the ring before the battle AshNazg 121 3 Feb 13, 4:32pm
                   Collapse Yes. I know. Otaku-sempai 108 2 Feb 13, 4:45pm
                       Collapse Oh, sorry. You said "This legendarium"... AshNazg 106 1 Feb 13, 4:58pm
                           That's fine. Otaku-sempai 94 0 Feb 13, 5:09pm
           Collapse Hmm...well in the book, yes, Thrain did suffer from a gold-sickness Eleniel 128 4 Feb 13, 3:48pm
               Collapse That line made it seem like the sickness was congenital. RosieLass 115 3 Feb 13, 4:19pm
                   Collapse But the gold hadn't been brooded over by a dragon... AshNazg 111 2 Feb 13, 4:37pm
                       More of a comparison? Otaku-sempai 102 0 Feb 13, 4:49pm
                       Well, Tolkien says that dwarves are susceptible to gold fever. RosieLass 107 0 Feb 13, 4:53pm
           Collapse I've been thinking about that line Kilidoescartwheels 96 2 Feb 13, 5:47pm
               Collapse Thorin Otaku-sempai 89 1 Feb 13, 6:10pm
                   Why the other houses care about the Arkenstone Kilidoescartwheels 85 0 Feb 13, 8:03pm
       No.. Thrain II 132 0 Feb 13, 3:41pm

  Collapse If they decide to do another LOTR adaptation in 20 years Martin Freeman would still be perfect to play Bilbo LoremIpsum 379 5 Feb 13, 2:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by Finrod)
     Totally agree! Thrain II 170 0 Feb 13, 3:43pm
       And whoever plays young Bilbo would be great in The Hobbit remake AshNazg 175 0 Feb 13, 4:39pm
       personally Me85 142 0 Feb 13, 6:54pm
       Yes, he would dormouse 80 0 Feb 14, 11:32am
       He’s ready now not later: he shouldn’t age a day! Finrod 49 0 Feb 15, 3:42am

  Collapse Do you think Richard Armitage should have been Aragorn? Thorins_apprentice 1128 56 Feb 13, 9:58am Jump to last post in thread (by RosieLass)
       Collapse Hypothetically Arannir 627 11 Feb 13, 10:07am
           Collapse simply no NoelGallagher 600 8 Feb 13, 10:24am
               Collapse Nah. Arannir 520 7 Feb 13, 12:15pm
                   Collapse I can't imagine that Kilidoescartwheels 447 5 Feb 13, 2:37pm
                       Collapse Agree that RA could easily play Aragorn Glorfindela 391 4 Feb 13, 5:01pm
                           Collapse Tolkien characters burrahobbit 329 3 Feb 13, 8:10pm
                               Collapse Yes Glorfindela 271 2 Feb 13, 11:29pm
                                   Collapse Have you read any of Tom Shippey's books about Tolkien's work? RosieLass 266 1 Feb 14, 12:06am
                                       Thanks very much for letting me know about this Glorfindela 177 0 Feb 14, 11:55am
                   He does at that marillaraina 333 0 Feb 13, 6:48pm
           Collapse Yes, I think he would have been too young for the part at the time. Riven Delve 493 1 Feb 13, 12:04pm
               That was my first reaction shadowdog 361 0 Feb 13, 5:01pm
       Collapse He could easily have been Glorfindela 564 22 Feb 13, 10:36am
           Collapse no balbo biggins 400 18 Feb 13, 4:32pm
               Collapse I've 'read the books' Magpie 335 17 Feb 13, 8:18pm
                   Collapse very interesting balbo biggins 245 16 Feb 14, 1:13am
                       Collapse Perhaps you don't get this place Magpie 245 13 Feb 14, 1:29am
                           I would add RA was an exceptional part Brethil 241 0 Feb 14, 1:40am
                           Collapse i do balbo biggins 235 11 Feb 14, 1:58am
                               Collapse Aha! Starling 231 10 Feb 14, 2:18am
                                   Collapse What other possible explanation is there Riven Delve 233 9 Feb 14, 3:11am
                                       So *that's* why... Eowyn of Penns Woods 218 0 Feb 14, 3:44am
                                       Collapse I don't think I have any hormones left Magpie 226 2 Feb 14, 3:57am
                                           Collapse appeal balbo biggins 187 1 Feb 14, 12:48pm
                                               its not a fact the unless you can back it up with some data Magpie 173 0 Feb 14, 2:38pm
                                       Collapse Oh dear. Is that why Ladies can't be film critics? // Brethil 154 4 Feb 14, 5:17pm
                                           Collapse Mmm.... the little ladies can't be relied on to think clearly.... dormouse 149 1 Feb 14, 5:58pm
                                             An unfathomable oddity, Dormouse. // Brethil 122 0 Feb 14, 6:20pm
                                           Collapse You're far too busy for that. DanielLB 141 1 Feb 14, 6:04pm
                                             There we have some good, solid Viking sensibilities. // Brethil 121 0 Feb 14, 6:19pm
                       The Crucible Dame Ioreth 125 0 Feb 14, 7:14pm
                       Just going to add re VM Avandel 116 0 Feb 15, 5:35pm
           Collapse Was about to say. Macfeast 397 1 Feb 13, 4:42pm
             Yes – absolutely agree Glorfindela 373 0 Feb 13, 4:53pm
           poor Viggo :) marillaraina 376 0 Feb 13, 5:25pm
       Rather different characters I would say... moreorless 509 0 Feb 13, 11:24am
       no Gianna 459 0 Feb 13, 1:19pm
       I though about it as well LoremIpsum 447 0 Feb 13, 1:58pm
       Collapse I wish Aragorn had been written more like Thorin. RosieLass 413 2 Feb 13, 4:14pm
           Collapse But Viggo made a great Strider, sauget.diblosio 54 1 Feb 18, 9:21pm
               That's what I said. RosieLass 40 0 Feb 19, 3:32am
       Armitage could have been Aragorn - Hanzkaz 397 0 Feb 13, 4:25pm
       He could be if they filmed it today Elessar 372 0 Feb 13, 5:21pm
       Totally different wigs.... EomundDaughter 285 0 Feb 13, 9:58pm
       Yes, I think he would have made a great Aragorn if time was not a consideration Kirly 212 0 Feb 14, 3:24am
       No, absolutely not.// Aragorn the Elfstone 207 0 Feb 14, 4:00am
       Collapse as of now he could have been ElendilTheShort 187 1 Feb 14, 10:56am
           In 1999 Richard Armitage Elanor of Rohan 184 0 Feb 14, 2:30pm
       Collapse He'd make a fantastic Aragorn now.... dormouse 199 2 Feb 14, 11:29am
           Agree Avandel 144 0 Feb 15, 12:28am
         Careful, dormouse Glorfindela 149 0 Feb 15, 12:55am
       Nah CathrineB 184 0 Feb 14, 11:38am
       Collapse RA would actually be my first choice to play Eol if the Sil were being made today Elarie 176 1 Feb 14, 2:43pm
           My dream role for RA in the Sil... laurethiel1138 82 0 Feb 17, 6:34pm
       ooooo! *ponders* Fascinating thought! grammaboodawg 170 0 Feb 14, 3:35pm
       Certainly not. // sauget.diblosio 50 0 Feb 18, 9:18pm

Collapse If "The Company" WAS a Company..? Bombadil 473 16 Feb 13, 12:17am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Gandalf? Otaku-sempai 232 8 Feb 13, 12:19am
         Collapse On Site & OFF Site @ Times// Bombadil 197 1 Feb 13, 12:48am
             Gandalf has MANY Duties... Bombadil 160 0 Feb 13, 3:14am
           Collapse No, he was definitely a staff member. Riven Delve 172 5 Feb 13, 3:16am
               IZZ it..He who Carries the BIGGEST STICK..Wins// Bombadil 147 0 Feb 13, 3:31am
             Collapse *Bwaahaaaa!!!* // Brethil 149 3 Feb 13, 3:32am
                   Collapse BUT? Sauron CREMATED G-Manzz Staff Bombadil 147 2 Feb 13, 3:39am
                       The wizard staff change: A detail I hope we see more of in EE Brethil 143 0 Feb 13, 3:46am
                       MISTAKE1.?.? Bilbo wazz "The Intern" Bombadil 139 0 Feb 13, 3:54am
       Collapse Gandalf the CEO? ecthelionsbeard 156 2 Feb 13, 4:03am
           Collapse EXCELLENT Point Bombadil 132 1 Feb 13, 4:27am
               Meanwhile back @ "The Ranch" Bombadil 82 0 Feb 13, 2:49pm
       Collapse What line of work is this company in? burrahobbit 64 1 Feb 13, 8:49pm
           SHORT Answer "THEY make Money" Bombadil 47 0 Feb 13, 10:57pm
       Collapse I don't think Nori would actually be part of the company. Meneldor 45 1 Feb 14, 12:44am
         IT's Kinda Implied in BagEND in AUJ Bombadil 54 0 Feb 14, 1:54am

  Collapse Character popularity on facebook nagaking 528 3 Feb 12, 5:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by nagaking)
       were these facebook pages created around the same time? Me85 221 0 Feb 12, 7:18pm
       Collapse Don't think this is anything to go by LordotRings93 212 1 Feb 12, 8:08pm
           so... nagaking 80 0 Feb 13, 5:06pm

  Collapse Forbes: 'The Hobbit' Trilogy Grossed Almost $3 Billion And No One Cared BlackFox 1468 47 Feb 12, 4:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by glor)
       9 haarp 693 0 Feb 12, 5:05pm
       Collapse "Yet no one seems to have paid it much attention." bungobaggins 716 1 Feb 12, 5:19pm
           Honestly the original statement seems untrue to me as well.. moreorless 625 0 Feb 12, 5:42pm
       Someone Cared Ham_Sammy 616 0 Feb 12, 5:43pm
       Collapse Phhhttt Avandel 609 3 Feb 12, 5:48pm
           Collapse Don't think the article was being critical LordotRings93 446 2 Feb 12, 8:11pm
               Exactly BlackFox 411 0 Feb 12, 8:54pm
               You're quite right, it was NOT critical, mae govannen 196 0 Feb 13, 8:51am
     Collapse What total rot – obviously, the people worldwide who saw it many times cared! Glorfindela 572 1 Feb 12, 5:59pm
           When a journalist says "no-one cares" it really means... AshNazg 522 0 Feb 12, 7:25pm
       At most he is referring to the lack of various film award recognition. Eruonen 562 0 Feb 12, 6:13pm
       Collapse In 5 years Lindele 618 11 Feb 12, 6:19pm
           Collapse Like "A Beautiful Mind".... Darkstone 584 2 Feb 12, 6:24pm
               Collapse Loved "A Beautiful Mind" bungobaggins 565 1 Feb 12, 6:27pm
                   No Lindele 570 0 Feb 12, 6:33pm
           Maybe, just maybe... bungobaggins 515 0 Feb 12, 6:45pm
           Collapse Some really good movies in that list burrahobbit 508 2 Feb 12, 7:33pm
               i probably should have said Lindele 438 0 Feb 12, 8:19pm
               Indeed Aragorn the Elfstone 336 0 Feb 12, 10:18pm
           You cover alot of ground there I'd say... moreorless 217 0 Feb 13, 8:05am
           Collapse Very glad you put that parentheses after Boyhood jtarkey 178 1 Feb 13, 10:37am
               Birdman and Boyhood Arannir 171 0 Feb 13, 10:50am
           I don't know. Elessar 151 0 Feb 13, 3:18pm
       Collapse Did I accidentally link to a wrong article? BlackFox 562 8 Feb 12, 6:36pm
           Collapse As I stated above bungobaggins 538 6 Feb 12, 6:43pm
               Collapse Nobody cares about modern blockbusters Riven Delve 549 5 Feb 12, 7:03pm
                 Collapse R-D for the WIN! BWaHahA..hha WOOT, Woody WOOT wooooot// Bombadil 307 1 Feb 12, 10:18pm
                       ;) // Riven Delve 265 0 Feb 12, 11:52pm
                   Collapse Well done sir! Ham_Sammy 267 2 Feb 13, 12:44am
                       Collapse I am no sir! Riven Delve 258 1 Feb 13, 2:44am
                           Mazel Tov! Ham_Sammy 250 0 Feb 13, 2:47am
           No, only some people didn't read it properly mae govannen 196 0 Feb 13, 8:57am
       Collapse I care! Kim 523 1 Feb 12, 6:48pm
           That's exactly what I was going to say.... dormouse 478 0 Feb 12, 7:36pm
       hmmmmm Elessar 459 0 Feb 12, 7:54pm
       Collapse I don't get it Ilmatar 490 3 Feb 12, 8:02pm
         Collapse You go! Avandel 353 1 Feb 12, 9:02pm
               thanks! Ilmatar 325 0 Feb 12, 9:47pm
           They've now entered the "SW prequal zone"... moreorless 281 0 Feb 13, 4:12am
       Collapse I'm nobody... Silverlode 297 3 Feb 13, 2:34am
           But you bring a much needed clarification mae govannen 195 0 Feb 13, 9:04am
           Collapse The article still kinda rubbed me the wrong way. RosieLass 143 1 Feb 13, 4:57pm
               Huh Elessar 135 0 Feb 13, 5:19pm
     At 3 Billion + (tie ins, home vid etc etc), English Language clearly needs a plural form for 'No One' squiggle 227 0 Feb 13, 7:39am
       Collapse Moment Arannir 221 1 Feb 13, 8:52am
           This glor 109 0 Feb 14, 3:22am
       relevance of the article elostirion74 134 0 Feb 13, 6:27pm

  Moved: The Hobbit Monopoly game??? Kilidoescartwheels - - Feb 12, 4:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)

  Collapse Has PJ commented about the various 'fan edits?' frodolives 960 51 Feb 12, 4:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by shadowdog)
       I would imagine he would just ignore such vanity projects Glorfindela 491 0 Feb 12, 5:56pm
       Probably neither.... dormouse 436 0 Feb 12, 7:21pm
       Collapse I feel that in hes teens we would have donde that (fan edits of his favourite films) Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 415 21 Feb 12, 8:01pm
           Collapse I don't think so Annatar598 310 20 Feb 13, 3:26am
               Collapse Well that´s exactly what he has done with the Hobbit Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 277 1 Feb 13, 7:39am
                   Sorry, that argument doesn't apply Annatar598 267 0 Feb 13, 7:43am
               Collapse Why do people get so venomous about it?! It's a bit of fun, lighten up... AshNazg 246 17 Feb 13, 1:26pm
                   Collapse Agree with the "why worry" point of view. Spriggan 236 16 Feb 13, 2:19pm
                       Collapse So you've never skim-read a boring paragraph or two? // AshNazg 197 15 Feb 13, 3:47pm
                           Collapse I very rarely re-read books but Spriggan 194 14 Feb 13, 5:34pm
                               Collapse Why do you always compare incopmparable mediums? Bishop 186 13 Feb 13, 7:02pm
                                   Collapse Why are they incomparable? Spriggan 165 12 Feb 13, 9:12pm
                                       Collapse Incomparable in the way you're describing it, not altogether generally Bishop 148 11 Feb 13, 9:59pm
                                           Collapse They are certainly different. Spriggan 139 10 Feb 13, 10:06pm
                                               Collapse Ahh! Audio books is a much better example Bishop 130 9 Feb 13, 10:25pm
                                                   Collapse Seems like it's all the same activity to me. Spriggan 124 8 Feb 13, 10:29pm
                                                       Collapse Did my example not make some sense Bishop 122 7 Feb 13, 10:30pm
                                                           Collapse I must confess not. Spriggan 116 6 Feb 13, 10:39pm
                                                               Collapse But that's the thing Bishop 113 3 Feb 13, 10:48pm
                                                                   Collapse Well there you are making two points. Spriggan 103 2 Feb 13, 11:06pm
                                                                       I think it's time to take this to PM entmaiden 95 0 Feb 14, 1:43am
                                                                       Ever make a mix tape? frodolives 42 0 Feb 15, 8:19pm
                                                               Collapse If I might add to this discussion pettytyrant101 111 1 Feb 13, 10:50pm
                                                                   I don't have any question about the feasibility of editing. Spriggan 101 0 Feb 13, 11:10pm
       Collapse My thoughts Bishop 406 25 Feb 12, 9:06pm
           Collapse They should leave it to the imagination Annatar598 326 24 Feb 13, 3:06am
               Collapse Don't be so judgemental Bishop 302 16 Feb 13, 3:37am
                   Collapse I disagree, it is illegal Annatar598 270 15 Feb 13, 7:39am
                       Collapse You seem very certain pettytyrant101 256 4 Feb 13, 8:08am
                           Collapse Maybe so in the UK Annatar598 248 2 Feb 13, 8:13am
                               Collapse That is my point pettytyrant101 234 1 Feb 13, 8:22am
                                   I'm not enforcing anything at all Annatar598 228 0 Feb 13, 8:26am
                           The law is similar in the US entmaiden 213 0 Feb 13, 2:39pm
                       Collapse They can? Aragorn the Elfstone 250 1 Feb 13, 8:10am
                           That was sarcasm on my part Annatar598 240 0 Feb 13, 8:15am
                       Collapse Nah, it is definitely legal (in the UK) now... Bofur01 243 7 Feb 13, 8:15am
                           Collapse I truly don't care much for these fan edits Annatar598 244 6 Feb 13, 8:22am
                               Collapse Agreed Aragorn the Elfstone 233 5 Feb 13, 8:25am
                                   Collapse Yes, and I apologize for any lack of clarity Annatar598 224 3 Feb 13, 8:29am
                                       Collapse Doesn't it just confirm that people were unsatisfied with PJ's version? AshNazg 236 2 Feb 13, 1:35pm
                                           That's what watching a fanedit feels like to me, though Skaan 230 0 Feb 13, 1:58pm
                                           There were fan edits for LOTR too LoremIpsum 225 0 Feb 13, 2:13pm
                                   That depends pettytyrant101 225 0 Feb 13, 8:34am
               Collapse An edit made from legally purchased material and kept to oneself... Aragorn the Elfstone 307 6 Feb 13, 3:41am
                   Collapse But isn't the process of ripping the legal source Annatar598 277 5 Feb 13, 7:34am
                       Collapse And it was illegal for me to record movies with my VHS player... Aragorn the Elfstone 276 2 Feb 13, 8:07am
                           It's over Skaan 258 0 Feb 13, 12:40pm
                           Fly, you fool. Arannir 254 0 Feb 13, 12:43pm
                       Not in the US. entmaiden 215 0 Feb 13, 2:47pm
                       That is what I was thinking. shadowdog 36 0 Feb 15, 11:10pm
       I think Pj couldn't care less about them imin 60 0 Feb 15, 5:00pm

Collapse There MUST be.? More Dol Guldur Bombadil 884 12 Feb 12, 2:08am Jump to last post in thread (by squiggle)
       Collapse More Galadriel? ... TiberiusOgden 444 5 Feb 12, 7:39am
           Collapse That Statue CENTERED in Many Shots Bombadil 355 2 Feb 12, 2:34pm
               Collapse When BOTH Pippin & Aragorn Hold it? Bombadil 304 1 Feb 12, 3:05pm
                   In some STRANGE way? Bombadil 276 0 Feb 12, 3:18pm
           No offense (seriously!) :) KingTurgon 183 0 Feb 13, 1:55am
           I would say the opposite.. moreorless 151 0 Feb 13, 4:07am
       Probably no palantir Otaku-sempai 272 0 Feb 12, 4:40pm
       Maybe... Iarhen 275 0 Feb 12, 4:47pm
       Collapse More Galadriel, Radagast & Sauron having council with the Nine! squiggle 198 3 Feb 13, 4:49am
         Collapse ANY Additional Minutes on Screen Bombadil 113 2 Feb 13, 3:52pm
               Here is a Quote that could be a Clue? Bombadil 118 0 Feb 13, 4:07pm
             Hehehe Bombadil squiggle 83 0 Feb 14, 2:09am

  Collapse US BluRay/DVD Release Date for “The Battle of the Five Armies” PrincessBlade 878 4 Feb 11, 9:42pm Jump to last post in thread (by nagaking)
       special box set? Mooseboy018 386 0 Feb 11, 9:44pm
       Ooooooh, with Lego Bard? Kilidoescartwheels 314 0 Feb 11, 10:54pm
       They should release it... Barrow-Wight 340 0 Feb 11, 11:40pm
       what about EE? nagaking 76 0 Feb 13, 5:05pm

  Collapse Drop him! Mooseboy018 694 1 Feb 11, 9:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kirly)
       Aw! Correct but sad comparison/// Kirly 287 0 Feb 11, 10:58pm

Collapse Re BOFA I am still not sure why Thorin lets go of Bilbo at the wall? Avandel 840 17 Feb 11, 5:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Collapse It seemed to me Glorfindela 456 1 Feb 11, 5:55pm
           I think it's particularly the mention of Thrain... QuackingTroll 289 0 Feb 11, 11:13pm
       Possibly Ilmatar 385 0 Feb 11, 7:22pm
       Collapse I think movie Thranduil would have let Thorin murder Bilbo skyofcoffeebeans 410 2 Feb 11, 7:39pm
           Collapse for those who still don't get it mirkwoodwanderer 416 1 Feb 11, 7:46pm
               I still don't believe you Bishop 365 0 Feb 11, 8:35pm
       The other dwarves Kilidoescartwheels 305 0 Feb 11, 10:50pm
       Collapse I think it was Kim 254 2 Feb 12, 3:10am
           We need the DVD Avandel 156 0 Feb 12, 5:24pm
           Yep...// mae govannen 62 0 Feb 13, 8:27am
       Collapse Harming a Traitor ... or Damaging Property? chauvelin2000 251 2 Feb 12, 5:44am
           this is interesting! Avandel 169 0 Feb 12, 5:20pm
           Very valuable observation indeed!!!...// mae govannen 67 0 Feb 13, 8:31am
       Collapse Yes Thrain II 156 3 Feb 12, 5:53pm
           Collapse I noticed that too! Avandel 132 1 Feb 12, 9:06pm
               Agreed! Thrain II 108 0 Feb 12, 9:54pm
         I hope so too...// mae govannen 70 0 Feb 13, 8:32am

  Collapse So is there a tiny chance it could be revealed in the EE that Thorin had his father's ring all along? LoremIpsum 863 31 Feb 11, 3:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by LoremIpsum)
       Collapse No, 'fraid not. Otaku-sempai 469 12 Feb 11, 3:44pm
           Well I'll still think of it as a missed opportunity LoremIpsum 426 0 Feb 11, 3:49pm
           Collapse Also Thrain's maimed hand doesn't prove anything LoremIpsum 419 10 Feb 11, 3:55pm
               Collapse No. Not really. Otaku-sempai 411 9 Feb 11, 3:58pm
                   Collapse Actually if you watch the scene in the DOS EE LoremIpsum 430 8 Feb 11, 4:02pm
                       Collapse You misremember the scene. Otaku-sempai 404 7 Feb 11, 4:18pm
                           Collapse I didn't say he cut off his hand LoremIpsum 376 6 Feb 11, 4:34pm
                               Collapse Okay. Otaku-sempai 363 2 Feb 11, 4:40pm
                                   Collapse You make a good point however LoremIpsum 352 1 Feb 11, 4:53pm
                                       fascinating discussion... nymmerod 336 0 Feb 11, 5:29pm
                               Collapse I think it's difficult to see the point of Azog taking it at all then, though. Spriggan 218 2 Feb 11, 9:31pm
                                   Collapse Azog taking the ring to Sauron could simply function as a red herring for the audience. LoremIpsum 202 1 Feb 11, 10:03pm
                                       But what is the purpose of the red herring? Spriggan 190 0 Feb 11, 10:16pm
       Collapse I share the excitement about new scenes to come in the EE... dormouse 400 13 Feb 11, 4:47pm
           Collapse You see I don't think Thorin is proud AT ALL in the movies, stubborn maybe but not proud LoremIpsum 311 2 Feb 11, 6:11pm
               Collapse WHY would Sauron NEED the Bombadil 297 1 Feb 11, 6:48pm
                   Sauron wanted Power Otaku-sempai 211 0 Feb 11, 9:45pm
           Collapse Thorin's lack of reaction Ilmatar 299 8 Feb 11, 7:04pm
               Collapse I wouldn't find it odd LoremIpsum 262 7 Feb 11, 7:52pm
                   Collapse Yes, Ilmatar 175 3 Feb 11, 10:46pm
                       Collapse Pride, Ofermod, Turambar & Monsters . . . chauvelin2000 157 2 Feb 12, 7:39am
                           I quite agree with this Voronwë_the_Faithful 120 0 Feb 12, 1:46pm
                           Very interesting, and well said!...// mae govannen 48 0 Feb 13, 9:23am
                   Collapse On Thorin's reasons for going back into Erebor rather than... dormouse 147 2 Feb 12, 8:52am
                       Collapse Thank you dormouse Ilmatar 80 1 Feb 12, 8:41pm
                           He looks very unwell and he's quite shaken up LoremIpsum 50 0 Feb 13, 2:07pm
           I agree on this DM Michelle Johnston 274 0 Feb 11, 7:12pm
       Collapse Interesting idea Michelle Johnston 314 2 Feb 11, 6:06pm
           Collapse Well... Ereinion Nénharma 265 1 Feb 11, 7:18pm
               This follows a pattern Otaku-sempai 213 0 Feb 11, 9:47pm
       Morgoth's ring Kagemusha 231 0 Feb 11, 9:33pm

  Moved: "The Lack of an Elitist Attitude" Bombadil - - Feb 11, 1:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)

  Collapse One question comes me at mind Konrad S 474 3 Feb 11, 6:10am Jump to last post in thread (by Konrad S)
       Silvan // Ilmatar 198 0 Feb 11, 6:18am
       Silvan Elf Otaku-sempai 133 0 Feb 11, 2:50pm
       Ok thanks Konrad S 135 0 Feb 11, 3:01pm
First page Previous page 1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 962 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.