Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 6 of 962 (346079 posts in 14427 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 962 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Why Thorin let Azog stab him.... NateGate 962 5 Feb 14, 9:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bernhardina)
       Collapse The mithril shirt... Ilmatar 534 3 Feb 14, 9:23pm
           Collapse I think it would have... NateGate 472 2 Feb 14, 9:38pm
               Collapse happy to be of assistance :D Ilmatar 434 1 Feb 14, 9:49pm
                 It sorta Fits..BUT "a Little Tight across the Chest"// Bombadil 372 0 Feb 14, 10:26pm
       This made me LOL xD // Bernhardina 371 0 Feb 14, 11:28pm

  Collapse BOTFA EE Breakdown (updated) grimbeorn15 2582 50 Feb 14, 6:13pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Why Azog? arithmancer 1092 3 Feb 14, 6:26pm
           I agree... lionoferebor 981 0 Feb 14, 7:07pm
           Trailer grimbeorn15 925 0 Feb 14, 8:40pm
           Ah, makes sense. Thanks!// arithmancer 523 0 Feb 15, 2:36pm
       Collapse Very intriguing list! Brethil 1051 4 Feb 14, 6:29pm
           Collapse I daren't even hope for 12..... dormouse 982 1 Feb 14, 7:21pm
             We need a 'Bring on Item 12' Wave...// Brethil 907 0 Feb 14, 7:38pm
           Collapse Yes, in part as well as from interviews with cast, PJ and Boyens. grimbeorn15 891 1 Feb 14, 9:23pm
               Thank you for that info on the staff! Brethil 819 0 Feb 14, 9:32pm
       Collapse I think there will be more Saruman Legolas_Shoehorn 1005 3 Feb 14, 7:31pm
           seriously ? NoelGallagher 965 0 Feb 14, 7:54pm
           Good point. grimbeorn15 798 0 Feb 14, 11:26pm
           I really don't want to see the Palantir. Elizabeth 763 0 Feb 15, 12:19am
       Collapse I would add in to #2... Eleniel 858 2 Feb 14, 11:06pm
           Wow. grimbeorn15 780 0 Feb 14, 11:32pm
           I'd love to see the thrush in this sequence, too... AshNazg 251 0 Feb 17, 1:46pm
       This list is great... lionoferebor 775 0 Feb 15, 12:11am
       Collapse Anything more with Thranduil? Glorfindela 789 4 Feb 15, 12:47am
           Collapse Funeral and/or coronation arithmancer 794 3 Feb 15, 12:51am
               Collapse I truly hope so Glorfindela 751 2 Feb 15, 1:01am
                   Collapse Me too dormouse 536 1 Feb 15, 2:51pm
                       Not sure grimbeorn15 305 0 Feb 16, 11:41pm
       Collapse Changes to the opening should be interesting to see... moreorless 758 1 Feb 15, 3:20am
           Smaug circling in the moonlight b4 attack enjoying the terror would be Smaugee squiggle 706 0 Feb 15, 4:24am
       Don't forget the "Bofur Troll"! DeadRabbits 665 0 Feb 15, 11:39am
       Collapse I fear CathrineB 640 1 Feb 15, 1:47pm
           Not just for the gold either... moreorless 536 0 Feb 15, 5:50pm
       This could be the EE... Arannir 484 0 Feb 16, 10:30am
       Collapse Counting Room TheSexyBeard 335 1 Feb 16, 11:24pm
           Would be great. grimbeorn15 306 0 Feb 16, 11:43pm
       Collapse Some of this stuff may be in the Chronicles books, but ... Defiant 346 18 Feb 17, 2:55am
           Collapse Actually... grimbeorn15 315 17 Feb 17, 3:07am
               The first one... Pandallo 305 0 Feb 17, 3:14am
               Collapse You could be setting yourself up for disappointment. Defiant 311 15 Feb 17, 3:27am
                   Collapse Better to be "defiantly" pessimistic and then pleasantly surprised Voronwë_the_Faithful 257 7 Feb 17, 2:16pm
                       Collapse Or try to curl up in your sand dune (or teapot) and pretend it isn't happening..... dormouse 238 6 Feb 17, 3:12pm
                           Collapse For the last two EEs I spoiled myself silly... AshNazg 246 1 Feb 17, 3:27pm
                               Best way if you can manage it, I think dormouse 230 0 Feb 17, 3:32pm
                           Collapse RotK is a good example Voronwë_the_Faithful 245 3 Feb 17, 3:42pm
                               Collapse I just focus on the achingly beautiful.... dormouse 231 2 Feb 17, 4:39pm
                                   Collapse I agree, of course Voronwë_the_Faithful 212 1 Feb 17, 4:42pm
                                       So true..... // dormouse 205 0 Feb 17, 5:00pm
                   Collapse Yes I know, but grimbeorn15 172 6 Feb 18, 2:42am
                       I think perhaps we differ on the definition of 'confirmed' ;) Defiant 173 0 Feb 18, 2:56am
                       Collapse Planned, yes. But shot? Otaku-sempai 139 4 Feb 18, 3:01pm
                           Collapse Why are you certain Beorn carrying Thorin was not shot? KingTurgon 109 3 Feb 19, 2:26am
                               Collapse Reasons... Otaku-sempai 94 2 Feb 19, 12:59pm
                                   Collapse For point 2, perhaps they pulled a DOS on us KingTurgon 74 1 Feb 20, 12:25am
                                       It still seems very unlikely... Otaku-sempai 74 0 Feb 20, 1:57am
       I'm sure that we won't see all of that. Otaku-sempai 258 0 Feb 17, 3:36pm

Collapse Anyone want to write about The MASTER of Laketown? Bombadil 400 6 Feb 14, 10:26am Jump to last post in thread (by ecthelionsbeard)
       Collapse I love the Master Bofur's Hat 156 3 Feb 14, 6:09pm
           Collapse Isn't it Funny? that FANS FOCUS Bombadil 133 2 Feb 14, 7:06pm
               Collapse WHAT Irony iZZ it?... to HAVE Smaug Land on... Bombadil 116 1 Feb 14, 7:21pm
                   When anyone iZZZ fighting a Foe? Bombadil 99 0 Feb 14, 10:14pm
       I Find the Master & Alfred good value and also alot of humor there squiggle 128 0 Feb 15, 1:24am
       His strawberry combover... ecthelionsbeard 51 0 Feb 18, 3:37am

  Collapse Hobbit Trilogy BluRay Artwork: 2D + (for the first time) 3D! TheHutt 1140 15 Feb 14, 10:21am Jump to last post in thread (by TheHutt)
       Very nice Glorfindela 448 0 Feb 14, 12:03pm
       Also the DVD artwork: TheHutt 517 0 Feb 14, 1:22pm
       Collapse Nice... Dipling 411 3 Feb 14, 3:23pm
           Collapse The 2D cover is actually quite clever symbolism... AshNazg 242 2 Feb 15, 6:05pm
               Collapse AshN...That was Bomby's First THOUGHT to0...// Bombadil 197 1 Feb 15, 6:32pm
                   Here's all the Blu-ray covers... AshNazg 243 0 Feb 15, 8:04pm
       Collapse that is so awesome Barrow-Wight 333 3 Feb 14, 8:41pm
           Collapse That 2D cover is what we're getting in the US. tsmith675 342 2 Feb 14, 9:03pm
               yeah same here Barrow-Wight 309 0 Feb 14, 9:28pm
               Well... TheHutt 71 0 Feb 17, 11:35pm
       Collapse Is anyone else mad that digital download comes out WAY earlier than Bluray? tsmith675 352 3 Feb 14, 9:06pm
         I'm fed up w. the early digital download "punsihment" scam Avandel 245 0 Feb 15, 5:09pm
           Not alone... Imladris18 139 0 Feb 16, 2:51pm
           I don't like it either, but Kirly 109 0 Feb 17, 2:08am
       The left one... Arannir 169 0 Feb 16, 10:32am

  Collapse Vote for The Hobbit at the TSR Movie Awards BlackFox 210 8 Feb 14, 10:17am Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       DONE// Bombadil 69 0 Feb 14, 10:49am
       Collapse I would vote Glorfindela 80 2 Feb 14, 12:02pm
           Collapse You can skip that step. // BlackFox 58 1 Feb 14, 1:24pm
             OK, done now Glorfindela 70 0 Feb 14, 3:24pm
       Collapse Okay where u vote, i dont find it Konrad S 64 1 Feb 14, 1:20pm
           Direct link BlackFox 63 0 Feb 14, 1:25pm
       Done, had to leave near all blank! Konrad S 62 0 Feb 14, 1:50pm
       The results are in! BlackFox 17 0 Feb 22, 5:35pm

  Moved: Hobbit Cast Happy Valentines’ Day image lard LOTS-OF-LUV (fun) thread! Avandel - - Feb 14, 2:53am Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)

  Collapse DOS Chapter of the Week: The Black Arrow Kim 296 11 Feb 14, 1:03am Jump to last post in thread (by Kim)
     Collapse KIM! WOW your LAST Line in Your POST? Bombadil 141 1 Feb 14, 1:13am
           Hey Bomby! Kim 130 0 Feb 14, 1:20am
       Collapse Stopping in for a bit... Brethil 135 6 Feb 14, 5:00am
           Collapse Thanks for stopping by! Kim 113 5 Feb 14, 7:42am
               Collapse Answers to just the First question? Bombadil 111 4 Feb 14, 8:17am
                   Collapse You bring up a good point Kim 108 3 Feb 14, 8:26am
                       Here is something else? Bombadil 114 0 Feb 14, 9:11am
                       Collapse This has always baffled me... lionoferebor 84 1 Feb 14, 7:24pm
                           That is an interesting point Kim 82 0 Feb 14, 10:15pm
       Collapse Who knew? Riven Delve 86 1 Feb 14, 7:06pm
           Thanks for your thoughts RD! Kim 74 0 Feb 14, 7:24pm

  Collapse Might be the last weekend near me (nw Chicago area) Eruonen 149 2 Feb 13, 11:34pm Jump to last post in thread (by Riven Delve)
       Its playing in the big AMC in NYC Brethil 44 0 Feb 14, 7:49pm
       It's reached our second-run theater now Riven Delve 57 0 Feb 14, 8:08pm

  Moved: Hobbit 3 Spoof! Kacey and Teresa - - Feb 13, 5:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kacey and Teresa)

  Collapse Thread Locked In Re to Azog lionoferebor 952 201 Feb 13, 5:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by entmaiden)
       Collapse Thread Locked Well... Otaku-sempai 488 184 Feb 13, 5:57pm
           Collapse Thread Locked That doesnt explain why pettytyrant101 406 180 Feb 13, 7:39pm
               Collapse Thread Locked Opportunity Otaku-sempai 390 179 Feb 13, 7:45pm
                   Collapse Thread Locked We are not given enough information pettytyrant101 383 178 Feb 13, 7:49pm
                       Collapse Thread Locked Azog and Thrain Otaku-sempai 365 6 Feb 13, 7:58pm
                           Collapse Thread Locked Yes, he would have, pettytyrant101 355 5 Feb 13, 8:07pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked 140 years Otaku-sempai 346 4 Feb 13, 8:27pm
                                   Collapse Thread Locked None of which information pettytyrant101 343 3 Feb 13, 8:30pm
                                       Collapse Thread Locked The dates are confirmed. Otaku-sempai 339 2 Feb 13, 8:34pm
                                           Collapse Thread Locked But we know nothing pettytyrant101 327 1 Feb 13, 8:40pm
                                               Thread Locked Yeah. Otaku-sempai 322 0 Feb 13, 8:46pm
                       Collapse Thread Locked I feel like I'm missing something Spriggan 306 170 Feb 13, 9:55pm
                           Collapse Thread Locked How does Azog know pettytyrant101 282 169 Feb 13, 10:35pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked Azog-movieverse arithmancer 275 3 Feb 13, 10:52pm
                                   Collapse Thread Locked Date of the Battle of Moria Otaku-sempai 129 2 Feb 14, 12:55pm
                                       Collapse Thread Locked Thanks! arithmancer 115 1 Feb 14, 2:36pm
                                           Thread Locked FotR-EE Otaku-sempai 143 0 Feb 14, 7:25pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked I always worry when I get a very long answer to a short question! Spriggan 266 164 Feb 13, 10:57pm
                                   Collapse Thread Locked I dont think Azog would sit there pettytyrant101 258 163 Feb 13, 11:16pm
                                       Collapse Thread Locked I don't see why we need to assume he sat there. Spriggan 246 162 Feb 13, 11:28pm
                                           Collapse Thread Locked I think pettytyrant101 240 161 Feb 13, 11:52pm
                                               Collapse Thread Locked Why? Spriggan 205 160 Feb 14, 12:26am
                                                   Collapse Thread Locked One would presume pettytyrant101 199 159 Feb 14, 12:36am
                                                       Collapse Thread Locked I would have assumed that was Sauron. Spriggan 193 158 Feb 14, 12:46am
                                                           Collapse Thread Locked I dont see Saurons motivation. pettytyrant101 186 157 Feb 14, 1:16am
                                                               Collapse Thread Locked The first is a question for Tolkien. Spriggan 186 151 Feb 14, 1:29am
                                                                   Collapse Thread Locked Mmmmm pettytyrant101 181 150 Feb 14, 1:47am
                                                                       Collapse Thread Locked Two quotes for you. Spriggan 163 149 Feb 14, 6:30am
                                                                           Collapse Thread Locked The trouble pettytyrant101 143 148 Feb 14, 12:10pm
                                                                               Collapse Thread Locked Your point was motivation. Spriggan 136 147 Feb 14, 12:50pm
  Collapse Thread Locked I would argue they do show messengers pettytyrant101 103 146 Feb 14, 4:12pm
       Collapse Thread Locked I don't see any messages going back Spriggan 90 103 Feb 14, 4:23pm
           Collapse Thread Locked That orcs have spies is establishe din the films pettytyrant101 235 102 Feb 14, 4:30pm
               Collapse Thread Locked But the book as adapted has changes implied Brethil 227 1 Feb 14, 4:38pm
                   Thread Locked Tolkien already took this into consideration pettytyrant101 221 0 Feb 14, 4:44pm
               Collapse Thread Locked Of course he could. Spriggan 204 99 Feb 14, 5:06pm
                   Collapse Thread Locked Sorry Spriggan somehow missed this one pettytyrant101 150 98 Feb 14, 6:52pm
                       Collapse Thread Locked None of which is in the films. Spriggan 138 97 Feb 14, 7:35pm
                           Collapse Thread Locked We end up at the same place becuase pettytyrant101 126 96 Feb 14, 7:56pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked What maps show villages? Spriggan 124 95 Feb 14, 8:09pm
                                   Collapse Thread Locked I am sure they will. pettytyrant101 110 94 Feb 14, 8:29pm
                                       Collapse Thread Locked Really? If you have a look back through your posts there is a significant list. Spriggan 102 93 Feb 14, 8:53pm
                                           Collapse Thread Locked The problem here pettytyrant101 98 92 Feb 14, 9:07pm
                                               Collapse Thread Locked No, the problem here. Spriggan 95 91 Feb 14, 9:10pm
                                                   Collapse Thread Locked Perhaps then you could articulate clearly and simply pettytyrant101 91 90 Feb 14, 9:19pm
                                                       Collapse Thread Locked The same thing Gandalf was doing for a thousand years. Spriggan 82 89 Feb 14, 9:31pm
                                                           Collapse Thread Locked So pettytyrant101 77 88 Feb 14, 9:40pm
                                                               Collapse Thread Locked No, no. Spriggan 70 71 Feb 14, 9:46pm
                                                                   Collapse Thread Locked I dont think even film Azog is that stupid pettytyrant101 66 70 Feb 14, 9:56pm
                                                                       Collapse Thread Locked Thorin could have been anywhere! Spriggan 118 69 Feb 14, 10:02pm
                                                                           Collapse Thread Locked I dont see why for 150 years pettytyrant101 108 67 Feb 14, 10:21pm
                                                                               Collapse Thread Locked No. Spriggan 104 66 Feb 14, 10:31pm
  Collapse Thread Locked We are shown Thorin in Bree, pettytyrant101 89 65 Feb 14, 10:45pm
       Collapse Thread Locked It's no stretch but it's no stretch the other way. Spriggan 73 64 Feb 14, 10:59pm
           Collapse Thread Locked I am basing it on Azog pettytyrant101 68 63 Feb 14, 11:07pm
               Collapse Thread Locked Is Azog psychic? Spriggan 63 61 Feb 14, 11:12pm
                   Collapse Thread Locked Reasonable Assumption Otaku-sempai 58 7 Feb 14, 11:19pm
                       Collapse Thread Locked But there is no evidence that Azog knows that. Spriggan 54 6 Feb 14, 11:20pm
                           Collapse Thread Locked No, but... Otaku-sempai 140 5 Feb 14, 11:25pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked What mechanisms would mean Spriggan 139 2 Feb 14, 11:29pm
                                   Collapse Thread Locked I did not say that. Otaku-sempai 117 1 Feb 15, 12:03am
                                       Thread Locked Apologies but that was the meat of the discussion. Spriggan 112 0 Feb 15, 12:09am
                               Collapse Thread Locked But who put out the bounty? pettytyrant101 137 1 Feb 14, 11:31pm
                                   Thread Locked Yes. Azog Otaku-sempai 116 0 Feb 15, 12:09am
                   Collapse Thread Locked A fairer question would be pettytyrant101 142 52 Feb 14, 11:25pm
                       Collapse Thread Locked Nope. Spriggan 138 51 Feb 14, 11:28pm
                           Collapse Thread Locked No I am pettytyrant101 133 50 Feb 14, 11:40pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked And how does Azog know about Thorin's people? Spriggan 116 48 Feb 15, 12:06am
                                   Collapse Thread Locked Dwarves in the Blue Mountains. Otaku-sempai 114 47 Feb 15, 12:20am
                                       Collapse Thread Locked In the film continuity, however, Spriggan 107 46 Feb 15, 12:31am
                                           Collapse Thread Locked I dont really see that this should be an issue pettytyrant101 102 15 Feb 15, 12:59am
                                               Collapse Thread Locked Thorin and the refugees Spriggan 93 14 Feb 15, 1:11am
                                                   Collapse Thread Locked They moved pettytyrant101 90 13 Feb 15, 1:14am
                                                       Collapse Thread Locked Not specified in the films. Spriggan 80 12 Feb 15, 1:21am
                                                           Collapse Thread Locked We are shown the refugees pettytyrant101 76 11 Feb 15, 1:25am
                                                               Collapse Thread Locked Yes the law of conservation of mass says that they cannot have disappeared. Spriggan 70 10 Feb 15, 1:33am
                                                                   Collapse Thread Locked Or the evidence of the films is that pettytyrant101 64 9 Feb 15, 1:38am
                                                                       Collapse Thread Locked I'd stick with my original quote. Spriggan 149 8 Feb 15, 1:44am
                                                                           Collapse Thread Locked Well if believing so pettytyrant101 146 7 Feb 15, 2:01am
                                                                               Collapse Thread Locked I'm a perceptive sort. Spriggan 145 6 Feb 15, 2:05am
  Collapse Thread Locked Well thats a relief pettytyrant101 143 5 Feb 15, 2:10am
       Collapse Thread Locked Sounds like a lot of effort on my part. Spriggan 138 4 Feb 15, 2:14am
           Collapse Thread Locked Well I can try the first part.... pettytyrant101 135 3 Feb 15, 2:17am
               Collapse Thread Locked Fear not. Spriggan 133 2 Feb 15, 2:18am
                   Collapse Thread Locked I dont doubt it! pettytyrant101 128 1 Feb 15, 2:21am
                       Thread Locked Nighty night Spriggan 123 0 Feb 15, 2:23am
                                           Collapse Thread Locked Fair enough. Otaku-sempai 114 29 Feb 15, 4:54am
                                               Collapse Thread Locked I don't even think we know that, do we? Spriggan 94 28 Feb 15, 9:53am
                                                   Collapse Thread Locked Why would the refugees go to Moria- pettytyrant101 93 16 Feb 15, 9:58am
                                                       Collapse Thread Locked I don't think I suggested that they took women and children to battle Spriggan 87 14 Feb 15, 10:15am
                                                           Collapse Thread Locked So where did all the refugees go then? pettytyrant101 85 13 Feb 15, 10:23am
                                                               Collapse Thread Locked Oh. I'm saying we don't know for certain. Spriggan 75 11 Feb 15, 10:43am
                                                                   Collapse Thread Locked It might not stop to give specifics but common sense pettytyrant101 73 10 Feb 15, 10:52am
                                                                       Collapse Thread Locked Again these things aren't in the films. Spriggan 73 9 Feb 15, 11:00am
                                                                           Collapse Thread Locked But in the film pettytyrant101 72 8 Feb 15, 11:10am
                                                                               Collapse Thread Locked Just as we are in the book. Spriggan 60 7 Feb 15, 11:55am
  Collapse Thread Locked You are forgetting film Dwalins words again pettytyrant101 60 6 Feb 15, 12:13pm
       Collapse Thread Locked Not at all. Spriggan 50 5 Feb 15, 12:25pm
           Collapse Thread Locked It keep raising as an issue pettytyrant101 49 4 Feb 15, 12:32pm
               Collapse Thread Locked Why not just as in the book? Spriggan 47 3 Feb 15, 12:37pm
                   Collapse Thread Locked Becuase I dont think pettytyrant101 197 2 Feb 15, 12:49pm
                       Thread Locked I don't see how they preclude the option in the book. Spriggan 197 0 Feb 15, 1:02pm
                       Thread Locked Durin's Folk to the Blue Mountains. Otaku-sempai 159 0 Feb 15, 3:39pm
                                                               Thread Locked We see.. arithmancer 166 0 Feb 15, 3:30pm
                                                       Thread Locked I just want to point out... Otaku-sempai 173 0 Feb 15, 3:17pm
                                                   Collapse Thread Locked We do have to make some assumptions Otaku-sempai 170 10 Feb 15, 3:11pm
                                                       Collapse Thread Locked Certainly they are assumptions. Spriggan 166 9 Feb 15, 3:22pm
                                                           Collapse Thread Locked If we are talking Tolkien... Otaku-sempai 161 8 Feb 15, 3:46pm
                                                               Collapse Thread Locked That's my point. Spriggan 148 6 Feb 15, 4:04pm
                                                                   Collapse Thread Locked Dunland Otaku-sempai 148 5 Feb 15, 4:06pm
                                                                       Collapse Thread Locked Yep - Thror was dwelling there Spriggan 121 4 Feb 15, 4:43pm
                                                                           Collapse Thread Locked Okay, that makes sense. Otaku-sempai 120 3 Feb 15, 5:11pm
                                                                               Thread Locked Thror, not Thor. Otaku-sempai 111 0 Feb 15, 5:30pm
                                                                               Collapse Thread Locked Not so far (which is good!) Spriggan 79 1 Feb 15, 8:47pm
  Thread Locked The Blue Mountains after Thror Otaku-sempai 72 0 Feb 15, 8:55pm
                                                               Thread Locked My film chronology for the Dwarves of Erebor Otaku-sempai 146 0 Feb 15, 4:15pm
                               Thread Locked food for thought... Elthir 189 0 Feb 15, 2:08pm
               Thread Locked Did Azog have spies in Bree? Otaku-sempai 63 0 Feb 14, 11:14pm
                                                                           Thread Locked Thorin in the Ered Luin Otaku-sempai 99 0 Feb 14, 10:38pm
                                                               Collapse Thread Locked Azog and Thorin Otaku-sempai 102 15 Feb 14, 10:34pm
                                                                   Collapse Thread Locked Do you mean in the films? Spriggan 101 14 Feb 14, 10:37pm
                                                                       Collapse Thread Locked Thorin's Halls Otaku-sempai 93 12 Feb 14, 10:41pm
                                                                           Collapse Thread Locked That's straight from the film. Spriggan 92 9 Feb 14, 10:45pm
                                                                               Collapse Thread Locked You assume too much. Otaku-sempai 88 8 Feb 14, 10:47pm
  Collapse Thread Locked It doesn't say that it was for the full time. Spriggan 85 7 Feb 14, 10:52pm
       Collapse Thread Locked We may have to agree to disagree on this point. Otaku-sempai 76 4 Feb 14, 10:56pm
           Collapse Thread Locked Other than Balin's line. Spriggan 70 3 Feb 14, 11:00pm
               Collapse Thread Locked Gandalf Otaku-sempai 67 2 Feb 14, 11:07pm
                   Collapse Thread Locked I don't disagree with that. Spriggan 55 1 Feb 14, 11:19pm
                       Thread Locked Thorin's Halls Otaku-sempai 54 0 Feb 14, 11:21pm
       Collapse Thread Locked Balin says... arithmancer 93 1 Feb 15, 1:16am
           Thread Locked That seems a reasonable assumpton to me pettytyrant101 76 0 Feb 15, 1:23am
                                                                           Collapse Thread Locked Thats a good point pettytyrant101 72 1 Feb 14, 11:00pm
                                                                               Thread Locked No contradiction Otaku-sempai 66 0 Feb 14, 11:10pm
                                                                       Thread Locked The eaxct quote, from AUJ: Eleniel 139 0 Feb 14, 11:31pm
       Collapse Thread Locked The effect of overlaying story telling jeopardy Michelle Johnston 195 41 Feb 14, 5:43pm
           Collapse Thread Locked Well put Michelle pettytyrant101 170 40 Feb 14, 5:59pm
               Collapse Thread Locked Where does each of us start from with our needs Michelle Johnston 53 24 Feb 14, 11:23pm
                   Collapse Thread Locked I agree in genral with your assessment pettytyrant101 129 23 Feb 14, 11:37pm
                       Collapse Thread Locked CGI violence lacks a moral compass and depth because there is no reality. Michelle Johnston 79 22 Feb 15, 8:57pm
                           Collapse Thread Locked I think you're missing some extraordinarily good storytelling.... dormouse 203 18 Feb 15, 11:38pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked I dont just object pettytyrant101 204 14 Feb 15, 11:52pm
                                   Collapse Thread Locked Azog is called the Defiler... arithmancer 186 13 Feb 16, 1:54am
                                       Collapse Thread Locked I didnt say it wasnt in the spirit of Tolkien pettytyrant101 188 12 Feb 16, 6:01am
                                           Collapse Thread Locked It's not... arithmancer 139 4 Feb 16, 2:13pm
                                               Collapse Thread Locked As a fan of Jacksons early work pettytyrant101 127 3 Feb 16, 3:25pm
                                                   Collapse Thread Locked Wiring... arithmancer 102 2 Feb 16, 5:17pm
                                                       Collapse Thread Locked I also feel pettytyrant101 96 1 Feb 16, 6:10pm
                                                           Thread Locked I just reread a post I wrote a few years back Magpie 101 0 Feb 16, 6:22pm
                                           Collapse Thread Locked The Defiler Otaku-sempai 131 6 Feb 16, 2:42pm
                                               Thread Locked I am not saying that was what most offended pettytyrant101 139 0 Feb 16, 3:05pm
                                               Collapse Thread Locked Yes. arithmancer 110 4 Feb 16, 4:37pm
                                                   Collapse Thread Locked I would think pettytyrant101 107 3 Feb 16, 4:46pm
                                                       Collapse Thread Locked IN the film... arithmancer 108 2 Feb 16, 5:20pm
                                                           Thread Locked My apologies pettytyrant101 100 0 Feb 16, 6:12pm
                                                           Thread Locked Not completely Voronwë_the_Faithful 85 0 Feb 16, 7:58pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked Thats a bit selective DM Michelle Johnston 69 1 Feb 16, 9:41pm
                                   Thread Locked Selective - how? dormouse 48 0 Feb 16, 11:32pm
                               Thread Locked Clariification of my list Michelle Johnston 65 0 Feb 16, 10:05pm
                           Collapse Thread Locked I can't fully disagree with you, Michelle Otaku-sempai 131 2 Feb 16, 2:50pm
                               Collapse Thread Locked My apologies Michelle Johnston 62 1 Feb 16, 9:51pm
                                   Thread Locked Apology accepted. Otaku-sempai 60 0 Feb 16, 9:55pm
               Collapse Thread Locked For what it's worth, a few thoughts to chew on..... dormouse 122 14 Feb 15, 12:05am
                   Collapse Thread Locked Well if it were me adapting it pettytyrant101 109 13 Feb 15, 12:57am
                       Collapse Thread Locked Four things.... dormouse 115 12 Feb 15, 9:20am
                           Collapse Thread Locked Morning Dormouse! pettytyrant101 107 11 Feb 15, 9:47am
                               Collapse Thread Locked "Do you mean that it is a good morning, or......" dormouse 184 10 Feb 15, 2:43pm
                                   Collapse Thread Locked "What can man do against such reckless hate?" Voronwë_the_Faithful 133 9 Feb 15, 4:44pm
                                       Collapse Thread Locked "The Locked Door stands as an eternal Temptation" dormouse 106 8 Feb 15, 6:47pm
                                           Collapse Thread Locked That's very good! Voronwë_the_Faithful 101 7 Feb 15, 7:01pm
                                               Collapse Thread Locked So true..... dormouse 98 6 Feb 15, 7:14pm
                                                   Collapse Thread Locked Perhaps not Voronwë_the_Faithful 94 5 Feb 15, 7:26pm
                                                       Collapse Thread Locked "Life, what is it but a dream" // dormouse 52 4 Feb 15, 11:10pm
                                                           Collapse Thread Locked "But it wasn't a dream. It was a place. ... Voronwë_the_Faithful 194 3 Feb 16, 12:28am
                                                               Collapse Thread Locked 'He drew a deep breath. "Well, I'm back," he said.' dormouse 161 2 Feb 16, 8:53am
                                                                   Collapse Thread Locked ". If any of your people poke their foul beards in here again, they will fare the same. Go and tell them so!" Voronwë_the_Faithful 117 1 Feb 16, 3:58pm
                                                                       Thread Locked No, just whiskers..... dormouse 49 0 Feb 16, 11:20pm
                                                               Collapse Thread Locked Sauron arithmancer 163 4 Feb 14, 4:06am
                                                                   Collapse Thread Locked In the books pettytyrant101 140 3 Feb 14, 12:13pm
                                                                       Collapse Thread Locked Not sure why you are telling me about the books... arithmancer 123 2 Feb 14, 2:24pm
                                                                           Collapse Thread Locked No offence met pettytyrant101 89 1 Feb 14, 4:24pm
                                                                               Thread Locked None taken! arithmancer 206 0 Feb 14, 5:04pm
           Collapse Thread Locked Never thought of that... lionoferebor 125 2 Feb 14, 1:45pm
               Thread Locked Except the films dont have the other rangers pettytyrant101 97 0 Feb 14, 4:16pm
               Thread Locked I spotted my error. Otaku-sempai 138 0 Feb 14, 7:29pm
       Collapse Thread Locked Answear Konrad S 433 2 Feb 13, 6:03pm
           Collapse Thread Locked I think we see that in AUJ. Spriggan 413 1 Feb 13, 6:33pm
               Thread Locked Well said. I agree. // Brethil 379 0 Feb 13, 6:52pm
       Thread Locked Oh now I might imitate you a bit but I start write my reply before i saw your. Konrad S 414 0 Feb 13, 6:05pm
       Collapse Thread Locked the two questions are connected Voronwë_the_Faithful 370 1 Feb 13, 7:59pm
           Thread Locked Necromancer or not. Otaku-sempai 360 0 Feb 13, 8:01pm
       Collapse Thread Locked You ask why Azog waited until Thorin set out for Erebor..... dormouse 160 8 Feb 14, 11:47am
           Collapse Thread Locked That makes it worse pettytyrant101 152 7 Feb 14, 12:23pm
               Collapse Thread Locked I don't agree dormouse 159 6 Feb 14, 12:32pm
                   Collapse Thread Locked When people are this intent on being critical at all costs Voronwë_the_Faithful 153 4 Feb 14, 1:54pm
                       Collapse Thread Locked Well thats rude! pettytyrant101 120 3 Feb 14, 4:18pm
                           Collapse Thread Locked My apologies Voronwë_the_Faithful 210 2 Feb 14, 5:45pm
                             Collapse Thread Locked Bomby learned MY Lesson a.a.a.While ago Bombadil 150 1 Feb 14, 7:41pm
                                   Thread Locked To be perfectly clear Voronwë_the_Faithful 118 0 Feb 14, 8:54pm
                   Thread Locked If the single dwarf pettytyrant101 115 0 Feb 14, 4:06pm
       Thread Locked And we're locked. entmaiden 63 0 Feb 16, 11:40pm

Collapse Why? bomby LOVES Alfrid... Bombadil 479 20 Feb 13, 5:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by iduna)
       Collapse SHOCKING..ISn't it..? Bombadil 257 4 Feb 13, 6:14pm
           Collapse Worse than Gollum? Otaku-sempai 255 3 Feb 13, 6:17pm
               Collapse Well? where did it come from... Bombadil 250 2 Feb 13, 6:23pm
                   DEEP in the STEEP Bookshelves in the Bombadil 231 0 Feb 13, 6:33pm
                   I'm guessing... Otaku-sempai 214 0 Feb 13, 7:41pm
       Collapse Hmmm elostirion74 243 8 Feb 13, 6:36pm
           Well? Both PJ & PB Bombadil 236 0 Feb 13, 6:48pm
           Collapse I do think having The Master and Alfrid showing their corruption was essential and Eruonen 220 6 Feb 13, 7:53pm
               Collapse I didn´t mind the humor... elostirion74 152 5 Feb 13, 11:55pm
                   Collapse I would have loved to see The Master continue rather than his untimely for effect death. Eruonen 151 4 Feb 14, 12:12am
                       Collapse This Kinda Plot Line was Coming from... Bombadil 141 3 Feb 14, 1:04am
                           Collapse Bomby, sometimes you lose me. Eruonen 130 2 Feb 14, 3:08am
                               Collapse Sorry for that..but Bomby was quite Curious how PJ Bombadil 111 1 Feb 14, 8:46am
                                   He's a foil iduna 16 0 Feb 23, 3:57pm
       Doubt it. DanielLB 211 0 Feb 13, 8:13pm
       Collapse Have to admire how consistently EomundDaughter 188 1 Feb 13, 9:55pm
           Many people have Alluded to Laketown Bombadil 171 0 Feb 13, 10:49pm
       Collapse I don't think I'll ever love him..... dormouse 108 1 Feb 14, 11:38am
           I can't say I'll ever love him either... brotherbeck 76 0 Feb 15, 3:29am
       He was OK in DOS, but completely over the top in BOTFA Nolane 37 0 Feb 16, 7:40pm

  Collapse Who is this? *Credits Scene* Curunir The White 970 10 Feb 13, 3:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by grammaboodawg)
       Hm... Thrain II 458 0 Feb 13, 3:49pm
       Radagast? // BlackFox 369 0 Feb 13, 4:02pm
       The spirit of Tolkien himself, as a wizard? Ruxendil_Thoorg 205 0 Feb 14, 2:06am
       Collapse I see a blurry tree-like thing? Where's the wizard-like figure?// Nira 192 3 Feb 14, 2:57am
           Collapse look between the tree trunk and JRR Tolkien's name, under the branches // Ruxendil_Thoorg 188 2 Feb 14, 4:04am
               Collapse ooooh! Thank you! Nira 177 1 Feb 14, 4:38am
                   quite welcome! Ruxendil_Thoorg 181 0 Feb 14, 5:11am
       So that's PJ's cameo! / DanielLB 152 0 Feb 14, 8:33am
       I think it's Radagast dormouse 137 0 Feb 14, 11:35am
       I think it's grammaboodawg 147 0 Feb 14, 3:19pm

  Collapse Would Thrain have gotten the "dragon-sickness"? Kilidoescartwheels 318 16 Feb 13, 2:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       The films did seem to hint at a different personality moreorless 161 0 Feb 13, 3:16pm
       Collapse Apparently he did fall under dragon-sickness... AshNazg 157 13 Feb 13, 3:31pm
           Collapse Perhaps. Otaku-sempai 139 4 Feb 13, 3:43pm
               Collapse Thror gave Thrain the ring before the battle AshNazg 121 3 Feb 13, 4:32pm
                   Collapse Yes. I know. Otaku-sempai 108 2 Feb 13, 4:45pm
                       Collapse Oh, sorry. You said "This legendarium"... AshNazg 106 1 Feb 13, 4:58pm
                           That's fine. Otaku-sempai 94 0 Feb 13, 5:09pm
           Collapse Hmm...well in the book, yes, Thrain did suffer from a gold-sickness Eleniel 128 4 Feb 13, 3:48pm
               Collapse That line made it seem like the sickness was congenital. RosieLass 115 3 Feb 13, 4:19pm
                   Collapse But the gold hadn't been brooded over by a dragon... AshNazg 111 2 Feb 13, 4:37pm
                       More of a comparison? Otaku-sempai 102 0 Feb 13, 4:49pm
                       Well, Tolkien says that dwarves are susceptible to gold fever. RosieLass 107 0 Feb 13, 4:53pm
           Collapse I've been thinking about that line Kilidoescartwheels 96 2 Feb 13, 5:47pm
               Collapse Thorin Otaku-sempai 89 1 Feb 13, 6:10pm
                   Why the other houses care about the Arkenstone Kilidoescartwheels 85 0 Feb 13, 8:03pm
       No.. Thrain II 132 0 Feb 13, 3:41pm

  Collapse If they decide to do another LOTR adaptation in 20 years Martin Freeman would still be perfect to play Bilbo LoremIpsum 379 5 Feb 13, 2:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by Finrod)
     Totally agree! Thrain II 170 0 Feb 13, 3:43pm
       And whoever plays young Bilbo would be great in The Hobbit remake AshNazg 175 0 Feb 13, 4:39pm
       personally Me85 142 0 Feb 13, 6:54pm
       Yes, he would dormouse 80 0 Feb 14, 11:32am
       He’s ready now not later: he shouldn’t age a day! Finrod 49 0 Feb 15, 3:42am

  Collapse Do you think Richard Armitage should have been Aragorn? Thorins_apprentice 1127 56 Feb 13, 9:58am Jump to last post in thread (by RosieLass)
       Collapse Hypothetically Arannir 626 11 Feb 13, 10:07am
           Collapse simply no NoelGallagher 599 8 Feb 13, 10:24am
               Collapse Nah. Arannir 519 7 Feb 13, 12:15pm
                   Collapse I can't imagine that Kilidoescartwheels 446 5 Feb 13, 2:37pm
                       Collapse Agree that RA could easily play Aragorn Glorfindela 390 4 Feb 13, 5:01pm
                           Collapse Tolkien characters burrahobbit 328 3 Feb 13, 8:10pm
                               Collapse Yes Glorfindela 270 2 Feb 13, 11:29pm
                                   Collapse Have you read any of Tom Shippey's books about Tolkien's work? RosieLass 265 1 Feb 14, 12:06am
                                       Thanks very much for letting me know about this Glorfindela 177 0 Feb 14, 11:55am
                   He does at that marillaraina 332 0 Feb 13, 6:48pm
           Collapse Yes, I think he would have been too young for the part at the time. Riven Delve 492 1 Feb 13, 12:04pm
               That was my first reaction shadowdog 360 0 Feb 13, 5:01pm
       Collapse He could easily have been Glorfindela 563 22 Feb 13, 10:36am
           Collapse no balbo biggins 399 18 Feb 13, 4:32pm
               Collapse I've 'read the books' Magpie 334 17 Feb 13, 8:18pm
                   Collapse very interesting balbo biggins 245 16 Feb 14, 1:13am
                       Collapse Perhaps you don't get this place Magpie 245 13 Feb 14, 1:29am
                           I would add RA was an exceptional part Brethil 241 0 Feb 14, 1:40am
                           Collapse i do balbo biggins 235 11 Feb 14, 1:58am
                               Collapse Aha! Starling 231 10 Feb 14, 2:18am
                                   Collapse What other possible explanation is there Riven Delve 233 9 Feb 14, 3:11am
                                       So *that's* why... Eowyn of Penns Woods 218 0 Feb 14, 3:44am
                                       Collapse I don't think I have any hormones left Magpie 226 2 Feb 14, 3:57am
                                           Collapse appeal balbo biggins 187 1 Feb 14, 12:48pm
                                               its not a fact the unless you can back it up with some data Magpie 173 0 Feb 14, 2:38pm
                                       Collapse Oh dear. Is that why Ladies can't be film critics? // Brethil 154 4 Feb 14, 5:17pm
                                           Collapse Mmm.... the little ladies can't be relied on to think clearly.... dormouse 149 1 Feb 14, 5:58pm
                                             An unfathomable oddity, Dormouse. // Brethil 122 0 Feb 14, 6:20pm
                                           Collapse You're far too busy for that. DanielLB 141 1 Feb 14, 6:04pm
                                             There we have some good, solid Viking sensibilities. // Brethil 121 0 Feb 14, 6:19pm
                       The Crucible Dame Ioreth 125 0 Feb 14, 7:14pm
                       Just going to add re VM Avandel 116 0 Feb 15, 5:35pm
           Collapse Was about to say. Macfeast 396 1 Feb 13, 4:42pm
             Yes – absolutely agree Glorfindela 372 0 Feb 13, 4:53pm
           poor Viggo :) marillaraina 375 0 Feb 13, 5:25pm
       Rather different characters I would say... moreorless 508 0 Feb 13, 11:24am
       no Gianna 458 0 Feb 13, 1:19pm
       I though about it as well LoremIpsum 446 0 Feb 13, 1:58pm
       Collapse I wish Aragorn had been written more like Thorin. RosieLass 412 2 Feb 13, 4:14pm
           Collapse But Viggo made a great Strider, sauget.diblosio 54 1 Feb 18, 9:21pm
               That's what I said. RosieLass 40 0 Feb 19, 3:32am
       Armitage could have been Aragorn - Hanzkaz 396 0 Feb 13, 4:25pm
       He could be if they filmed it today Elessar 371 0 Feb 13, 5:21pm
       Totally different wigs.... EomundDaughter 284 0 Feb 13, 9:58pm
       Yes, I think he would have made a great Aragorn if time was not a consideration Kirly 212 0 Feb 14, 3:24am
       No, absolutely not.// Aragorn the Elfstone 207 0 Feb 14, 4:00am
       Collapse as of now he could have been ElendilTheShort 187 1 Feb 14, 10:56am
           In 1999 Richard Armitage Elanor of Rohan 184 0 Feb 14, 2:30pm
       Collapse He'd make a fantastic Aragorn now.... dormouse 199 2 Feb 14, 11:29am
           Agree Avandel 144 0 Feb 15, 12:28am
         Careful, dormouse Glorfindela 149 0 Feb 15, 12:55am
       Nah CathrineB 184 0 Feb 14, 11:38am
       Collapse RA would actually be my first choice to play Eol if the Sil were being made today Elarie 176 1 Feb 14, 2:43pm
           My dream role for RA in the Sil... laurethiel1138 82 0 Feb 17, 6:34pm
       ooooo! *ponders* Fascinating thought! grammaboodawg 170 0 Feb 14, 3:35pm
       Certainly not. // sauget.diblosio 50 0 Feb 18, 9:18pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 962 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.