Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 6 of 913 (328475 posts in 13693 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 913 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse What does Bilbo achieve in the trilogy? Macsen 571 15 Tue, 1:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Roheryn)
       Collapse He gets back, back to where he once belong Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 302 1 Tue, 1:22pm
           The long and winding road goes ever on and on.// L. Ron Halfelven 118 0 Tue, 7:12pm
       Collapse A few missing, I think, just from AUJ and DOS Spriggan 283 4 Tue, 1:54pm
           Most importantly I would add.. moreorless 252 0 Tue, 1:59pm
           Collapse Good point with some of those Spriggan Macsen 229 2 Tue, 2:07pm
               Well, if Bilbo hadn't been there Spriggan 227 0 Tue, 2:14pm
               Just like in the book... DanielLB 200 0 Tue, 2:29pm
       All of the above... plus what he was MEANT to do: mae govannen 223 0 Tue, 2:20pm
       The sparing of gollum Ham_Sammy 198 0 Tue, 2:38pm
       Collapse Everything he achieved in the book... dormouse 210 1 Tue, 2:39pm
           True dubulous 127 0 Tue, 6:32pm
       Collapse His impact on Thorin is huge in BOFA (spoilers) LoremIpsum 131 1 Tue, 7:02pm
           Exactly Ham_Sammy 107 0 Tue, 7:21pm
       He gave the Arkenstone to the Elves and humans Milieuterrien 83 0 Tue, 8:33pm
       Thorin's redemption (arguably, perhaps). Roheryn 43 0 Wed, 12:35am

  Collapse Random thoughts and questions (spoilers) Guert 422 2 Tue, 1:16pm Jump to last post in thread (by DisDwarfWoman)
       Black speech TiberiusOgden 223 0 Tue, 2:16pm
       For me... DisDwarfWoman 139 0 Tue, 5:28pm

  Collapse Dwalin (mild spoilers) emre43 686 6 Tue, 11:42am Jump to last post in thread (by Roheryn)
       Really liked that scene also! adt100 308 0 Tue, 1:22pm
       Yes Macsen 261 0 Tue, 1:54pm
       That was a great scene Ham_Sammy 215 0 Tue, 3:53pm
       Collapse Line Bernhardina 106 1 Tue, 9:48pm
           Yes that is it I think emre43 84 0 Tue, 10:16pm
       Along with that line, Roheryn 68 0 Tue, 11:27pm

  Collapse What does Kili tell Tauriel? Bernhardina 580 2 Tue, 10:52am Jump to last post in thread (by Macsen)
       I read somewhere... Angharad73 404 0 Tue, 11:03am
       I could tell you, but I'd be banned from the forum. Macsen 290 0 Tue, 12:56pm

  Collapse Go back to your books (Spoiler!) CasiBaggins 664 2 Tue, 10:00am Jump to last post in thread (by Macsen)
       OMG you felt that too?! elvish.mafia 357 0 Tue, 10:08am
       Yup Macsen 228 0 Tue, 12:58pm

  Collapse Why we need the extended edition...and why we DON'T. elvish.mafia 1240 43 Tue, 8:38am Jump to last post in thread (by Lindele)
       Collapse So you thought DoS was good without the EE? painjoiker 617 4 Tue, 8:59am
           Collapse Yes it was. elvish.mafia 585 2 Tue, 9:15am
               Too bad for you, I would say; mae govannen 538 0 Tue, 9:51am
               That is so unfortunate Lindele 7 0 2:58am
           Really? DOS EE is very good, but DOS TC still bettered AUJ in both forms // adt100 302 0 Tue, 1:55pm
       Collapse But I don't feel that way - at all dormouse 603 5 Tue, 9:17am
           Collapse That's a great point Dormouse :) elvish.mafia 528 4 Tue, 9:30am
               Yes, I have seen it once.... dormouse 500 0 Tue, 9:47am
               Collapse "An EE is simply a director's cut" QuackingTroll 407 2 Tue, 11:38am
                   Collapse Definitive means 'FINAL'... elvish.mafia 381 1 Tue, 11:58am
                       Again, those "shoulds" are all theoritical, mae govannen 343 0 Tue, 12:36pm
       Collapse What you don't need is returning to theaters many times Milieuterrien 523 1 Tue, 9:42am
           Which is what we are doing right now... elvish.mafia 476 0 Tue, 9:50am
       Collapse Theories do not always apply to reality... mae govannen 507 14 Tue, 9:48am
           Collapse Ummm... elvish.mafia 487 9 Tue, 9:59am
               in this I agree with you, though I liked it aswell Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 438 0 Tue, 10:45am
               Collapse Exactly; PJ had forgotten (oops!) mae govannen 376 7 Tue, 12:20pm
                   Collapse But pettytyrant101 335 6 Tue, 1:05pm
                       Collapse No thanks! Danielos 310 1 Tue, 1:15pm
                           Each to their own pettytyrant101 310 0 Tue, 1:20pm
                       AUJ's length Macsen 311 0 Tue, 1:26pm
                       Collapse I am very disappointed... mae govannen 252 2 Tue, 3:51pm
                           Collapse Well that seems a little rude pettytyrant101 172 1 Tue, 6:31pm
                               Sorry for the unintentional rudeness: mae govannen 34 0 Wed, 8:36am
           Collapse Only two? Hanzkaz 247 3 Tue, 3:33pm
             Collapse Did you read the rest of my post??? mae govannen 230 2 Tue, 4:05pm
                   Collapse I read your post. I was joking - sort of. Hanzkaz 210 1 Tue, 4:33pm
                       Absolutely true, I am very aware of that... mae govannen 46 0 Wed, 5:19am
       Collapse If you haven't even bothered to watch all the EEs lurtz2010 462 3 Tue, 10:44am
           Collapse because I was happy with all the theatrical editions until now... elvish.mafia 443 2 Tue, 10:47am
               But still lurtz2010 429 0 Tue, 11:11am
               I would severely recommend QuackingTroll 407 0 Tue, 11:23am
       Collapse Why BOTFA TE felt incomplete to me... (spoilers) Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 512 2 Tue, 11:22am
           Awesome! elvish.mafia 412 0 Tue, 11:38am
           Kind of agree... adt100 294 0 Tue, 2:04pm
       Collapse The TE stood on its own Macsen 350 1 Tue, 1:01pm
           I agree Ham_Sammy 272 0 Tue, 2:32pm
       Collapse Interesting comments on the TORN homepage.... adt100 216 2 Tue, 5:12pm
           So - Hanzkaz 195 0 Tue, 5:22pm
         What a lovely quote from PJ... mae govannen 38 0 Wed, 8:40am
       A Thought IdrilofGondolin 123 0 Tue, 8:16pm
       What...? Mooseboy018 112 0 Tue, 8:46pm
       The theatrical edition of a film is soemtimes forgotten glor 71 0 Wed, 1:32am

  Collapse Bofur Mooseboy018 684 12 Tue, 6:55am Jump to last post in thread (by sueb1863)
       Collapse Not much I'm afraid Carne 393 1 Tue, 6:59am
           *Goosebumps all over* Wow!... mae govannen 340 0 Tue, 7:47am
       Collapse not a lot Ham_Sammy 321 1 Tue, 7:00am
           Thanks for the replies. Mooseboy018 300 0 Tue, 7:07am
       Collapse He doesn't have much to say... Angharad73 280 7 Tue, 8:07am
         Collapse Yes, nice detail indeed, thank you! // mae govannen 171 6 Tue, 12:42pm
               Collapse Yeah, no room for the dwarves... sarahb1863 189 5 Tue, 12:44pm
                   Collapse lol, kinda true unfortunately.... adt100 163 2 Tue, 1:32pm
                       Absolutely Agree IdrilofGondolin 80 0 Tue, 8:21pm
                       PJ had eight and a half hours sueb1863 42 0 Wed, 1:12am
                   Collapse Please keep your sarcasm in a separate post, mae govannen 138 1 Tue, 3:23pm
                       Well, I'd call it more bitterness than sarcasm... sarahb1863 108 0 Tue, 4:38pm

  Collapse And just for the record Ham_Sammy 577 13 Tue, 6:54am Jump to last post in thread (by Old Toby)
       Collapse So glad to read this... mae govannen 249 1 Tue, 7:39am
           Yeah, I think Bilbo makes a very good account for himself. adt100 111 0 Tue, 1:33pm
       I just saw it tonight for the first time Old Toby 234 0 Tue, 8:51am
       Collapse Agreed! dormouse 195 6 Tue, 9:21am
           Collapse Yes, that silence Dame Ioreth 121 5 Tue, 1:32pm
               Collapse I liked the silence, but........ adt100 110 4 Tue, 1:36pm
                   Powerful Silence = Powerful Thoughts Bombadil 97 0 Tue, 2:08pm
                   Collapse THe pipe mirkwoodwanderer 99 2 Tue, 2:15pm
                       Collapse I agree, BUT I think it went on a bit long.... adt100 87 1 Tue, 2:36pm
                           I agree with you on this moment Old Toby 78 0 Tue, 3:10pm
       Collapse Definitely! And actually... tsmith675 109 1 Tue, 2:11pm
         Laughing NOW? Bombadil 95 0 Tue, 2:22pm
       Agreed Elessar 89 0 Tue, 2:33pm

  Collapse Genuine concern from someone who has not seen the film... ecthelionsbeard 616 11 Tue, 6:34am Jump to last post in thread (by adt100)
       For me definitely live action Ham_Sammy 291 0 Tue, 6:43am
       Collapse For the most part Kim 298 5 Tue, 6:44am
           Collapse Good to know and many thanks for the replies... ecthelionsbeard 265 4 Tue, 6:48am
               I actually thought Kim 261 0 Tue, 7:02am
               Um....... how can you say a scene is ludicrous dormouse 189 0 Tue, 9:19am
               Collapse Legolas (and film's overall aesthetic) Osskil 158 1 Tue, 10:31am
                   I very much like the autumnal/evening look they gave the battle... and the snow! adt100 84 0 Tue, 1:44pm
       The CGI was very obvious at times... elvish.mafia 218 0 Tue, 8:09am
       Well, it won't look like Goblin-town again, so don't worry // Bernhardina 149 0 Tue, 10:27am
       Not too much CGI Macsen 107 0 Tue, 1:04pm
       Honestly did not feel that AT ALL! adt100 85 0 Tue, 1:42pm

  Collapse I was happily surprised by (spoiler?) Sebastian the Hedgehog 873 10 Tue, 6:32am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Yes! Mooseboy018 365 1 Tue, 6:34am
           It's intense Sebastian the Hedgehog 347 0 Tue, 6:42am
     Collapse You make my heart cry out for him as well mae govannen 311 3 Tue, 7:27am
           Collapse Thorin almost Kills dear Bilbo??! ecthelionsbeard 316 2 Tue, 7:36am
               His performance is amazing // dormouse 216 0 Tue, 9:22am
               Just like he almost does in the book too... mae govannen 200 0 Tue, 10:37am
       I thought this scene was beautifully played by RA Old Toby 249 0 Tue, 8:57am
       I loved it CathrineB 208 0 Tue, 9:53am
       Collapse The time SPJ gives to Thorin's descent into madness makes this scene Dame Ioreth 153 1 Tue, 2:01pm
           bom does feel that is why? SSoo..many dwarves Bombadil 134 0 Tue, 2:19pm

  Collapse Most Emotional Moment Bombadil 728 18 Tue, 6:07am Jump to last post in thread (by Eleniel)
       Collapse That was certainly one of them! Roheryn 340 1 Tue, 6:41am
           Maybe we should coin the Phase? "One on One" PJ moments Bombadil 303 0 Tue, 7:00am
       Collapse The Acorn scene Ham_Sammy 345 5 Tue, 7:01am
           Collapse Me too. Roheryn 307 4 Tue, 7:14am
               Agreed Kim 292 0 Tue, 7:22am
               Balin says to Bilbo "You can Thank them yourself"..CUT to Bombadil 296 0 Tue, 7:30am
               I would agree, and add Avandel 262 0 Tue, 8:39am
               Sound like a Thorin Appreciation thread is needed, Ro. Dame Ioreth 116 0 Tue, 2:23pm
       Yes - me too.... dormouse 231 0 Tue, 9:27am
       +1 Remus 209 0 Tue, 10:00am
       Collapse Hmm CathrineB 225 1 Tue, 10:04am
           Actually, I know you were joking.... dormouse 105 0 Tue, 2:47pm
       Collapse I was so confused thinking 'What the heck is going on?' QuackingTroll 235 4 Tue, 10:18am
           Collapse Has to be Bilbo Thorin conversation at the end anthonyroy 217 2 Tue, 10:26am
               Collapse What I loved about that scene Ham_Sammy 119 1 Tue, 2:27pm
                 There are many ways to interpret an Empty? BagEND Bombadil 101 0 Tue, 2:45pm
           2nd and third viewings always help for me! adt100 127 0 Tue, 1:49pm
       The Bard-Bain moment was extremely good, Eleniel 92 0 Tue, 4:03pm

  Collapse Hobbit board/reviews/news refugee coming home - brief *SPOILER!!!* comments after marathon Avandel 644 25 Tue, 5:09am Jump to last post in thread (by Kim)
       Collapse Coming back in, myself. cats16 284 13 Tue, 5:24am
           Collapse Bom is just the OPPOSITE? Bombadil 283 11 Tue, 5:38am
               Collapse Sleep well tonight, Bomby. cats16 242 9 Tue, 5:43am
                   Collapse Cinemark Xtreme Digital theater ...REALLY was Bombadil 246 8 Tue, 6:01am
                       Collapse Am impressed with the clarity... Avandel 177 7 Tue, 7:53am
                           Collapse Glad to have you back Avandel,Cats,Kim NecromancerRising 168 6 Tue, 8:01am
                               I second that.... dormouse 139 0 Tue, 9:25am
                               I third that BlackFox 125 0 Tue, 10:33am
                               *bows deeply and smiles to NR, Dormouse, Black Fox, everyone!* Avandel 75 0 Tue, 6:22pm
                               Collapse Why, thanks everyone! Kim 26 2 Wed, 4:29am
                                 Collapse LOL Kim I was reading too fast Avandel 25 1 Wed, 6:40am
                                       mwhahaha Kim 7 0 Wed, 11:53pm
               I agree Bomby Ham_Sammy 204 0 Tue, 6:52am
           Hi, cats 16!!! Seeing finally your brief post! Welcome back!!! // mae govannen 154 0 Tue, 8:01am
       Collapse Welcome back!!! Was missing you on this Board!... mae govannen 237 6 Tue, 5:55am
           Collapse Thank you ! (: and more will come back I am sure Avandel 184 5 Tue, 7:48am
               Collapse We're trickling back in! Roheryn 126 4 Tue, 10:59am
                 Collapse Think the marathons are an "urban thing"? Avandel 73 3 Tue, 6:30pm
                       Collapse Understandable... Roheryn 67 2 Tue, 7:48pm
                           Collapse Bet the support is there, but the PR isn't! Avandel 46 1 Tue, 11:29pm
                               There are other movies out there? Roheryn 35 0 Wed, 12:21am
       Collapse Well, I'm back Kim 230 1 Tue, 6:41am
           Welcome-welcome to you too!... mae govannen 169 0 Tue, 7:55am
       Collapse Haven't seen it yet... Queen of Erebor 46 1 Tue, 11:50pm
           Audience reaction to *scene* spoiler comment (no, I don't mind you asking!) Avandel 41 0 Wed, 2:53am

  Collapse Critics Reviews #16 NecromancerRising 784 11 Tue, 5:04am Jump to last post in thread (by Elessar)
       Top critics? tdklimek 316 0 Tue, 5:09am
       Collapse Top Critic Michael Phillips NecromancerRising 362 9 Tue, 5:13am
           Collapse Travis Hopson from Examiner NecromancerRising 351 8 Tue, 5:15am
               Collapse Daniel Kimmel's from New England Movies Weekly NecromancerRising 299 7 Tue, 6:23am
                   Collapse Tasha Robinson from The Dissolve NecromancerRising 324 6 Tue, 6:35am
                       DOS best? Danielos 263 0 Tue, 7:30am
                       The negative reviews from AV club and New York Daily News NecromancerRising 192 0 Tue, 12:38pm
                       Collapse A very negative review by a Top Critic of Boston Globe NecromancerRising 172 3 Tue, 1:28pm
                           Collapse The Kansas City Star Elessar 129 2 Tue, 2:39pm
                               Collapse 66% now. American critics seem a lot more harsh on it than British critics anthonyroy 86 1 Tue, 4:28pm
                                   Not a fan of critics in general. Elessar 35 0 Tue, 6:21pm

Collapse Quite possibly the best moment of all 6 films (Small BoFA spoiler) tsmith675 834 9 Tue, 5:03am Jump to last post in thread (by adt100)
       Collapse He runs out of arrows during Helms Deep too Joe20 333 5 Tue, 5:18am
           Collapse Movie Legolas has never run out of arrows. tsmith675 327 4 Tue, 5:23am
               Collapse Yes he does... Joe20 327 3 Tue, 5:30am
                   Collapse And he has a full quiver of arrows seconds later. tsmith675 296 2 Tue, 5:34am
                       No, he doesn't get a refill until he is back up at the Keep. Joe20 285 0 Tue, 5:36am
                       Hmm... Dipling 259 0 Tue, 5:57am
       Yep Angharad73 302 0 Tue, 5:21am
       Wrong place for me Sebastian the Hedgehog 305 0 Tue, 5:24am
       Loved that moment too! adt100 125 0 Tue, 1:24pm

  Collapse Richard Armitage deserves serious awards recognition for (spoiler) thomasofrohan 630 11 Tue, 4:32am Jump to last post in thread (by Kimtc)
       Collapse If you read reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, the critics agree! Kimtc 371 2 Tue, 4:47am
           Collapse Not just fantasy films, CGI films too glor 55 1 Wed, 1:44am
               Exactly Kimtc 51 0 Wed, 2:01am
       agree 100% mirkwoodwanderer 323 0 Tue, 4:51am
       His exchange with Bard at the wall of Erebor... elvish.mafia 256 0 Tue, 8:13am
     I would disagree in that RA's whole performance deserves awards IMO Avandel 253 0 Tue, 8:25am
       Collapse Yes dubulous 215 1 Tue, 9:04am
           Thank you for saying this Avandel 84 0 Tue, 6:41pm
       I'd say his whole performance deserves every award going // dormouse 185 0 Tue, 9:29am
       Armitage is... Bernhardina 203 0 Tue, 10:26am
       "I don't believe in Oscars.... Miss-Merriweather 169 0 Tue, 10:54am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 913 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.