Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 5 of 927 (331994 posts in 13905 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 927 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse So much for a 'Winter Battle'... BornOutOfTheWest 873 7 Mon, 5:28pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       The trilogy of missed upportunities Azaghâl 425 0 Mon, 5:56pm
       Collapse Not to mention.... tiamy 385 3 Mon, 5:58pm
           Collapse Who knows, it could have been a day above freezing and not every Eruonen 323 2 Mon, 6:26pm
               Collapse Breath condensation... Elizabeth 81 1 Tue, 8:50am
                   And things looked pretty dry, not unusual in winter. Eruonen 48 0 Tue, 2:53pm
       Weird Danielos 337 0 Mon, 6:10pm
       It was a winter battle... Annatar598 321 0 Mon, 7:01pm

  Collapse What happens to the Elvish army? Did they all die? Aranarth 734 7 Mon, 5:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       I shouldn't think so Glorfindela 396 0 Mon, 5:14pm
       Collapse Elves evaporate after battles... Brandybuckled 363 3 Mon, 5:35pm
           lol ... horses too Loresilme 200 0 Mon, 8:36pm
           Yes, they are like spun sugar in the rain ;D // Morthoron 76 0 Tue, 3:56am
           Actually in Helm's Deep they do all die... QuackingTroll 61 0 Tue, 10:57am
       If I remember correctly... Scorchster 357 0 Mon, 5:50pm
       If I recall, there were scattered units fighting all over the field. Eruonen 251 0 Mon, 7:25pm

  Collapse So who's decision was the 3 movie split? LoremIpsum 976 37 Mon, 3:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       Collapse It was Peter Jackson and co's idea Lindele 575 2 Mon, 3:52pm
           Collapse Not so sure Fleuz 502 1 Mon, 4:06pm
               I do. Lindele 476 0 Mon, 4:11pm
       It was purely creative DigificWriter 482 0 Mon, 4:04pm
       Collapse There's no doubt in my mind... tsmith675 506 1 Mon, 4:04pm
           Re: There is no doubt in my mind DigificWriter 460 0 Mon, 4:12pm
       PJ's decision DjU 484 0 Mon, 4:04pm
       PJ Aragorn the Elfstone 379 0 Mon, 4:37pm
       Collapse Ideas Danielos 397 10 Mon, 4:42pm
           That, I don't know, but Lindele 373 0 Mon, 4:46pm
           Collapse Definitely not PJ's idea macfalk 399 5 Mon, 4:48pm
               Collapse Evangeline Lily Danielos 402 2 Mon, 4:51pm
                   The triangle was added... Aragorn the Elfstone 379 0 Mon, 4:55pm
                   Tauriel isnt involved in a love triangle DigificWriter 365 0 Mon, 4:59pm
               Agreed. RabidWolverine 347 0 Mon, 4:55pm
               Ya, I get the impression that PJ was never a big fan of that KingTurgon 280 0 Mon, 6:00pm
           It was always there. Aragorn the Elfstone 361 0 Mon, 4:53pm
           Almost certainly... RabidWolverine 350 0 Mon, 4:53pm
           I believe lionoferebor 45 0 Tue, 4:57am
       Collapse Why does it matter? Glorfindela 336 4 Mon, 5:10pm
           Collapse Because Lindele 317 3 Mon, 5:19pm
               Collapse I'm thinking Ham_Sammy 289 2 Mon, 5:28pm
                   Collapse It was driven far more by creative concerns... DigificWriter 253 1 Mon, 6:06pm
                       Agreed Ham_Sammy 215 0 Mon, 6:55pm
       Collapse Are we all even talking about the same 3 films? Brandybuckled 243 1 Mon, 6:38pm
           There were never originally going to be more than two films DigificWriter 183 0 Mon, 7:05pm
       Collapse It was PJ's decision, not WB's... Salmacis81 182 2 Mon, 7:13pm
           Collapse Most of what's in the films was dreamed up by Pete, Fran, Phillipa, and GDT DigificWriter 172 1 Mon, 7:30pm
               I only mention PJ... Salmacis81 162 0 Mon, 7:38pm
       Collapse I suspect a key issue was the way the break changed latter stages of the story.. moreorless 178 3 Mon, 8:07pm
           Collapse TDoS's climax was added after the decision to make things into a trilogy of films and wasn't filmed until 2013.... DigificWriter 150 2 Mon, 9:27pm
               Collapse Most definitely... Eleniel 117 1 Mon, 11:01pm
                   I think thats quite telling as well... moreorless 50 0 Tue, 5:44am
       Collapse Well, the way it was reported at the time.... Silverlode 92 3 Tue, 12:59am
           Collapse I'm interested in these '3rd film' rumors... DigificWriter 53 2 Tue, 5:16am
               Collapse As I recall.... Silverlode 41 1 Tue, 7:04am
                   About the "bridge film" DigificWriter 44 0 Tue, 7:34am

  Collapse The test videos CathrineB 498 1 Mon, 3:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by shaundobson)
       these are great! shaundobson 168 0 Mon, 5:10pm

  Collapse Thorin's age DigificWriter 675 28 Mon, 3:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       Collapse According to the book Guert 425 12 Mon, 3:37pm
           Collapse That's not really what I was asking about DigificWriter 380 11 Mon, 3:45pm
               Collapse Somewhere here someone said, not until they Bombadil 369 10 Mon, 3:56pm
                   Collapse at 240 Cirashala 226 9 Mon, 8:27pm
                       Collapse This might not match what we know, but... DigificWriter 192 8 Mon, 9:19pm
                           Collapse Well... BlackFox 180 6 Mon, 9:29pm
                               Collapse How much credence do we want to give that relative to... DigificWriter 177 5 Mon, 9:34pm
                                   Collapse Call it an inconsistency then BlackFox 151 4 Mon, 10:07pm
                                       Collapse You probably wouldn't know there's an issue... DigificWriter 146 3 Mon, 10:18pm
                                           Collapse Then you ought to move the Sack of Erebor to a later date also BlackFox 135 2 Mon, 10:45pm
                                               Collapse Too young according to what? DigificWriter 124 1 Mon, 11:39pm
                                                   Guess I was wrong.... DigificWriter 111 0 Tue, 12:25am
                           My usual strategy is to just go by the actors ages... fiveforchaos 96 0 Tue, 1:53am
       He looks younger, but he actually isn't BlackFox 369 0 Mon, 4:00pm
       Collapse Not the exact age... Angharad73 340 1 Mon, 4:03pm
           I'll take a look at what Tolkien says about Dwalin's age, then.... DigificWriter 318 0 Mon, 4:25pm
       Collapse One year younger... Otaku-sempai 82 11 Tue, 4:06am
           Collapse It's been stated that Balin is the oldest member of the Company... DigificWriter 77 10 Tue, 5:05am
               Collapse It does, although it's not totally readable in this image...(purposefully distressed!) Eleniel 63 4 Tue, 7:45am
                   Collapse Ooh marillaraina 39 3 Tue, 3:43pm
                       2760 and 2751 BlackFox 35 0 Tue, 3:46pm
                       As neat as the tapestry is.... DigificWriter 35 0 Tue, 3:51pm
                       Dates from the Tapestry Otaku-sempai 29 0 Tue, 5:04pm
               Collapse Sources Otaku-sempai 27 2 Tue, 5:10pm
                   Collapse Statements from the writers and actors would also be primary sources... DigificWriter 27 1 Tue, 5:21pm
                       Interesting marillaraina 24 0 Tue, 7:26pm
               Collapse Depends on the source. Otaku-sempai 21 1 Tue, 8:03pm
                   There's no way to reconcile Thorin's presence at the Sacking of Erebor... DigificWriter 7 0 Wed, 3:11am

  Collapse Cameos theroadgoeseveron 669 10 Mon, 1:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse I quite enjoyed... CathrineB 400 4 Mon, 2:24pm
           Not sure thats PJ DjU 300 0 Mon, 3:28pm
           Collapse Pretty sure he's not a ringwraith. Silverlode 100 2 Tue, 12:41am
               me too DisDwarfWoman 43 0 Tue, 7:37pm
               I saw it Cirashala 24 0 Wed, 12:38am
       Collapse Some more Carne 292 1 Mon, 3:35pm
           Shane Rangi cameo in DOS Laketown "Welcome" scene Lissuin 122 0 Mon, 10:02pm
       Collapse Maybe he's the big squishy-faced orc iduna 109 2 Mon, 10:22pm
           Collapse I dont think the Orc theroadgoeseveron 47 1 Tue, 6:26pm
               Well, it still might be... iduna 31 0 Tue, 9:46pm

  Collapse John Rateliff's thoughts on BOTFA Shagrat 858 10 Mon, 12:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Thanks for posting this. mefansmum 314 0 Mon, 1:07pm
       I found myself mostly agreeing - Hanzkaz 339 0 Mon, 1:11pm
       Collapse Ooooh! I like this Review and its author!...! mae govannen 324 5 Mon, 1:18pm
         Collapse Oin: "He says hezz an EXPERT!" That is WHAT John is...// Bombadil 278 4 Mon, 1:53pm
               Collapse Sorry, can you explain what you mean mae govannen 273 3 Mon, 1:56pm
                   In BagEND Oin doesn't hear correctly what Bilbo Bombadil 269 0 Mon, 2:02pm
                   Collapse In AUJ... arithmancer 263 1 Mon, 2:09pm
                     Okay, got it!!! Thanks!...// mae govannen 223 0 Mon, 2:29pm
       Interesting read, always like to hear what Tolkien scholars have to say about these films... Salmacis81 119 0 Mon, 7:08pm
       Finally! I feel like I just read a real review Loresilme 82 0 Mon, 10:05pm

  Collapse the movie is in fact in par to ROTK in terms of tension Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 653 22 Mon, 11:19am Jump to last post in thread (by Kim)
       Collapse Um....no..... NateGate 286 17 Mon, 3:23pm
           Collapse humble opinions...humble opinions everywere Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 253 15 Mon, 3:38pm
               Collapse Eh... NateGate 232 13 Mon, 3:49pm
                   Collapse Sorry, I dont give a heck for the oscars Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 226 9 Mon, 3:51pm
                       Collapse Me either Ham_Sammy 218 8 Mon, 3:57pm
                         Collapse Thirded Glorfindela 210 7 Mon, 4:05pm
                               Collapse The Oscars.... NateGate 200 6 Mon, 4:12pm
                                   Collapse Perhaps to you Glorfindela 186 5 Mon, 4:20pm
                                       Collapse True.... NateGate 176 1 Mon, 4:31pm
                                           stupidity? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 162 0 Mon, 4:36pm
                                       Collapse The Oscars Ham_Sammy 163 2 Mon, 4:47pm
                                           Collapse Yes, agree, Ham-Sammy Glorfindela 134 1 Mon, 5:08pm
                                               Yes I agree Ham_Sammy 122 0 Mon, 5:15pm
                   I agree with the conclusion, personally. Spriggan 163 0 Mon, 4:34pm
                   While I don't necessarily disagree with you Lindele 155 0 Mon, 4:36pm
                   tense Mooseboy018 100 0 Mon, 6:08pm
               Fans Aranarth 73 0 Mon, 7:40pm
           the stakes Ruxendil_Thoorg 67 0 Mon, 8:17pm
       The movie is in fact in par to ROTK in terms of tension Glorfindela 248 0 Mon, 3:45pm
       I can only speak for myself Ham_Sammy 233 0 Mon, 3:49pm
       The posting was about TENSION not which film is better. Eruonen 151 0 Mon, 4:54pm
       Agreed Kim 39 0 Tue, 5:47am

  Collapse What is the real reason of showing Galadriel so powerful? erdildeniz 899 29 Mon, 11:06am Jump to last post in thread (by AinurOlorin)
       Must say Glorfindela 533 0 Mon, 11:07am
       This way Saruman has a more ambiguous role. irasel 478 0 Mon, 11:53am
       I always thought that the Istari aren't allowed to challenge Sauron with pure power... Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 473 0 Mon, 11:53am
       Collapse It's a femine conspiracy. // Riven Delve 413 1 Mon, 12:13pm
         *snort* BlackFox 377 0 Mon, 12:58pm
       Collapse . Nerven 419 2 Mon, 12:19pm
           Good quotes! Tend to agree with your last point, mae govannen 350 0 Mon, 1:34pm
           Feanor never killed any Balrogs. In fact, with the exception of a factually flawed AinurOlorin 57 0 Tue, 4:24am
       Collapse Pays off later huzzlewhat 440 2 Mon, 12:48pm
           Exactly. Nicely explained..// mae govannen 341 0 Mon, 1:23pm
           Excellent point! // Loresilme 138 0 Mon, 8:33pm
       Collapse It seems they've sort of combined two different scenes from the book Elarie 355 4 Mon, 2:25pm
           Collapse Well, no. We need to be a bit careful about the quote. Spriggan 278 3 Mon, 4:13pm
               Collapse that's true - I wonder what that means? Elarie 259 2 Mon, 4:20pm
                   It could simply refer to his planning.... Eruonen 250 0 Mon, 4:24pm
                   Tolkien uses the word in four possible senses Spriggan 242 0 Mon, 4:39pm
       I think.... Girdle of Melian 302 0 Mon, 3:22pm
       She employed the power of her elven ring, which Sauron cannot Eruonen 303 0 Mon, 4:07pm
       Because Boyens IMO focuses too much on her favorite characters KingTurgon 219 0 Mon, 6:13pm
       Collapse Yeah... Salmacis81 178 1 Mon, 7:21pm
           Didn't I warn you, Salmalcis?? lol She did keep passing out, so that helped to balance AinurOlorin 54 0 Tue, 4:33am
       Collapse I don't think they showed her that powerful dubulous 172 7 Mon, 8:00pm
           Collapse That's true... Salmacis81 131 6 Mon, 10:15pm
               Collapse On that basis, we don't know Saruman was there either. Spriggan 125 4 Mon, 10:46pm
                   Collapse There is more textual basis... Salmacis81 107 3 Mon, 11:18pm
                       Collapse The texts suggest no hero at all. Spriggan 79 2 Mon, 11:59pm
                           Collapse Except for the fact that... Salmacis81 80 1 Tue, 12:11am
                               Not a bigger role, just a specific one. Spriggan 82 0 Tue, 12:14am
               Well dubulous 118 0 Mon, 10:54pm

Entertainment Weekly has Steven Colbert on the Cover...AS Bombadil 246 0 Mon, 10:49am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)

Collapse Love the beginning of BOFA/Bard/Bain Avandel 557 16 Mon, 7:56am Jump to last post in thread (by DisDwarfWoman)
       Collapse great stuff Mooseboy018 293 1 Mon, 8:02am
         very special Avandel 114 0 Mon, 5:33pm
       Collapse I loved that! CathrineB 237 1 Mon, 9:41am
           Me, too. Estel78 221 0 Mon, 9:52am
     Collapse Avandel...XTreme HDHFR3D is the Only way Bom will see a movie Bombadil 233 1 Mon, 9:53am
           Think I agree with you! Avandel 115 0 Mon, 5:28pm
     It's fantastic! Glorfindela 208 0 Mon, 11:03am
       Collapse Isn't it truly extraordinary? mae govannen 197 2 Mon, 11:53am
         Collapse Extraordinary - oh yes! Avandel 150 1 Mon, 4:13pm
               Didn't manage to notice all this mae govannen 37 0 Tue, 8:08am
       Collapse My favorite opening ever, right up there with Gandalf fighting the Balrog hobbitylass 127 2 Mon, 5:31pm
           Collapse Feel better! Avandel 115 1 Mon, 5:34pm
               Thanks! I already checked the movie times hobbitylass 107 0 Mon, 5:48pm
       Collapse John Bell is really a great actor KingTurgon 110 2 Mon, 6:02pm
           Collapse Terrific scene Ham_Sammy 65 1 Mon, 11:12pm
               loved the taunting! DisDwarfWoman 23 0 Tue, 7:45pm

  Collapse I don't really like TBOFA compared to AUJ and TDOS... delius82 874 13 Mon, 6:05am Jump to last post in thread (by adu)
       Collapse Yes.. ecthelionsbeard 475 1 Mon, 6:10am
           I'm with you on this! Glorfindela 269 0 Mon, 10:58am
       Collapse PJ was right, DOS was the best one of the three MouthofSauron 484 1 Mon, 6:29am
           Yeah but this year he said Lindele 83 0 Mon, 6:35pm
       Collapse The book also Silverlode 383 3 Mon, 8:04am
           Collapse and thats why DOS MouthofSauron 327 1 Mon, 9:16am
               Now We Can Discuss The Effect of Three Films Michelle Johnston 261 0 Mon, 11:17am
           Quite true and important remark... I will add that mae govannen 182 0 Mon, 1:42pm
       It's the same in the book... TheHutt 346 0 Mon, 8:30am
       that is strange mirkwoodwanderer 273 0 Mon, 11:00am
       Collapse Hope you enjoy the EE more... QuackingTroll 208 2 Mon, 1:39pm
           I actually disagree with you there KingTurgon 96 0 Mon, 6:21pm
           The EE makes a big difference... adu 63 0 Mon, 9:34pm

  Collapse The real question is... Saneliur 566 4 Mon, 5:30am Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       Collapse Dale Mooseboy018 289 2 Mon, 5:44am
           Collapse Bomby wantz it to Become the PARTY TREE! Bombadil 229 1 Mon, 5:52am
               Too young. Bumblingidiot 11 0 Wed, 2:17am
       The significance mirkwoodwanderer 159 0 Mon, 11:01am

Collapse Whose armor did you like best? Loresilme 539 10 Mon, 4:25am Jump to last post in thread (by MedwedtoBeorn)
       Hmm... cats16 295 0 Mon, 4:58am
       Thranduil's looks very movement friendly. Eruonen 277 0 Mon, 5:21am
       Collapse I liked Kili's Cirashala 221 1 Mon, 7:58am
           Yes, lionoferebor 186 0 Mon, 8:20am
       Thorin and Fili's CathrineB 185 0 Mon, 9:38am
       Really can't make up my mind Glorfindela 172 0 Mon, 10:57am
       Loved Gloin wearing Gimli's helmet // QuackingTroll 139 0 Mon, 1:28pm
       Collapse Off the cuff... Otaku-sempai 136 1 Mon, 1:37pm
           Elrond had two SETS, one in Rivendell & the Other Bombadil 117 0 Mon, 1:58pm
       Dain MedwedtoBeorn 77 0 Mon, 5:53pm

  Collapse Who do you think? lionoferebor 449 6 Mon, 4:18am Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Nori or Gloin, perhaps. Silverlode 240 0 Mon, 4:22am
       Collapse In his madness grammaboodawg 237 3 Mon, 4:50am
           He did.... NateGate 82 0 Mon, 3:26pm
           You would think Ham_Sammy 71 0 Mon, 3:46pm
           I know, right? Cirashala 27 0 Tue, 1:58am
       He does not know any more mirkwoodwanderer 130 0 Mon, 11:03am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 927 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.