Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 5 of 951 (342357 posts in 14264 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 951 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse It will never be enough: fan fic sequels/time to recast Legolas, Aragorn, Gandalf? *ducks* Avandel 1086 37 Jan 19, 7:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by burrahobbit)
       Collapse I don't see what the problem would be. Spriggan 499 2 Jan 19, 8:26pm
           Collapse Simple and elegant Avandel 388 1 Jan 19, 10:22pm
               This is what I think Glorfindela 341 0 Jan 20, 12:15am
       it would be awesome to see the badass trio: Aragorn , Legolas and Gandalf Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 455 0 Jan 19, 9:08pm
       DO WE MAKE A LIST? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 442 0 Jan 19, 9:23pm
       yes please Ilmatar 418 0 Jan 19, 9:35pm
       Think I'd be fine with it Eruvandi 376 0 Jan 19, 10:29pm
       Collapse Nah it will never happen burrahobbit 382 16 Jan 19, 11:57pm
           Collapse I disagree Glorfindela 349 2 Jan 20, 12:06am
               Collapse Well they appointed GDT to direct the films burrahobbit 158 1 Jan 20, 8:12pm
                   Not true! Otaku-sempai 135 0 Jan 20, 9:44pm
         Collapse Whoa - IMO this is a bit strong Avandel 339 3 Jan 20, 12:49am
               Collapse ... burrahobbit 153 2 Jan 20, 8:45pm
                   Collapse some good points IMO! Avandel 74 1 Jan 21, 5:41pm
                       Thanks burrahobbit 44 0 Jan 21, 10:50pm
           Collapse Peter Jackson isn't 'bored out of his mind with Middle Earth'... dormouse 254 7 Jan 20, 9:02am
               Perhaps its just me seelng things that arent there BUT... moreorless 235 0 Jan 20, 9:52am
               Collapse Cinema does have an influence burrahobbit 162 5 Jan 20, 9:12pm
                   Collapse Yes and no. Spriggan 128 4 Jan 20, 9:54pm
                       Collapse The concern was with burrahobbit 126 3 Jan 20, 10:16pm
                           I think you're under estimating the audience Elarie 102 0 Jan 20, 11:35pm
                           I'm not sure why we should be concerned about that. Spriggan 100 0 Jan 20, 11:45pm
                           But if those people have never and will never read the book.... dormouse 111 0 Jan 20, 11:49pm
           Just to be clear here. NecromancerRising 212 0 Jan 20, 10:55am
       Just want to remind everyone that del Toro toyed with the idea of a bridge movie... AshNazg 358 0 Jan 20, 12:01am
       I'm actually quite glad Bumblingidiot 312 0 Jan 20, 1:19am
       Collapse Recasting Aragorn would certainly bother me Gianna 319 2 Jan 20, 1:57am
           And IMO that is a huge compliment to the actors' work Avandel 290 0 Jan 20, 3:28am
           I agree with you on those points. // mae govannen 173 0 Jan 20, 12:24pm
       Collapse fan fic sequels are fine. FrogmortonJustice65 278 1 Jan 20, 3:45am
           but the desire for sequels is love, not greed! Avandel 168 0 Jan 20, 5:43pm
       (blunders into wild uproar, checks to see if helmet strap is tightened...) swordwhale 273 0 Jan 20, 5:07am
       Collapse It all depends on the quality Elarie 174 2 Jan 20, 1:18pm
           Collapse Exactly IMO - and a quality sequel or rebbot is possible! Avandel 128 1 Jan 20, 5:18pm
               The first Star Trek reboot Loresilme 102 0 Jan 20, 11:01pm
       Collapse Why does people seemingly think, painjoiker 190 1 Jan 20, 1:20pm
           Perhaps it's because he says now that if another film happens.... dormouse 166 0 Jan 20, 2:00pm

  Collapse A matter of nods Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 700 6 Jan 19, 6:14pm Jump to last post in thread (by painjoiker)
       Too old Glorfindela 333 0 Jan 19, 6:28pm
       Collapse Don't think it would work. Kelly of Water's Edge 242 3 Jan 19, 7:33pm
           Dunedain appearence Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 203 0 Jan 19, 9:25pm
           I think that isn't a particularly major obstacle. Spriggan 182 0 Jan 19, 9:45pm
           The tention is already broken... painjoiker 100 0 Jan 20, 1:23pm
       No. Bumblingidiot 145 0 Jan 20, 1:20am

  Collapse Storming China - PB/PJ/RA arrive in Bejing for premiere Avandel 1637 61 Jan 19, 5:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by vigshane)
     Collapse $$$ Bofur's Hat 813 6 Jan 19, 6:10pm
           Smaug Torching Laketown? Bombadil 777 0 Jan 19, 6:16pm
           Collapse It will need about $170m from China for $1b Estel78 782 4 Jan 19, 6:27pm
               Collapse I suspect it will do about $120 million Voronwë_the_Faithful 348 3 Jan 20, 9:35pm
                   Collapse Very good presales Estel78 253 2 Jan 21, 9:39am
                       Let's hope so! NecromancerRising 234 0 Jan 21, 10:09am
                       It will certainly be higher Voronwë_the_Faithful 230 0 Jan 21, 1:37pm
       Collapse That's great Glorfindela 755 5 Jan 19, 6:29pm
           Collapse you are welcome! Avandel 686 4 Jan 19, 6:49pm
               Collapse I Recommend Bank Robbery smtfhw 688 2 Jan 19, 6:54pm
                   Collapse Thanks for the tip! Avandel 640 1 Jan 19, 7:05pm
                       We Were Lucky smtfhw 631 0 Jan 19, 7:23pm
               I've been to Australia (from London) Glorfindela 661 0 Jan 19, 7:02pm
       Collapse Richard Taylor is there, also! dernwyn 724 1 Jan 19, 6:33pm
           Not the dragonslayer? Avandel 680 0 Jan 19, 7:02pm
       Collapse RA got a good reception at the airport ShireHorse 648 31 Jan 20, 1:03am
           That was so cute! The singing of the Misty Mountains song! Old Toby 534 0 Jan 20, 2:23am
         Collapse LOL fangirling in any language Avandel 521 29 Jan 20, 3:39am
               Collapse He turned up to the Premiere ShireHorse 388 28 Jan 20, 8:33pm
                 Collapse Oh yes! A vid of RA joining in would be great Avandel 359 6 Jan 20, 9:30pm
                       Collapse Here you go! ShireHorse 352 5 Jan 21, 12:01am
                         OH THANK YOU! Avandel 286 0 Jan 21, 5:09am
                           :-) Thanks for posting that! // dormouse 253 0 Jan 21, 8:27am
                           What fun! dernwyn 265 0 Jan 21, 11:26am
                           Collapse Oh, that is great Elarie 269 1 Jan 21, 11:55am
                             Like Great STARS HAVE..a,a,a,..? Bombadil 264 0 Jan 21, 12:07pm
                   Those are so cool Kim 271 0 Jan 21, 6:58am
                   Collapse These are our gifts for them. ninquelote 289 19 Jan 21, 12:48pm
                       They are wonderful gifts! dernwyn 217 0 Jan 21, 1:43pm
                     These are awesome Ninquelote! // Brethil 216 0 Jan 21, 1:47pm
                       The gifts were a wonderful idea, ninquelote... dormouse 211 0 Jan 21, 2:12pm
                       Those are wonderful! Voronwë_the_Faithful 211 0 Jan 21, 2:17pm
                       Collapse Thanks ninquelote! Kim 179 7 Jan 21, 6:45pm
                           Collapse Meanings vigshane 163 6 Jan 21, 8:10pm
                               Collapse Cool! Kim 160 3 Jan 21, 8:13pm
                                 Collapse HOW interesting!..Like an Artist's Watermark!!! // Bombadil 142 2 Jan 21, 8:36pm
                                       Collapse yes it's like a signature they use for art Me85 196 1 Jan 21, 9:32pm
                                           You're right about that. vigshane 182 0 Jan 21, 10:27pm
                               Collapse did Peter get to keep the stamp? Me85 84 1 Jan 22, 1:34pm
                                   It was a gift vigshane 80 0 Jan 22, 7:39pm
                       Collapse i can't see the contract Me85 188 6 Jan 21, 10:06pm
                           Collapse Chinese version of Burglar Contract ninquelote 162 5 Jan 22, 1:00am
                               Collapse Gorgeous! Do you know why some of the writing is in red? / Ataahua 136 1 Jan 22, 1:13am
                                   There is red in English also. arithmancer 137 0 Jan 22, 1:47am
                               wow Me85 142 0 Jan 22, 1:16am
                               Those are beautiful! dernwyn 123 0 Jan 22, 3:18am
                               That's a lovely piece of work! // dormouse 101 0 Jan 22, 8:21am
       Collapse New pic of Richard and Peter at the Great Wall Kim 302 5 Jan 21, 6:53am
           Collapse What's that tube thing RA is holding? Glorfindela 267 4 Jan 21, 12:27pm
               Collapse The camera... arithmancer 263 3 Jan 21, 12:39pm
                   Collapse Oh, I see – thank you Glorfindela 256 2 Jan 21, 12:45pm
                       Hence, the dernwyn 228 0 Jan 21, 1:39pm
                       It's the dreaded selfie stick... smtfhw 229 0 Jan 21, 2:00pm
       Collapse Video of the premiere Kim 195 6 Jan 21, 7:03pm
           Collapse What is Sir Peter wearing? Voronwë_the_Faithful 183 2 Jan 21, 7:11pm
               Collapse Heck, that's dressed up for him! Kim 189 1 Jan 21, 7:13pm
                 Bomby had to Laugh? Bombadil 165 0 Jan 21, 8:14pm
           Collapse Mandarin vigshane 169 2 Jan 21, 8:19pm
               Collapse Thanks again! Kim 140 1 Jan 21, 8:58pm
                   No problem! vigshane 135 0 Jan 21, 9:05pm
       Sending a link to this to Main dernwyn 107 0 Jan 22, 11:22am

  Collapse Finally Extremly Powerful Magic sphdle1 1212 48 Jan 19, 2:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by sphdle1)
       Collapse Fifth HP film... arithmancer 578 1 Jan 19, 3:04pm
           well... sphdle1 429 0 Jan 19, 5:25pm
       Collapse When I saw this i was like "OH YEAAAAAAAAH!!!" aifeme 533 1 Jan 19, 3:23pm
           Yeah, I thought it was awesome someone stepped up to the plate :) sphdle1 198 0 Jan 20, 5:00pm
       Collapse The Lord of the Rings didn't want to fall prey to the cliches of Harry Potter magic... AshNazg 449 4 Jan 19, 5:40pm
           Collapse Really? DjU 414 2 Jan 19, 6:04pm
               Not to mention a giant disembodied eye floating atop a radio tower in Mordor // Morthoron 389 0 Jan 19, 6:09pm
               I didn't say there was no magic. My gripe is with the way the magic was handled aesthetically // AshNazg 250 0 Jan 19, 10:57pm
           To me Magic is sphdle1 384 0 Jan 19, 6:18pm
       Collapse I thought the Harry Potter films were horrible Glorfindela 396 14 Jan 19, 6:25pm
           Collapse If you only saw a couple of them... sphdle1 385 12 Jan 19, 6:28pm
               Collapse No Glorfindela 378 9 Jan 19, 6:32pm
                   Collapse How can you understand the plot sphdle1 173 8 Jan 20, 1:12pm
                       Collapse I didn't say I didn't understand Glorfindela 144 7 Jan 20, 3:51pm
                           Collapse Did you read all the HP books? sphdle1 150 6 Jan 20, 4:19pm
                               Collapse Why can't you accept that somebody just doesn't like Harry Potter? AshNazg 141 1 Jan 20, 4:28pm
                                   I didn't say anything about liking HP ... Why can't you accept a good conversation? sphdle1 199 0 Jan 20, 4:43pm
                               Collapse Heaven forbid! Glorfindela 208 3 Jan 20, 4:39pm
                                   No joke sphdle1 202 0 Jan 20, 4:55pm
                                   That's not the joke. Eowyn of Penns Woods 193 0 Jan 20, 5:05pm
                                   # 3 and on... arithmancer 187 0 Jan 20, 6:01pm
               Collapse Well, I agree with Glorfindela on HP AshNazg 256 1 Jan 19, 11:08pm
                   Beg to differ sphdle1 167 0 Jan 20, 12:54pm
           Agree, and I've seen all of them. // xxxyyy 155 0 Jan 20, 8:57pm
       Collapse OOP duel Loresilme 360 1 Jan 19, 7:24pm
           And if I recall sphdle1 145 0 Jan 20, 3:16pm
       Collapse Nevermind... Salmacis81 344 10 Jan 19, 7:37pm
           Collapse would have been nice to see Gandalf in action sphdle1 157 8 Jan 20, 3:18pm
               Collapse I actually enjoyed the Gandalf/Sauron confrontation... Salmacis81 182 7 Jan 20, 7:02pm
                   Collapse Hear! Hear! Ereinion Nénharma 164 6 Jan 20, 8:24pm
                       Collapse Yup... Salmacis81 141 5 Jan 21, 12:25am
                           Collapse Would it have made a difference if they were set on having one person do it sphdle1 132 4 Jan 21, 2:37am
                               Collapse I don't mind that Galadriel Was leading the charge.... QueenCirce 140 1 Jan 21, 3:29am
                                   That would have been cool too sphdle1 99 0 Jan 21, 12:51pm
                               Collapse No... Ereinion Nénharma 76 1 Jan 21, 8:04pm
                                   yes I agree with this. QueenCirce 54 0 Jan 22, 1:43am
           Thank goodness I'm not the only one to feel like this. Scalpy 121 0 Jan 21, 5:00am
       Collapse Too bad... Ereinion Nénharma 327 3 Jan 19, 7:49pm
           Collapse I would have been fine with whomever did it sphdle1 36 2 Jan 22, 2:06pm
               Collapse It's not... Ereinion Nénharma 25 1 Jan 22, 4:35pm
                   I will definitely agree that it did make the others look weaker sphdle1 24 0 Jan 22, 5:26pm
       Collapse That kind of magic has nothing to do with what Tolkien was trying to describe. Bumblingidiot 256 1 Jan 20, 1:07am
           I love that the elves seem not to understand magic AshNazg 148 0 Jan 20, 4:17pm
       Collapse you're right!! Gandalf and magic was toned down. QueenCirce 142 4 Jan 21, 3:26am
           Collapse A bit unfortunate sphdle1 105 3 Jan 21, 12:56pm
               Collapse Gandalf doesn't lack power in LotR... dormouse 103 2 Jan 21, 2:09pm
                   you are right.... QueenCirce 55 0 Jan 22, 1:45am
                   I realize that is true sphdle1 40 0 Jan 22, 1:45pm

  Moved: Thorin clone shadowdog - - Jan 19, 4:40am Jump to last post in thread (by shadowdog)

  Collapse Kili, Tauriel and Thorin Noria 1201 35 Jan 19, 1:54am Jump to last post in thread (by Lindarielwen)
       Collapse "throw her over the ramparts" Bofur's Hat 594 3 Jan 19, 2:34am
           Collapse Yup, pretty much... lionoferebor 555 2 Jan 19, 3:07am
               Collapse Dwalin would have said? Bombadil 521 1 Jan 19, 6:17am
                   ... Ilmatar 472 0 Jan 19, 7:01am
       Collapse PeckishOwl was way ahead.. Eleniel 548 13 Jan 19, 8:06am
           That's priceless! // dormouse 423 0 Jan 19, 9:14am
         LOL!!! Excellent. mae govannen 389 0 Jan 19, 11:39am
           That's great!// Noria 348 0 Jan 19, 12:55pm
           Oh, that is brilliant! // Voronwë_the_Faithful 345 0 Jan 19, 1:12pm
           Collapse I love Peckish Owl, lol!! RosieLass 315 7 Jan 19, 5:38pm
               Oh, wonderful - Greenwood Hobbit 283 0 Jan 19, 5:51pm
               Indeed! Eleniel 255 0 Jan 19, 6:54pm
               That's so clever! // dormouse 238 0 Jan 19, 7:04pm
               Oh my Arnor, laughing so hard right now! Gianna 256 0 Jan 19, 7:05pm
               Collapse *snigger* Avandel 242 1 Jan 19, 7:52pm
                   Oh dear Riven Delve 230 0 Jan 19, 8:17pm
             *snort* // BlackFox 217 0 Jan 19, 8:01pm
           Bwa ha ha ha ha!!! :D // Loresilme 230 0 Jan 19, 7:24pm
       Love the idea! I had it too... mae govannen 425 0 Jan 19, 11:31am
       Also fun to imagine... Elarie 408 0 Jan 19, 1:00pm
       Collapse Heh. Riven Delve 364 13 Jan 19, 2:58pm
         Collapse Phhhht. Avandel 269 12 Jan 19, 9:11pm
               Collapse I lost you at the strawberry-red glow (inflamed by the power of love!) Riven Delve 161 10 Jan 20, 1:39pm
                 Collapse *bows* LOL I am in hiding Avandel 131 9 Jan 20, 7:48pm
                       Collapse Drums...drums in the deep Riven Delve 142 5 Jan 20, 8:08pm
                         Collapse Hmm - good idea! Avandel 130 4 Jan 20, 8:42pm
                               Collapse Shimmering sea-pearl teeth? Kilidoescartwheels 116 3 Jan 20, 10:46pm
                                   Collapse gotta have one... Avandel 94 2 Jan 21, 2:34am
                                       Well, who wouldn't Kilidoescartwheels 49 0 Jan 21, 2:34pm
                                       Avandel, I haven't read this entire thread, but just jumped into this and read this post Old Toby 58 0 Jan 21, 3:12pm
                       Collapse :D Ilmatar 132 1 Jan 20, 9:30pm
                           *humbly bows* Avandel 84 0 Jan 21, 3:10am
                       You can cast me... Queen of Erebor 105 0 Jan 21, 1:36am
               Oh my! Elarie 64 0 Jan 21, 12:09pm
       Ha ha ha!! Lindarielwen 6 0 2:22pm

  Moved: TOR.N=THeOnRIng.Net Donkay2200 - - Jan 19, 12:39am Jump to last post in thread (by Donkay2200)

  Collapse More Middle Earth Bofur's Hat 1164 25 Jan 19, 12:34am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse A War in the North movie! Holly Hobbit 548 5 Jan 19, 1:29am
           Collapse well, it wouldn't be a "War in the North" movie, technically FrogmortonJustice65 527 1 Jan 19, 1:38am
               Not necessarily. Elizabeth 452 0 Jan 19, 5:28am
           well now swordwhale 458 0 Jan 19, 3:57am
           Collapse He's X thousands of years old; he's not going to be changing his character every 5 minutes. Bumblingidiot 330 1 Jan 19, 1:49pm
               I'm in Jeffrodo 299 0 Jan 19, 2:15pm
       This is one more ME movie that I would like to see. Noria 542 0 Jan 19, 1:35am
       Collapse I totally agree... Ereinion Nénharma 397 1 Jan 19, 9:48am
           I love one of your ideas! Holly Hobbit 148 0 Jan 19, 10:33pm
       Hello and welcome! dormouse 372 0 Jan 19, 11:19am
       Great first post, welcome, welcome! // mae govannen 351 0 Jan 19, 11:45am
       no book Gandalf 348 0 Jan 19, 12:53pm
       I think the other question is what the story would be. Spriggan 320 0 Jan 19, 1:44pm
       Collapse Bard ought to be dead by then. Otaku-sempai 299 2 Jan 19, 2:21pm
           Collapse Characters Jeffrodo 289 1 Jan 19, 2:40pm
               Aragorn - The Legendary Journeys Otaku-sempai 275 0 Jan 19, 2:58pm
       Collapse I'd like more Middle-Earth movies - Hanzkaz 287 1 Jan 19, 3:15pm
           Agree. Holly Hobbit 149 0 Jan 19, 10:25pm
       Collapse Wish List for The War In the North Bofur's Hat 277 1 Jan 19, 3:59pm
           I would so totally watch this. Holly Hobbit 146 0 Jan 19, 10:30pm
       Collapse i always thought that messenger was the mouth of sauron Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 268 1 Jan 19, 4:02pm
           Me too... Ereinion Nénharma 190 0 Jan 19, 8:14pm
       Tolkien didn't write enough material on this for one film, Bumblingidiot 146 0 Jan 20, 12:51am
       Collapse I think the studio would have to have a very viable set or trilogy of movies Eruonen 88 1 Jan 20, 4:14pm
           Pretty much this. Otaku-sempai 40 0 Jan 20, 4:40pm

  Collapse Thorin and Balin's Relationship Starglass 725 12 Jan 18, 10:16pm Jump to last post in thread (by Starglass)
       Collapse They are quite a pair lionoferebor 325 3 Jan 18, 11:09pm
           Collapse "BALIN, sound the ALARM.." Bombadil 342 2 Jan 18, 11:24pm
               Collapse Thorin + Balin Bofur's Hat 291 1 Jan 18, 11:45pm
                   Welcome Bofur's Hat! Starglass 96 0 Jan 19, 7:28pm
       Collapse Take all the moments you want for that! dormouse 313 1 Jan 18, 11:35pm
           SSOoo.. sorry the First line in the Prologue.. Bombadil 280 0 Jan 18, 11:43pm
       Collapse There is so much affection and respect between them Elarie 294 1 Jan 18, 11:44pm
           I never noticed that! Starglass 102 0 Jan 19, 7:30pm
       Dwalin & Balin's intro together in AUJ is pretty Dwarve Funny squiggle 291 0 Jan 18, 11:58pm
       I too love Thorin and Balin's relationship. Noria 228 0 Jan 19, 1:42am
       Yes, I too loved their relationship Old Toby 189 0 Jan 19, 3:51am
       there's something archetypal about that relationship swordwhale 213 0 Jan 19, 4:00am

  Collapse Why did they build pre-destrucion Dale as a full scale set, painjoiker 1176 17 Jan 18, 5:00pm Jump to last post in thread (by swordwhale)
       Collapse Presumably because they weren't sure at that stage.... dormouse 681 7 Jan 18, 5:05pm
           Collapse Which is ironic considering... Arandir 576 6 Jan 18, 6:44pm
               Collapse Well, they did construct sets as well for Bag End, dormouse 528 5 Jan 18, 7:10pm
                   Collapse great list, I'll add some Ilmatar 424 3 Jan 18, 8:54pm
                       Collapse It's a shame CGI dominates so much discussion. [STARS}TyranT 374 2 Jan 18, 10:30pm
                           Collapse Could it also be that the perception.... dormouse 355 1 Jan 18, 11:07pm
                               It really doesn't... // Bofur01 296 0 Jan 19, 12:08am
                   Thank you, thank you for this list of sets!!! mae govannen 175 0 Jan 19, 11:27am
       We did see some more in DOS moreorless 596 0 Jan 18, 5:10pm
       How did they film post-destruction Dale? arithmancer 613 0 Jan 18, 5:11pm
       Collapse Well SafeUnderHill 625 1 Jan 18, 5:13pm
         Great THINKING! ADD that!.. to our Wish LIST..// Bombadil 494 0 Jan 18, 6:21pm
       Collapse I love CG swordwhale 265 4 Jan 19, 4:04am
           Collapse Never say never. cats16 209 2 Jan 19, 8:44am
               Not sure I need realism, as such. Bumblingidiot 164 0 Jan 19, 12:45pm
               one of the beauties of CG swordwhale 127 0 Jan 19, 5:36pm
           To me... Eleniel 181 0 Jan 19, 11:05am

  Collapse Durin's Day - An Astronomical Error? Otaku-sempai 764 53 Jan 18, 2:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Where does it say in that quote SafeUnderHill 418 38 Jan 18, 2:54pm
           Collapse That is why the question requires some expertise. Otaku-sempai 394 37 Jan 18, 2:56pm
               Collapse I know little about Tolkien's mythology SafeUnderHill 384 36 Jan 18, 3:09pm
                   Collapse It might have been a new moon (according to Tolkien) Otaku-sempai 381 34 Jan 18, 3:22pm
                       Collapse Where it says thin new moon SafeUnderHill 357 4 Jan 18, 3:42pm
                           Collapse Or... Otaku-sempai 348 3 Jan 18, 3:48pm
                               Collapse Yes SafeUnderHill 332 1 Jan 18, 4:04pm
                                   For it to be A, A a, FULL Moon...? Bombadil 295 0 Jan 18, 6:42pm
                               Not that far off? DanielLB 252 0 Jan 18, 7:54pm
                       Collapse Yes, I think a new moon is implied. Silverlode 197 28 Jan 18, 11:28pm
                           Collapse "the first day of the last moon of Autumn" Otaku-sempai 189 27 Jan 18, 11:58pm
                               Collapse What's your definition of Autumn? Elizabeth 168 3 Jan 19, 1:04am
                                   Collapse Autumn as per Shire Reckoning Otaku-sempai 158 2 Jan 19, 2:43am
                                       Collapse Funny, I just noticed this for the first time Gwytha 220 1 Jan 19, 3:09am
                                           Great observation! Otaku-sempai 213 0 Jan 19, 3:20am
                               Collapse In my opinion*, DanielLB 202 22 Jan 19, 7:04am
                                   Collapse If my understanding is now correct... Otaku-sempai 183 11 Jan 19, 1:46pm
                                       Collapse I am now very confused. Bumblingidiot 162 10 Jan 20, 2:00am
                                           Collapse The two events are not mutually exclusive. DanielLB 153 2 Jan 20, 7:35am
                                               Collapse What I meant was Bumblingidiot 122 1 Jan 20, 3:35pm
                                                   It's a question of alignment. Elizabeth 72 0 Jan 21, 7:53am
                                           Fulll Moons Otaku-sempai 127 0 Jan 20, 2:28pm
                                           Collapse Our calendar is different from Middle-earth iduna 42 5 Jan 21, 7:34pm
                                               Collapse I read that. Otaku-sempai 38 4 Jan 21, 8:06pm
                                                   Collapse Ack! Otaku-sempai 14 3 Jan 23, 12:02am
                                                       Collapse Second (Third?) Thoughts Otaku-sempai 16 2 Tue, 6:03pm
                                                           Collapse Duin's Day in TH:DoS Otaku-sempai 10 1 Tue, 10:04pm
                                                               It's always something! Otaku-sempai 6 0 Wed, 3:09pm
                                   Collapse And...what was considered to be the start of Winter? Otaku-sempai 113 9 Jan 20, 4:36pm
                                       Collapse October 23 to November 20? Otaku-sempai 109 8 Jan 20, 5:07pm
                                           Collapse Semantics ... Bracegirdle 93 7 Jan 20, 11:11pm
                                               Collapse Okay... Otaku-sempai 86 6 Jan 21, 1:04am
                                                   Collapse Durin's Day in 'TH:BotFA' Otaku-sempai 84 5 Jan 21, 1:24am
                                                       Collapse I can’t refute Bracegirdle 76 4 Jan 21, 4:02am
                                                           Collapse Yes. realistically it would make a difference Otaku-sempai 69 3 Jan 21, 11:01am
                                                               Collapse Is 6000 years enough time? . . . Bracegirdle 57 2 Jan 21, 3:08pm
                                                                   Collapse Best guess Otaku-sempai 60 1 Jan 21, 3:20pm
                                                                       One final (I hope!) correction: Otaku-sempai 53 0 Jan 21, 4:26pm
                   I think it means the last lunar cycle. Elizabeth 162 0 Jan 19, 1:30am
       Collapse I don't know whether it's an error or not... But... leonmuse 307 4 Jan 18, 6:56pm
           Collapse Aaargh! Otaku-sempai 286 2 Jan 18, 7:00pm
               Collapse Don't worry about it! leonmuse 274 1 Jan 18, 7:03pm
                   As an Aquarius, Double Gemini W/ a Full Moon Bombadil 266 0 Jan 18, 7:11pm
           It's been corrected. dernwyn 251 0 Jan 18, 7:48pm
       Collapse I think Tolkien would have known enough astronomy to realise ... DanielLB 269 4 Jan 18, 7:45pm
           Collapse Are you sure that's right? AshNazg 243 3 Jan 18, 8:25pm
               The full moon is opposite the sun. Elizabeth 179 0 Jan 19, 12:56am
               Collapse Earth casting shadow swordwhale 205 1 Jan 19, 4:11am
                   As the moon passes quarter moon and heads shadowdog 203 0 Jan 19, 4:22am
       Collapse Maybe things work differently in Middle Earth... HeWhoArisesinMight 166 2 Jan 19, 1:31am
           What is Myth? Otaku-sempai 153 0 Jan 19, 2:53am
           As the moon wanes and approaches the new moon shadowdog 223 0 Jan 19, 3:20am
       Dwarven New Year and Durin's Day (final thoughts) Otaku-sempai 29 0 Jan 23, 2:35pm

  Collapse Re-Visiting the Golden Statue Bombadil 1477 164 Jan 18, 1:22pm Jump to last post in thread (by Michelle Johnston)
       Collapse I think SafeUnderHill 735 23 Jan 18, 1:24pm
           Collapse Where is That ?in the commentaries.. Bombadil 677 22 Jan 18, 1:29pm
               Collapse Disc 2 of the commentary SafeUnderHill 673 21 Jan 18, 1:39pm
                 Collapse Thang you Berry Buch...goes to grab disc..// Bombadil 626 1 Jan 18, 1:41pm
                     OP Typo Boo-Boo? Bombadil 613 0 Jan 18, 2:23pm
                   Collapse Boyens can try to explain it... Morthoron 626 18 Jan 18, 3:53pm
                       Collapse You can try and slag it off as much as you want SafeUnderHill 600 14 Jan 18, 4:03pm
                           I liked it Glorfindela 555 0 Jan 18, 4:13pm
                           Collapse You can tow the company line all you wish... Morthoron 577 12 Jan 18, 4:19pm
                               Actually... SafeUnderHill 554 0 Jan 18, 4:23pm
                               Collapse I don't think anybody's towing anybody's line... dormouse 511 9 Jan 18, 5:02pm
                                   Collapse division balbo biggins 491 7 Jan 18, 5:14pm
                                       Collapse The statue was not. arithmancer 494 2 Jan 18, 5:16pm
                                           Collapse yes balbo biggins 470 1 Jan 18, 5:30pm
                                               He wasn't, was he? arithmancer 464 0 Jan 18, 5:35pm
                                       Collapse Well, no one could hope for the scene beforehand.... dormouse 473 3 Jan 18, 5:35pm
                                           Collapse yes they could. balbo biggins 349 1 Jan 18, 6:11pm
                                               "How was the film?" "Everything in it was predictable." Spriggan 235 0 Jan 18, 10:37pm
                                           Alan Lee swordwhale 314 0 Jan 19, 4:18am
                                   There are a FEW Reasons that the Statue Bombadil 372 0 Jan 18, 5:46pm
                               I would merely like to point out Gwytha 363 0 Jan 18, 5:57pm
                       Collapse I can see... arithmancer 531 2 Jan 18, 4:20pm
                           Collapse I love the symbolism in this sequence too glor 457 1 Jan 18, 5:43pm
                               This is a good point! arithmancer 338 0 Jan 18, 6:13pm
       Collapse was it a statue? balbo biggins 535 4 Jan 18, 4:29pm
           Collapse It is a bell. arithmancer 529 3 Jan 18, 4:34pm
               yes balbo biggins 498 0 Jan 18, 4:42pm
               Collapse It's also there 5 seconds before they charge out the gate... Bofur01 509 1 Jan 18, 4:49pm
                   Not hard to imagine... arithmancer 478 0 Jan 18, 5:14pm
       Collapse Thank you Bomby Old Toby 475 1 Jan 18, 5:14pm
           YOU are Thrice Welcome..TOBY...&, &, &, Bombadil 332 0 Jan 18, 6:16pm
       I had issues with it. Ham_Sammy 331 0 Jan 18, 7:12pm
       Collapse My problem with it Bishop 326 17 Jan 18, 7:54pm
           The way he does... arithmancer 295 0 Jan 18, 8:47pm
           Collapse And... BlackFox 290 13 Jan 18, 8:57pm
               Collapse I know this is fantasy Bishop 267 12 Jan 18, 9:51pm
                 Collapse If that's the case... BlackFox 245 9 Jan 18, 10:14pm
                       Collapse Not at all! Bishop 236 8 Jan 18, 10:26pm
                           Collapse I understand where you're coming from BlackFox 220 7 Jan 18, 10:41pm
                               Collapse You know, the first time I saw it Bishop 213 6 Jan 18, 10:54pm
                                   Collapse Again, I see your reasoning... BlackFox 202 1 Jan 18, 11:07pm
                                       No, I get you Bishop 192 0 Jan 18, 11:14pm
                                   It seems to me... Silverlode 195 0 Jan 18, 11:14pm
                                   But it didn't achieve nothing - don't you see? dormouse 193 0 Jan 18, 11:29pm
                                   The purpose was to show how virtually indestructible Smaug was... glor 315 0 Jan 19, 3:37am
                                   Gold coating Xylla 202 0 Jan 20, 6:19am
                   Collapse A desperate plan, with much that could have gone wrong, but what's so odd about that? Spriggan 210 1 Jan 18, 10:41pm
                       Throughout the Book Bombadil 201 0 Jan 18, 11:05pm
           Collapse Yes, "We have to be standing Lissuin 271 1 Jan 18, 9:32pm
               yes. Absolutely anything with no limits always makes total sense. Bishop 260 0 Jan 18, 9:52pm
       Golden Statue was very Dragonesque moments squiggle 202 0 Jan 18, 11:21pm
       Collapse I still love this scene Noria 164 3 Jan 19, 1:48am
           Collapse I agree mostly Ham_Sammy 311 2 Jan 19, 4:02pm
               Collapse Thorin's plan could have doomed Middle Earth... Brandybuckled 308 1 Jan 19, 4:38pm
                   maybe Ham_Sammy 295 0 Jan 19, 4:44pm
       Collapse that statue was dumb jtarkey 329 3 Jan 19, 3:55am
           Collapse Your technically correct ha ha Michelle Johnston 313 2 Jan 19, 4:41am
             Collapse Correction? The Idea was Alan Lee's...idea Bombadil 308 1 Jan 19, 5:33am
                   The tall thin one !! Michelle Johnston 280 0 Jan 19, 7:02am
       Collapse As with the vast majority of Jackson's fan fiction scenes... Gurtholfin 339 83 Jan 19, 5:00am
           That is Your Opinion..NOT a Fact.// Bombadil 290 0 Jan 19, 5:36am
           Collapse As with the vast majority of "Tolkien Scholars"... moreorless 330 12 Jan 19, 5:39am
               Right on moreorless! Bombadil 302 0 Jan 19, 5:50am
               Collapse Well said! NecromancerRising 294 9 Jan 19, 6:37am
                   Collapse Nihilism, Control and Replacement Creationism. Michelle Johnston 278 6 Jan 19, 7:46am
                       Collapse Insightful as always your posts are always very good, ElendilTheShort 244 1 Jan 19, 8:29am
                           Dragons & Treasure Negative Ownership Michelle Johnston 225 0 Jan 19, 9:00am
                       Collapse I am not sure i agree with you NecromancerRising 251 2 Jan 19, 8:33am
                           Collapse Water get yourself in that cool clear water Michelle Johnston 231 1 Jan 19, 9:14am
                               Really Michelle, NecromancerRising 224 0 Jan 19, 9:41am
                       I actually felt the film focus more on control/arrogance, on both sides... moreorless 189 0 Jan 19, 11:22am
                   Collapse I think theres a difference between disliking the films and disrespecting there intensions.. moreorless 262 1 Jan 19, 8:03am
                       Yes. NecromancerRising 243 0 Jan 19, 8:26am
               good storytelling? FernysApple 246 0 Jan 19, 7:07pm
           Collapse Crumbs - I've never been called the 'lowest common denominator' before... dormouse 248 68 Jan 19, 9:05am
               Add another one to that NecromancerRising 210 0 Jan 19, 9:44am
               Collapse Is there any space left on the lowest common denominator bench? Starling 193 1 Jan 19, 10:24am
                   You're welcome! I'm sure we can squeeze up a bit... // dormouse 180 0 Jan 19, 11:04am
               Collapse Not to mention Voronwë_the_Faithful 369 59 Jan 19, 1:27pm
                   A little perplexed by the "scholars" nomenclature, myself. Spriggan 353 0 Jan 19, 1:33pm
                   And you are all an ornament to the company! dormouse 339 0 Jan 19, 1:51pm
                   Collapse It was somewhat of a joking comeback BUT... moreorless 293 56 Jan 19, 5:15pm
                       Collapse I am indeed dismissive of Jackson's fan-fiction... Morthoron 248 55 Jan 19, 7:16pm
                           So... Bishop 237 0 Jan 19, 7:27pm
                           Collapse Speaking of brick walls Spriggan 233 53 Jan 19, 7:40pm
                               Collapse Tell you what... Morthoron 220 52 Jan 19, 7:53pm
                                   Collapse Such lists show no correlation to how literal they are. Spriggan 183 51 Jan 19, 8:22pm
                                       Collapse But it does show... Morthoron 178 50 Jan 19, 8:31pm
                                           Collapse Not at all. Spriggan 177 49 Jan 19, 8:41pm
                                               Collapse Do mean "literal" here Bishop 160 48 Jan 19, 9:02pm
                                                   Collapse No - just as a comparative. Spriggan 148 47 Jan 19, 9:15pm
                                                       Collapse I guess I'm not sure what you mean then Bishop 142 46 Jan 19, 9:22pm
                                                           Collapse Well I was thinking of things other than names Spriggan 134 45 Jan 19, 9:32pm
                                                               Collapse Names, places, themes, physical descriptions, events Bishop 332 44 Jan 19, 9:43pm
                                                                   Collapse Oh not at all on most of those. Spriggan 325 43 Jan 19, 10:00pm
                                                                       Collapse Sorry, you lost me there! Bishop 296 42 Jan 19, 11:49pm
                                                                           Collapse I'm not sure what "pinned down" means. Spriggan 171 41 Jan 20, 12:51pm
                                                                               Collapse You are like a dancing word man Bishop 125 38 Jan 20, 5:34pm
  Collapse Odd charge Spriggan 113 37 Jan 20, 5:58pm
       Collapse This is what I mean by "Dancing word man" Bishop 105 36 Jan 20, 6:06pm
           Collapse "Were my examples exact? The broad strokes" Spriggan 102 35 Jan 20, 6:25pm
               Collapse I'm sure the mods are about to come in and shut this down. Bishop 102 34 Jan 20, 6:33pm
                   Collapse More likely... arithmancer 88 4 Jan 20, 6:56pm
                       Collapse Or as John Howe once said.... dormouse 84 3 Jan 20, 7:09pm
                           Collapse And yet in your example Bishop 82 2 Jan 20, 7:20pm
                               Collapse But it will be a particular cup.... dormouse 197 1 Jan 20, 7:53pm
                                   Here's what I mean by my last sentence Bishop 190 0 Jan 20, 8:04pm
                   Collapse Hopefully not - it's an interesting discussion. Spriggan 180 28 Jan 20, 8:54pm
                       Collapse Well as long as there are others involved! Bishop 173 26 Jan 20, 9:21pm
                           Collapse Your door must have extra qualities. Spriggan 168 25 Jan 20, 9:41pm
                               Collapse In reality the door will have extra qualities Bishop 155 24 Jan 20, 10:04pm
                                   Collapse I'm saying that you can't exactly replicate something with missing qualities. Spriggan 138 23 Jan 20, 11:28pm
                                       Collapse Hold up a sec Bishop 134 22 Jan 20, 11:34pm
                                           Collapse Take it both ways if the answer would be different. Spriggan 126 21 Jan 20, 11:48pm
                                               Collapse Well ok Bishop 122 20 Jan 20, 11:56pm
                                                   Collapse Are you suggesting that they don't? Spriggan 121 19 Jan 21, 12:07am
                                                       Collapse Exactly according to who? Bishop 118 18 Jan 21, 12:10am
                                                           Collapse Also, is "Exact" simply an abstraction to you? Bishop 119 17 Jan 21, 12:12am
                                                               Collapse I think they are sort of the same question. Spriggan 116 16 Jan 21, 12:19am
                                                                   Collapse OK Bishop 114 15 Jan 21, 12:26am
                                                                       Collapse I'm more than happy with visible to the naked eye! Spriggan 111 14 Jan 21, 12:44am
                                                                           Collapse No it's worse than that Bishop 109 13 Jan 21, 12:48am
                                                                               Collapse If it's noticeably different then no. Spriggan 105 12 Jan 21, 12:55am
  Collapse Nowhere fast! Bishop 101 11 Jan 21, 1:19am
       Collapse It's not arbitrary... arithmancer 94 10 Jan 21, 1:35am
           Collapse Here is one of the things said about the impossibility of something being exact Bishop 91 9 Jan 21, 1:48am
               Collapse So is this one... arithmancer 85 8 Jan 21, 1:53am
                   Collapse You didn't answer the question though Bishop 85 7 Jan 21, 1:56am
                       Collapse Because we have made any number of choices Spriggan 64 6 Jan 21, 9:01am
                           Collapse I'll be damned! Bishop 108 5 Jan 21, 6:51pm
                               Collapse Ha - I don't dare tell you that I haven't said otherwise! Spriggan 98 4 Jan 21, 9:37pm
                                   Collapse Didn't you say Bishop 90 3 Jan 21, 9:43pm
                                       Collapse Give or take yes. Spriggan 89 2 Jan 21, 10:01pm
                                           Collapse Oh, ok dancing words man! Bishop 88 1 Jan 21, 10:12pm
                                               I thought we'd already covered this. Spriggan 83 0 Jan 21, 10:26pm
                       To shift this to a more direct examples in the films moreorless 64 0 Jan 21, 8:22am
                                                                               Collapse I'll have to disagree with you in several respects.... Morthoron 120 1 Jan 20, 5:56pm
  Sigh. Have you actually read the thread? Spriggan 113 0 Jan 20, 6:09pm
               Me Too smtfhw 338 0 Jan 19, 2:03pm
               Add me to the group of LCDs! Old Toby 206 0 Jan 19, 7:58pm
             Collapse Where do I sign up? // BlackFox 194 2 Jan 19, 8:04pm
                 Collapse Looks Like Bomby Bombadil 196 1 Jan 19, 8:19pm
                       After spending 20 years as an enlisted man, Meneldor 334 0 Jan 19, 9:58pm
       Collapse Ugh that scene....Totally fails in the three movie arc. Arannir 194 14 Jan 19, 12:42pm
           Collapse Just wanted to say thats where I am. Michelle Johnston 281 13 Jan 19, 6:09pm
               Collapse Michelle, I respect your view, and Arannir's, but I couldn't disagree more.... dormouse 251 7 Jan 19, 7:43pm
                   Collapse I agree with dormouse Noria 282 1 Jan 20, 1:24am
                       My Cup Has Been Runneth Over Michelle Johnston 62 0 Jan 22, 8:39am
                   Thanks D M Michelle Johnston 208 0 Jan 20, 7:02am
                   Collapse The impossible challenge of Hobbiton to Rivendell Michelle Johnston 67 3 Jan 22, 8:20am
                       Collapse Hello Michelle, and many thanks for the detailed reply..... dormouse 47 2 Jan 22, 10:04am
                           Looking at the "Out of the FryingPan" scene Eleniel 45 0 Jan 22, 11:18am
                           Two Film Theory Michelle Johnston 37 0 Jan 22, 6:05pm
               Collapse I do not think AUJ is the problem. glor 274 1 Jan 20, 2:05am
                   The 13 or is 8 Michelle Johnston 64 0 Jan 22, 8:30am
               Collapse I think the statue is actually key to understanding why Jackson desided on three films moreorless 244 2 Jan 20, 5:22am
                   I'd like to cheer this post! dormouse 199 0 Jan 20, 8:31am
                   *mods up* BlackFox 160 0 Jan 20, 1:55pm
       The statue was ridiculous. Bumblingidiot 248 0 Jan 20, 4:08am
       Collapse Where is the statue, anyways? Bishop 242 1 Jan 20, 4:32am
           Yes so much Ham_Sammy 161 0 Jan 20, 2:08pm
       Collapse Still like it Elessar 128 2 Jan 21, 2:09pm
           Collapse Yes but that point need not be made again Michelle Johnston 59 1 Jan 22, 8:51am
               I guess Elessar 41 0 Jan 22, 12:08pm

  Collapse Questions that need answering...regarding the soundtrack. FrogmortonJustice65 725 9 Jan 18, 6:30am Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Right, I'm musically ignorant too, but I'll give it a go... Bofur01 335 0 Jan 18, 10:14am
       . SafeUnderHill 286 0 Jan 18, 12:01pm
       Collapse I'm a soundtrack guy and musician! Bishop 200 6 Jan 18, 8:26pm
           Bard has 4 themes :p Bofur01 191 0 Jan 18, 8:31pm
           Collapse That is an interesting theory. FrogmortonJustice65 169 4 Jan 18, 8:33pm
               Collapse I think soundtracks are fascinating Bishop 173 3 Jan 18, 8:50pm
                   Collapse I agree. FrogmortonJustice65 154 2 Jan 18, 9:23pm
                       Collapse Listened to the Complete FotR today.. ponybarfly 45 1 Jan 20, 12:41pm
                           But that's you really and not the music, isn't it.... dormouse 45 0 Jan 20, 1:38pm

  Collapse This video had more location shots than the whole BOTFA movie... elvish.mafia 965 5 Jan 18, 2:58am Jump to last post in thread (by SafeUnderHill)
       Collapse Tha'ts the most awesome safety video-- elentari3018 351 1 Jan 18, 5:55am
           Well Starling 328 0 Jan 18, 6:39am
       Collapse I wish SafeUnderHill 263 2 Jan 18, 12:03pm
           Collapse Well, there is only one significant battle.... dormouse 264 1 Jan 18, 12:22pm
               I fully understand why there isn't more SafeUnderHill 228 0 Jan 18, 1:19pm

  Collapse The acorn Donkay2200 1042 19 Jan 17, 11:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by Gianna)
       Collapse According to the Official Movie Guide Beorn's Bees 651 1 Jan 17, 11:53pm
           Yes, and this from Jude Fisher's Visual Companion: Eleniel 220 0 Jan 18, 8:21pm
       Collapse Unfortunately can't happen... AshNazg 554 2 Jan 18, 12:20am
           yes Ham_Sammy 445 0 Jan 18, 12:59am
           but if you notice the tree in BOFA when we comes back looks as if its sick because has no leaves in one side and looks pale Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 287 0 Jan 18, 11:00am
       Collapse I thought that was the acorn that becomes the party tree ghost_matt 464 9 Jan 18, 12:40am
           Collapse Here 's a cute series of cartoons ShireHorse 518 8 Jan 18, 12:47am
               Collapse SHIREHORSE you made bomby cry... Bombadil 421 6 Jan 18, 1:23am
                   Collapse Does anyone know... ecthelionsbeard 461 3 Jan 18, 1:24am
                       Collapse That was Andy Serkis in mo-cap Old Toby 419 2 Jan 18, 1:26am
                           He deserves the Oscar I say! Barrow-Wight 365 0 Jan 18, 2:49am
                           Wow, that guy can do anything! // Kim 304 0 Jan 18, 7:46am
                   Collapse Me too, darnit! Kim 328 1 Jan 18, 7:45am
                     Me too...*sniff* // mae govannen 297 0 Jan 18, 8:49am
               argh! swordwhale 125 0 Jan 19, 4:23am
       Collapse Yes, it's a lovely idea... dormouse 331 2 Jan 18, 9:17am
           Dormouse is correct. Bumblingidiot 88 0 Jan 19, 6:14pm
           Though... arithmancer 56 0 Jan 20, 1:50am
       I want that to be true so much Gianna 64 0 Jan 20, 2:17am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 951 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.