Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 5 of 924 (331026 posts in 13854 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 924 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Hostility to this trilogy in the media MatthewJer18 1306 27 Sun, 2:11am Jump to last post in thread (by hobbitylass)
       Collapse Don't let them bother you. Aragorn the Elfstone 663 1 Sun, 2:17am
           I agree with this hobbitylass 46 0 Sun, 11:05pm
       I have found that a lot of the more negative reviews are busy comparing them to LOTR Old Toby 534 0 Sun, 4:33am
       I'm getting the same feeling as you do mae govannen 476 0 Sun, 5:37am
       Most of the reviewers mefansmum 501 0 Sun, 5:41am
       Collapse Increasingly its the nature of criticism I would say... moreorless 516 9 Sun, 5:47am
           Collapse Very well said Old Toby 438 5 Sun, 6:28am
               Collapse The problem I would say is confusing expectation with quality... moreorless 423 4 Sun, 7:36am
                   Collapse Hm... zalmoxis 331 3 Sun, 9:56am
                       Collapse I would say judge everything by a similar standard moreorless 303 2 Sun, 11:00am
                           Collapse Agreed,... zalmoxis 281 1 Sun, 11:24am
                               I think both can be "done well" though... moreorless 235 0 Sun, 1:18pm
           Collapse Yes, this is true Glorfindela 358 1 Sun, 9:28am
               The end result to me seems to be fewer interesting opinions not more... moreorless 292 0 Sun, 11:06am
           Yes, I've found this, too Glorfindela 170 0 Sun, 3:49pm
       Collapse I think you guys are going to deep... Avnar 489 3 Sun, 6:29am
           Collapse I just don't understand it... AshNazg 369 2 Sun, 10:28am
             *snicker*..*snicker* Bomby getzz.. it! quietly ..NOW? AshNag... Bombadil 330 0 Sun, 10:53am
               It's... zalmoxis 336 0 Sun, 10:54am
       Collapse It's true... Arvida 360 4 Sun, 10:07am
           Collapse To some degree I think Lucas's Starwars Prequals created a desire for something similar moreorless 162 3 Sun, 4:40pm
               Collapse Another one Ham_Sammy 141 2 Sun, 5:16pm
                   I think he's a great example of what I was posting about earlier in the thread.. moreorless 123 0 Sun, 5:42pm
                   Yes Glorfindela 82 0 Sun, 5:43pm
       Collapse Media love winding people up, it's how they get hits/sell papers sycorax82 202 1 Sun, 3:24pm
           Well Glorfindela 174 0 Sun, 3:50pm
       The problem is that many of them are impostors, not trained film critics Elarie 85 0 Sun, 6:10pm

  Collapse Gandalf and Bilbo's last conversation is in the wrong order... AshNazg 839 8 Sun, 1:39am Jump to last post in thread (by Aragorn the Elfstone)
       This is another example of the messiness of the trilogy... sycorax82 395 0 Sun, 3:44am
       Collapse Gandalf's last line... Aragorn the Elfstone 397 4 Sun, 3:48am
           Collapse Nope AshNazg 213 3 Sun, 9:12am
               Collapse Well, I'm not going to argue... Aragorn the Elfstone 91 2 Sun, 5:14pm
                   Collapse He's not in frame when previously stood close either... AshNazg 55 1 Sun, 8:11pm
                       Stalemate Aragorn the Elfstone 57 0 Sun, 8:13pm
       Collapse Just because it's different doesn't mean it's 'out of order' DigificWriter 62 1 Sun, 7:59pm
           I didn't mean out of order from the book... AshNazg 55 0 Sun, 8:06pm

  Collapse Top Ten Scenes of The Hobbit Trilogy Elutherian 756 11 Sun, 1:38am Jump to last post in thread (by grimbeorn15)
       Collapse 10 Ham_Sammy 430 2 Sun, 2:18am
           Collapse Here's mine KingTurgon 317 1 Sun, 4:23am
               Same here :D Spalko 244 0 Sun, 6:11am
     13..?.. THUMBS UP fur THAT..TOTALLY..OP!!...// Bombadil 329 0 Sun, 3:04am
       Collapse My Top 15 Favorite Scenes (divided by movie) DigificWriter 351 1 Sun, 4:04am
           Following that route. moreorless 101 0 Sun, 5:17pm
       Top 10 is a 14 - mostly Thorin Kilidoescartwheels 264 0 Sun, 6:31am
       Ten favorite! Peterthorn of Rohan 196 0 Sun, 10:37am
       In no particular order and off the top of my head: Nira 84 0 Sun, 5:48pm
       I just can't do it Glorfindela 85 0 Sun, 5:49pm
       Top 10 grimbeorn15 82 0 Sun, 6:05pm

  Collapse Tauriel/Kili Appreciation... Laineth 605 25 Sun, 1:08am Jump to last post in thread (by marillaraina)
       Collapse Well if you're going to have an elf/dwarf romance, Ataahua 394 2 Sun, 2:05am
           Yes! tarasaurus 336 0 Sun, 2:41am
           Oh, Ataahua!... I had no idea mae govannen 286 0 Sun, 5:08am
       Collapse Hi marillaraina 352 1 Sun, 2:07am
           Agreed. BalrogTrainer 297 0 Sun, 3:39am
       Collapse I love these two DigificWriter 311 12 Sun, 3:46am
           Ditto, ditto, ditto... I love those two!!! mae govannen 282 0 Sun, 5:05am
           Collapse Are you sure you were watching the same film as me? Eleniel 251 10 Sun, 7:52am
               Collapse Let me clarify what i meant DigificWriter 247 8 Sun, 7:59am
                   Collapse I think that is a matter of interpretation... Eleniel 240 7 Sun, 8:05am
                       Collapse He was already intent... arithmancer 178 6 Sun, 2:36pm
                           Collapse Hmmm - yes. I'm not sure Spriggan 167 5 Sun, 2:51pm
                               Collapse No one is suggesting that he would have run away... Eleniel 160 4 Sun, 3:09pm
                                   Collapse Well, they were there to remove the leadership. Spriggan 140 3 Sun, 4:32pm
                                       Collapse subject marillaraina 100 2 Sun, 6:04pm
                                           Collapse Other way around :) Cirashala 29 1 8:54am
                                               subject marillaraina 2 0 30 mins ago
               subject marillaraina 106 0 Sun, 5:49pm
       Collapse subject marillaraina 307 1 Sun, 5:07am
           Beautifully said! Agree with you...// mae govannen 281 0 Sun, 5:10am
     Re: PWOKristy 285 0 Sun, 5:32am
       Collapse Just posting to say... arithmancer 165 1 Sun, 3:36pm
           subject marillaraina 105 0 Sun, 6:02pm
       I love Tauriel and I love Kili and I love their friendship...just not their romance // Nira 103 0 Sun, 5:53pm
       Tauriel/Kili Appreciation... Ilmatar 81 0 Sun, 8:58pm

  Collapse Question about Bofur& James Nesbitt? erdildeniz 554 5 Sun, 12:25am Jump to last post in thread (by DjU)
       PJ doesn't care about the dwarfs anymore Azaghâl 301 0 Sun, 12:50am
       That's not the purpose of the credits or the marketing. Spriggan 286 0 Sun, 12:54am
       Collapse I'm thinking he must be in more of the EE tarasaurus 228 1 Sun, 2:43am
           Over 9 Months ago DjU 27 0 Sun, 11:13pm
       There is a definitely a scene missing that MF said was filmed with Bofur... Eleniel 176 0 Sun, 7:54am

  Collapse scenes I loved in BOFA, spoilers. shaundobson 448 1 Sun, 12:13am Jump to last post in thread (by Gianna)
       My favourite part Gianna 73 0 Sun, 3:40pm

  Collapse Dain Ironfoot MedwedtoBeorn 888 10 Sat, 10:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elentari03)
       Collapse Liked Connolly's performance... Salmacis81 466 1 Sat, 11:09pm
           Still hoping... BalrogTrainer 251 0 Sun, 3:12am
       Totally agree! Thrain II 396 0 Sat, 11:10pm
       Collapse I like most of Dain's scenes Carne 402 3 Sat, 11:19pm
           Collapse The headbutting Ham_Sammy 406 1 Sat, 11:22pm
               favorites MedwedtoBeorn 341 0 Sat, 11:34pm
           yeah deskp 316 0 Sat, 11:44pm
       Collapse I loved Dain! Old Toby 206 2 Sun, 4:18am
           Dain having woven boar tusks into his beard was a nice touch DigificWriter 209 0 Sun, 4:24am
           Yes! :) Elentari03 181 0 Sun, 5:31am

  Collapse Did Legolas love Tauriel? Kilidoescartwheels 921 19 Sat, 9:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by Laineth)
       Collapse Doesn't Legolas say to Thranduil... Eleniel 574 5 Sat, 9:50pm
           Collapse May not be romantic love SirDennisC 459 3 Sat, 10:31pm
               Collapse Agreed. cats16 411 1 Sat, 10:42pm
                 Something to Consider..? Bombadil 368 0 Sat, 11:18pm
               I thought the same D. Brethil 105 0 Sun, 5:30pm
           Agree totally with you, Eleniel/ mae govannen 217 0 Sun, 3:32am
       Re: Did Legolas love Tauriel? DigificWriter 473 0 Sat, 9:59pm
       Collapse I think he loved her Cirashala 488 1 Sat, 10:02pm
           You have spoken for me too!... mae govannen 207 0 Sun, 4:32am
       Collapse He is in love with gimli mirkwoodwanderer 442 2 Sat, 10:34pm
           Collapse Re: He is in love with Gimli DigificWriter 414 1 Sat, 10:41pm
               Well, not super serious, but it is free for all to fill in the blanks mirkwoodwanderer 92 0 Sun, 7:17pm
       Collapse No. Laineth 328 5 Sun, 12:52am
           Collapse But all you say shows his love for Tauriel in fact!!! // mae govannen 218 3 Sun, 4:40am
               Collapse Yes, Laineth 46 2 2:54am
                   Collapse True love respects the other person's choice, mae govannen 36 1 5:50am
                       I agree Laineth 10 0 5:25pm
           No love triangle Bluewriter 84 0 Sun, 10:24pm
       does PJ have a crush on Legolas ?? MouthofSauron 184 0 Sun, 9:43am

  Collapse Question about BOTFA... ecthelionsbeard 427 6 Sat, 9:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       It lets the audience know... Aragorn the Elfstone 239 0 Sat, 9:41pm
       Well it is to deliver that warning that Spriggan 212 0 Sat, 9:44pm
       Collapse they are eagles Cirashala 199 2 Sat, 10:15pm
           Plus Ham_Sammy 107 0 Sun, 12:17am
           All points very true...// mae govannen 60 0 Sun, 5:16am
       I liked the messiness of the battle. Bumblingidiot 37 0 Sun, 2:15pm

  Collapse Begging PJ for 48fps on Home Video... Aragorn the Elfstone 585 20 Sat, 7:28pm Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)
       Collapse I have still yet to see HFR, but... tsmith675 296 12 Sat, 7:34pm
           Collapse Just remember... Aragorn the Elfstone 281 8 Sat, 7:38pm
               Collapse HFR was great for the marathon. cats16 270 1 Sat, 7:50pm
                   Yes... Aragorn the Elfstone 251 0 Sat, 7:56pm
               Yes, it looked like you were watching thru a window, that's how real it looked hobbitylass 266 0 Sat, 7:57pm
               Collapse But it may not be jarring at all Glorfindela 130 4 Sat, 11:45pm
                   Collapse Yes, same here. Silverlode 88 3 Sun, 2:51am
                       And for some... cats16 83 0 Sun, 2:54am
                       Collapse Well, it's not that I didn't like it... Aragorn the Elfstone 82 1 Sun, 3:02am
                           While for me Silverlode 74 0 Sun, 3:59am
           Also... Aragorn the Elfstone 264 0 Sat, 7:46pm
           Choice of seat for 48HFR Lissuin 199 0 Sat, 9:32pm
           BOTFA has finally converted me to HFR Elarie 145 0 Sat, 11:22pm
       Collapse I'm pretty desperate for WB to at least release the trailer AshNazg 176 4 Sat, 10:33pm
           Yes Aragorn the Elfstone 169 0 Sat, 10:37pm
           Collapse I remember seeing this a while back on YouTube actually... Misty Mountain Hop 129 2 Sun, 12:24am
               Collapse That's just... Aragorn the Elfstone 123 1 Sun, 12:28am
                   Yeah that's what I figured. Misty Mountain Hop 114 0 Sun, 12:36am
       Collapse I doubt 4K UHD will support 48fps TheHutt 159 1 Sat, 11:17pm
           Actually it will. Aragorn the Elfstone 140 0 Sun, 12:04am

  Collapse Biggest Laugh in Cinema HelmHammerHand 1256 16 Sat, 6:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Collapse Lots macfalk 660 1 Sat, 7:01pm
           We had laughter Ham_Sammy 453 0 Sat, 8:47pm
       Probably... BlackFox 596 0 Sat, 7:03pm
       By far, thunderously loud.. ~Medieval Soul 639 0 Sat, 7:19pm
       Collapse None in my theater hobbitylass 577 2 Sat, 7:32pm
           Collapse Different perspectives on humour perhaps? HelmHammerHand 524 1 Sat, 7:36pm
               Maybe hobbitylass 480 0 Sat, 7:53pm
       One of the... CathrineB 460 0 Sat, 8:32pm
       I laughed out loud a few times... Pipe Dream 479 0 Sat, 8:34pm
       agreed completely Cirashala 404 0 Sat, 9:22pm
       Dain's language raised a few chortles Greenwood Hobbit 370 0 Sat, 10:16pm
       Collapse "Yish." cats16 334 1 Sat, 10:38pm
           when the big troll Fichtenbrenner 299 0 Sat, 11:02pm
       UK audience - i think i heard one or two sensible chuckles Crunchable Birdses 292 0 Sat, 11:17pm
       In Paris European Premiere... TheHutt 299 0 Sat, 11:19pm
       In my cinema Glorfindela 268 0 Sat, 11:37pm

  Collapse War in the North yannischatzi 860 26 Sat, 6:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by yannischatzi)
       Collapse "Interquels" are a tricky thing DigificWriter 427 3 Sat, 6:55pm
           Collapse Flashback yannischatzi 383 2 Sat, 7:06pm
               Collapse That might work DigificWriter 367 1 Sat, 7:12pm
                   Galadriel's? yannischatzi 327 0 Sat, 7:40pm
       Collapse I think that would work better as a videogame personally malickfan 386 8 Sat, 6:59pm
           Collapse Emmerich's statement doesnt mean much DigificWriter 376 7 Sat, 7:03pm
               Collapse True malickfan 342 6 Sat, 7:14pm
                   Collapse As far as I know... DigificWriter 339 4 Sat, 7:21pm
                       Collapse Actually the 2012 lawsuit in still ongoing malickfan 341 3 Sat, 7:27pm
                           Collapse Re: Actually the 2012 lawsuit in still ongoing DigificWriter 325 1 Sat, 7:36pm
                               Yes... malickfan 301 0 Sat, 7:45pm
                           Irony sharku 295 0 Sat, 7:52pm
                   Ask me in 2 years time... yannischatzi 293 0 Sat, 7:48pm
       Collapse I suppose the question is what would the story be? Spriggan 313 8 Sat, 7:44pm
           Collapse Three story arcs: Lothlorien, Mirkwood, Battle of Dale yannischatzi 322 7 Sat, 7:54pm
               Collapse Well, they are backdrops Spriggan 279 6 Sat, 8:16pm
                   Collapse The story could be yannischatzi 267 5 Sat, 8:35pm
                       Collapse Re: the story could be DigificWriter 260 2 Sat, 8:39pm
                           Collapse Of course you are right yannischatzi 241 1 Sat, 8:53pm
                               i have to disagree DigificWriter 238 0 Sat, 8:59pm
                       Collapse I'm probably not explaining awfully well. Spriggan 236 1 Sat, 9:10pm
                           All in favor say YEAH mirkwoodwanderer 182 0 Sat, 10:41pm
       Given the way Jackson's LotR Trilogy ends... DigificWriter 329 0 Sat, 8:19pm
       So they don't have to overstrech stories Hobbity Hobbit 184 0 Sat, 11:02pm
       Collapse There is also "The search... patrickk 88 1 Sun, 4:35am
           I just think yannischatzi 51 0 Sun, 11:06am

Collapse People attracted to Azog... NateGate 908 14 Sat, 6:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by glor)
       Collapse They have Manu Bennett NecromancerRising 523 3 Sat, 6:32pm
           Collapse I think Manu Bennett would be offended MouthofSauron 477 2 Sat, 6:35pm
               Collapse Sure,but i never implied NecromancerRising 419 1 Sat, 6:49pm
                   I'm a fan of his voice MouthofSauron 171 0 Sun, 12:44am
       Collapse Rule 43. // cats16 489 4 Sat, 6:33pm
           Collapse 34... NateGate 490 3 Sat, 6:34pm
             Collapse Ack yes, 34! // cats16 434 2 Sat, 6:39pm
                   Collapse I may regret asking Cirashala 288 1 Sat, 10:58pm
                       PM'ing you. // cats16 260 0 Sat, 11:01pm
       Collapse You are not alone. Gianna 258 2 Sat, 11:25pm
           Collapse That's not all.... NateGate 217 1 Sun, 12:08am
               Well, just another 'Shade of Gray' mae govannen 125 0 Sun, 4:51am
       He's a sexy looking orc...he's got the bad-boy thing going on... Crunchable Birdses 257 0 Sat, 11:30pm
       Whatever next! glor 117 0 Sun, 5:52am

  Collapse Addressing some of the concerns about the plot nhui06 702 8 Sat, 6:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Radagast... Aragorn the Elfstone 331 0 Sat, 6:35pm
       Collapse I hope someone else directs any new Middle-earth films.... Bladerunner 297 2 Sat, 7:18pm
           Collapse Born of Hope sharku 258 1 Sat, 8:00pm
               Born of Hope priell3 95 0 Sun, 3:12am
       Collapse Why would it seem disrespectful to show Dain being crowned King? Salmacis81 199 2 Sat, 10:59pm
           Don't worry, they won't Thrain II 188 0 Sat, 11:17pm
           Crowning MedwedtoBeorn 164 0 Sat, 11:30pm
       I'm rather in the middle with reguards the ending moreorless 76 0 Sun, 6:09am

  Collapse How I'd rewrite the White Council storyline HiddenSpring 487 7 Sat, 6:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by Girdle of Melian)
       Collapse Methinks you missed the wider thematic point of Tauriel's inclusion DigificWriter 209 2 Sat, 7:47pm
           Collapse I have no real opinion on Tauriel HiddenSpring 165 1 Sat, 8:17pm
               I never said she was inserted purely to counter Thranduil's isolationism DigificWriter 167 0 Sat, 8:21pm
       Since nobody so far has actually made comment on your version of the Dol Guldur events Radagast-Aiwendil 78 0 Sun, 11:03am
       Collapse Here's how I would have done it... AshNazg 77 1 Sun, 11:44am
           Well, since we are doing this..I am reposting (lol) with editing.. Girdle of Melian 44 0 Sun, 5:15pm
       I do like many of the details of your version... Salmacis81 61 0 Sun, 3:29pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 924 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.