Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 5 of 1001 (357904 posts in 15011 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1001 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Moved: James Nesbitt will play a Marvel superhero? Kilidoescartwheels - - Aug 18, 1:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)

  Collapse Kili's ruin stone... lionoferebor 914 22 Aug 18, 1:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Nuradar)
       Collapse an extra knife? Kilidoescartwheels 847 3 Aug 18, 1:18pm
           I'm not sure... lionoferebor 566 0 Aug 18, 6:37pm
           Collapse I like to imagine Elanor of Rohan 513 1 Aug 18, 7:58pm
               Well... Otaku-sempai 423 0 Aug 19, 12:17am
       Collapse No one cares about Fili ... Arandir 835 9 Aug 18, 1:27pm
           Collapse Come now... lionoferebor 742 6 Aug 18, 3:04pm
               Collapse Okay I give in ... Arandir 646 5 Aug 18, 5:01pm
                   Collapse Me too. Mooseboy018 638 2 Aug 18, 5:04pm
                       Collapse Please elaborate... lionoferebor 619 1 Aug 18, 5:33pm
                           "Kili!" Mooseboy018 575 0 Aug 18, 6:25pm
                   Collapse It bugs me too... lionoferebor 610 1 Aug 18, 5:44pm
                       EE Mooseboy018 572 0 Aug 18, 6:25pm
           Collapse LOL Avandel 698 1 Aug 18, 3:58pm
               Agreed Arandir 639 0 Aug 18, 5:04pm
       Collapse Whatever she gave Fili... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 704 1 Aug 18, 3:47pm
           LOL! I'm sure he would not too... lionoferebor 660 0 Aug 18, 4:43pm
       Collapse Kili's ruin stone... TheHutt 553 2 Aug 18, 6:58pm
           Collapse Rune stone Elizabeth 424 1 Aug 19, 12:27am
               Thank you shadowdog 282 0 Aug 19, 3:48pm
       Collapse What does the rune stone say anyway? Nuradar 262 2 Aug 19, 4:42pm
           Collapse The runes translate as.... dormouse 263 1 Aug 19, 4:49pm
               Thanks dormouse! // Nuradar 161 0 Aug 20, 12:03pm

  Collapse Why didn't they have Tauriel kill Bolg? Bishop 1203 39 Aug 18, 1:58am Jump to last post in thread (by RosieLass)
       Neither of them should have killed Bolg Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1118 0 Aug 18, 2:31am
       Collapse Right, since killing Bolg Lindele 1080 2 Aug 18, 3:03am
           Collapse Is that what I said? Bishop 1033 1 Aug 18, 4:04am
               Exactly. RosieLass 88 0 Aug 21, 6:40pm
       Collapse I agree... lionoferebor 1053 10 Aug 18, 3:32am
           Collapse So do I Glorfindela 846 9 Aug 18, 9:25am
               Collapse I'm sorry you agree with them! Bishop 724 8 Aug 18, 1:09pm
                   Collapse Maybe strong in a physical sense Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 578 6 Aug 18, 3:46pm
                       Collapse Well, OK.... dormouse 495 4 Aug 18, 6:00pm
                           Collapse I very much agree with your post Bishop 465 3 Aug 18, 6:26pm
                               Yes. Arannir 392 0 Aug 18, 7:06pm
                               Collapse OK, yes, that is a fair point.... dormouse 385 1 Aug 18, 7:09pm
                                   Tauriel is not finished. Milieuterrien 374 0 Aug 18, 7:32pm
                       I don't think she was trying to save Kili Kilidoescartwheels 369 0 Aug 18, 7:33pm
                   Agreed. Arannir 530 0 Aug 18, 5:04pm
       Collapse I think I actually would have preferred it. Mooseboy018 1005 5 Aug 18, 4:28am
           Collapse Yes, exactly Bishop 993 3 Aug 18, 4:44am
               Collapse Legolas Mooseboy018 973 2 Aug 18, 5:07am
                   Collapse Mission creep? Kilidoescartwheels 704 1 Aug 18, 1:25pm
                       Use of humour, a diversion Glorfindela 648 0 Aug 18, 2:23pm
           Plus, there's the fact that anyone even vaguely familiar with LotR knew that nothing was going to happen to Legolas. Imladris18 677 0 Aug 18, 1:45pm
       Collapse Tauriel wasn't easy to kill bolg because Milieuterrien 929 3 Aug 18, 6:45am
           Wow, hadn't thought of that Kilidoescartwheels 694 0 Aug 18, 1:32pm
           Collapse She lost her bow Otaku-sempai 685 1 Aug 18, 1:39pm
               Beorn vs Bolg Milieuterrien 618 0 Aug 18, 2:42pm
       Collapse Why would they? dormouse 877 1 Aug 18, 8:35am
           Gundabad Milieuterrien 753 0 Aug 18, 12:33pm
       Collapse Saving vs Avenging Kilidoescartwheels 677 1 Aug 18, 1:50pm
           to join the fellowship in 60 years Milieuterrien 638 0 Aug 18, 2:31pm
       Collapse Tauriel vs. Bolg: Best One-On-One Fight? DwellerInDale 272 9 Aug 20, 7:52am
           Excellent ! Milieuterrien 243 0 Aug 20, 9:59am
           Collapse Yes.... dormouse 234 3 Aug 20, 11:05am
               Collapse I'm not sure that t would have been any more unrealistic than Eowyn, say. Spriggan 194 2 Aug 20, 1:35pm
                   Collapse Well, OK, fair point.... dormouse 173 1 Aug 20, 2:35pm
                       Sure - we are probably saying similar things. Spriggan 167 0 Aug 20, 2:57pm
           Collapse I appreciate your analysis for sure Bishop 214 3 Aug 20, 12:20pm
               Collapse Separate Points DwellerInDale 149 2 Aug 20, 5:05pm
                   Dramatic vs physical Bishop 130 0 Aug 20, 6:18pm
                   Maybe i get a little partial because i do have a crunch on EL, but Milieuterrien 126 0 Aug 20, 6:26pm

Collapse Is the Chow dead ?! NoelGallagher 902 4 Aug 17, 12:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kim)
       Collapse I'm not sure what you are asking... lionoferebor 644 2 Aug 17, 5:23pm
           Collapse I think he means... Elizabeth 623 1 Aug 17, 5:47pm
               Yes,thats what i mean NoelGallagher 599 0 Aug 17, 5:57pm
       More like "indefinite hiatus" Kim 342 0 Aug 18, 3:33am

  Collapse Middle earth collection questions bilbo1997 1024 16 Aug 16, 11:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by TheHutt)
       Collapse Bilbo Glorfindela 979 9 Aug 16, 11:35pm
           Collapse no bilbo1997 970 8 Aug 16, 11:39pm
               Yes Glorfindela 963 0 Aug 16, 11:48pm
               Collapse No he won't Kilidoescartwheels 848 6 Aug 17, 3:21am
                   Collapse Really? Mooseboy018 840 5 Aug 17, 3:28am
                       Bilbo aragorn2015 822 0 Aug 17, 4:18am
                       Collapse Here does PJ discuss that bilbo1997 646 3 Aug 17, 12:06pm
                           Collapse commentary Mooseboy018 453 2 Aug 17, 6:23pm
                               Yes Jeffrodo 355 0 Aug 18, 12:28am
                               In the AUJ commentary... TheHutt 287 0 Aug 18, 6:49am
       Collapse I like Ian Holm's OldestDaughter 946 2 Aug 17, 12:00am
           Collapse I've seen it bilbo1997 937 1 Aug 17, 12:06am
               Brilliant! Timdalf 581 0 Aug 17, 1:57pm
       Yeah leonmuse 863 0 Aug 17, 3:00am
       My $0.02 TheHutt 766 0 Aug 17, 7:30am
       PJ isn't Geoege Lucas... adt100 469 0 Aug 17, 5:56pm

Collapse best Alfrid scene? DainPig 984 42 Aug 16, 11:23pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse in Dale bilbo1997 926 1 Aug 16, 11:29pm
           he also called him a vagabond Kilidoescartwheels 489 0 Aug 17, 1:30pm
       Collapse None Glorfindela 919 2 Aug 16, 11:32pm
           Collapse i agree bilbo1997 914 1 Aug 16, 11:42pm
             Arr – I second that. Glorfindela 906 0 Aug 16, 11:49pm
       I like the scene where Bard... QuackingTroll 903 0 Aug 16, 11:52pm
       Collapse Alfrid in a dress! OldestDaughter 891 1 Aug 16, 11:57pm
           DoS EE Mooseboy018 844 0 Aug 17, 1:31am
       The one he had in AUJ lionoferebor 885 0 Aug 17, 12:07am
       he started... balbo biggins 865 0 Aug 17, 12:30am
       POINTY HAT! Mooseboy018 846 0 Aug 17, 1:28am
       l third that, Adrianna 820 0 Aug 17, 2:17am
       The one in which... arithmancer 817 0 Aug 17, 2:17am
       Collapse I like how it was Alfrid Bishop 799 1 Aug 17, 2:53am
           They were all bad. brotherbeck 777 0 Aug 17, 3:34am
       Alfrid's Glee squiggle 753 0 Aug 17, 4:29am
       I love Alfrid Avandel 736 0 Aug 17, 5:31am
       Funniest? dormouse 687 0 Aug 17, 7:41am
       Everything with Alfrid is funny. Smaug the iron 676 0 Aug 17, 7:51am
       I honestly like most of his scenes! adt100 638 0 Aug 17, 8:35am
       for me best alfird scene mo0on-light 598 0 Aug 17, 9:32am
       Every scene he's not in =) CathrineB 597 0 Aug 17, 9:33am
       I am okay with his scenes. Arannir 592 0 Aug 17, 9:39am
       I loved the way he walks Elarie 542 0 Aug 17, 12:04pm
       after Bard saves him from the lynching Kilidoescartwheels 500 0 Aug 17, 1:27pm
       Collapse Why is Alfrid such a hamfistedly obnoxious character? Bishop 464 14 Aug 17, 3:35pm
           Collapse 'Abandon the cripples!'.... adt100 437 11 Aug 17, 6:01pm
               Collapse I'm an American Bishop 431 10 Aug 17, 6:12pm
                   Collapse I wouldn't call it 'British' humour Glorfindela 382 8 Aug 17, 10:50pm
                       Collapse To offer counter examples. Spriggan 379 1 Aug 17, 10:55pm
                           and on the other hand Avandel 349 0 Aug 18, 12:43am
                       Collapse I would be more accepting of Alfrid Bishop 346 1 Aug 18, 12:50am
                           You seem to be asking two questions (or I'm asking which!) Spriggan 300 0 Aug 18, 5:52am
                       Disagree Smaug the iron 301 0 Aug 18, 5:43am
                       Collapse Sorry but I can't agree... adt100 229 2 Aug 18, 11:43am
                           Collapse Yes, he did. DanielLB 222 1 Aug 18, 11:59am
                               Some of Tolkien's humor was included... Otaku-sempai 194 0 Aug 18, 1:49pm
                   To the contrary, I think humour DOES belong in the film.... adt100 243 0 Aug 18, 11:01am
           "Stupid..." Ilmatar 399 0 Aug 17, 9:51pm
           Interesting Avandel 346 0 Aug 18, 12:50am
       Alfrid as a character squiggle 316 0 Aug 18, 5:09am
       Interesting thing about this thread.... dormouse 264 0 Aug 18, 8:09am

  Collapse What are the possibilities? lionoferebor 853 11 Aug 16, 8:16pm Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Collapse There's a possibility CathrineB 786 1 Aug 16, 8:37pm
           Thank you! I love it too. :) lionoferebor 625 0 Aug 16, 10:52pm
       Collapse All the other EEs had cuts QuackingTroll 776 1 Aug 16, 8:44pm
           Mirkwood path Mooseboy018 556 0 Aug 17, 1:36am
       in LOTR most additions in the EE Elanor of Rohan 721 0 Aug 16, 9:19pm
       and in DoS DolGuldur was rearanged aswell Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 716 0 Aug 16, 9:21pm
       Collapse Tell my son I loved him, Gandalf Wasserwaldnymphe 254 4 Aug 18, 6:01pm
           Collapse Indeed. arithmancer 231 2 Aug 18, 7:00pm
               Collapse Recently rewatched the gates of Erebor scene... Arannir 209 1 Aug 18, 7:28pm
                   That is what I thought initially. arithmancer 196 0 Aug 18, 8:03pm
           I'm thinking the same... Dipling 219 0 Aug 18, 7:13pm

  Collapse One thing which I noticed Hamfast Gamgee 751 6 Aug 16, 5:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Hamfast Gamgee)
       Yes.... dormouse 704 0 Aug 16, 6:09pm
       Collapse Quite a stretch... Arannir 674 1 Aug 16, 6:35pm
           But he does Hamfast Gamgee 151 0 Aug 18, 11:47pm
       Collapse Not only that Smaug the iron 656 1 Aug 16, 6:42pm
           Yes, I noticed that as well Hamfast Gamgee 152 0 Aug 18, 11:45pm
       Radagast has no active role in the original Hobbit. Otaku-sempai 457 0 Aug 16, 11:38pm

  Collapse Alfrid's death = R rating? DainPig 631 5 Aug 16, 5:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
       Collapse I still hope this is a false rumour. Arannir 570 2 Aug 16, 6:39pm
           Alfred already had a good send off. Arthael 400 0 Aug 16, 11:31pm
           Goblin scribe Mooseboy018 369 0 Aug 17, 1:40am
       Eh... lionoferebor 518 0 Aug 16, 7:32pm
       Well... Otaku-sempai 397 0 Aug 16, 11:40pm

  Collapse killing time article - BOFA voted best BR mid-year Avandel 630 3 Aug 16, 4:03pm Jump to last post in thread (by Pandallo)
       Collapse But, but, but Spriggan 385 1 Aug 16, 11:56pm
         *grins* Avandel 330 0 Aug 17, 5:25am
       It would seem that... Pandallo 175 0 Aug 18, 7:25am

  Collapse Which Extended scene do we want to see the most? JamesPaganini 1474 45 Aug 16, 2:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by Nuradar)
       Bifur losing his axe. Smaug the iron 1396 0 Aug 16, 2:45pm
       Collapse Hard to say... arithmancer 1373 1 Aug 16, 3:05pm
           Now then - don't be viewing this as an audience! Spriggan 940 0 Aug 16, 11:52pm
       Bilbo buries the acorn in dale // PryftanAW 1362 0 Aug 16, 3:06pm
       More Beorn (battlefield) and Avandel 1297 0 Aug 16, 3:55pm
       What I want vs what I expect Kilidoescartwheels 1255 0 Aug 16, 4:20pm
       Collapse This is my list. Arannir 1254 3 Aug 16, 4:24pm
           Collapse So much this! NoelGallagher 1164 2 Aug 16, 5:43pm
               Collapse Like-minded! Eleniel 1015 1 Aug 16, 9:28pm
                   Top 10 bilbo1997 945 0 Aug 16, 11:37pm
       Collapse The funeral scene Thrain II 1129 1 Aug 16, 6:23pm
           Funeral Scene brotherbeck 1058 0 Aug 16, 8:10pm
       Hmmm... Dipling 1051 0 Aug 16, 8:16pm
       Collapse I don't know what they're going to be... dormouse 996 2 Aug 16, 10:02pm
           Hear hear! Kim 909 0 Aug 17, 1:41am
           True! Earl 572 0 Aug 18, 6:53am
       Dol Guldur extended, that's all // xxxyyy 958 0 Aug 16, 11:01pm
       Collapse Dwarves and Beorn... lionoferebor 928 8 Aug 17, 12:30am
           Don't think anyone is being a downer! (: Avandel 707 0 Aug 17, 4:57pm
           Collapse Totally agree. Arannir 671 6 Aug 17, 6:02pm
               Collapse I hope you are pleasantly surprised, Arannir... dormouse 607 5 Aug 17, 10:07pm
                   Collapse Prologue Jeffrodo 569 3 Aug 18, 12:19am
                       This... Dipling 580 0 Aug 18, 6:34am
                       Collapse Agreed with all of this ! Arannir 566 1 Aug 18, 7:23am
                           Agree Avandel 520 0 Aug 18, 4:22pm
                   Thank you :) Arannir 562 0 Aug 18, 7:25am
       Me too... since the rumour is there'll be Dwarvish chanting // Earl 886 0 Aug 17, 2:56am
       for me mo0on-light 818 0 Aug 17, 9:34am
       Must-Have's... Dcole4 777 0 Aug 17, 12:48pm
       Collapse From most important to less important NecromancerRising 457 14 Aug 19, 4:44am
           Collapse For me it would be Glorfindela 426 13 Aug 19, 9:18am
               Collapse More or less NecromancerRising 406 12 Aug 19, 9:32am
                   Collapse Yes Glorfindela 367 11 Aug 19, 11:43am
                       Collapse Thank you very much for your concern Glorfindela! NecromancerRising 354 10 Aug 19, 11:53am
                           Collapse Negativity Arannir 326 3 Aug 19, 12:57pm
                               Collapse Nice to hear Arannir NecromancerRising 315 2 Aug 19, 1:11pm
                                   Collapse To be honest I would share your impression.... dormouse 292 1 Aug 19, 2:06pm
                                       I can definitely see what you mean DM NecromancerRising 270 0 Aug 19, 2:37pm
                           Collapse Political events? Glorfindela 263 5 Aug 19, 2:50pm
                               Collapse Yes, I am Greek :) NecromancerRising 252 4 Aug 19, 2:54pm
                                   Collapse OT Glorfindela 245 3 Aug 19, 3:03pm
                                       Collapse Thank you Glorfindela NecromancerRising 235 2 Aug 19, 3:33pm
                                           Collapse Nice to see you, NR! Voronwë_the_Faithful 213 1 Aug 19, 3:53pm
                                               Nice to see you too Voronwe NecromancerRising 170 0 Aug 19, 4:19pm
       the special feature I want to see most is... Nuradar 159 0 Aug 19, 4:37pm

  Collapse Any info on the EE figurine design? Eruonen 894 9 Aug 15, 7:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by Defiant)
       Collapse Oh! CathrineB 830 2 Aug 15, 8:06pm
           Good one, it could be a choice too. Eruonen 826 0 Aug 15, 8:07pm
           Statue aragorn2015 361 0 Aug 16, 5:13pm
       No idea Mooseboy018 797 0 Aug 15, 8:26pm
       Collapse BREAKING balbo biggins 635 1 Aug 16, 1:20am
           In the catapult then! Eruonen 617 0 Aug 16, 2:00am
       It could be Azog and Thorin on the plate of ice Milieuterrien 533 0 Aug 16, 6:32am
       Collapse It will involve Bilbo // QuackingTroll 246 1 Aug 17, 12:30pm
           Yep, Bilbo for sure. Defiant 94 0 Aug 19, 8:53pm

  Collapse Yawwwnn. And no NOT because I don't like these movies... Olorin2607 909 8 Aug 15, 6:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by BalrogTrainer)
       Collapse I'm very surprised... Aragorn the Elfstone 881 5 Aug 15, 7:04pm
           Collapse Maybe... Otaku-sempai 814 1 Aug 15, 7:47pm
               That seems possible.... dormouse 660 0 Aug 15, 10:31pm
           Collapse You're not the only one whose surprised. lionoferebor 574 1 Aug 16, 12:39am
               Ee theater release Goldeneye 499 0 Aug 16, 4:31am
           Yeah BalrogTrainer 334 0 Aug 16, 2:20pm
       Collapse hope Avandel 823 1 Aug 15, 7:40pm
           Finished product Mooseboy018 758 0 Aug 15, 8:34pm

  Collapse in defense of Peter Jackson Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1520 24 Aug 15, 1:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by basti255)
       Collapse I've seen all of Peter Jackson's films Bishop 1164 1 Aug 15, 8:12pm
           Too much CGI basti255 65 0 Aug 23, 8:41pm
       Collapse PJ's filmography Goldeneye 1115 5 Aug 15, 9:36pm
           Collapse I am curious Starling 1100 4 Aug 15, 9:50pm
               Collapse I was going to ask the same thing Bishop 1089 1 Aug 15, 9:52pm
                 bomby FINDS it Rank.. to RANK Bombadil 1051 0 Aug 15, 10:36pm
               Collapse Heavenly Creatures Goldeneye 907 1 Aug 16, 4:27am
                   I think Starling 892 0 Aug 16, 5:03am
       Collapse Well... dormouse 1061 5 Aug 15, 10:28pm
           Collapse Lovely Bones Goldeneye 903 1 Aug 16, 4:40am
               re: Lovely Bones BalrogTrainer 748 0 Aug 16, 2:29pm
           Collapse The Lovely Bones Starling 894 2 Aug 16, 5:09am
               re: King Kong BalrogTrainer 735 0 Aug 16, 2:37pm
               King Kong Goldeneye 528 0 Aug 17, 3:38pm
       love his work balbo biggins 960 0 Aug 16, 1:13am
       Yes... Dipling 578 0 Aug 17, 2:10pm
       Collapse I own all of PJ's movies and have seen all the special features... QuackingTroll 579 2 Aug 17, 2:26pm
           Excellent point Goldeneye 525 0 Aug 17, 3:43pm
           "Appealing to the lowest common denominator"? Spriggan 433 0 Aug 17, 8:41pm
       My take on PJ's films Kilidoescartwheels 510 0 Aug 17, 4:07pm
       Collapse a few comments elostirion74 469 2 Aug 17, 7:08pm
           Collapse I don't think he was attempting to make The Hobbit 'more epic'.... dormouse 395 1 Aug 17, 10:00pm
               it depends if you find the idea of a six-part saga either interesting or convincing: I don´t elostirion74 141 0 Aug 20, 5:31pm
       movie Lusitano 259 0 Aug 19, 5:13am

  Collapse so what do we think... nymmerod 975 10 Aug 14, 10:12pm Jump to last post in thread (by Nuradar)
       Collapse Dale! Lindele 930 1 Aug 14, 10:17pm
           Yep. Dale. Mooseboy018 908 0 Aug 14, 10:30pm
       Dale Avandel 877 0 Aug 14, 10:44pm
       Dale, for sure. Great question, though! // QuackingTroll 832 0 Aug 14, 11:20pm
       go for the fisical set and lazy I would say laketown Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 788 0 Aug 15, 12:16am
       The whole trip. Bumblingidiot 756 0 Aug 15, 1:03am
       I hope Dol Guldur // xxxyyy 726 0 Aug 15, 1:43am
       Clearly... Brandybuckled 401 0 Aug 15, 3:49pm
       I too wish for Erebor... lionoferebor 389 0 Aug 15, 4:12pm
       Erebor! Nuradar 74 0 Aug 19, 4:32pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1001 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.