Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 5 of 991 (354889 posts in 14865 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 991 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
Collapse In Dol Guldur.. Bombadil 814 14 Jul 8, 11:17am Jump to last post in thread (by Michelle Johnston)
       Bomby, are you coming over to the dark side? ;) Eruonen 587 0 Jul 8, 5:52pm
       The Three Elven Rings Otaku-sempai 533 0 Jul 8, 8:21pm
       Editing Mooseboy018 506 0 Jul 8, 9:29pm
       Collapse I found the Dol Guldur climax extraordinarily disappointing... Salmacis81 484 10 Jul 8, 10:58pm
           Collapse Salmacis81 ElendilTheShort 458 8 Jul 9, 1:22am
               It's from the UT - the Istari section. Mind you... Spriggan 449 0 Jul 9, 2:07am
             Collapse In an Effort to do a little research.. Bombadil 443 6 Jul 9, 2:28am
                   Collapse Dol Guldur in Bot5A NoelGallagher 416 4 Jul 9, 6:39am
                       Collapse NoelG..Excellent point! Bombadil 356 3 Jul 9, 1:55pm
                           Collapse Honestly Bomby NoelGallagher 324 2 Jul 9, 4:33pm
                             Collapse Well, since Sir LEE has DIED recently..there is HOPE Bombadil 272 1 Jul 10, 1:07am
                                   True, Bomby NoelGallagher 251 0 Jul 10, 6:38am
                   Good Questions Bom. Michelle Johnston 185 0 Jul 10, 7:59pm
           I too thought Saruman should have been presented to be the most powerful KingTurgon 214 0 Jul 10, 6:04pm

  Collapse AUJ is my favourite jf300 1196 21 Jul 7, 1:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by emre43)
       I agree... adu 1061 0 Jul 7, 2:28pm
       Well, after re-watching all three Hobbit films over the weekend... Avandel 1052 0 Jul 7, 2:51pm
       AUJ is the best of this trilogy Dcole4 1012 0 Jul 7, 3:52pm
       And herein lies the problem. Kelly of Water's Edge 977 0 Jul 7, 4:48pm
     I agree with you! DainPig 935 0 Jul 7, 5:35pm
       By way of contrast, it is my least favourite of the six. Spriggan 933 0 Jul 7, 5:38pm
       AUJ was nearly perfect Kilidoescartwheels 925 0 Jul 7, 5:42pm
       Collapse AUJ is my favourite too! Thrain II 903 1 Jul 7, 6:03pm
           ONCE again Ol' Bomby will wait for the Final Bombadil 894 0 Jul 7, 6:26pm
       Collapse A lovely post Thranderz 872 1 Jul 7, 7:17pm
           This Lindele 670 0 Jul 8, 3:54am
       Yiesh! CathrineB 831 0 Jul 7, 8:11pm
       Collapse AUJ is still my favorite, too Elarie 803 2 Jul 7, 9:20pm
           Collapse Far from my favorite... Pandallo 790 1 Jul 7, 9:51pm
               'serious reviewers' Lindele 672 0 Jul 8, 3:49am
       They're all my favourite... dormouse 778 0 Jul 7, 10:22pm
       Both AUJ & DOS ee are 10 out of 10s to me squiggle 605 0 Jul 8, 7:33am
       'Book fans' tend to favour AUJ.... adt100 578 0 Jul 8, 8:54am
       Collapse It's my second favorite... Queen of Erebor 314 1 Jul 9, 9:58pm
           Me too Jeffrodo 267 0 Jul 10, 12:47pm
       It's my favourite too emre43 165 0 Jul 13, 6:54pm

  Collapse Radagast and Beorn plot DainPig 952 21 Jul 6, 6:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Many of us know you Live in Brazil.. Bombadil 861 2 Jul 6, 8:13pm
           Beorn mounting an eagle in the EE joec_34 471 0 Jul 7, 3:37pm
           I like your wish list, Bomby Nuradar 458 0 Jul 7, 3:56pm
       Collapse Hopefully Mooseboy018 853 5 Jul 6, 8:18pm
           Collapse Personally don't want to see that Kilidoescartwheels 817 4 Jul 6, 9:05pm
               Collapse What? DainPig 769 3 Jul 6, 10:14pm
                   He is in the book - but actually (and unfortunately)not in the Movie-Hobbit NoelGallagher 736 0 Jul 6, 11:14pm
                   More Beorn is fine, Kilidoescartwheels 721 0 Jul 6, 11:44pm
                   Not according to PJ. Mooseboy018 701 0 Jul 7, 12:36am
       Collapse The TE explained rather poorly Milieuterrien 817 11 Jul 6, 9:07pm
           Collapse Was Beorn caught? Otaku-sempai 797 1 Jul 6, 9:21pm
               That would make interesting scenes Milieuterrien 790 0 Jul 6, 9:32pm
           Collapse Where did this come from? Kilidoescartwheels 725 8 Jul 6, 11:41pm
               Collapse Given the sequences Milieuterrien 628 2 Jul 7, 6:27am
                 Collapse "Beorn escaping from Gundabad"...BRILLIANT.. Bombadil 532 1 Jul 7, 1:19pm
                       Inside this Gundabad setting Milieuterrien 505 0 Jul 7, 2:34pm
               Collapse The reason this keeps coming up is due to the comment in the Weta Chronicles V Eleniel 484 4 Jul 7, 3:18pm
                   Collapse I have to agree. Otaku-sempai 474 2 Jul 7, 3:34pm
                       Collapse We have glimpses of Beorn being tortured in DG Milieuterrien 461 1 Jul 7, 3:57pm
                           Yes. Otaku-sempai 451 0 Jul 7, 4:17pm
                   I agree that sure would be redundant Milieuterrien 467 0 Jul 7, 3:43pm

  Moved: If Dwarves are Norse, then are Elves Celtic? Kilidoescartwheels - - Jul 6, 4:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)

  Collapse Would you agree that the First 10 Minutes of BOT5A Bombadil 1287 66 Jul 6, 3:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Collapse No Shagrat 1130 1 Jul 6, 4:17pm
           'out of character'? adt100 385 0 Jul 7, 12:17pm
       Yes Smaug the iron 1119 0 Jul 6, 4:26pm
       I do not agree. // priell3 1110 0 Jul 6, 4:27pm
       Collapse Yes! One of my favorite sections Avandel 1103 25 Jul 6, 4:42pm
           Collapse This calls for MythBusters! Otaku-sempai 1032 24 Jul 6, 6:00pm
               Collapse Yeah, it's a feather... Bofur01 1016 4 Jul 6, 6:15pm
                   Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 1014 3 Jul 6, 6:18pm
                       Collapse They are supposed to be feathers, but none big enough could be found Bofur01 1008 2 Jul 6, 6:27pm
                           Thanks. Otaku-sempai 1002 0 Jul 6, 6:30pm
                           Thanks for that Loresilme 364 0 Jul 7, 1:23pm
               Collapse Multiplication of force? Avandel 757 1 Jul 7, 2:34am
                   Sure. Otaku-sempai 746 0 Jul 7, 3:30am
               Collapse For those interested in the actual results of the bow Eruonen 182 16 Jul 8, 7:36pm
                   Collapse Thanks for the links. Otaku-sempai 169 15 Jul 8, 8:00pm
                       Collapse Yes, but complicated by the actual use of a broken bow firing a heavy metal bolt. Eruonen 160 4 Jul 8, 8:20pm
                           Collapse Is it supposed to be metal? Bofur01 152 1 Jul 8, 8:27pm
                               Metal, I think. Otaku-sempai 235 0 Jul 8, 8:34pm
                           Collapse You are mistaken Otaku-sempai 153 1 Jul 8, 8:27pm
                               Right, and that is the issue for me when the belief is shattered. Eruonen 219 0 Jul 8, 8:45pm
                       Collapse And the third one is simply incorrect. Spriggan 157 9 Jul 8, 8:21pm
                           Collapse This is the section I was referring to in the 3rd link Eruonen 238 7 Jul 8, 8:28pm
                               Collapse That's the bit I meant. Spriggan 235 6 Jul 8, 8:37pm
                                   Collapse I added this late above. Eruonen 217 5 Jul 8, 8:47pm
                                       Collapse Yes, I see that you did. Spriggan 212 4 Jul 8, 8:53pm
                                           Collapse Just a discussion of the various physics factors that go into arrow performance. Eruonen 202 3 Jul 8, 9:09pm
                                               Collapse Oh ok. Spriggan 196 2 Jul 8, 9:18pm
                                                   Collapse Which statement is wrong? You mean the bowstring and draw? Eruonen 195 1 Jul 8, 9:21pm
                                                       The very one you posted above Spriggan 192 0 Jul 8, 9:24pm
                           The third link. Otaku-sempai 225 0 Jul 8, 8:42pm
       Yes to Smaug Kilidoescartwheels 1059 0 Jul 6, 5:26pm
       Collapse A trial of a recreated windlance Eruonen 997 15 Jul 6, 6:37pm
         GREAT FIND...HE's WayCOOL Bombadil 939 0 Jul 6, 7:49pm
           Collapse Proof-of-concept. Otaku-sempai 915 13 Jul 6, 8:25pm
               I agree, the jury rigged-bow just does not look possible as the windlance Eruonen 909 0 Jul 6, 8:30pm
               Collapse Not the jury-rigged number Kilidoescartwheels 875 11 Jul 6, 9:01pm
                   Collapse I wouldn't want to have to build one Spriggan 849 10 Jul 6, 10:13pm
                       Collapse Didn't Bard use the Structural Strenght Bombadil 817 2 Jul 6, 11:18pm
                           No, the arrow was on Bain's shoulder Kilidoescartwheels 801 0 Jul 6, 11:50pm
                           Actually... Otaku-sempai 747 0 Jul 7, 3:32am
                       Collapse pre-existing holes Kilidoescartwheels 803 6 Jul 6, 11:48pm
                           Collapse Pre-existing holes Milieuterrien 695 4 Jul 7, 6:50am
                               Collapse Ypu're reaching. Otaku-sempai 328 3 Jul 7, 3:42pm
                                   Collapse A smart bowman Milieuterrien 324 2 Jul 7, 3:47pm
                                       Collapse I sense... Otaku-sempai 317 1 Jul 7, 4:20pm
                                         For sucha small part they SURE gave BAIN Bombadil 307 0 Jul 7, 6:20pm
                           Fortuitous, certainly. Spriggan 397 0 Jul 7, 9:37am
       Sure CathrineB 801 0 Jul 6, 11:59pm
       Collapse Fantastic sequence Elarie 389 2 Jul 7, 11:57am
         Collapse Well, PJ has mentioned before.. Bombadil 371 1 Jul 7, 1:08pm
               One prologue to rule them all Milieuterrien 340 0 Jul 7, 3:03pm
       Loved the Bard / Bain interaction Loresilme 359 0 Jul 7, 1:45pm
       Collapse Yes, I would.... dormouse 365 5 Jul 7, 2:14pm
           Collapse Who cares? I care. We are not talking magic here. When showing a Eruonen 235 4 Jul 8, 4:10pm
               Collapse Well, neither you nor I is in a position to say what 'the dominant thought' dormouse 219 2 Jul 8, 4:34pm
                   Collapse As Tolkien said Eruonen 203 1 Jul 8, 5:43pm
                       Yes, exactly,.... dormouse 192 0 Jul 8, 7:02pm
               I didn't know or care how the improvised arrow worked Elarie 208 0 Jul 8, 5:25pm
       Certainly one of the finest in the Hobbit trilogy at least Goldeneye 330 0 Jul 7, 3:38pm
       Collapse Yes Glorfindela 289 6 Jul 7, 10:40pm
           Collapse The whole 10 minutes, Please. Bombadil 171 5 Jul 9, 1:25pm
               Collapse Is Tauriel ambidextrous? Elarie 158 1 Jul 9, 1:38pm
                   You reminded me of something Kilidoescartwheels 148 0 Jul 9, 2:22pm
               Collapse Well Glorfindela 147 2 Jul 9, 2:30pm
                 Collapse NOT @ ALL..Bomby was Bombadil 122 1 Jul 9, 3:36pm
                       OK, Bomby Glorfindela 118 0 Jul 9, 3:50pm

Collapse "The White Gems of Lasgalen"... Bombadil 958 27 Jul 6, 2:42am Jump to last post in thread (by Elthir)
       Collapse Another mistake by Jackson.... Morthoron 890 16 Jul 6, 3:47am
           Collapse Legolas Greenleaf Arthael 868 13 Jul 6, 4:43am
               Collapse Greenleaf is not his surame... Eleniel 827 12 Jul 6, 6:24am
                   Collapse Legolas of Gondolin Otaku-sempai 792 10 Jul 6, 8:12am
                       Collapse another Legolas in what sense Elthir 683 7 Jul 6, 1:04pm
                           Collapse The other Legolas Otaku-sempai 620 6 Jul 6, 3:05pm
                               Silvan dialectal form Elthir 597 0 Jul 6, 3:45pm
                               Collapse naming Elthir 394 4 Jul 7, 12:52pm
                                   Collapse PS on Rumil Elthir 381 3 Jul 7, 1:25pm
                                       Collapse Legolas/Laiqalassë Otaku-sempai 150 2 Jul 7, 3:24pm
                                           Possible... Eleniel 133 0 Jul 7, 7:35pm
                                           Laicolasse Elthir 111 0 Jul 8, 10:02am
                       Collapse family names Elthir 658 1 Jul 6, 1:51pm
                           No, I did not mean that Greenleaf was a surname. Otaku-sempai 618 0 Jul 6, 3:13pm
                   about the Quenya Elthir 690 0 Jul 6, 12:45pm
           Well CathrineB 730 0 Jul 6, 11:18am
           Neither a mistake nor pulled from PJ's posterior adt100 405 0 Jul 7, 12:07pm
       Lasgalen Otaku-sempai 883 0 Jul 6, 4:05am
       Collapse How did the Dwarves obtain the white gems? Nuradar 631 5 Jul 6, 2:43pm
           The Elves needed the Dwarves to Fashion it Bombadil 622 0 Jul 6, 3:02pm
           Collapse We don't know the origin of the White Gems of Lasgalen Otaku-sempai 609 3 Jul 6, 3:27pm
               Collapse But didn't they belong to his wife? Nuradar 589 2 Jul 6, 3:56pm
                   Collapse Did they? Otaku-sempai 568 1 Jul 6, 4:34pm
                       Ahhh... Nuradar 545 0 Jul 6, 6:02pm
       Collapse Thranduil gave the gems to have a necklace made Milieuterrien 509 2 Jul 6, 8:39pm
           Collapse It's my understanding... Pandallo 473 1 Jul 7, 12:28am
               They should have estimate Milieuterrien 437 0 Jul 7, 6:05am

  Collapse I lost it Hamfast Gamgee 1328 49 Jul 4, 10:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by entmaiden)
       I think the film makes clear that Gandalf doesn't buy it. Spriggan 1243 0 Jul 4, 11:01pm
       Collapse Gandalf never bought it MyWeeLadGimli 910 10 Jul 5, 7:31pm
           Collapse Blame Saruman Otaku-sempai 907 9 Jul 5, 7:35pm
               Collapse Blame Tolkien on this one, I think. Spriggan 876 8 Jul 5, 8:28pm
                   Collapse I think... Guert 704 5 Jul 6, 12:40pm
                       Collapse Exactly. glor 553 4 Jul 7, 2:35am
                           Does the ring allows his bearer Milieuterrien 529 0 Jul 7, 6:39am
                           Collapse When you say "Gandalf knew Bilbo had the ring" Spriggan 513 2 Jul 7, 10:22am
                               Collapse By the way, Milieuterrien 476 1 Jul 7, 3:30pm
                                   There isn't a particularly good reason given. Spriggan 454 0 Jul 7, 5:31pm
                   Collapse Other rings of power tgshaw 700 1 Jul 6, 12:49pm
                       Unfortunately, and oddly, Tolkien specifies that he did know Spriggan 695 0 Jul 6, 1:11pm
       Collapse Gandalf only knew that Bilbo had found Milieuterrien 608 36 Jul 6, 8:58pm
           I don't think that's right. Spriggan 604 0 Jul 6, 9:09pm
           Collapse No, Gandalf knew (or guessed) about a ring. Otaku-sempai 603 34 Jul 6, 9:10pm
               Collapse Gandalf guessed, but he didn't know Milieuterrien 597 5 Jul 6, 9:20pm
                   Collapse Okay Otaku-sempai 591 2 Jul 6, 9:25pm
                       Collapse Gandalf knew that Bilbo had had a ring Milieuterrien 586 1 Jul 6, 9:35pm
                           Maybe. Otaku-sempai 582 0 Jul 6, 9:37pm
                   Collapse He says that he knew. Spriggan 587 1 Jul 6, 9:39pm
                       I can concede Milieuterrien 576 0 Jul 6, 10:14pm
               Collapse The driver is Bilbo's behaviour Michelle Johnston 429 27 Jul 7, 7:25pm
                   Collapse It's not about defending the movie at every turn Milieuterrien 422 1 Jul 7, 7:40pm
                       In addition... Otaku-sempai 359 0 Jul 7, 7:59pm
                   Collapse The end of the book Otaku-sempai 422 3 Jul 7, 7:41pm
                       Collapse The Ring is the main plothole between Tolkien's hobbit and trilogy Milieuterrien 357 1 Jul 7, 8:04pm
                           Well... Otaku-sempai 351 0 Jul 7, 8:44pm
                       Correct O S Michelle Johnston 341 0 Jul 7, 10:06pm
                   Collapse That's not correct, I don't think Spriggan 336 5 Jul 7, 10:27pm
                     Collapse There are a couple other things.. Bombadil 323 1 Jul 8, 12:20am
                           Bomby's questions. Otaku-sempai 290 0 Jul 8, 12:45pm
                       Collapse "Great Ring, as plainly it was" Michelle Johnston 262 2 Jul 9, 6:17am
                           Collapse I think it's very tricky to imagine how else we can read it. Spriggan 249 1 Jul 9, 6:53am
                               Your help on the Tale of Years Michelle Johnston 245 0 Jul 9, 7:13am
                   Collapse What is credible and in character for Gandalf glor 322 14 Jul 8, 12:27am
                       Collapse This is also exactly what happens in the book. Spriggan 300 12 Jul 8, 10:54am
                           Collapse Just to be polite Michelle Johnston 254 11 Jul 9, 6:35am
                               Collapse No that's not correct either. Spriggan 246 10 Jul 9, 7:02am
                                   Collapse Bare Faced Lie Where does this appear in the Hobbit Book Michelle Johnston 240 7 Jul 9, 7:21am
                                       Collapse Not in the TH - in LOTR. Spriggan 237 6 Jul 9, 7:35am
                                           Collapse Gollum's Journeys Michelle Johnston 228 5 Jul 9, 8:09am
                                               Collapse "Ere" means "before" Spriggan 220 2 Jul 9, 8:59am
                                                   Collapse I do not agree Michelle Johnston 188 1 Jul 9, 9:33am
                                                       I'm afraid that I have provided many quotes. Spriggan 188 0 Jul 9, 9:44am
                                               Collapse Sorry I missed your quote - but it says he opposite. Spriggan 190 1 Jul 9, 9:26am
                                                   It's well past time to move on entmaiden 162 0 Jul 9, 3:07pm
                                   Collapse Gandalf's Knowledge of The Ring Michelle Johnston 238 1 Jul 9, 7:24am
                                       A few brief replies rolled together. Spriggan 231 0 Jul 9, 7:53am
                       I agree and I like your description of Gandalf Michelle Johnston 257 0 Jul 9, 6:29am

  Collapse Amazon Uk has extended edition up for Nov. 16 Mithfânion 1051 7 Jul 4, 6:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by Dcole4)
       SPOILERY SPECULATION VID links #2 and #3 from Pryftan Avandel 969 0 Jul 4, 7:42pm
       Collapse Great... adu 517 5 Jul 7, 2:41pm
           Collapse On TORn Tuesday tonight Kim 476 4 Jul 8, 3:06am
               That would be lovely! adu 427 0 Jul 8, 1:50pm
               Collapse I don't think they know much... Dcole4 417 2 Jul 8, 3:07pm
                   Collapse Hear, hear... Avandel 382 1 Jul 8, 4:25pm
                       Regarding the EE Dcole4 378 0 Jul 8, 4:30pm

  Collapse Why does Thranduil turn the Dwarves away? lionoferebor 777 10 Jul 3, 8:34pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       grudges Mooseboy018 687 0 Jul 3, 9:38pm
       Collapse They didn't give a lot of detail in the films, but.... Silverlode 656 2 Jul 3, 11:00pm
           Collapse But Avandel 626 1 Jul 4, 12:29am
               Maybe an early decision to head for Moria? moreorless 306 0 Jul 6, 12:07pm
       Were the Elves even there because of the Dragon? Otaku-sempai 422 0 Jul 4, 10:15pm
       Collapse "Starving, homeless, asking for help." Otaku-sempai 282 4 Jul 6, 3:46pm
           Collapse I think this is correct. Riven Delve 239 3 Jul 7, 12:31pm
               Collapse Agree with all above but in addition... Spriggan 235 2 Jul 7, 12:52pm
                   Collapse I'm not far from guessing Milieuterrien 221 1 Jul 7, 3:18pm
                       Yes, probably. Otaku-sempai 214 0 Jul 7, 3:49pm

  Collapse BOTFA is Nominated for 8 Online Whale Awards Smaug the iron 708 5 Jul 1, 11:22pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruvandi)
       Whale awards? Really? CathrineB 659 0 Jul 1, 11:27pm
       Martin Freeman nominated? DainPig 648 0 Jul 2, 12:03am
       For aspects of the film I thought were outstanding Glorfindela 518 0 Jul 2, 9:27am
       You can vote by commenting. Peterthorn of Rohan 516 0 Jul 2, 9:30am
       Whale Awards? Eruvandi 394 0 Jul 2, 7:58pm

  Collapse Why do the people hate Azog? DainPig 1528 65 Jun 30, 6:38pm Jump to last post in thread (by Milieuterrien)
       I agree... Ereinion Nénharma 1394 0 Jun 30, 6:45pm
       Collapse A lot of the complaints I've heard... Eruvandi 1390 1 Jun 30, 6:55pm
           Actually Adrianna 1104 0 Jul 1, 5:24am
       Because he's not very nice.... dormouse 1346 0 Jun 30, 7:43pm
       Because of the Durins Avandel 1331 0 Jun 30, 8:02pm
       Collapse not Azog necessarily Mooseboy018 1308 18 Jun 30, 8:36pm
           Collapse Yup, his story makes zero sense... AshNazg 1266 17 Jun 30, 9:27pm
               Collapse I would recast that somewhat - and don't think the conclusion is the same. Spriggan 1216 16 Jun 30, 11:12pm
                   Collapse Azog brotherbeck 1174 2 Jul 1, 1:00am
                       Collapse What I find interesting in that... Pandallo 1164 1 Jul 1, 1:16am
                           The Beginning of DoS brotherbeck 1148 0 Jul 1, 1:37am
                   Collapse Things that don't make sense... AshNazg 1022 12 Jul 1, 10:03am
                       That's quite long so I'll split up replies: Intro, 1. and 2. Spriggan 993 0 Jul 1, 11:17am
                       3. Why did he wait. Spriggan 982 0 Jul 1, 11:35am
                       Collapse 4. and conclusion. Spriggan 976 9 Jul 1, 11:44am
                           Respect, DainPig. NoelGallagher 965 0 Jul 1, 12:07pm
                           Collapse We clearly view films very differently AshNazg 634 7 Jul 2, 12:05pm
                               Collapse I don't think I follow all of that. Spriggan 616 6 Jul 2, 1:23pm
                                   Collapse I see your viewpoint, but I disagree with it... AshNazg 608 5 Jul 2, 2:28pm
                                       Collapse Something just occurred to me on your bomb point.... dormouse 600 1 Jul 2, 3:24pm
                                           Like any theory there are exceptions... AshNazg 429 0 Jul 3, 7:51am
                                       Azog brotherbeck 591 0 Jul 2, 3:25pm
                                       This then seems like a third category of objection. Spriggan 596 0 Jul 2, 3:32pm
                                       Oh and just on DG in the text as an example Spriggan 556 0 Jul 2, 6:17pm
       I find the character to be unimaginative. Meneldor 1305 0 Jun 30, 8:36pm
       I actually... CathrineB 1286 0 Jun 30, 9:01pm
       I think he makes a good villain Glorfindela 1214 0 Jun 30, 11:10pm
       He killed Fili Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1156 0 Jul 1, 1:27am
       Collapse He was superfluous. DanielLB 1076 22 Jul 1, 6:44am
           I'm not sure about this... dormouse 660 0 Jul 2, 9:19am
           Collapse I agree with this 100% Fredeghar Wayfarer 412 20 Jul 3, 9:10am
               Totally agree... Salmacis81 327 0 Jul 4, 6:10pm
               Collapse Given the fact that Azog and Bolg had been named by Tolkien Milieuterrien 308 18 Jul 4, 7:28pm
                   Collapse But why couldn't they stay within canon? That's what I don't get... Salmacis81 273 17 Jul 5, 4:38pm
                       Collapse They could have, easily. Otaku-sempai 250 16 Jul 5, 7:45pm
                           Oh yeah, I KNOW they could've stayed within the canon... Salmacis81 240 0 Jul 5, 8:06pm
                           Collapse Anything could be done Spriggan 228 4 Jul 5, 8:37pm
                               Collapse Um...huh? Otaku-sempai 221 3 Jul 5, 9:04pm
                                   Collapse I think that probably illustrates the point. Spriggan 216 2 Jul 5, 9:26pm
                                       Collapse I see. Otaku-sempai 301 1 Jul 5, 10:41pm
                                           Changes brotherbeck 282 0 Jul 5, 11:23pm
                           Collapse What 'Jackson fell in love with' is speculation, I feel Glorfindela 268 9 Jul 6, 12:44am
                               Collapse Perhaps; perhaps not. Otaku-sempai 260 8 Jul 6, 12:57am
                                   Collapse It was actually Philippa Boyens who made the statement about Azog the Defiler... Eleniel 244 7 Jul 6, 6:32am
                                       Thanks Otaku-sempai 231 0 Jul 6, 7:58am
                                       Collapse I remember that, too Glorfindela 218 5 Jul 6, 10:41am
                                           Collapse How would that work? Otaku-sempai 199 4 Jul 6, 3:50pm
                                               Collapse How would what work? Glorfindela 198 3 Jul 6, 4:09pm
                                                   Collapse Crushing on the actor is all well and good. Otaku-sempai 188 2 Jul 6, 4:41pm
                                                       Collapse Argh! Glorfindela 184 1 Jul 6, 5:19pm
                                                           Look. I understood what you posted. Otaku-sempai 181 0 Jul 6, 5:54pm
       Collapse It started badly Michelle Johnston 893 9 Jul 1, 5:25pm
           They had no other choice than explaining their own plot Milieuterrien 782 0 Jul 1, 11:08pm
           Collapse Well, if Azog did 'just pop up'....... dormouse 656 4 Jul 2, 9:36am
               Collapse DM I think you have misunderstood me. Michelle Johnston 508 3 Jul 2, 8:54pm
                   Collapse Not really, I simply answered what you said.... dormouse 484 1 Jul 2, 10:16pm
                       DM correction again Michelle Johnston 440 0 Jul 3, 6:20am
                   Excellent analysis Michelle... Salmacis81 317 0 Jul 4, 6:33pm
           Collapse It's not about the story Milieuterrien 162 2 Jul 6, 8:20pm
               Collapse Killing Azog Otaku-sempai 159 1 Jul 6, 8:34pm
                   Don't forget we have three meetings between Azog and Bolg Milieuterrien 149 0 Jul 6, 9:30pm
       because he is bad :) Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 818 0 Jul 1, 9:02pm
       I think one of the reasons people dislked Azog - Hanzkaz 662 0 Jul 2, 8:56am
       Collapse He's a one-dimensional bad guy Kilidoescartwheels 504 1 Jul 2, 9:09pm
           I can't really agree there... moreorless 214 0 Jul 6, 11:50am

  Collapse ''Bilbo is right...'' Matthijs 703 5 Jun 30, 5:20pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bofur01)
       Welcome to the forum Matthijs Smaug the iron 664 0 Jun 30, 5:26pm
       trailer line Mooseboy018 645 0 Jun 30, 5:37pm
       That could be interesting. Eruvandi 597 0 Jun 30, 6:40pm
       Collapse I think this could be part of the extended Arkenstone debate... AshNazg 498 1 Jun 30, 9:51pm
           Well yes, and Gandalf will have to say... Bofur01 494 0 Jun 30, 10:01pm

  Collapse Little scenes that would have been nice.... Eruonen 1140 12 Jun 28, 5:14am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Legolas' arrows AshNazg 1001 1 Jun 28, 11:42am
         Legolas' hanging upside down Bracegirdle 960 0 Jun 28, 1:20pm
       Smaug smashing the Mountainside Otaku-sempai 960 0 Jun 28, 1:22pm
       This would only work Bishop 923 0 Jun 28, 3:18pm
       DOS: The giant golden Dwarf statue Legolas_Shoehorn 887 0 Jun 28, 4:31pm
       Thranduil's halls... yes xxxyyy 863 0 Jun 28, 5:10pm
       Scenes in BOT5A? Kilidoescartwheels 796 0 Jun 28, 8:03pm
       Collapse i don't recall that Barrow-Wight 789 1 Jun 28, 8:21pm
           AUJ Appendices MyWeeLadGimli 766 0 Jun 28, 9:05pm
       Collapse Details Avandel 422 2 Jun 30, 7:59pm
           Collapse Especially your 2nd point as that scene in DOS was a little unreal Eruonen 409 1 Jun 30, 8:32pm
             Don't we NEED Raddy giving Gandalf HIS STAFF? Bombadil 259 0 Jul 3, 6:00pm

  Collapse Fili, Kili and Tauriel - Extended Edition scene DainPig 1738 22 Jun 27, 6:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by KingTurgon)
       Collapse More Kili - Fili Interactions would be most welcome but... Dcole4 1630 4 Jun 27, 6:54pm
           missing Thranduil scene. Mooseboy018 1546 0 Jun 27, 8:24pm
           Collapse *sigh* Avandel 1520 2 Jun 27, 8:39pm
               Collapse This. Eruvandi 582 1 Jun 30, 6:22pm
                   Extension? Gandalf the Green 410 0 Jul 3, 1:21pm
       Collapse yes Mooseboy018 1534 1 Jun 27, 8:29pm
         I agree with ya DainPig 1505 0 Jun 27, 8:46pm
       Not for me Avandel 1521 0 Jun 27, 8:33pm
       But why would Fili ask who Tauriel is.... dormouse 1431 0 Jun 27, 10:32pm
       We need more Fili, but Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1374 0 Jun 28, 12:20am
       No Glorfindela 1348 0 Jun 28, 1:45am
       Collapse Ah no way CathrineB 1194 6 Jun 28, 10:40am
           Collapse Kili's anger Kilidoescartwheels 1048 5 Jun 28, 7:57pm
               Collapse Yeah CathrineB 986 4 Jun 28, 10:25pm
                   Collapse Dwalin and Fili Mooseboy018 954 3 Jun 29, 12:54am
                       Collapse Faramir an Eowyn too Elanor of Rohan 829 2 Jun 29, 2:00pm
                           Don´t forget Smaug the iron 825 0 Jun 29, 2:04pm
                           Yes.... dormouse 677 0 Jun 30, 6:42am
       Collapse OK, I'll play along Kilidoescartwheels 1053 2 Jun 28, 7:54pm
           Collapse Doesn't sound like something PJ would approve... AshNazg 1049 1 Jun 28, 8:12pm
               You mean another "subtle" reference to LoTR? Kilidoescartwheels 918 0 Jun 29, 4:52am
       No more Tauriel and Kili please! KingTurgon 231 0 Jul 8, 5:32pm

  Collapse The Curse of the Orcs on the Hill Arandir 631 3 Jun 27, 9:59am Jump to last post in thread (by Silverlode)
       Collapse Some of the concepts are the same exact shots in FoTR... Hobbity Hobbit 589 2 Jun 27, 11:08am
           Collapse Or maybe... Fredeghar Wayfarer 164 1 Jul 3, 9:34am
               Shirkers. Silverlode 135 0 Jul 3, 11:02pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 991 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.