Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 5 of 913 (328404 posts in 13687 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 913 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Moved: Peter Jackson talks 'Hobbit: Battle of the the Five Armies' and all Middle-earth with TheOneRing.net News from Bree - - Tue, 5:24pm Jump to last post in thread (by News from Bree)

  Collapse Critics Reviews #17 NecromancerRising 2412 102 Tue, 4:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse Not looking good on RT King_horse 848 2 Tue, 4:55pm
           Collapse Not that bad! Danielos 812 1 Tue, 5:05pm
               Yep Ham_Sammy 753 0 Tue, 5:08pm
       Collapse I've only taken a look at a couple of reviews myself BlackFox 753 1 Tue, 5:11pm
           Thanks Fox NecromancerRising 705 0 Tue, 5:14pm
       Still faring better than DOS Annatar598 740 0 Tue, 5:13pm
       Collapse 63% now frodolives 747 1 Tue, 5:14pm
           The RT consensus will be changed King_horse 729 0 Tue, 5:23pm
       Collapse What is going on with the reviews? macfalk 797 40 Tue, 5:16pm
           Collapse Well, you know Glorfindela 768 5 Tue, 5:20pm
               Collapse A question Ham_Sammy 690 4 Tue, 5:26pm
                   Collapse I saw BoFA on its own Glorfindela 625 3 Tue, 5:51pm
                       Collapse Okay thanks! Ham_Sammy 549 2 Tue, 6:02pm
                           Collapse I saw it standalone as well, and I liked it a lot // macfalk 442 1 Tue, 6:06pm
                               Ok great to hear! Ham_Sammy 431 0 Tue, 6:08pm
           A lot of these Ham_Sammy 705 0 Tue, 5:24pm
           Collapse Certified Rotten? Danielos 746 31 Tue, 5:29pm
               Collapse On the bright side... Brandybuckled 707 30 Tue, 5:32pm
                   Collapse Rotten Tomatoes... ecthelionsbeard 673 25 Tue, 5:39pm
                       Collapse In what way? frodolives 642 24 Tue, 5:40pm
                           Collapse I meant it... ecthelionsbeard 646 3 Tue, 5:42pm
                               Oh, then I agree to an extent frodolives 609 0 Tue, 5:47pm
                               Collapse Well they are an aggragator Ham_Sammy 584 1 Tue, 5:52pm
                                   I agree with this so much. Glorfindela 572 0 Tue, 5:54pm
                           Collapse They very well may have. macfalk 606 19 Tue, 5:56pm
                               Collapse There are many more to come. NecromancerRising 460 18 Tue, 6:40pm
                                   Collapse Good to hear! macfalk 406 17 Tue, 6:43pm
                                       Collapse And yes there are still plenty of older reviews NecromancerRising 434 16 Tue, 6:45pm
                                           Collapse We'll see Voronwë_the_Faithful 402 15 Tue, 7:00pm
                                               Collapse A stellar review by Bruce Kirkland was just added NecromancerRising 428 4 Tue, 7:05pm
                                                   Collapse Saw that one already Voronwë_the_Faithful 381 2 Tue, 7:10pm
                                                       Collapse Yup.I have. NecromancerRising 382 1 Tue, 7:11pm
                                                           HoF is back // Voronwë_the_Faithful 210 0 Wed, 3:12am
                                                 PERFECT QUOTE: Bombadil 380 0 Tue, 7:32pm
                                               Collapse I am sceptical too right now but there are so many to ignore all of them NecromancerRising 426 9 Tue, 7:07pm
                                                   Collapse 2 fresh and 1 rotten addes Voronwë_the_Faithful 351 8 Tue, 7:32pm
                                                       Collapse I had tracked the negative yesterday but not the 2 fresh that were added NecromancerRising 347 7 Tue, 7:34pm
                                                           Collapse There is still hope! Voronwë_the_Faithful 367 6 Tue, 7:36pm
                                                               Collapse 2 more negatives added anthonyroy 327 5 Tue, 8:02pm
                                                                   Collapse More accurately... ecthelionsbeard 320 2 Tue, 8:08pm
                                                                       I don't think so Ham_Sammy 317 0 Tue, 8:10pm
                                                                       Has it? anthonyroy 302 0 Tue, 8:13pm
                                                                   Collapse Normal Estel78 308 1 Tue, 8:12pm
                                                                       From the last 40 reviews on RT, 21 have been negative, 19 positive anthonyroy 332 0 Tue, 8:20pm
                   Collapse Considering Exodus... Aragorn the Elfstone 304 3 Tue, 11:05pm
                       Collapse Same here Elessar 277 2 Tue, 11:10pm
                           Collapse I don't go there at all Ham_Sammy 254 1 Tue, 11:22pm
                               Ditto Elessar 229 0 Tue, 11:30pm
           US critics after international release have been a lot more negative so far anthonyroy 401 0 Tue, 7:29pm
       critics Mooseboy018 777 0 Tue, 5:19pm
       Also added NecromancerRising 542 0 Tue, 6:12pm
       I know one thing: Critics overuse flippancy even more than PJ overuses CGI.// L. Ron Halfelven 273 0 Tue, 8:44pm
       Collapse Baffled by some of these reviews. MatthewJer18 338 1 Tue, 8:46pm
           sounds familiar Mooseboy018 280 0 Tue, 8:59pm
       I'm just not a fan of RT Elessar 434 0 Tue, 9:03pm
       Collapse Rave review from Top Critic Colin Covert Voronwë_the_Faithful 449 2 Tue, 9:22pm
           It seems to me that regardless... MasterOrc 435 0 Tue, 9:27pm
         "...Nobody makes death more creative than Jackson. .."LOVE it..// Bombadil 289 0 Tue, 11:00pm
       Collapse Down to 60% Voronwë_the_Faithful 392 10 Tue, 10:33pm
           All things being equal. Spriggan 384 0 Tue, 10:39pm
           Collapse They have to have some kind of agenda. Elessar 350 8 Tue, 10:55pm
               Collapse Well that would be easily established. Spriggan 344 7 Tue, 11:00pm
                   Collapse Apparently yes Voronwë_the_Faithful 323 2 Tue, 11:04pm
                       I don't get Elessar 299 0 Tue, 11:09pm
                       If they aren't added at all then there may be some oddity Spriggan 264 0 Tue, 11:19pm
                   Maybe we have a detective Elessar 297 0 Tue, 11:08pm
                   Collapse Some of the older tracked reviews have already been added NecromancerRising 320 2 Tue, 11:13pm
                       At this point Voronwë_the_Faithful 306 0 Tue, 11:17pm
                       Now officially rotten Voronwë_the_Faithful 255 0 Tue, 11:37pm
       Collapse This is strange as... something strange Bernhardina 292 15 Tue, 11:36pm
           Well folks... ecthelionsbeard 264 0 Tue, 11:37pm
           Collapse It is rotten now.. King_horse 288 13 Tue, 11:38pm
               Um...? Bernhardina 256 0 Tue, 11:42pm
               Collapse Never thought... Aragorn the Elfstone 272 11 Tue, 11:43pm
                   LOL shadowdog 228 0 Tue, 11:48pm
                   Collapse Except that RT is the go-to for a lot of moviegoers... Osskil 471 9 Wed, 12:05am
                       Collapse Seemed a cert easily be fresh a few days ago, now rotten at 58%. anthonyroy 456 7 Wed, 12:15am
                           Collapse AUJ fell to the low 50s early on Annatar598 229 6 Wed, 3:54am
                               Collapse It's finding its level Silranhir 157 5 Wed, 6:53am
                                   Collapse In your opinion Glorfindela 150 1 Wed, 7:11am
                                       Agreed. If I do adhere to critics though in some cases Annatar598 146 0 Wed, 7:23am
                                   Collapse you cannot fairly judge Cirashala 113 2 Wed, 8:53am
                                       Collapse What I can say... Silranhir 47 1 Wed, 1:53pm
                                           you missed my point entirely Cirashala 8 0 12:11am
                       Don't think RT makes much difference to box office. Look at Transformers. anthonyroy 438 0 Wed, 12:17am
       Collapse Very odd. thomasofrohan 540 2 Tue, 11:48pm
           It IS baffling. JTurner82 344 0 Wed, 1:32am
           Things common to negative reviews. mefansmum 247 0 Wed, 3:23am
       Collapse I am speechless. Utterly speechless. macfalk 504 4 Wed, 12:26am
           Collapse Makes two of us Elessar 430 2 Wed, 12:39am
               Collapse Rotten Tomatoes Consensus.. ecthelionsbeard 455 1 Wed, 12:50am
                   Those two Elessar 400 0 Wed, 1:08am
           Critics, well um some of them are not... glor 387 0 Wed, 1:20am
       Collapse This is something I'm used to seeing duats 318 3 Wed, 2:24am
           Collapse I appreciate that sentiment. Osskil 271 2 Wed, 2:43am
               Collapse Regarding the higher frame rate duats 255 1 Wed, 2:59am
                   HFR Osskil 236 0 Wed, 3:17am
       Four more reviews. JTurner82 237 0 Wed, 4:29am
       Another positive! JTurner82 242 0 Wed, 4:32am
       Collapse I told you that by the time it would have been released in america the critics gonna hate it Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 97 2 Wed, 11:16am
           Collapse Fresh again Fleuz 72 1 Wed, 12:09pm
               I dont care at all sorry Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 59 0 Wed, 12:59pm

  Collapse Why do so many people get uptight about a movie? tripecac 1121 56 Tue, 4:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       Very well said! JamesPaganini 523 0 Tue, 4:13pm
       High Five shadowdog 516 0 Tue, 4:14pm
       Collapse But... Darkstone 574 9 Tue, 4:20pm
           Collapse They know because you keep posting on TORn// Kangi Ska 348 8 Tue, 5:50pm
               Collapse But.... Darkstone 336 5 Tue, 6:05pm
                   Collapse It would be bad press if we were to claim Kangi Ska 296 4 Tue, 6:22pm
                       Collapse But... Darkstone 294 3 Tue, 6:32pm
                           Collapse I'm with ya brother Dame Ioreth 278 1 Tue, 6:38pm
                               Same here Ham_Sammy 265 0 Tue, 6:44pm
                           I know. Kangi Ska 166 0 Tue, 8:44pm
               Collapse Even if I post once in a blue moon? Tintallë 95 1 Tue, 11:04pm
                   yes Virginis there is a Santa Claus.// Kangi Ska 83 0 Tue, 11:59pm
       Collapse Strange comments Macsen 531 7 Tue, 4:36pm
           Collapse I respectfully agree to this, but... Misty Mountain Hop 489 6 Tue, 4:48pm
               Totally Agree shadowdog 445 0 Tue, 4:54pm
               Collapse Hmmm Macsen 424 1 Tue, 5:10pm
                   I'm not necessarily saying this happens on these boards Misty Mountain Hop 389 0 Tue, 5:28pm
               Collapse Wow Darkstone 357 1 Tue, 5:52pm
                   Wow, thank you for the compliment Misty Mountain Hop 254 0 Tue, 6:48pm
               For every EEyore there is a Tigger. Kangi Ska 270 0 Tue, 6:29pm
       Everyone is different frodolives 475 0 Tue, 4:40pm
       Collapse Well, speaking personally Glorfindela 481 3 Tue, 4:51pm
           Bingo! frodolives 434 0 Tue, 4:55pm
           Collapse Hit the nail on the head... Salmacis81 217 1 Tue, 7:35pm
               I too waited a long time Kangi Ska 147 0 Tue, 9:05pm
       Collapse My thoughts on this... Girdle of Melian 472 10 Tue, 4:53pm
           Collapse My intention tripecac 410 9 Tue, 5:34pm
               Collapse oh wow... Magpie 385 1 Tue, 5:42pm
                   Raises hand! Voronwë_the_Faithful 249 0 Tue, 7:05pm
               Collapse I hope your effort does not pay off. Kangi Ska 340 2 Tue, 5:58pm
                 Collapse WOWIe SSooo nice that? the Immortals & Half-Elvenzz Bombadil 285 1 Tue, 6:22pm
                       I do not believe that it is possible to save a day.// Kangi Ska 261 0 Tue, 6:31pm
               Here is a suggestion... Morthoron 330 0 Tue, 6:05pm
               I dislike this distinction between positive and negative. Macfeast 263 0 Tue, 6:44pm
               Collapse It's not your job to manage the discussion entmaiden 259 1 Tue, 6:51pm
                   Can you imagine if.. Girdle of Melian 237 0 Tue, 7:08pm
       So, let me get this straight.... Morthoron 442 0 Tue, 5:06pm
       Collapse oh for heaven's sake folks... Dame Ioreth 428 1 Tue, 5:28pm
           That's how I read it too! Ham_Sammy 383 0 Tue, 5:29pm
       This is akin to saying Bishop 392 0 Tue, 5:35pm
       disagree Me85 360 0 Tue, 5:42pm
       Okay, that's dangerous - Hanzkaz 288 0 Tue, 6:25pm
       Collapse Why do so many people get uptight about people getting uptight about a movie? bungobaggins 204 6 Tue, 8:01pm
           Collapse Why do so many people get uptight about people getting uptight about people getting uptight about a movie? Darkstone 204 5 Tue, 8:04pm
               Collapse ha ha bungobaggins 187 4 Tue, 8:08pm
                   Collapse No no no Darkstone 180 3 Tue, 8:25pm
                       Collapse I triple dog dare ya Dame Ioreth 166 2 Tue, 8:31pm
                           Collapse I'm upset about people getting upset with other people getting upset with other people getting upset about a movie. Darkstone 91 1 Tue, 10:52pm
                               Well... Dame Ioreth 47 0 Wed, 3:20am
     Collapse Insults have been edited out of this discussion thread. Ataahua 136 3 Tue, 9:57pm
           *from the sidelines* Many thanks to the mods Tintallë 70 0 Wed, 1:25am
           Collapse It seems to me that the first post of this thread mefansmum 68 1 Wed, 1:32am
               I tried Ataahua 60 0 Wed, 1:57am
       My own view would be that I don't understand where the loss is. Spriggan 93 0 Tue, 11:29pm
       Collapse This post is so deep... lastnickleft 69 1 Wed, 2:12am
         Hehehe! // BlackFox 13 0 Wed, 5:35pm

  Collapse Some favorite most powerful moments Old Toby 695 7 Tue, 3:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by drewster81)
       Collapse Great list, and totally agree Elarie 238 1 Tue, 5:58pm
           Great moment!!! Ham_Sammy 224 0 Tue, 6:04pm
       Need to see it again but some things that struck me: Avandel 278 0 Tue, 6:13pm
       Collapse All of the above Dame Ioreth 235 2 Tue, 6:15pm
           Collapse Bomby is STILL waiting for moahunter & Lissuin Bombadil 178 1 Tue, 7:11pm
               Lobelia Elarie 105 0 Tue, 10:02pm
       Bilbo drewster81 50 0 Wed, 3:41am

  Collapse Has Jackson been asked any critical questions? frodolives 971 21 Tue, 3:27pm Jump to last post in thread (by DanielLB)
       Questions that need answering Macsen 546 0 Tue, 3:41pm
       Collapse I don't know about the questions Dame Ioreth 468 3 Tue, 3:55pm
           Collapse Interestingly smtfhw 408 2 Tue, 4:22pm
               Collapse Really? Dame Ioreth 352 1 Tue, 4:42pm
                   I agree with this Ham_Sammy 318 0 Tue, 5:09pm
       Collapse Humble PJ? Danielos 420 1 Tue, 4:19pm
           Most of the appendices footage Skaan 360 0 Tue, 4:51pm
       Philippa Boyens made some interesting comments about Alfrid... dormouse 469 0 Tue, 4:25pm
       Collapse Is it the role of the filmmaker to give answers? Spriggan 383 5 Tue, 4:27pm
           Collapse No, but... frodolives 365 3 Tue, 4:36pm
               Collapse Really? Some of those seem like odd things Spriggan 126 2 Tue, 10:05pm
                   Collapse Each to his own frodolives 118 1 Tue, 10:13pm
                       Ha - well they don't interest me either! Spriggan 111 0 Tue, 10:24pm
           The role of the artist is to articulate. Darkstone 236 0 Tue, 6:41pm
       Collapse I sometimes would like PJ's explanations on such things, particular changes.... adt100 394 3 Tue, 4:35pm
           Collapse My issue with the troll scene... frodolives 366 2 Tue, 4:50pm
               Good point. My issue with the troll scene Brandybuckled 302 0 Tue, 5:30pm
               Completely agree with this! Bladerunner 70 0 Wed, 1:53am
       I've just read the new article on the homepage - very interesting! adt100 352 0 Tue, 5:08pm
       so much time on alfrid ? mirkwoodwanderer 231 0 Tue, 6:56pm
       I want him to answer: DanielLB 46 0 Wed, 7:28am

  Collapse The way critics are reviewing The Hobbit films tiamy 1055 17 Tue, 2:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by Spriggan)
       Critics are "..pre-disposed to be disappointed.." Bombadil 456 0 Tue, 2:54pm
       Collapse One cannot ignore, though... Arannir 479 1 Tue, 2:59pm
           Each Reviewer Ham_Sammy 376 0 Tue, 3:40pm
       True, but that's probably mainly the popular press Kristin Thompson 348 0 Tue, 3:58pm
       Collapse The Hobbit was always at a disadvantage to begin with.. Jim 345 1 Tue, 4:16pm
           I think that the disadvantage is the name huzzlewhat 230 0 Tue, 6:48pm
       Collapse What happens with many critics TnuaccayM 344 4 Tue, 4:48pm
           Collapse I agree with this totally Ham_Sammy 291 2 Tue, 4:58pm
               Collapse Exactly why bom Needed to see the Marathon... Bombadil 279 1 Tue, 5:09pm
                   I agree Bom Ham_Sammy 257 0 Tue, 5:13pm
           and I'll add Avandel 87 0 Wed, 2:24am
       Collapse The films arent above criticism of course BUT... moreorless 248 5 Tue, 6:54pm
           Collapse To be honest, I have happened to agree with the general drift of criticism Spriggan 143 4 Tue, 10:07pm
               Collapse I think the big issue tends to be the degree of it... moreorless 79 3 Wed, 4:31am
                   Collapse Honestly, I would think so Spriggan 57 2 Wed, 8:11am
                       Collapse To define "uneven quality" moreorless 33 1 Wed, 1:50pm
                           So are you saying Spriggan 25 0 Wed, 2:40pm

  Collapse Marathon yesterday grimbeorn15 303 3 Tue, 2:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
     Nice review *waves to fellow marathoner* Avandel 89 0 Tue, 5:42pm
       Collapse My double marathon Elarie 86 1 Tue, 6:05pm
         GREAT IDEA!...*Grabs Disks* Bombadil 75 0 Tue, 6:32pm

  Collapse High Frame Rate listing athenslotr 202 5 Tue, 2:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by athenslotr)
       Collapse There is Always a simple way.. Google it? Bombadil 97 2 Tue, 2:51pm
           Collapse Indeed I have... athenslotr 88 1 Tue, 3:12pm
               This is the list for IMAX with HFR DisDwarfWoman 69 0 Tue, 6:04pm
       Collapse No, but Regal theaters generally have HFR showings Tintallë 24 1 Tue, 10:58pm
           Thanks to all athenslotr 16 0 Wed, 2:27am

Collapse Kili and Tauriel - heightism? (spoilers) Macsen 773 21 Tue, 1:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by marillaraina)
       Elves Danielos 368 0 Tue, 2:10pm
       Collapse I'm 6' 5'' myself Nightwing 340 1 Tue, 2:29pm
           Happily IdrilofGondolin 139 0 Tue, 8:06pm
       I don't think it's unbelievable Angharad73 329 0 Tue, 2:33pm
       .. or perhaps Bookism? ;-) // dormouse 311 0 Tue, 2:34pm
       Collapse Heightism? DanielLB 322 4 Tue, 2:39pm
           Collapse So is the problem Macsen 307 3 Tue, 2:46pm
               Collapse It has nothing to do with perceptions of the viewer. DanielLB 308 1 Tue, 2:49pm
                   So... Macsen 255 0 Tue, 3:32pm
               What Daniel said... dormouse 294 0 Tue, 2:51pm
       Collapse uh...no... Eleniel 290 9 Tue, 3:27pm
           Collapse Love? Macsen 268 4 Tue, 3:35pm
               Collapse I didn't say she actually says those three little words Eleniel 239 3 Tue, 3:59pm
                   Collapse Past the edit window... Eleniel 230 2 Tue, 4:19pm
                       Collapse Wuv Macsen 213 1 Tue, 5:05pm
                           Sadly, I think it is heavily suggested... FlyingSerkis 203 0 Tue, 5:26pm
           Collapse This was my feeling as well Ham_Sammy 277 3 Tue, 3:36pm
               Collapse Still racism or heightism or whatever :D marillaraina 76 2 Tue, 11:18pm
                   Collapse This! Arvida 48 1 Wed, 7:32am
                       Thank you! marillaraina 13 0 Wed, 9:31pm
       Frodo and Arwen Darkstone 138 0 Tue, 8:21pm

  Collapse What does Bilbo achieve in the trilogy? Macsen 570 15 Tue, 1:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by Roheryn)
       Collapse He gets back, back to where he once belong Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 301 1 Tue, 1:22pm
           The long and winding road goes ever on and on.// L. Ron Halfelven 117 0 Tue, 7:12pm
       Collapse A few missing, I think, just from AUJ and DOS Spriggan 282 4 Tue, 1:54pm
           Most importantly I would add.. moreorless 251 0 Tue, 1:59pm
           Collapse Good point with some of those Spriggan Macsen 228 2 Tue, 2:07pm
               Well, if Bilbo hadn't been there Spriggan 226 0 Tue, 2:14pm
               Just like in the book... DanielLB 199 0 Tue, 2:29pm
       All of the above... plus what he was MEANT to do: mae govannen 222 0 Tue, 2:20pm
       The sparing of gollum Ham_Sammy 197 0 Tue, 2:38pm
       Collapse Everything he achieved in the book... dormouse 209 1 Tue, 2:39pm
           True dubulous 126 0 Tue, 6:32pm
       Collapse His impact on Thorin is huge in BOFA (spoilers) LoremIpsum 130 1 Tue, 7:02pm
           Exactly Ham_Sammy 106 0 Tue, 7:21pm
       He gave the Arkenstone to the Elves and humans Milieuterrien 82 0 Tue, 8:33pm
       Thorin's redemption (arguably, perhaps). Roheryn 42 0 Wed, 12:35am

  Collapse Random thoughts and questions (spoilers) Guert 415 2 Tue, 1:16pm Jump to last post in thread (by DisDwarfWoman)
       Black speech TiberiusOgden 219 0 Tue, 2:16pm
       For me... DisDwarfWoman 136 0 Tue, 5:28pm

  Collapse Dwalin (mild spoilers) emre43 679 6 Tue, 11:42am Jump to last post in thread (by Roheryn)
       Really liked that scene also! adt100 305 0 Tue, 1:22pm
       Yes Macsen 258 0 Tue, 1:54pm
       That was a great scene Ham_Sammy 211 0 Tue, 3:53pm
       Collapse Line Bernhardina 102 1 Tue, 9:48pm
           Yes that is it I think emre43 81 0 Tue, 10:16pm
       Along with that line, Roheryn 65 0 Tue, 11:27pm

  Collapse What does Kili tell Tauriel? Bernhardina 572 2 Tue, 10:52am Jump to last post in thread (by Macsen)
       I read somewhere... Angharad73 398 0 Tue, 11:03am
       I could tell you, but I'd be banned from the forum. Macsen 285 0 Tue, 12:56pm

  Collapse Go back to your books (Spoiler!) CasiBaggins 655 2 Tue, 10:00am Jump to last post in thread (by Macsen)
       OMG you felt that too?! elvish.mafia 351 0 Tue, 10:08am
       Yup Macsen 223 0 Tue, 12:58pm

  Collapse Why we need the extended edition...and why we DON'T. elvish.mafia 1222 42 Tue, 8:38am Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Collapse So you thought DoS was good without the EE? painjoiker 609 3 Tue, 8:59am
           Collapse Yes it was. elvish.mafia 577 1 Tue, 9:15am
               Too bad for you, I would say; mae govannen 530 0 Tue, 9:51am
           Really? DOS EE is very good, but DOS TC still bettered AUJ in both forms // adt100 295 0 Tue, 1:55pm
       Collapse But I don't feel that way - at all dormouse 594 5 Tue, 9:17am
           Collapse That's a great point Dormouse :) elvish.mafia 521 4 Tue, 9:30am
               Yes, I have seen it once.... dormouse 493 0 Tue, 9:47am
               Collapse "An EE is simply a director's cut" QuackingTroll 400 2 Tue, 11:38am
                   Collapse Definitive means 'FINAL'... elvish.mafia 374 1 Tue, 11:58am
                       Again, those "shoulds" are all theoritical, mae govannen 336 0 Tue, 12:36pm
       Collapse What you don't need is returning to theaters many times Milieuterrien 515 1 Tue, 9:42am
           Which is what we are doing right now... elvish.mafia 469 0 Tue, 9:50am
       Collapse Theories do not always apply to reality... mae govannen 500 14 Tue, 9:48am
           Collapse Ummm... elvish.mafia 480 9 Tue, 9:59am
               in this I agree with you, though I liked it aswell Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 431 0 Tue, 10:45am
               Collapse Exactly; PJ had forgotten (oops!) mae govannen 369 7 Tue, 12:20pm
                   Collapse But pettytyrant101 328 6 Tue, 1:05pm
                       Collapse No thanks! Danielos 303 1 Tue, 1:15pm
                           Each to their own pettytyrant101 305 0 Tue, 1:20pm
                       AUJ's length Macsen 305 0 Tue, 1:26pm
                       Collapse I am very disappointed... mae govannen 246 2 Tue, 3:51pm
                           Collapse Well that seems a little rude pettytyrant101 167 1 Tue, 6:31pm
                               Sorry for the unintentional rudeness: mae govannen 29 0 Wed, 8:36am
           Collapse Only two? Hanzkaz 242 3 Tue, 3:33pm
             Collapse Did you read the rest of my post??? mae govannen 225 2 Tue, 4:05pm
                   Collapse I read your post. I was joking - sort of. Hanzkaz 205 1 Tue, 4:33pm
                       Absolutely true, I am very aware of that... mae govannen 41 0 Wed, 5:19am
       Collapse If you haven't even bothered to watch all the EEs lurtz2010 455 3 Tue, 10:44am
           Collapse because I was happy with all the theatrical editions until now... elvish.mafia 436 2 Tue, 10:47am
               But still lurtz2010 422 0 Tue, 11:11am
               I would severely recommend QuackingTroll 400 0 Tue, 11:23am
       Collapse Why BOTFA TE felt incomplete to me... (spoilers) Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 501 2 Tue, 11:22am
           Awesome! elvish.mafia 405 0 Tue, 11:38am
           Kind of agree... adt100 289 0 Tue, 2:04pm
       Collapse The TE stood on its own Macsen 343 1 Tue, 1:01pm
           I agree Ham_Sammy 267 0 Tue, 2:32pm
       Collapse Interesting comments on the TORN homepage.... adt100 209 2 Tue, 5:12pm
           So - Hanzkaz 190 0 Tue, 5:22pm
         What a lovely quote from PJ... mae govannen 32 0 Wed, 8:40am
       A Thought IdrilofGondolin 118 0 Tue, 8:16pm
       What...? Mooseboy018 107 0 Tue, 8:46pm
       The theatrical edition of a film is soemtimes forgotten glor 65 0 Wed, 1:32am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 913 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.