Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 5 of 848 (312042 posts in 12713 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 848 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
Collapse Poll: your feeling towards approaching BOTFA? TheHutt 722 29 Mon, 12:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Collapse I fall somewhere in the middle BlackFox 392 2 Mon, 12:39pm
           I'm with you, BlackFox Eruvandi 254 0 Mon, 3:04pm
           "All of them at once, I suppose" Loresilme 134 0 Mon, 8:38pm
       [over] Fleuz 370 0 Mon, 12:40pm
       Missing category on your 'list' Glorfindela 379 0 Mon, 12:44pm
       Can't choice from thse two. Arannir 354 0 Mon, 12:47pm
       Collapse Somewhere in the middle Noria 342 1 Mon, 12:56pm
           This! // NecromancerRising 295 0 Mon, 1:36pm
       Collapse To be honest.. Avnar 353 1 Mon, 1:08pm
           yep FernysApple 227 0 Mon, 3:32pm
       meh Avandel 330 0 Mon, 1:18pm
       Both at once Elarie 303 0 Mon, 1:28pm
       Cannot wait! Bofur01 300 0 Mon, 1:32pm
       I'm looking forward to it - Hanzkaz 275 0 Mon, 2:15pm
       It's mixed for me, but I guess more of… Cillendor 253 0 Mon, 2:48pm
       Savouring every moment Elanor of Rohan 233 0 Mon, 3:28pm
       The Hobbit will be re-booted architecthis 257 0 Mon, 3:36pm
       Eagerly anticipating 12/17 arithmancer 200 0 Mon, 4:01pm
       Sort of both dubulous 198 0 Mon, 4:02pm
       Both dormouse 194 0 Mon, 4:12pm
       Mixed cats16 98 0 Mon, 10:20pm
       I am feeling FernysApple 86 0 Mon, 11:17pm
       Not sure yet... Bard'sBlackArrow 80 0 Mon, 11:40pm
       [can' wait] for the theatrical version. [over] for the EE next year. // xxxyyy 62 0 Tue, 2:16am
       Both Kim 47 0 Tue, 2:40am
       Collapse I'm savoring the moment FoundEntwife 53 2 Tue, 2:47am
           Collapse Step by step for me: DOS EE first, please!... mae govannen 20 1 Tue, 2:25pm
               My post above was a reply to the thread itself, mae govannen 20 0 Tue, 2:29pm
       I'm somewhat excited.. delius82 46 0 Tue, 4:26am

  Collapse BoxOffice predicts The Battle of Five Armies' domestic income News from Bree 371 4 Mon, 12:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elessar)
       Collapse Opening weekend will be higher than that I think LordotRings93 180 2 Mon, 7:56pm
           Keep in mind... cats16 148 0 Mon, 10:22pm
           I expect it will be higher as well Elessar 43 0 Tue, 1:08pm
       Limit Arannir 65 0 Tue, 8:34am

Collapse Thranduil Appreciation Thread Part XXI Lurker in the Mirk 1057 154 Mon, 10:45am Jump to last post in thread (by mariel)
       Collapse A Look Back At Past TA Threads (XI to XX) Lurker in the Mirk 546 13 Mon, 11:18am
         Collapse 3rd from the top VValar 505 3 Mon, 12:46pm
             Collapse Really? Lurker in the Mirk 293 2 Tue, 2:38am
                   Collapse LOL that seriously didn't even cross my mind VValar 122 1 Tue, 1:49pm
                       LoL... well, you've got choices now Lurker in the Mirk 82 0 Wed, 6:34am
           Collapse Elves look durn good In Uniform. vanima ephel 363 8 Tue, 12:08am
               Collapse durn right! Lurker in the Mirk 183 4 Tue, 4:39am
                   Collapse What Thranduil piccie do you mean? VValar 127 1 Tue, 2:00pm
                       My sis... Lurker in the Mirk 86 0 Wed, 6:35am
                   Collapse I think that's why they've made him so lofty (and... vanima ephel 126 1 Tue, 11:51pm
                     Just gotta... Lurker in the Mirk 169 0 Wed, 7:30am
             Collapse Yup *snerkles* Lurker in the Mirk 162 2 Tue, 6:57am
                   Collapse *snort* Eruvandi 178 1 Tue, 2:34pm
                     Durn ritey! Lurker in the Mirk 169 0 Wed, 7:04am
     Collapse Let's celebrate TA 21 with a HR of the BOFA poster VValar 519 5 Mon, 12:45pm
         Collapse And here's Thranduil isolated from the clutter Lurker in the Mirk 306 2 Tue, 2:36am
             Collapse Very very nice VValar 126 1 Tue, 1:47pm
                   Touche! Lurker in the Mirk 84 0 Wed, 6:33am
           Collapse When you said it was HR you weren't kidding! Eruvandi 172 1 Tue, 4:35pm
               Wow,, good observations there, Eruvandi Lurker in the Mirk 169 0 Wed, 7:22am
       Collapse My goodness mariel 493 13 Mon, 2:21pm
         Great piccies, I absolutely the second piece of fanart VValar 363 0 Mon, 10:52pm
           Collapse I love the red... vanima ephel 310 5 Tue, 1:16am
               Collapse eh... either and both Lurker in the Mirk 179 2 Tue, 4:40am
                   Collapse So it's both! vanima ephel 119 1 Tue, 11:56pm
                     LoL! That's all sorts of wrong Lurker in the Mirk 166 0 Wed, 7:33am
               Collapse Wounded Thranduil fanart VValar 186 1 Tue, 2:23pm
                   Well, I'm pretty sure there are Dwarf fans who... vanima ephel 118 0 Wed, 12:11am
         Collapse *squee* oooh, new Pretty!, thanks mariel! Lurker in the Mirk 295 2 Tue, 2:33am
               Collapse Well, hello there! mariel 141 1 Wed, 2:25pm
                 Pretty! *saves toothy grin smiley Thranduil* Lurker in the Mirk 88 0 Thu, 3:34am
         Collapse Fresh fan art of the Elvenking's side profile [HTR] Lurker in the Mirk 170 2 Tue, 6:40am
               Collapse Lovely mariel 147 1 Tue, 8:25am
                   Perhaps someone should give her a poke Lurker in the Mirk 84 0 Wed, 6:26am
     Collapse Thread XXI! Eruvandi 464 3 Mon, 3:07pm
           Collapse And are you done with your RL commitments? Lurker in the Mirk 192 2 Tue, 2:46am
               Collapse For the most part Eruvandi 172 1 Tue, 3:55pm
                   Oh good! Lurker in the Mirk 170 0 Wed, 7:08am
       Collapse The antler crown and costume try-on mariel 446 15 Mon, 6:21pm
           *drool* Eruvandi 378 0 Mon, 10:32pm
         Collapse quick lame edit Lurker in the Mirk 199 6 Tue, 3:07am
             Collapse Haha mariel 150 1 Tue, 8:19am
                   Happy to know that Lurker in the Mirk 83 0 Wed, 6:25am
               Collapse Lol! Eruvandi 169 3 Tue, 4:05pm
                   LoL Ba-Bam cloak flip Lurker in the Mirk 174 0 Wed, 7:12am
                   Collapse Addendum: Ba-bam cloak flip in one convenient GIF Lurker in the Mirk 57 1 Thu, 2:19pm
                       *THUD* Eruvandi 37 0 Thu, 10:31pm
           Collapse @mariel: Back of the crown in pic2 Lurker in the Mirk 172 5 Tue, 6:35am
               Collapse Much more elegant mariel 152 3 Tue, 8:27am
                   Collapse Sorry to disappoint Lurker in the Mirk 87 2 Wed, 6:28am
                       Collapse Hmmph mariel 160 1 Wed, 9:48am
                         *LoL* where the Elvenking cracks elegant jokes like Lurker in the Mirk 89 0 Thu, 3:37am
             That expression..... VValar 120 0 Tue, 2:09pm
           Another costume try-on Lurker in the Mirk 78 0 Thu, 6:49am
       Collapse A question for stn5 or Lurker (or anyone who knows) [SPOILER ALERT but only so you'll know what I'm talking about...] vanima ephel 417 35 Mon, 9:40pm
           Collapse Do you mean this? - link removed - copyright violation mariel 404 12 Mon, 10:16pm
               Thanks for the link to the bigger version of the text VValar 383 0 Mon, 10:49pm
             Collapse Yes! [Real? Spoilers this time] vanima ephel 371 1 Mon, 11:57pm
                   My thoughts exactly VValar 355 0 Tue, 12:20am
               Collapse Sorry - another copyright violation entmaiden 364 8 Tue, 12:00am
                   Collapse Quick query mariel 355 5 Tue, 12:13am
                       Collapse About your linking to tumblr question VValar 353 2 Tue, 12:26am
                           Collapse I did some follow-up on that... vanima ephel 337 1 Tue, 12:47am
                               If it's from the same sources as that lot of phots from the Chinese site Lurker in the Mirk 186 0 Tue, 4:16am
                       Collapse It looks like it's probably just the copyrighted material... vanima ephel 326 1 Tue, 12:57am
                           Urm... vanima ephel 318 0 Tue, 1:20am
                   Collapse entmaiden... so in summary Lurker in the Mirk 196 1 Tue, 4:10am
                       This is basic copyright law entmaiden 124 0 Tue, 1:50pm
         Collapse For what it's worth... these tumblr posts sums and discusses it on violation-free grounds Lurker in the Mirk 199 14 Tue, 4:25am
               Collapse Thrandy's wife (continuing Lurker's spoiler alert) Eruvandi 167 13 Tue, 7:04pm
                   Collapse Very well put [spoiler cont] mariel 155 12 Tue, 7:48pm
                       Collapse That's what I wonder too [still spoilery] Eruvandi 151 11 Tue, 8:14pm
                         Collapse my thoughts [spoilery and rambling and perhaps not PC-conforming] Lurker in the Mirk 179 10 Wed, 8:22am
                               Collapse It made sense Eruvandi 109 9 Wed, 11:08pm
                                   Collapse Women characters and extremes arithmancer 104 5 Thu, 1:39am
                                       Collapse Great characters does not mean having to make them into male stereotypes, just in skirts. Lurker in the Mirk 83 4 Thu, 3:58am
                                           Collapse Female character in TH VValar 82 3 Thu, 11:25am
                                               Collapse Galadriel... arithmancer 77 1 Thu, 12:25pm
                                                   I do agree they need characters aside from Thranduil, Lurker in the Mirk 62 0 Thu, 2:00pm
                                               Yup Lurker in the Mirk 67 0 Thu, 1:45pm
                                   Thanks. Really appreciate that you always take the time to really read, especially Lurker in the Mirk 84 0 Thu, 3:42am
                                 Collapse Addendum: you'll like this Lurker in the Mirk 59 1 Thu, 2:17pm
                                     Aw, thanks! Eruvandi 52 0 Thu, 3:23pm
         Collapse Articles perfect for the discussion of the original spoiler topic and then some - with regards to Thranduil, of course Lurker in the Mirk 81 6 Thu, 6:42am
             Collapse Thanks for sharing these good reads VValar 92 3 Thu, 10:38am
                   Collapse Welcome... and re Elves fading Lurker in the Mirk 70 2 Thu, 1:41pm
                       Collapse I still believe that Thranduil went west ltnjmy 64 1 Thu, 1:57pm
                           Totes agreement from me Lurker in the Mirk 60 0 Thu, 2:01pm
               Collapse Thanks mariel 58 1 Thu, 2:02pm
                   Yay for miraculously resolved IT issues Lurker in the Mirk 58 0 Thu, 2:05pm
       Collapse DOS EE BTS: Concept and Design of Thranduil's throne - Gleeful Thranduil GIF! [HTR] Lurker in the Mirk 189 2 Tue, 4:47am
         Collapse SQUEEE!!!! VValar 123 1 Tue, 2:07pm
               Glad to oblige Lurker in the Mirk 86 0 Wed, 6:38am
     Collapse Interlude (sorta)... overwhelmed by the Thranduil Pretty! (and spoilers and shock) we've been getting? Come on in Lurker in the Mirk 203 6 Tue, 5:05am
         Collapse Light read to cap off the interlude Lurker in the Mirk 170 3 Tue, 6:44am
               Collapse I haven't even seen him play im five different roles VValar 122 1 Tue, 2:13pm
                   Haha Lurker in the Mirk 170 0 Wed, 7:02am
               Hmm Eruvandi 147 0 Tue, 8:37pm
           Collapse Ahhhhhhhhhh... vanima ephel 122 1 Wed, 12:32am
               *SNERKLES* Lurker in the Mirk 171 0 Wed, 7:35am
     Collapse FLAST+ HTR MFE Lurker in the Mirk 173 2 Tue, 6:49am
           Collapse LOL @ the FLAST VValar 185 1 Tue, 2:15pm
               Yup. And who can deny the MFE of Lurker in the Mirk 172 0 Wed, 7:03am
       More Thranduil in red plaid Lurker in the Mirk 173 0 Tue, 6:54am
     Collapse Hateful Thrandy VValar 199 2 Tue, 2:27pm
         LoL Lurker in the Mirk 87 0 Wed, 6:43am
         another LoL... both at once Lurker in the Mirk 73 0 Thu, 6:51am
     Collapse LOL VValar 196 4 Tue, 2:36pm
         Classic! Lurker in the Mirk 176 0 Wed, 7:05am
         Collapse Another good one Lurker in the Mirk 171 2 Wed, 8:37am
             Collapse LOL Thranduil sure knows how the crack a joke VValar 99 1 Wed, 11:49pm
                 Yup! Lurker in the Mirk 80 0 Thu, 3:59am
       Collapse HD photos - total film stn5 189 1 Tue, 4:50pm
           Cool article, thanks VValar 84 0 Thu, 10:54am
     Collapse Question: In the BTS image of Thranduil holding his two swords Lurker in the Mirk 184 4 Wed, 8:30am
           Collapse Intriguing mariel 153 3 Wed, 1:47pm
               Collapse *excitedly jumpnig up and down* Yes, that's it! Lurker in the Mirk 90 2 Thu, 4:07am
                   Collapse The swords VValar 83 1 Thu, 11:03am
                       That crossing of the tip Lurker in the Mirk 67 0 Thu, 1:44pm
     Collapse Beautiful (new?) image of Leggy VValar 108 5 Wed, 11:21pm
         Collapse Two lovely Elves... vanima ephel 96 3 Wed, 11:51pm
             Collapse I agree Legolas is the prettiest, Thranduil the sexiest VValar 96 2 Wed, 11:55pm
                   Collapse I always planned to see it just down the street... vanima ephel 79 1 Thu, 12:27am
                       Just this Lurker in the Mirk 82 0 Thu, 4:13am
           Nice one. And here's a vid of BTS Leggy in DoS Lurker in the Mirk 80 0 Thu, 4:09am
       Collapse Another BTS Thranduil piccie VValar 110 1 Wed, 11:24pm
           Thanks! Lurker in the Mirk 78 0 Thu, 4:14am
       Collapse Definitely more Orc blood going on! Thrandy might be the first dirty Elf in battle we've seen? VValar 91 1 Thu, 12:01am
           Looks like they might be working on the Vlog11 sequence? Lurker in the Mirk 80 0 Thu, 4:16am
       Collapse Very cool edit VValar 89 4 Thu, 12:06am
           Nice! Lurker in the Mirk 78 0 Thu, 4:17am
         Collapse another one in the same style - gotta love Armour!Thranduil in snow Lurker in the Mirk 80 2 Thu, 6:53am
               Collapse Ohhwww, Thranduil in the snow + armor + The Hair is a wonderful combination VValar 54 1 Thu, 10:23am
                   If the trailer works... I'll just be the gibbery drooly mess in the corner Lurker in the Mirk 67 0 Thu, 1:37pm
     Collapse Last one for today VValar 120 1 Thu, 1:24am
         *THUD* Lurker in the Mirk 81 0 Thu, 4:18am
       Image (sit ye down HTR) Lurker in the Mirk 81 0 Thu, 6:48am
       Collapse Beautiful fan art Lurker in the Mirk 81 2 Thu, 6:58am
           Collapse Another nice one from this site mariel 63 1 Thu, 1:59pm
             LOVE IT!! Lurker in the Mirk 58 0 Thu, 2:05pm
     Collapse One more fan art of Armour!Thranduil Lurker in the Mirk 78 2 Thu, 7:01am
         Collapse This is a beautiful edit VValar 54 1 Thu, 10:22am
             Oh yeah! And I just perused the artist's site Lurker in the Mirk 67 0 Thu, 1:36pm
     Collapse Trailer Release on 6 Nov Lurker in the Mirk 65 7 Thu, 10:04am
           Collapse That's very cool! VValar 57 3 Thu, 10:19am
               Collapse BOFA runtime speculations VValar 95 1 Thu, 10:32am
                   Well, PJ is known Lurker in the Mirk 62 0 Thu, 2:02pm
               I didn't know about the imdb thingy Lurker in the Mirk 77 0 Thu, 1:35pm
           Collapse Finally mariel 65 2 Thu, 2:06pm
             Collapse "Around October", he sez Lurker in the Mirk 48 1 2:17am
                   Haha mariel 15 0 2:54pm
     Collapse Halloween Goodness [Tea-spew fun & HTR!] Lurker in the Mirk 59 1 2:31am
           Happy Halloween mariel 15 0 2:59pm
       Nice edit of OP mariel 5 0 41 mins ago

Collapse Battle: Book-verse vs movie [Book and Movie spoilers] Lurker in the Mirk 583 14 Mon, 8:45am Jump to last post in thread (by Lurker in the Mirk)
       Collapse Karen Wynn Fonstad's map showing the Bo5A Otaku-sempai 302 5 Mon, 9:35am
           Collapse Thanks for the map, Sempai! Lurker in the Mirk 211 4 Mon, 10:41am
               Collapse You're welcome, Lurker. Otaku-sempai 124 3 Mon, 5:04pm
                   Collapse imo, the book also provides a good idea Lurker in the Mirk 64 2 Tue, 2:50am
                       Collapse Yes, Tolkien lays it out well in the book itself... Otaku-sempai 39 1 Tue, 1:45pm
                           Just like a time-lapse sequence Lurker in the Mirk 18 0 Wed, 6:29am
       Collapse I would imagine that the numbering suggests Spriggan 271 3 Mon, 10:19am
           I think so too Lurker in the Mirk 224 0 Mon, 10:43am
           Collapse ^This Aitieuriskon 176 1 Mon, 1:12pm
               #18 is still intriguing to me Lurker in the Mirk 57 0 Tue, 4:03am
       Collapse Do we know that this map is even accurate to what's in the film? Defiant 84 3 Tue, 12:43am
           Collapse Goblins are orcs // Bofur01 75 1 Tue, 12:49am
               Not in Peter's movies. I'm talking about a battle plan for the films, not the books. Defiant 74 0 Tue, 1:00am
           PJ showed this to Empire in his interview, didn't he? Lurker in the Mirk 59 0 Tue, 4:01am

  Collapse Trailer this week? NewZeasYT 1763 32 Mon, 7:08am Jump to last post in thread (by adt100)
       Collapse Alberta? TheHutt 891 20 Mon, 7:13am
           Collapse Friday is PJ's Birthday Fleuz 847 13 Mon, 7:28am
               Collapse Highly disappointed lidlessEye 830 12 Mon, 7:58am
                   Tuesday for us, Wednesday for others Cirashala 767 0 Mon, 8:04am
                   Sigh. Arannir 671 0 Mon, 8:21am
                   Again SafeUnderHill 651 0 Mon, 8:23am
                   Nobody has stolen anything from you dormouse 619 0 Mon, 8:47am
                   Collapse Trailers are not in the business of serving fan anticipation Spriggan 559 6 Mon, 9:28am
                       Collapse This!! People seem to have forgotten what a trailer is for! QuackingTroll 450 5 Mon, 12:24pm
                           Collapse people seem to have forgotten, what the meaning for marketing is... lidlessEye 344 4 Mon, 2:23pm
                               Not relevant for WB. Arannir 324 0 Mon, 2:29pm
                               Collapse So you will see it once Spriggan 313 2 Mon, 2:32pm
                                   Collapse Its called "Biting off your nose to spite your face". Moahunter 111 1 Mon, 10:41pm
                                       Well it certainly struck me as odd. Spriggan 102 0 Mon, 10:58pm
                   I think your demands have gotten higher QuackingTroll 405 0 Mon, 12:29pm
           Collapse Yes, I hope. caglarkuraner 690 5 Mon, 8:10am
               Collapse Age Of Ultron Fleuz 682 3 Mon, 8:19am
                   Collapse --- lidlessEye 631 2 Mon, 8:24am
                       Marvel of course... Fleuz 613 0 Mon, 8:38am
                       Well... Arvida 571 0 Mon, 8:58am
               It was leaked though. Arannir 673 0 Mon, 8:19am
       Sem SafeUnderHill 669 0 Mon, 8:19am
       This late to the game, let's go without a trailer! leonmuse 621 0 Mon, 9:15am
       Collapse Trailers with TH Arannir 645 8 Mon, 9:27am
           Collapse Imagine if the trailers that were attached to BoFA were... tsmith675 465 7 Mon, 1:02pm
               That would be great! Arannir 394 0 Mon, 1:03pm
               Collapse Oh my gosh, I would probably die from excitement before the movie even started! Cillendor 281 1 Mon, 2:32pm
                   Marketing Arannir 285 0 Mon, 2:35pm
               As a big fan of Jurassic Park, Star Wars *and* the Middle-earth films... MechaGodzilla 279 0 Mon, 3:06pm
               Collapse You're in luck! Smaug Report 262 2 Mon, 4:18pm
                   Collapse I'm way more psyched to see the "Jurassic World" teaser jtarkey 211 1 Mon, 5:51pm
                       Jurassic World?!? adt100 12 0 Wed, 3:36pm

  Collapse Thrain... ecthelionsbeard 525 5 Mon, 5:09am Jump to last post in thread (by Spriggan)
       Collapse Necromancer "sauron" tortured him MouthofSauron 266 4 Mon, 5:47am
           Collapse To quote the Great Goblin... Mooseboy018 286 3 Mon, 6:07am
               Collapse And... ecthelionsbeard 245 2 Mon, 6:13am
                   Collapse Sauron didn't need a reason... Otaku-sempai 168 1 Mon, 9:43am
                       I tend to agree. Spriggan 151 0 Mon, 10:31am

  Collapse How will this film FEEL? Scourge of the Stoors 699 15 Mon, 2:11am Jump to last post in thread (by Arannir)
       Collapse It will probably be more like DoS MechaGodzilla 380 10 Mon, 2:46am
           Collapse That's Unfortunate Scourge of the Stoors 356 9 Mon, 3:17am
               Collapse Color... delius82 327 3 Mon, 4:09am
                   Collapse haziness redgiraffe 251 2 Mon, 7:18am
                       I agree.There was an excessive NecromancerRising 231 0 Mon, 7:44am
                       That scene after Bilbo sees Beorn... QuackingTroll 117 0 Mon, 3:02pm
               Yes, I agree Glorfindela 236 0 Mon, 7:06am
               Collapse I disagree. Arannir 183 3 Mon, 8:58am
                   I totally agree. Orange/teal is sooo overdone. Cillendor 110 0 Mon, 2:57pm
                   Collapse Orange and teal? Bumblingidiot 11 1 Thu, 11:23pm
                       AUJ certainly has it... Arannir 3 0 12:01pm
       Dark and epic. Elizabeth 314 0 Mon, 4:52am
       Judging by the teaser... dormouse 216 0 Mon, 8:52am
       Great question! I think it might be lighter than some think QuackingTroll 132 0 Mon, 2:52pm
       feel? FernysApple 116 0 Mon, 3:28pm

  Collapse Are there any changes from the book that you actually liked? thomasofrohan 1154 55 Sun, 9:51pm Jump to last post in thread (by Starling)
       Sure! cats16 689 0 Sun, 10:12pm
       Collapse Most of the changes I don't have a problem with until Joe20 721 8 Sun, 10:13pm
           Totally Agreed Wordofmask 499 0 Mon, 12:24am
           well said redgiraffe 312 0 Mon, 7:33am
           Collapse Mmm... Anubis 286 3 Mon, 8:19am
               Collapse Your last argument about fantasy. leonmuse 255 2 Mon, 8:52am
                   Collapse Hm Arannir 244 1 Mon, 9:02am
                       Thank you, Arannir! leonmuse 231 0 Mon, 9:09am
           To be fair… Cillendor 185 0 Mon, 3:01pm
           Agreed... Dcole4 155 0 Mon, 4:23pm
       I like a lot of the Spriggan 621 0 Sun, 10:20pm
       Several. Arannir 611 0 Sun, 10:22pm
       Collapse Yes... dormouse 544 1 Sun, 11:21pm
           Agree with you on all points!... mae govannen 232 0 Mon, 12:46pm
       I liked the addition of.... Bladerunner 541 0 Sun, 11:32pm
       Collapse Yes, there is one big change that I like a lot... Kendalf 555 16 Mon, 12:20am
           Collapse No, it wouldn't KingTurgon 367 13 Mon, 4:35am
               Collapse Agreed dubulous 266 4 Mon, 8:38am
                   Collapse Totally disagree. Arannir 273 2 Mon, 8:46am
                       I agree with Arannir NecromancerRising 286 0 Mon, 9:10am
                       Agree with you, Arannir. // mae govannen 224 0 Mon, 12:59pm
                   Agreed too, dubulous! Lurker in the Mirk 236 0 Mon, 8:59am
               Collapse I never say "need" but it would certainly have made a statement! Spriggan 275 2 Mon, 9:25am
                   Right; and instead she is a great statement to the contrary! mae govannen 222 0 Mon, 1:13pm
                   Ha! Kendalf 88 0 Mon, 8:10pm
               Collapse In my view, you'd be right in most cases...but not this one Kendalf 96 4 Mon, 8:07pm
                   Collapse Fairytales do NOT have heroines! Finrod 114 3 Mon, 8:25pm
                       I'm not sure if you are joking? Spriggan 98 0 Mon, 8:43pm
                       Different time, different media, different audience Kendalf 81 0 Mon, 9:45pm
                       Those darn girls Starling 30 0 Tue, 7:19am
         Collapse Lovely comment, beautifully worded, Kendalf...! mae govannen 228 1 Mon, 12:56pm
               Gosh! Kendalf 111 0 Mon, 8:14pm
       Collapse Yes dubulous 458 1 Mon, 12:40am
           With you on all this! // mae govannen 217 0 Mon, 1:15pm
       Extermination of the talking wallet gkgyver 400 0 Mon, 2:21am
       Tone Yngwulff 385 0 Mon, 2:31am
       Barrel chase, Gandalf/necromancer confrontation, dwarf attack on smaug MouthofSauron 393 0 Mon, 2:41am
       Collapse Wizards and Witchkings! QueenCirce 389 1 Mon, 2:43am
           With you on all three points // mae govannen 217 0 Mon, 1:18pm
       There are lots of changes that I agree with both in LOTR and the Hobbit emre43 280 0 Mon, 8:08am
       Collapse Yes! dormouse 252 3 Mon, 8:54am
           Collapse Isn't that mae govannen 222 2 Mon, 1:25pm
               Collapse How weird - thanks for pointing that out... dormouse 202 1 Mon, 2:09pm
                   It was the post by someone else mae govannen 178 0 Mon, 2:51pm
       Yes Noria 244 0 Mon, 12:32pm
       Collapse I'm OK with most of the changes Elarie 246 2 Mon, 1:13pm
           Collapse Very valid observations, thank you!.. mae govannen 218 1 Mon, 1:31pm
               Bomby iz gunna go with the Quiet moments Bombadil 184 0 Mon, 2:58pm
       Take all the positive changes mentioned by others, mae govannen 191 0 Mon, 2:44pm
       NO FernysApple 189 0 Mon, 3:31pm
       I'm going to actually respond to the thread this time KingTurgon 181 0 Mon, 3:56pm
       Collapse The two big ones Kilidoescartwheels 159 2 Mon, 5:32pm
           stuff i liked and disliked mo0on-light 133 0 Mon, 6:21pm
           Well in the book they have four claims upon a share of the treasure Spriggan 119 0 Mon, 6:31pm
       Sure... Bard'sBlackArrow 56 0 Mon, 11:38pm

  Collapse Why Dain instead of Thorin? NateGate 1099 33 Sun, 8:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Collapse Canon and more worthy TheSexyBeard 597 8 Sun, 9:09pm
           Collapse I like the idea of Thorin never succeeding (Spoilers!!) QuackingTroll 487 7 Sun, 10:16pm
               Collapse Dies in the process... NateGate 429 5 Sun, 10:37pm
                   I didn't say he was a villain QuackingTroll 387 0 Sun, 10:55pm
                   subject redgiraffe 232 0 Mon, 6:57am
                   Collapse It wasn't all HIS gold.... Eleniel 229 2 Mon, 7:35am
                       Exactly. Well-said, Eleniel! Lurker in the Mirk 192 0 Mon, 8:37am
                       Thanks for keeping the record straight...// mae govannen 157 0 Mon, 11:38am
               Perfectly stated redgiraffe 229 0 Mon, 6:49am
       Because the whole point of Thorin's charachter Joe20 486 0 Sun, 10:15pm
       Collapse One of the things that makes the book stand out Bumblingidiot 465 3 Sun, 10:23pm
           Collapse It rather depends on the execution but it need not be a victory. Spriggan 409 2 Sun, 10:42pm
               Collapse Can't agree. Bumblingidiot 305 1 Mon, 1:29am
                   A few thoughts Spriggan 172 0 Mon, 9:11am
       Collapse Well...(book spoilers inside) cats16 444 2 Sun, 10:27pm
           Collapse Parallels with Bard are really interesting! QuackingTroll 419 1 Sun, 10:36pm
               I wonder... cats16 355 0 Sun, 11:18pm
       Personally for me Skaan 411 0 Sun, 10:36pm
       Collapse Some good points already raised. Macfeast 408 2 Sun, 10:39pm
           my hopes redgiraffe 222 0 Mon, 7:01am
           To your point I truly resonate most. I agree with you. mae govannen 158 0 Mon, 11:31am
       My personal take Bishop 328 0 Mon, 12:34am
       No... Gandalf the Green 234 0 Mon, 6:45am
       Clishéd Arannir 199 0 Mon, 8:32am
       Collapse I agree! Arvida 189 4 Mon, 8:53am
           Collapse Exactly my point.... NateGate 116 3 Mon, 4:14pm
               Collapse That would be... Ereinion Nénharma 105 2 Mon, 4:52pm
                   Collapse Eh... NateGate 87 1 Mon, 6:12pm
                       The problem with your analysis Kilidoescartwheels 62 0 Mon, 10:11pm
       Collapse If Dain kills Azog (spoilers) Otaku-sempai 179 1 Mon, 9:52am
           Yes,... Eleniel 178 0 Mon, 9:57am
       All they really need to do for Dain is a well-exectued prologue. Cillendor 130 0 Mon, 3:57pm
       But there's more than one villian Kilidoescartwheels 103 0 Mon, 5:20pm

  Collapse New Tauriel picture Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1591 17 Sun, 7:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by FernysApple)
       Collapse oohh that's very interesting! Cirashala 732 2 Sun, 7:57pm
           Collapse That's not Tilda, that's Kili Kilidoescartwheels 157 1 Mon, 1:38pm
               Gotcha :) Cirashala 90 0 Mon, 8:04pm
       Intriguing image and Tauriel looks GORGEOUS Avandel 654 0 Sun, 8:15pm
       Great one! Arannir 587 0 Sun, 8:25pm
     Interesting! Eruvandi 566 0 Sun, 8:36pm
       Collapse It's from the Total Film article... Eleniel 489 1 Sun, 9:47pm
           It was Voronwë_the_Faithful 409 0 Sun, 10:31pm
       Though I'm definitely not a big Tauriel fan VValar 463 0 Sun, 10:26pm
       Lovely shot Kendalf 345 0 Mon, 12:22am
       Alternate source DwellerInDale 339 0 Mon, 1:04am
       Collapse I think... Arvida 227 2 Mon, 9:01am
           ROFL. NecromancerRising 203 0 Mon, 9:03am
           *Giggles...* Good one!!! // mae govannen 176 0 Mon, 10:11am
     For once, unanimous appreciation among us!!! Congrats, Tauriel... mae govannen 187 0 Mon, 10:10am
       Collapse She looks beautiful! And - Loresilme 98 1 Mon, 8:35pm
           agreed FernysApple 41 0 Tue, 3:42pm

  Collapse Inspiration for one of the EE scenes *might be a spoiler* Seaber 682 1 Sun, 7:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by FoundEntwife)
       Ha! FoundEntwife 176 0 Sun, 9:09pm

  Collapse !EE Spoiler! lo-res caps "Halls of the Elven King" Thranduil, Thorin, etc. green screen image lard thread Avandel 786 7 Sun, 6:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       More Thranduil etc. Avandel 361 0 Sun, 6:53pm
     And Thorin and Fili Avandel 341 0 Sun, 6:55pm
       Tauriel, Legolas, dwarves Avandel 331 0 Sun, 7:00pm
     Collapse Hey Thrandy piccies!! VValar 189 1 Sun, 10:22pm
           *Cough* Avandel 163 0 Sun, 11:37pm
       Collapse Thank you for sharing all this! mae govannen 35 1 Tue, 3:12pm
           Agreed! and you are welcome! Avandel 29 0 Tue, 4:32pm

  Collapse Thrain has changed everything... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1114 12 Sun, 6:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cillendor)
       Yep...totally with you! Simon 483 0 Sun, 7:22pm
       Collapse Dissagree Avnar 474 2 Sun, 8:22pm
           Of course tsmith675 364 0 Sun, 9:15pm
           In the end, when all three movies and, mae govannen 131 0 Mon, 12:31pm
       Collapse Good to hear FoundEntwife 387 4 Sun, 8:52pm
           Collapse Thrain's death scene Óintment 421 3 Sun, 8:56pm
               Collapse For many people it didn't ruin anything: mae govannen 143 2 Mon, 11:54am
                   agreed. nusilver 96 0 Mon, 3:12pm
                   Once heard, it cannot be unheard. Cillendor 90 0 Mon, 4:14pm
       Ditto! NecromancerRising 369 0 Sun, 9:05pm
       Important conclusions, beautifully stated. mae govannen 138 0 Mon, 12:05pm
       Hope I agree with you burgahobbit 97 0 Mon, 3:12pm

  Collapse Chapter Of The Week: The Prophecy FaramirAndEowynMorningStar 327 10 Sun, 5:34pm Jump to last post in thread (by cats16)
       Lord of Silver Fountains, King of Carven Stone Kim 167 0 Sun, 6:35pm
       my thoughts Cirashala 160 0 Sun, 7:27pm
       Collapse Curious IdrilofGondolin 142 1 Sun, 8:16pm
           I think Cirashala 139 0 Sun, 8:24pm
       Collapse I am amazed SafeUnderHill 121 1 Sun, 9:21pm
           Yep Shagrat 80 0 Mon, 10:11am
       A Note about the Tapestry Otaku-sempai 88 0 Mon, 10:00am
       What I want to know is...(no EE spoilers :) Riven Delve 71 0 Mon, 12:56pm
       My thoughts Noria 51 0 Mon, 7:55pm
       Back for some thoughts. cats16 11 0 Thu, 7:19am

  Moved: WHY? hasn't someone THOUGHT of this Before? Bombadil - - Oct 26, 4:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 848 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.